Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Morelli Family #4

Seduced by a Sinner

Rate this book
He’s innocent. He’s chaste. He’s promised to God.
And he’s more temptation than I can handle.


I’m supposed to guard the Boss's husband, but I just can’t keep my eyes off his best friend, Aidan O’Leary.

Watching him.

Wanting him.

Knowing I can never have him.

Aidan is pure in body and soul. He’s about to be ordained as a priest. Me? I’m going to burn for the things I’ve done. And I can’t stop thinking about all the sinful things I want to do to him.

But when there’s an attack on Aidan’s life, I’m reassigned to protect him, and we grow closer than ever.

Someone wants Aidan dead. It’s my job to deliver him safely to the Church to take his vows, although I’d rather have him as my own.

I’ve sworn to protect him until I can give him away to God. But it's getting harder and harder to let him go without a fight.

And if I can’t focus on the job, how can I keep Aidan safe when our enemies are closing in?

***

Seduced by a Sinner is best enjoyed as part of the Morelli Family mafia romance series. Characters and events from previous books are referenced.

374 pages, Kindle Edition

First published March 25, 2021

179 people are currently reading
391 people want to read

About the author

Leighton Greene

40 books365 followers
Leighton Greene has been writing stories since she was old enough to hold a pencil. Her first book was a choose-your-own-adventure style book about deciding what to eat for breakfast. It didn't shake the New York Times bestseller list, but she still has a copy of it.

After spending some time writing in academia, fanfiction and corporate reporting, Leighton decided she should probably do what she actually wanted to do, which was to write commercial fiction. So she did. She writes gay romance and, when the mood strikes, erotica as L.J. Greene.

Leighton lives with her partner and her cockatiel on the east coast of Australia.

(Source: Amazon.com)

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
443 (51%)
4 stars
293 (33%)
3 stars
102 (11%)
2 stars
21 (2%)
1 star
5 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 119 reviews
Profile Image for ♡ cal ♡.
758 reviews340 followers
March 29, 2021
This was really done well but not as great as the first three. A part of me enjoyed Aidan and another part of me wish he wasn’t the main character. Luca and Baxter in the previous books fought so hard for their romance to work but Aidan played it somehow safe until the end. Annnnddd I think I misled myself because I thought this is going be a seductive novel when in reality it wasn’t?
Profile Image for Jessica.
507 reviews
September 25, 2025
5* FINALLY! 🙌🏻

After one 3* and a string of 4* reads in this series, I have finally hit the 5* jackpot! Aiden and Teo have done it. Bravo boys, your priest (in-training)/bodyguard romance did the trick! 👏🏻

I'm a sucker for a good priest book, but sadly, the last couple I've read missed the mark. It's a tricky one to get right, so I was more than pleased the moment I knew this was shaping up to be exactly the perfect vibe for me. The pacing was good, the plot kept me entertained, and the romance was on point 💙

Even though Aiden was the innocent one in every sense, he had a soft wildness about him that I found endearing. Then there was Teo who was in no way innocent, from the bedroom to his mafia work, who had a gentleness about him that was incredibly lovable. The two men couldn't have been any different and shouldn't have worked, but there was a magnetism between them that they couldn't fight. Their chemistry was off the charts, and their first time is quite possibly one of my all-time favorites 😌

Kudos to Leighton Greene not only for the great story, but also for choosing Michael Ferraiuolo to narrate it. He was the perfect choice for this series. His ability to voice a wide range of distinct characters is unmatched in my book, and he nailed it here. The way he captured Teo's New York mobster accent and the way he said "baby" was sheer perfection 🤌🏻
Profile Image for Renae Reads.
760 reviews745 followers
March 27, 2021
*** I received an eArc from the author in exchange for an honest review.***

I enjoyed how this installment tackled difficult subject matters such as religious values and their relationship with your own personal core values/truths.

This was another great addition to the Morelli Family series that expands upon characters already introduced while offering new insights that promote exciting personal developments.

I loved how personal this story was in regards to the Priest/Aidan and his bodyguard/Teo, their feelings toward one another were clearly displayed and were so sweet to see. Their relationship was completely natural and you could really feel their connection.

