What do you think?
Rate this book
The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall
She arrived as a housekeeper
Will she leave as a countess?
To some, Thornhallow Hall might be tarnished by tales of vengeance and ghosts, but to new housekeeper Rebecca Merrickson it represents independence and peace from her tumultuous past. Until the estate’s owner, William Reid, the disappeared earl, unexpectedly returns… After clashing with him over the changes she’s made to the house, Rebecca slowly unearths the memories that haunt brooding Liam—and her defiance gives way to a shockingly improper attraction to her master!
From Harlequin Your romantic escape to the past.
Will she leave as a countess?
To some, Thornhallow Hall might be tarnished by tales of vengeance and ghosts, but to new housekeeper Rebecca Merrickson it represents independence and peace from her tumultuous past. Until the estate’s owner, William Reid, the disappeared earl, unexpectedly returns… After clashing with him over the changes she’s made to the house, Rebecca slowly unearths the memories that haunt brooding Liam—and her defiance gives way to a shockingly improper attraction to her master!
From Harlequin Your romantic escape to the past.
288 pages, Mass Market Paperback
Published July 27, 2021
13 people are currently reading
84 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews
July 26, 2022
I enjoyed some aspects of this, but I wish the gothic aura had been more consistent; the detailed descriptions of Feels clogged up pagetime that would’ve been better spent developing tension with the villain or unraveling the mystery of Hal’s decline. Alas, the MCs isolation at Thornhallow is so complete that those two aspects felt rather undercooked. Even in the most isolated romantic utopia, I’d expect such major fulcrums to be more completely addressed by the close of the book—Hal’s fate, in particular, seems vague, which wouldn’t bother me so much if the characters themselves didn’t act like they’d gotten all the answers they needed. As it was, the villain’s final act felt rushed compared to the lengthy monologues of tingly lust & guilty consciences…but I like how Ms James played on gothic expectations by referencing more famous authors like Shelley & Poe. I also liked that Rebecca wasn’t some outlandishly virginal heroine—she was tall, capable, outspoken, & had previous *positive* sexual experience—but her character showed little development from beginning to end, whereas the hero’s arc made no logical sense either way.
Overall, it was different from the usual ho-hum Harley Historical, so in that much it was intriguing. Is it that rare breed of next-level HQN? Unfortunately, no. 😶 But I do hope this encourages Harley to release other gothic-tinged novels; most of their recent output has been ultra-stale & bland.
Overall, it was different from the usual ho-hum Harley Historical, so in that much it was intriguing. Is it that rare breed of next-level HQN? Unfortunately, no. 😶 But I do hope this encourages Harley to release other gothic-tinged novels; most of their recent output has been ultra-stale & bland.
dnf
January 19, 2022DNF at 35%. I just couldn't accept the heroine's rationale that the hero wouldn't harm her (just a mere gut feeling). The hero did try to throttle her during an episode (I'm not sure what he has since I couldn't be bothered to continue). It left bruises on her throat. So, this one's a DNF for me.
Read
March 26, 2022I'm throwing in the towel at 37%. It's not holding my attention and there's a moment in the hero's study where the heroine's lack of self-preservation bothered me. I may come back to this at a later date given my reading mood has been the pits lately.
September 4, 2021
1.5 stars, rounded up.
Yikes. This was a mess. I have a soft spot for the old-fashioned housekeeper or governess gothic romance, so when I saw this I just had to bite. Sadly, it didn't live up to its "Jane Eyre-esque" promise.
For one thing, in terms of vocabulary, there were a lot of words that had me scratching my head, page after page. The author said "x", did she really mean to say "y"? Because "x" doesn't exactly work here, but "y" would work. Why are the sentences so overwrought, with what seemed to be lots of unnecessary descriptors, when simpler and more straightforward language would move the story along faster?
And seriously, what is the last word of the following sentence from the book even doing there, given that the story takes place in the 1800s: "Tall and lithe, fine-featured, his appearance was effortlessly but carefully curated."
I also wanted to understand what Rachel did for birth control. She easily disposes of concerns about pregnancy by telling Reid she knows what to do to prevent it. But we never see her leave the house to purchase any sort of supplies, nor are we told just what she does to prevent pregnancy. And when you consider she probably didn't plan on sleeping with Reid, well, I was amazed she seemed nevertheless prepared and unbothered.
Rachel has several tattoos--to symbolize important moments or things in her life--and I asked myself how likely it was that an Englishwoman (moreover not an aristocrat) would have tattoos in the early 1800s. I researched a bit, but I ended up unconvinced that the tattoos would have been likely (or that Reid would have been okay with them).
I'm hoping someone will explain exactly what it was the villain did (or wanted to do to Rachel) again? Things were so vague, I got confused as to what he planned to do when he finally showed up.
Reid's own issues regarding Thornhallow are dragged out and yes, a bit overwrought. (We get it, Reid--you're tortured by the past and want to be rid of Thornhallow.)
Maybe you will have better luck with this story than I did.
Yikes. This was a mess. I have a soft spot for the old-fashioned housekeeper or governess gothic romance, so when I saw this I just had to bite. Sadly, it didn't live up to its "Jane Eyre-esque" promise.
For one thing, in terms of vocabulary, there were a lot of words that had me scratching my head, page after page. The author said "x", did she really mean to say "y"? Because "x" doesn't exactly work here, but "y" would work. Why are the sentences so overwrought, with what seemed to be lots of unnecessary descriptors, when simpler and more straightforward language would move the story along faster?
And seriously, what is the last word of the following sentence from the book even doing there, given that the story takes place in the 1800s: "Tall and lithe, fine-featured, his appearance was effortlessly but carefully curated."
