The Truth of the Matter

by Gough Whitlam

On Remembrance Day, 1975, the Governor-General of Australia, Sir John Kerr, sacked the Prime Minister, Gough Whitlam. The Dismissal was the culmination of almost three years of political conflict, as Whitlam's reforming Labor government rammed home overdue legislative reforms in the face of implacable, and increasingly bitter, conservative opposition. The focus of the Opposition's scheming was the Senate, where its leaders blocked supply in order to force a political crisis. Whitlam, famous for his 'crash through or crash' style, refused to compromise with his political enemies. After consulting secretly with the Opposition Leader, Malcolm Fraser, and the Chief Justice, Sir Garfield Barwick, Kerr abruptly informed the PM that he had withdrawn his commission. Half an hour later, Kerr swore Fraser in as 'caretaker Prime Minister'. At an election a month later, the conservatives were returned to office. Controversy and recrimination followed. Many Australians, including Whitlam himself, b

Genres: Politics, Australia, Nonfiction, History, Biography, Memoir

191 pages, Paperback

First published December 31, 1979

About the author

AKA Edward Gough Whitlam

Reviews

[Rowan Rafferty · Rating 5 out of 5]

Alright, we are talking about someone I hold in exalted status. Why did I not read this before?

I guess I was still very angry and didn't want to stir things up for myself.

All these years on, it's still hard, the bile rises as far more comprehensive facts about skulduggery, deception, illegality and bullshit rises to the surface. The observations from EGW as to the mistakes, the way things may have happened and options on the day of the dismissal are just awful.

One can only put the Dismissal down as an orchestrated coup by the Liberal party, their followers and supporters that could never happened without the complicity of politicians, government officials, public servants and members of the judiciary. I was aware of some of this but had no idea how long it lingered (festered) after 11 November 1975

IMHO without any regard to democratic process or care for fragile tradition. the details of actions, the opinions outlined have NEVER been challenged or resulted in any defamation actions. That in itself brings the truth to the matter.

A eruditely written account by the man in the middle of a democratic shit sandwich.

I still maintain the rage and continue to rail against the abuse of our democracy. It didn't start here and no lessons have been learnt on the conservative side of politics.

[Dan · Rating 5 out of 5]

A riveting read. I got through this book in a weekend.

I read this straight after reading Sir John’s autobiography and am glad I did. It obviously balances Sir John’s account and leaves the reader wanting to read even more about the events of 11/11/75.

Whitlam’s wit, also, is in fact possibly the highlight of the book - some wickedly funny observations on Sir John.

[Veronika · Rating 4 out of 5]

I love history (read: decades old beef)

this book was sitting at a solid 3 but Whitlam’s case for an Australian republic in this edition really tied the book together and improved my opinion. the bitterness and snarkiness, while totally understandable given the subject matter and the recency in which Whitlam was writing, really started to bug me. but on the whole a fascinating and brilliant read

[Joseph Thorsen · Rating 4 out of 5]

If I’m ever asked to write another speech/article on whether Australia should become a republic, The Truth Of The Matter will be the first bullet point in the bibliography.

There are some incredibly poignant sentences in this memoir, capturing all of Whitlam’s harboured (but justified) malice towards Sir John Kerr. Sometimes some of the subject matter in various chapters (4 and 10 specifically) went a bit off topic - some observations here definitely could have been more concise - but it was informative nonetheless. A truly great insight that we are lucky to have on record.

And just to reiterate the legendary quote (in order to substantiate the worth of this book I suppose): “Well we may say ‘God Save the Queen,’ because nothing will save the Governor-General.” - Gough Whitlam

Epic.

[David Allwood · Rating 4 out of 5]

Prime Minister Gough Whitlam, and his democratically elected Labor government, was sacked by Governor General, Sir John Kerr, on Remembrance Day in 1975. This was the greatest political crisis in Australia’s history. Now, with the 50th anniversary of this shameful event looming, ‘The Truth of the Matter’ by Gough Whitlam, originally published in 1979, has been republished. Whitlam meticulously sets out the circumstances leading to the dismissal and recounts the event in sobering detail. He tries to find reasoning for the sacking and can not only find no justification at all, but convincingly argues that Sir John Kerr’s actions were a dreadful conspiracy in collusion with ‘Kurr’s cur’, Malcolm Fraser and the Coalition opposition. Whitlam draws on his barrister background in strongly articulating his point of view and the raw facts of the political crisis. His anger seethes from every page punctuated by bewilderment that such an undemocratic action could ever occur in this country. Fifty years later, the outrageous dismissal has left a permanent scar on Australian politics, and in this book Whitlam importantly reminds us to ‘maintain the rage’.

[Dr_Hales · Rating 5 out of 5]

Fuck me John Kerr is a slimy, disgusting and downright vile piece of excrement. That useless and spineless twat capitulated to and conspired with the opposition to bring down a Prime Minister. Kerr was also a self-important and pretentious bore. He should have been shot for treason

[Linda Summer · Rating 3 out of 5]

Not as engaging as anticipated. Feels like a slow boat to China but I guess that's politics. I shall persevere.

[Daniel Lang · Rating 5 out of 5]

"The Truth of the Matter" by Gough Whitlam is an extraordinary testament to the life and legacy of one of Australia's most iconic political figures. Whitlam, with his characteristic wit, intellect, and candor, provides readers with an intimate and insightful account of his years in public service, offering a compelling narrative that is both engaging and historically significant.

Whitlam's memoir is a literary gem that takes readers on a journey through the highs and lows of his political career, offering a firsthand perspective on the tumultuous events that shaped Australia in the mid-20th century. His narrative style is refreshingly honest and reflective, providing readers with a deeper understanding of the challenges, triumphs, and complexities inherent in the realm of politics.

One of the standout features of "The Truth of the Matter" is Whitlam's ability to blend personal anecdotes with political analysis. His vivid storytelling transports readers into the heart of historic moments, making the book not only informative but also emotionally resonant. Through the pages of this memoir, Whitlam invites readers to witness the passion, vision, and unwavering commitment that fueled his pursuit of progressive policies and social change.

Furthermore, the memoir sheds light on Whitlam's unwavering dedication to the principles of social justice, equality, and diplomatic independence. His accounts of key policy initiatives, such as the implementation of universal healthcare and the recognition of China, showcase the transformative impact of his leadership on the Australian political landscape.

"The Truth of the Matter" is not merely a recounting of events; it is a powerful reflection on the nature of leadership, the complexities of governance, and the enduring values that guided Whitlam's political philosophy. Whitlam's narrative is not confined to self-praise; he acknowledges the challenges faced and the controversies that marked his tenure, providing a well-rounded and nuanced portrayal of his time in office.

In conclusion, Gough Whitlam's "The Truth of the Matter" stands as an indispensable historical document that offers readers a rare and invaluable glimpse into the mind of a visionary leader. With its captivating storytelling, intellectual depth, and historical significance, this memoir is a must-read for anyone interested in Australian politics, history, and the enduring legacy of Gough Whitlam.

[Mathew O'keefe · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a must read for anyone interested in politics, left or right. It's brutal, Gough was clearly very angry when writing it, there's nothing diplomatic about it.