What do you think?
Rate this book
A Midnight Dance #1
A Midnight Dance
All theater romances are tragedies. Ella Blythe knows this. Still, she cannot help but hope her own story may turn out different than most--and certainly different than the tragic story of the Ghost of Craven Street Theater. Yet as she struggles to maintain her tenuous place in the ever-shrinking ballet company, win the attentions of principal dancer Philippe, and avoid company flirt Jack, Ella cannot deny the uncanny feeling that her life is mirroring that of the dead ballerina.
Is she dancing ever closer to the edge of her own tragic end? Or will the secrets that are about to come to light offer release from the past?
Mystery and romance make the perfect dance partners in this evocative story from fan-favorite Joanna Davidson Politano.
Is she dancing ever closer to the edge of her own tragic end? Or will the secrets that are about to come to light offer release from the past?
Mystery and romance make the perfect dance partners in this evocative story from fan-favorite Joanna Davidson Politano.
384 pages, Paperback
First published September 7, 2021
119 people are currently reading
4833 people want to read
About the author
Joanna Davidson Politano
9 books1,543 followersJoanna Davidson Politano spends much of her time spinning tales that capture the colorful, exquisite details in ordinary lives. She is always on the hunt for random acts of kindness, people willing to share their deepest secrets with a stranger, and hidden stashes of sweets. She lives with her husband and their babies in a house in the woods near Lake Michigan and shares stories that move her at www.jdpstories.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 428 reviews
October 5, 2021
*Warnings*
#1 This is a long review, so pull up a chair and grab a bowl of popcorn. You’ll be here awhile. #2 When I read a review, I want substantial information. So I will not skimp on the details. Which may mean some spoilers, so watch out.
You know how there are some books that, when you turn the final page and walk away, you leave a piece of you behind?
You know how there are some stories that become so vivid that you feel as though you yourself are entangled in the words?
You know how there are some characters who are so alive and vibrant that you could almost touch them?
You know how there are some romances so beautiful that you wish you could claim it as your own?
You know how there are some sentences that weave together so seamlessly, in a dance so intricate and lovely, that you feel your heart soar?
You know how there are some heroes so imperfectly perfect in every way that you wish to God that you could marry them?
That was this book.
This story.
These characters.
This romance.
Those sentences.
And, Lord have mercy, my Jack.
*sighs*
I suppose I should write a full review. I should probably tell you about how lovely and melodic, how lyrical and alive Politano’s prose is. I should probably tell you about how well thought-out and paced her plots are. I should probably tell you about how unique, mysterious, and engaging her story is. I should probably tell you how vibrant and intriguing the characters are. I should probably tell you how intricately and beautifully she weaves in spiritual truths and messages to her novels.
Or...I could just continue to melt. You could join me. All you have to do...is read.
Seriously, y’all. When Politano began the story with the most enchanting pas de deux, I knew my heart was lost to me forever. You see, I have long loved all things ballet. I am by no means an expert nor an accomplished dancer (although I did take for a couple years); however, a part of me belongs to the barre...a part of me rises on releve...a part of me soars in a jete...a part of me pirouettes to the gentle refrains of classical music and sighs on a cloud of artistic euphoria.
(Please don’t ask me what any of that meant. I just went poetically wild for a moment there. Bear with me.)
Politano took that part by the hand and led it in the most beautiful, most exquisite dance ever.
Her descriptions of dance…augh, they were like kisses. Ballet...ah, yes, I now know why they called it sensual, for when you simply read the words Politano penned to evoke those images, those sounds, those emotions...you come alive.
Nothing...nothing, I tell you, has ever melted me as this novel did. True, I have melted before...but not...not in this way. Not like with Jack and Ella...mainly Jack. No, definitely, completely, wholly, fully, utterly, and irrevocably Jack.
Y’all, he was like perfection bottled into one man in tights and oil paint. (Never thought I’d find perfection in that form...but, hey, first time for everything, am I right?) I’ll be entirely honest and say I was as fooled as Ella that whole dad-blamed time, which was the point, wasn’t it? I tried so hard to save my heart for Phillippe (or, um, save Ella’s heart, I guess) and not fall for Jack. At all costs. (Considering the last time I fell for a Jack, he died and the girl ended up with some other guy that I just didn’t love as much as my man Jack and so yes me and Jacks have had some seriously rough relationships hence why I was hesitant to love on Jack Dorian but here we are and I have already claimed this sexy ballet-dancing blond from the circus as my husband. So, no, you can’t have him. Sorry, not sorry.)
And I just realized that probably constitutes as a spoiler. Oh well.
The point is that Jack was perfect. Ella was actually a heroine I more than tolerated—I may have even loved her. The way her focus always came back to God...and how she wanted Him more than anything else...and how she found a way to honor Him through dance...y’all. That was probably one of the most beautiful themes I’ve ever read. Not only because it was so unique and different from the typical themes of trust and forgiveness...but also because it was so very applicable and relatable.
Not to mention, Ella stuck to her convictions. She wasn’t just a “church-going girl”; she was a Christian and she walked (or, rather, danced) like it. Even though she was surrounded by immorality and temptation, she clung to her faith and her values, something that I truly appreciated from a reader’s perspective and also from the perspective of someone trying to do the exact same thing in our messed-up world.
That said, I would’ve liked more Jack. I would’ve loved to have seen more of his spiritual transformation...but, then again, this was technically Ella’s story.
I mean, Jack totally took it over, but it’s still Ella’s.
And...that’s basically it. I probably could’ve summed this review up in two sentences: Jack was so dad-blamed perfect and beautiful and I’m so marrying him. And if you haven’t read this book, you haven’t lived (or flown either, for that matter).
If you do nothing else, read this book for Jack.
ALSO. While I’m thinking about it...they’re from 130 years in the future, but “Come Fly With Me” and “Fly Me To The Moon” by Frank Sinatra just fit this story so well. Wonder why? Read the blessed book! I cannot stress how important that is to your well-being. You. Must. Read. This Book. Like, yesterday.
The End.
*curtsies*
Disclaimer: A complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
#1 This is a long review, so pull up a chair and grab a bowl of popcorn. You’ll be here awhile. #2 When I read a review, I want substantial information. So I will not skimp on the details. Which may mean some spoilers, so watch out.
You know how there are some books that, when you turn the final page and walk away, you leave a piece of you behind?
You know how there are some stories that become so vivid that you feel as though you yourself are entangled in the words?
You know how there are some characters who are so alive and vibrant that you could almost touch them?
You know how there are some romances so beautiful that you wish you could claim it as your own?
You know how there are some sentences that weave together so seamlessly, in a dance so intricate and lovely, that you feel your heart soar?
You know how there are some heroes so imperfectly perfect in every way that you wish to God that you could marry them?
That was this book.
This story.
These characters.
This romance.
Those sentences.
And, Lord have mercy, my Jack.
*sighs*
I suppose I should write a full review. I should probably tell you about how lovely and melodic, how lyrical and alive Politano’s prose is. I should probably tell you about how well thought-out and paced her plots are. I should probably tell you about how unique, mysterious, and engaging her story is. I should probably tell you how vibrant and intriguing the characters are. I should probably tell you how intricately and beautifully she weaves in spiritual truths and messages to her novels.
Or...I could just continue to melt. You could join me. All you have to do...is read.
Seriously, y’all. When Politano began the story with the most enchanting pas de deux, I knew my heart was lost to me forever. You see, I have long loved all things ballet. I am by no means an expert nor an accomplished dancer (although I did take for a couple years); however, a part of me belongs to the barre...a part of me rises on releve...a part of me soars in a jete...a part of me pirouettes to the gentle refrains of classical music and sighs on a cloud of artistic euphoria.
(Please don’t ask me what any of that meant. I just went poetically wild for a moment there. Bear with me.)
Politano took that part by the hand and led it in the most beautiful, most exquisite dance ever.
Her descriptions of dance…augh, they were like kisses. Ballet...ah, yes, I now know why they called it sensual, for when you simply read the words Politano penned to evoke those images, those sounds, those emotions...you come alive.
Nothing...nothing, I tell you, has ever melted me as this novel did. True, I have melted before...but not...not in this way. Not like with Jack and Ella...mainly Jack. No, definitely, completely, wholly, fully, utterly, and irrevocably Jack.
Y’all, he was like perfection bottled into one man in tights and oil paint. (Never thought I’d find perfection in that form...but, hey, first time for everything, am I right?) I’ll be entirely honest and say I was as fooled as Ella that whole dad-blamed time, which was the point, wasn’t it? I tried so hard to save my heart for Phillippe (or, um, save Ella’s heart, I guess) and not fall for Jack. At all costs. (Considering the last time I fell for a Jack, he died and the girl ended up with some other guy that I just didn’t love as much as my man Jack and so yes me and Jacks have had some seriously rough relationships hence why I was hesitant to love on Jack Dorian but here we are and I have already claimed this sexy ballet-dancing blond from the circus as my husband. So, no, you can’t have him. Sorry, not sorry.)
And I just realized that probably constitutes as a spoiler. Oh well.
The point is that Jack was perfect. Ella was actually a heroine I more than tolerated—I may have even loved her. The way her focus always came back to God...and how she wanted Him more than anything else...and how she found a way to honor Him through dance...y’all. That was probably one of the most beautiful themes I’ve ever read. Not only because it was so unique and different from the typical themes of trust and forgiveness...but also because it was so very applicable and relatable.