This was another fantastic installment and I cannot wait for the next.
Profile Image for Nelly S..
673 reviews166 followers
January 15, 2023
3.75 stars

”My Boss’s husband’s best friend, a man of the cloth, my new ward of protection—there was nothing about him that wasn’t forbidden, but that just made it all the sweeter.”

This continues to be an entertaining series. I’ve got a weakness for mob romances and this being a forbidden one between a Mafia bodyguard and a soon-to-be ordained priest just hit a lot of spots for me.

Aidan is conflicted about his faith and long-held belief that he’s called to serve God, and his burgeoning attraction for Teo. Teo thinks he’s unworthy because of all the blood he has on his hands, but he’s a really sweet, protective and loyal guy. Aidan’s ordination is only a week away and he regrets the fact that he’s never even kissed a guy. As a mysterious threat to his life emerges and Teo is called upon to protect him, they’re thrown into close proximity and the ground is set for an intense whirlwind romance to develop. The sexy times are hot and sweet as we experience everything from Aidan’s perspective for the first time.
Profile Image for Andi.
Author 15 books250 followers
July 29, 2021
Every book in this series continues the saga of the Morelli family.

Since book one, I've been intrigued by Aiden. As a man who is to be soon ordained as a priest, his gentleness and selflessness was something I really liked about him. As a priest/not priest he has become Finch's best friend, and though he is conflicted by what it means to call a mafia Boss's husband his BFF, he genuinely loved the Morelli family and the community he serves.

Teo was just as honorable as Aiden, but obviously in a different way. As one of the main bodyguards, Two is steadily claiming up the ladder by working hard and earning his trust with Luca and Finch. He's smart, thinks on his feet and takes care of his many brothers and sisters.

I liked that these men are complex characters. Being thrown together in many dangerous situations, they develop a friendship and trust between them. They know their affection is forbidden, but through friendship, love and trust they develop into a sweet and loving couple.

I loved them. Their love is sweet without the overabundance of it being too sugary. I liked that Aiden is a gentle, pure hero and in some ways, Teo is too. I enjoyed their story but wish there had been more of their lives growing together. I wanted a scene where Aiden meets Teo's family. I wanted more of them blending together instead of feeling like it was glossed over.

That is why it isn't a five star read for me.

I still loved it, but it is a 4.5 star read. I rounded it up because it IS worth more than four and because I love all of these characters so much. 😉
Profile Image for CrabbyPatty.
1,712 reviews194 followers
April 23, 2022
This fourth book in the Morelli Family continues the saga and focuses on Adrian, the soon-to-be-priest and Teo Vitali, one of Finch's bodyguards. I especially dislike how in this particular book Finch is depicted as an entitled, arrogant diva (okay, more so than he is in earlier books, but in this one he seems to have no self-awareness that he is being a brat).

I don't know if I entirely buy the romance between Teo and Adrian, but any dark mafia M/M romance that quotes Kierkegaard is okay in my book. 3.5 stars.
Profile Image for Saimi Vasquez.
1,952 reviews94 followers
April 18, 2025
Adrian va a tomar por fin sus votos como cura católico, en menos de una semana, pero se encuentra con amenazas de muerte dirigidas hacia él sin una razón aparente. Así que se encuentra con que tiene un guardaespaldas de los Morelli asignado que lo sigue a todas partes, e inclusive se encuentra viajando a Boston y quedándose, rodeado de seguridad, dentro de la mansión de los Donovan. Pero lo peor no es eso, es que ahora se siente con dudas sobre tomar sus votos, ahora que siente la atracción por su guardaespaldas (Mateo). Pero será capaz de dejar su vocación de lado para estar con él? Será capaz de no caer en la tentación de perder su "pureza"? Dios realmente querrá que se convierta en cura?

Este libro fue extremadamente aburrido, lento, con una gran cantidad de drama que no venía al caso, y un desarrollo de los personajes de lo mas monótona. Realmente lo termine de leer, mas por la trama general de la serie, por saber cual es el próximo problema al que deben enfrentarse la familia Morelli, que por la pareja protagonista.
En fin, creo que voy a dejar esta serie hasta aquí por ahora, y mas adelante, cuando descanse un poco del universo, vuelvo a retomarla a ver como va a seguir la "guerra" entre los Morelli y los Irlandeses.
Profile Image for Ronie Reads.
1,554 reviews29 followers
March 27, 2025
The ebook was so fun...then the audiobook was released. Enjoyed this read a second time
Profile Image for Caia.
333 reviews11 followers
January 17, 2025
adventurous dark emotional tense medium-paced
Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
4.5