I also wanted to understand what Rachel did for birth control. She easily disposes of concerns about pregnancy by telling Reid she knows what to do to prevent it. But we never see her leave the house to purchase any sort of supplies, nor are we told just what she does to prevent pregnancy. And when you consider she probably didn't plan on sleeping with Reid, well, I was amazed she seemed nevertheless prepared and unbothered.
Rachel has several tattoos--to symbolize important moments or things in her life--and I asked myself how likely it was that an Englishwoman (moreover not an aristocrat) would have tattoos in the early 1800s. I researched a bit, but I ended up unconvinced that the tattoos would have been likely (or that Reid would have been okay with them).
I'm hoping someone will explain exactly what it was the villain did (or wanted to do to Rachel) again? Things were so vague, I got confused as to what he planned to do when he finally showed up.
Reid's own issues regarding Thornhallow are dragged out and yes, a bit overwrought. (We get it, Reid--you're tortured by the past and want to be rid of Thornhallow.)
Maybe you will have better luck with this story than I did.
June 19, 2024
As a writer of historical romance, I don't actually read a lot of historical romance these days, but I was drawn to this one as a Gothic romance (which I'm currently immersed in writing myself) and because (of course) anything mentioning a housekeeper makes you think of Rebecca.
The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall was not a retelling of Du Maurier's classic, and even though the housekeeper was called Rebecca, she bore no resemblance to the first Mrs de Winter, never mind the terrifying Mrs Danvers. This Rebecca was the opposite of Mrs Danvers, determined to open up Thornhallow Hall and expel the ghosts, not to preserve them or celebrate them. This Rebecca was determined to heal Liam, the (until she arrived) absentee owner of the estate, and to bring light and happiness back to all. Not that she expressed any of that though, this Rebecca considers herself a practical, pragmatic woman with no illusions about any of the softer emotions. With reason. 'Love' has not been kind to her. And as for Liam, the earl determined not to be an earl? He wants to expel his ghosts, that's why he comes back to Thornhallow, but he simply doesn't know how. Is it any wonder that he vents at Rebecca? She's so annoying, so right, and so very attractive.
This is a great romance, of two people determined not to romance each other, and determined that they have no future - I mean not only together, but anything permanent. Wherever they lay their hats, to quote a song, has been the case until now. No putting down roots for very different but understandable reasons. But what becomes clear is that putting down roots - together - is exactly what they need.
There's a brilliant cast of secondary characters in this book, and a really good storyline underpinning the slow simmer romance. The haunting Gothic overtones of the back stories are brilliant, and the Hall itself plays a very Manderlay-style role. I loved all the inversion of Du Maurier's Rebecca too. Thoroughly enjoyed this one.
The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall was not a retelling of Du Maurier's classic, and even though the housekeeper was called Rebecca, she bore no resemblance to the first Mrs de Winter, never mind the terrifying Mrs Danvers. This Rebecca was the opposite of Mrs Danvers, determined to open up Thornhallow Hall and expel the ghosts, not to preserve them or celebrate them. This Rebecca was determined to heal Liam, the (until she arrived) absentee owner of the estate, and to bring light and happiness back to all. Not that she expressed any of that though, this Rebecca considers herself a practical, pragmatic woman with no illusions about any of the softer emotions. With reason. 'Love' has not been kind to her. And as for Liam, the earl determined not to be an earl? He wants to expel his ghosts, that's why he comes back to Thornhallow, but he simply doesn't know how. Is it any wonder that he vents at Rebecca? She's so annoying, so right, and so very attractive.
This is a great romance, of two people determined not to romance each other, and determined that they have no future - I mean not only together, but anything permanent. Wherever they lay their hats, to quote a song, has been the case until now. No putting down roots for very different but understandable reasons. But what becomes clear is that putting down roots - together - is exactly what they need.
There's a brilliant cast of secondary characters in this book, and a really good storyline underpinning the slow simmer romance. The haunting Gothic overtones of the back stories are brilliant, and the Hall itself plays a very Manderlay-style role. I loved all the inversion of Du Maurier's Rebecca too. Thoroughly enjoyed this one.
July 17, 2021
As you can see from the blurb, the story resembles 'Jany Eyre' a lot, which is one reason that tempted me. Well, there is a bigger hurdle here since our hero is an Earl and heroine a common girl with no hidden inheritance to dream of. As they say, love conquers all and so it happens.
I loved Rebecca from the start. Her confidence in her own abilities is admirable and the same goes for that liberal attitude (a bit too liberal considering the time period). Will any virtuous female dare to have tattoos? Good for you girl!
The death in the castle and the mystery surrounding the vanished Earl contributes much to the gothic atmosphere. There are no ghosts but the creepy atmosphere haunts you throughout. Apart from that nail-biting climax which I found out of place, I found the story quite enjoyable. The slow-burn romance, the community that creates a world of its own inside this castle and the beautiful writing all makes it an endearing read.
I loved Rebecca from the start. Her confidence in her own abilities is admirable and the same goes for that liberal attitude (a bit too liberal considering the time period). Will any virtuous female dare to have tattoos? Good for you girl!
The death in the castle and the mystery surrounding the vanished Earl contributes much to the gothic atmosphere. There are no ghosts but the creepy atmosphere haunts you throughout. Apart from that nail-biting climax which I found out of place, I found the story quite enjoyable. The slow-burn romance, the community that creates a world of its own inside this castle and the beautiful writing all makes it an endearing read.
August 11, 2021
Sometimes, this weird algorithm that Google Playstore has, ends up in a success. I don't exactly remember what author/titles that I was looking for in Google Playstore when this title appeared on the search result. I was instantly intrigued with the "gripping gothic" description in the title, and I loved the cover. So I wishlist-ed it (it wasn't released back then) and the grabbed in on release-day. Only had a chance to read it now
Well, yes, I indeed enjoyed this one very much!!