Not to mention, Ella stuck to her convictions. She wasn’t just a “church-going girl”; she was a Christian and she walked (or, rather, danced) like it. Even though she was surrounded by immorality and temptation, she clung to her faith and her values, something that I truly appreciated from a reader’s perspective and also from the perspective of someone trying to do the exact same thing in our messed-up world.
That said, I would’ve liked more Jack. I would’ve loved to have seen more of his spiritual transformation...but, then again, this was technically Ella’s story.
I mean, Jack totally took it over, but it’s still Ella’s.
And...that’s basically it. I probably could’ve summed this review up in two sentences: Jack was so dad-blamed perfect and beautiful and I’m so marrying him. And if you haven’t read this book, you haven’t lived (or flown either, for that matter).
If you do nothing else, read this book for Jack.
ALSO. While I’m thinking about it...they’re from 130 years in the future, but “Come Fly With Me” and “Fly Me To The Moon” by Frank Sinatra just fit this story so well. Wonder why? Read the blessed book! I cannot stress how important that is to your well-being. You. Must. Read. This Book. Like, yesterday.
The End.
*curtsies*
Disclaimer: A complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher, publicist, or author, including NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
October 13, 2021
There are a handful of authors that I always read, no matter the title, no matter the subject, just bam! Buy it and read it. Joanna Davidson Politano is one of the few. Her latest, A Midnight Dance, did not let me down…and it won’t let you down, either.
As always, Politano’s characters are the sort that by the end of the story, you discover you’ve become best friends. I especially loved the mysterious Philippe. His story is woven in gradually, making you sit up and beg for more. But Jack…ahh Jack. He is the real show stopper.
And let’s talk about that plot, shall we? Because it gives the same effect. Snippets of backstory are sprinkled throughout, leading you on to wonder how and what and why, which of course all culminates in a very satisfying end.
I’ll admit I”m not a huge fan of dance, but after reading this one, you just. might see me in the audience at the next ballet.
As always, Politano’s characters are the sort that by the end of the story, you discover you’ve become best friends. I especially loved the mysterious Philippe. His story is woven in gradually, making you sit up and beg for more. But Jack…ahh Jack. He is the real show stopper.
And let’s talk about that plot, shall we? Because it gives the same effect. Snippets of backstory are sprinkled throughout, leading you on to wonder how and what and why, which of course all culminates in a very satisfying end.
I’ll admit I”m not a huge fan of dance, but after reading this one, you just. might see me in the audience at the next ballet.
July 19, 2021
Honestly, I'm not sure I have words for this review. I could tell right from the opening pages that I was going to love Joanna Davidson Politano's latest....what I didn't realize was how deeply and personally this story was going to touch me. It's an absolutely beautiful book with lyrical writing, characters that tuck themselves into your heart, and surprising plot turns that heighten the stakes and deepen the tension. All of that would've been enough to make this one of my favorite reads of 2021, but Ella's emotional and spiritual journey throughout the story make it one of my favorites period. I'll be thinking and talking about this book for weeks, I know, but for now, suffice to say I pre-ordered the paperback within minutes of reaching The End. I'm absolutely in love with it and wish I could give it far more than five stars!
actual-tbr-list
October 6, 2021Woah, more than 30 of my Goodreads friends / people I follow have marked this one as to-read (or reviewed it)! That's crazy!
March 20, 2023
I have no words to express how beautiful this book is, or how much I loved it. It left me breathless, and all I can do is think about it.
It was so very vivid! From the characters to the story, I was completely swept away in the 1838 theater. It was as if the moment I met these characters, I was captivated by every word.
These characters didn’t just exist for me. They lived. I grew so attached to them and their unique stories.
I loved Ella. She was wholly inspiring. She was so real, so raw, so relatable. Her insecurities, her past mistakes, her struggles with perfectionism. All of it was so very relatable for me. I loved her and her story. And her faith and relationship with God was so, so inspiring. When she decided to dance for God, I was so inspired to use my gifts for Him too. I cried.
Jack Dorian was amazing. Amazing. I fell in love with his character before I even knew it had happened. He has become my favorite hero of Joanna’s books, and that’s saying a lot. I was quite in love.
The romance was beautiful and everything I ever want in a book’s love story. It entirely satisfied my romantic-loving heart. It was perfect. So, so perfect. I loved these two characters with all my heart.
The faith was beautiful. It was woven so beautifully into the story. I was left so inspired. So hopeful.
The writing. Oh, how can I describe how much I love the writing? It’s absolutely beautiful. It’s lyrical and poetic while also being so very real. There’s such a distinction, tone, and grace in Joanna’s writing. I love it.
I laughed, I cried, I felt.
There were so many great plot twists. The mystery was so very compelling.
I was so reluctant to put this book down that I didn’t. I couldn’t get my head out of this book. Literally. I finished it within hours. I’m so glad I read it on a lazy Sunday otherwise my mind would not have been at peace.
The historical details were so intriguing. The setting was wonderfully neat. The 1838 theater and ballet was so interesting. I loved it!
The ending was the BEST. It was beyond perfect. I can’t say how very happy it made me. I felt like crying just by the sheer beauty of it.
I love reading Joanna’s books. I discovered her books last year, and I’m forever grateful that I did. I knew then that she would be one of my TOP favorite authors, and every book she publishes proves that.
I come back to her books because they aren’t merely entertainment for me. I come to her books because they change me. They inspire me, encouraging me to be better and grow in my relationship with God. And that’s invaluable. Something a lot of books can’t do. Not only am I swept away by the story, I’m inspired to live my life for my Savior.
A Midnight Dance was everything I hoped it would be but so, so much more. It was beautiful and I loved it. It made it straight to my list of favorite books. It’s one of those books I know I will reread over and over again. The story is timeless.
I’m beyond excited for her future books.
If you’re a lover of historical fiction— read this book. Even if you aren’t, this book is amazing and I don’t think you’ll be disappointed in the least.
*Thank you to the publisher for sending me a copy of this book in exchange for a review! All opinions are my own.
2023 Reread-
This book is one of my favorite books I have ever read. Period. I still have no words. It is just so beautiful! I loved it even more than I did the first time I read it if that’s even possible. I just love this story and these characters so much! They came alive for me all over again and it was magical. I enjoyed every single minute reading it and I didn’t want the story to end. Ella and Jack are two of my favorite fictional characters ever and will always have a piece of my heart.💗 Also, excuse the fangirling, but I have decided that Jack Dorian is one of my favorite fictional heroes ever and I fell in love with him even more than I did the first time I read it… which is saying something. He’s just amazing!! I love his character so very much. He just feels so real to me! So does Ella. I love them both so much.
The message of this story seemed to resonate with me even more than time reading it. I related with Ella even more this time. The way the faith is woven into this story is so beautiful and brought tears to my eyes. It’s just a beautifully written story, one I want to revisit over and over again.💗
It was so very vivid! From the characters to the story, I was completely swept away in the 1838 theater. It was as if the moment I met these characters, I was captivated by every word.
These characters didn’t just exist for me. They lived. I grew so attached to them and their unique stories.
I loved Ella. She was wholly inspiring. She was so real, so raw, so relatable. Her insecurities, her past mistakes, her struggles with perfectionism. All of it was so very relatable for me. I loved her and her story. And her faith and relationship with God was so, so inspiring. When she decided to dance for God, I was so inspired to use my gifts for Him too. I cried.
Jack Dorian was amazing. Amazing. I fell in love with his character before I even knew it had happened. He has become my favorite hero of Joanna’s books, and that’s saying a lot. I was quite in love.
The romance was beautiful and everything I ever want in a book’s love story. It entirely satisfied my romantic-loving heart. It was perfect. So, so perfect. I loved these two characters with all my heart.
The faith was beautiful. It was woven so beautifully into the story. I was left so inspired. So hopeful.
The writing. Oh, how can I describe how much I love the writing? It’s absolutely beautiful. It’s lyrical and poetic while also being so very real. There’s such a distinction, tone, and grace in Joanna’s writing. I love it.
I laughed, I cried, I felt.
There were so many great plot twists. The mystery was so very compelling.
I was so reluctant to put this book down that I didn’t. I couldn’t get my head out of this book. Literally. I finished it within hours. I’m so glad I read it on a lazy Sunday otherwise my mind would not have been at peace.
The historical details were so intriguing. The setting was wonderfully neat. The 1838 theater and ballet was so interesting. I loved it!
The ending was the BEST. It was beyond perfect. I can’t say how very happy it made me. I felt like crying just by the sheer beauty of it.
I love reading Joanna’s books. I discovered her books last year, and I’m forever grateful that I did. I knew then that she would be one of my TOP favorite authors, and every book she publishes proves that.
I come back to her books because they aren’t merely entertainment for me. I come to her books because they change me. They inspire me, encouraging me to be better and grow in my relationship with God. And that’s invaluable. Something a lot of books can’t do. Not only am I swept away by the story, I’m inspired to live my life for my Savior.
A Midnight Dance was everything I hoped it would be but so, so much more. It was beautiful and I loved it. It made it straight to my list of favorite books. It’s one of those books I know I will reread over and over again. The story is timeless.
