Carved in Stone

The Blackstone Legacy #1

by Elizabeth Camden

After years of tragedy, Gwen Kellerman now lives a quiet life as a botanist at an idyllic New York college. She largely ignores her status as heiress to the infamous Blackstone dynasty and hopes to keep her family's heartbreak and scandal behind her.

Patrick O'Neill survived a hardscrabble youth to become a lawyer for the downtrodden Irish immigrants in his community. He's proud of his work, even though he struggles to afford his ramshackle law office. All that changes when he accepts a case that is sure to emphasize the Blackstones' legacy of greed and corruption by resurrecting a thirty-year-old mystery.

Little does Patrick suspect that the Blackstones will launch their most sympathetic family member to derail him. Gwen is tasked with getting Patrick to drop the case, but the old mystery takes a shocking twist neither of them saw coming. Now, as they navigate a burgeoning attraction and growing danger, Patrick and Gwen will be forced to decide if the risk to the life they've always held dear is worth the reward.

Genres: Historical Fiction, Romance, Christian Fiction, Fiction, Historical, Christian, Historical Romance

342 pages, Paperback

First published August 1, 2021

Reviews

[Lindsey (Books for Christian Girls) · Rating 2 out of 5]

About this book:

“After years of tragedy, Gwen Kellerman now lives a quiet life as a botanist at an idyllic New York college. She largely ignores her status as heiress to the infamous Blackstone dynasty and hopes to keep her family's heartbreak and scandal behind her.
Patrick O'Neill survived a hardscrabble youth to become a lawyer for the downtrodden Irish immigrants in his community. He's proud of his work, even though he struggles to afford his ramshackle law office. All that changes when he accepts a case that is sure to emphasize the Blackstones' legacy of greed and corruption by resurrecting a thirty-year-old mystery.
Little does Patrick suspect that the Blackstones will launch their most sympathetic family member to derail him. Gwen is tasked with getting Patrick to drop the case, but the old mystery takes a shocking twist neither of them saw coming. Now, as they navigate a burgeoning attraction and growing danger, Patrick and Gwen will be forced to decide if the risk to the life they've always held dear is worth the reward.”


Series: Book #1 in “The Blackstone Legacy” series.


Spiritual Content- A couple Scriptures are mentioned & discussed (in a courtroom); Prayers, Saying the rosary, & Hail Marys; Talks about God & faiths; ‘H’s are not capitalized when referring to God; Patrick was in seminary to become a priest but stopped before talking his vow (he thought that best way to show his devotion to God was to aim for the highest rank which meant priesthood, but really wanted a wife and family); Patrick gives the impression of being a devote Catholic (though he does call himself a Christian one time); Patrick goes to the nearest Catholic church to give a confession & their discussion is shown; Patrick crosses himself (once); Many mentions of priests, being a priest, churches, church going, rosaries, & confessions; Mentions of God; Mentions of prayers, praying, & a blessing over food; Mentions of infants’ baptisms; Mentions of saints, nuns, monks, & monasteries; Mentions of sins & sinners; A few mentions of those & places in the Bible; A few mentions of a famous Bible (the Book of Kells); A few mentions of blessings; A few mentions of miracles; A mention of the cross; A mention of a godsend;
*Note: Mentions of a man being called the spawn of the devil and tales about terrifying demons that suck blood and marrow from humans; A mention of a man being the devil and all Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse in one person; A mention of someone’s past demons; A mention of a man with a devilish gleam in his eyes; A mention of a man who thinks he will go to hell because of a crime he committed; A mention of a mother that “suffered the agonies of the damned” when she delivered a large baby; A mention of a godforsaken city; A mention of an untrue story someone told about smuggling a piece of the true cross and guards chasing him; A mention of Zeus; A mention of children looking at Gwen like a goddess.


Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘blasted’, a ‘bull hockey’, a form of ‘dumb’, a ‘give a fig’, an ‘idiot’, five forms of ‘stupid’, and five ‘shut up’s; Mentions of curses (Patrick also lets a string of profanities out as well, said, not written); Some eye rolling & sarcasm; Killing a man in self-defense & the body (barely-above-not-detailed); Pain, Injuries, Broken bones, Fighting, Seeing someone in extreme pain, seeing someone stabbed, being shot at, & blood/bleeding (up to semi-detailed); Social drinking (both Patrick & Gwen, but mainly him, around five times); Many mentions of a kidnapping, kidnapper, & death of a child (Gwen’s older brother); Many mentions of attacks/assaults, blood/bleeding, injuries, fighting, being shot, & being shot at (up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of crimes, criminals, pickpockets, arrests & jailtime; Many mentions of drinking, social drinking, alcohol, pubs, alcoholics, & drunks; Mentions of murder & someone ordering a murder; Mentions of assassination attempts on Gwen’s family, the assassins, bombs, deaths, & injuries (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a child/teenager being beat up (by his father, but also the cops when he did a crime, barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of tetanus, giving an injection in the spinal column, & major pain (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of gangs & fighting for money; Mentions of thieves, stealing, & heist/robberies; Mentions of cigarettes, cigars, smoking, & tobacco; Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of gossip & rumors; Mentions of hatred; Mentions of jealousy; Mentions of poker, gambling, & bets; Mentions of hunting & hunters; A few mentions of wars; A few mentions of setting fires & breaking windows, causing a baby to be hurt; A few mentions of child labor; A few mentions of divorces; A few mentions of bullies & bullying; A few mentions of prejudice against the Irish; A couple mentions of a possible drowning; A couple mentions of deaths from a vaccine’s trials; A couple mentions of sending someone to the gallows; A couple mentions of blackmail; A couple mentions of urinals (Gwen’s perspective) & Liam’s comment about “letting one rip” in the bathroom; A mention of a child being shown autopsy photos of people killed in factory accidents; A mention of shooting noisy children (that woke someone from their sleep, doesn’t happen); A mention of throwing up; A mention of nightmares; A mention of telling someone to put something “where the sun doesn’t shine”;
*Note: A couple mentions of authors (Mark Twain and Charles Dickens); A mention of Marxist sentiments.