re-read/first time audiobook listen
I started bingeing the whole Morelli Family series (and the spin-off) last January
So I’m uber ecxited that I was able to listen to Seduced by a Sinner on audio.
Aiden and Teo were a match made in heaven (pun intended)
I loved the ‘teach me/show me’ sexual interactions between them and how thoughtful Teo was with Aiden.
Aiden’s inner turmoil and conversations with side characters about his thoughts and feelings really added to his character growth.
Teo had a lot to work out with himself.

While this story could probably be read without having the first three books, I would highly recommend to listen to them all, since the overlapping plot is super interesting and got me on my toes all the time!
I really love how well written and developed all the side characters were as well.

Michael Ferraioulu is a narrator with a huge range of accents and voices in general, that it was a delight. I’m always amazed if an audiobook has distinct voices and I can follow way easier if it’s like that.
Profile Image for Simona.
679 reviews62 followers
March 1, 2022
Liked it but the last one was better.
Jumping on the next one though ;)
Profile Image for lauraღ.
2,343 reviews171 followers
April 15, 2025
The words of Saint John the Evangelist came to me: Love is of God; everyone who loves is begotten by God and knows God.

REREAD 2025. 4.5 stars. I enjoyed this just as much as I did the first time! When I saw that this mafia series was getting audiobooks, I was so excited. This was my absolute favourite in the series, so I just skipped straight to it. Teo and Aidan have my whole heart, ugh. I'm such a sucker for forbidden romance like this, especially with a hint of the taboo, what with Aidan being a priest in training. Add in the bodyguard element, and I'm the happiest camper. So many lines struck me as swoony and romantic, and even though this takes place in such a short period of time, the author knocked it out of the park with their chemistry. Guh, I just loved this. I kinda wish Tara had more of a storyline, and I wish that the romance had been more slow burn, but this was still deeply compelling to me. It was a little ansgty, but not too much, and all the angst was balanced perfectly with the sexiness and heart.

Listened to the audiobook as read by Michael Ferraiuolo and I really enjoyed it. I'm obviously no expert, but I thought all the different accents were excellent and authentic. And every time Teo called Aidan 'baby' I wanted to absolutely melt. I don't know if I'll reread the rest of the series (I might go back to read Angelo and Bax's romance) but this has definitely motivated me to continue reading the spin-off series.

--

“You’re close to God,” he said softly. “And I’m the worst kind of sinner.”

4.5 stars. A near-perfect amalgamation of some pretty bullet proof themes and romance tropes for me: forbidden romance, opposites attract, bodyguarding. These are characters that we've seen on and off throughout the series, and I've always really liked Aidan, and Teo has been an interesting character. To have an almost-priest (he's weeks away from taking his vows) and a mafia bodyguard fall in love is a tall order, but the author absolutely sold me on it.

This follows loosely with the overarching plot of the series, though it takes a while to really see where and how everything ties in. It wasn't what I was interested in, and I won't say the whole Boston plotline did a heck of a lot for me. But Teo and Aidan were gold from page one. In a lot of ways it's a kind of pairing that's been done many times before: a pure, innocent believer who's trying to do good in the world, and a jaded, hardened semi-believer who thinks he's beyond redemption. But Teo was always really soft and gentle and attentive, never overbearing or obnoxious, and while Aidan's faith and his upcoming vows were obviously a barrier to the relationship, they were both really understanding and communicative about it, and it didn't present a problem in the way I thought it would. Aidan also has a lot of misgivings about Teo's job and his path in life, being a made man in the mafia, and it made for really good tension and angst. But honestly not that much angst. I think I would have loved this even more if it had been a super slow burn with less sex, and it had taken them ages to act on their feelings and desires. That wasn't how it played out, but the author wrote their chemistry so convincingly that I still loved it, quick as it was. There's a good amount of lightness, and also soooo much bodyguarding-induced forced proximity, it's great. And the innate taboo-ness of the relationship made a great backdrop for all the other action and stuff. At the core of it, they just made me feel so soft. ;; I'm a sucker for a good term of endearment, and Teo's for Aidan was simple but so... ;;

So I continue to enjoy this series way more than I expected to at the outset! Will definitely pick it up again, some time soonish. 

