Of the books I’ve read by the prolific K.L. Slater, I think this is probably my favourite - the plot was really intriguing, with a couple of genuine surprises. (Though it took me far too long to make a certain connection which, in retrospect, was obvious. Must’ve been off my game.)
Ten year old cousins, Maddy and Brianna, are accused of a horrific crime - a brutal assault on a vulnerable elderly woman, Bessie. Whether they’re guilty or not is unclear - their mothers, sisters Juliet and Chloe, certainly can’t believe it - but there’s no doubt that they were there and that they know something. But nobody knows what, because the girls aren’t talking.
Unable to get a word out of either girl, the police bring in family therapist Dana - a character I really liked - in an attempt to communicate with them. But it soon becomes clear to Dana that issues in the girls’ apparently normal family run deeper than anyone suspected.
What we are told of the attack on Bessie is harrowing and I did feel this sometimes got a bit lost among Juliet’s worries about her business and what people are saying on social media. Still, Juliet was far less annoying than her sister Chloe, who was a massive pain in the neck, and mother Joan (ditto). Although there was some attempt at showing the impact on Bessie’s family, I never really felt we got to know the victim.
I’d like to think the description of the hate and harassment aimed at the girls and their families, both on the dreaded social media and in real life (and before any guilt has been proven) is excessive... but sadly, I’m not sure that’s the case.
While the ending scene was quite touching (and the twist leading up to it excellent), I found the actual ending, i.e. the very last lines, to be a bit trite, as if the author hadn’t really put any thought into her closing lines. This took me out of what should have been quite an emotional moment.
All in all, though, a compelling and intriguing read.
Merged review:
Of the books I’ve read by the prolific K.L. Slater, I think this is probably my favourite - the plot was really intriguing, with a couple of genuine surprises. (Though it took me far too long to make a certain connection which, in retrospect, was obvious. Must’ve been off my game.)
Ten year old cousins, Maddy and Brianna, are accused of a horrific crime - a brutal assault on a vulnerable elderly woman, Bessie. Whether they’re guilty or not is unclear - their mothers, sisters Juliet and Chloe, certainly can’t believe it - but there’s no doubt that they were there and that they know something. But nobody knows what, because the girls aren’t talking.
Unable to get a word out of either girl, the police bring in family therapist Dana - a character I really liked - in an attempt to communicate with them. But it soon becomes clear to Dana that issues in the girls’ apparently normal family run deeper than anyone suspected.
What we are told of the attack on Bessie is harrowing and I did feel this sometimes got a bit lost among Juliet’s worries about her business and what people are saying on social media. Still, Juliet was far less annoying than her sister Chloe, who was a massive pain in the neck, and mother Joan (ditto). Although there was some attempt at showing the impact on Bessie’s family, I never really felt we got to know the victim.
I’d like to think the description of the hate and harassment aimed at the girls and their families, both on the dreaded social media and in real life (and before any guilt has been proven) is excessive... but sadly, I’m not sure that’s the case.
While the ending scene was quite touching (and the twist leading up to it excellent), I found the actual ending, i.e. the very last lines, to be a bit trite, as if the author hadn’t really put any thought into her closing lines. This took me out of what should have been quite an emotional moment.
All in all, though, a compelling and intriguing read.