Now, I admit that I don't read many gothic romance, so I don't exactly know what gothic romance should entail. The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall has a neglected estate, but no ghosts really appeared in form - more like a sorrow feel from the Earl that currently owns the house.
There's nothing really dark and sinister too, in my humble opinion. Sure, William "Liam" Reid, current Earl of Thornhallow, has been having nightmares from losing people he loved but that one is quickly chased away with Rebecca showing him kindness, without fear and judgment. Rebecca has a secret of her own, which comes later on as the threat of their happiness, but Rebecca shares that past of hers to Liam around halfway of the book, I think.
So I couldn't described this one as dark (if gothic does has dark element to it, I meant).
Nonetheless, I loved the progress of Liam and Rebecca falling in love. It was sweet and satisfying. I also loved the staffs of Thornhallow Hall that surrounded the two main characters. One of my favorite moments of this book was when the staffs, Rebecca, and Liam, celebrated the Twelfth Night, singing, dancing, drinking, and laughing. I loved that moment so much.
I didn't completely understand how the villain found Rebecca in Thornhallow Hall though. It's not like Liam announcing her to the world. But yeah, that's the only part that I wasn't completely satisfied for. Besides it pushed Liam to do the right thing by Rebecca in the end. So all's good.
In the end, this is a successful introduction to Lotte R. James. I look forward to the next book by her. I hope it's about Liam's friend, Spencer, whose short appearance in this book already made me want to read more about him
Well, yes, I indeed enjoyed this one very much!!
Now, I admit that I don't read many gothic romance, so I don't exactly know what gothic romance should entail. The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall has a neglected estate, but no ghosts really appeared in form - more like a sorrow feel from the Earl that currently owns the house.
There's nothing really dark and sinister too, in my humble opinion. Sure, William "Liam" Reid, current Earl of Thornhallow, has been having nightmares from losing people he loved but that one is quickly chased away with Rebecca showing him kindness, without fear and judgment. Rebecca has a secret of her own, which comes later on as the threat of their happiness, but Rebecca shares that past of hers to Liam around halfway of the book, I think.
So I couldn't described this one as dark (if gothic does has dark element to it, I meant).
Nonetheless, I loved the progress of Liam and Rebecca falling in love. It was sweet and satisfying. I also loved the staffs of Thornhallow Hall that surrounded the two main characters. One of my favorite moments of this book was when the staffs, Rebecca, and Liam, celebrated the Twelfth Night, singing, dancing, drinking, and laughing. I loved that moment so much.
I didn't completely understand how the villain found Rebecca in Thornhallow Hall though. It's not like Liam announcing her to the world. But yeah, that's the only part that I wasn't completely satisfied for. Besides it pushed Liam to do the right thing by Rebecca in the end. So all's good.
In the end, this is a successful introduction to Lotte R. James. I look forward to the next book by her. I hope it's about Liam's friend, Spencer, whose short appearance in this book already made me want to read more about him
July 19, 2021
I have read many historical romances and I have always enjoy them. This one was just as amazing. The novel has put in the subgenre Gothic Romance, and I haven't explored that subgenre much compared to others, it doesn't really matter. It was exciting, and it had the elements I love in historical romances.
In this story we follow Rebecca, the new housekeeper at Thornhallow Hall, and William, the earl and owner of the estate. I just loved them. I felt connected to them, I was curious about their lives, their past, and their dreams. And from the very beginning I wanted to know more about them. Memories, uncovering the background of Liam and Rebecca... It all grab my attention.
The circumstances that made them interact, fall in love... It made sense, it was exciting, it had a good pace and flow. Seeing them grow and open up, it helped with connecting with the characters, which is always a plus. With the housekeeper and earl roles, the romance was lovely and emotional. And since it was in a historical setting, it added the context of certain themes of the story and the characters' life.
Overall, I enjoyed the stor. I liked that there was some drama, romance, secrets and a dark past, it's just what I like in any book, specially in Historical Romances. The cultural and social elements that make the story unique and take us on this time-trip, is always an welcome read. It was fascinating.
[I want to thank Rachel, at Rachel’s Random Resources, and Lotte R. James for the eCopy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.]
In this story we follow Rebecca, the new housekeeper at Thornhallow Hall, and William, the earl and owner of the estate. I just loved them. I felt connected to them, I was curious about their lives, their past, and their dreams. And from the very beginning I wanted to know more about them. Memories, uncovering the background of Liam and Rebecca... It all grab my attention.
The circumstances that made them interact, fall in love... It made sense, it was exciting, it had a good pace and flow. Seeing them grow and open up, it helped with connecting with the characters, which is always a plus. With the housekeeper and earl roles, the romance was lovely and emotional. And since it was in a historical setting, it added the context of certain themes of the story and the characters' life.
Overall, I enjoyed the stor. I liked that there was some drama, romance, secrets and a dark past, it's just what I like in any book, specially in Historical Romances. The cultural and social elements that make the story unique and take us on this time-trip, is always an welcome read. It was fascinating.
[I want to thank Rachel, at Rachel’s Random Resources, and Lotte R. James for the eCopy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.]
July 21, 2021
Thornhallow Hall might be tarnished by tales of vengeance and ghosts, but to new housekeeper Miss Rebecca Merrickson aka Mrs Hardwicke it represents independence and peace from her tumultuous past. Until the estate’s owner, William Reid, the disappeared earl, unexpectedly returns after ten years away. After clashing with him over the changes she’s made to the house, Rebecca slowly unearths the memories that haunt brooding Liam.
A new author to me & I enjoyed this hauntingly well written book. The characters were well portrayed & had depth. The story flowed well, there were secrets that were gradually revealed. I liked both Liam & Rebecca who were both haunted by their pasts but I found the chemistry between them to be slightly lacking. That said they did complement each other & deserved their HEA.
