'Gothic, claustrophobic, and wonderfully dark' GUARDIAN on Sam Hurcom's Thomas Bexley novels.. .
The next stifling, atmospheric gothic crime novel following one of the world's first forensic photographers - for fans of The Woman in Black , The Silent Companions and Little Strangers .
* * * * * * * *
1905 . A year after 'the affair' in Dinas Powys, Thomas Bexley has become a drunkard and recluse, haunted by terrible visions of the dead. But when news of a spate of extraordinary kidnappings reaches him, Thomas is shocked to learn that his dear friend and former mentor, Professor Elijah Hawthorn, is the lead suspect.
Discovering a plea for help from Hawthorn claiming to have unearthed a gruesome conspiracy at the heart of the Metropolitan Police, Thomas embarks on a journey to prove Hawthorn's innocence.
But wherever Thomas goes, he is followed by the dead, and as the mystery of Hawthorn's disappearance deepens, so too does Thomas's apparent insanity...
How can Thomas be certain of the truth when he can't trust anybody around him, not even himself...?
* * * * * * * *
Praise for Sam
'An intriguing debut' THE TIMES
'A promising debut - gothic, claustrophobic and wonderfully dark ' GUARDIAN
'A sparkling debut from a name to watch...You might as well be in another world. This is top notch historical crime fiction , with a dash of the supernatural. A gorgeous book and a riveting tale ' David Young
Sam Hurcom was born in Dinas Powys, South Wales in 1991. He studied Philosophy at Cardiff University, attaining both an undergraduate and master's degree. He has since had several short stories published, and has written and illustrated a number of children's books. Sam currently lives in the village he was raised in, close to the woodlands that have always inspired his writing. A SHADOW ON THE LENS is Sam's debut novel.
Really 3.5, but I'm rounding up as it's obvious the author put in a lot of effort here. Also, there's the outstanding audio narration.
I rarely recall details of the plots of books I've read. This one is no exception regarding A Shadow On The Lens, featuring the same main character. There are a few references to the action in the other book, but not many. I felt this one stood alone well. However, I recall the other book as being more consistently spooky. Here, there's a slow start, followed by some seriously creepy, Gothic action. Then, as is referred to in the blurbs and some reviews, the protagonist becomes the accused for the multiple murders; I skimmed through the chapters taking place while he was incarcerated, feeling there was more graphic violence than I care for, no matter how realistic it may have been. At the risk of a major spoiler, all I'll say is that he's able to work on clearing himself from outside the jail, which brings back the previous excitement.
As for the conclusion, Hurcom left open the possibility for a paranormal series featuring the main character, which would be just fine with me!
I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. This review is spoiler free.
I have been absolutely loving Gothic historical fiction at the moment -- it's the perfect thing to read when the weather begins to turn and the nights get longer -- and Letters from the Dead perfect fit the bill. I was totally swept away by this harrowing Gothic crime novel and its unreliable narrator -- I struggled to put it down!
Letters from the Dead is the second book in the Thomas Bexley series, however you can absolutely read this book without picking up the first novel, A Shadow on the Lens (although I plan to go back and read the first book!). These novels are set in Edwardian London and Scotland, and Hurcom creates a dizzyingly claustrophobic narrative that is so incredibly compelling. I had a great time watching the mystery unfold, picking up on the clues dotted throughout the story, and trying to figure out what was happening.
Bexley is a fascinating character because he's a totally unreliable narrator. Not only is he an alcoholic with huge gaps in his memory between the events of the first book and the beginning of the second, but he's also absolutely sure he's going mad. He's a twist on the classic broken detective character and being haunted by the dead -- filling his life with unease and terror and keeping him on edge at all times. As the story progresses, he becomes more and more unstable and unreliable, but is he truly losing his mind? I really enjoyed following his story arc throughout this book, but I do feel like I missed a little bit of his initial character development having not read the first novel, which is totally my fault -- I didn't know him well to start out with and couldn't compare him to the man he was before joining the police. Regardless, I found him absolutely fascinating and really enjoyed, if that's the right word, watching his story unfold.
A fantastically twisted and macabre crime novel with just the right amount of horror, Letters from the Dead is a book I'd highly recommend for fans of historical-set crime fiction or Laura Purcell's novels. In fact, I've already handed it off to my mother -- what better endorsement can you get?
