Say it with me: currently hovering between 3.5 and a four star. This did wonders to yank me from my historical romance reading slump (no shade on the sub genre; simply too much of a good thing). This read quite differently from its predecessor and I'll explain soon:
Pros/Interesting Elements
-Contained Plot
*Unlike the first novel, this one has Freya and Arrow trekking to the dreaded Goblin Queen's (AKA the former Winter Princess/Goblin King's adoptive sister) palace in the Winter Court. Allies were intact, and as a reader, I got a feel for the icy surroundings instead of getting secondhand whiplash trying to keep up with the courts.
-Opening Line
*"They plotted rebellion over a cup of earl grey tea". Nowadays, I'm strictly an herbal tea girl... however, that tea name takes me back! Took me forever to get the brewing time/add in's just right (so, hang in there, Arrow), but when I did, the scent of bergamot was heaven incarnate.
-Being Human/Breaking the Mold
*Most "chosen one" stories have the heroine go from "What?! But I can't be doing this? I'm just a girl..." then two chapters later, they wield their weapon of choice like a boss. But here, Freya has qualms till the end about:
1.Fighting correctly (no training montages here; it's all about that mental warfare, and when she does fight back, it's the way many of us would with no formal training: lots of kicking/elbowing their assailant).
2.Killing the admittedly horrible Goblin Queen (I mean, she eventually gets her with a special knife, but the act makes Freya physically sick, recalling the sound the weapon made tearing through the woman's heart and how even though the Queen treated her badly, Freya stayed by her side, refusing to let her die alone).
3.Has few allies seeing as she's mortal (despite being in love with a man of authority/their race, they don't just fawn all over her, also prior to her journey into the Fae realm, she openly despised Goblins. She admits this fear won't fade overnight, but she's learning to banish what she was conditioned to believe).
-Metaphorical vs. Physical Journey
*Freya complains she's taken one step forward and three steps back, seeing as she achieved victory over the Goblin King, and now must free him/face another royal threat. Yeah, she uses her feet to journey into the Winter Court with Arrow, but once they get there, they're separated, to the point where we really don't see Arrow and she's got to face the threat solo.
*Also, is the series "repetition" an extended metaphor for growing up/annoyances of adulting? Just when Freya thinks she's in control, a similar/slightly twisted task must be completed. Kind of like how life throws curve balls/obstacles right when you've got a handle on things (got a better job, but then they hike up your rent sort of deal) and now you've got to cope with the hopefully minor in the long run issue.
-Sibling Struggle
*It's interesting that Esther was the one who craved adventure, but has now settled down/forced to hold down the fort while Freya, the one who wanted the quiet life, must go off on a perilous journey.
-Romance
*It's definitely not as in your face as other Labyrinth homages, but to say it's sidelined is flippant (yeah, Freya's taking down the queen to clean up the mess/save the goblins, but it's also because at the journey's end, she's hoping she'll know what to do about these pesky feelings she's caught for G.K.).
*His "there's always time for romance" and not a page later "there's no right time for romance", their kiss, and his begging her to let him stay the night, just to feel her next to him... Perfection.
*Also, when Freya brings up her sister's odd marriage, G.K. asks "Do you think a goblin and a human could fall in love?", as well as the fact that the reason she's able to see him at all is because he's using all his magic to project himself into her presence... I'm rambling/listing at this point, but who cares? Its my review.
-Meta Ref/Breaking the Mold
*The G.K. claims her affection makes no sense, seeing as he's the villain in her story, referring to the idea that they're living a fairy tale, and that your enemy shouldn't wind up comforting you. Kind of saw this as picking out the harmful nature that in the wrong hands, could turn the trope of enemies to lovers deadly.
*Freya is not only on a hero's journey, but is called the hero on multiple occasions by G.K. as a term of endearment, while his being held captive by one woman and saved by another sends a nice feminist message to me. G.K. is not only the damsel in distress, but an authority figure at the mercy of a lower class outlier.