“Thank you for coming back. I prayed for help and—there you were.”
Profile Image for ML.
1,602 reviews1 follower
September 18, 2021
When opposites attract!

Teo and Aiden are a VERY unlikely pair.

This was a very entertaining read. I really love all the layers of this series. We met Aiden the priest in training a few books back. He became BFFs with Finch. This puts him into Teo’s orbit. Teo is Finch’s bodyguard and a made man. The more Teo and Aiden spend together the closer they get. Their chemistry was very hot.

Aiden is in serious danger and Teo is tasked with his protection. Serious sexiness ensues.

I wasn’t sure how this would end but it does end very sweet and now I want to read the next book immediately! This series is so good.
I highly recommend it!
Profile Image for &#x1f989;Maggie Whitworth.
3,254 reviews113 followers
April 30, 2021
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
💋💋💋

Action packed, passionate,wildly romantic and steamy too.
Mafia tension and priestly goings on.
What’s not to like.
Love it 😍
Profile Image for Szidi ☼.
946 reviews61 followers
April 8, 2021
"The idea of my marks on Aiden's neck under a priest collar was weirdly sexy."

Holy Aidan! I mean, Saint Aidan. Aww, I've waited for this book so hard and it's finally here. I love Aidan's character so much and I'm so happy that he got his own HEA!

Priest love story, ermm sorry, not priest, not yet. Or should I say Priest-Boy as Finch calls him? ;)

"I was hiding for my life in a crapy motel with a New York mobster just days away from my ordination, and I'd never been happier than I was right then."

This story was everything you want from a virgin and gay soon-to-be-priest who falls in love with the mob boss' husband's bodyguard. Ahh, Teo! Loved these two together. Teo was so caring and so adorable when it came to Aidan. They were perfect together and I loved how Aidan was thinking, he wasn't crazy, he knew what he wanted and what he needed to do. That's a whole other question that after recognizing how many things he missed, he questions everything. Really loved how he was all the time about God, and the best, he didn't felt bad after doing those things with Teo.

"Teo took orders from Don Morelli like I took orders from God."

The mobster things were exctiting too, and I love the author for those too. It wasn't a simply and easy love story, it still got many dark elements, and loved when Finch and Luca was there, just awww. They are still my favorite couple ever and I love when they're on the pages. Luca is still the sweetest when it comes to Finch, and Finch is still that crazy lovely person who he was all the time - loved when he called Aiden his BFF. So cute these two.

My favorite scenes were when Teo and Aiden got into bed together. All the damn time. The book has many erotic scenes and I'm so happy about it! I was afraid we'd got only one or two, but wow, they were all so hot! Aiden and all his first time, ahh, just perfect! And loved him at the end. "Would you like to fist me later?" HOLYMOLY! I laughed way to hard! Yeah, that's the line all the priests says... hahahahahahaa.

Loved reading it and can't wait for the next book! This series is everything!♥
Profile Image for R.
2,113 reviews
April 1, 2021
Aiden, while not a saint, is certainly saintly. The soon to be priest had always known he was meant to serve God. His faith unshakable even with his past actions. Then when his life is threatened he gets Teo as a bodyguard. A gorgeous, kind, slightly scary bodyguard.

Lots of action kept the story going while the romance made it touching. I was surprised at how romantic I felt their story was. While not strictly forbidden, the relationship skirted the line between layman and priest.

Lovely main characters and the hint of trust issues between the families kept my interest. I liked the vulnerability between Aiden and Teo. Their faith and acceptance of each other is exactly what I look for in a good romance.

I haven’t read the other books in the series but I didn’t feel lost.

