Non abbiamo più spazio per i vestiti che acquistiamo compulsivamente? Siamo curiosi di sapere come possiamo fare la differenza nella battaglia sul cambiamento climatico? Partecipiamo alla rivoluzione di Orsola de Castro e impariamo a vestirci con abiti belli, a farli durare a lungo, in armonia con la nostra personalità e con il pianeta. Nei Vestiti che ami vivono a lungo, Orsola de Castro, stilista e fondatrice di Fashion Revolution, ci parla di moda, di estetica, di taglia-e-cuci, del piacere di vestirci costruendo al contempo una nostra identità. Ma il suo è anche un libro politico, scritto da una donna che per decenni ha operato nel fashion system, che da dentro ne ha potuto conoscere la volatilità, le contraddizioni, gli sprechi, addirittura i crimini, e che ha deciso di lavorare per trasformarlo radicalmente. E la sua forza sta nel farci capire che la vera politica incomincia da scelte individuali, da gesti quotidiani che appartengono al nostro vissuto collettivo, come prendere in mano un ago e un filo per riparare qualcosa che altrimenti siamo costretti a buttare. E scoprire che è un gesto non solo necessario, ma anche bello: perché rimanda a saperi perduti e capaci di rendere tutto ciò che è standardizzato e impersonale incredibilmente unico e simile a noi.
I expected to love this book. I at least wanted to like it. But for me, it just didn't deliver on its promise. What's actually here? A few clothing-care tips, some details on repair and remodelling that you could get from any secondhand 20th-century household management or needlework book, some descriptions of fabric types, and a breakdown of washing label instructions that you could find on Wikipedia. Some information on environmental impact and sweatshops that any halfway-informed person would already know. Some statistics and facts - but for me these couldn't all be trusted once I discovered I knew some of them were actually false (no, folks, people in 1300 didn't think lambs were grown on trees and Baumwolle is tree-wool, not wool-tree...). I'm from a family who always sewed, who bought and sold secondhand clothes, who were in the clothing industry, who were department-store clothing buyers, I grew up mending, embellishing, remodelling, wearing clothes from jumble-sales and charity shops out of choice not poverty, and so I'm perhaps being harsh but this book taught me nothing new. The author"s middle-class assumptions of how others treat their clothes grates on me, and I feel little empathy with someone who says she's considering buying an extra freezer to keep near her laundry specifically for freezing her jeans and who gives a recipe for dying clothes pink using avocado (I nearly gave up at that point, but ploughed on!). Aside from the content, the gimmicky graphics and irrelevant sparse illustrations detract from the reading experience. Now I feel I might have been churlish. If this book makes someone think differently about how they buy and use clothing, then it will have done the good its author obviously intended, and that person will obviously give it a higher rating. But I feel I'm not the target audience. From me, one star at most. Once my partner has read it, I will definitely pass this book on rather than keep it!
Perhaps the most innovative idea is that mending should be institutionalized, rather than falling on individuals. While certain major papers like the Guardian are on board with the idea that we need to make our clothes last, we're still hyper-focused on individual action. Since some people (my visually impaired boyfriend, for instance) can't learn to sew and others have limited time, we need to recognize that sewing - and re-soling shoes, fixing bags, etc - are a valuable skill imbued with cultural heritage. We need professionals on every high street and a culture that normalizes taking our stuff in for repair.
De Castro's central thesis is that there is no such thing as throwing clothes away, because our "away" is inevitably somebody else's here: it's vast bales of fabric polluting waterways and destroying local textile industries in Ghana, it's noxious incineration fumes sickening communities. The devastating human and environmental impact of fast fashion creates a moral imperative to kick our addiction, she argues.
She displays surprisingly little interest in making one's own clothes, admitting early on that she's never been much good at sewing. This approach makes the book accessible to those who are daunted by anything beyond repairing a hem. I felt the idea was implicit, too, that sewing your own clothes from scratch is not only a highly developed skill, it still involves consumption of new resources.
The book is also packed with historical insights that encourage us to think about the layers of cultural meaning behind our clothes - especially the brief history of denim.
