Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Saints & Scoundrels #3

The Sinful Scot

Rate this book
Constance Campbell, the Duchess of Kilmaine, once believed that all she needed in life was a duke. But everything unraveled when she realized her perfect husband was a perfect monster. Now broken beyond repair, she hides her misery behind a perfect Society mask...even from her childhood friend, Alec.

Dr. Alec McGuinness reluctantly finds himself back in Scotland, and checking up on the only woman to ever get under his skin, Connie. After she spurned him many years ago, he knows his humble life as a doctor could never be enough for her. But when the Duke of Kilmaine is murdered in cold blood, with Connie sleeping right next to him in bed, Alec knows he must protect Connie at all costs from those who would frame her for the duke’s murder.

Now on the run, Connie feels a freedom she only ever dreamed about before, and an unexpected attraction to the man who is keeping her safe. But even if they can win her freedom and clear her name, could she ever open her heart up to someone again?

Each book in the Saints & Scoundrels series is STANDALONE:
* The Devilish Duke
* The Elusive Earl
* The Sinful Scot

Audiobook

First published January 27, 2020

86 people are currently reading
351 people want to read

About the author

Maddison Michaels

11 books440 followers
Maddison Michaels, is an award-winning historical romantic suspense author, who captivates readers with her signature blend of "Sexy History with a Dash of Mystery." Her debut novel, "The Devilish Duke," won the prestigious Romance Writers of Australia RUBY Award in 2019, along with two of her subsequent novels being finalists in the 2021 and 2022 RUBY Awards. Maddison is the published author of ten historical romance novels, that promise page-turning mystery and suspense, and keep readers hooked until the last word. She’s also set to release two non-fiction writing craft books, aimed to help her fellow writers let their stories take flight!

Maddison draws on her success as an author, along with her previous 17-year career as a police officer, prosecutor, and teacher of senior NSW Police officers, to offer writing courses, webinars and coaching services to mentor aspiring and established authors. Maddison helps her fellow writers infuse their writing with authenticity and master their craft. Her upcoming podcast ‘The Writer’s Nest’ will explore and discuss various strategies and ways writers can use their personality to unleash their writing.

She lives in Northern New South Wales, Australia, with her own handsome hero, little princess, and fur babies. She’s recently taken up golf with her husband (you don’t want to know her handicap… even she doesn’t want to know, lol) and she’s a committed coffee connoisseur (read: total caffeine addict), who always starts her day with a cup of liquid gold!

When not whisking herself away to a world of historical romance or helping other writers hone their craft, Maddison loves engaging with her readers. You can contact her through her contacts page, or visit her on most social media platforms, where she shares her writing journey, writing news, life snippets, and behind-the-scenes tidbits.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
155 (31%)
4 stars
187 (38%)
3 stars
107 (21%)
2 stars
31 (6%)
1 star
9 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 122 reviews
Profile Image for Maddison Michaels.
Author 11 books440 followers
January 29, 2020
Connie and Alec's journey was a very different story for me to write - as Connie herself had been through some horrendous experiences, which had impacted upon her to the point where she wasn't as carefree and free spirited as some of my other heroines in past books. So for Connie to heal and get to a point where she could trust a man and give her heart to him, was a big thing, and couldn't happen overnight. Not to mention Alec too, who had been through some extremely tough life experiences, so the two of them together had a lot to deal with alongside of having to find a murderer!

So I can honestly say that balancing writing a romance combined with a heroine who had been abused was a challenge! On one hand I had to be mindful that as an author I have a finite period that the romance arc has to be met within, whilst still being true to the characters past experiences - however this is a fictional story, so I definitely had to be careful not to bog the story down in the angst of Connie’s past experiences - though obviously throughout the book they do effect the storyline and the romance arc.

Also, I have had years of personal experience dealing with victims of domestic abuse in my full time occupation - and can I say that some of the resilience and strength of character that these victims display would surprise and challenge the stereotype that they are always fragile victims for years after the abuse. Some of them have become a great deal stronger through their adversity - and are determined not to let their abuser win over them, so in some instances there are certainly some survivors who do move on and form new relationships in what would generally be considered a quick time frame. So for those who think that forming a relationship so soon after the abuse ends, is not possible, I have seen victims of domestic abuse do exactly that. Certainly not in all cases, but definitely in some.

And as usually, with all of my books, I combine a heavy dash of mystery throughout the story - as I personally prefer reading more than just a straight up romance. So if you want subplots galore with more than just a romance arc as the focus, then my stories are for you!

