This review is long long overdue, but I finally finished! (Even if I technically finished at 3 AM which is not good for my sleep schedule but whatever, this book was worth it)
The Bridesmaid has such an alluring, unique premise that immediately drew me to the story. The book starts with a bang, getting right under a reader’s skin and foreshadowing an unsettling future. As the first bit of this story is keen on the descriptions and details, the storytelling is a bit slow. This pace greatly picks up however as the plot begins to move forward and different experiences of the past come to light.
The style is very atmospheric, really going into detail about the environment, the emotions, the whole aura of the setting. The dual timeline format of this book is very effective as you can see how different relationships were formed and grew over time. The jumps from past to present made this a fairly unique form of storytelling, and I found myself looking forward to the tidbits of the past to see how certain situations turned out the way they did. The back and forth added so many layers to this story, further contributing to the buildup and impact of the reveals.
I do find the whole “I have a secret, I wonder what’ll happen if I tell someone” situation to be a bit... repetitive? It just stuck out a bit while I was reading this, especially in the beginning, though this is pretty prominent in mystery/thriller-type books in general.
I didn’t actually like the characters throughout the first half of the book, which honestly did add to the very unsettling style of this mystery. I never really knew who was in the wrong and who was in the right throughout this! Each character had a dark, immoral side along with other somewhat redeeming qualities? This made for such a creepy, eerie form of storytelling with lots of very effective suspense and foreshadowing. What I did love was how you could see the motives behind every character, and why they act the way they do. Different perspectives reveal different aspects of these characters, and things are often not what they seem.
I also very much loved some of the minor characters and their supportive nature towards the main characters. Even as they didn’t play much of a role in the actual mystery element, they didn’t cause further problems for our MCs thus making me like them much more as a whole.
I did feel like the critical reveals were a bit rushed and very much packed towards the end. The first reveal definitely caught me by surprise and worked really well with the plot of the book, but the ones afterward were a bit dimmed due to how they just kept piling on top of the first one. This book I feel would be characterized less as a mystery and more like a collection of unraveling secrets and various truths of the Saxby Hall and its family.
I loved the different themes explored throughout this book and how Manning did not shy away from showing all the sides of her characters, as ugly as they may be. The suspense and drama are prominent in this story, making this such a page-turner! I was glued to this until the AMs!
I had a really great time with this story, watching as secrets come to light, relationships are unraveled, and new, hidden sides of characters are revealed. The twisted friendship along with the mysteries of the past made this such a dark, suspenseful read! I’d definitely recommend this to anyone looking for an atmospheric mystery with twists and turns at every corner and eerie, unsettling relationships waxing and waning throughout the story.
Thank you to Netgalley and Boldwood Books for a complimentary copy of this book!
Strong 3.5, rounded up :)