I’m beyond excited for her future books.
If you’re a lover of historical fiction— read this book. Even if you aren’t, this book is amazing and I don’t think you’ll be disappointed in the least.
*Thank you to the publisher for sending me a copy of this book in exchange for a review! All opinions are my own.
2023 Reread-
This book is one of my favorite books I have ever read. Period. I still have no words. It is just so beautiful! I loved it even more than I did the first time I read it if that’s even possible. I just love this story and these characters so much! They came alive for me all over again and it was magical. I enjoyed every single minute reading it and I didn’t want the story to end. Ella and Jack are two of my favorite fictional characters ever and will always have a piece of my heart.💗 Also, excuse the fangirling, but I have decided that Jack Dorian is one of my favorite fictional heroes ever and I fell in love with him even more than I did the first time I read it… which is saying something. He’s just amazing!! I love his character so very much. He just feels so real to me! So does Ella. I love them both so much.
The message of this story seemed to resonate with me even more than time reading it. I related with Ella even more this time. The way the faith is woven into this story is so beautiful and brought tears to my eyes. It’s just a beautifully written story, one I want to revisit over and over again.💗
October 1, 2021
About this book:
“The best moments in dance are the unscripted ones.
At their core, all theater romances are tragedies. Ella Blythe knows this. Still, she cannot help but hope her own story may turn out different than most—and certainly different than the tragic story of the Ghost of Craven Street Theatre.
After a chance encounter with one of the ballet company’s handsome dancers late one night, Ella is swept off her elegantly pointed toes. The dance they share and the promise he makes to her feels like a new beginning. Yet as she faces the mounting challenges in the ever-shrinking ballet company, Ella cannot deny the uncanny feeling that her life is mirroring that of the ghostly ballerina.
Is she dancing ever closer to the edge of her own disastrous end? Or will the secrets that are about to come to light offer release from the unyielding grip of the past?”
Series: As of now, no.
Spiritual Content- Many Scriptures (Psalms) are remembered, quoted, & mentioned; Prayers; Talks about God & your dreams; ‘H’s are not capitalized when referring to God; A hymn; Because of comments from others, Ella wonders if God and dance really are separate and not able to both be in her (she struggles with this a lot (as well as dance becoming more important to her than God) but, about midway, she realizes that she can worship God through dance); Ella is called a nun by other dancers (because she is not interested in men) & mentions of it; Jack says she doesn’t put much stock in religion & was disappointed to learn about “Ella’s obsession with religion” (towards the end, he asks God what He wants from him, but not much else is said); Mentions of God; Mentions of the Psalms & David; Mentions of prayers & praying; Mentions of churches, church going, denominations, & stained glass; A few mentions of miracles; A couple mentions of being blessed; A couple mentions of sins; A mention of a Christian’s duty;
*Note: Mentions of a haunted place in a theater & a rumored ghost; Mentions of a pair of ballet slippers being called ‘enchanted’; A mention of a devilish smile; A mention of Greek mythology.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘blasted’ and a ‘for all that is holy’; Some eye rolling; A fire (up to semi-detailed); Falling down the stairs, a body, & pain (barely-above-not-detailed); Many mentions of a death, fire, & possible murderer; Mentions of pain, injuries, & burns (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of an attempted robbery & assault; Mentions of stealing & stolen items; Mentions of drinking, drunks, an addiction, alcohol, & pubs/bars; Mentions of cigars & smoking; Mentions of lies, lying, liars, & deception; Mentions of gossip & rumors; A few mentions of threats; A few mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of animal manure; A mention of a thief; A mention of hatred.
Sexual Content- A couple hand kisses, two forehead kisses, barely-above-not-detailed kisses, a semi-detailed kiss, and a detailed kiss; Dances & Touches (including a thought by Ella after a man touches her waist, now understanding what the finer set of London declared dancing as immoral, barely-above-not-detailed); Blushes & Winks; Noticing, Nearness, Smelling, & Staring (barely-above-not-detailed); A man touches Ella’s hair when it’s down (an intimate thing in this time period, barely-above-not-detailed); An older man touches Ella (a boss, not in a creepy way) and she wonders what other decent profession allowed a man to put his hands on a woman whenever he wished; Ella’s father hasn’t been in the picture (her parents were married, ; ; Mentions of a boss not wanting his dancers “to be inflicted with immorality” (with child); Mentions of prostitutes & a comment about them not working during the day; Mentions of married man having affairs & mistresses (a man makes an offer to Ella and she quickly says she’s not for sale); Mentions of romances and marriage never working for dancers & that no man will marry a female dancer, but will make them a mistress; Mentions of comments about dancers’ reputation & virtue; Mentions of kisses, hand kisses, & expecting a kiss; Mentions of a bet about kissing a girl; Mentions of a flirt & flirting; Mentions of jealousy; Mentions of blushes/blushing; Mentions of impropriety; A few mentions of a female dancer not having a speck of sensuality or allure; A few mentions of the possibility of a women having two husbands; A couple mentions of illegitimate children; A mention of wondering if a couple was in love when they produced a child; A mention of secret kisses; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: A mention of imagining a man in his knickers (to look bashful/blushing in front of him).
-Elodie “Ella” Blythe, age 18/21 (unsure based on the timeline and comments)
1st person P.O.V. of Ella & 3rd of Jack (x5), Josefina (x1), & Maymie Dobbs (x1)
Set in 1833 (first two chapters), then 1838-1839
373 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- Two Stars (and a half)
Older High School Teens- Three Stars (and a half)
My personal Rating- Four Stars
Oh, where do I begin?
While I’ll easily admit, when first learning about this book, the plot-line didn’t interest as much as past books by this author (such as “A Rumored Fortune” which quickly got my attention). Once I started reading, though, this book quickly grabbed me into story. There was many events and secrets I wasn’t expecting that shocked me again and again. That would probably that number one reason I enjoyed this book as much as I did. It takes good book to pull in me to not try to figure out what will happen and try to predict the next events.
While the characters were interesting (more on that in a minute), I can’t say they’re the ones that hook me into the story. It was the plot with the mysteries and all the secrets.
I liked Ella, her dedication to ballet and her mother. I can’t say I always agreed with her thoughts or actions, but I could understand (most of the time) where she was coming from and why she did the things she did.
I wasn’t sure where the romance would go in this story, but besides those couple kisses, it was pretty clean in the romance regard. Other Sexual Content comments and hints (mistresses, affairs, illegitimate children & abortion) were not over the top, but I hesitate about recommending this book of those under 16 because of that content.
I’ve been sitting here at my laptop for a few minutes now, debating not only my own personal rating but the higher two age groups’ ratings. This is why: “A Midnight Dance” felt more grown-up (I prefer to avoid the word “mature” as each girl is different and one word with a broad meaning cannot cover for every girl) then most books I’ve reviewed on here—but also enjoyed. (To clarify, there has been plenty of books that have been more “grown-up” because of sexual content that have received low ratings. Trust me, plenty of books.) This novel was different in the way that the Sexual Content that was there (see above) was typically more glossed-over then expounded upon like other books, so it felt cleaner than most, even while it was dealing with some similar topics.
Another reason for my debate: Ella’s Spiritual Content parts were great, however, I do question her kissing a man (quite soundly, I might add) who was not a Christian and did not seem open to sharing her faith. There’s a moment at the end with him and his own walk with the Lord, but I wish it would have been clearer and obvious. But, I suppose that could mimic life in a way, that someone’s witness takes more “pages” than what’s written down in a story. I do wish, though, it had been more precise, especially with the rumors about him being a flirt. (He does say in one of his own point of view chapters, that it’s a role he’s given himself, but I would have preferred that also be told to Ella for clarity’s sake.)
So, yes, I’m not sure if I was able to put my feelings about this book into words well, but it was a fascinating novel. I’m becoming quite a fan of historical mysteries, so I’m curious to see what this author will write next.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Revell) for this honest review.
“The best moments in dance are the unscripted ones.
At their core, all theater romances are tragedies. Ella Blythe knows this. Still, she cannot help but hope her own story may turn out different than most—and certainly different than the tragic story of the Ghost of Craven Street Theatre.
After a chance encounter with one of the ballet company’s handsome dancers late one night, Ella is swept off her elegantly pointed toes. The dance they share and the promise he makes to her feels like a new beginning. Yet as she faces the mounting challenges in the ever-shrinking ballet company, Ella cannot deny the uncanny feeling that her life is mirroring that of the ghostly ballerina.
Is she dancing ever closer to the edge of her own disastrous end? Or will the secrets that are about to come to light offer release from the unyielding grip of the past?”
Series: As of now, no.
