.Note: This review may spoil some of the book’s contents. The page numbers referenced are for the U.S. 1st Edition Hardcover.
So... this review is pretty much a book in itself. Before I start, I want to mention I have been following Dan's online presence fairly consistently since 2017, but I am reviewing this book objectively as a person who reads books (rather than a fan looking to provide unconditional support). Even though I was rather pessimistic about the idea of a Youtuber mental health book, I made sure to go in with a completely open mind.
Because it's clear he wishes for this to be regarded as a separate, more serious, project from his online career, I won't be treating Dan’s book as a "Youtuber book". Rather, I will compliment and criticize it as I would any regular text.
My first comment is a negative one about the first page titled "KEEP SAFE" which gave a police station as an example of a safe place to go if you are experiencing a serious mental health crisis. I think this is not only poor advice, but wildly tone-deaf to write when we are witnessing video footage each and every day proving that this is not the case for most people. Too many people who turned to the police during their lowest points are now dead. It's not dramatic or stretching to say that citing police stations as safe places for people experiencing a crisis could be life-ending advice being that police in most countries have little to no training in handling mental health crises, yet extensive training in combat.
The book is littered with (IN MY OPINION!) outdated attempts at relatability, but amongst the cheugy millennial humor there are sentiments, anecdotes, and examples for the mh activities that I found funny. Is it immature to point and laugh at a 13 year old accidentally touching a boob? Probably yeah, but it keeps you engaged! I think Dan succeeded in his effort to involve his core demographic in a book that offers practical mental health advice.
"I know unlimited internet is necessary for my lifestyle, but I reserve the right to complain about how expensive it is." I don't think this attempt at financial relatability was needed. Two world tours, tens of thousands of pieces of merch and books sold, a big custom-built house in London... I'm sure you can afford your internet cost. It's a personal pet peeve of mine to see rich or upper-middle class influencers complain about money in an attempt to be relatable to the working class. Like, while I'm sure you came from a lower-middle class family, you're well off now or at least much better off than at least 95% of people in the world.
I found Part 2 “TOMORROW” very useful, as I was introduced to the concept of “mood congruence” on page 113! Because of the advice in this book, I also will be writing down my tasks and choices, both mundane and major, and seeing which ones correlate to my mood. Sometimes, I feel like my mental health and motivation does its own thing but realistically I know it probably corresponds to what I do throughout my day on a stronger level than I give it credit for. Is it possible science will destroy my procrastinating tendencies?!
An initial thought I had when I first learned Dan Howell was releasing a mental health book was, “Why Dan? How are you qualified whatsoever to give me mental health advice?” And when I learned everything was proofread by a licensed psychologist the question still remained, “Why DAN? Why couldn’t a psychologist have written the whole thing? Surely someone who’s studied mental health for forty years would give better advice than someone with no mental health training! But then it occurred to me, THAT BOOK ALREADY EXISTS. Probably thousands of books by fancy psychology people exist. And yet, the one I picked up and read was this one. Why? Because none of the other books would bonk me to horny jail, openly resent babies and the simplicity of which they live their lives, or refer to the urethra as “that convenient hole.”
I still think the psychologist could’ve had a hand in writing it to the point they would’ve been considered a proper co-author. In what I think is the ideal scenario, the psychologist would’ve supplied the extensive knowledge about mental health topics and Dan’s part would be making the humorous, well-formatted book that’s consumable to the average young person. A middle ground would’ve been best here in my opinion as we could’ve avoided vague phrases like “one study showed” on page 169. I get the goal was to make it accessible but surely there’s a line somewhere!! But like I said, I’ve never read “Reducing Cortisol and Improving Cognition By Albert E. Harvard PHD³”... I read the Daniel Howell Mental Health Guide. So the fact I’m reading this and being reminded of/learning new things that I wouldn’t have otherwise counts for a lot. Also, I believe the author in question’s creative control issues were brought up in the book so maybe a collaboration-heavy project wasn’t in the cards. All in all, much better that this book exists and all these people benefit from this advice than it never having been written.
