I have to say, the third instalment of T.L Higley's seven wonder's series was a big disappointment.
I read City of the Dead first, even though it is the second book, and loved it. It was very intense and her writing style immediately sold me. I bought that book and the first one not but a few weeks later and loved both of them. To this day, I've read them both countless times and would highly recommend them to anyone who loves a good portrayal of history's ancient worlds and cultures.
So as you can imagine, I was watching eagerly for Guardian of the Flame to be released, even requested it as a Christmas present with high hopes to be highly entertained. A quarter of the way into the novel, I was disappointed. The prose was slow and the events seemed to build up only to have the action drag. For most of the novel, the heroine and lighthouse keeper Sophia lives as a greying scholar in Alexandria, observing the world below with contempt. Through the tide of quickly shifting events, she must break through to perhaps find love...and all those other cliches.
I love historical fiction especially stuff set in the ancient civilization of Egypt. And Higley does deliver with beautiful descriptions of Ancient Egypt and accurate portrayals of such famous characters such as Cleopatra who remains Sophia's friend and student throughout the novel.
However, the romance between Sophia and her roman soldier starts out pretty stereotypical. Both despise each other but are forced to co-exist with each other within the confines of the lighthouse. Their disgust for each other rapidly sparks into attraction, which of course was predictable from the start.
I have to admit for myself, I hate this kind of plot frame, nothing annoys me more than seeing two people I'm actually supposed to care about, do something so predictable that they no longer seem like real life people, but like cardboard cut outs. And sadly Higely has sacrificed her characters for the sake of a tiredly used plot cliche.
For this reason, among others, I find the book slow and dragging, perfect if you're interested in a long read. Cause it definitely feels long. Though no longer than the following two books, Guardian of the Flame travels along at a pace reserved for slow contemplation and sight seeing seen from the eyes of Sophia.
Perhaps the romance won't turn off some people, but compared to her fabulous writing in City of the Dead, by far my favourite, I'm just not sold.