Spiritual Content- Many Scriptures (Psalms) are remembered, quoted, & mentioned; Prayers; Talks about God & your dreams; ‘H’s are not capitalized when referring to God; A hymn; Because of comments from others, Ella wonders if God and dance really are separate and not able to both be in her (she struggles with this a lot (as well as dance becoming more important to her than God) but, about midway, she realizes that she can worship God through dance); Ella is called a nun by other dancers (because she is not interested in men) & mentions of it; Jack says she doesn’t put much stock in religion & was disappointed to learn about “Ella’s obsession with religion” (towards the end, he asks God what He wants from him, but not much else is said); Mentions of God; Mentions of the Psalms & David; Mentions of prayers & praying; Mentions of churches, church going, denominations, & stained glass; A few mentions of miracles; A couple mentions of being blessed; A couple mentions of sins; A mention of a Christian’s duty;
*Note: Mentions of a haunted place in a theater & a rumored ghost; Mentions of a pair of ballet slippers being called ‘enchanted’; A mention of a devilish smile; A mention of Greek mythology.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘blasted’ and a ‘for all that is holy’; Some eye rolling; A fire (up to semi-detailed); Falling down the stairs, a body, & pain (barely-above-not-detailed); Many mentions of a death, fire, & possible murderer; Mentions of pain, injuries, & burns (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of an attempted robbery & assault; Mentions of stealing & stolen items; Mentions of drinking, drunks, an addiction, alcohol, & pubs/bars; Mentions of cigars & smoking; Mentions of lies, lying, liars, & deception; Mentions of gossip & rumors; A few mentions of threats; A few mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of animal manure; A mention of a thief; A mention of hatred.
Sexual Content- A couple hand kisses, two forehead kisses, barely-above-not-detailed kisses, a semi-detailed kiss, and a detailed kiss; Dances & Touches (including a thought by Ella after a man touches her waist, now understanding what the finer set of London declared dancing as immoral, barely-above-not-detailed); Blushes & Winks; Noticing, Nearness, Smelling, & Staring (barely-above-not-detailed); A man touches Ella’s hair when it’s down (an intimate thing in this time period, barely-above-not-detailed); An older man touches Ella (a boss, not in a creepy way) and she wonders what other decent profession allowed a man to put his hands on a woman whenever he wished; Ella’s father hasn’t been in the picture (her parents were married, ; ; Mentions of a boss not wanting his dancers “to be inflicted with immorality” (with child); Mentions of prostitutes & a comment about them not working during the day; Mentions of married man having affairs & mistresses (a man makes an offer to Ella and she quickly says she’s not for sale); Mentions of romances and marriage never working for dancers & that no man will marry a female dancer, but will make them a mistress; Mentions of comments about dancers’ reputation & virtue; Mentions of kisses, hand kisses, & expecting a kiss; Mentions of a bet about kissing a girl; Mentions of a flirt & flirting; Mentions of jealousy; Mentions of blushes/blushing; Mentions of impropriety; A few mentions of a female dancer not having a speck of sensuality or allure; A few mentions of the possibility of a women having two husbands; A couple mentions of illegitimate children; A mention of wondering if a couple was in love when they produced a child; A mention of secret kisses; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: A mention of imagining a man in his knickers (to look bashful/blushing in front of him).
-Elodie “Ella” Blythe, age 18/21 (unsure based on the timeline and comments)
1st person P.O.V. of Ella & 3rd of Jack (x5), Josefina (x1), & Maymie Dobbs (x1)
Set in 1833 (first two chapters), then 1838-1839
373 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- Two Stars (and a half)
Older High School Teens- Three Stars (and a half)
My personal Rating- Four Stars
Oh, where do I begin?
While I’ll easily admit, when first learning about this book, the plot-line didn’t interest as much as past books by this author (such as “A Rumored Fortune” which quickly got my attention). Once I started reading, though, this book quickly grabbed me into story. There was many events and secrets I wasn’t expecting that shocked me again and again. That would probably that number one reason I enjoyed this book as much as I did. It takes good book to pull in me to not try to figure out what will happen and try to predict the next events.
While the characters were interesting (more on that in a minute), I can’t say they’re the ones that hook me into the story. It was the plot with the mysteries and all the secrets.
I liked Ella, her dedication to ballet and her mother. I can’t say I always agreed with her thoughts or actions, but I could understand (most of the time) where she was coming from and why she did the things she did.
I wasn’t sure where the romance would go in this story, but besides those couple kisses, it was pretty clean in the romance regard. Other Sexual Content comments and hints (mistresses, affairs, illegitimate children & abortion) were not over the top, but I hesitate about recommending this book of those under 16 because of that content.
I’ve been sitting here at my laptop for a few minutes now, debating not only my own personal rating but the higher two age groups’ ratings. This is why: “A Midnight Dance” felt more grown-up (I prefer to avoid the word “mature” as each girl is different and one word with a broad meaning cannot cover for every girl) then most books I’ve reviewed on here—but also enjoyed. (To clarify, there has been plenty of books that have been more “grown-up” because of sexual content that have received low ratings. Trust me, plenty of books.) This novel was different in the way that the Sexual Content that was there (see above) was typically more glossed-over then expounded upon like other books, so it felt cleaner than most, even while it was dealing with some similar topics.
Another reason for my debate: Ella’s Spiritual Content parts were great, however, I do question her kissing a man (quite soundly, I might add) who was not a Christian and did not seem open to sharing her faith. There’s a moment at the end with him and his own walk with the Lord, but I wish it would have been clearer and obvious. But, I suppose that could mimic life in a way, that someone’s witness takes more “pages” than what’s written down in a story. I do wish, though, it had been more precise, especially with the rumors about him being a flirt. (He does say in one of his own point of view chapters, that it’s a role he’s given himself, but I would have preferred that also be told to Ella for clarity’s sake.)
So, yes, I’m not sure if I was able to put my feelings about this book into words well, but it was a fascinating novel. I’m becoming quite a fan of historical mysteries, so I’m curious to see what this author will write next.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Revell) for this honest review.
October 14, 2021
I am not sure what I was expecting in this book but it wasn't this. It is mysterious, with a Victorian era gothic feel to it.
I really knew nothing about ballet before reading this now I feel enriched for having read it.
You travel in a place while reading in where you are asking yourself if this is realistic or you are in a dream world.
Very atmospheric the book has a dark gothic feel to it as though you know something is just around the corner waiting to happen.
There are bits of it I just don't understand, like the red ballet slippers. They are such an important connection ,then when they are stolen they are no longer important?
The ending was surprising and a shake up. The book felt a bit like swimming in murky waters while reading it.
Pub Date: 07 Sep 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
I really knew nothing about ballet before reading this now I feel enriched for having read it.
You travel in a place while reading in where you are asking yourself if this is realistic or you are in a dream world.
Very atmospheric the book has a dark gothic feel to it as though you know something is just around the corner waiting to happen.
There are bits of it I just don't understand, like the red ballet slippers. They are such an important connection ,then when they are stolen they are no longer important?
The ending was surprising and a shake up. The book felt a bit like swimming in murky waters while reading it.
Pub Date: 07 Sep 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
October 13, 2022
I really enjoyed this beautiful story! A Midnight Dance is all about Ella, an inspiring ballet dancer who is just so relatable throughout her struggles and determination to be a successful dancer. 3.5 stars rounding up to 4 on Goodreads.
Ella is so dedicated to dancing and her mom – who was also a ballet dancer. In this story, there is a mystery surrounding an accident in her mother’s past and her father. Ella meets the charming Jack Dorian and they work together to try and figure out what they can about her mother and father.
My favorite parts of this story were the dancing scenes and ballet details. When I was a young girl, I did a ballet class and had a little recital. So those scenes just really captivated me – I could visually see all of that.
The writing in this story is poetic, atmospheric, and beautiful. Enjoyed the ending. My only 2 downsides to this is I was honestly very confused on the family storyline for some reason and wish the faith of Jack was expanded upon. I just had a hard time keeping up with “who is who” on the family story/mystery.
The faith content in this is a good balance - scriptures, prayer and multiple faith discussions.
Overall, a very engaging and enjoyable story! If you love dance stories and a bit of mystery and romance, especially ballet 🩰, you will like this.
Ella is so dedicated to dancing and her mom – who was also a ballet dancer. In this story, there is a mystery surrounding an accident in her mother’s past and her father. Ella meets the charming Jack Dorian and they work together to try and figure out what they can about her mother and father.
My favorite parts of this story were the dancing scenes and ballet details. When I was a young girl, I did a ballet class and had a little recital. So those scenes just really captivated me – I could visually see all of that.
The writing in this story is poetic, atmospheric, and beautiful. Enjoyed the ending. My only 2 downsides to this is I was honestly very confused on the family storyline for some reason and wish the faith of Jack was expanded upon. I just had a hard time keeping up with “who is who” on the family story/mystery.
The faith content in this is a good balance - scriptures, prayer and multiple faith discussions.
Overall, a very engaging and enjoyable story! If you love dance stories and a bit of mystery and romance, especially ballet 🩰, you will like this.
June 2, 2022
Since finishing A Midnight Dance by Joanne Davidson Politano, I think I've watched three documentaries on ballet and ballet dancers--which is always a sign that the novel completely captivated me and I'm hungry for more on the subject. Thankfully, I own three other novels that include ballet, so I'll get to those soon!
But this one. Oh, Joanna, you slay me. The writing is as ethereal as the cover. Many times I just stopped to reread a particularly beautiful passage. The story is absolutely layered with meaning--I saw metaphors, analogies, and parallels to spiritual journey all over the place. Some are spelled out, the rest are left for the discerning reader to discover on her own.
The author totally nailed the ending to the book. The way she wrapped up the story could not have been more perfect. I'm so, so impressed. I'll read anything she writes.