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
A new author to me & I enjoyed this hauntingly well written book. The characters were well portrayed & had depth. The story flowed well, there were secrets that were gradually revealed. I liked both Liam & Rebecca who were both haunted by their pasts but I found the chemistry between them to be slightly lacking. That said they did complement each other & deserved their HEA.
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
October 31, 2021
Glad I bought this one and ended up choosing it for our Gothic TBR Challenge. More details in a future review at TheZestQuest.com and reposted here.
October 4, 2022
A super easy gothic romance for an autumn afternoon!
October 16, 2022
Fudging amazing!
Full review to follow.
Full review to follow.
July 22, 2021
I did enjoy this book, although the pace was a little slow at times, there was plenty of action in the latter part. The two main characters Rebecca and Liam were likeable. There was a mystery surrounding the Hall and why it was difficult to get staff. Rebecca, too, had a mystery as to why she kept changing her jobs. Rebecca is a hard working and strong woman. Liam, the earl, also had something in his background that he was reluctant to talk about. These are gradually revealed and I’m glad to say I didn’t have to wait until the end to find out these mysteries. Rebecca and Liam were attracted to each other but their stations in life were very different. There are some dangerous events and passionate moments. I will look to future books by this author. I received a copy and have voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and opinions are my own. I did preorder my own copy.
September 16, 2021
A surprising good find that is a delightful regency romance with some solid twists. I loved every moment of it and the Jane eyre vibes were for sure fun but not overbearing which is perfect in my opinion
November 1, 2024
This was way too long for what this was. I was hoping for a light, quick read, but unfortunately the author attempted to emulate actual Victorian novels in the writing style. The story dragged on until it finally reached an absolutely ridiculous ending.
Liam's character makes no real character progression in this book. He 1)hates Thornhallow because of his bad memories there and 2)doesn't want to be an Earl. His character progression over the course of the book is him making peace with his bad memories, and by proxy, Thornhallow. This is shown by Rebecca's restoration of the rooms, the climax of which is his sister's rooms. He begrudgingly accepts this before ultimately admitting she was right. It therefore doesn't make sense The other character progression isn't developed at all until the end
Another problem is the resolution of their relationship. He can't make her his Countess because it's too far even for him, and she wouldn't accept it, but he also can't give up being an Earl without just running away. We are told this multiple times throughout the book, and his friend even has an explosive confrontation with him about it, where he's forced to accept it. The resolution?
There was no conflict between the leads. Any conflict that might have happened was immediately diffused as Liam realized Rebecca was right and promptly agreed with her. He also had no problem with her promiscuity and tattoos, and accepted them both immediately, which was not only unrealistic, but also made for a dull resolution.
Liam's character makes no real character progression in this book. He 1)hates Thornhallow because of his bad memories there and 2)doesn't want to be an Earl. His character progression over the course of the book is him making peace with his bad memories, and by proxy, Thornhallow. This is shown by Rebecca's restoration of the rooms, the climax of which is his sister's rooms. He begrudgingly accepts this before ultimately admitting she was right. It therefore doesn't make sense The other character progression isn't developed at all until the end
Another problem is the resolution of their relationship. He can't make her his Countess because it's too far even for him, and she wouldn't accept it, but he also can't give up being an Earl without just running away. We are told this multiple times throughout the book, and his friend even has an explosive confrontation with him about it, where he's forced to accept it. The resolution?
There was no conflict between the leads. Any conflict that might have happened was immediately diffused as Liam realized Rebecca was right and promptly agreed with her. He also had no problem with her promiscuity and tattoos, and accepted them both immediately, which was not only unrealistic, but also made for a dull resolution.
August 4, 2021
This book had such good recommendations that I was really looking forward to reading it. Unfortunately, it just did not do it for me. The angst of the hero was overdone and the plot was too loose and meandering. I just did not care enough to read anymore after the 57% mark.
December 10, 2021
Lovely gothic romance with interesting characters and a fabulous Christmas 'upstairs/downstairs' vibe.
Read
July 16, 2021I read a lot of historical romance. I was interested in reading this book because of its focus on the housekeeper of a large house. I tend to enjoy historical romances that focus on ordinary people more than I enjoy always reading about the rich and famous.
I enjoyed the premise that Thornhallow Hall has set empty for ten years. The skeleton staff has been instructed to keep a few rooms ready as if the Earl may return any moment but not to touch the rest of the house. There has been a succession of housekeepers who don't stay long. Rebecca was the only applicant for this most recent vacancy. She decides that the remaining rooms need to be cleaned and tidied before the whole house falls down in disrepair. This does not go well with the Earl when he suddenly does return.
This book features a more Gothic vibe than I usually see in books that I read. To me Gothic books lean more towards tragedy and heightened (but yet repressed) emotion than towards the lighter, more comic, books that I tend towards.
This book fits that bill. Both of the main characters have secrets that they will not reveal. Both feel that they are not going to live normal lives because of their past. They recognize a bit of themselves in each other and are drawn together. Slowly they start to reveal parts of their lives that they've kept hidden from everyone else. There are high stakes problems in addition to their angst. If you enjoy romances with a Gothic feel, then this might be the book for you.
Lotte James trained as an actor and theatre director, but spent most of her life working day jobs crunching numbers whilst dreaming up stories of love and adventure. She’s thrilled to finally be writing those stories, and when she’s not scribbling on tiny pieces of paper, she can usually be found wandering the countryside for inspiration, or nestling with coffee and a book.
This review was originally posted on Based On A True Story
July 19, 2021
🏰 The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall 🏰
A gripping gothic debut
✒️ Lotte R. James
Release Date 07/22/2021 & 07/27/2021
Publisher Harlequin Historical / Mills&Boon Historical
➪ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08WK3Q2MQ/...
➪ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08WX7CBJL/...
𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯
She arrived as a housekeeper
Will she leave as a countess?
