In a reasoned critique of Hindutva and Hinduism, feminist scholar and activist, Wandana Sonalkar, outlines why she, born female and upper caste in Maharashtra, has repudiated her religious identity.
Based on her personal experience, and on textual and empirical evidence, she offers an intimate account of caste practices, and argues that patriarchy and Brahminism are integral to Hinduism. As such, it is misogynist and casteist, and its exclusionary imperatives are essential to both its practice - and to Hindutva, which extends this imperative to Muslims.
She reiterates that discrimination and inequality have been so internalised that their daily observance segues seamlessly into social interactions, thus crystallising and entrenching them deeply in society.
This book is NOT a guide to become an atheist or why not to follow Hinduism. This book, as cleared in the title itself, is an autobiographical account of an atheist. A marxist, a feminist and a retired professor of women and gender studies, Wandana Sonalkar, born and raised in an upper caste middle class family, has critically observed and presented how patriarchy is so deeply rooted in religion.
Published in January 2021, Sonalkar's work raises a voice against the "political hinduism" and forceful hindutva. Her writing effortlessly put forward the caste hierarchy and how the "modern day hindutva" is based on hatred and causes so much moral dismantling and humanitarian destruction in the society. This raising of voice is commendable in itself considering the present scenario.
Wandana Sonalkar has put together her memoir in a very well researched, balanced and brave way. An important work formulated to show how patriarchy and misogyny is so deeply rooted in Hindu society and are sustained by caste.
An engaging mix of personal stories, political history and cultural analysis. Very lucidly explains how casteism and misogyny are inherent to Hinduism. Easy to read as a feminist introduction to the deep roots and everyday manifestations of caste privilege.
Wandana Sonalkar’s Why I Am Not a Hindu Woman is not a quiet rebellion. It’s a precise, courageous refusal of Hinduism, of upper-caste womanhood, and of the lie that devotion can ever protect those meant to serve, not belong.
As an upper-caste woman herself, Sonalkar doesn’t speak on behalf of the oppressed .she calls out the violence her own identity has enabled, and the silence it demanded from others. Through deeply personal yet unapologetically political storytelling, she reveals how Hinduism's structure depends on caste-based hierarchy, gendered obedience, and family-sanctioned suffering.
One of the most powerful moments in the book is when her father’s extramarital affair becomes a lens into the caste-patriarchal family. While he remained respected, her mother was left to suffer alone .her only refuge being endless pujas, rituals, and the empty consolation of religious duty. The message was clear: men get to stray, women must stay and pray.
This book made me look at Hinduism clearly not through the lens of liberal romanticism. For the marginalized, there is no ladder here only walls. There is no upward mobility. Only ritualized othering.
This is not a comfortable read. It doesn’t soothe. It sharpens.
"It is as a woman who has rejected her Hindu identity that I look at the misogyny, the Islamophobia, and the Brahmanical divisiveness that have put down deep roots in India today. Mine is not a Dalit feminist standpoint, for my life has not been that of a Dalit woman. It is that of an upper-caste woman, a feminist, who has tried to learn from being in that upper-caste location; who accepts that leadership for social change will come from elsewhere, from another generation, another caste, another class. And it is as one such that I have written about why I am not a Hindu woman."
“I cannot pretend to shake off my upper caste origins, but I unequivocally reject the Hinduism that perpetuates their relevance.” ✍️
I'm an Atheist, and the frequent questions I receive from my relatives or friends are 'whom do I believe in then?' or 'whom do I seek blessings from while appearing for important tasks?'
I've tried giving some of them my answers, but a large section comes back to one single statement — "You're quite young to understand how the system, the culture, the society works & haven't faced tough callings, so you have these ridiculous notions. Wait till you grow up, you'll realise in the power of that *Supreme*."
Well, I'm old enough to be married, have kids, raise a family BUT not old enough to have my own belief systems. *Heightened eye roll*
So, obviously when I found a book whose title reads out “Why I am Not a Hindu Woman: A Personal Story”, I had to devour it at one go & I sure did that! I dropped down everything to focus on this book.
Wandana Sonalkar, a feminist scholar & an activist, in her book, pours her lived experience of born in a 'Liberal' Hindu household & critiques the Hindutva & Hindu fervor that has entrenched the country like a fever dream post 2014.
She talks of the demands of the Hindu Rashtra & War hysteria engulfing this country and the inherent misogyny, patriarchy, casteism rampant in Hinduism & its religious texts. While talking of other religions, she draws parallelism in their faults with Hinduism but also lays down the differences in their approach to the baseline of sexism.
From her personal experience as a daughter, educator, writer & activist, she further critiques the Hindu family structure & how significantly they imbibe in their daily lives the notions of 'Manusmriti' & other sacred texts.
She uses famous writings of Caste Hindus & privileged ones to point out how Religion enables them & how important a tool it becomes for them to promote their misogyny, in the garb of Culture & Tradition. She further questions the women who act as watchdogs for the Patriarchy & analyses the bigger role of religion in their choices
The author acknowledges her upper caste identity & privileges, and to reflect diversity in her writing by citing the works of prominent Dalit writers & activists and their contribution towards dismantling the caste hierarchy & fight against religious atrocities.
No matter who you are, a believer or an atheist, do take out time to read this piece of work. It offers a reasoned critique of the issues at hand & these works need to be read & amplified more especially now, at times when a fascist regime is using Religion as a tool to instigate disharmony & communalism.
It's 170 pages long book but would leave a deep impact. READ THIS!
This book gives some serious insights into the way hinduism has been and is practiced in the subcontinent, with it's inherent caste patriarchy. It goes on to describe the author's experience as an upper-caste woman living in India as an atheist married to a working class man. She gives us deep explanations on how this system in itself caters to the new version of hindutva.
But, there is a lack of flow as such in the narration and the text is not intriguing or a compelling read.