But this one. Oh, Joanna, you slay me. The writing is as ethereal as the cover. Many times I just stopped to reread a particularly beautiful passage. The story is absolutely layered with meaning--I saw metaphors, analogies, and parallels to spiritual journey all over the place. Some are spelled out, the rest are left for the discerning reader to discover on her own.
The author totally nailed the ending to the book. The way she wrapped up the story could not have been more perfect. I'm so, so impressed. I'll read anything she writes.
January 19, 2024
Wow wow wow!!! That ending…the little plot twists. The CHARACTERS and the faith!!!!😭
*Just finished my first reread of this and wow. Even better the second time. The amount of tabs that I have in this book now is kinda crazy but I love it so much!!!! One of my fave books of all time…well most of her books are but whatever. I already want to read it again😂🥹😭😍🤍🤭
*Just finished my first reread of this and wow. Even better the second time. The amount of tabs that I have in this book now is kinda crazy but I love it so much!!!! One of my fave books of all time…well most of her books are but whatever. I already want to read it again😂🥹😭😍🤍🤭
August 8, 2023
This book started off slow for me. Maybe I was comparing it too much because I had just finished Finding Lady Enderly, which I LOVED and was so intriguing from the first chapter. But the mystery wasn't that interesting at first and not much was happening. But all the twists and reveals in the latter half/the end of the book made up for a lot!
October 26, 2021
All I had to do was be still, cease striving, and know. Know, as I knew breathing and gravity and Mama's love.
help I've fallen in love with this story and I can't get up. In equal parts, I want to shout from the rooftops how much I loved it and hold it quietly close to my heart and never let go. I haven't read any of this author's books before now, but rest assured I will be devouring her backlist sooner rather than later.
"A Midnight Dance" is an enchanting, haunting, deeply moving story of how God has His plan for us in place before we can see it ourselves. There's a bit of mystery, some fascinating characters, and so much love for dance that I ended up unashamedly twirling instead of walking around my house when I couldn't read. Dance has been a part of my life since I was very young, but at this moment in time, I haven't been able to go to class in over a year, and this book brought a yearning to be back like I haven't felt in a long time.
The faith content was just... amazing. I will always love a novel where the main character is firmly rooted in their faith, and their biggest desire is to know God better, and do what He's called them to do. (Don't get me wrong, a salvation story is great ((we get one of those in here too)) but as someone who's been a Christian for a long time, I just don't see as much representation of that as I'd like.) God used this book for me, and I know I won't be the only one.
I loved the mystery element here, it was so well done. The story peels back layer after layer as the plot progresses, where we learn new things about the characters and history, and each twist felt nicely placed, and nothing felt like a left turn. It made sense, as much as some of it hurt, and I enjoyed that a lot.
((also yes I am a little in love with Jack Dorian. he'd drive me crazy in real life, but he's prime book boyfriend material, lol))
Overall, this is definitely going to be amongst my favorites of the year, just from how it made me feel. I don't think it's going to leave me for a long while. Five stars from me!
**I received a copy of this book from Netgalley. A positive review was not required. All opinions are my own.**
help I've fallen in love with this story and I can't get up. In equal parts, I want to shout from the rooftops how much I loved it and hold it quietly close to my heart and never let go. I haven't read any of this author's books before now, but rest assured I will be devouring her backlist sooner rather than later.
"A Midnight Dance" is an enchanting, haunting, deeply moving story of how God has His plan for us in place before we can see it ourselves. There's a bit of mystery, some fascinating characters, and so much love for dance that I ended up unashamedly twirling instead of walking around my house when I couldn't read. Dance has been a part of my life since I was very young, but at this moment in time, I haven't been able to go to class in over a year, and this book brought a yearning to be back like I haven't felt in a long time.
The faith content was just... amazing. I will always love a novel where the main character is firmly rooted in their faith, and their biggest desire is to know God better, and do what He's called them to do. (Don't get me wrong, a salvation story is great ((we get one of those in here too)) but as someone who's been a Christian for a long time, I just don't see as much representation of that as I'd like.) God used this book for me, and I know I won't be the only one.
I loved the mystery element here, it was so well done. The story peels back layer after layer as the plot progresses, where we learn new things about the characters and history, and each twist felt nicely placed, and nothing felt like a left turn. It made sense, as much as some of it hurt, and I enjoyed that a lot.
((also yes I am a little in love with Jack Dorian. he'd drive me crazy in real life, but he's prime book boyfriend material, lol))
Overall, this is definitely going to be amongst my favorites of the year, just from how it made me feel. I don't think it's going to leave me for a long while. Five stars from me!
**I received a copy of this book from Netgalley. A positive review was not required. All opinions are my own.**
September 17, 2021
Characters: Ella was my favorite character in this novel, probably because she was the primary narrator. I felt like I knew her way better than I knew Jack. Which brings me to Jack ... He didn't have a scene from his perspective until approximately 150 pages in, plus he had a reputation as a womanizer that was never entirely cleared up. I'm not at all a fan of womanizers portrayed as attractive in books (or in real life), and I struggle when they're presented as good matches for the main ladies.
Language: Clean.
Moral: The moral had to be one of my favorite parts of this book. I enjoyed seeing Ella learn she could worship God through her ballet. I found it a little strange, however, that Jesus wasn't mentioned in Ella's account of being saved (at least not that I remember ... my brain was struggling).
Plot: Fair warning ... my brain wasn't working the best when I read part of this book, but some of the plot seemed like those weird dreams you have when you're sick. You know, really foggy and just a little convoluted. I also felt like important plot points were skimmed over and/or not explained well until the very end (Jack and Ella's spat and Ella's big secret). I really loved the setting, however. I don't believe I've ever read a book about ballet set in England during the 1830s.
Romance: Clean. I didn't like how Ella didn't seem to care all that much that Jack wasn't a Christian. She kissed him and got way closer to him than was responsible when he was an unbeliever.
Writing: Joanna has an engaging writing style that fit the mood of this book well.
Overall: A Midnight Dance was an entertaining read, and I'd recommend it to those who enjoy Christian historical romances.
Disclaimer: I received this book free from the publisher/author. The opinions I have expressed are my own, and I was not required to write a positive review. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.
Language: Clean.
Moral: The moral had to be one of my favorite parts of this book. I enjoyed seeing Ella learn she could worship God through her ballet. I found it a little strange, however, that Jesus wasn't mentioned in Ella's account of being saved (at least not that I remember ... my brain was struggling).
Plot: Fair warning ... my brain wasn't working the best when I read part of this book, but some of the plot seemed like those weird dreams you have when you're sick. You know, really foggy and just a little convoluted. I also felt like important plot points were skimmed over and/or not explained well until the very end (Jack and Ella's spat and Ella's big secret). I really loved the setting, however. I don't believe I've ever read a book about ballet set in England during the 1830s.
Romance: Clean. I didn't like how Ella didn't seem to care all that much that Jack wasn't a Christian. She kissed him and got way closer to him than was responsible when he was an unbeliever.
Writing: Joanna has an engaging writing style that fit the mood of this book well.
Overall: A Midnight Dance was an entertaining read, and I'd recommend it to those who enjoy Christian historical romances.
Disclaimer: I received this book free from the publisher/author. The opinions I have expressed are my own, and I was not required to write a positive review. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.
August 11, 2021
This book held within its pages as much grace and drama as ballet itself. Politano is an artist, painting pictures with her words and digging deep to far corners of ever readers’ hearts. I loved this unique view into the history of theater and ballet and how we can worship God in the form of dance. The mystery woven within kept me turning the pages until the very last with a satisfied sigh.
January 3, 2022
Perfection. Would you expect anything less of Joanna Politano? Of ballet? And yet, in the perfection of this story, we see the "inclusions" of lives lived with true flaws and the sparkle they amplify. I loved that illustration in the story.
But A Midnight Dance is more than a story... it is a dance! It spins, sweeps, hides, and bursts onto the stage at just the right intervals. Center stage glows with the beauty of a solo, a pas de duex, an entire company. Relationships are all you hope for and nothing that they seem.
The story? Equally mystifying and compelling. Jealousy, love, anger, betrayal, joy, trust. And through it all, the love of a Father poured out on His children. Can they feel it? Will they allow themselves the wonder of a Daddy's protective care? The music of the tale carries it along until the reader gasps for breath at the crescendo.
In other words, this is one brilliant story that will keep you riveted to the story until the last page. You don't want to miss it.
But A Midnight Dance is more than a story... it is a dance! It spins, sweeps, hides, and bursts onto the stage at just the right intervals. Center stage glows with the beauty of a solo, a pas de duex, an entire company. Relationships are all you hope for and nothing that they seem.
The story? Equally mystifying and compelling. Jealousy, love, anger, betrayal, joy, trust. And through it all, the love of a Father poured out on His children. Can they feel it? Will they allow themselves the wonder of a Daddy's protective care? The music of the tale carries it along until the reader gasps for breath at the crescendo.
In other words, this is one brilliant story that will keep you riveted to the story until the last page. You don't want to miss it.
August 17, 2023
Not my favorite by this author but definitely a great book, I liked the setting and the storyline alot.
But really Jake carried this book for me 😂 he has officially made it on to my list of top fictional men. He was just absolutely amazing🥺
But honestly the main character (Ella) got on my nerves just a little bit, and I just got so tired of hearing about phillippe 😂
Also there were many times l felt kinda lost will reading this and though the ending was really sweet and beautiful it felt kind of rushed.