I received an arc of this book.
Profile Image for J.P. Bowie.
Author 136 books232 followers
April 2, 2021
Title should be Seduction of a Sinner because pure and innocent Aiden totally hooked Teo with his naivety - and so he should. Both men were great and the plot - if you can suspend your disbelief for most of it - was fun and well written. I mean, who wouldn't want a bodyguard like Teo?
Profile Image for Bianca.
417 reviews
January 4, 2024
4.75 stars 🌟

This has got to be my favorite out of the entire series?? (at least so far). There’s lots of religious references which is to be expected considering the fact that Aidan was set to be ordained as a priest but I find that, that just helped shaped the entire thing. Teo and Aiden’s love for each other was so pure and selfless. I’m not even going to lie to you I was crying by the end of it 😭 I just want a love like Matteo’s!!! It especially hit when he was describing the beauty of the sunrise and how he couldn’t possibly compete with what God has to offer and how he wouldn’t even want to. I wasn’t expecting it to turn out like this but I find their story really beautiful 🥹

Aidan was also a nice reprieve from Finch lol. He’s definitely easier to persuade to follow instructions? 😂 I thought his character was more grounded. Not to say I don’t like Finch’s character but he could definitely be a lot at times 😂
Profile Image for K-Me.
2,822 reviews
March 29, 2021
OH My just love this BIG Family!!! This book is so full of action, tension, family, love.. just everything! I want to be very careful not to give too much away since this book is driven by an over arching family and plot! The Action is non stop and you will not want to put it down because you need to know what will happen next!! and of course how the relationship will progress! Aiden is a beautiful person inside and out and Teo is Perfect for him! This is told from both of Aiden and Teo's POV so you can really feel all the struggles and feelings they go through! Finch is here to ramp up the Humor too!! The romance in this book can be read as standalone, but I recommend starting at the beginning of the Series as the other characters are heavily involved throughout!!! I received an ARC for my honest review. I definitely recommend this book for those who love action and suspense stories that are also a Loving and Sexy romance too!! I cannot wait for the next adventure and romance in this series!
Profile Image for Antisocial Recluse.
2,711 reviews
December 30, 2021
A wannabe priest

This won’t be my favorite, only because I dislike reading *anything* about religion, especially Catholicism (I mean, WHY would anyone give up sex for life?) but throw in the Queer Mafia and the Irish mob and I can live with it!
Profile Image for Sarah.
1,899 reviews115 followers
May 30, 2023
Much enjoyed. I’m really liking this series. 4.5 stars.

Reread May 2023
Profile Image for KC.
69 reviews
January 15, 2025
📚 Seduced by a Sinner by Leighton Greene: A Masterclass in Storytelling and Narration! 🎧✨
I’m so excited to share my thoughts on the Morelli Family (Book 4) book series! This has easily become one of my all-time favorites, and having received an advanced copy of the audiobook for the fourth book, I couldn’t wait to dive back into the world the author, Leighton Greene, has so brilliantly crafted.
The character development in this series is next level. Each book focuses on a new character, but what’s incredible is how each story builds upon the last, adding layers to both new and returning characters. It’s a masterful way to keep you invested, always giving you something new while honoring what came before. The character list is complicated—but in the best way. It makes you think, connects dots across books, and keeps you on your toes with every twist and turn.
The author is incredibly detailed, with a knack for crafting complex plots that only get better with each installment. The pacing is perfect—there’s always something happening, but not in a way that feels overwhelming. The best part? The plot twists. They're crafted so tactfully that while you’re definitely surprised, you don’t feel anxious or rattled. It’s like the author is always keeping you just intrigued enough without pushing you too far.
Now, let me talk about the narration. I don’t know how Michael Ferraiuolo does it, but the choice of narrator for this series is absolutely UNMATCHED! I’ve listened to many audiobooks, thousands, but Michael Ferraiuolo ... wow. The narrator is in my top 3 favorites —no doubt. What’s so impressive is how consistent he is across all books within a series, seamlessly switching between characters and maintaining the nuances of their personalities. And his accent work? Pure magic.
This narrator brought so much life and emotion to the series. It felt like I was listening to my favorite characters come to life again. His pacing, timing, and voice control made each scene even more immersive. I honestly can’t imagine anyone else doing it better.
Overall, I can’t recommend this series enough. The writing, the character arcs, the slow-burn suspense—it’s all top-notch. Whether you’re a fan of audio or print, this is a series you need to experience. Trust me—you’ll be hooked from the first page (or the first word of the audiobook)!
#SeducedbyaSinner #LeightonGreene #MorelliFamily #MichaelFerraiuolo #Ferrajunkies
#BookReview #AudiobookLove #NarrationPerfection #TopSeries #mmromance #gayromance #bookstagram #mmromancebooks #kindleunlimited #mmbooks #mmreads #queerromance #loveislove #readersofinstagram
Profile Image for Kristina.
1,094 reviews2 followers
January 13, 2025
Narrator: Michael Ferraiuolo

Rating: 4/5 stars

Thank you to Leighton Greene for allowing me a copy of this audio book in return for an honest review.