Letters from the Dead is the second novel featuring Thomas Bexley, but it can be read as a standalone, I should know, it’s what I did. Throughout Letters from the Dead there are references to and hints at what happened to Thomas in the first instalment, A Shadow on the Lens. These references and hints are enough to allow readers like myself who are new to Thomas Bexley to follow the narrative of Letters from the Dead perfectly and I must say that they’ve made me very curious indeed. I enjoyed my time with Thomas so much that I’ve ordered a copy of A Shadow on the Lens.
In Letters from the Dead, we find London terrorised by the Wraith of London. Men and women from all walks of life and all corners of the capital are being kidnapped by a criminal so insidious, so dangerous, so fear-inspiring that people are saying he might be the phantom of the Ripper, able to walk through walls and locked doors. The victims are missing, presumed dead, and the police is at a loss. Former special investigator / crime scene photographer Thomas Bexley is called in for questioning, since a friend and former colleague of his, an forensics expert named Hawthorn, is the prime suspect. Thomas doesn’t know what or who to believe and he’s obviously going through a bit of a rough patch: he can see ghosts and he’s not quite coping with that fact.
On his quest for the truth, Thomas’ lot is thrown in with Beatrice’s, who tells him she’s the sister of one of the missing persons and dead set on finding out who’s responsible, on getting justice. What ensues is part murder mystery, part ghost story, all fantastic historical crime fiction. Set a few decades after Jack the Ripper’s Whitechapel murders, that is exactly the gloomy atmosphere and eerie vibe you can expect from Letters from the Dead, and there are some decidedly creepy scenes in there as well. Victims go missing without leaving a trace or with anyone in their vicinity – family, friends, neighbours – being none the wiser. It is all awfully mysterious so of course I couldn’t get enough of it.
I saw one of the reveals (or rather: part of it) coming ages before Thomas did. At first it made me feel quite clever – look at me, master sleuth – but after a while I just wanted to scream at him to wake up and smell the bloody coffee! Despite his issues and struggles, or perhaps thanks to his issues and struggles, I really liked Thomas Bexley as a protagonist. Most of the time we got on like a house on fire, and part of my obsession with Letters from the Dead stemmed from my needing him to be okay.
A satisfying murder mystery and compelling historical crime fiction with the added bonus (to this particular reader, at least) of an occult element in the form of ghosts, Letters from the Dead was the perfect fit for me, and I think a great many other readers as well. If you enjoy Gothic historical crime fiction set in Victorian/Edwardian times or books like The Quickening by Rhiannon Ward, Spirited by Julie Cohen or Wakenhyrst by Michelle Paver, I highly recommend you check out Letters from the Dead!
I have conflicting thoughts about this book. I appreciate the effort put into the plot - it was done really well, and kept me guessing to the very end. However, the supernatural elements, which are a big part of the book, were juvenile, verging on the comic and repetitive. I think the whole book would have been more convincing without all that silly ghost banter. Actual rating: 2.5*
This is the second Bexley novel, one in which London is terrorised by the Wraith; a mysterious figure that has kidnapped people and left only a cultish symbol as a clue. It works as a standalone novel but I think I would’ve liked to have read the first book as there’s quite a bit referencing back to that one especially in where the ghost sightings started. I did really enjoy it though regardless.
It’s very atmospheric. It would make a great old time hammer film. The descriptions of foggy London and atmospheric creepy houses on the abandoned island in Scotland are so indepth. It was so easy to transport myself to all of them. There are quite a few twists to keep you guessing and it never slows from the start. A creepy, compelling ghost-crime read. Loved it.
It’s 1905 and Thomas Bexley, a forensic photographer has begun seeing ghosts.
Bexley also has a drinking problem and has gaps in his memory but after his former mentor is accused of going on a spate of killings, he then has to put all of his problems aside to solve the case.
Problem is The Dead want to find out the truth and they won’t leave him alone until he has done so.
Is it his former mentor that’s killed all those people or a cult that’s behind the killings or is it someone else entirely?
After he finds a body of one of his friends, things start to come to light and he soon starts uncovering the truth.
I loved that I had no idea where it was going and Hurcom constantly surprised me. Every time I thought I knew where the novel was going, Hurcom changed it on us.
This is a fantastic read that’s brilliantly creepy and highly descriptive.