I do hope you enjoy Connie and Alec's story as they travel through the Scottish Highlands on their quest that turns into something a lot more than either of them had planned!
Profile Image for Barbara Rogers.
1,754 reviews207 followers
January 13, 2020
Series: Saints & Scoundrels #3
Publication Date: 1/27/20
Number of Pages: 400

While there is no trigger warning in the book blurb, there is one at the beginning of the book. Of course, you wouldn’t see that until you’d already bought the book, so, I thought I’d go ahead and mention it here. If you are particularly sensitive/susceptible to reading about those kinds of things, you should be aware that domestic abuse – severe beatings and rape – are talked about in this book. I thought the author handled that subject matter well and got her point across without getting overly graphic.  I thought it was all really well done.

One would think that Constance and Alec were opposites and could never be a good match. Alec is a self-made man who works for a living even though he is the second son of an earl and his working is frowned upon. Alec works tirelessly to help, as a doctor, those who have no champions. Constance’s sole goal in life was to marry a title – specifically, a duke. Well – she sure managed to reach that goal. What is missing from that scenario is that, as children, they knew and liked each other very much. Then, Constance (Connie) was sweet and loving and greatly admired Alec. What happened? Well – there are parents – particularly mothers – who seem to be spawns of Satan.

The opening chapter shows what Constance Campbell’s life has been like for the last three years – since she married Duncan Campbell, the Duke of Kilmaine and moved to Scotland to live in Castle Kilmaine. It also shows that she’s stronger than you’d think given the weak-willed way she bent to her mother’s desires rather than her own. She’d certainly have to have some strength to her to endure all she has for the last three years and not be a huddled, whimpering, mass of fears. So, while I didn’t admire the way she acquiesced to her mother’s desires, I did admire that she had managed to endure her brute of a husband and had managed to survive without going stark-raving mad.  I liked her very much.

Alec McGuiness is only attending the Duke of Kilmaine’s ball in order to speak with the Duchess of Kilmaine – and he’s only doing that because their mutual friend Sophie asked him to do so. When she finally appears on the stairs, he loses his breath because she is still so very beautiful. Then, when he speaks to her, his sharp physician's eye notices the telltale signs of the abuse to which she is subjected. How can he help her?

When Constance (Connie) awakens the morning following the ball, she feels groggy and disoriented – at least until she sees the lifeless body of her husband sprawled across her bed. He’s been viciously stabbed and there is blood all over the place, including all over Connie. Did she finally snap and murder him? She’s not sure, but she knows her first order of business has to be to get her step-daughter, Amelie, away from the castle to protect her from her uncle Fergus.

Everyone immediately assumes Connie snapped and killed the duke – including Fergus, the duke’s brother. Alec doesn’t believe a word of it and quickly helps Connie escape the castle where she’s been confined. Once they are away from there, everything breaks loose – everybody is chasing Connie and Alec and Connie and Alec are trying to find out who the real murderer is. The answer will surprise you – and perplex you.

One thing that perplexed me was a ‘monthly dowry’. That is one I’ve never heard of, but maybe it was possible. I can’t imagine any circumstances under which a potential groom would agree to that – but – it just doesn’t seem feasible to me and every time I saw it mentioned it just jarred me right out of the story. ** Note -- I asked the author about this and she said it was possible. However, I also asked several other knowledgable British authors about it and they said this would not have been possible.

I also have to add that I thought Connie’s falling for Alec and being able to relax around him and even allow him to touch her came a little too quickly. We all heal at different rates, but Connie's recovery seemed remarkable - to me. ** Note ** I asked the author about this and she said that in her experience, healing of this type could occur quickly.

I enjoyed the read and I hope you will as well. The stories in this series are stand-alone, so you don’t have to have read the other books in the series in order to enjoy this one.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Shatarupa  Dhar.
620 reviews84 followers
February 2, 2020
Synopsis:
Constance is unable to leave her abusive husband of two years. Not only because her mother refuses to support her, but also because she will then be leaving her six-year-old stepdaughter to the mercy of a rage-fuelled madman. But one morning she wakes up with Duncan stabbed to death in bed next to her and her with no memory of how or what happened the previous night.

Alec McGuiness is in Kilmaine to attend the Ball hosted by the Duke and Duchess and also to ensure Connie's friend Sophie that the former is doing well. He is a doctor practising in London, a place where Connie, Sophie, and he grew up together. But when he gets wind of the Duke's death and that Connie has been accused of the crime, he knows that he has to help her in any way he can.

Review:
The story starts in May 1857 in Castle Kilmaine in the Highlands where Constance thinks about the various physical abuses she daily suffers at the hand of her husband Duncan Campbell, the Duke of Kilmaine. He is nothing short of a monster who tortures and rapes Connie. But she still lives on for Amelie, the six-year-old daughter of the Duke and his first wife, the latter having allegedly committed suicide.

Doctor Alec is half-English and is the youngest of two sons of a Scottish Earl. Yet, in Connie's eyes, that hadn't been enough. He had been hurt when even after knowing him since she was ten and he was fifteen, she ignored him after her debut, instead preferring to chase after the Duke. Basically chasing after titles and the privileges that it entailed after her mother's behest.