Sexual Content- Two almost kisses, not-detailed kisses, two barely-above-not-detailed kisses, and four semi-detailed kisses; Touches, Embraces, & Nearness (barely-above-not-detailed); Blushes & Winks; Noticing & Smelling (barely-above-not-detailed); Gwen secretly teases Patrick by taking her foot and running it along his ankle and higher while with other people (barely-above-not-detailed); Seeing a man greet with wife with a hearty kiss & a tacky grope her (which causes her to have to fix her blouse, no true details); Mentions of Patrick having a secret tryst with a woman during his priesthood training that made him realize that he wants a wife and family; Mentions of temptation (& Patrick saying that temptation was nothing new to him as girls tempted him since he “developed a healthy appreciation for anything a skirts when he was thirteen years old”); Mentions of Gwen’s (fifteen-years her senior) husband’s affair, his mistress, and their child born out-of-wedlock (and how Gwen tried to make herself look and act more like the mistress to get his attention); Mentions of conceiving a child (including that Gwen’s greatest disappointment of her marriage was that she didn’t conceive a child, but this was due to her husband not having an interest in her, only his mistress; Also a mention of Gwen wondering how long it would take to conceive a child); Mentions of kisses & kissing; A few mentions of wondering if a married woman has a man in her apartment (Patrick thinks that her husband has a roving eyes and wonders if the wife is balancing the scales); A few mentions of a girl (tailor’s daughter) looking at Patrick with “hot eyes and a hungry expression” and measuring him with her hands traveling in a dangerous direction; A few mentions of a rich woman’s “dolly boy” and her paying for everything for him; A few mentions of catcalls; A few mentions of flirting; A few mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of other affairs; A couple mentions of prostitutes; A couple mentions of dreaming about someone they like (and being stopped by another that they don’t want to hear about their seedy dreams); A couple mentions of a rumor that a man ordered his fiancé to see a specialist to ensure she was able to bear children; A mention of that if a wife bears a daughter, she’ll be pregnant again by next full moon (the husband wants a son); A mention of a man pulling his wife onto his lap; A mention of Patrick wanting to kiss and hold his future wife until dawn; A mention of a married woman throwing herself at a rich man; Love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: When Patrick and Gwen first meet, he thinks “Mrs. Kellerman was a stunning woman, tall and willowy and fit. He wasn’t free to pursue a married woman, but admiring her seemed fair game.” (when he finds out she’s a widow, he was even more intrigued and that he shouldn’t feel guilty for noticing that she was a looker as any man with a pulse would notice that. This causes a misunderstanding from his mother thinking he’s running around with a married woman); Mentions of two babies that were stillborn (blue) and the mother grieving; A few comments from Liam on Gwen’s loose-fitting dresses (including that someone would say she looks “a wee bit knocked up”); A mention of a child streaking buck naked through a group of people; A mention of someone butting into a conversation.

-Gwendolyn “Gwen” Blackstone Kellerman, age 29
-Patrick O’Neill, age 34
P.O.V. switches between them
Set in 1900
342 pages

~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*

Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star
Early High School Teens- One Star
Older High School Teens- Two Stars
My personal Rating- Two Stars

What an interesting book and plot! I’ve read most of Elizabeth Camden’s novels and the only thing I can ever expect from them is that there will be lots of historical details that will be more than likely fascinating.

“Carved in Stone” was no exception in this. I don’t know why I enjoy reading (or watching Korean dramas) with the plot point of family politics or family business politics, but, oh, I so do enjoy those. Add in Patrick’s lawyer profession and an assumed dead family member, I was very interested in seeing how this plot would come together by the end.

I actually have lots of thoughts on this book, but let’s see if I can make it coherent.

First all, the characters: Gwen. She was cunning but not in a bad or mean way, but you could tell she’s been raised in her family’s dynamics. She was (typically, unless you pushed too much) kind in her speech but firm as well. I really liked her and that ending made her even better to me as it wasn’t the complete normal layout for a Historical Romance.

Patrick. Hmm, I liked him at first, but as he is around Gwen’s family more, I wasn’t liking how he was acting or treating others. There was the typical points of her being from a rich family and him being poor, of course, but it wasn’t in an over-the-top way that I ever though “I’ve seen this story before.” (And that might be because I truly adore this author’s writing style.) Out of the whole book, I think I liked him the most at the beginning (mainly the courtroom scene because I wanted to cheer for him and yet also smack him), but he still wasn’t anywhere near my top favorite male leads. He was sincere to his faith, which I appreciate. I’m not sure if I’ve seen a historical book show a character with a strong Catholic faith as much as this book did.