So for those reasons I didn't give this five stars but I still would recommend it. It's definitely a story that will stick with you even after you turn the last page. And you need to read this book even if it's just so you can experience the amazingness that is Jack Dorian👌😍 he definitely gets a 5⭐ rating even if the book didn't 😂
But really Jake carried this book for me 😂 he has officially made it on to my list of top fictional men. He was just absolutely amazing🥺
But honestly the main character (Ella) got on my nerves just a little bit, and I just got so tired of hearing about phillippe 😂
Also there were many times l felt kinda lost will reading this and though the ending was really sweet and beautiful it felt kind of rushed.
So for those reasons I didn't give this five stars but I still would recommend it. It's definitely a story that will stick with you even after you turn the last page. And you need to read this book even if it's just so you can experience the amazingness that is Jack Dorian👌😍 he definitely gets a 5⭐ rating even if the book didn't 😂
May 26, 2024
Initial Reaction:
Wow….wow….my brain is like….I just need a minute to process this….like…whatttt???
Full Review:
Okay so I’m just gonna give a heads up this book was very complex in a good way so it’s gonna be quite difficult to write a review without spoilers but here we go!
This book is just so beautiful and I think it’s really because it’s so ugly. The decisions people had to make, the situations people had to live through, the words people had to swallow from others, it was all ugly. And out of that ugliness the author showed the beauty of God and how He can sustain and bring beauty to anything. You are never too far from God to be redeemed. No matter what ugly decisions you have had to make, no matter how unworthy people make you feel, you are never unredeemable by God. He loves you and He says you are BEAUTIFUL. Now that we’ve gotten that truth settled let’s move through the review.
Overview:
Ella’s been hit hard by life. Both her parents have passed away and she lives with her adopted sister in the poorest of conditions. She has little hope or beauty in her life other than her passion for ballet. However, due to her financial stance she knows she can never enter the ballet theatre she so admires from afar. That is until she bumps into the principal dancer who offers her a promise: one day she will dance opposite him on the stage. This one promise propels her into a new future that makes her question whether God can truly coincide with her passion for dance and whether he can use her small status to change the face of dance once and for all.
Characters:
Ella - I got to be honest, I didn’t love Ella too much but I enjoyed reading from her point of view. Sometimes I wanted to scream at her like just TELL HIMMMM and other times I was like you go girl! I loved her attitude and how she was so staunch on not settling for less. Gotta be honest tho when she said she couldn’t memorize dance combos I was like giiirrrllll what u doin in dance?? 😂
Jack - Ohhhhhh Jackieeeeeee 🤗. I really loved him I had a hard time liking him at first but eventually I warmed up to him. I love how much he pushed Ella and saw her past her simply being a performer.
Philippe - yikes I have mixed feelings about him. At first I was all Philippe but as time went on I just didn’t trust him…And why he always watching Ella….like brother 🫠…. I did kinda feel bad for him but he definitely wasn’t good for Ella since he kind of pushed her to perfection and was too deep in his sorrows.
Lily - yikes about that. I thought she was just a hard character mainly for Ella. I think when Ella finally realized she couldn’t protect her from herself or the world and when she did was when Ella was set free but yikes.
**there are many side characters so I’ll just keep the list to this
My reading journey:
OMG can i just say my inner dancer was like fangirling kicking and screaming in delight. Like every dance move that was written I had done on the floor before. I was like oohhh ooh I know that one. And I could just picture the combination. And all day my mind just repeated my ballet teachers dance combos after like pas de bourrée jeté jeté….i was so delighted. And when they paired Psalms with memorizing dance combos…oh they so got me. Like God x Dance = PERFECTION 😁 🩰 DAHHHHHH. Ok anyways *fans face to cool down* the actual book. It dealt with very heavy topics so the book felt heavy and there were many layers to the mystery. So it definitely took some thinking and reflecting but the messages throughout were so deep and heart wrenching. It was like at the end no one was perfect, all the characters had done evil things in the past, but the point was God saw through it, loved them regardless, and redeemed them. Wow just beautiful!
*I don’t think I’m gonna add any dislikes but one thing I didn’t prefer was going to a Lutheran church in the book. I’m personally not Lutheran so I felt it a little weird to say the type of church, and I don’t entirely agree with all their beliefs/practices…. being non denominational
So in the end it was a beautiful book with heavy topics that reminded me that God loves me no matter what I do, the mistakes I’ve made, or the “perfect” comparison standards the world influences us believe in.
Wow….wow….my brain is like….I just need a minute to process this….like…whatttt???
Full Review:
Okay so I’m just gonna give a heads up this book was very complex in a good way so it’s gonna be quite difficult to write a review without spoilers but here we go!
This book is just so beautiful and I think it’s really because it’s so ugly. The decisions people had to make, the situations people had to live through, the words people had to swallow from others, it was all ugly. And out of that ugliness the author showed the beauty of God and how He can sustain and bring beauty to anything. You are never too far from God to be redeemed. No matter what ugly decisions you have had to make, no matter how unworthy people make you feel, you are never unredeemable by God. He loves you and He says you are BEAUTIFUL. Now that we’ve gotten that truth settled let’s move through the review.
Overview:
Ella’s been hit hard by life. Both her parents have passed away and she lives with her adopted sister in the poorest of conditions. She has little hope or beauty in her life other than her passion for ballet. However, due to her financial stance she knows she can never enter the ballet theatre she so admires from afar. That is until she bumps into the principal dancer who offers her a promise: one day she will dance opposite him on the stage. This one promise propels her into a new future that makes her question whether God can truly coincide with her passion for dance and whether he can use her small status to change the face of dance once and for all.
Characters:
Ella - I got to be honest, I didn’t love Ella too much but I enjoyed reading from her point of view. Sometimes I wanted to scream at her like just TELL HIMMMM and other times I was like you go girl! I loved her attitude and how she was so staunch on not settling for less. Gotta be honest tho when she said she couldn’t memorize dance combos I was like giiirrrllll what u doin in dance?? 😂
Jack - Ohhhhhh Jackieeeeeee 🤗. I really loved him I had a hard time liking him at first but eventually I warmed up to him. I love how much he pushed Ella and saw her past her simply being a performer.
Philippe - yikes I have mixed feelings about him. At first I was all Philippe but as time went on I just didn’t trust him…And why he always watching Ella….like brother 🫠…. I did kinda feel bad for him but he definitely wasn’t good for Ella since he kind of pushed her to perfection and was too deep in his sorrows.
Lily - yikes about that. I thought she was just a hard character mainly for Ella. I think when Ella finally realized she couldn’t protect her from herself or the world and when she did was when Ella was set free but yikes.
**there are many side characters so I’ll just keep the list to this
My reading journey:
OMG can i just say my inner dancer was like fangirling kicking and screaming in delight. Like every dance move that was written I had done on the floor before. I was like oohhh ooh I know that one. And I could just picture the combination. And all day my mind just repeated my ballet teachers dance combos after like pas de bourrée jeté jeté….i was so delighted. And when they paired Psalms with memorizing dance combos…oh they so got me. Like God x Dance = PERFECTION 😁 🩰 DAHHHHHH. Ok anyways *fans face to cool down* the actual book. It dealt with very heavy topics so the book felt heavy and there were many layers to the mystery. So it definitely took some thinking and reflecting but the messages throughout were so deep and heart wrenching. It was like at the end no one was perfect, all the characters had done evil things in the past, but the point was God saw through it, loved them regardless, and redeemed them. Wow just beautiful!
*I don’t think I’m gonna add any dislikes but one thing I didn’t prefer was going to a Lutheran church in the book. I’m personally not Lutheran so I felt it a little weird to say the type of church, and I don’t entirely agree with all their beliefs/practices…. being non denominational
So in the end it was a beautiful book with heavy topics that reminded me that God loves me no matter what I do, the mistakes I’ve made, or the “perfect” comparison standards the world influences us believe in.
March 7, 2023
This is absolutely incredible 😭
August 19, 2023
2023 review:
Just as lovely and breathtaking as the first time I read this one. It is unmatched in its beautiful storyline and characters. A must read.
2021 review:
"I live every time I dance onstage."
YOU GUYS. This book is absolutely stunning. It is on another level and I am blown away at Joanna Davidson Politano's ability to write such beautiful stories that pull you in like no other.
After the first chapter alone, I knew in my bones that this would be a book I loved. And I desperately wanted to ignore my real life responsibilities so I could spend more time reading.
I absolutely loved that this book was about ballet and set in the theater. There is an ethereal beauty that ballet embodies, and this book infused that sense of wonder and magic into the pages, both when the characters were dancing, and when they were on adventures offstage.
This book was such a delight. From the rivalries and friendships, to the mystery and adventures, all in the midst of dance, I was so invested in this story. Ella's struggle drew me in, and watching her wrestle between the certainty that dance was what she's made to do and the uncertainty of how to pursue that dream had me eager to read more.
And with the twist at the end, I was nearly in tears, it had my heart bursting with happiness. I absolutely loved it. What a hero.