When Aidan, a catholic priest in training, just weeks away from his ordination, gets threatened in his church his best friend Finch insists he needs protection. Finch, married to mob boss Luca, suggests one of his bodyguards Teo take on the role of protector. As Teo and Aidan spend more time together their feelings cause them to question what they want in life.

This is the fourth instalment of the Morelli Family Series. I had actually bought it as an e-book over Christmas but hadn’t had a chance to read it yet, so when I was given the opportunity to listen to the audio version I quickly read number three in preparation. Michael Ferraiuolo did a fantastic job narrating Teo and Aidan’s romance, all characters had a unique voice and Michael’s acting skills breathed life into the story.

What I liked: This felt like a slightly different, sweeter, beast from the previous books, mainly down to increased amount of introspection, and Aidan’s crisis of faith was especially well handled. The series' overarching plot is now starting to move into the forefront of the narrative and it was cleverly incorporated into this story. Teo stepping up into his role was a particularly fun scene to witness.

What didn’t work for me: I’m probably being picky but it frustrated me that a scene in which Teo and Aidan have, what we are told is a massive argument, isn’t actually given to us as dialogue, it quelled some of the passion of the moment. I wanted to feel my stomach clenching in anxiety for the characters and I felt robbed of that.

Final thoughts: A great addition to a brilliant series.

Who would enjoy this: Fans of contemporary romance with mobster main characters. While this could be read on its own, I would strongly recommend starting with book one, "Married to the Mobster” (still my favourite but this is a close second).
Profile Image for Megan McGrath .
578 reviews5 followers
January 25, 2025
Aiden & Teo (Matteo)
I have been remiss that this is the first of the Morelli Family series I have enjoyed, but enjoy I did! I knew a mafia-based story would have violence and action, but I appreciate the tension the author builds without making it too harmful for your blood pressure or anxiety.

The chemistry between the two MCs isn't immediately obvious, and it evolves somewhat gradually, although that is primarily due to Aiden's church-bound designation and his personal vows. But once they begin the physical aspect of their relationship, their connection and intensity is exciting and fun to experience. Their relationship is fraught with interruptions and suspense and sometimes outright terror, but they manage to persevere. I enjoyed their personal HEA, but the ominous lead-in to the next book in the series definitely gave me some pause.

I definitely need to follow-up with the earlier books in the series, because while this one reads pretty well as a standalone (to me at least), there is a decent amount of background story available that would have been helpful for me when diving into this series.

Audiobook Update:
Narrated by Michael Ferraiuolo
This is my first audiobook from this narrator, and I think he did a fantastic job with these two incredibly complex men. Having to include the subtle Italian and then Boston-Irish accents between the two and the many other characters was really interesting to follow, but easy to do so. A multi-narrated audiobook is fun when you have two completely different people offering many character voices, but it's truly impressive when one narrator can manage such a large assembly of characters and still make them unique enough to follow, especially when it's well beyond more than just the two or more MCs.

I received an authorized copy of this story/audiobook and am volunteering my honest review.
Profile Image for AshPenny37 .
1,025 reviews5 followers
March 31, 2021
Four books deep into this series, I'm totally invested in all things Morelli Family. Whilst Seduced By A Sinner can standalone, I'd recommend reading it in order to get the full flavour of the overarching storyline concerning the Morellis and Donovans.

In this installment Finch's BFF, Aiden, is in danger so Finch's bodyguard, Teo, steps up to protect him...and they get super close. There's just a couple of things, though: one, Teo's rising through the ranks in the Morelli Family and has a secret he's been carrying and two, Aiden's a soon-to-be priest in the weeks leading up to his ordination ceremony.

OK, the biggest potential sticking point for me is the priesthood angle. I usually swerve that trope as I'm uncomfortable with stuff that leans really heavily on this taboo. That's not a judgement at all - it's just not for me. However, here, Aiden's faith is dealt with in a sensitive manner, especially when it comes to other characters' approach to it, i.e. Aiden's family as well as Teo. It feels to me like this is also why the pace of the book is a bit slower. Yes, there's still plenty of action, but there are stretches of time where it's just Teo and Aiden together or one of them having an introspective moment. The romance, too, is the right balance of hot and sweet for me.