Now, the ratings. Going into these final thoughts, I thought I would personally give it a three star. However, there are certain things that are lingering with me that I wasn’t a fan of seeing in this book. To some they may be small things that can be overlooked, but they’re giving me hesitation of giving it a high rating.

Some of those things: Patrick’s attitude towards Gwen’s family in the middle and end (he was almost determined for her to realize that her family isn’t as wonderful as she thinks, when in reality I don’t see the harm in her believing the best in people—as long as it’s not a blind trust of someone. He was lackluster in the middle section and his pride really got in the way of their relationship. Also want to note that I don’t agree with a few of his thoughts about their relationship and a comment her made about maybe the hand of God brought him and Gwen together. There’s no “maybe” about it, sonny.), a few crass comments from Liam about Gwen’s choice of loose fitting dresses (including a mention that someone else would say she looked a bit knocked up), some words that sounding proper for that time period (which could just be me thinking that, it’s possible that were used in the time-period but it pulled me from the story each time they were used), quite a bit of social drinking, and personally the mentions of vaccines and medicine from that time period wasn’t something I enjoyed seeing in a book I picked up for enjoyment when I see about vaccines quite often in my normal life on social media.

Again, some of these things may not bother some readers and overall, I was absolutely enthralled in the plot-lines of this story (family politics, lawyer/courtroom events, and a missing family member that’s presumed dead? I would be instantly intrigued with anything that has just two of those topics) but little things added up that pulled away from my enjoyment of the story, which is reflected in my personal rating. The other ratings for different age groups are based on the content and comments, as always. I will probably try out the rest of the trilogy if the books interest me.



Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...



*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.

[Kav · Rating 5 out of 5]

Prepare to settle in and be dazzled by the depth and breadth of this stunning historical novel. Camden always delivers exquisite research and creates the most amazing maverick heroines and she doesn't disappoint in this page-turning marvel.

Loved Gwen right from the start. She's a survivor. A woman of depth who hasn't allowed the hardships she's endured to turn into bitterness. She's brimming with life and intelligence and is so much more than a 'Blackstone heiress.' And she can hold her own with her imposing relatives.

Patrick appreciates all those qualities and revels in the alluring woman who is, essentially, his opposition. They are on different sides of a legal issue and from vastly different social classes for starters, and yet, there is something so intensely right about Patrick and Gwen as a couple. Their romance is fraught with complications and turmoil but it's pure magic too. Deep friendship and toe-curls -- my kind of romance!

And then there's the mystery -- a twisty-turny, conniving bit of intrigue and danger that turns an already complicated plot into a stunner of a rabid read.

Perhaps, best of all, is the intrinsic way the author has woven an inspirational thread throughout the entire story. Patrick in particular humbled me with the way he lives out his deeply rooted faith.

I was both excited and sad to reach the end of Carved in Stone (wonderful title tie-in, by the way.) Excited because we all got closure and a happily every after but sad because I had to say goodbye. I do so hate to be cut off from the characters I've grown to love. But, there's good news too -- definitely a reason to happy dance -- because this is the first book in Camden's Blackstone Legacy series which means I'll get to travel back to 1900 New York City again sometime in my reading future. Yay!

[Amanda Hupe · Rating 5 out of 5]

“You can ignore those not born into wealth and leisure, or you can open your heart to people who work with their hands and minds to make the world a better place…

CARVED IN STONE
I absolutely love when Elizabeth Camden comes out with a new series. Empire State and Hope and Glory are some of my favorites! So I was eager to dive into Carved in Stone which is the first book in The Blackstone Legacy series. In this series, she is inspired by JP Morgan and the history and rising power of banks and capitalism. Gwen Kellerman loves her home that is nestled in the Blackstone college and hosts all kinds of professors and pioneers of education and science. Her husband died years before but it wasn’t a happy marriage. Her only care now is making sure Blackstone receives the funding to keep making advancements in medical research. However, she is the heiress of the Blackstone family who has the money and power and is often riddled in scandal. Patrick O’Neill is a lawyer who has worked hard for everything and has such a giving heart. His next case, although, requires him to help a man who is writing a book which contains information about the Blackstones. That information is linked to the missing Blackstone boy, who was also Gwen’s brother. Two worlds collide with love, classism, and mystery.

Elizabeth Camden never disappoints! I always find myself completely immersed in her stories-which always contain imperfect characters trying to find their way into the world. But there is always a woman ahead of her time. Gwen is that woman in this story. While it was hard to like her at first because of her naivety and privilege, she grows on you, especially when she is exposed to the realities of the world around her. One of the truly difficult things she must endure is realizing her family isn’t the ideal family she thought they were. Patrick O’Neill is the quintessential Irishman who came to the United States with his mother for a better life. He knows how hard life can be, especially when those around you won’t give you a chance. I love his patience with Gwen as she comes to understand her privilege.

Not only are the characters wonderful with amazing chemistry but there is a mystery and innovation intertwined that gives this story so much depth. Gwen realizes how important it is to find out what happened to her brother, while Patrick sees the benefits of scientific breakthroughs in regards to vaccinations.

As always, the historical details are phenomenal and I am already counting down for book two! I rate this book 5 out of 5 stars!