According to a Guardian interview, the book was written in just four months, and like a sweatshop T shirt, the rush shows in the quality. Vast tracts are dedicated to top-down overviews of problems that have already received extensive coverage elsewhere: slavery in cotton, exploitation in sweatshops, microplastics in water. She quotes extensively from No Logo by Naomi Klein, but given that book's status as an established classic, I can't have been the only reader to sigh: yes, we know. In some cases, references are entirely lacking.
It would have benefited from close reporting and a series of thorough interviews. The entire last chapter consisted of trite suggestions built out into whole sections for the purpose of completing her year-round challenge. The idea that weddings are a major contributor to single-use outfits could have been covered in two sentences.
I was also bothered by an odd ambiguity or inconsistency in her arguments. On the one hand, most of the book is dedicated to discussing how fashion is an industry shot through with exploitation, environmental devastation, elitism, and cruelty, how the most ethical garment is the garment you already own, and how mending is a fine and almost infinitely flexible skill. To me as a reader, the logical conclusion is: don't buy clothes. Once you own enough quality pieces, it should almost never be necessary. Yet, with whiplash-inducing about turns, after a section on the evils of both real and fake fur, we are treated to a section on how to buy fur. She references "your regular T shirt shop", but by her own logic, there should be no such thing.
More broadly, her argument appears to be a version of the point that there is no ethical consumption in capitalism, but somehow, she never quite gets there. She is at times quite aware of the limitations of placing the responsibility on individuals (institutionalized mending) but at others, strangely enthusiastic on ludicrously impractical propositions such as everyone starting to handwash their lingerie after a shower, because the burden is apparently on us to stop our clothes shedding microplastics. Whether handwashing addresses this problem at all is a question she doesn't answer. At one point, she even confesses that she is considering buying a second freezer to freeze her clothes rather than washing them in an effort to prevent this problem. She doesn't appear to have thought about the environmental impact of electrodomestic goods here.
The author is clearly aware that hints of a hemp sackcloth future will put readers off, and is at pains to stress that affordable, attractive clothing means that hideous clothing as a marker of poverty, class and shame is a thing of the past. Perhaps some of these ambiguities are an endeavour to avoid appearing too radical. But in a world where the major challenge of climate change is that putative solutions never go far enough, many elements of her argument fail to convince.
While the idea behind this book was rooted in a principle I strongly agree with, the execution was poor. While reading you can (rather irritatingly) sense the author has another agenda. This is a piece of writing which indulges a self-righteous author's fantasy. However worst of all was the hypocrisy, I felt many of the pages were simply being filled for the sake of it, wasting precious paper, quite going against her environmental high horse stance.
I agree 100% with the premise of this book! I just thought it was a bit all over the place. Who was the audience supposed to be? Normal people who wash their own clothes? Or fashion industry insiders? Maybe it tried to do too much: provide a history of fashion, some “how to mend” content, an argument for valuing clothes, a listing of environmental disasters and building collapses... Instead of this, please read Modern Mending and How to Break up with Fast Fashion.
I enjoyed this book to begin with however as soon as it got to the natural dyeing page I lost interest as it gives false information. The book claims a post dye salt bath is a mordant however that is simply untrue. So from there I lost trust in other information given. The chapter about different fibres could have been a really useful resource however some sections like the acrylic section is lazily written.
Really enjoyed this book - an intelligent look at sustainable fashion from a fashion insider who knows her subject from experience. Alongside facts and figures about the garment industry there is a simple message; cherish your clothes, mend them and care for them, and know where they come from, be sure that the people who make them and the raw materials are employed safely and fairly.
Davvero chiaro e completo. In Italia ci sono pochi libri sulla tematica della sostenibilità nel settore della moda e delle conseguenze che porta il fast fashion a livello ambientale e sociale. Ottimo libro con il quale potersi approcciare/approfondire sulla tematica
Great thesis about how it is revolutionary to wear old clothes, and being written by a fashion insider, the book provides a unique perspective. However, the mishmash of fonts, text sizes, quotes, and disorganized presentation make it hard to follow the thread. By the end I was skimming.
