start on: 12.19.24
end on: 12.21.24
‧₊˚✧final review✧˚₊‧
❝You are not a burden. Your dreams aren’t burdens either.❞
‧₊˚🖇️✩₊housekeeping˚🎧⊹♡
·˚ ༘₊·꒰➳: ̗̀➛ possible minor spoilers
🫧𓇼𓏲rest of review✩‧₊˚🎐
·˚ ༘₊· ͟͟͞͞꒰➳ genre: YA Romance
·˚ ༘₊· ͟͟͞͞꒰➳ what to expect
➳ 1st person present tense
➳ single pov
➳ holiday romance
➳ coworkers
➳ secret keeping
➳ students
➳ hate-to-love
➳ bookworm FMC
➳ athletic MMC
➳ small-town romance
➳ strict parents
➳ anonymous blogging
·˚ ༘₊· ͟͟͞͞꒰➳★★★.5 rounded down to 3.
·˚ ༘₊· ͟͟͞͞꒰➳ 0.5/5 (spice rating)
·˚ ༘₊· ͟͟͞͞꒰➳ ❀❀❀/5 (fluff rating)
「 ✦The Holiday Switch✦ 」
(noun) a hallmark movie
Only A Lifetime
↻ ◁ II ▷ ↺
1:35 ───ㅇ───── 3:47
❝Don’t waste the time you have waiting for time to pass.❞
☁️ . . . ⇢ ˗ˏˋ overall thoughts
╰┈➤ ❝Because books. Books are an escape. Books are a reminder that opposites can exist at the same time, both good and bad, positive and negative.❞
As this quote would suggest, there is good in this book, and there is bad. It was cute, it was cozy, it was warm, and it was what I needed. The ending was cheesy, as most romance books seem to be, and it didn’t hit very hard overall. However, it was nice to read and exactly what I’ve been in the mood for.
˚˖𓍢ִ໋🌷͙֒✧˚.🎀༘⋆ writing style
╰┈➤ ❝Finally, New Year’s Eve at the Lake is here!❞
I personally think that this writing was…not the best. And that isn’t to say that it was awful, it just felt amateur, like something I might expect from a debut author (which Tif Marcelo is not). As a romance novel, the writing is also cheesy, and reads like I imagine the script for a Hallmark movie does. However (and yes there’s another however), sometimes it was too cheesy, too peppy.
♡₊˚ 🦢・₊ ♪ ✧ plot
╰┈➤ ❝Okay, that's a little extra. Not a criminal, but a sneak, an undercover.❞
First, let me introduce my synopsis policy to you. This policy is super important for me because it helps me stabilize my rating when I’m unsure about it. This policy has two parts:
Part 1: If an important part of the synopsis doesn’t come into play by 30% through the book, I remove .25 stars from what my rating would be otherwise. After that, for every 10% we reach without that plot point, I remove .10 stars. This part of the policy was developed after I realized that I wasn’t enjoying books when I was waiting for part of the plot as stated in the synopsis to occur.
Part 2: When I feel like the synopsis doesn’t do a book justice, I remove .5 stars from what my rating would be otherwise. Then, I discuss what I would change about the synopsis.!! This part of the policy was adopted for this book, actually.
Original Synopsis: ‘Lila Santos is ready for her last winter break of high school. The snow in her small town of Holly, New York, is plentiful, the mood is as cozy as a fuzzy Christmas sweater, and she's earning extra cash working at the local inn—AKA the setting of the greatest film of all time, Holiday by the Lake—while moonlighting as an anonymous book blogger.
But her perfect holiday plans crash to a halt when her boss's frustratingly cute nephew, Teddy Rivera, becomes her coworker. Lila is type A; Teddy is type “Anything but Lila’s Way,” and the two of them can’t stop butting heads over tangled icicle lights and messy gift shop merch. But when they accidentally switch phones one afternoon, they realize they've both been hiding things from each other. Will their secrets—and an unexpected snowstorm—bring these rivals together?’
I wish the synopsis had put more emphasis on the fact that Teddy and Lila become coworkers and put less emphasis on their phone swap, because that barely lasted half a day and was like 7 pages of the book.
Obviously this book has the plot of a Hallmark movie: girl meets boy, they’re both keeping secrets, it’s around christmas time, and there’s celebrities. Now let’s be totally clear: was the plot cute? Yes. Was it anything special? No.
✧˖*°࿐ world building
╰┈➤ ❝Here’s the thing about the snow up north. What others might think is a snow storm is, simply, heavy snow.❞
All I will say is that Tif Marcelo needs to do her research on what it’s like to live in the USA north - I was very put out by some of the ways she described the weather.
˖◛⁺⑅♡main romance♡⑅⁺◛˖
╰┈➤ ❝A headache creeps into my skull, and his name is Teddy Rivera.❞
These two are simply adorable. They have great banter, and the way Lila was falling for Teddy? ADORABLE OMG. I just wish we had seen Teddy fall for Lila, too.