But when the Duke is dead, rather murdered in bed with Constance covered in his blood, she and Alec are in a race against time to prove that she had nothing to do with his murder and that she was framed, most probably by the Duke's younger brother Fergus.
She couldn’t allow herself to fall in love with him. She couldn’t give up her newfound and tenuous independence for an emotion that could rip one’s heart out if allowed.

I always wanted to start reading historical romances and it is a pleasure that this one had to be the first after some five hundred romance books that I've already read. That this was as charming as it was suspenseful was an added bonus! Alec is one of the most amazing male protagonists I have read till date and I loved how the author made Connie level-headed and strong instead of a hysterical damsel in distress even after all that she has been through.
Connie was nothing if not made of steel, even if she had forgotten that about herself.

I was a bit disappointed when neither Sophie, Alec and Connie's mutual best friend, nor Connie's mother made an appearance anywhere. But the story was a well-paced one, with thrilling twists, murders that kept everyone busy and me as a reader on my toes, to the point where I was literally holding my breath at many instances, eagerly waiting to see where the story was headed next. Everyone had their own interest in getting their hands on Connie. And while Alec is attracted to Connie, he has some deep-seated abandonment issues in his past which prevented him from acting on his attraction. It is kind of a second chance story with a suspenseful theme.
The man was a walking sin just waiting to happen. And his smile simply amplified the effect. It was mesmerizing.

I quite enjoyed reading the Scottish brogue that made an appearance from time to time in the narrative. I'm not sure I can comment on the language until I read more historical stories. The revelation at the end, I so wasn't expecting it. It totally caught me by surprise. Especially the identity of the murderer. The story ends with an epilogue in March 1858 in London, eight months after the incidents that brought Alec and Connie together. It is, of course, a romance with a happy ever after and also some good news to tide over all the bad that happened. But it is also a romance with lots of investigations, suspense, chasing around and running away which will thrill you to no end.

P.S. There is a hint of another romance. I wonder if Alec's older brother Iain and Amelie's aunt Lorelie MacKinnon will get their own story.

Thank you to Entangled Publishing and NetGalley for an e-ARC of the book.

Originally posted on:
Shaina's Musings
Profile Image for Candace N.
318 reviews10 followers
December 11, 2019
The Sinful Scot by Maddison Michaels is the third book in her Saints and Scoundrels series. This story is an amazing addition to an already wonderful series. I absolutely loved the characters! I loved the chemistry between them. Alec was a strong, honourable, and protective hero who is extremely alluring. Connie is a heroine who has been hurting and afraid for a while. She has a hard time trusting men even though she knows not all men are cut from the same cloth. The heroine is very likeable. The story touches on some sensitive subjects but it is tastefully done. The writing is fantastic and has a mystery and suspense element to it that completely sucks you in. It’s not predictable and it’s easy to follow. Just a wonderful story all the way around.
Profile Image for Sarah.
142 reviews62 followers
December 7, 2019
Maddison Michaels is going on my auto buy list. This is another great story. Connie and Alec know each other from childhood but have not seen each other in years. Connie has become a Duchess to a horrible Duke who beats and rapes her all the time. Alec has become a doctor but is estranged from his family. Connie awakens one morning to find her husband dead in her bed and her brother in law accusing Connie of his murder. Alec helps her escape and they go on the run to clear her name. On the way they fall in love and heal each other.
This was good story. There were incorrect forms of address which will hopefully be fixed before it’s published.
Profile Image for Tween 2 Teen Book Reviews.
1,216 reviews76 followers
March 24, 2022
Before I get into the review, I want to give a content warning for the book. The book depicts a survivor of domestic violence, and may be tough for some readers.

I really enjoyed this book! I loved how Alex quickly got over any anger he might have had with Connie over childhood squabbles when he realized she needed help. Alex comes in preparing to dislike Connie, but his compassion quickly overtakes his annoyance. The book both has a good mystery and a great romance! Connie's abusive husband died mysteriously at the beginning of the book, and Connie is blamed. She knows she didn't do it, but is worried that the worst will happen if she and Alex can't find the real culprit. Connie had clearly suffered during her marriage, and I enjoyed watching her heal and come into her own. Connie went from scared of the world, to ready to conquer it. The secondary mystery plot is really strong in this book, which I really appreciate. Solid plots alongside the romance are always fun.
4 reviews
December 7, 2019
The Sinful Scot.
What do you get when you cross Jane Austen with Agatha Christie? You get Maddison MIchaels. Her new book, The Sinful Scot, is another page turner from this talented author. Set in a period where women were basically the property of their husband, with no legal rights and little choice but to turn a blind eye to extra marital affairs, Constance Campbell seems doomed to suffer at the hands of her cruel husband.
But, fate (and Maddison) have other plans for the beautiful Duchess of Kilmaine, and, when the handsome, yet brooding, Dr. Alec McGuiness is thrown into the mix, strap yourself in for a wild ride. If the sizzling chemistry, between the protagonists, isn’t enough to keep you reading, the fast paced action certainly will. I stayed up until two in the morning to finish it. I highly recommend this book to lovers of romance and mystery alike. Five stars from me.


