Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
This is book 1 in the Good Harbor Witches Cozy Mystery series.
Carly Cooper and her sister, Dana, live in the coastal town of Good Harbor, Maine where they belong to a small community quilting club. Only their “community” is a group of witches, warlocks, and a vampire who are terrible at magic. A non-magical town citizen who moved to Hollywood fifteen years ago is returning to film a new series and the mayor wants the quilting club to plan a party for the famous actress. Trouble brews when the assistant to the actress is found dead with strange markings on her forehead.
Will Carly, Hazel her pet raven, Dana, and their friends find the clues to a killer before he or she strikes again?

153 pages, Kindle Edition

First published May 15, 2021

227 people are currently reading
55 people want to read

About the author

J.A. Whiting

168 books319 followers
USA TODAY Bestselling Author and Amazon All Star, J A Whiting is the author of over 100 cozy mysteries. She lives with her family in Massachusetts. Whiting loves spending time with family, reading, traveling, cycling, following New England sports teams, exercising, and being outdoors.

For exclusive content and new book announcements please visit www.jawhiting.com and sign up for my mailing list.

Also please "like" my Facebook page www.facebook.com/jawhitingauthor

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
167 (49%)
4 stars
112 (32%)
3 stars
49 (14%)
2 stars
8 (2%)
1 star
4 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews
Profile Image for Tari.
3,653 reviews103 followers
July 16, 2021
A fun and unique cozy featuring witches who stink at magic but are great at quilting. Chad, the only guy and a vampire as well has it a little backward with being really terrible at quilting, lol. But the group was just different enough that it kept my interest going. That raven familiar of Carly's named Hazel was cracking me up! Somehow I could picture Reba as her voice, lol.

I really had no clue whodunit, the showdown was pretty exciting, and I'm going to enjoy getting to know the members of this group even better when I borrow the second book on KU.
61 reviews2 followers
May 20, 2021
Not good!

I managed six chapters before giving up. I had difficulty understanding what this was about. When two authors are writing a book it should be seamless but I felt I could identify the two different minds as the storyline developed. The snarky starlet looking down on everyone. The unassuming feeble witch with sewing skills that we hadn't had displayed yet. I love the Sweet Cove mysteries that J.A. Whiting has written as sole author, but only a couple of the series co-written have appealed to me. Sorry but this one hadn't made the cut.
2,009 reviews
June 5, 2022
Book #1 in the series and it will be the only one I attempt to read. the characters were one-dimensional, the plot felt hackneyed and I only slogged through one-third. Not for me!

Amazon synopsis:
This is book 1 in the Good Harbor Witches Cozy Mystery series.
Carly Cooper and her sister, Dana, live in the coastal town of Good Harbor, Maine where they belong to a small community quilting club. Only their “community” is a group of witches, warlocks, and a vampire who are terrible at magic. A non-magical town citizen who moved to Hollywood fifteen years ago is returning to film a new series and the mayor wants the quilting club to plan a party for the famous actress. Trouble brews when the assistant to the actress is found dead with strange markings on her forehead.
Will Carly, Hazel her pet raven, Dana, and their friends find the clues to a killer before he or she strikes again?
Profile Image for Linda.
1,377 reviews
July 21, 2022
Not bad

When the quilting ladies get wrangled into organizing a party for a celebrity returning home, the pressure of pleasing the diva is almost too great. After her assistant is murdered, and it looks like a magical potion gone wrong was the cause of death, Carly decides to look into who had motive before one of her friends ends up in jail. The problem is, none of them where great at magic and a few look like good candidates for wanting to murder the celebrity. Now Carly has to protect someone she doesn't like and catch the killer.
835 reviews2 followers
July 25, 2021
Another witch who is unsure of her ability when it comes to the use of her powers. A group of quilters who are also unsure about their skills and seem to not do anything but talk about it instead of practicing. A friend is harmed it seems that the police are stumped. Unable to say she is a witch but finds she must use her skills to help solve the mystery. It was a cute short read on a rainy day with a cup of coffee
958 reviews2 followers
March 5, 2023
Murder