୭ 🧷 ✧ ˚. ᵎᵎ 🎀 friendships/other relationships
╰┈➤ ❝Why haven’t we hung out before?
“Because high school,❞
➳Lila and Carm: Their friendship is absolutely beautiful. Carm is the push that Lila needs at pretty much any given moment, and I love it.
➳Teddy and his Parents: I wish that we had gotten more resolution on how Teddy’s parents reacted to the whole rock-climbing thing.
➶-͙˚ ༘✶ characters
╰┈➤ ❝His smile is polite, but he's clearly unenthused.❞
Main Character 「 ✦ Lila Santos ✦ 」
╰┈➤ ❝But of all the romance tropes, the enemies-to-lovers arrangement is the hardest for me to get on board with.❞
·˚ ༘₊·꒰➳: ̗̀➛relatability?
[■■■■■■□□□] 70%
Lila truly is one of the most relatable main characters I’ve read about in a while. If you’ve read any of my more recent reviews, you know that I have rated the last few MCs a 20-30% of the relatability scale, and I have found that very disappointing. Then, of course, we get a book with a FMC who’s a bookworm, and OF COURSE that relatability scale goes up. The only problems I have with her: she rates EVERY BOOK 4 or 5 stars, which is absolutely wild (this is a bit ironic coming from me, but you all get the point. Even I have books I’ve rated 3, 2, 1 stars). Also, she doesn't like enemies-to-lovers, which is DEFINITELY not me.
·˚ ༘₊·꒰➳: ̗̀➛how much i liked them
8/10
It’s been a LONG time since I have rated a main character a 10/10 on my ‘i like you’ scale. I’m very picky when it comes to main characters. When I read the synopsis for this book, I had hoped that Lila would be the 10/10. Unfortunately, she was not.
⋆·˚ ༘ * 🔭 quotes
╰┈➤ ➸❝Because books. Books are an escape. Books are a reminder that opposites can exist at the same time, both good and bad, positive and negative.❞
➸❝Remember that with struggle, there’s opportunity.❞
➸❝She loves books - and book people are really the best people.❞
➸❝Choices are never easy to make; there usually seems to be an easy, safe route and a riskier choice. One that involves stretching yourself. Probably reaching for areas unknown. The payoff? It could be great. But it’s not without its bumps and bruises.❞
➸❝Risk is real. It’s scary, uncomfortable, and has consequences.❞
➸❝I’ve always thought that work makes a person. That working solves it all.
But does it?❞
➸❝First of all, while I’m all about crushes and book boyfriends, real ones have to room in my schedule.❞
➸❝I peer at him. “Is this motivation I detect? What have you done with the Teddy Rivera we know and don’t love?❞
➸❝From here, it doesn’t look that bad. And yet, it’s not the going up that scares me, but the coming down. It’s the mis-step, the feeling of not being able to catch myself.❞
➸❝But while it’s so easy to change your mind with Legos if you don’t like the structure, what happens if you simply want to change your mind about the future? At what point cna I switch things up? Is there even such a thing?❞
➸❝Family is all we have.❞
➸❝And despite my best efforts not to inflate his ego, I say, “You called it. You were right.❞
➸❝It’s like finding out someone likes the same book you do - it creates an instant bond.❞
➸❝Knew what?”
“That, if anything, being with you had changed me, for the better.❞
➸❝It makes me wonder what I’m willing to risk for a secret. And, here’s the thing, since secrets come out anyway,❞
➸❝I dunno, maybe it’s to show yourself that you can do something scary. ANd maybe taking one small step toward something scary can lead to other things?❞
➸❝Yeah, sometimes you do get hurt. Sometimes it means falling. But sometimes it’s grabbing that extra bit of air and then catching yourself.❞
➸❝You are not a burden. Your dreams aren’t burdens either.❞
⋆·˚ ༘ * 🔭 other bits
╰┈➤ ❝It makes me wonder what I’m willing to risk for a secret. And, here’s the thing, since secrets come out anyway,❞
(🎁 who was your favorite character? Why?) I'm almost certain it's Teddy, although I'm not sure. None of the characters really spoke to me, even Lila, who, as our MC, I wish I connected with. Unfortunately, while she is a total book worm, she only reads holiday books, which I do not relate to AT ALL. this is only my 3rd holiday book, and the 2nd one which I have rated under 4 stars. Anyways, Teddy or Carm are probably my favorites.
(🎁 who was your least favorite character? Why?) This is another hard question. I didn't find myself particularly hating anyone in this book. No one is really dislikeable, honestly, and though I find books often more fun when there's someone I dislike, the fact that there wasn't any character to hate was honestly kind of a breath of fresh air that I desperately needed while in the midst of reading many books with MANY hateable characters.