Profile Image for Carole Burant.
1,277 reviews36 followers
January 1, 2020
Wow, what a story! I just finished reading "The Sinful Scot" and my first thought is "wow, this author sure knows how to write"!!! I realize that some readers might not like that the heroine is a physically abused wife at the start but if you give it a chance, the story really evolves and not only do you get passion and caring, you also get a murder mystery!! This is so well written, I was actually shocked when it's revealed who the murderer is, I never suspected that person!

Connie is a physically abused wife and when her husband is found murdered in her bed, she is accused of his murder and ends up on the run with the help of a longtime friend, Alec. I loved how gentle he was with her and could show her that most men were not like her husband. There are many twists and turns in this story that will keep you on your toes. Be prepared to not want to put the book down once you've started reading it!!

I received an ARC of this book via NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
Profile Image for eyes.2c.
3,112 reviews111 followers
January 20, 2020
Highlander regency romance thriller!

My sympathies certainly were with the abused duchess Constance Campbell, the Duchess of Kilmaine. Married to a vile Duke who used her as a punching bag, his arousel dependent upon inflicting pain.
When Constance awakes to find herself covered blood next to her husband who's been stabbed to death, she wonders if she's been the perpetrator.
So begins the journey for Connie to prove her innocence dogged by the law, her brother-in-law, and other mysterious forces. Her flight is engineered by her childhood friend Dr. Alec McGuiness.
Alec, betrayed in love (and that's a whole 'nother story) is a doctor. His sister has asked him to see how her friend is faring as they've lost touch. He attends the Duke's Ball and is not happy by what he intuits, and what he glimpses.
The path to proving Connie's innocence uncovers further dark dealings and evidence of depraved appetites having turned to murder. As death mysteriously follows Alec and Connie's escape, the novel becomes more of thriller than a romance.
I must admit that given Connie's brutalizations by the Duke her relations with Alec seemed a bit sudden to my mind, but Michaels seems to have tried to mitigate that through Connie's determination and Alec's empathy.
I was totally surprised by the ending. Galvanized by my enjoyment of The Sinful Scot, I find myself itching to read the rest of this series (that if this book is anything to judge the test of the series by). Michaels presents a rather different take in the Highlander / Regency romance genre.

An Entangled Publishing ARC via NetGalley
(I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own)
1,949 reviews18 followers
December 22, 2019
This is a beautiful love story that revolves around the murder of a Duke and numerous other people. Constance has been framed for the murder of her husband and Alec is helping her find proof of her innocence while keeping her safe at the same time. People are not who they appear to be and the murderer is finally uncovered but not before lives are lost. After being betrayed by the people he loved most, Alec has vowed to never again trust another woman with his heart. There is a HEA for Constance and Alec but a lot happens first. The book is full of danger, numerous murders, hidden agendas and a love story that is beautifully written. I enjoyed the story and the mystery and would highly recommend it as a great read.
Profile Image for Ghazal.
433 reviews9 followers
December 7, 2019
I received an ARC of this book from Netgalley. The Sinful Scot by Maddison Michaels is the first book I have read by this author, and she had me hooked from the very beginning of the story.
Constance and Alec McGuiness have known each other for a while, but circumstances lead them to escape from the law and determine the truth behind the murder of the Duke, Constance' husband. There is intrigue in this story, as well as a whodunnit aspect, but most importantly, there is the budding romance between the hero and heroine. A spectacular read!
3,542 reviews14 followers
January 27, 2020
The Sinful Scot is an outstanding historical romance by Maddison Michaels. I think this is my first book by this author, but wow, it won't be the last. Ms. Michaels has given readers a well-written book furnished with a stellar cast of characters. Constance tried to make her mother happy by marrying a duke. Unfortunately, he was an abusive, evil duke...until Constance woke up next to a dead duke. Alec arrived at the Duke's ball the night before he was murdered, only because he promised his friend he would check on Constance. Alec helps her escape after Constance's brother-in-law claims she killed the duke. Constance and Alec's story is packed with drama, humor, action, spice and suspense. I enjoyed every page of this book and look forward to reading more from Maddison Michaels in the future. The Sinful Scot is book 3 of the Saints & Scoundrels Series but can be read as a standalone. This is a complete book, not a cliff-hanger.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book that I received from NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Helen.
2,903 reviews64 followers
January 23, 2020
This one is emotional with so much happening there are issues about domestic abuse but also another gorgeous romance, MS Michaels has taken us on a journey that is action packed, as we get to see the gorgeous and caring Doctor Alec McGuiness find the love of his life in Constance Campbell, the Duchess of Kilmaine, there is a lot of mayhem before they get to their HEA but it is a journey that I truly enjoyed.