To some, Thornhallow Hall might be tarnished by tales of vengeance and ghosts, but to new housekeeper Rebecca Merrickson it represents independence and peace from her tumultuous past. Until the estate’s owner, William Reid, the disappeared earl, unexpectedly returns… After clashing with him over the changes she’s made to the house, Rebecca slowly unearths the memories that haunt brooding Liam—and her defiance gives way to a shockingly improper attraction to her master!
𝗠𝘆 𝗿𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄
When her past will come to call, which journey will she decide for …
This book offers a zest of Rebecca, fitting with the heroine’s first name, but also of Jane Eyre.
As the house seems to have its own persona, plus the isolated place, the very limited staff and the secrets surrounding the area.
And with the missing Tower key, I even imagined a secret like Blue Beard’s.
Rebecca is the lead element in this book, she is no meek demure woman, she might be running from something, she knows what she wants and what she does. I was a bit surprised about what she did hide behind her prim and proper demeanor, yet she is no lofty lady, so much less is expected from her in term of conduct and virtue. And I understand she wanted to be the one in control, to do with herself as she saw fit. But it is sure, for the era, it is a much modern view, especially for a woman.
She sees the house has an entity, her mission is to bring it back to its past splendor. And as she gets to know her new employer, to sooth his heart from his plight. She is one hell of a woman, never giving up, always bouncing back whatever life throws on her path. Why her momentary surrender astonished me, hopefully it was only a lapse.
William is no real conundrum, he ran far away from his birth place and now he is back it is to get rid of his title which is impossible outside death or treason. He is a man who each time lost everything while he was away, not his fault but he lives with the guilt.
Why when his feelings deepen for his one of a kind housekeeper, he refuses to let go of Rebecca, he will protect her, even against her will, his way to heal his past wound, redeem his soul.
My regret is that the dramatic event which led to William flight was never solved, when it could have been linked to Rebecca’s pursuer or explored.
With this debut novel, the author sets an intriguing tale filled with shadow and darkness but brightened by its heroine’s strength and will to control her fate.
4 stars
𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 onscreen lovemaking scene.
I have been granted an advance copy by the author and Rachel’s Random Ressources, here is my true and unbiased opinion.
https://www.facebook.com/429830134272...
A gripping gothic debut
✒️ Lotte R. James
Release Date 07/22/2021 & 07/27/2021
Publisher Harlequin Historical / Mills&Boon Historical
➪ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08WK3Q2MQ/...
➪ https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08WX7CBJL/...
𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯
She arrived as a housekeeper
Will she leave as a countess?
To some, Thornhallow Hall might be tarnished by tales of vengeance and ghosts, but to new housekeeper Rebecca Merrickson it represents independence and peace from her tumultuous past. Until the estate’s owner, William Reid, the disappeared earl, unexpectedly returns… After clashing with him over the changes she’s made to the house, Rebecca slowly unearths the memories that haunt brooding Liam—and her defiance gives way to a shockingly improper attraction to her master!
𝗠𝘆 𝗿𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄
When her past will come to call, which journey will she decide for …
This book offers a zest of Rebecca, fitting with the heroine’s first name, but also of Jane Eyre.
As the house seems to have its own persona, plus the isolated place, the very limited staff and the secrets surrounding the area.
And with the missing Tower key, I even imagined a secret like Blue Beard’s.
Rebecca is the lead element in this book, she is no meek demure woman, she might be running from something, she knows what she wants and what she does. I was a bit surprised about what she did hide behind her prim and proper demeanor, yet she is no lofty lady, so much less is expected from her in term of conduct and virtue. And I understand she wanted to be the one in control, to do with herself as she saw fit. But it is sure, for the era, it is a much modern view, especially for a woman.
She sees the house has an entity, her mission is to bring it back to its past splendor. And as she gets to know her new employer, to sooth his heart from his plight. She is one hell of a woman, never giving up, always bouncing back whatever life throws on her path. Why her momentary surrender astonished me, hopefully it was only a lapse.
William is no real conundrum, he ran far away from his birth place and now he is back it is to get rid of his title which is impossible outside death or treason. He is a man who each time lost everything while he was away, not his fault but he lives with the guilt.
Why when his feelings deepen for his one of a kind housekeeper, he refuses to let go of Rebecca, he will protect her, even against her will, his way to heal his past wound, redeem his soul.
My regret is that the dramatic event which led to William flight was never solved, when it could have been linked to Rebecca’s pursuer or explored.
With this debut novel, the author sets an intriguing tale filled with shadow and darkness but brightened by its heroine’s strength and will to control her fate.
4 stars
𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 onscreen lovemaking scene.
I have been granted an advance copy by the author and Rachel’s Random Ressources, here is my true and unbiased opinion.
https://www.facebook.com/429830134272...
July 22, 2021
This is a captivating tale full of secrets and teaming with hints of Jane Eyre including a brooding Lord and a defiant and determined young housekeeper.
Rebecca has been running for fifteen years and she finally has found a job as a housekeeper where she has the independence and autonomy to make a difference. With her unorthodox ways and friendly manner, she eventually wins over the small contingent of servants, and since the Disappeared Earl has not set foot in the manor for a decade, she takes the liberty of cleaning more of the large manor than ordered thinking it is such a travesty to let it fall into ruin. Until the glowering Earl suddenly returns and tempers flair along with an unprofessional attraction.
Liam has stayed away from his home for long enough and plans to face his demons and give up his Earldom. There are too many bad memories to keep him here. Yet, the young and vibrant housekeeper has brought his home to life and has forced him to fight his demons while beguiling him all at the same time.