(🎁 if you had to choose a holiday song to base a short story around, what would it be? Why?) So honestly, obviously this book is just one big holiday book in and of itself. BUT I think I'd choose 'It's Beginning To Look A Lot Like Christmas.' The book is set in a town that is REALLY big on the holidays, and of course it snows quite a bit. So of course it would be looking like Christmas, and I think it would be fun to write a story where Lila returns from Syracuse with Teddy and enjoys the holidays in Holly.
(🎁 if you could choose any winter holiday for a novella to be centered around, what would it be? Why?) Due to this book being a romance already centered around Christmas, I'm going to have to say Valentine's Day. While I think this is a pretty self-explanatory answer, here's my reasoning: Teddy and Lila are VERY cute together. I can already picture in my mind Teddy announcing that he read 1-2 holiday romances for Lila for Valentine's Day and Lila agreeing to go rock climbing. It would be adorable.
(🎁 what was your favorite quote from the book? Why?) 'You are not a burden. Your dreams aren't burdens either.' This quote feels like it was spoken directly to me. At a time where I feel like I can't/wont be able to do what I want to do the most (be an author) or that that dream might hurt someone I love, this quote came into my life and spoke directly into my soul. If you are feeling the same way, this quote is for you.
(🎁 what character would you most like to build a snowman with? Why?) Honestly, I think Irene. We could just chill and complain about being cold together, but at the same time I think we'd actually enjoy each other's company while doing smth fun. I rlly did love her character and building a snowman with her would also be a great way to get to know her more.
(🎁 what character would you most like to shop for for the holiday season? Why?) Absolutely Teddy. I will do anything I can to get people into reading, and if I could shop for Teddy and buy him the right books to get into reading, I would be ECSTATIC. Don't mind that this would totally be for personal gain so that I can discuss said books with him, it’s the thought that counts, right?
(🎁 what character would you most like to spend a snowy day inside with? Why?) Lila. We could just chill and watch cheesy holiday movies together, then go read quietly. Then we would write reviews about the books and discuss with each other. As Lila stated in the book, 'bookworms really are the best people'. And Lila is one of the best bookworms. She would be so fun to do smth like this with.
(🎁 what would you change about the book? Why?) I really wish we had gotten more of a resolution. I understand why Tif Marcelo chose to end the book where she did, however I also believe that we didn't get enough fleshing out and I would love to know more about the following: Lila's interviews; Teddy's parents' reactions to the rock climbing; the Syracuse financial aid; Lila's blog. There is so much more that could be explored and honestly I was let down.
(🎁 would you gift this book to a friend for the holidays? Why or why not?) Maybe, if they said they wanted it or were in the mood for something like it. It wouldn't be my first choice of book to give someone, but if it was the right person and I was given the right incentive, I might just agree to it. I just don't know if there would ever be a circumstance where a friend of mine would say they wanted to read this - honestly, I probably never would have read it if it hadn't been for my obligation to my book club lol.
(🎁 what character would you most like to vibe to holiday music with? Why?) Hm, that's hard. Maybe KC, he seems fun. He's a super minor character but he's definitely fun and chill and it seems like we could get into the vibe. Also, though, I will say Lila's family had that whole karaoke thing going on...but that's less of a vibing thing and more of a game thing. So, yeah, probably KC.
(🎁 what moment in the book would most likely happen to you? why?) Ummmm none of it? This book...idk. I live in the 'north' I suppose (its north relative to the rest of the US) BUTTTT I can't really see myself doing any of this stuff. I wish I had a better answer because this book is so fun and I would LOVE for it to happen to me, but like I just cant see it happening. ok, this isn't rlly a moment but more of a plot device: maybe Lila's blog? I suppose thats kind of what I do on here already, so yeah, probably that.
‧͙⁺˚*・༓☾ favorites
ˋ°•*⁀➷ favorite characters
·˚ ༘₊·꒰➳: ̗̀➛ i have no idea
ˋ°•*⁀➷favorite scenes
·˚ ༘₊·꒰➳: ̗̀➛i also have no idea
ˋ°•*⁀➷favorite quotes
·˚ ༘₊·꒰➳: ̗̀➛❝You are not a burden. Your dreams aren’t burdens either.❞
✩₊˚.⋆☾⋆⁺₊✧ final thoughts
It was cute, and I liked it, I just wish I had enjoyed it more.
⋆.ೃ࿔*:・ please comment or pm me if I missed anything, especially tropes!
ʚɞ˚ ༘♡ ⋆。˚ Love y’all. Let’s go light it up and rattle some stars! Mwah ♡
ﮩ٨ـﮩﮩ٨ـ♡ﮩ٨ـﮩﮩ٨ـ
‧₊˚✧pre-review✧˚₊‧
VERY cute, VERY cozy. wish i could have enjoyed it more. rtc 😘
‧₊˚✧pre-read✧˚₊‧
reading for book club (it was the dec/jan pick). it looks SO cute, here’s hoping it’s amazing