Loved Clothes Last was a fairly interesting read. At times, I liked the content, and at others, it was just okay.
There is a good amount of intersection with Aja Barber's Consumed, which is another lockdown literary baby.
Orsola de Castro is known (not to me) for her upcycled clothing brand, and I wish that she had devoted more space to upcycling information! Several times throughout the book, she mentions crocheting holes to salvage a moth eaten sweater, but she never tell us how to do it! Instead she tells us how to make a skirt of out men's shirts or old jeans. 😑
"Clothing companies no longermake clothing, they sell it ." Amen, sister!
A lot of this is extremely helpful and timely; it's a call to action, so doesn't get in all the weeds, but I'd still have liked her to get more into the class and racial differences and inequalities that make some of the things she suggests more difficult for certain groups of people. But it's good and it's changed my habits!
Sehr angenehm zu lesen. Vieles war mir bekannt, aber die Zusammenstellung in einem Buch hat mir trotzdem sehr gut gefallen. Neben Kapiteln zu Materialien und ihren sozialen und ökologischen Auswirkungen z.B. auch ein Kapitel zu “cultural appropriation vs. cultural appreciation” :) Mit kleinen Anekdoten aus ihrem Leben in der Fashionbranche und dem persönlichen Alltag, die den Text auflockern.
A really inspirational book about changing how we shop for clothes and how we look after the ones we have, written by someone who loves clothes. The message is a simple and well supported one, don't buy things you don't love and trust and look after them when you have them.
A timely warning concerning the wasteful clothes industry. The level of waste is truly shocking, and we all buy into this. Orsola de Castro reminds us to buy less, and extend the life of clothes by mending and adapting; once created they are on the planet for a long time, and if they contain plastic, do not rot away . .
Some genuinely interesting points and ideas, but as expressed by other reviewers, short-sightedly close to the author.
I was looking for something that would go into a lot of detail into the 'make do and mend mentality', but this didn't cut it.
The book reads like an unproofread self-published affair.
As one commenter shrewdly remarked, this book is essentially hypocritical- despite featuring an impressive amount of buzz words in its title, loudly proclaiming itself as an ecologically published book, and given the subject matter itself- it is immensely wasteful. Pages are given over to pointless images and unnecessarily spaced out text and title pages (and not even in a necessary way a la poetry- where it is necessary to allow the poem to sit right an give the reader room to think). Given this, an the lacking content, I think that the phrase 'all fur coat and no knickers' is extremely appropriate.
The book loses momentum towards the end, and I found myself not wanting to finish.
2 1/2 stars rounded up While this book had some interesting information and makes you cringe at the amount of waste that results from our clothing habits it wasn't exactly what I was expecting. I thought there would be a lot more information about upcycling, repurposing the clothes we have already purchased. I did skim read quite a bit.
I feel very passionately about this book which in any form of art is usually the first step of knowing you've produced something good, I don't know if this is the case for Orsola's book. Between her contradicting ideas, very serious uncited claims and statistics, constant boasting of her achievements, or redundancy leaving most chapters feeling unsatisfying, I found myself at the end of this book frustrated. I am not a writer so bear with me(how,s that for hypocrisy). I want to start out with what I liked about this book, because of course it wasn't all bad. Controversially one of my favorite things was her use of graphics, she had acknowledge that this book started out as a zine and I thought that was a fun way to keep that connection while also expressing her creativity. The graphics as well as her accessible language created a good momentum for me throughout the book, especially with non-fic which can really be hard sometimes. Most importantly this book really did inspire me, I mean I'm already kind of into this stuff, hence why I picked it off the shelf, But I really feel encouraged to be more mindful of my consuming and disposing habits. Now for the bad I guess. I really feel like with some extra time and editing this book has promise but here's my critiques based purely off of what I read 1. The first thing that I noticed weighing down the book was the fact that the central idea was repeated to the point of making the text boring, and creating an unsatisfied feeling as I kept on reading. I read nonfiction with the idea I'm gonna come out of it with interesting concepts, ideas, and facts, and although I feel she got her philosophy across I don't know if I necessarily feel productive after reading this 2. Another kind of just annoying part of this book is the authors tendency to preen. She talks about her successful businesses, won awards, and flattering nicknames/titles without real point or purpose, making her feel distant and slightly snobbish. Now I've personally never heard of her or seen her in any other form of media, so this is just how I interpreted her presence in this book and it very possibly does not represent how she is in life 3. This brings me into my last point which is that Orsula feels unrelatable to me. between her success in the fashion industry, seeming familial wealth, and inability in most textile arts she does not engage me as a home sewer. This book has lots of good ideas, which despite the writing will continue on, so does it actually matter what I think, no, but what's the internet for if not to put my unsolicited opinions.