I love the slow build of Rebecca and Liam's attraction. Rebecca's strength and professionalism are admirable. Though she has been pursued by an evil person for most of her life, she is courageous and determined to make her life work wherever she is. But her inappropriate behavior with Liam cannot continue and her determination to maintain her professional obligations as the housekeeper is commendable. Liam falls for Rebecca's courage and strength as they battle wits and reveal their secrets. As he realizes, what all he will lose if he goes back to the old ways, he makes an important decision that is unheard of for a person of his stature. In addition, there is some nail-biting suspense towards the end when Rebecca's past almost gets them all killed. The honesty between Rebecca and Liam is what makes their relationship so remarkable and what kept me rooting for a HEA against all odds.
The supporting characters are mainly the other servants at the Hall who become Rebecca and Liam's only family. The steadfast butler, Mr. Brown, is my favorite with his austere outward appearance and kind heart.
I recommend this historical romance for those who adore gothic nuances, long-buried secrets, and a forbidden romance that will stand against time.
Thank you to Ms. James for giving me the opportunity to read this book with no expectation of a positive review.
Rebecca has been running for fifteen years and she finally has found a job as a housekeeper where she has the independence and autonomy to make a difference. With her unorthodox ways and friendly manner, she eventually wins over the small contingent of servants, and since the Disappeared Earl has not set foot in the manor for a decade, she takes the liberty of cleaning more of the large manor than ordered thinking it is such a travesty to let it fall into ruin. Until the glowering Earl suddenly returns and tempers flair along with an unprofessional attraction.
Liam has stayed away from his home for long enough and plans to face his demons and give up his Earldom. There are too many bad memories to keep him here. Yet, the young and vibrant housekeeper has brought his home to life and has forced him to fight his demons while beguiling him all at the same time.
I love the slow build of Rebecca and Liam's attraction. Rebecca's strength and professionalism are admirable. Though she has been pursued by an evil person for most of her life, she is courageous and determined to make her life work wherever she is. But her inappropriate behavior with Liam cannot continue and her determination to maintain her professional obligations as the housekeeper is commendable. Liam falls for Rebecca's courage and strength as they battle wits and reveal their secrets. As he realizes, what all he will lose if he goes back to the old ways, he makes an important decision that is unheard of for a person of his stature. In addition, there is some nail-biting suspense towards the end when Rebecca's past almost gets them all killed. The honesty between Rebecca and Liam is what makes their relationship so remarkable and what kept me rooting for a HEA against all odds.
The supporting characters are mainly the other servants at the Hall who become Rebecca and Liam's only family. The steadfast butler, Mr. Brown, is my favorite with his austere outward appearance and kind heart.
I recommend this historical romance for those who adore gothic nuances, long-buried secrets, and a forbidden romance that will stand against time.
Thank you to Ms. James for giving me the opportunity to read this book with no expectation of a positive review.
August 18, 2021
The first part of this book is great. Although it is presented as some sort of gothic romance, there's really nothing gothic about it. Maybe a hint of suspense, some talk about ghosts and a partially haunted house (which never really never materialises in any way) and a bit of a tortuous romance.
The second part of the book disappointed me a bit. First, the way Rebecca describes her past life, in particular her experiences with men, didn't match the idea I had of her from the beginning - an honestly, at the time and place of the book I doubt a woman would discuss those things freely, particularly with someone in Liam's position. And second, the way Rebecca is persecuted by a man from her past makes little sense and, while it's important for the plot to unfold the way it does, it just lengthens and confuses the story a bit too much.
Overall, and despite the above, The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall is an interesting book, a lovely romance (even if not entirely original) and if you like the genre, you should give it a try.
The second part of the book disappointed me a bit. First, the way Rebecca describes her past life, in particular her experiences with men, didn't match the idea I had of her from the beginning - an honestly, at the time and place of the book I doubt a woman would discuss those things freely, particularly with someone in Liam's position. And second, the way Rebecca is persecuted by a man from her past makes little sense and, while it's important for the plot to unfold the way it does, it just lengthens and confuses the story a bit too much.
Overall, and despite the above, The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall is an interesting book, a lovely romance (even if not entirely original) and if you like the genre, you should give it a try.
July 20, 2021
The characters in this Gothic style historical romance are easy to empathise with. Rebecca is clever, independent and kind, and her introspective reflections are humorous and insightful. William is a credible anti-hero, but as Rebecca gets to know him, she discovers his guilt and emotional pain.
Their relationship is reminiscent of The Beauty and Beast fairytale in parts and is full of emotion, poignancy and romance. Whilst the gothic element is present, this could have been more developed earlier in the story.
This is an engaging historical romance. The main protagonists deserve to find happiness with each other.
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher in return for an honest review.
Their relationship is reminiscent of The Beauty and Beast fairytale in parts and is full of emotion, poignancy and romance. Whilst the gothic element is present, this could have been more developed earlier in the story.
This is an engaging historical romance. The main protagonists deserve to find happiness with each other.
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher in return for an honest review.
July 27, 2021
Rebecca arrives at Thornhallow Hall as the new housekeeper for the property. She’s young and doesn’t quite have the respect of the rest of the staff who’ve been there for years, some for decades. But she’s determined to change their hearts after they’ve gone through twenty-one housekeepers in the last ten years.
No one knows what happened to the Earl for the last decade. He seemed to vanish after his family all but slowly passed away for whatever reason and he has not returned. The orders have been to keep a handful of rooms ready for the master’s return. Rebecca has other ideas though, insisting that the house is sad and will fall apart if not taken care of. She takes it into her own hands to bring the rest of the home back into livable conditions after years of neglect.
It’s when Liam suddenly returns to Thornhallow Hall that he noticed that his new housekeeper has been disobeying his orders. Yet he refuses to let her go. She was the only person to apply for the position so finding a replacement would be a tiresome affair. Plus, Liam seems to have found attraction to this woman and she with him, even though they attempt to hide it.
It seems pretty obvious that eventually Rebecca and Liam would find a way to come together. I did not expect some of the events that happened once the Earl began having unexpected visitors. I find it amazing how authors can stretch my imagination so far before springing it back to events that I had not foreseen!