Constance grew up wanting to marry a Duke, she was sure that this would be the life for her and when she meets Duncan, The Duke of Kilmaine, and becomes his Duchess, her life is turned upside down he is a cruel beast and she hides behind a wall playing the perfect duchess, when she meets her old friend Alec at a ball her mind is taken back to another time in her life.

Alec is back in Scotland and attends a ball to check up on his old friend Connie and even though she would have nothing to do with him years before she still affects him enough to feel that something is not right with her life. When her husband is found murdered in their bed he helps her escape as she is accused of his murder, he must do what he can to protect her and find out who has set her up, and keep his feelings for her under control because love and marriage will never be for Alec after the people he has loved before have left him.

Oh my what a fabulous story this one is, MS Michaels knows how to write a story that will win the hearts of the readers, I loved Alec he is strong and caring, such a wonderful hero and Connie is strong and vulnerable at the same time, with its witty banter and danger around every corner threatening Alec and Connie, this one is a page turner and one I highly recommend, I have to say the Sottish Highlands is one of my favourite places for a story, this one is moving and emotional. MS Michaels has taken on some matters that sadly happen too often and treated them with respect and in a caring way, don’t miss this one.
Profile Image for Simply Love Book Reviews.
7,046 reviews870 followers
February 19, 2020
Constance Campbell (Connie) wanted to become royalty. All her life, she wanted to marry a Duke. To become a Duchess would be everything she ever wanted and more!! Even separating herself from her childhood friend, Alec, she knew what she was after in life to become happy.

However, one becoming the Duchess of Kilmaine, she realized that everything in royalty isn’t all she believed to be with her husband Duncan. Physically and verbally abusive, Duncan took any and everything out on her. Knowing this is NOT what she saw as her life, Connie knew this was how she would live to protect Duncan’s first duaghter (from his widow wife) Amelie.

Alec, visiting to check on his former flame and sister’s best friend, immediately knows something is wrong when he spies Connie at a ball her husband is holding. Knowing he has to protect her, he leaves, vowing to make sure that the rights are wronged.

Before Alec can take care of the Duke, he is murdered, and Connie, not being able to remember anything, is the prime suspect. Knowing she is not capable of murder, no matter what the Duke did to her, Dr. McGuinness (yes he’s a sexy Scottish Dr!!) vows to not only free her from the accusations, but from being scared of any man again…in his own way. His heart and his hands will cure any fear she has ever had.

This book gave me all the feels. Connie immediately clutched my heart with her abuse. Not knowing love by a man, and Alec stepping in to right the wrongs (knight in shining armor…ho hum 😍) had me crying and longing for Connie to have the happiness she so deserves.

Review copy provided for a voluntary review.
Profile Image for Samantha.
725 reviews31 followers
January 1, 2020
This was a painfully good read—painful because of the vicious subject matter; good because of the excellent writing and romance. TW are definitely needed before reading, but this was such a lovely book of starting over.
189 reviews1 follower
December 11, 2019
This book is not to be missed. Talk about a book that keeps you on your toes. Talk about villains. We have several. Her main characters mother, her husband, her brother-in-law. Connie’s life is filled with Villains. She also has a hero. Alex. Who is had his own life shattering incidents. And the whodunit part of this is fabulous. It keeps you guessing right to the end. And I love an extended epilogue. Especially one it alludes to possibly another book. I will be following this author to see if we can have a follow up. This is a book that you will love
Profile Image for Tracy Emro.
2,124 reviews64 followers
February 1, 2020
Constance “Connie” Campbell, the Duchess of Kilmaine thought being a Duchess would make her life perfect, but in reality it has become a nightmare. Her husband Duncan is a monster who beats her and makes her life hell. She is trapped in Scotland with no money and no family and even if she could leave, she wouldn’t leave Duncan’s daughter Amelie. She is sure Duncan killed his first wife and the only reason she is still alive is because her father structured her dowry to be paid in monthly payments – payments that would cease if she died.

When she sees her old childhood friend, Alec McGuiness at the ball her husband insists on holding each year, she pretends everything is fine. But Alec is a doctor and he sees through her lies, he lets her go, but decides to stick around awhile to learn what is going on. He leaves the ball and returns the next day to find all hell has broken loose – the duke is dead and Connie is the prime suspect. Alec helps her escape and vows to help her clear her name.
But the killer is clever, wily and hell-bent on framing Connie for not only the duke’s murder, but several others as well! Through it all Alec stands by Connie and helps her heal from not only the physical injuries, but also the mental and emotional trauma she has endured the last two years. Slowly, the girl he once knew starts to emerge and the heart he thought had long ago closed, begins to open.