This book changed my life and my perception of myself.
I've always described myself as "not into fashion" because I tend to buy things I really love and then wear them to the point of destruction. My Grannie was a seamstress and my Mum, as a result, is a talented home sewer. I don't have either of their level of skill, but I can take up hems and do basic repairs, and so I do darn things, and I have been known to buy plain cardigans and swap the buttons for something a little fancier.
I thought people who love fashion are always changing their clothes, wearing things once or twice and then moving onto the next thing. Actually, that's not the case. Orsola de Castro herself made her breakthrough when she wore her favourite cardigan to an important event, using the finest wool and crochet hook to make a feature of some moth-holes in the old woollen, and coming home with commissions from several of the event attendees. She has been at the forefront of the slow fashion movement ever since, and this books contains articles about the way the industry has been contributing to greenhouse gases and the amount of landfill on the planet, alongside useful hints and tips on how to preserve and upcycle your clothes.
I loved this book so much I chose to theme my posts for APDO's Spring Clearing Week 2021 around it, and even gave a copy away in a competition that week.
As well as trying some of de Castro's tips on my own wardrobe, I've realised that actually I do love my clothes, and can see now that my friends were right - I have my own sense of style. It's just that slow fashion is my thing rather than the high-paced disposable side of the industry.
Huge thanks to de Castro for changing my views. I would recommend this book to anyone interested in what they wear. An easy 5/5 stars.
This book changed my life and my perception of myself.
I've always described myself as "not into fashion" because I tend to buy things I really love and then wear them to the point of destruction. My Grannie was a seamstress and my Mum, as a result, is a talented home sewer. I don't have either of their level of skill, but I can take up hems and do basic repairs, and so I do darn things, and I have been known to buy plain cardigans and swap the buttons for something a little fancier.
I thought people who love fashion are always changing their clothes, wearing things once or twice and then moving onto the next thing. Actually, that's not the case. Orsola de Castro herself made her breakthrough when she wore her favourite cardigan to an important event, using the finest wool and crochet hook to make a feature of some moth-holes in the old woollen, and coming home with commissions from several of the event attendees. She has been at the forefront of the slow fashion movement ever since, and this books contains articles about the way the industry has been contributing to greenhouse gases and the amount of landfill on the planet, alongside useful hints and tips on how to preserve and upcycle your clothes.
I loved this book so much I chose to theme my posts for APDO's Spring Clearing Week 2021 around it, and even gave a copy away in a competition that week.
As well as trying some of de Castro's tips on my own wardrobe, I've realised that actually I do love my clothes, and can see now that my friends were right - I have my own sense of style. It's just that slow fashion is my thing rather than the high-paced disposable side of the industry.
Huge thanks to de Castro for changing my views. I would recommend this book to anyone interested in what they wear. An easy 5/5 stars.