[Grandma Susan · Rating 5 out of 5]

Gwen is an heiress, yet she lives a simple life.I really enjoyed this character and how humble she was. The plot was intriguing. Patrick has had a difficult time in life and now an attorney works hard for the Irish immigrants. They are two kindred souls. I look forward to the next in the series. Outstanding narration. Highly recommend. Enjoy.

[Deanne Patterson · Rating 5 out of 5]

I have read ALL of Elizabeth Camden's books. I love the immaculate research the author puts into all of them and what I can learn from them.
Carved In Stone is the first book in The Blackstone Legacy series.
It is a very intriguing book with well detailed characters whose personality's we learn a lot from.
The Gilded Age was a fascinating time, a time such as we will never see a return to but it was also a time of corruption.
This was a real page turner for me. Really looking forward to what the author puts out next!

Pub Date 31 Aug 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.

[Lori · Rating 2 out of 5]

I'm not happy with this book. It was a 'good enough' read, but not much depth to it. Something that was a major disappointment to me was the use of rosary beads in the story - the characters prayed the rosary, bead by bead. The author went on to write the words of the 'hail mary' prayer. This really bothered me and the story was written in a way that leads the readers to believe the 'faith' the characters had was is in the rosary beads. I strongly disliked this element and almost didn't finish the book because of it. If this type of false doctrine is pushed in other books, I will not read Elizabeth Camden anymore.

[Staci · Rating 4 out of 5]

1900 New York City

Engaging historical fiction primarily about class differences.

[Rachel McMillan · Rating 4 out of 5]

There just isn't anyone better than Elizabeth Camden at introducing fabulous family dynamics and pitting intelligent young women against absolutely intriguing and little known tenets of historical periods. Camden's depth of research and characterization gives me chills. Absolutely CANNOT wait for next year's release!!

[Kremena Koleva · Rating 4 out of 5]

Избрах Carved in Stone на Elizabeth Camden заради исторически реалните събития, заради имената на известни личности и заради увличащия разказвачески стил на писане. Така звучат, всъщност, всички книги от поредицата на Camden. И във вихъра на сюжета аз се потопих в толкова много теми за размисъл, научих интересни подробности от света на големите финанси и на фамилиите, които света познава като корпорации с огромно влияние на икономическата сцена. Срещайки се с Патрик О' Нийл , аз " видях" образа на смирен ирландец, завършил семинария, с талант в правото и със стрaстта на човек, искащ да срещне жената на живота си и да помага на бедните граждани на Ню Йорк да имат достъп до адвокат. Гуен Блекстоун е жена с голямо богатство на свое име, но с желание да живее в уютната си къща в кампуса на Университета, създаден от фамилията й. Общуването й със студенти и преподаватели, заедно с грижата й за ботаническата градина в задния й двор, й дават цялото щастие на света след смъртта на баща й и на съпруга й. И сред срещата на тези коренно различни социални среди, в книгата се развиват конфликти, мистерии и отношения , за да предизвикат гордостта, чувствителността и силата на чувствата. Любовта, връзките със семейството и собствените желания и принципи могат да създадат трудна плетеница от ситуации. Но само, когато всичко е стабилно и носи целия смисълът за живота ни, кълбото може да бъде разплетено. Страхотна Elizabeth Camden отново!

* „Понякога най-голямата сила, която човек може да притежава, е да не позволява на гордостта си да пречи на пътя му да се движи в правилната посока.“

[Paula Shreckhise · Rating 5 out of 5]

Ms. Camden once again takes us to the Gilded Age and a lesson in clashes between the classes where the characters learn just what traditions are carved in stone and what changes are in store.
Gwen comes from a wealthy family and hopes to make her mark in Botany at Blackstone College.
Patrick wanted to become a priest but turned to law, having been trained by the Church in both vocations.
Patrick and Gwen meet when they are on opposite sides of a dispute between her prominent family and a client Patrick is representing. They find they both have similar life aspirations: to help people in need. But differences loom to keep them apart.
Ms. Camden always fills her books with interesting characters. Liam is a great example of how a life can turn around. He is very rough around the edges but has a quality that makes him a leader.
Filled with opulence that was indicative of the times, we also see the contrast in the slums if the Five Points. But it is the changed lives and priorities that make this book special.
Well researched with colorful characters and a lesson in compromise between the classes, this book will interest readers of Historical Christian Fiction.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bethany House on behalf of the author. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own. *

[Pegg · Rating 4 out of 5]

I loved Elizabeth Camden's early novels, but then I read a few that didn't interest me much. This book was a choice I picked from a reading challenge on Goodreads. I'm so glad I did! It's a well-written story about a woman from a rich New York family in 1900 and an Irish immigrant lawyer who falls in love with her. If you know your history at all, you'll know that the Irish were treated very poorly in New York around 1900. The chasm between her world and his was vast. How they manage to walk between the two is a beautiful story with its share of intrigue. I'm looking forward to reading the rest of this series.

[Fiction with Phoebe · Rating 4 out of 5]

Blog Post: https://fictionwithphoebe.com/carved-...

Wealthy heiress Gwen Blackstone Kellerman and lawyer Patrick O’Neill come from vastly different worlds. But when questions surface regarding the decades old disappearance of Gwen’s older brother, they find themselves working together.

Reading about the Blackstones felt like getting a peek into how the Astors, Vanderbilts, and Rockefellers may have lived.

While their riches didn’t make the Blackstones immune to tragedy, I can see why others would resent them for it.