‘Letters from the Dead’ is full of lots of moments that is guaranteed to send chills down your spine and is the kind of novel that is bound to keep you up all night in more ways than one.
This is a perfect mix of Sherlock Holmes and The Others so if you love gothic crime novels or spooky reads then this is the one for you.
WOW! First of all thank you to NetGalley and Orion Publishing for providing me with the eARC of this fantastic book. This was a wild ride in the best sense of the word. It kept me gripped from start to finish and I couldn't bare to put the book down. I finished the second half in one sitting! The writing was absolutely stunning (I have a whole folder of quote screenshots) and Sam Hurcom did a great job of building up the tension, which I have to say was palpable and I found myself holding my breath multiple times. I especially loved how Hurcom wrote the more horror-esque aspects of the book like Bexley's visions and the scenes at the manor which were at some points absolutely terrifying. Watching our lead character unravel and starting to question whether he is or is not a reliable narrator was fascinating. I loved how the author made me want to go back and analyse the previous chapters to uncover the truth. And of course, the plot twists! There were quite a few and all took me by surprise. About 60% through the book I was wondering 'so, what now?'. It felt like everything was coming up to an end, we knew or thought we knew who the killer was. So, what could possibly happen within the next 100 pages or so? And the answer is, a LOT. The second half of the story was so masterfully executed that I couldn't bare to take my eyes of the book. So, in conclusion... you need to read this book! Seriously, it's really damn good. :D
Just finished this dark and macabre tale, great follow up to the first in the series, Shadow on the Lens,
It’s 1905, London and Thomas Bexley Is a troubled and deeply disturbed forensic photographer for the police. After the events of the first book leave him mentally scarred, Thomas is soon under pressure again when the police ask for his help finding a devilish criminal who is carrying out a spate of kidnappings.
With murders, ghosts and frights galore, this is a tense and often scare filled story whilst a pretty cracking crime mystery aswell.
Ooh what a sequel!! This book took my expectations, smashed me over the head with it and ran.
This takes place after the events of A Shadow on the Lens and Thomas Bexley is a changed man. A recluse and a drunk Bexley is living on his last nerve, one ghost away from losing his mind.
Whilst shut away from the world, the Wraith of London is snatching people from their homes and the police have nothing. After they turn up at his door, convinced a former friend and colleague of his is responsible the story spirals and I couldn't guess where it was going.
I had so much fun reading this, it was so different to the first book and for that I'm grateful, going into it I wondered if it would be as good as book 1 without repeating a similar story. If there ever comes a book 3 I'm here for it!!
Turns out it's quite hard to read a book AND hide behind a cushion... But I gave it a very good try,from very early in the book,because those visits from the dead were too creepy.
Thomas Bexley, a year on from where we left him,is a broken man with a drink problem. As the book continues,I began to think he was also mad,and a mass murderer. The only reason I know he wasnt going to swing from the gallows was that he was narrating the book from 10 years in the future. That didn't stop the tension,the horror and the surprise that came as I worked my way through the book.
This is the second (of many I hope) books to feature Bexley,and I feel it really upped the creepy/fear factor of the first,and left us with a man and a mission.
Look forward to seeing where he goes.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I loved Shadow on the Lens and I loved this novel. It's gripping, creepy and highly entertaining. A gothic thriller that kept me on the edge and wondering if what I read was reality or another of the visions of Thomas. The plot is tightly knitted and flows, the world building and character development are excellent. It's a thriller but it's also a fascinating story and I thoroughly enjoyed it even if I discovered the culprit quite soon. Highly recommended. Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this ARC, all opinions are mine
This was an enjoyable follow up to the first Bexley novel:A shadow on the lens. This had atmospheric writing that helped make the setting realistic and eerie but the plot felt a little bit convoluted at times, which made it a bit difficult to stick with. It did however have a good ending which brought things to a satisfying and definitely left things open for another installment. Whilst I preferred the first novel for its more simplistic plot and rural setting, which I found more scary, I enjoyed the characters in this installment more. I'd be eager to read more adventures from Bexley.
