Education policy in England is constantly evolving and becoming increasingly incoherent and it is therefore becoming harder to keep up with, and make sense of, all the changes. This bestselling book looks at the role of the UK as a social laboratory for global education policy. Covering key concepts, it then examines new areas, including: • Global education policy mobility • Edu-business and philanthropy as policy actors • Marketisation of education • Increase in performance gap • Poverty and austerity • Impact of COVID-19 on schools and in education policy • New forms of governance This extensively updated fourth edition by the key author in the field will maintain its place as the most important text on education policy and makes essential reading for all students and anyone interested in education policy more generally.
This is a lovely wee book, but it would be much better if you are from the UK – as pretty much everything after the first chapter is probably ‘too much information’ for anyone from elsewhere. That isn’t quite true – as seeing how globalised forces play out in any one sphere gives an interesting insight into how these forces play out everywhere, but still.
Policy is an incredibly interesting field. You know, policies exist to bring about change. No one ever had a policy for keeping everything the same, although there is the case of the Australian Prime Minister who said one of those great lines that ought to be more quoted, but which I can't find to check – The government’s policy on this matter is quite clear, we have no policy on this.
And since policies are about change they are also ‘aspirational’. There’s not a lot of point having policies that are designed to make the world a worse place – even if that ends up being the outcome. Policies are about fixing stuff so that the world becomes, in some way at least, a better place. In a lot of ways this book isn’t really looking at how misguided or ill-informed policies might be, as much fun as this tends to be – but rather what are the main policy directions that impact on education and why do they throw up the particular policy choices they do?
In the early 1990s there was a turn in the Anglophone nations of the world towards the idea that governments should stop rowing and rather just steer. The idea was that the private sector is innately better at delivering services and that therefore it is in everyone’s interests for them to do so, following proper competitive and free market mechanisms being put in place. The arguments for and against this are mostly irrelevant here – and do nothing to take away from the fact of the wide scale privatisation that has continued unabated over the decades since or of the increasing free market preferences of both sides of politics in all Anglophone nations I can think of. So, whether you get a Labour Party elected in Britain or a Labor Party elected in Australia, it may slightly slow down the sale of government assets when compared to Conservative or Liberal governments, but then again it might not too. The efficacy of free market solutions will not be challenged. Policy, then, will tend to be about steering, not about rowing.
So, what does that mean for schools? Well, many schools tend to be run by governments. There was a time – not all that long ago – when schools were seen as being a societal good, and an investment, rather than a cost. Now schools are seen as providing positional advantage for our children and, like all such things, ought to operate according to the strictures imposed by consumer choice. This means discovering means of heightening competition – as competition weeds out the underperforming school and improves the middling school. It also involves giving parents as much choice as possible. This is all framed in the language of freedom – one really ought to remember that ‘free’ is a four-letter word and should be used with as much care and discretion as other four letter words. Assume that when someone starts talking about freedom that they mean you harm and you probably can’t go too far wrong.
All of this implies finding ways to introduce markets into schools - including government schools - so that the private sector can do some of the rowing.
Choice then requires something to make choices on – information is often seen as a good start here – but what kind of information is right for making these choices? The problem is that buying an education isn’t quite like buying a phone. It is complicated and hard work and you never really have the ‘right’ information on which to make your decision. In Australia we have a thing called NAPLAN – a series of tests given to all school children in years 3, 5, 7 and 9. The idea being that parents can then look at the ‘My School’ site and get all of the information on their school that will not only enable them to shop around – but also help them to put pressure on underperforming schools so as to make them perform. Schools are not just compared to all schools, but also to 'like' schools.
The problems with these data are many and varied. Firstly, parents don’t send their kids to schools only based on the academic performance of schools – some parents are even stupid enough to actually want their kids to be happy and not just economically viable units. Bizarre, I know, but there you go, there's no helping some people. Also the information you get from these sites is of remarkable poor quality given the purpose it is supposed to serve – in Australia the tests which produce NAPLAN gives statistically invalid information at child, class, school and state level. But it has graphs and numbers with decimal places – so it must be scientific and it must be true.
The real problem here is in what education has become. Education was once about giving children the resources they would need to become functioning citizens within our society. Today this is hardly mentioned and if it is only as a kind of ‘Jesus is coming, look busy’ aspiration. No, what is necessary in a highly competitive world that is globalised in a dog-eat-dog way is for us to have the skills necessary to turn our society into knowledge economy. And we can only do that if we raise standards and those standards are generally constructed around literacy and numeracy – with everything else seen as finger painting. The question you are meant to ask is, 'so, how is this going to get me a job?'
Policy is constructed in response to how we envision our world – the problems it faces and the solutions it proposes to those problems. But what is increasingly interesting is that fact that schools are actually diminishing in importance in relation to educating the population, even as our kids spend more time in them. There was a time when education could be finished and done with by the time most people where 14. Now, governments want the majority of people to be still at school at 24. And when they talk about life long learning they are being quite literal. What is interesting here is that education stops being a matter for the State to provide, but rather a task to be undertaken according to the life-biography of each individual.
We can often be fooled into thinking that education is somehow above politics and above petty squabbles – but a quick look at the swirling, dizzying policy changes and realignments over the last few decades in virtually any nation shows that this is a highly contested space. It isn't above politics, it is a playing out of politics and power.
To put matters bluntly – education teaches people how and what to think – no government can leave it alone because all governments want you to think as they do. But education policies are anything but over and above – or somehow outside and separate from – the mess of other policies that governments and bureaucracies impose. Only by understanding the world that policies are trying to bring into being can we have any hope at all of understanding why it is these policies and not others that are being pursued.
As I said, the first chapter of this particularly is a very useful introduction to the main flavours of education policies and how these have been influenced by ideas such as globalisation, privatisation, school choice and knowledge economies.
Brilliant book for anyone who wants to understand the British education system with a focus on the last 30 years. Ball identifies trends that have continued despite which political party is in power and argues his case with care. Well researched and coming from one of the most important education sociologists of our time is essential reading for anyone who is disturbed by what is happening to our state sector schools. As markets gradually seep into and take over education we should all be very afraid of what happens when education is linked to profits.
A small book about the education policy of the UK. The writer encourages any reader to sample this book with ease due to his smooth and precise style. The lesson learned dr the British experience with education it that education reform is in a state of flux and is never ending.