I read this to my 2nd grader, 5th grader, and 8th grader, as per the 8th grader's recommendations, describing it "as funny as Ramona Quimby, only she's Amish." It's a pretty good, humorous family read. Originally, the 2nd grader didn't like the book, saying that it wasn't fun reading about someone who was always in trouble, and didn't like the Amish words because they were unfamiliar. The 2nd grader wanted me to say, "Rachel thinks that her brother didn't love her, but he did in the end," and I think grew to like the story as it went along. The 5th grader says, "You should follow the rules. She wants to break their rules and ride in a car."