I thought this was a very gripping read, the mystery portion of this book was amazing and the villain’s true identity came as a real surprise to me – I loved it! The romance was a little understated and frankly dull, but the heroine was a victim of abuse and I think the romance reflected that and was considerate to Connie’s experiences and the slow, understated burn was probably an accurate portrayal. I was disappointed that three books in this author is still butchering nobility titles and formal address, but if you can ignore that (then you are a better person than I am) the story itself is very good and the mystery is excellent. This is the third book in the series, but it can definitely be read as a stand-alone title.

*I am voluntarily leaving a review for an eARC that was provided to me by NetGalley and the publisher.*
Profile Image for EstelaReadsRomance .
334 reviews
January 9, 2020
Starring Constance “Connie” Campbell, the Duchess of Kilmaine and Dr. Alec McGuiness. Characters with history already established.

The first chapters of this book hurt... like really, really, really hurt my heart!! I felt so bad for Connie and the abuse that she had to endure in the hands of her husband. But she was such a magnificent heroine... her inner strength and determination to push through and survive day after day was just amazing.

Alec was an absolutely delicious hero, coming to Connie’s aid when she needed him the most. He totally knew when to comfort her and when to give her space. And I love that he kept resisting his attraction to her. The hero that protests love too much... fall the hardest.

I love Maddison Michaels and her writing style. She kept me at the edge of my seat with all the intrigue, but she didn’t lose sight of the fact that this was a romance book. She kept the delicious tension between Alec and Connie front and center. But I did gasp when she revealed who the killer was... I usually guess but, I was so engrossed in the story that it unfolded and surprised me!! Good job, Maddison Michaels!!

This is the 3rd book in the Saints and Scoundrels series! Can’t wait for Iain (Alec’s brother) and Lorelei’s story.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. I voluntarily review it and the comments are 100% my own.

My star system: 5 Stars
Ugly cried AF!!! Characters were amazing. Storyline kept me captivated. Made me wanna hug the author for writing a book that gave me all the feels!!
Profile Image for Lori D.
4,079 reviews130 followers
January 27, 2020
Scotland, 1857
A story that runs a gamut of emotions that tore at my heart from the first page as I had a strong visual and physical image of Connie in my mind. Maddison Michaels has an amazing gift with her pen that bring her characters alive and invest the reader in suspense, a mystery and a slow building romance that is beyond compare.
A mask of perfection. That is what she wore when she was forced to present herself at the ball her husband was hosting. The Duke. The Monster behind the smile. How fooled she had been, but at her mother's insistence she was to marry a title and endure.
Dr Alex McGuiness was reluctantly attending the ball due to the insistence of his sister Sophie, Connie's best friend. Alex had known her since she was young and sweet. But all that changed with her debut when it seemed all she cared about was her appearance and catching a Duke.
When he finally did see her, he knew something was wrong and figured it out. But she would not confide in him.
But everything changed the next morning when Connie woke up beside her husband who had been murdered. Blood everywhere. She remembered nothing....
Gripping, mesmerizing, page turning and a story I will not soon forget. One of the best books I have read, although not surprising coming from this author. I highly recommend!
2,440 reviews28 followers
January 13, 2020
This was a very engaging read right from the beginning. Not only was there romance but also an intriguing mystery. Connie has suffered abuse during her marriage and now she stands accused of murdering her husband. She has help from an old acquaintance, Dr. Alec MacGuiness. Alec has also had heartbreaking experiences in his past and has sworn never to love again. They work together to try and prove Connie’s innocence and unmask the true killer. Alec also has problems with his father and brother that he needs to work through. Connie will need to draw on her inner strength to overcome all her trials. I certainly didn’t work out who was the murderer. I enjoyed Alec’s and Connie’s growing relationship but could they commit to each other given their experiences? There seemed to be a love /hate relationship between Alex’s brother, Iain and the formidable Lady Lorelie MacKinnon and I would love to read their story. I received a copy and have voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
2,420 reviews22 followers
January 8, 2020
This story is what I imagine a penny dreadful would read like – murder, mayhem, mystery, villains and shocking conclusions. The mystery was really good and Ms. Michaels throws in a lot of red herrings. Even though I figured it out close to the end but was only partially correct, the mystery was so good. The story was interspersed with the romance between Alec and Connie. Two great characters. Connie is a fighter and a survivor. Her character is so strong. I loved her. And the other characters are so well written. I want more of this type of storyline. I am hoping the next between is about an ornery brother and his arch nemesis.