I noticed a contradiction in the advice. The book first states:
“...food is not a bargaining chip, it is essential for us to stay alive. If we feel bad and our minds tell us we don’t deserve to eat, or have food we enjoy, we are sabotaging ourselves emotionally and physically. Try to be aware of how you view food as a punishment or prize and recognize instead that it’s essential fuel that you always deserve.” (154)
However, only twenty pages later it gives the post-workout recommendation:
“Treat yourself-- give yourself a carrot on a stick… have something to look forward to afterwards. Whether that’s a decadent bath, a snack, or permission to partake in some trashy entertainment. You’ve earned it.” (177)
This, obviously paints the food you enjoy as a reward to be had after doing something straining, or in other words, a bargaining chip. Genuinely believe the author did not mean for it to be interpreted that way and if he could go back might add something along the lines of “Which isn’t to say you don’t deserve a snack or self care bath regardless of all the exercise you did!” Don’t worry, I’ve already added the mental revision.
“Changing Your Mind” on 221 is incredibly important if you feel powerless about your depression or other mental health issues. For many years I felt that my depression controlled me and that I was just built differently from all these successful people. That I’d never be able to function as a normal member of society. Now, I work a full-time job that I am passionate about which is more than I EVER thought possible for me.
I also resonated deeply with the “All-Or-Nothing Thinking” segment on 225. I still struggle with this every day. In school if I didn’t think I could get straight-A’s in a certain class I would not attend school, ignore all the classwork, and ultimately spiral until I think I’m an incurable failure.
Finally, “Attitude of Gratitude” starting on 310 made me realize something fundamentally self-sabotaging about the way I view the world. Almost everything around me is covered in blood, this is a fact. The apartment I live in was built by someone who was paid in pocket change. The avocado I’m eating was picked by a child who is getting no education. That meat patty used thousands of gallons of water and put CO2 in the air at gross rates. The land I’m on was brutally colonized yet the local indigenous community isn’t provided with quality living standards. And when I know these things, I’m consumed with anger. Anger that drives me to fight for fairer policy and as a consumer, live as ethically and sustainably as I can in such a cruel society. However, not often do I take the time to set aside that anger for a moment to be grateful that I am where I am. This section made me consider that apart from literally fighting for better policy, perhaps the best thing someone in a privileged position can do is to at least be grateful for the things others wish that they had.
Overall I still think that because it was written by a non-professional, it doesn't offer anything incredibly profound but I personally benefited from it because I usually ignore my mental health and this forced me to actually think about it, even on just a basic level.
To finish it off on a positive note, here were my favorite quotes:
- "In mental health, there are no miracle cures that work for everyone." (26)
- "You may be the product of what made you, but you have the power to change and grow and make yourself feel better." (39)
- “Humans are just really complicated plants.” (121)
- “Try not to expect too much from other people -- remember they’re human and they won’t be able to read your mind or come up with magic solutions, so you might need to spell out what’s wrong, and even tell them what you need from them.” (213)
- “I won’t lie, when I first saw a therapist I was disappointed. Not with the experience-- that was profound and arguably life changing; I mean the room. I was not sitting in some grand library study, reclining on a chaise lounge while a man with a floor-length beard hummed every time I spoke.” (261)
- “Despite our best efforts and intentions, it’s normal to have ups and downs. Remember that mental health is not a straight line, we can do what we can to raise the floor level, but it will always wave with the happenings of the world.” (287)
P.S. Doubt anyone actually read all this, but if you did thanks for listening. Also, if the criticisms in this book made you mad or sad I recommend rereading Mental Filtering on page 227, which discusses looking at the big picture and not focusing on one perspective. Also know that if I didn’t like the book at all, I wouldn’t have finished it and this review wouldn’t be so damn long! Bye now.