Thank you to Harlequin and Rachel’s Random Resources for access to this amazing title! I give this book 5 out of 5 tiaras because of the angst and attraction found between the covers. I hope Liam decides to tell his staff that they’re like family and connie to treat them as such.
No one knows what happened to the Earl for the last decade. He seemed to vanish after his family all but slowly passed away for whatever reason and he has not returned. The orders have been to keep a handful of rooms ready for the master’s return. Rebecca has other ideas though, insisting that the house is sad and will fall apart if not taken care of. She takes it into her own hands to bring the rest of the home back into livable conditions after years of neglect.
It’s when Liam suddenly returns to Thornhallow Hall that he noticed that his new housekeeper has been disobeying his orders. Yet he refuses to let her go. She was the only person to apply for the position so finding a replacement would be a tiresome affair. Plus, Liam seems to have found attraction to this woman and she with him, even though they attempt to hide it.
It seems pretty obvious that eventually Rebecca and Liam would find a way to come together. I did not expect some of the events that happened once the Earl began having unexpected visitors. I find it amazing how authors can stretch my imagination so far before springing it back to events that I had not foreseen!
Thank you to Harlequin and Rachel’s Random Resources for access to this amazing title! I give this book 5 out of 5 tiaras because of the angst and attraction found between the covers. I hope Liam decides to tell his staff that they’re like family and connie to treat them as such.
July 24, 2021
The Housekeeper of Thornhallow Hall by Lotte R. James is an intriguing historical romance that kept me invested from beginning to end. I’m a relatively new consumer of historical fiction, and this is the kind of book I’ve grown to love.
This book has a more Gothic feel to it, which I rather enjoyed. It is much more along the lines of my preferences. I enjoyed the secrets of the characters and how their pasts tie in.
Great writing, interesting characters, and a good plot. I’d recommend this for historical romance fans.
Thank you to Rachel’s Random Resources for the review copy and the opportunity to honestly review this book on the blog tour. All opinions are my own and unbiased.
This book has a more Gothic feel to it, which I rather enjoyed. It is much more along the lines of my preferences. I enjoyed the secrets of the characters and how their pasts tie in.
Great writing, interesting characters, and a good plot. I’d recommend this for historical romance fans.
Thank you to Rachel’s Random Resources for the review copy and the opportunity to honestly review this book on the blog tour. All opinions are my own and unbiased.
did-not-finish
November 12, 2021DNFing this one about 70 pages in. Even for a Harlequin, the writing in this one is pretty poor and feels like it never went through an editing process. The basic premise is kind of nonsensical to begin with, and the characters are all so flat. I went to pick it up this evening, and was just like…nah.
Oh and the way the people in the house kept referring to the absent earl as "the master" just kept making me picture The Brave Little Toaster, which was nice because that movie is the fucking bomb, but also a very strange juxtaposition with a wannabe gothic historical romance.
Oh and the way the people in the house kept referring to the absent earl as "the master" just kept making me picture The Brave Little Toaster, which was nice because that movie is the fucking bomb, but also a very strange juxtaposition with a wannabe gothic historical romance.
June 14, 2023
I don't know if I've just been reading too many romances lately or what, but this book just isn't doing it for me. I wish I could buy into the gothic vibes this book is going for, because I love gothic stories, but unfortunately I could not forget that this was also a Harlequin novel, so...it kind of felt like I was reading two separate books in terms of the atmosphere the author was trying to create.
July 29, 2021
Rating: 4 stars
What I Liked: I enjoyed this. The writing is nice and easy to read, with some good descriptions. The horror elements of this were atmospheric and suitably creepy and added an edge to the romance that I enjoyed.
I really liked the main character, Rebecca. I enjoyed her determination and the confidence she showed throughout. There were also some details about her character that were unusual for a historical novel, but I really appreciated them, such as
I did find Liam a little bit harder to like, but I warmed to him more as the story went on. Their relationship was good. Their dynamic was interesting and I liked that he . I particularly liked the part where he rescued her from the snow storm:
I also liked that she came to view
The plotting worked well for me - I really liked that I also appreciated the part where Another plot detail that I thought was great was that
What I Didn’t: The only complaint I really had is that I would have liked more of the horror element.
Overall: I’m not usually a fan of gothic romance, and I’ve been struggling recently to get into historical romance in general. But this was great, I got into it really easily and I enjoyed it a lot. It was just a very solid read, with some good writing, interesting characters, and new takes on certain concepts. It did a lot of things that I’ve seen very rarely in a historical romance, such as , but also in how Rebecca was unconventional. Historical romance is filled with unconventional but wealthy heroines, who either scandalously take lovers or attend gambling hells, or engage in typically male pursuits such as science and education. I don’t think I’ve ever read one where the heroine is of servant class but is unconventional in her own way, and I really liked that about this. Some people might see it as unrealistic, but there’s no doubt to me that somewhere in history a woman like Rebecca did exist, and I liked that.
Would I Recommend It?: Yes, if you want a well-written, atmospheric gothic historical romance with an interesting, somewhat unconventional heroine.
Would I Read Something By The Author Again?: Yes.
Content Notes:
What I Liked: I enjoyed this. The writing is nice and easy to read, with some good descriptions. The horror elements of this were atmospheric and suitably creepy and added an edge to the romance that I enjoyed.
I really liked the main character, Rebecca. I enjoyed her determination and the confidence she showed throughout. There were also some details about her character that were unusual for a historical novel, but I really appreciated them, such as
I did find Liam a little bit harder to like, but I warmed to him more as the story went on. Their relationship was good. Their dynamic was interesting and I liked that he . I particularly liked the part where he rescued her from the snow storm:
I also liked that she came to view
The plotting worked well for me - I really liked that I also appreciated the part where Another plot detail that I thought was great was that
What I Didn’t: The only complaint I really had is that I would have liked more of the horror element.
