I will never doubt that an in-universe biography of the Skywalker dynasty would be a huge draw to both Star Wars fans and to the people of AGFFA. As one of the former, I was very excited to read this book, to get at the very least a summary of the era between the Original Trilogy and the Sequel Trilogy, since I’m pretty selective of what I read of Disney’s canon (plus, not being all that big a fan of the ST doesn’t encourage me to read the a lot of the new material).
The overall results were mixed, however. The idea of this being an in-universe biography of the Skywalkers (that is, that it is written by someone within AGFFA) doesn’t hold water very long, since so much of what the book portrays would not have been recorded by history. Shmi Skywalker herself would be a very mysterious figure, perhaps known only in whatever stories were passed down by her family, mostly Owen and Beru Lars (since Anakin/Vader were hardly inclined to speak much of her). How well-known would it be that Shmi and Anakin were slaves? Where would it have been recorded, other than, again, passed down via the Lars family? What’s more, how would the author have known the characters’ personal feelings or what they witnessed since, again, such things would not have been recorded by history.
All the same, I did enjoy the Prequel-era information. Beyer does an excellent job portraying Anakin’s Fall, such as how his faith in the Jedi slowly eroded and then finally broke as events unfolded throughout the Clone Wars. Seeing how Palpatine wove his web around Anakin, encouraging certain character traits and essentially making a total mess of an already-messed-up kid. It is very easy to see that Anakin in no way ever received any kind of therapy for his time enslaved on Tatooine, not to mention that the Jedi seemed to have been oblivious to the signs of how shady Palpatine’s relationship to a young Anakin was. I mean, were they really that unaware of how skeevy things sound when one learns that Palpatine told Anakin to keep the contents of their meetings secret from Obi-Wan and the Jedi? This is a sure-fire sign of a pedophilic manipulation, and yet the Jedi are oblivious.
Then there is the ST era. While Beyer did her best, there’s really just very little she could do given what an utter shit show the ST era was, owing to the complete lack of a plan Disney had for the trilogy. The abundance of retcons and just plain weirdness did not make it easy to plot it out in biographical form.
And let’s not forget the myriad of grammatical errors. The book needed another round or two of editing before it went to publication.
Overall, I give this one 3 stars. A decent read, but it had quite a bit going against it, plus the concept of it being in-universe falls apart very fast.