Being the first person to rate and review the book always brings out a sort of uncharacteristic generosity. But the goal is objectivity. And objectively, I’m not in love. Or like, even. I’m…mildly entertained. At best.
Actually, I read the author before, a forgettable novella titled Shut Up that seemed too young. Because it was forgettable I did forget about it, so I requested this one from Netgalley based on just on the description and the fact that it’s Flame Tree press, which has fairly decent quality control. And usually very reasonable page count, so you don’t get too stuck with a dud.
So anyway, second experience with the author has been objectively more favorable by comparison, but then again the bar was pretty low. This is one of those creature feature in space things that’s been done and done and done before. They are tons of fun cinematically, usually. In fact, this might have been more fun as a movie. It would have a young cast, a bunch of 20somethings, who cuss up a storm, to showcase their toughness or angst or something. Seriously, so much cussing. And I don’t even care about that sort of thing as a prude might, for me it’s more of a linguistic thing…language evolves, there are abundant epistemological evidence of that, so why hasn’t anyone come up with some new fun ways to cuss in the year 2231?
Anyway, that aside…so a bunch of these youngsters are on a spaceship Demeter…yes, seriously, someone went and named the ship Demeter and thought that was a good and safe and not at all ominous choice. Maybe Dracula’s gone out of print by then?
Anyway, that aside…the team is on a mission, the mission is to gather biological samples from other planets in order to bring them back to Earth and find out if they can be of use. Let’s pause to appreciate that terrible idea. Why would you want to screw around with biodiversity like that? Or take those kinds of risks? Australia won’t even let people bring pets in. Not even Johnny Depp, for crying out loud. Imagine that. And that’s all on the same planet. Imagine how many things can go terribly wrong by dragging things in from outer space.
Anyway, that aside…one day close to the two year mission’s end it turns out there’s a foreign biological creature on the ship. Free and murderously rummaging around. And now everyone has to overlook their differences, band together and fight. And the death toll goes up. And up. And up
So pretty standard fair, right? Space terror, horrific sci fi…one of those. But wait, there’s an angle. In fact, it is this angle that got the book sold. The book that’s originally been passed around and rewritten for years (the author rewrote Shut Up a bunch too, she must be very passionate about rewrites, it explains a fairly limited literary output). But then #MeToo era rolled in and all stories having to do with some sort of abuse of women gained new relevance and Flame Press not wanting to miss the train, grabbed this book. Because this book is indeed about an abusive relationship, in fact it hinges on it.
Yeah, tricky, right. You thought you were just getting a creature feature, but no, you’re getting also a relationship drama, a relationship so messed up ,dysfunctional and violent, it makes Ike and Tina (or we can use Johnny Depp again) look like that nice old couple form the first five minutes of Up. The couple here are Raina (GR’s description’s got a typo) and Moe.
Raina’s our protagonist, actually, the intrepid mechanic who has to deal with both a sh*tty boss and a lunatic for a bf. But, you know, a hot lunatic. They have spaceship quaking sex, despite strict orders not to fraternize, but then Moe turns psycho and starts confusing Raina for an emotional and/or physical punching bag. Raina puts up with it for a good while, because he’s so fine, he’s so fine, he blows her mind, even overlooking his rapey moments, but eventually she ever so reluctantly drags herself away from him and the entire novel is essentially that dynamic between them, they are fighting each other while fighting the larger scale fight of staying alive. And yes, it does get tiring. But it’s also the backbone of this entire production, because Raina and Moe are born survivors while the rest of the team are creature snacks.
So that’s the entire story. You can scream if you want to. It goes by fairly quickly, It still has some of that YA energy the author can’t seem to get all the way away from, but it’s for adults, adults are in it, technically. There’s action, alien scares, all sorts of things you’d expect.
The story is interspersed with the account of Raina/Moe sh*tshow of a relationship. That line of narrative goes backwards (an actually inspired choice) right to when first they met and sparks went wild. While the actual story is bullettraining forward over the course of a single day. I believe the novel is actually meant to be one of those female empowerment stories with Raina getting her groove and all that, but really her likeability is questionable and I suppose will depend on a reader.
And that’s that. Yes, I’m aware it isn’t the most encouraging of reviews, but it’s detailed, honest and might give you an idea about whether this book may be right for you. It isn’t terrible by any means, it does a fairly decent job of telling the same old story, it is, as mentioned earlier, mildly entertaining. Your mileage may vary. Thanks Netgalley.