All in all, I think Seduced By A Sinner is a worthy addition to the series: Family-oriented plot, likeable and engaging characters, and a last line that promises much from the next installment. It might not be for you if you like a priest taboo story on the darker side, but if you've enjoyed the Morellis so far you'll most likely be just fine with this one. 4*

An ARC was provided by GRR. This is my honest review.
Profile Image for Juniper.
3,391 reviews24 followers
April 7, 2021
Teo is a bodyguard in the Morelli family. Aiden is a soon-to-be-ordained priest. Teo has been part of the Family for so long it’s his calling. Aiden’s calling should take him in an entirely different direction-- but an attack on him pushes the two together. There’s definitely the angle of the forbidden here-- Aiden isn’t just a religious initiate, he’s in many ways a true innocent, and his faith and sweetness are an essential part of who he is. Teo seems harder and more cynical, but in truth, I wouldn’t really call this an “opposites attract” romance, because for all of the differences in their lived experiences, at the core Teo and Aiden are very similar: they’re devoted to their purposes, want to do right by people, and are willing to sacrifice themselves for what they perceive as the greater good. Watching them fall in love, in spite of themselves, is watching both of them get exactly what they need, even if Aiden does tie himself into an exhausting number of metaphysical knots along the way. This is a great love story first and foremost-- there’s plenty of steam and a solid backdrop of crime and intrigue, but at the end of the day, Aiden and Teo will steal your heart, and it’s well worth it.

As a final note, this book is part of a series, and while the romance definitely makes sense as a standalone, there’s an overarching narrative thread that begins in previous books and continues through this one, so you’ll get the most out of it if you begin at the beginning (also, all the books in this series are excellent, so it’s well worth it).

*I received an ARC of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review.
1,633 reviews13 followers
April 10, 2021
Suspenseful, surprising, poignant M/M mafia romance between unlikely men
One man, Matteo Vitali, has been Angelo Messina’s understudy for the job as head of protection in the Morelli Familia. (For Angelo’s story read ENTICED BY THE ENEMY) The other man is Aidan O’Leary soon-to-be ordained priest in the Catholic church and best friends of The Boss’s husband, Finch who plays a big part in this book as well. Teo happens to save Aidan from a surprise attack which launches him into his new job as Aidan’s protector. Teo has been sensitive to this young man for some time, but he sees himself as too sinful for a priest-to-be. As Aidan’s ordination looms near, he wants to experience “things” that he will not have after becoming a celibate priest. Teo agrees to help him in his quest. Besides this stirring love story, there is a war brewing and I’m afraid the Morelli’s will be dragged into it by associations through marriage.
Reading this book was like watching a movie. It was written so well that I could figuratively “see” the actions of the many characters. LOVED it. I got my tear ducts cleaned while reading pages 332 through 342 on my tablet. The ending is so beautiful. When you realize what Teo’s life had been like, you will rejoice with him when things turn out well. I have loved this entire series and I can’t wait for the next one, already purchased it! Ms. Greene chose the perfect cover too. Each book is a standalone but builds on the one before it. I volunteered to review an ARC of this book through Gay Romance Reviews and highly recommend it. If you like well-written, page-turners with explicit M/M action and romance, read this story!
Profile Image for Kat reads romance.
213 reviews
March 28, 2021
Yay! I loved this addition to the Morelli Family series. In fact, I'd go so far as to say that this rivals the first book for my favorite one. This was for a combination of reasons:
First, I loved the characters. I've been looking forward to Aiden's book ever since we met him. I didn't find his religious devotion off-putting, for those of you, like myself, who might have reservations about that. Instead, Aiden has a really interesting spiritual journey reconciling Catholicism with his sexuality, and it sounds like the author did her research. I was happy that Teo, despite his role in the mafia and belief that he was a "sinner," had great respect for Aiden's religion. His perception of Aiden as adorable and pure transformed into something steamy in the bedroom which, ahem, made for some sexy first times for a certain not-a-priest.
Second, I thought that it was fluffier than some of the previous books, and, not gonna lie, I needed the change. Don't get me wrong, we get our violence and mafia fix, but this one didn't feel as dark to me. Perhaps that's down to Aiden, you know, just being Aiden.
Third, even though there were plot lines left unresolved, I felt as though Aiden and Teo got a solid enough happy ever after to satisfy me. The previous book in the series didn't give me that, so I was super pleased to get it this time. Overall, I highly recommend this book. Fans of the Morellis (and Aiden!) will not be disappointed. FYI, I don't recommend you read this as a standalone.
**I received a copy of this book from Gay Romance Reviews and this is my honest review**
Profile Image for Claudia.
219 reviews4 followers
April 22, 2021
I read this almost a month ago and kept meaning to do a proper review but having a newborn kind of mind wipes you for anything that isn’t bottles, nappy changes and sleep.

