Any Chicago Cub fan knows all too well about the 1969 team that first captured and then broke the hearts of millions of fans across the country. After holding on to first place for 155 days, a combination of the Cubs' collapse and the New York Mets' hot streak down the stretch ended any hopes of the North Siders' first appearance in the World Series since 1945.
In "The Forgotten 1970 Chicago Cubs," author William Bike makes the case that the 1970 version of the Cubs was actually better than the 1969 club that included five eventual Hall of Famers: Ernie Banks, Ron Santo, Billy Williams, Fergie Jenkins and manager Leo Durocher.
In fact, Bike says the Cubs would have gone on to win the pennant if they'd played in the West Division rather than the East Division. He also believes they would have beaten the Baltimore Orioles in the World Series for their first Series title since 1908!
Bike argues that the acquisition of pitcher Milt Pappas and outfielder/first baseman Joe Pepitone; more depth, on paper at least; and the strong starting pitching of Jenkins, Kenny Holtzman, Bill Hands and Pappas should have been enough to carry the Cubs to the Promise Land in 1970. Although they didn't steal too many bases, they had a powerful lineup with the likes of Santo, Williams, Jim Hickman and Pepitone in the middle of the order. The biggest loss that season was catcher Randy Hundley, who missed almost half the season with injuries. His absence from the lineup was worth at least 10 games in the standings, Durocher said.
While Durocher platooned more than he did in 1969, the Cubs' skipper still underutilized and stressed the young players such as Terry Hughes and Roe Skidmore, Bike says.
The author also points out that in 1970 and subsequent years, the Cubs' management got rid of players who went on to have success for other teams: Ted Abernathy, Jim Colborn, Boots Day, Joe Decker, Larry Gura, Oscar Gamble, Roger Metzger, Bob Miller and Dick Selma.
"All Cub management had to do was literally nothing -- just keep what they had -- and the team would have been a dominant one in the 1970s, instead of a perennial doormat or .500 club," Bike maintains.
If you're a baseball fan, especially a Cubs fan, I highly recommend "The Forgotten 1970 Chicago Cubs." The book includes a nice summary of what happened to each player, coach, Durocher, broadcaster, owner Phillip Wrigley, vice president/general manager John Holland and Wrigley Field after 1970.