I enjoyed this WWII historical fiction but think I would have enjoyed it a bit more if I hadn't come in expecting to learn more about Catherine Dior, sister of Christine Dior. Most of what I learned about her came from my internet searches and those searches helped me to understand her value to the story, that I wouldn't have gotten from just reading the book. I know I'm going to read more about her now that I know the part she played as a Resistance fighter.
The book starts in 1947, where we are introduced to Yvette, just arriving in France from New York, where she made her home after escaping France, late in the war. We also meet Yvette's sister, Gabby, who still lives with their mother, where she works as as the concierge of ten rue Royale. Yvette is back in France so that she can testify at the trial of a woman who is accused of war crimes. She's never answered any of Gabby's letters since she left France three years ago. She's racked with guilt because of things she did or neglected to do during her time as a Resistance Fighter.
Gabby has accepted her fate in life. She long ago lost her father and her fiancé and never hoped to love again. And now her sister seems to be lost to her. There is also another person she has lost although she doesn't know if he is dead or has just forgotten her.
The other timeline in this story takes place in 1944. Everything is related to us by jumping back and forth between 1944 and 1947 and jumping between the viewpoint of Yvette and Gabby, in each of those timelines. We see all the deprivations of living in wartime France, the brutality inflicted on the people by the Nazis, gangs, those in power over those who are oppressed. In 1944, nineteen year old Yvette is so extremely naïve despite having endured so much of wartime France and being a member of the Resistance. Twenty five year old Gabby is already weary of a life that doesn't look to ever get better. She's always worried about her rash, headstrong, and reckless sister. Little does she know she'll be taking on similar risks once she realizes what is going on in the building that she runs.
I think the story would have been less confusing it it had been told from 1944 to 1947, without the back and forth in the timeline. But, still, it's very interesting as we see how the war is waged, not just on the front lines but behind the scenes, by people who are not what they seem and by people who have nothing left to give but their lives. Both sisters have so much to give, if they can figure out who they can trust.
Publication: June 8, 2021
Thank you to the Book Club Girl Early Read program, William Morrow and Custom House, and NetGalley for this ARC.