Orsola de Castro è leader esperta a livello internazionale di moda sostenibile nonché co-fondatrice del movimento globale Fashion Revolution nato nel 2013. In questo libro l’autrice apre a chi legge una grande finestra sulla moda, su ciò che acquistiamo e sul nostro rapporto con ciò che indossiamo. L’industria della moda è un sistema complesso che dà lavoro a milioni di persone, che ha un gigantesco impatto sull’ambiente, sulla diversità di genere e sui diritti di chi ci lavora, tragedie incluse come quello del Rana Plaza del 2013 in Bangladesh. Ogni volta che acquistiamo un nuovo capo da indossare o un accessorio dovremmo chiederci da dove viene, di che materiale è fatto, chi lo ha realizzato e in quali condizioni di lavoro, quanto è costato produrlo rispetto a quanto lo abbiamo pagato e soprattutto che fine farà se resterà inutilizzato con ancora il cartellino attaccato. Il nostro approccio con la moda è costretto a un cambiamento: il sistema produce in quantità eccessive e spesso acquistiamo cose d’impulso che non ci servono.
Ogni vestito invece ha una storia, prima del nostro acquisto e anche dopo, quando entra a far parte del nostro armadio. Ciò che indossiamo merita le nostre cure e attenzioni, merita di essere riparato, riutilizzato e vissuto più e più volte. Perché ciò che indossiamo parla di noi, del nostro stile e della persona che siamo.
Il libro offre suggerimenti e consigli per aver cura del proprio guardaroba, per riciclare ciò che non indossiamo più e dargli una nuova vita. Tuttə abbiamo a che fare con la moda, perché tuttə compriamo e siamo clienti di uno o più brand. È una storia e un futuro che non esclude nessuno.
Le prime parole che mi vengono in mente per descrivere questo libro sono: illuminante, coinvolgente, struggente. Mi ha aperto un mondo su una cosa che fa parte del nostro quotidiano ma a cui, tendenzialmente, prestiamo pochissima attenzione: i vestiti. Siamo abituati ad acquistare compulsivamente, gettando ció che non usiamo più... Ma avremmo tante alternative: rimodernare, riutilizzare, scambiare, personalizzare, riproporre in diverse vesti.
Leggendo ho avuto modo di conoscere anche delle tragedie di cui non sapevo nulla, ho arricchito la mia conoscenza su tematiche importanti come lo sfruttamento sul lavoro e le condizioni di vita pessime in cui vivono molti lavoratori non troppo lontano da noi... Quante volte ci abbiamo pensato prima? Io davvero poche, sono onesta.
Ho scoperto l’importanza di porsi delle domande quando si acquistano gli abiti. Da dove viene? Com’è stato realizzato? Il costo è adeguato alla tipologia di capo? Se il costo è troppo basso, ci siamo mai chiesti il perché? E poi ancora: quante volte abbiamo indossato quel capo di abbigliamento? Quante volte abbiamo riparato un abito? Quante volte abbiamo ricucito quel bottone che si è staccato dalla camicia, oppure abbiamo fatto riparare la zip a quel jeans?
Questo libro mi ha suscitato tante domande, ma mi ha dato altrettante risposte. Credo che ognuno di noi, o almeno chi ha intenzione di fare qualcosa di più per il mondo meraviglioso in cui viviamo, debba leggere questo capolavoro e farne un punto di partenza per una nuova vita. Più consapevole, più sostenibile.
I really loved this book. It made me reconsider my relationship with my clothes and my consumer habits. Happy to say it actually inspired me to get a mini sewing machine and learn how to mend and alter my own clothes. I have stored some clothing for a while to be sent to a tailor but never got around to it, or never felt determined to put in the effort. However, learning to do some bits myself now helps me build a much stronger relationship with my clothes and feels so much more rewarding.
What also struck me was when she said that our clothes are unloved and unwanted, we buy them and discard them. And thinking of the past years of my life I realise that is so true. But that did not use to be the case growing up, I used to love all my garments and I think because they were just not that accessible and I had to earn them from my parents by helping around.
Now they are so cheap and affordable that almost anyone can get a big pile of clothes at small price every time they visit Primark for example.
My plan is to recreate the same relationship I had with my clothing when I was younger.