A bit of a roller coaster with this one. I enjoyed it but I think it could have been a lot better. The plot is way too obvious from the start and the writting a tad too simple. No real surprise at the end of the book, it made me feel hungry for more. I enjoyed the grimness and the gothique atmosphere, as well as the main caractere difficulties to adjust to his life and visions, drinking and thinking way too much for his own good. Also liked the depiction of London and London police force in the early 1900.
very fun and exciting. I almost couldn't stop turning the pages (alas, one must sleep). I loved the creepy and supernatural parts, Hurcom has a very good talent at describing even the most gruesome things so that one cannot stop reading them. it was a fascinating story. my only downside is that I was able to guess one of the plot twists way too quickly which took me out a bit, followed by the final twist which I found predictable, but I enjoy finding out how and why things happened. love the mystery and all that
• At first it started out slow and I wasn't too interested but later on it got interesting and I got really invested in the story. • I had a couple of theories of my own of what was going one at some parts but I was still very surprised with the plot twists. • It was great.
I absolutely love discovering new authors and particularly those who write historical crime fiction. Sam Hurcom is certainly a new author for me but having enjoyed ‘Letters From The Dead’ as much as I did, I can guarantee that I will be reading more of his work in the future. I loved reading ‘Letters From The Dead’ but more about that in a bit. I read the synopsis for ‘Letters From The Dead’ and it certainly screamed ‘read me’ at me. So doing as I was told (for once), I grabbed my copy of the book and settled down for a darn good read. Well I have to say that I was blown away by the quality of the story and by how quickly I got into the story. To say that reading ‘Letters From The Dead’ became addictive is an understatement. I picked the book up only intending to read the first couple of chapters to dip my toe in the water so to speak and I ended up becoming so wrapped up in the story that I read more like a dozen chapters in one go. I couldn’t bear to be parted from the book for fear of missing something and so the book travelled everywhere with me. The pages turned at a rapid rate but because I had become so involved in the story, I lost all track of time and just how quickly I was getting through the story. All too quickly I reached the end of ‘Letters From The Dead’ and I had to bid farewell to Thomas Bexley. I soon cheered up when I realised that I had the first book in the series to catch up on. ‘Letters From The Dead’ is superbly written. The author has one of those writing styles appropriate to the time in which the book is set. By that I mean he uses the language of the time and writes it in an Edwardian gothic style. For me, this helped the story seem that bit more authentic and I felt as though I had jumped inside a time machine and travelled back to the era in which the story is set. The author has written a crime novel, with a twist of the supernatural which you don’t often find in crime novels. It’s this sprinkling of the supernatural that helps the book stand out from the crowd. ‘Letters From The Dead’ drew me in and then took me on one hell of an unpredictable journey with many twists and turns along the way. For me, ‘Letters From The Dead’ hit the ground running and maintained a fairly speedy pace throughout. I was gripped by the story from start to finish and on the edge of my seat throughout. In short, I thoroughly enjoyed reading ‘Letters From The Dead’ and I would have no hesitation in recommending this book to other readers. I will be reading much more from Sam Hurcom in the future. The score on the Ginger Book Geek board is a very well deserved 5* out of 5*.
Special thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing a review e-copy in exchange for honest feedback.
At first, I was totally wondering why I seemed so lost in reading a few chapters. After I finished this book then I realized, this is the 2nd book already. How I wish I can read the first book and do the review too. However, the storyline is different from the first book so I was able to catch up with the plot. I was bored at the first few chapters then things change when there new character comes in.
When Beatrice showed up, it's getting interesting including the mystery/adventure exists in the story. I can't stop reading when I already able to pick up the storyline and curious about what is going on in this story. Beatrice quite annoying to me. A bit. Asking here, there and being a bit of pushy while Thomas is struggling. However, it fits the story or else it will be a dull one.
It is also appealing to me since there is some sort Sherlock vibes, not to the character but to the mystery surrounding in the story. I wish to see Thomas acted as the best investigator as Beatrice mentioned it. He should be portrayed so in this story but all I can found is he is struggling perhaps his strength is shown in the first book. The plot twist thrown in the book already kind of expected near to its revealing time. I mean when you read a few dialogue before the truth came out, you can predicted whos and whats but still good to me. It also can regards as horror genre since there were ghost apparitions here. It gave me goosebumps while reading. I love it !!! From here I realized I love Gothic Historical Fiction books. To me, if I can't stop reading, this book is a page turner and deserve 4.5 or 5 stars.