There were some strong hints about what actually happened to William Blackstone. So I was glad that it wasn’t treated as a huge twist, and that there was more focus placed on the fallout of the reveal.

Gwen could have stood up for Patrick, Liam, and herself a bit more, though. I know the Blackstones are her family, but their treatment of Patrick and Liam was rude. And they never really apologized or expressed regret for it, meanwhile Patrick was (rightly) called out for his judgmental attitude toward them.

I would have also liked to see more of Gwen’s reaction to Edwin being the culprit, since she had been pretty adamant that no one in her family would want to harm Liam.

Speaking of Liam, his struggle with reintegrating into the Blackstone family felt very realistic.

He hadn’t experienced the same luxuries or gone through any of the education the other Blackstones did. And the people he grew up around taught him to despise rich people. That difference in mindset wouldn’t just disappear because he found out they’re his blood relatives.

Patrick’s mother Birdie was a delight. She was such a trooper to go through those tetanus treatments. And I loved reading about her cake creations 😊

Apart from being a really great callback, Patrick’s grand gesture really showed that he truly understands and cares about Gwen, rather than her money.

Favorite Moments:
🌴 hypothetical legal question
🌴 conversation at the marina
🌴 second proposal

Content Notes
some mild innuendo, death of a parent (mentioned), death of a spouse (mentioned), mention of various crimes, mention of a “tacky grope,” one use of “godforsaken,” mention of alcohol consumption, mention of prostitutes, infidelity, two uses of “devilish,” two uses of devil, one mention of demons, one use of “the damned,” effects and treatment of tetanus, reference to suicide, mention of cursing (none specified), one mention of hell, an illegitimate child, noticing and awareness, touching, kissing, death of an infant (mentioned), some mild violence, blood, a man accidentally kills another man in self-defense (nothing overly graphic), mention of “bawdy humor,” one use of naked (no explicit details), one use of “bull hockey”

[Sydney · Rating 4 out of 5]

I enjoyed this! This one felt very reminiscent of Downton Abbey to me, with all the family drama and historical details. The romance between Gwen and Patrick felt very much like Sybil/Branson, and it was interesting to see the class differences throughout the story. The romance was a little lackluster in my opinion... I really didn't connect with either Gwen or Patrick, so I wasn't super invested in their relationship. I didn't dislike them, but what really kept me coming back was the family drama! I loved the parts that had to do with the long-lost sibling and the snooty family members. I definitely look forward to reading the next two books in this series!

[Ashley · Rating 4 out of 5]

Carved in Stone was another fascinating historical romance from Elizabeth Camden. I love the way she always brings to light little-known historical facts and weaves them into a truly compelling read. I know I always say that about Camden's books, but it bears repeating. I love learning about these things that I probably never would've known otherwise.

This book really reiterated the fact that appearances can be deceiving. It was a good reminder to not be so quick to judge someone else just because they come from a different background or have a different opinion.

This story had a bit of a slow start for me, but it wasn't long before I became completely invested in it and couldn't read fast enough. I enjoyed getting to know the complicated Blackstone family and highly recommend this book to fans of historical romance.

I received an advanced copy of this book and voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and comments are my honest opinion.

[Carrie Schmidt · Rating 4 out of 5]

I have long been a fan of Elizabeth Camden’s books and the unique way she captures the heart of that period when the Gilded Age was beginning to edge into the Progressive Era: when America is still hanging on to a grand society while also embarking on important social & political reforms and medical breakthroughs. I’m so fascinated by this time period, and I always love reading Camden’s books because she paints such a heartfelt portrait of both sides of society with grace and talent.

Carved in Stone kicks off The Blackstone Legacy series by introducing us to the Blackstone family with all their foibles and follies and heart. Out of the pack of family members who are motivated by wealth, a handful stand out as being people of integrity, compassion, and inner strength. Gwen Blackstone Kellerman is one such person. I loved her right away! Despite all the losses she has braved, she has not let any of them turn her heart toward bitterness but maintains a joy for life and a heart for others. She steers her passion for the college her father started into researching cures for deadly diseases like tetanus (after reading about the experimental treatments, I will never again complain about getting a tetanus shot lol) and harnessing the power of nature to heal in more ways than just physically.

Into her world comes Patrick O’Neill, an immigrant turned almost priest turned lawyer who fights on behalf of the downtrodden and poor. His steadiness and quiet faith endeared him to me immediately also! He is exactly the man that Gwen needs and exactly the hero for this story. I also adored the two of them together. Banter, intelligence, courage… all three are sparking through the air whenever Gwen and Patrick share the same page, not to mention the swoony romance building between them.

Bottom Line: Carved in Stone is another captivating example of Camden’s impeccable research, engaging writing voice, and layered characters. Gwen and Patrick face an uphill battle to get their chance at a happily-ever-after, but the journey is more than worth it for them as well as for the reader. With a deft hand, Camden leads us – and our intrepid protagonists – through clashes between the classes, high-stakes boardroom drama, family tension, a decades-old mystery with a couple of stunning twists, the mansions of the rich, the tenements of the poor, and the sweetness of new love. A definite must-read for fans of the author and the Gilded Age setting!

(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)

first reviewed (with full disclosure) at Reading Is My SuperPower

[MJSH · Rating 5 out of 5]

"They will be carved in stone to last for all time."

