This is a review that I almost wish I didn't have to write.
AD Fox (aka Ali Sparkes) is an author that until last month, I had never heard of. I came across her quite by chance on the 'UK Crime Book Club' Facebook page, on which she asked whether having a female detective as a lead character was off-putting to male readers. My reply - for what it's worth, and as a male reader who loves crime fiction - was that I don't mind in the least if a book has a strong female lead character. Where I have been known to become a little irked is if there has to be a weak male character as a sidekick. What's wrong with both male and female characters having their own strengths and weaknesses?
Ali's response to this one comment showed her to be a truly lovely and generous person. Because it resulted in me being sent ARC's of not only her first crime novel, The Dying Dolls, but her second - Dead Air - as well. If my review was based on the author's loveliness, I'd finish and award five stars right now.
But, I always say that my reviews are of the book and not the author. And I'm really sorry to have to say that my comments here aren't quite so gushingly praising.
I do have some good things to say. It's absolutely true that both the female and male lead characters have strengths and weaknesses here. DS Kate Sparrow is a dedicated police officer who has so far been unable to find a breakthrough in the case that has seen three female runners abducted. The first was found to have died horribly, the other two have so far disappeared without trace. Her frustration, and fear that she may be unable to save the lives of two other women is palpable.
In desperation, she turns to her childhood friend Lucas Henry, who is ... well, he's quirky. A wannabe artist, living in an inherited bungalow but unable to afford to keep the electricity connected, he also has a gift for dowsing. This enables him to not so much find as to sense new evidence at the abduction scenes.
The trouble with 'quirky' is that it's also divisive. I am sure that there will be people out there who will absolutely be ready to fall in love with Kate and Lucas and be more than happy to accept everything that happens in the storyline. But there will be others for whom the quirks don't really do it, and I have to say that I personally lean towards the second category.
My real problem wasn't with the character of Lucas so much as how he has to fit into the main story. I'm trying hard not to give spoilers away, but it relies on Kate being willing to accept his gift but her fellow police officers being somewhat more cynical. The point is reached where Lucas, despite having been arrested and tasered, senses how he can escape police capture and stay off their radar until he has managed to save more than one life. But for me, it just seemed so improbable as to be almost farcical.
That's not to say I didn't enjoy the book, though. I did. I read it easily and will definitely give Dead Air a chance. AD Fox deserves no less. If you're looking for a new crime fiction series, I'll happily
recommend that you give this one a go. And I'll be even happier if, having read the Dying Dolls, you disagree with everything I say.
My thanks, again, to the author for an ARC of this book. I will post my review on Goodreads and Amazon.