Characters: Humpty Dumpty, the three blind mice, Miss. Muffet, Tom, the piper’s son, Solomon Grundy, and an assortment of other Mother Goose characters
Setting: Settings vary, depending upon the rhyme, with many not clearly stated
Theme: Nursery Rhymes
Summary: This is a rereleased copy of an older edition of Mother Goose nursery rhymes that had been illustrated by the famous cartoonist, Charles Addams. The book contains 26 conventional nursery rhymes that are illustrated very unconventionally. For example, a dinosaur hatches from Humpty Dumpty. Actual heads grow in Mistress Mary’s garden. Jack Sprat’s wife has a red rimmed, yellow eyes. The rhymes are followed by “The Charles Addams Mother Goose Scrapbook,” which includes captioned photographs, drawings, and cover art by the artist.
Strengths/Weaknesses: A variety of rhymes are included, going beyond those traditionally learned in kindergarten or first grade. However, the illustrations are a bit dark and disturbing. While this is a positive for an older student, the illustrations may not make this book the best choice for younger children. Younger children are typically who would be exposed to nursery rhymes, so this book is most appropriate for a narrow group.
Illustrations: The illustrations were created by the illustrator of the original “Addams Family” comics. Many of the illustrations are in black and white. Most are somewhat unsettling or disturbing. The macabre interpretation of the characters makes inappropriate a book that would otherwise have been very appropriate for a five or six year old. Older children and adults, particularly those familiar with Addam’s work, could find the paradox appealing.
Target Audience: The text is best suited for ages 4 to 6, the illustrations to Ages 10 and above. Overall, I would recommend this book to readers aged 10 to adult.
Curriculum Ties: Mother Goose Nursery Rhymes are typically taught in kindergarten and first grades. They are taught as a genre, and also are used for practice identifying rhyme. The text would work for this purpose, if not the illustrations. The book could be used to review examples of the genre with upper elementary students.
Personal Critique: I enjoyed this book, but I didn’t love it. While most of the nursery rhymes included were familiar to me, a few weren’t. As a mature reader who grew up watching “The Addams Family” television show, I enjoyed the slightly disturbing yet playful illustrations. I’m certain that this book would be very appealing to fans of the artist.