I hadn't noticed that this was the second book, so I was worried at first whether or not I would be needing to have read the first book in order to understand the book. Luckily, this wasn't the case, altough I am certain it would have been to my personal benefit had I read the first book already. Nontheless, I was able to read the book without having lost too much context, because the book was doing a great job at keeping me posted about the neccessary information. At first, I thought I was going to like the book a lot - the first chapter started intriguing enough and I was captivated immediately. However, when I continued to read, I was close to just put it down and mark it as a DNF. I thought I knew exactly what was going to happen and was dissappointed, since the book itself had sounded promising enough. Luckily, I did not give in to that urge. The book took a wonderful twist in more than one way and I was (and still am) glad to have continued reading the book, because it was worth every second of it. I love a story set in Great Britain, especially in the 18th to 20th century. I love a good crime story and I love supernatural elements in my books. Most of all, I love a book that takes a good twist and leaves the reader guessing and following the red herrings the author left. I admit, I did. I was convinced of the character's guilt and I enjoyed the cat-and-mouse- game they were playing - all of them with the Wraith; Thomas with Hawthorne; the Police with Hawthorne and the Police with Thomas. The ending has left me hoping that there will be at least one more book, but until that book will be published, I am probably going to give the first book a go. I hope there will be even more information about Hawthorne, since he was my favorite character. (Considering the outcome of the story, I am nor really surprised.) I am usually rather picky and hesitant about giving a book five stars, but this one deserves every one of them - for the setting, the word-building, the characters and most of all, the twists it had in store.
I received a free copy by Netgalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
First things first, that cover is just gorgeous - it's everything I look for! Thomas is a character who i didn't really like as a person, but I appreciated how much detail was put into him. My favourite character is 'Beatrice', she's strong and helpful and everything this book needed for a female sidekick.
Sam wrote the book in such a clever way, I found myself second guessing the whole story half way through. It toys with mental illness and the supernatural, which is hard to do in such a fascinating and dark way.
A mysterious, gripping tale which immerses you in the story brilliantly, just maybe a little something missing.
Wow, what a great book. Really want to read the first one in the series and others thereafter. Think Sam Hurcom is an author to watch. "Letters from the Dead" is a twist on a Victorian detective novel, as Thomas can see the dead. From a photography background, he discovers when he develops pictures, he develops supernatural goings-on too which give him an insight into the crimes.
This book takes you from the slums of London right up to the wilds of Scotland. You don't know who to trust, and this is played out with real conviction right until the end.
Was lost in the world that Sam Hurcom has imagined. Thomas Bexley is a photographer in 1905 and I empathised with him greatly during this evocative story. Beatrice she was a fabulous well drawn woman. I loved her little tricks. Oh gosh Letters From The Dead is not to be missed if you like your historical fiction; likewise really if not. It’s a great book! Thanks Orion for the opportunity to read and review.
I was sent an arc of this book via Netgalley in exchange for a honest review. After enjoying the first book so much I was really looking forward to reading this and I'm glad to say it didn't disappoint. I enjoyed being inside Thomas's head, it helped with the confusion over what was real and what wasn't. The tension and mystery builds nicely throughout. The struggle that Thomas has with alcohol addiction after the events of the last book was well done, he didn't just suddenly get over it during the investigation. I found him to be a very sympathetic character. The horror imagery is strong with this one, it's not for the weak stomached and if you have a phobia of rats then there are certain scenes that will probably make it worse. The mystery had enough twists and turns to keep me interested. There were a couple of things that I was able to predict quite early on (though I was made to doubt it a few times) but there were also things that I just didn't see coming. Overall if you enjoyed the first book (and if you haven't read it, I highly recommend it) then you'll love this one too. A great spooky read for the dark winter months. It also helps that they both have gorgeous covers.
Sam Hurcom's debut, A SHADOW ON THE LENS, was one of the surprises of 2019, a genre mashup which was a great read. Hurcom's follow up, LETTERS FROM THE DEAD, continues the story of forensic photographer, Thomas Bexley. It is 1905, a year after the terrifying events of the previous book, and Bexley has not recovered. Mentally disturbed, drinking heavily, he loses whole days, weeks even, to blackouts; he does not work, avoids human contact, and believes he is haunted by the dead. Bexley is a mess but is pulled out of his fugue state, at least partially, when his estranged mentor, Elijah Hawthorn, is identified as the chief suspect in a series of kidnappings, and presumed murders, carried out by 'The London Wraith'. Bexley sets out to prove Hawthorn innocent.
