Murder Most Pemberley: The basic premise is: a fictional character who lives in South Dakota is related through her father to the fictional Bennetts and the Darcys of Pemberley in England, as created by Jane Austin in her most well known novel Pride and Prejudice. The fictional American Eliza Darcy plans to attend the fictional reunion of the fictional Pemberley, and finds intrigue, romance and mystery in one crazy fictional summer. What a brilliant idea! Sign me up!
This is not a retelling so those of you trying to find a book to match that in a reading challenge prompt need to look elsewhere for fulfillment. I was really excited to read this book that was given to me by Book Sirens, author Jessica Berg and Red Adept Press for my honest opinion and to share that opinion with fellow readers on this site. I thank them for the opportunity.
When I started the book, I was excited to read it, but as I got deeper into the story, little things started to bother me. Why does the best friend always have to be a more sophisticated, gorgeous, shallow, dumb blonde to the bookish, more serious, dark haired nerdy girl? And really, these "girls" were adult women, not teenagers in their sophomore year of high school. I don't know about Belle but Eliza was a teacher so you know she a had to have gone to college plus she likes to read murder mysteries which should show she has an analytical mind but somehow that went out the window as the story went on. I was relived Belle didn't accompany Eliza on the adventure but then we meet her cousin Jo, who strangely she had met before so this was not Eliza's first trip across the pond. I found that odd for sure. So why have Bella when there was already the cousin who was the same type of character? And since she had been there before, shouldn't the long time staff, friends and family know her too?
Then there was Heath, whose name kept making me think of he candy bar, that she met on the plane as he was sitting next to her, then (cue Hallmark moment) she meets again at Pemberley because he was invited to the reunion too, although I really didn't understand why. Turns out Heath was one of Jo's old cast off boyfriends and there didn't seem to be any jealousy or awkwardness at all This is what drives me crazy about books billed as "Mystery" and it ends being a sappy teenage-like romance. which is really strange because both of them are way into adulthood. I mean, when you and your love interest are trapped and a murderer is on the loose and most likely trying to get to them to finish the job and they are discussing their relationship???? It was so sappy and silly and not true to what one would expect from adults.
Then there is the bit about the cat. I am always excited to know there is a cat in the mystery because they can make great characters and even help in solving the crime. But this cat Caesar? After the the ugly incident in which he was involved, he wasn't around much at all. I don't know why a person would bring a cat on a long trip like that anyway when it is not a permanent situation or he didn't play a major role in the story. If there was a dead bloody body in my bed, I wouldn't be running to my boyfriend, I would be frantically searching for my kitty! In fact, he was never mentioned at all in the story after that scene. I kept thinking in the end he would show up but Nada. Maybe he went to London to visit the Queen? That really bugged me even more than the silly teenage-like romance. Men are a dime a dozen but your cat is worth the entire universe.
I didn't tonally hate the book. The writing was OK, I felt like the author didn't have real focus on what she wanted the book to be: A cozy mystery? A dark tragedy? a Rom-Com,? a YA novel? I did like some of the characters, especially Aunt Iris. She was terrific! On the whole, I felt most of the characters were flat and undefined and even stereotypes. Maybe it is because I am a seasoned reader of mysteries and frequently review them, but I figured out whodunit pretty quickly because you just knew by their behavior that they were up to no good. I did laugh at some of the humor but probably not for the reason the author intended.
If you like cozy mysteries and not too picky about details, you will love this book. If you are a Jane Austen fan, you might enjoy it too. My rating is four stars because I think the series shows promise and I will read the next in the series when it is available but if I don't see any growth, then I won't continue the series.