Sono riuscita a finirlo nonostante il capitolo sul cotone ogm, la Monsanto e i contadini suicidi che mi ha fatto mettere veramente in dubbio tutto l’impianto del libro. È un peccato perché la sostenibilità è un problema e un tema serio e su alcuni punti mi pare che il discorso sia molto tirato via senza fare spazio alla complessità, ma forse l’autrice (anche comprensibilmente) non ha tutti i mezzi per parlare di ambiente e sostenibilità generale, fuori dalla moda.
Di quello che conosce, invece, vale la pena leggere anche se ho dovuto trattenermi davanti ai consigli per tingere con l’avocado, fare una gonna con due camicie, i golfini di cachemire della nonna evidentemente ricca e i vari foulard di seta che possiede. Insomma il libro è attaccabile da moltissimi punti di vista, ma la sostanza rimane: siamo responsabili della vita e dell’impatto di quello che acquistiamo. E infatti sono già pronta a vendere e scambiare molto del mio guardaroba, comprare ancora meno e soprattutto provare a riadattare. Tocca solo trovare una sarta brava e mi mangio le mani per non aver imparato da mia madre quando potevo.
Unusually for a non-fiction book, this provoked both laughter and tears.
Laughter, from reading de Castro's analysis of the distressing on a stylish man's jeans: "that kind of use could only happen to someone who had spent an inordinate amount of time wearing their pants all the way down. Like 25 years on the toilet, for example."
Tears, from reading about the workers at the Rana Plaza factories: "Imagine what it must have felt like to be forcibly working while simultaneously fearing for your life...feeling the outrage of being imprisoned in a visibly crumbling building for the sake of a few million T-shirts and someone else's profits. But those T-shirts were produced, labelled and boxed, at that time, under those circumstances, by garment workers justifiably freaking out. And those T-shirts were most likely delivered into stores - and we bought them. Those T-shirts, made in terror, in humiliation and in semi-captivity, are the reason why everything must change".
Le 4 stelle sono per i contenuti e perchè spero che con una recensione alta aumentino le letture perchè c’è bisogno di sensibilizzare il più possibile sul tema ma sarebbe da 3 stelle per come è impostato e scritto. Ci sono un sacco di spunti e occasioni di riflessione sul tema dello spreco e dell’inquinamento da abbigliamento, con schede tecniche e approfondimenti su lavaggi, composizione, riparazione dei tessuti. È peró un po’ dispersivo e ripetitivo, forse superficiale si alcuni temi perchè l’autrice parla molto in prima persona (io ho inventato questo, io ho vinto questo) dove si poteva dare spazio maggiore a fatti internazionali. Rimane che è stato scritto da una delle massime referenti per queste tematiche e lo consiglio per approciare la questione e rivoluzionare almeno un pochino il proprio modo di vivere il proprio armadio e lo shopping. Lettura facile e scorrevole.
Questo libro mi è molto piaciuto, ma ad essere onesta ho la sensazione di averlo apprezzato solo perché è stato il mio primo contatto con questo argomento. Mi ha fatto aprire gli occhi e riconsiderare un'industria e una realtà che dal punto di vista superficiale già sapevo essere dannosissime. Infatti vengono date moltissime informazioni utilissime ed interessanti... forse troppe, senza entrare abbastanza in dettaglio in alcune di cui io, personalmente, avrei voluto sapere di più. Inoltre vengono ripetute molto spesso le stesse cose. In generale metto comunque 4 stelle perché apprezzo lo spirito dietro questo libro, lo sforzo, il messaggio e il movimento di cui l'autrice è fondatrice. Spero di approfondire meglio con l'utilissima lista di libri e documentari in appendice!
This book is a very mixed bag. I'm pretty well informed about the evils of fast fashion but it still taught me a lot, and gave me some useful ideas. But equally there was a lot that I knew, or that was quite repetitive, or was advice so basic it was obvious to anyone who knew anything about reusing and repairing (and keys face it, that's the kind of person who will read this book). I also found the pace very odd - the first half was prepared with pages with hardly any words on, then second half was so dense and technical I found it really hard to plough through. I'm glad I read it but don't think I'll be rereading - I would pass it on to someone who doesn't know much about the subject matter though.