As in his last novel, Sam Hurcom weaves a story which crosses genres. There are elements of Sherlock Holmes and Hammer Horror, The 39 Steps and, particularly early on, Scooby Doo (and I really mean that as a compliment) as Bexley evades his former colleagues in Scotland Yard and travels to Scotland, drawn by letter from Hawthorn, a letter sent several months previously. Accompanied by the sister of one of The Wraith's victims, Bexley follows a series of clues which lead to an even bigger mystery. Here the novel becomes a little DaVinci Code-like (albeit with better prose) as the plot is driven by coincidence and I admit my heart sank a little. But...suddenly it ALL changes and the changes cause Thomas Bexley, and the reader, to doubt everything that has gone before. It is a masterstroke.
Ultimately, Hurcom stops short of going where I really wanted him to but still delivers s thrilling, disturbing, and very satisfying second novel and I look forward to his third.
When I started reading this book I didn’t actually realise it was book 2 in the Thomas Bexley series but it honestly made no difference and can definitely be read as a stand alone which is fab. I will however be reading book 1 A Shadow on the Lens very soon because I just devoured and loved Letters from the Dead.
Thomas Bexley is a very unreliable narrator, he’s a drunk, he doesn’t know what he did yesterday, the day before or even the month before. Having stopped working he’s become a recluse and heavily depends on alcohol to help ward off the visions of the dead he sees but he’s a very interesting character and one I thoroughly enjoyed getting to know.
Throughout the story he questions himself, his sanity and his innocence and as the reader I questioned them too only finding things out as Thomas did.
Set in 1905 London and Scotland the author has done a marvellous job of creating a story that is compelling and eerie. I loved the abandoned Scottish castle, it totally gave me the heebie jeebies and it’s written so well it’s very easy to imagine, to picture the scenes clearly in your mind.
It’s a fantastic mystery that really pulls you in, giving you little clues throughout and I really enjoyed trying to fit them together. It’s dark, gothic, it’s gripping and tense. It’s a story that I got so excited about while reading that i completely lost track of time, it felt like it had a hold of me and wouldn’t let go until I finished the very last page.
Letters from the Dead is a story I highly recommended. It has everything and more that a historical crime fiction book should have and I cannot wait to read more from the very talented Sam Hurcom.
1905. After the troubling case in Dinas Powys, Tom Bexley has become a drunkard and recluse, forever haunted by the dead... You once again join Thomas Bexley as he is trying to shake off the demons of his last case from the sleepy Welsh village that nearly cost him his life. Upon being questioned regarding an old colleague, accused of crimes of the utmost disgusting nature, Tom embarks on a quest to find out the truth and track down his friend to get some answers. What Tom discovers will push his very sanity to the brink and possibly straight into the abyss, when he is accompanied by someone who may have a link to what has been going on even though he cannot surely trust this person who seems to know far too much.... When the unlikely pair are taken to a desolate and crumbling old Manor House, Tom makes a discovery which sees his eyes open wide to just how corrupt both the real, and the spirit world really are. However, as he digs deeper into a conspiracy that apparently is at the very heart of the Metropolitan Police, Thomas will stop at nothing to reveal the truth.. But will he succeed or will powers from both the living and the dead overcome him and silence Thomas forever? The ghosts of his past come back to haunt Tom at every turn. One minute a voice is calling him, the next a hand is reaching out to him... but surely it is all just his overactive imagination,Right? Gothic, atmospheric, fast-paced and genuinely disturbing, the author yet again will have you leaving the lights on, just in case a shadow leaps out to claim you...☠️
"Letters From the Dead" by Sam Hurcom grips readers with a compelling ending, overshadowing somewhat predictable plot twists. The book's unique format sparks intrigue, prompting us to question its initial phases. The main characters shine, but the supporting cast feels lackluster. However, one of the book's shining aspects is its vivid and atmospheric descriptions of early 20th-century London. The city comes alive with every turn of the page, immersing readers in its historical charm. Overall, the novel balances an engaging conclusion and format with less impressive twists and character development. Though some plot elements fall short, the vivid setting and thought-provoking structure contribute to a worthwhile reading experience.