If you want to read a book with lyrical writing about vibrant characters who are full of life, with a dash of mystery and the romantic essence of dance, I hope you choose to read this book. JDP is a master storyteller, and her books are well worth your time.
“We can talk about me if you wish, but I’d much rather speak of the God for whom I dance.”
I received a gifted copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review. These are my honest and personal thoughts on the book.
Just as lovely and breathtaking as the first time I read this one. It is unmatched in its beautiful storyline and characters. A must read.
2021 review:
"I live every time I dance onstage."
YOU GUYS. This book is absolutely stunning. It is on another level and I am blown away at Joanna Davidson Politano's ability to write such beautiful stories that pull you in like no other.
After the first chapter alone, I knew in my bones that this would be a book I loved. And I desperately wanted to ignore my real life responsibilities so I could spend more time reading.
I absolutely loved that this book was about ballet and set in the theater. There is an ethereal beauty that ballet embodies, and this book infused that sense of wonder and magic into the pages, both when the characters were dancing, and when they were on adventures offstage.
This book was such a delight. From the rivalries and friendships, to the mystery and adventures, all in the midst of dance, I was so invested in this story. Ella's struggle drew me in, and watching her wrestle between the certainty that dance was what she's made to do and the uncertainty of how to pursue that dream had me eager to read more.
And with the twist at the end, I was nearly in tears, it had my heart bursting with happiness. I absolutely loved it. What a hero.
If you want to read a book with lyrical writing about vibrant characters who are full of life, with a dash of mystery and the romantic essence of dance, I hope you choose to read this book. JDP is a master storyteller, and her books are well worth your time.
“We can talk about me if you wish, but I’d much rather speak of the God for whom I dance.”
I received a gifted copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review. These are my honest and personal thoughts on the book.
January 21, 2023
Quite, QUITE Impressive.
January 7, 2025
Oh gosh, I really wish I would have written the review right after I read the book.
I do remember this one being really atmospheric, with a fun mystery, and maybe a sort of (maybe) slight bit of gaslighting.
A little more Christian-focused than I was hoping for, and one plot point that came out of the blue.
But a solid book that, at a 4-star, is recommended.
I do remember this one being really atmospheric, with a fun mystery, and maybe a sort of (maybe) slight bit of gaslighting.
A little more Christian-focused than I was hoping for, and one plot point that came out of the blue.
But a solid book that, at a 4-star, is recommended.
October 9, 2021
FTC Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this book. These are my honest thoughts.
This was my most-anticipated book of 2021. I’m not sure yet what I think about it.
In one way, I feel very misled by a couple of things. The back blurb and meet-cute both indicated a certain romance was going to take place, but the story took a weird turn on that front. While I grew to enjoy certain aspects of the romantic thread and rather adored the finale, it wasn’t anything like what I’d been led to believe it would be.
In another way, this story grew on me and wrapped me in a vintage era that felt very much like home. The atmosphere in this book helped the story slowly sift past my defenses at the aforementioned deception. The words chosen created such vivid imagery that I found myself immersed in a different time and place and wanted to stay in the fantastical ballet-and-circus world the author created.
I struggled to understand why Mr. Dorian had such a sullied reputation. While he was known as a flirtatious playboy who could have any of the female dancers he wanted, the character I got to know on the page wasn’t anything close to that sort. Why did he have such a terrible reputation? That thread did not make any sense to me at all, because what I saw was a kind, generous, compassionate gentleman. His personality was in direct contrast with his reputation, and the two never melded for me. It was very clear throughout that he cared greatly about wanting to keep the leading lady’s reputation intact, further instilling his gentlemanly qualities.
The circus bits were fascinating. It wasn’t really full-blown circus stuff, but that made it even more special. It was like stepping into the behind-the-scenes, day-to-day aspects of the circus, and I loved that. To glimpse what it might have been like to be an intrinsic part of the circus was mesmerizing and utterly fantastic. I would love to see a circus story or two by this author’s hand. Pretty please, Mrs. Politano???
The red shoes got lost for half the book. They were stolen pretty early on, but after a brief worry and rummage, the leading lady simply went on about her everyday life. So why were those shoes so important to her again? She apparently forgot they were one of her last ties to her dead mother. I wanted to feel urgency in discovering who had stolen them and why. I wanted there to be a heart-pounding search and investigation into the matter and a yearning to have them returned. Instead, the leading lady randomly stumbled onto the shoes at one point, which was very anticlimactic and not something she’d actively pursued. She’d quite forgotten about that memento of her mom’s that she’d cherished in the opening scenes.
The cover is exquisite and sets a beautiful tone for this story. There’s something romantic and atmospheric and utterly amazing about the color scheme and saturation, the wistful, reminiscent pose of the ballerina, and the lyrical typeface of the title that really called to me when I originally saw it. Those things still drew me in every time I picked up this book to read a little more in the time I found between work obligations and family time.
Because of the abovementioned issues that bothered or confused me, it took me about three weeks to read a book that I thought I’d guzzle in three days. However, now that I know the ins and outs of the story and which aspects I didn’t understand on my first read, I have a feeling this story will continue to grow on me through another two or three reads. It’s one I really want to love, so I’ll be giving it another chance. The final several chapters did bump my rating up from three to four stars, because some things came to satisfactory ends and the climax of the ballet swept me away so that I kept flipping pages as quickly as I could.
The big secret that I didn’t even realize until late that Ella was keeping close didn’t make sense to me. It seemed to come out of nowhere. Even when it was “revealed,” she didn’t come out and say what the secret was, so I’m still not sure I fully understand what had happened and if it had indeed happened to Ella or not. Maybe I’ll understand that part better next time.
This book definitely had some mesmerizing qualities. It was lyrical and vintage and exquisite at times. I will likely read it again in coming years, and I believe a lot of readers will adore it.
Content: pub, drunkenness, gambling on a woman’s virtue, swearing by “heaven’s name” and “all that is holy,” tobacco, prostitutes mentioned, statues of Greek mythology, alcohol
This was my most-anticipated book of 2021. I’m not sure yet what I think about it.
In one way, I feel very misled by a couple of things. The back blurb and meet-cute both indicated a certain romance was going to take place, but the story took a weird turn on that front. While I grew to enjoy certain aspects of the romantic thread and rather adored the finale, it wasn’t anything like what I’d been led to believe it would be.
In another way, this story grew on me and wrapped me in a vintage era that felt very much like home. The atmosphere in this book helped the story slowly sift past my defenses at the aforementioned deception. The words chosen created such vivid imagery that I found myself immersed in a different time and place and wanted to stay in the fantastical ballet-and-circus world the author created.
I struggled to understand why Mr. Dorian had such a sullied reputation. While he was known as a flirtatious playboy who could have any of the female dancers he wanted, the character I got to know on the page wasn’t anything close to that sort. Why did he have such a terrible reputation? That thread did not make any sense to me at all, because what I saw was a kind, generous, compassionate gentleman. His personality was in direct contrast with his reputation, and the two never melded for me. It was very clear throughout that he cared greatly about wanting to keep the leading lady’s reputation intact, further instilling his gentlemanly qualities.
The circus bits were fascinating. It wasn’t really full-blown circus stuff, but that made it even more special. It was like stepping into the behind-the-scenes, day-to-day aspects of the circus, and I loved that. To glimpse what it might have been like to be an intrinsic part of the circus was mesmerizing and utterly fantastic. I would love to see a circus story or two by this author’s hand. Pretty please, Mrs. Politano???
The red shoes got lost for half the book. They were stolen pretty early on, but after a brief worry and rummage, the leading lady simply went on about her everyday life. So why were those shoes so important to her again? She apparently forgot they were one of her last ties to her dead mother. I wanted to feel urgency in discovering who had stolen them and why. I wanted there to be a heart-pounding search and investigation into the matter and a yearning to have them returned. Instead, the leading lady randomly stumbled onto the shoes at one point, which was very anticlimactic and not something she’d actively pursued. She’d quite forgotten about that memento of her mom’s that she’d cherished in the opening scenes.
The cover is exquisite and sets a beautiful tone for this story. There’s something romantic and atmospheric and utterly amazing about the color scheme and saturation, the wistful, reminiscent pose of the ballerina, and the lyrical typeface of the title that really called to me when I originally saw it. Those things still drew me in every time I picked up this book to read a little more in the time I found between work obligations and family time.
Because of the abovementioned issues that bothered or confused me, it took me about three weeks to read a book that I thought I’d guzzle in three days. However, now that I know the ins and outs of the story and which aspects I didn’t understand on my first read, I have a feeling this story will continue to grow on me through another two or three reads. It’s one I really want to love, so I’ll be giving it another chance. The final several chapters did bump my rating up from three to four stars, because some things came to satisfactory ends and the climax of the ballet swept me away so that I kept flipping pages as quickly as I could.
The big secret that I didn’t even realize until late that Ella was keeping close didn’t make sense to me. It seemed to come out of nowhere. Even when it was “revealed,” she didn’t come out and say what the secret was, so I’m still not sure I fully understand what had happened and if it had indeed happened to Ella or not. Maybe I’ll understand that part better next time.
This book definitely had some mesmerizing qualities. It was lyrical and vintage and exquisite at times. I will likely read it again in coming years, and I believe a lot of readers will adore it.