Elizabeth Camden has a way of painting little known historical facts during the Gilded Age into full masterpieces and her inaugural novel in The Blackstone Legacy series is no exception. The author fuses the founding of a conglomerate steel corporation with advancement in science and medicine, the swirling decadence of the elite with a close look at the slums and tenements within the backdrop of 1900 New York City. The main characters are opposites as well but they work to bridge the differences in their worlds and, in many ways, learn to complement each other. This story has it all - great historical background, spellbinding backdrop, fluid writing, deeply layered characters, intriguing suspense, achingly tender romance, and a seamless faith thread.

I loved Patrick and his steadfast loyalty as the lawyer and spiritual counselor for the downtrodden. I needed a bit more time to warm up to Gwen, the ivory tower princess wrapped up in botany and comforts of academia, but her compassion and generous spirit won me over. Their flirtations are quite delicious and the humor sprinkled throughout the book is quite unexpected but equally enchanting. I loved learning about development of tetanus serum and vaccine among many other things.

If you enjoy historical romance, this book will captivate you. I can't wait for the next book in the series. I received the book from Bethany House Publishers and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are solely my own.

[Faith · Rating 5 out of 5]

The first in a captivating new series set in the Gilded Age, Carved in Stone introduces the powerful Blackstone family, as secrets are revealed with the future of the largest merger in US history at stake.

Gwen Kellerman loves her life at college hosting gatherings of some of the most inquisitive minds, drawing comfort from the familiar. But her safe haven is at risk of going under, a chance sighting has her fighting to save the college alongside Patrick a principled young lawyer who dislikes everything her family represents. Does their love stand a chance?

A captivating and engaging novel, and an excellent introduction to the powerful Blackstone family. I loved how this book juxtaposes the lives of Gwen, Liam and Patrick, who come from vastly different backgrounds, as they try to find common ground and fight for what matters. Gwen is passionate about education, and longs for the close family connection that she was robbed of throughout her life. I admired her willingness to help, her compassion, and courage. Patrick is a hardworking and compassionate lawyer, he holds high standards of integrity for himself, and he is a wonderful friend.

Overall, a wonderful introductory to this brand new series by Elizabeth Camden. I loved the characters, rich history, and engaging plot. I'm so excited to see what happens next with this series, crossing my fingers for more on Liam and Natalia!

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

[DevotedToHope · Rating 5 out of 5]

Release Date: August 31, 2021 by Bethany House
Genre: Christian, Historical Fiction, Historical Christian Romance
5 Stars

Romance, fictional history, and a mystery is spun together beautifully in Carved in Stone!

Carved in Stone is another fantastic story written by the extraordinarily talented and award-winning author, Elizabeth Camden. This engaging historical romance includes splendidly dimensional characters. I highly recommend this book to everyone who enjoys a wonderful, historical romance!

This author is known for excellent research and conveying facts to us in a beautiful way. In this novel, we peek into the world of botany, a research experiment, banking, a monastery, as well as other historical facts. Don’t miss the “Historical Note” from the author at the end of the book as well as the “Questions for Discussion.”

One of my favorites, significant quotes from this book: “Patrick believed the best way to prove his devotion to God was to aim for the highest rank, and that meant the priesthood. It was the purest form of commitment and came with lifelong responsibilities and sacrifices he was eager to assume. His vows would be joyfully offered and forever carved in stone.” As soon as I read those three sentences, I immediately thought of Romans 12:1-2: “Therefore I urge you, brethren, by the mercies of God, to present your bodies a living and holy sacrifice, acceptable to God, which is your spiritual service of worship. And do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, so that you may prove what the will of God is, that which is good and acceptable and perfect.”

I am looking forward to quickly reading the next two books in this series: Written on the Wind and Heart of Steel.

#CarvedInStone #ElizabethCamden #BethanyHouse

[Morgan Giesbrecht · Rating 4 out of 5]

I am quickly falling in love with Camden’s expert ability in bringing the Gilded Age to life with little known historical tidbits!

The Blackstone bank, the Blackstone College, a proposed steel merger, a two-decade old child abduction, and a trial to stop a criminal memoir all work together to create this fascinating reading experience.

I adored Gwen. Her determination & courage are admirable. She can be a wee bit naïve at times, but still, she’s a plucky lady worthy of admiration. Also, her deceased husband was the absolute worst. She deserved far better.

Patrick, the Irish hero, is the almost-priest turned lawyer defending the man accused of kidnapping & murdering Gwen’s older brother as a toddler twenty-years earlier… this time in a new case. Patrick gets bonus points for being Irish because that’s just the way it works. 🤭 His pride comes into a major play over the story as he and Gwen try to bridge the chasm between their worlds, not always successfully. I will note that Patrick is a devout Catholic (probably the most sincere I’ve read in fiction), so that does factor in (praying the rosary, going to confession, etc.). However, I didn’t find that the theology was all wrong, and his sincerity is admirable. Just something to be aware of going in. :)

I’m very excited to read more about this powerful family, and I have a feeling Natalia might be my favourite!


