All's Fair in Love and Blood was an okay read for me. Although I always love the writing style of this author, this book didn't hold the same charm as the other books I've read by her. Additionally, in terms of clean romantic content, I'm not sure if I would pick up any of her future books. Here's a breakdown of my thoughts while reading.
1. Scarlett - I felt like Scarlett was a very reactive heroine and a lot of her personal growth, regarding her self-esteem and following her dreams, was reliant on Kane and his actions. I think there's a big difference between being inspired by a person to change for the better and allowing a person's actions/view of you/relationship with you to change your perception of yourself and the choices you make. Unfortunately, Scarlett was more defined by the latter. While this is mildly addressed towards the end of the book, it didn't really convince me that Scarlett was capable of independent personal growth and I was still left questioning the authenticity of it overall. Aside from that, I sympathized with Scarlett's emotional abandonment from her father and was curious about how her relationship with him would evolve. I also adored her relationship with Naomi, and their mother-daughter dynamic was really sweet.
2. Kane - In the first part of this book, I absolutely loved Kane. His character was sweet, attentive, kind, and gentle. However, in the second half of the book, when Kane's trying to win Scarlett back, I thought his initial approach was really off-putting. I think there's a distinct difference between fighting for love and maneuvering to get your way. To clarify, I think he should have given Scarlett space instead of acting like they had never broken up. As a result, my interest in him and the romance declined somewhat after that.
3. The romance - I liked the first half of this book, more than the second. I thought the falling in love phase for Scarlett and Kane was enjoyable - although I did question if Scarlett should be dating Kane because of her self-esteem issues. In the second half of the book, aside from Kane's actions, my biggest issue was the back-forth regarding Scarlett's feelings towards Kane. While I understood her hesitancy and her feelings, her processing did wear a bit and perhaps dragged on a bit longer than necessary. Also, there was a lot of heavy kissing and make-out sessions in this book - more than I personally liked and more than I'm used to reading from this author. There's also a considerable amount of conversations about sex, though there was no on-page intimacy between the hero and the heroine. I have to admit, even though they always kept their clothes on, it still kinda felt like they were going to have sex a couple of times - that's how heavy it was or felt to me.
All in all, All's Fair in Love and Blood just wasn't for me.