I received a complimentary copy from the publisher through NetGalley.
Profile Image for Becky (romantic_pursuing_feels).
1,283 reviews1,710 followers
February 24, 2020
Safety issues are found in this book, including

Constance, or Connie, has secured a duke for a husband and left her friend Alex McGuiness in the past. Being a naive, young debutante, with a ruthless mother only after the best title, she found herself trapped in a hell of a marriage where abuse was a daily ritual. She has no one in her escape this life and just tries to survive, cherishing the days her husband leaves town or becomes inebriated and passes out.

Alec has become a respected doctor and due to his mutual friendships, he would like to speak the Connie and relay her wellbeing. However, when he finds her at Duke Kilmaine's ball, he can see past her cold facade and see the bruises underneath. She tries to push him away to protect him, but he perseveres and provides his protection.

Soon they are both on the run and only have each other. The mystery and relationship progress along with plenty of action happening too.

This is so not my thing, and that is because it's a total murder mystery. I did find it intriguing the first 30% and then when the relationship took second to the ever evolving murder plot, I started to lose more interest. It's not bad, or poorly written, and I think if you love some mystery, or solving a murder mixed with romance this would be a great choice. It deals with serious issues without being overly graphic. But it's definitely not a warm and fuzzy romance, but it falls short of maybe Kerrigan Byrne's writing. Its not that I need a warm and fuzzy romance though, in fact I much prefer an angsty, gritty, graphic novel, but that tension and relationship needs to be carried strongly through the book and I just didn't feel that here in this novel. I did think with everything the heroine had experienced, she moved into a new relationship fairly fast, yet it also felt not soon enough within the book to build a good tension (to me). Again this is just because so much was spent on the developing plot. It did keep me guessing, which was good. I also didn't get quite the character depth I wanted, but I didn't dislike either character.

I would definitely try this author again though, if I found one that was a bit more focused on the romance and relationship building.

I give 3 stars.
This is my first book by this author.

I was able to receive an ARC copy complimentary from netgalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Profile Image for Ruchika Mahajan.
591 reviews8 followers
December 21, 2019
This is my first book by the author. I was impressed by her writing style. The story was fast paced with elements of intrigue and romance. Constance was a strong woman. After enduring so much she really blossomed with Alex. Alex was a very likeable hero. It was fun to see their budding romance. They were always attracted to each other but circumstances drifted then apart. Heir interactions were very entertaining. Would love to read the next book in this series
Profile Image for Nicole.
1,251 reviews99 followers
March 14, 2020
As a young debutante vaunted for her ethereal beauty, Constance Campbell was determined to settle for nothing less than a duke. Now the Duchess of Kilmaine has learned to be careful what she wishes for. As she suffers at the hands of her cruel husband, Duncan, Connie hides her true pain from everyone, even the childhood friend who comes to check on her.

Dr. Alec McGuiness had no desire to return to Scotland, especially not to check on the one woman who ever got under his skin, but he finds he cannot refuse his dear friend's request to check on her friend. Alec knew how high Connie's aims were and despite being an earl's son, he knew his status as a professional and a younger son would never be lofty enough for her. But when Alec sees Connie he knows immediately that something is very wrong and when the Duke is murdered in bed, next to a sleeping Connie no less, Alex knows he must help Connie and keep her from being framed for the murder.

In order to keep her brother-in-law from having her committed to an asylum, or worse hanged for murder, Connie finds herself on the run. She enjoys this slight bit of freedom but is dismayed by her attraction to Alec, who has devoted himself to keeping her safe. Though she finds herself increasingly comfortable with Alec, Connie is afraid to ever give a man power over her again. For his part, Alec remembers all too well the snobbish, catty girl Connie used to be and has no wish to have his heart broken again as it was when he was betrayed by the girl he'd once hoped to marry. With more secrets coming out about Connie's late husband, her feelings for Alec may be a moot point.

As a survivor of severe domestic abuse, Connie had a lot of issues to deal with. Alec also had trust issues after having his heart broken by both his parents and the girl he'd hoped to marry. Connie was rather nasty to Alec when they were younger, as she was unabashedly focused on marrying a title, but despite this Alec cannot abandon his childhood friend when she's in such dire straits. Connie starts to come into her own without her domineering mother or late husband getting in the way and I liked that it is she who pursues a deeper relationship with Alec and it is Alec who pulls away.

There were lots of characters in this one and at times I struggled to keep straight who was who and what their motivations were. There were also some issues with incorrect forms of address, some awkward phrasing and a huge overuse of the word darn in particular, but this is just down to my pet peeves and will likely be fixed in final edits. This story had plenty of intrigue, which I liked, but somehow the story still seemed to drag in places, especially between Alec and Connie. Many of Connie's inner monologues became rather repetitive to me, which is probably why I perceived a lag in the story, and all the descriptions of her great beauty got a bit old after awhile. Nonetheless, the mystery was good and I really did enjoy the story.