-Gothic Imagery/Tension
*I mean, the moment they arrive in Winter Court, Freya's fingers feel like they're about freeze off (we've all forgotten our gloves at some point...), but it's when she's forced to slide down into the icy dark tunnel, knowing that because her hands are tied, she's got no way of catching herself from hitting something that ups the ante. The men escorting her don't care whether she makes it or not, and her realizing that one wrong move means she's left to bleed out or freeze to death should she turn wrong... chills and not the windy kind, either
*The Goblin Queen freezes one of her guards to death and tips his crystalized body over, and it's described as "spilling out perfectly pebbled baubles, like rubies pouring from a jewelry box". Eerie.
*The dancers the Queen has trapped for amusement are destroying their feet with every step: Freya watches their feet bleeding, skin tearing with each turn, lovely skirts shield most eyes from the sound/sight of bloody flesh sticking to the floor, ripping with each tug. Jesus, took me back to my Point Horror days, there.
-Seasonal Symbolism
*Not so hard to see here, but winter, in lit. represents death. With the Goblin Queen now in control, it's the death of free will, competent rule, and free speech (if you don't agree with what she wants, she'll have more "rubies" to put in her jewelry box.. watch your back...)
Fairy Tale/Misc. Refs.
-Snow White
*When the queen asks what color she'd like to wear, Freya goes "White, seeing as it's your kingdom's color... white as snow and all." Very Snow White whose skin was described as white as snow.
*The G.K. lets it slip that the queen tried dressing Freya in dowdy colors to hide her beauty, seeing as the queen's afraid Freya will outshine her, also has insecure Evil Queen/stepmother vibes who made sure Snow was thought of as less than.
-Misc./Various
*Freya being tricked by the table laden with food which, upon tasting it, finds it's gone ice cold and inedible had me remembering...
1.In the film, Labyrinth, Jareth makes Hoggle give Sarah an enchanted peach, which looked appealing from the outside.
2.Neil Jordan's The Company of Wolves, had our RRH biting into a beautiful shiny red apple, only to to spit it out two seconds later because a worm made its home in the core.
3.In another Labyrinth inspired novel, Wintersong, that Goblin King gives Liesel, his new bride, a bowl of her favorite fruit, strawberries. Strawberries so juicy, they stain her fingertips scarlet. But upon biting into one, it turns to ash in her mouth/makes it difficult to swallow.
Labyrinth Elements
-The back cover ends with "...Unless she's willing to go through hardships unnumbered", harkening back to the famous line from the film: "Through dangers untold and hardships unnumbered".
-Freya tells Arrow that the queen reorders the corridors so people lose their way, sort of like how Sarah tried to Hansel and Gretel her way through the labyrinth using red lipstick to mark the tiles. Come to find out, little goblins living beneath the floor rearrange the tiles, making her arrows useless.
-Just like the film, there's a sinister ballroom scene.
-A character claims "he's-G.K.- moved time and space for you" reminiscent of Jareth's "I've turned the world upside down and I've done it all for you", declaration.
-The G.K. wears an open chested white collar shirt and during his kidnapping and donned a velvet coat prior. Jareth, is that you?
Cons
-Over Explaining
*A lot of the cleverness was tarnished by the author jumping in and stating exactly what characters and even objects meant, wasting an extra paragraph to do it. Insults a reader's intelligence, really.
-Repetition
*Early on, Freya makes note that Arrow and Lux will argue till they're blue in the face. And then a the next chapter begins: "They argued till they were blue in the face". Could we not have this be the last line of a chapter and the next one begin, "and blue in the face they were by argument's end, no progress made, not a single compromise". Just flows better.
-Why couldn't the actual dress have made it on the cover?
*What even is this breezy blue thing? Couldn't have been Freya's; she says she's been stuck in traveling clothes. Plus, her real dress was midnight blue, dotted with silver stars. Beautiful.
-Grammatical Error
*One of the queen's goblin guards, says about his friend turned rubies, that their mother's told them to look after one another... Umm, did you mean "mothers"?
-Where in the World are These Elves You Speak Of?
*Seriously, am I supposed to infer the Winter Court houses elves, not goblins? 'Cause I'm pretty sure the author called the race of creatures, goblins throughout, not elves... Maybe I'm wrong...
All in all, I think this was entertaining, a real feast for the eyes. I could go on about the dangerous décor of the queen's court (ex: frozen icicles hang from the ceiling, like ribbons torn from ball gowns), but honestly, I want some fan to make a miniseries out of these books: they read like serials. One book could be a whole season. Someone with time, talent, and true vision, get on it!