This is my new favorite of Karen McManus's YA thrillers! It hit many sweet spots for me: beach town, family secrets, rich assholes, and a few more that are spoilers. It's kind of unfortunate for everyone else this won't be out until winter, because it's a perfect summer jam!
Karen's books are always adept at multi-POV, but I really gelled with the characters in this one. I think b/c this one focuses on family trauma and the "sins of the father" being carried out on the children, there was a lot to latch onto (since I enjoy that stuff). The cousins are Milly, Aubrey, and Jonah, whose parents were disowned by their mega-rich mom 24 years ago and no one knows why. After two decades of radio silence, Grandma Milicent reaches out finally to her grandchildren and invites them to work at her resort for the summer so she can get to know them.
Milly (short for Millicent) is named for her estranged grandmother and is the daughter of the only Story daughter, Allison. We get third person close chapters from an 18-year-old Allison back in 1996 throughout the book as we try to piece together why they were disowned. Milly is a New York socialite with a ton of sass, who doesn't end up getting exactly what she wants from her reunion with her grandmother...
Aubrey is a state swimming champion whose dad is a self-centered, one-hit-wonder novelist--the eldest Story, the family's former golden boy. Aubrey, her dad, and Aubrey's growth are, IMO, the heart of the book. She starts off the least interesting cousin (sorry Aubrey!) and grows into the book's strongest character as she comes to terms with who her dad is, and what that makes her.
Jonah is the son of Anders, the charismatic and cold-hearted second son--his most recent newsmaking turn is running a financial scheme that bankrupted people. Jonah's a bit much, really, but even though he has a major chip on his shoulder, that doesn't stop him from liking his cousins rather a lot, really... but will those warm, fuzzy feelings stop him from doing what he came to the island to do?
Aubrey is probably the most layered character who experiences the most growth; I definitely cheered for her at certain points. It's really her book, IMO. Milly starts out VERY strong (I longed for more of her chapters at the beginning) but that said I do wish she'd been equally as strong at the end? (meaning, wish she were more involved in the book's climax) Maybe because we also get POV chapters from her mom in the past, I found Milly the trickiest to parse as the book went on-her mom then and Milly now didn't always connect. But when Milly came out swinging I LOVED her. Jonah was his own brand of fun, though he largely exists to augment the girls', which I was a-ok with. Regardless: once I got to know all three cousins, I was equally happy to be in any of their given POVs, and I cared about what happened to them.
The tension was delicious at times and I was turning pages trying to piece together why on earth the Story kids were disowned--what did they do!--and that alongside the summer vibes and characters made this just a thoroughly fun read. It has some really juicy twists and of course a swoony summer romance. Highly recommend for YA thriller fans generally, but particularly those who like beach towns, summer vibes, family secrets, etc.