Wendy returns to town to celebrate the start of her new TV show. Her assistant is murdered and every magic user especially Carly since her magic usually goes wrong. Wendy is very demanding in what she wants for her party. Rachel is trying to get Logan to give the party to her. Tells Logan he's not up to Wendy's standards. Didn't really care for story, too slow.
351 reviews5 followers
June 22, 2024
Really a cute and easy read

I liked that these witches aren't perfect, nor even adept, at their magic. Being a quilter myself helps me relate...A little. The mystery was good. I couldn't solve the crime even if I had a bit of magic.
The characters were well portrayed and fleshed out. They plot well layed out and completed... No cliff hangers, I'm reading for book two.
Profile Image for Neena Christianson Martin.
1,185 reviews11 followers
May 18, 2021
Misfits

The town's quilting club is made up of witches and a vampire, none of them very good with magic, you could almost call them cursed. When a famous native returns to town it's up to the misfits to keep her safe.
146 reviews2 followers
June 1, 2021
Interesting new series.

A new series by J A Whiting always grabs my attention. This book didn't disappoint. Fun as well as interesting. A good mystery. I'm looking forward to the next book.
Profile Image for Myra Ball.
649 reviews
January 7, 2022
Pleasantly Surprised

I don't usually like hobby themed mysteries much but this first book of this series was entertaining. J.A. Whiting is a pro at the paranormal cozy mystery and this story is quite good.
44 reviews
January 11, 2024
Fun to read

Loved the plot with twists and turns, and was surprised by who the killer was. Excellent writing and good editing as well.
I recommend this book as good, easy read 📚 with a heap of drama and suspense
710 reviews1 follower
June 17, 2024
Sew Dead

Great story. I love the quilting inserts but I have to admit that her getting her magic taken away was scary. I hope they all learn to control their magic and keep working together for good. 👍
Profile Image for Nigel Syin.
21 reviews11 followers
August 1, 2025
So why the misleading titled?

It's titled SEW Dead, it's needlecraft connection is quilting rather than sewing, there's very little quilting reference, and what exists isn't relevant to the plot.
Profile Image for JANE VAN HORN.
2,099 reviews12 followers
May 17, 2021
New series

This is the first book in a great new series by J A Whiting. I can't wait to see what happens next.
164 reviews3 followers
June 20, 2021
There were a few pages where this book was entertaining. The rest was just meh. I really enjoy JA Whiting’s books she’s written solo, but this collaboration fell flat.
Profile Image for Matthew Murray.
1,002 reviews
September 28, 2021
Enjoyed

This was the first book in this series of yours that I have read and enjoyed the characters and story line are fun to read.
974 reviews3 followers
October 14, 2021
A good Harbor witches mystery #1

An interesting story, one I accidentally grabbed on Kindle to thinking it was another. I really enjoyed the characters and the storyline.
Profile Image for Stephen Levesque.
2,808 reviews
December 30, 2021
This has unique storytelling in this series. Love the characters. The development of them was easy and blended well into the story line. Great Reading Everyone!
Profile Image for Tyrannosaurus regina.
1,199 reviews26 followers
March 7, 2022
I feel like the book didn't really know what it wanted to be, and lacked a lot of focus. It took me forever to finish because every time I put it down I basically forgot it existed.
Profile Image for Sanderella.
522 reviews
January 17, 2024
This was a refreshing book that I needed after the last book I read!! On to the next!! 👸💜👸
Profile Image for Juliet Minerva Swift.
820 reviews15 followers
November 9, 2023
Another first book in a series written by this author! I am starting to get them all a bit mixed up in my head, but this one had a stronger paranormal element that differentiated it from other books.

I like that Carly is not great with magic, it definitely makes for an interesting character that is trying to improve, and adds a layer of difficulty in solving the mystery, since it would be too easy if she could just figure it all out with a spell at the start.

The quilting aspect is not my favourite, I have never done anything remotely similar, and I can’t say I’m super interested, but it’s a nice change from the usual bookshop or bakery.

The mystery was sort of on the simple side, I could tell that I was satisfied with the resolution anyway.
Displaying 1 - 23 of 23 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.