Probably with the best ending in the "Drenai Tales" series and also one hell of a beginning, "Hero in the Shadows" is one of those books that grips your attention from the very first page and takes you to an unknown world full of wonders, death, fear, desire and unfulfilled dreams.
Our old friend Waylander is back, now retired and living the live as a rich merchant in the far away lands of Kydor. He is getting old, slow and needs a motivation in life. And Gemmell pretty soon gives him a motivation, with magickers, demons and a danger that may bring an end to the known world...
That I have a weakness for Gemmell is something that I realized probably from the very first novel I read from him, a feeling that had gotten stronger with each novel I have read with his name on the cover. Gemmell is writing more or less the same story over and over: someone who really doesn't want to fight is 'forced' to fight, his success close to impossible, always fighting against insurmountable odds. Some magic, some unexpected help, dreams and beautiful characters, fleshed out in two sentences.
What does then "Hero in the Shadows" be a great novel? Well, that it follows the Gemmell mold is one. Gemmell knew what he was writing about and here is another great example. The pace suffers on moments, and some decisions reek of deus ex machina, but otherwise, it is interesting, gripping and full of plot developments. The ending is beautiful, probably Gemmell's best, if not close to it. And the characters, as always, interesting, human (even the non-humans, so better say 'alive') and full of strengths and weaknesses. Gemmell's musings about what makes us heroes, or strong or weak, and how we can all use violence and make mistakes are right to the point, clear, concise and true. He talks about how our reality depends on upbringing, on what we know and how we may change. All of that makes you care for Waylander, ditchdigger Yu Yu or I-don't-want-to-fight Keeva. The inclusion of female characters with personality is also highly welcomed, even if this world is still a world populated by male that fight against other male (a point that fantasy still struggles about).
"Hero in the Shadows" is for fans of classical fantasy. And even I, who believes a world without heroes would be a better world, has to bow to Gemmell's knowledge of what makes us what we are: flawed, and able of the best and worst.
8/10
(English Original Version)