The Woman Question in Socialist Russia
The message may be problematic in parts but this collection of short writings does show the strides made by socialist/communist Russia in the treatment of women. Though the use of the phrase "the woman question" is a little irksome, it was the vernacular of the time.
This was my first reading of any writing by V.I. Lenin and gave me a good introduction to his goals for women in post-revolution Russia. Some of the pieces in this collection are brief, as Lenin apologizes for not being able to attend certain conferences, with him writing of the continued support of conferences for and by women, and including motivational points and congratulations.
The point of this writing is to show a consistent message in the pieces, that a socialist society must have "full equality for all citizens irrespective of sex, religion, or race." This equality was indeed guaranteed under the law of the new government after the revolution. Lenin recognizes this as the first step, and writes that the social change in the minds of Russian citizens is what must next be approached. And in this he empowers women by giving them the responsibility and the role of educating other women on what this equality means, including divorce rights, children born out of wedlock holding the same status as children born in a marriage, ability and access to employment outside of the home, and even autonomy over herself (birth control and abortion are both discussed and are accessible to women after 1917). These collected pieces demonstrate a continued need to educate citizens, especially to the poorer classes under the Monarchy and the serfs working the fields.
Many of the ideas espoused in these writings, and the goals of a Russian socialist society, are very progressive, even for our time. Equality was named in the laws but also extended to the workplace, with equal wages, equal representation on labor boards and courts, and in divorce proceedings where a woman could seek a dissolution of the marriage and not be dependent on a husband for the means to survive. By being able to work, women could support themselves, especially with the creation of kindergartens and nurseries to take care of the working woman's children. In one essay, Lenin encourages newspapers to post information about where the nurseries and homes open to women and children are available in the area. A continued theme of communication across all strata of Russian citizens and using the available means to spread the message is found in these texts.
There is also the issue of sex in these writings. Lenin touches on sex work, and recognizes it as work, but also sees an oppression of women who had no other options but to become prostitutes. He suggests helping these workers acquire other employment, as it was now guaranteed by the government, to help them escape the situation and to eradicate prostitution in Russia. There is also an interview at the end of the book by Clara Zetkin, which which "free love," and promiscuity is discussed. In this interview, Lenin does sound orthodox and traditional. He states women, and men, are free to engage in sexual activity, but that promiscuity is a hindrance to the socialist worker and absorbs energy that is needed to spread the socialist message. He does say this is true for both men and women, which is equal responsibility, but does appear to still espouse traditional thought on the act of sex before marriage.
This issue of sexual equality is problematic in this respect. And though there was access to birth control, abortion, and childcare, there are moments where Lenin does tend to mansplain to women. For instance, abortion is accessible, but he states that women should refrain from abortion if possible, because the people "are already laying the foundation of a new edifice and out children will complete the construction." Basically, women needed to continue having children for the sake of the country and the continued growth of socialism and communism. This is troubling as much of the revolution took heavy burdens away from woman but this idea puts a heavier burden on her. Perhaps this is because he does see women as the leaders of their sex and of the young people being indoctrinated into political thought. A woman is still the mother at the hearth, teaching her children by the fire, though the message has changed.
Within the difference pieces of writing there is the continued proclamation that a socialist country is more democratic than one populated by capitalists. For, in a socialist society, every citizen is equal, as is every vote, and judges, board members, and committee officials are elected by popular vote (rather than an electoral college). Throughout the collection, Lenin stresses that "wherever there are landowners, capitalists, and merchants, women cannot be the equal of men even before the law." When these are in place, a woman is subservient to the landowners, etc, but is also beneath her husband in terms of power and labor value. At the time, Russian women had access to social programs that helped her to work, as opposed to being "slaves" to the household, which is a continued state that Lenin rails against in his writings from 1917 - 1922.