Content: mention of man having a secret tryst with a woman two weeks before taking his priesthood vows, which he ended up not taking; mentions of man having a mistress and caring for her more than his wife; child abduction; mild violence

[Lori · Rating 5 out of 5]

I always love Camden's novels and I eagerly look forward to the next one!
Her books are so interesting and I love her extensive research to make a grand read!
This one I believe will be my favorite so far.
I love the mystery that was sneaked into the story.
I also felt that she did an awesome job of letting us look into the life of an aristocratic family and how they lived.
To me, money isn't everything. It doesn't make you happy. Yes it can make life easier but even then not always.
In my opinion Gwen really didn't fit in with the rest of her family. I think it was because she wore her heart on her sleeve and wants to see the good in everything and everyone. ( just like me).
Another thing I like about her books is that I learn something new. Something that I never knew about or heard of.
I love history especially American history. Elizabeth Camden is my go to for this.
Another great book to add to my list of favorites for 2021.
Highly recommend! 5 stars!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.

[A.M. Heath · Rating 5 out of 5]

My Thoughts:
Camden is gifted at creating compelling stories. From the opening page, I was drawn into their world and eager to see how it would all end for them.
My one complaint was that the only real religious content was from a Catholic character, which included Catholic prayers to Mary.
But I loved the chemistry between Patrick and Gwen. And I especially loved Liam. He was so rough around the edges. I really hope he gets his own story later.
If you haven’t read a Camden novel yet, then you’re in for a real historical treat. She’s entertaining while also keeping a steady hand on history, but not in a tedious way. It’d be hard not to learn something new or to leave without falling in love with the characters she creates.

Rating and Recommendations: I’m giving it 5 stars and recommending it to those who enjoy Christian Historical Romance

~ I received a copy from Bethany House. I was not compensated for this review or required to give a favorable one. All thoughts are my own.

[Becka · Rating 3 out of 5]

I really enjoyed the historical aspects of the story. There was quite a bit going on in the plot, which kept the story moving at a good clip. The use of modern day informalities when speaking did distract me, as it felt untrue to the time period/ situation. No man in 1900 would shorten the name of a woman he barely knows from Poppy to “Pops”. Nor would a man in 1900 have greeted another man with “Yo, Patrick!”
Otherwise, this was an enjoyable book, although I would classify it as historical romance, not mystery/suspense.

[Jennifer · Rating 4 out of 5]

I quite enjoyed this book. The historical details were rich, the characters well drawn, and the surprise mystery (which turned out to be not as mysterious as I expected) was interesting. I also really appreciated the business aspect of this story. Business practices during the Gilded Age have always fascinated me (and as an economics major in college I was known to geek out on that topic), and the inclusion of U.S. Steel's creation was just so cool :)

I also really liked the main characters' development. They were able to accomplish something that we mere real people aspire to achieve. The message of God's forgiveness and grace was fantastic too. The only quibble I have is that that terrible woman never got her comeuppance. I guess her judgment will come in the after life. I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys reading historical inspirational fiction with a touch of romance.

[Kirsten · Rating 2 out of 5]

DNF at 50%. I gave this one a good go. I really tried to like it, and I just didn’t. I thought all of Liam’s inappropriate comments seemed out of place for the era. It made me sad when Patrick was wanting to pray, and didn’t really, because he didn’t have a rosary with him. And then, when he was struggling because of something that he did, he went to a priest to ask for forgiveness. I know these are very Catholic things, but it made his supposedly very strong faith seem shallow. These weren’t the only reasons I didn’t find myself loving the book, but they were contributing factors. If you loved this book, I’d love to hear how it picks up in the second half.
Oh, and I felt that revealing Liam’s identity so early in the novel felt premature somehow.
One more thing! Patrick is forever calling Gwen “Mrs. K.”
Even thought her husband who gave her that last name was a piece of work and he knew it. I wouldn’t want my new romance interest to identify me that way. Just me? Okay.

[Vibliophile · Rating 5 out of 5]

Absolutely wonderful!

Gwen & Patrick are from two very different worlds, and initially, their love story seemed like it was going to be a traditional star-crossed lovers trope. Well done, of course, but fairly predictable. However, Elizabeth Camden reminded me of why I love her writing so much, as she quickly reeled me in to the mystery of Gwen's little brother, and the unexpected paths the story takes.

The story's pace is fairly brisk & never lagged. The main characters are richly developed, and I loved how the reader gets to view things from both perspectives, so that we see each side of the divide is capable of being both good and bad - or in other words, fully human.

While I had a suspicion of who the villain was, the mystery was still handled deftly enough to keep me fully immersed. Best of all, the ending is absolutely charming & left me with a big smile on my face. And I'm thrilled that Natalia's story will be next & will involve the crazy Count - sounds fun!

*Romance level: sweet kisses, nothing graphic

*Religion: Patrick is an Irish Catholic & former seminarian who discerned that he was not called to the priesthood prior to receiving Holy Orders. As a Catholic, I greatly appreciate the effort the author made to be accurate & respectful in her depictions. The faith aspects in the story are both cultural & spiritual; the spiritual aspects are universally Christian & flow very naturally from the story.

[Rachelle Cobb · Rating 4 out of 5]

I honestly struggled to relate to and like Gwen but when the pieces of her past started falling into place, I couldn’t stop reading.

I love Patrick’s strong, proud Irish self.

The subplot with the tetanus scare seemed very rushed to me; I wanted to get back to the decades-old scandal/mystery, and I really enjoyed how that all played out!

The ending is great, but can Patrick please start calling Gwen by her given name now? 😂

I hope the next books in the series are about Liam and then Natalia and her count!