Overall: I’m not usually a fan of gothic romance, and I’ve been struggling recently to get into historical romance in general. But this was great, I got into it really easily and I enjoyed it a lot. It was just a very solid read, with some good writing, interesting characters, and new takes on certain concepts. It did a lot of things that I’ve seen very rarely in a historical romance, such as , but also in how Rebecca was unconventional. Historical romance is filled with unconventional but wealthy heroines, who either scandalously take lovers or attend gambling hells, or engage in typically male pursuits such as science and education. I don’t think I’ve ever read one where the heroine is of servant class but is unconventional in her own way, and I really liked that about this. Some people might see it as unrealistic, but there’s no doubt to me that somewhere in history a woman like Rebecca did exist, and I liked that.
Would I Recommend It?: Yes, if you want a well-written, atmospheric gothic historical romance with an interesting, somewhat unconventional heroine.
Would I Read Something By The Author Again?: Yes.
Content Notes:
August 1, 2021
Great book. First time reading Lotte's books. I love Gothic books and this one was wonderful.
September 12, 2021
A stubborn new housekeeper and a haunted owner…
Rebecca Merrickson is ready to start to work as a housekeeper at Thornhallow Hall. She is determined to gain the respect of the other servants, while at the same time making changes to the house. Of course making changes is easy when the estate’s owner William Reid isn’t nearby, in fact he has just disappeared! But when Liam returns, he is not happy at all with the made changes, and more than once he clashes with Rebecca. However, Rebecca uncovers the secrets and ghosts haunting Thornhallow Hall and its master, while she is keeping her own secrets and fighting the attraction she begin to feel.
When I was reading the first chapters of this book, I was reminded of one of my favourite books ever, namely Jane Eyre. There were many similarities, like a young woman going to work in a place with a dark secret, the master being initially an absent character, but also with a past that still haunts him. But luckily this story takes another turn. Not that changing direction was a bad choice, on the contrary, because if you have to read a rip – off of a beloved book, it’s certain that you will be disappointed in the end. And I surely wasn’t when I reached the end!
Often in historical romances, there is one character with a secret, but in this romance, both main characters are having their own secrets. Rebecca her secret has made her being on the run for a long time, and she is still looking over her shoulder being afraid that her whereabouts have been discovered. But no matter what happened in her past, and her fear, she is determined to make the best of the time she is staying at Thornhallow Hall. She is also a strong character, ready to take responsibility for her actions, and slowly she is also having the respect of the other servants. When we get to know her secret, and how it changed her, I felt truly sorry for her. At a young age she realized that not everyone is acting with good intentions and that people work with ulterior motives. There are many moments she clashes with Liam, which of course is inevitable as Liam is not ready for all the changes Rebecca made, despite his clear instructions. Liam is a brooding man, carrying his guilt around like a dark cloak. Thornhallow Hall holds too many sad memories for him, and he is looking for a way to escape his title as an Earl. But he is also a caring man, the way he acts towards his servants, seeing them as real people and not just as ‘things’ he can bend at his will. And the way he starts to see Rebecca in a different light shows the readers that there is always more than meets the eye…
I found this a beautiful story about scarred and also scared characters, but also strong characters. The author wrote a story that somehow would look like thirteen in a dozen, but she managed to add her own things, making this a unique story. Not only the characters but also the twists in the story made me keep reading it, making me feel like I was walking around Thornhallow Hall myself!
Rebecca Merrickson is ready to start to work as a housekeeper at Thornhallow Hall. She is determined to gain the respect of the other servants, while at the same time making changes to the house. Of course making changes is easy when the estate’s owner William Reid isn’t nearby, in fact he has just disappeared! But when Liam returns, he is not happy at all with the made changes, and more than once he clashes with Rebecca. However, Rebecca uncovers the secrets and ghosts haunting Thornhallow Hall and its master, while she is keeping her own secrets and fighting the attraction she begin to feel.
When I was reading the first chapters of this book, I was reminded of one of my favourite books ever, namely Jane Eyre. There were many similarities, like a young woman going to work in a place with a dark secret, the master being initially an absent character, but also with a past that still haunts him. But luckily this story takes another turn. Not that changing direction was a bad choice, on the contrary, because if you have to read a rip – off of a beloved book, it’s certain that you will be disappointed in the end. And I surely wasn’t when I reached the end!
Often in historical romances, there is one character with a secret, but in this romance, both main characters are having their own secrets. Rebecca her secret has made her being on the run for a long time, and she is still looking over her shoulder being afraid that her whereabouts have been discovered. But no matter what happened in her past, and her fear, she is determined to make the best of the time she is staying at Thornhallow Hall. She is also a strong character, ready to take responsibility for her actions, and slowly she is also having the respect of the other servants. When we get to know her secret, and how it changed her, I felt truly sorry for her. At a young age she realized that not everyone is acting with good intentions and that people work with ulterior motives. There are many moments she clashes with Liam, which of course is inevitable as Liam is not ready for all the changes Rebecca made, despite his clear instructions. Liam is a brooding man, carrying his guilt around like a dark cloak. Thornhallow Hall holds too many sad memories for him, and he is looking for a way to escape his title as an Earl. But he is also a caring man, the way he acts towards his servants, seeing them as real people and not just as ‘things’ he can bend at his will. And the way he starts to see Rebecca in a different light shows the readers that there is always more than meets the eye…
I found this a beautiful story about scarred and also scared characters, but also strong characters. The author wrote a story that somehow would look like thirteen in a dozen, but she managed to add her own things, making this a unique story. Not only the characters but also the twists in the story made me keep reading it, making me feel like I was walking around Thornhallow Hall myself!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 31 reviews