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

https://mustreadalltheromance.blogspo...
4 reviews1 follower
December 27, 2019
What a wonderful read this was. I very much enjoyed Dr Alec and Connie’s romance, and found myself cheering on Connie as she reclaimed her inner strength that a terrible marriage had nearly destroyed. And Alec, oh my, what a hunk. This book was an excellent additional to Ms Michaels Saints and Scoundrels series, and dealt with some really relevant issues that at the time were generally hushed up. I imagine it would have been difficult balancing a romance with a heroine that had been physically abused - but Ms Michaels did it deftly. I’m already looking forward to what I hope is Lorelie and Ian’s story for book 4... Thanks to the publisher for an arc copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Sonia N..
996 reviews65 followers
January 1, 2021
I listened to this amazing book on Audible and it's narrated by the wonderfully talented Justine Eyre!!

This is such a great storyline, it has murder, mystery and romance. It also touches on physical abuse by a spouse, which is never okay. But, the way it was written n this story went well with the plot.

Constance Campbell is the Duchess of Kilmeade and wakes up to find herself a widow. Connie as she is known by is an English beauty, she comes from dysfunctional parents.
Dr. Alec McGuinness is visiting Connie to check on her welfare, when he finds himself helping her escape the Kilmeade estate.
Alec McGuinness is the second of an Earl, Alec practices medicine in London, and has known her for years.
This is a really well written murder, mystery with a who done it?! It has so many characters, the story line flowed so well throughout the book. I couldn't stop listening to it. Such an addictive book with so much action.
And, Alec Mc Guinness, omg, he is gorgeous, masculine and attracted to Connie, and the attraction is mutual. I really loved this book, and I always enjoy epilogues, this one was such a good one =)
Profile Image for Janet.
5,174 reviews66 followers
January 21, 2020
Constance Campbell, the Duchess of Kilmaine, once believed that all she needed in life was a duke. But everything unravelled when she realized her perfect husband was a perfect monster. Dr. Alec McGuiness reluctantly finds himself back in Scotland, and checking up on the only woman to ever get under his skin, Connie. After she spurned him many years ago, he knows his humble life as a doctor could never be enough for her. But when the Duke of Kilmaine is murdered in cold blood, with Connie sleeping right next to him in bed, Alec knows he must protect Connie at all costs from those who would frame her for the duke’s murder.
This is the third book in the series & yes it stands on its own but there is a connection between the characters & quite honestly the books are just SO good I’d recommend reading in order. This is another very well written book, it's hard to believe it’s only the author's third novel. The characters have lots of depth. I loved the chemistry between Alec & Connie & how they wanted to remain friends. I loved how Connie grew in confidence & how Alec valued her for herself. Parts of the book especially the start are heart wrenching & was taken on a plethora of emotions from crying to laughing. Once again I was drawn in from the start & found it very hard to put it down, I love romance but also love mysteries so to have the two combined made my day. There were twists to the mystery & I certainly didn’t guess who the murderer was. An engrossing, enthralling read, which I loved.
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
Profile Image for Stephanie (Bookfever).
1,104 reviews198 followers
May 2, 2025
The Sinful Scot featured dr. Alec McGuinness who'm we have met before in the other books. The story also introduced us to a new character: Constance Campbell, the Duchess of Kilmaine. Married to an abusive husband, Constance is in fear every moment of her life, scared that she'll say or do the wrong thing that might set him off. Until one day she wakes up next to her husband who's covered in blood with a knife shoved into his chest. Did she finally snap and killer her husband? Or was there someone else who wanted him dead? Luckily she has Alec McGuinness, an old friend coming to her rescue and going on the run with her to try and find out who is behind the murder.

This book had a little bit of a more heavy topic, considering the abuse that Connie has been going through for the last few years since she got married. And in my opinion Maddison Michaels wrote this very well and realistic. I also loved Connie and Alec's chemistry together. They had somewhat of a past together and it clearly showed in their interactions, which had sparks flying! They may even be my favorite couple out of all three books. I enjoyed reading about them so much!

I really liked how this story was a bit of a historical romance meets a murder mystery. It's always fun to try and figure out who the killer is. I ended up being partly right and partly wrong. I had a feeling of who the murderer was but I had no idea who they really turned out to be. No spoilers though!


Just like the previous two books in the Saints & Scoundrels series I highly enjoyed this one, The Sinful Scot. It took place in Scotland (as the title would suggest) and it's quite the page-turner. I was really hooked by the characters and the story that was both romantic and thrilling at the same time. Maddison Michaels has definitely become a new favorite historical romance author of mine.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 122 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.