Let me preface this with: this isn’t really my type of book. The first half felt like a fantasy rpg which I mostly enjoyed (besides a few character choices). The second half was mostly a war novel which I personally didn’t enjoy.
Things I liked:
The world-building, hands down, was my favorite part. I thought it was spectacular. You could tell that a lot of research and thought went into every single part of it.
A few of the more specific scenes: Klaus and his Night Terror, the death of the little boy Marco, Cyrus and Dasha before the final battle, scenes that showed the characters’ personalities.
Her uncle was Lazarus! Loved that. I knew he was alive and when her father said he knew him, I thought, “wouldn’t it be cool if Lazareth were the uncle?” I was, however, horrendously upset that her father didn’t TELL her this at that moment.
Things I didn’t like:
The beginning felt very … confusing? I was confused how the outsiders were able to get into the castle unnoticed AND get the guard on their side AND not a single person told the King or Queen? Queen’s handmaiden? King’s aide? No one thought it fit to tell them? It was mentioned that the castle had less people so anyone loyal to the Crown should have alerted them to newcomers, right? Especially if they had a good reign. It seems a bit far fetched.
Training was very long and a bit boring. I felt like Lumin had very little point to it. We already knew Dasha was rash and naive and Klaus was headstrong. We didn’t really learn much during these games and they weren’t that exciting… what I wished we had gotten in the training sequence was more character interaction and less of the actual training.
Character building in general was a bit lacking in places. The first half of the book was decent (more about one character in particular later) but the second half… it was hard to tell who was who. I knew a name and a job, sure, but I had know idea what their personality was like. So they all blended together.
I would have LOVED a time lapse between the first half and second half, even just 2-3 years. A few reasons for this: Dasha had a huge personality jump between the end of training and meeting her parents + gathering people for war. It was like she aged 3 years mentally but not physically. I think just a page of “3 years later” would have sufficed with a summary of what she did in those years, gathering followers. We could still get many of those scenes but we could also avoid some of the more boring ones.
Now… let me talk about what disappointed me most. Klaus. SIGH. After his Night Terror scene, I was curious about him. I was SO excited to get a morally grey character in this sea of black and white. But what we got was a horribly awful boy. Him hitting Cora made sense. Him abandoning Cora made sense. Even him trying to turn Dasha in made sense! There is where I felt it went overboard. He then tried to attack Dasha anytime he could, ultimately bringing about his death over the very stupid action of attacking on dragons. It seemed so stupid of him to do it… His death seemed like a cop out and his life seemed like it was just there to bring conflict to a section that had none. I wish he would have been more remorseful: I really wanted a grey character. But all I feel for the boy is hate and disappointment, not even pity.
All in all, I struggled with the book. I think Robbins has real talent in world-building and writing. Her book got SO much more well-written near the end. I think she just needed a little more characterization to make me feel for these characters she created.
Hoping her next book goes well!