This is one of my favourite types of stories that are few and far between to find. I think there’s only been maybe two or three that I’ve found and enjoyed that follow the priest/religious person being corrupted. (KA Merikan have a great gothic fantasy style one I swear by). At the same time, Teo doesn’t really corrupt Aidan, so much as Aidan wants and encourages Teo to lead him down the path of passion and indulgence.

Aidan is deliciously devout, seemingly content with his sexuality but nonetheless dedicating himself to his faith. He battles through-out the story with his attraction to Teo, believing he can fulfil his goal of becoming a priest and faithfulness to God as long as he doesn’t partake in homosexual acts. That then devolves into, it doesn’t count as long as he does it before he takes his vows - which is both hilarious and sweet as it’s because he can’t keep himself away from Teo who is protective and possessive.

Teo treats Aidan with such kindness and selflessness, it strips your heart bare. He knows and respects what Aidan’s faith symbolises for him and refuses to make him choose, in fact he actively refuses to let Aidan throw it away for Teo.

I really adore this series and was so excited for this instalment, I’m really glad it lived up to all my hopes.
Profile Image for Ana Silva.
520 reviews9 followers
July 26, 2025
Each book just gets better and better in this series.

I’ve always loved forbidden tropes and this one is as forbidden as can be. An almost priest and a mafia bodyguard? Yes, please.

All his life Aidan O’Leary thought he wanted to be a priest. After all, that is what he thought God wanted from him. He was on the verge of making that dream come true until he met the Morelli family. Nothing was ever the same after that.

His friendship with the Don’s husband and his close proximity to one of the family’s bodyguards made him have doubts about his true vocation. He couldn’t understand why the presence of Theo made him feel things a priest in training shouldn’t be feeling.

Theo was attracted to Aidan the moment he laid eyes on him. His innocence and pure heart made him want things he knew he could never have. But knowing something doesn’t make it go away.

Theo became Aidan’s bodyguard after an attempt on his life and the closeness only reinforced his attraction for Aidan. Theo knew Aidan was off limits but you can’t tell your heart how to feel.

Warring between following his love for God and his feelings for Theo, Aidan decides to listen to what he knows God wants for him not of him.

Between sins and guilt, Theo and Aidan understand that sometimes choosing to be happy for yourself doesn’t mean you’re abandoning your love for God. After all, God’s true love means loving with all your heart.
765 reviews2 followers
May 3, 2021
OMG I'm so happy Aidan got his happy ending.

He is probably the Thing to happens in Finch life. A person he can call a friend who doesn't have an agenda. Aidan didn't know what hit him when Finch blew into his life but he accepted him as a friend. Protected him and kept his secret. Finch old body guard was killed by protecting Finch and Aidan is getting to know his new body guard Teo. Has come to accept his presence in Finches life. Teo is looking for a better life for his family. Working hard to move up the rail in the business. They both come to accept and respect each other. Aidan one night is trying to clock the church up for the evening when he's accosted by an intruder. Teo who was at the church decided to stay after to make finch didn't leave a whole lot extra work for Aidan and once he deposit finch in the car heads back into the church to check on Aidan. But finds him being attached by a street thug or so they thought. Several other things come up before Aidan is to be ordained. Between being attacked and high speed car chases these two grow closer. Aidan is still very Innocent in the ways of the world. Teo is more than happy to show him several different things to break his cherry. As the Coronation draw closer Aidan has more and more questions in regards to his faith. Can both men figure out what the want?
Displaying 1 - 30 of 119 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.