[Hannah Elisabeth · Rating 4 out of 5]

I really don’t know where to begin. I was really anticipating this book, and while I wouldn’t say I’m disappointed in it, I will say that I don’t feel like my expectations were met. Maybe they were too high to begin with. Because I thought “I don’t know how she’s gonna top the Hope and Glory series but hey it’s Elizabeth Camden so maybe she will.” In my honest opinion she did not top the Hope and Glory series.

Don’t get me wrong, I did love this book. They’re were plenty of things I loved about it. The writing was great as usual. I liked the college aspect to it. I thought that was pretty interesting. I LOVED the rich people family drama. That’s something new that I’ve discovered I like in books is rich family drama; I don’t know why but there you have it. Also the humor in this book was my kind of humor. It was delivered in a blunt, dry way and I laughed out loud multiple times. And the snappy one line zingers that a character would deliver to another….I loved it.

However obviously there was stuff I didn’t love as well.

For one thing, this book deals a lot with big banks and their operating procedures and stuff like that because the Blackstone family, which the series is named for, own a rather large bank. It also deals with legal issues since our main guy Patrick is a lawyer. However there were times where when the characters were discussing banking business or lawyer things, it would go kinda like this: “and then the conversation revolved around *this thing* for a while.” Like sections of dialogue were cut out when they’d talk about things that were talking business. Which I understand you don’t want to get bogged down with arguments and technicalities that aren’t actually relevant but it happened every time.

I also liked the couple. But I didn’t love them. It felt almost like a side character couple that you’re happy they got together, but also it didn’t really matter all that much because they’re not the main couple. But Patrick and Gwen were the main couple! I think maybe I felt that way because a lot of when they apparently started courting was off the page. We were informed of it after “three weeks we’d been talking to each other and we kind of like each other and maybe this could be the start of something great.” *not a direct quote.*

The final thing I want to mention is this. Close to the end of the book, one character calls out another character for their behavior. I won’t say who or want because I don’t want to spoil anyone. But when this person was called out, I was like “but you’re absolutely right. That is exactly what’s been going on.” I did not see it before something was said (I don’t know what that says about me as a reader lol) but when it was said I was like yes I see that. And thinking back over the book what was said was 100% true! So we should have had an epiphany from the character that was called out right? Like oh this person is right that’s how I’ve been acting even though I haven’t realized it. I’m sorry about my behavior. But we didn’t….we just go about our business and make a half apology without saying you were right and now all is forgiven? I mean ok I guess. Not exactly any kind of character development but I guess that’s fine.

Overall, with my negative grievances being aired, I did like the book. And I’m SUPER excited for book two which is SPOILER ALERT! Going to be about Natalia!!! I’m so excited!

[Rosalyn · Rating 4 out of 5]

Elizabeth Camden has brought to life the gilded age.
This book shows the different classes, and just how difficult it was for them to interact on a deeper level.
Gwen is from one of those rich families, the ones that run the world. And her parents have nothing more in mind for her but that she make a good match. Only, this is not what Gwen wants.
Then she meets Patrick, a lowly Irish lawyer. They are on opposite sides of a court case. Strangely, they are drawn together.
When Gwen wants answers to what happened in the disappearance of her brother so many years ago, she knows that Patrick will help her.
I really enjoyed seeing the relationship between Patrick and Gwen progress and grow.
I also was held captive by the mystery of what really happened to William.
Not your typical story, you may guess at the answers, but be prepared to be surprised!
Disclaimer: I receive complimentary books from various sources, including, publishers, publicists, authors, and/or NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review, and have not received any compensation. The opinions shared here are my own entirely. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255

[Joleen · Rating 4 out of 5]

Carved in Stone, audiobook
Narrated by Pilar Witherspoon

April, 1900
New York City

Characters
Gwen Kellerman - An heiress of the Blackstone dynasty
Patrick O'Neill - nearly a priest, became a lawyer for the downtrodden Irish immigrants in his community
Liam Malone - Gwen's kidnapped brother (as a child)
Natalia - Gwen's aunt with a head for business
Poppy - Piece of work

As usual, Ms. Camden's story is evident of hours of research and precise writing. I’ve always been intrigued by her style and storytelling.

This offering has an heiress whose brother was kidnapped at three years of age and the family has all but given up…until one day a man walks into a meeting and the family resemblance was astounding.

But my, how he differed from what she believed he'd be if she ever saw him again. No manners or sense of decorum, making fun of or disgusted by the rules of society…even his new family was too different a class of people for him to want to do anything other than roll his eyes. Scrappy and crude. He could never fit like this!

A sweet romance and much needed justice.

The narrator was a bit sing-songy and slightly dramatic for my taste

[Rachael · Rating 3 out of 5]

Carved in Stone by Camden is in an interesting time in history. I have watched documentaries on the Rockefeller and Carnegie dynasties so I’m familiar with steel and this time period. I enjoyed the history, plot. And characters. It was predictable but interesting enough to keep me in the book.

I felt more connected to the main female character, but I found myself wishing to know a bit more about her younger years. I liked the main male character, but I didn’t really like all of the rosary mentions that came up in regards to his character. I realize that some of it made it historical as Irish immigrants were Catholic, but it seemed odd in a Christian fiction book.

The history and its background was what really held my attention throughout this book. It was very well done.

I received this book from the publisher.All opinions are my own.