Content: pub, drunkenness, gambling on a woman’s virtue, swearing by “heaven’s name” and “all that is holy,” tobacco, prostitutes mentioned, statues of Greek mythology, alcohol
February 26, 2022
“It is the great paradox of art, ma petite. Ballet is all delicacy and grace, yet it brings out the barbaric side of every woman who dances it.”
Wow. Wow! I'm totally blown away. What a unique and compelling story! If you enjoy Christian fiction in any way, I highly recommend picking this one up. The quality of writing is superb. The mystery is deeply intriguing. The romance - ah, a chef's kiss! And most importantly, the love story between God and his children is just absolutely beautiful.
I went into this one completely blind, relying on a recommendation from a friend. I think you should experience it that way too 😉 I don't want to give anything away! So I'll skip the plot and speak in bookstagram reviewer terms and tell you the nitty gritty: the writing has that perfect hint of darkness. It's atmospheric, but still moves at a perfect pace. Victorian era London. The theme of faith is a main focal point and it is done SO WELL. This is clean romance, and that is done perfectly too! I think many, *many* readers of Christian fiction will find this one an absolute favorite - I know I do! I will read everything this author writes! 👏 I would buy this book for a friend; I will buy it for myself! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️+❤
"It never had made sense, God’s personal pursuit of me. The longer the pain wore on, and my dim future stretched before me, the less I believed it had ever truly happened. And that thought made life seem bleak."
"There. That was my story. No romance or tragedy, only ballet, colored with the presence of God."
Wow. Wow! I'm totally blown away. What a unique and compelling story! If you enjoy Christian fiction in any way, I highly recommend picking this one up. The quality of writing is superb. The mystery is deeply intriguing. The romance - ah, a chef's kiss! And most importantly, the love story between God and his children is just absolutely beautiful.
I went into this one completely blind, relying on a recommendation from a friend. I think you should experience it that way too 😉 I don't want to give anything away! So I'll skip the plot and speak in bookstagram reviewer terms and tell you the nitty gritty: the writing has that perfect hint of darkness. It's atmospheric, but still moves at a perfect pace. Victorian era London. The theme of faith is a main focal point and it is done SO WELL. This is clean romance, and that is done perfectly too! I think many, *many* readers of Christian fiction will find this one an absolute favorite - I know I do! I will read everything this author writes! 👏 I would buy this book for a friend; I will buy it for myself! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️+❤
"It never had made sense, God’s personal pursuit of me. The longer the pain wore on, and my dim future stretched before me, the less I believed it had ever truly happened. And that thought made life seem bleak."
"There. That was my story. No romance or tragedy, only ballet, colored with the presence of God."
July 23, 2021
This is an enthralling novel I could not put down. This master wordsmith pens and engaging theatrical story, getting readers caught up in the misfortune that befell Ella Blythe. Her mother trained her, passed down her love of ballet and theater. Ella would do her best to continue her mothers’ legacy. She secretly hopes to find answers to her mothers’ past and desires to dance with principal dancer Phillippe. It’s a dream, but one could only hope it to come true. Ella does her best to track down answers at the Ghost of Craven Street Theater. She needed to know what really happened the night of the fire that changed everything.
This author does a brilliant job of sweeping readers into the magic of theater and the fierce competition between dancers to get coveted roles. Ella Blythe auditions to be part of the core, she didn’t want to be in the spotlight. But the judges see something in her, she can’t hide. They wonder where this girl came from. What training did she have? Where did she learn to dance so unconventionally?
I loved the theatrical setting and how the author made readers feel all the nervousness of the performers and then shows how Ella learned to set herself free (in body and mind) to dance the part she was made to play. It all comes together for her and the reader. Loved this haunting, hopeful novel that is a surprising mystery, memorable read, and one that would work well for your next book club pick and/or read for pure fun.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I have received a complimentary copy of this book by the publisher through NetGalley. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins!
The Book Club Network blog www.bookfun.org
This author does a brilliant job of sweeping readers into the magic of theater and the fierce competition between dancers to get coveted roles. Ella Blythe auditions to be part of the core, she didn’t want to be in the spotlight. But the judges see something in her, she can’t hide. They wonder where this girl came from. What training did she have? Where did she learn to dance so unconventionally?
I loved the theatrical setting and how the author made readers feel all the nervousness of the performers and then shows how Ella learned to set herself free (in body and mind) to dance the part she was made to play. It all comes together for her and the reader. Loved this haunting, hopeful novel that is a surprising mystery, memorable read, and one that would work well for your next book club pick and/or read for pure fun.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I have received a complimentary copy of this book by the publisher through NetGalley. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins!
The Book Club Network blog www.bookfun.org
October 13, 2023
4.5 ✨
To audiences held captive by the breathtaking performances, ballet is utterly enchanting. To Ella Blythe, the theatre is a place of haunting secrets and debilitating perfectionism.
Joanna Davidson Politano captivated me with this incredibly absorbing and atmospheric tale. One look at the cover and you have the very essence of what this story is telling. I have only read one of her previous works, The Love Note, but this one has raised the bar.
Misconceptions are everywhere, and as the reader, you have to pay attention to the story-telling to really separate the truth from the fiction. I enjoyed this form of story-telling. We aren't handed answers on a silver platter; rather we have to connect the dots in our heads. It might take a few rereads before I figure it all out, but that just means I get to spend more time with Ella and Jack.
Lily and Jack are perfect foils for Ella and Phillipe. Jack in his sincerity, however grandiose it may be; Lily in her naive selfishness and vivacity. I liked how these characters played off each other, showcasing the other's faults and strengths.
And Jack... what a perfect leading man. Without spoiling anything, I must say I've never enjoyed a male character more than this one. His character is hard to sum up, because he is so outrageous yet sincere.
"I glanced at Jack, wrestler of tigers and son of a silk heiress, who threw me the most beguiling grin I'd ever seen, and suddenly I realized every story he'd ever told me was true."
The love story was beautiful, the mystery engaging, and the pull to read the ending before I got there was very strong! But I didn't! And you shouldn't either. This story is one best told in layers.
For my final thoughts, what can I say except this lyrical narrative will have you in tears by the end and feeling inspired to reach greater heights with your own talents.
To audiences held captive by the breathtaking performances, ballet is utterly enchanting. To Ella Blythe, the theatre is a place of haunting secrets and debilitating perfectionism.
Joanna Davidson Politano captivated me with this incredibly absorbing and atmospheric tale. One look at the cover and you have the very essence of what this story is telling. I have only read one of her previous works, The Love Note, but this one has raised the bar.
Misconceptions are everywhere, and as the reader, you have to pay attention to the story-telling to really separate the truth from the fiction. I enjoyed this form of story-telling. We aren't handed answers on a silver platter; rather we have to connect the dots in our heads. It might take a few rereads before I figure it all out, but that just means I get to spend more time with Ella and Jack.
Lily and Jack are perfect foils for Ella and Phillipe. Jack in his sincerity, however grandiose it may be; Lily in her naive selfishness and vivacity. I liked how these characters played off each other, showcasing the other's faults and strengths.
And Jack... what a perfect leading man. Without spoiling anything, I must say I've never enjoyed a male character more than this one. His character is hard to sum up, because he is so outrageous yet sincere.
"I glanced at Jack, wrestler of tigers and son of a silk heiress, who threw me the most beguiling grin I'd ever seen, and suddenly I realized every story he'd ever told me was true."
The love story was beautiful, the mystery engaging, and the pull to read the ending before I got there was very strong! But I didn't! And you shouldn't either. This story is one best told in layers.
For my final thoughts, what can I say except this lyrical narrative will have you in tears by the end and feeling inspired to reach greater heights with your own talents.
October 2, 2021
.Ella goes off to become a ballerina when her Mother, a famous ballerina herself that was burnt in a fire at the theater. There she wants to know the mystery behind her accident and also meet her father. She soon befriended Jack a worker at the theater. Together they are out to solve the mystery. Will they stop only at the mystery or will they fall in love themselves. First of all I love books that sound like poetry and this one did. The relationship with Jack and Ella is perfect. Jack funny and not series blends with Ella serious nature, At first she doesn't like him because of the rumors of him but they soon form a friendship. I was routing for Jack on his entrance. Both characters are so well written by the middle of the book they seem like old friends. Ella finds some sad truths in this book, but her faith doesn't only help her dancing but her relationships, she only needed to trust. I heard a lot of recommendations on this book and I can tell all of you it is so worth the read. It will make you n feel like dancing yourself so be ready!!
August 27, 2021
I know basically nothing about ballet and yet after reading A Midnight Dance I am in awe. The author did a fantastic job of enlightening me without overwhelming me. The book was beautiful, lyrical and mysterious. The ending blew my mind and and was one of the most romantic and surprising endings I have ever read. I enjoyed this book very much.
*I was given a copy of this book by the publisher and this is my honest opinion
*I was given a copy of this book by the publisher and this is my honest opinion
December 17, 2021
This was a wonderful story! I loved the mystery and romance and learned so much about ballet and theater in that era. The romance was well written and the spiritual themes were meaningful. Well written and highly recommended!
October 24, 2021
4.5 stars. Rtc
March 7, 2022
For some reason, the second-half of the book didn't intrigue me as much as the first, but overall a great read. Ballet, faith, mystery, relationships, and some romance.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 428 reviews