What do you think?
Rate this book
Paris in Ruins
September 1870. With the Prussian army marching toward Paris, Camille Noisette defies her parents’ wishes for her to leave the city and agrees to spy on a radical group of women calling for armed revolution.
As Paris suffers military defeats and falls deeper into chaos and ruin, Camille risks her safety to nurse wounded soldiers. After the French government surrenders, radical leaders seize control and civil war rages across the city. Camille’s only solace is an unexpected friendship with her brother’s fiancé, Mariele de Crécy. With newly discovered courage and their lives and reputations at risk, Camille and Mariele continue their efforts to protect the city and the people they love.
War has a way of teaching people lessons – if they can only survive to learn them.
As Paris suffers military defeats and falls deeper into chaos and ruin, Camille risks her safety to nurse wounded soldiers. After the French government surrenders, radical leaders seize control and civil war rages across the city. Camille’s only solace is an unexpected friendship with her brother’s fiancé, Mariele de Crécy. With newly discovered courage and their lives and reputations at risk, Camille and Mariele continue their efforts to protect the city and the people they love.
War has a way of teaching people lessons – if they can only survive to learn them.
370 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 30, 2021
15 people are currently reading
305 people want to read
About the author
M.K. Tod
8 books228 followersHi - I'm M.K. Tod, Mary actually, the author of newly released THAT WAS THEN, a contemporary thriller. Also the author of THE ADMIRAL'S WIFE, PARIS IN RUINS, TIME AND REGRET, LIES TOLD IN SILENCE and UNRAVELLED. I write stories of resilience, strength, and hope.
My blog—www.awriterofhistory.com—considers all aspects of historical fiction including interviews with authors, readers and others involved in this genre as well as insights from five historical fiction surveys. I live in Toronto and I’m happily married with two adult children.
You can follow me on Instagram @mktodauthor, find me on Facebook M.K. Tod Author or check out my website - www.mktod.com.
My blog—www.awriterofhistory.com—considers all aspects of historical fiction including interviews with authors, readers and others involved in this genre as well as insights from five historical fiction surveys. I live in Toronto and I’m happily married with two adult children.
You can follow me on Instagram @mktodauthor, find me on Facebook M.K. Tod Author or check out my website - www.mktod.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews
March 31, 2021
Guess who's back? Back again? MK's back...tell a friend :)
MK Tod is back with another gripping, emotional historical that will grip you from the start!
Paris in Ruins tells the story of the siege on Paris during the Franco-Prussian War through the eyes of two upper class women, Camille and Mariele. Although they are soon to be sisters-in-law the two don't become close until they are thrust into helping the city during the tumult.
Camille refuses to leave the city when her mother and siblings escape before the siege and stays to see what she can do to help. When the famous French actress Sarah Bernhardt opens a hospital to help treat the wounded Camille signs up to help.
Mariele sees the disparity in the streets. Food is either scarce or too expensive. The poor are dying from starvation and battle for the city is imminent. She soon becomes involved in a group that helps young children, while she waits for word from her fiancé who is fighting.
I was blown away by the courage and conviction of these two women, and the love they had for their city. I think this quote sums them both up pretty well:
"I'm doing it for Paris, for my family and friends, and for France. It's important, and I want to do something important. I'm privileged, Monsieur. Privileged to be part of an educated, wealthy class. With privilege comes responsibility."
Paris in Ruins is truly a remarkable read! There is never a dull moment. In fact, the scenes where Miriele and her mother try to escape seriously had me at the edge of my seat! There was romance, and a little mystery as well so truly something for everyone.
This is my first read about the siege of Paris and MK Tod did a fabulous job at bringing it to life! I highly recommend it!
MK Tod is back with another gripping, emotional historical that will grip you from the start!
Paris in Ruins tells the story of the siege on Paris during the Franco-Prussian War through the eyes of two upper class women, Camille and Mariele. Although they are soon to be sisters-in-law the two don't become close until they are thrust into helping the city during the tumult.
Camille refuses to leave the city when her mother and siblings escape before the siege and stays to see what she can do to help. When the famous French actress Sarah Bernhardt opens a hospital to help treat the wounded Camille signs up to help.
Mariele sees the disparity in the streets. Food is either scarce or too expensive. The poor are dying from starvation and battle for the city is imminent. She soon becomes involved in a group that helps young children, while she waits for word from her fiancé who is fighting.
I was blown away by the courage and conviction of these two women, and the love they had for their city. I think this quote sums them both up pretty well:
"I'm doing it for Paris, for my family and friends, and for France. It's important, and I want to do something important. I'm privileged, Monsieur. Privileged to be part of an educated, wealthy class. With privilege comes responsibility."
Paris in Ruins is truly a remarkable read! There is never a dull moment. In fact, the scenes where Miriele and her mother try to escape seriously had me at the edge of my seat! There was romance, and a little mystery as well so truly something for everyone.
This is my first read about the siege of Paris and MK Tod did a fabulous job at bringing it to life! I highly recommend it!
March 27, 2021
I don't read a lot of historical fiction but this one grabbed me and I loved it! I hope you'll give it a try :)
May 5, 2021
I knew little about the outbreak of the Franco-Prussian War, and the emergence of the Third French Republic in September 1870, followed by the siege of Paris by the Prussian Army. Mary Tod’s new book was therefore an insight into an unfamiliar period of French history.
In turns gentle and harrowing, I particularly liked the deft touches of prose which ground the troubling story in the real world.
I really cared about her characters, women who found new strength and resolve in the midst of war. I was also intrigued by the appearance of actress Sarah Bernhardt. I looked up her history and found she led the conversion of the Paris Odeon into a hospital for wounded soldiers, and worked as a nurse, showing great leadership to the women of Paris.
This thought-provoking novel is a worthy successor to Mary Tod’s three earlier books, and one I’m happy to recommend.
In turns gentle and harrowing, I particularly liked the deft touches of prose which ground the troubling story in the real world.
I really cared about her characters, women who found new strength and resolve in the midst of war. I was also intrigued by the appearance of actress Sarah Bernhardt. I looked up her history and found she led the conversion of the Paris Odeon into a hospital for wounded soldiers, and worked as a nurse, showing great leadership to the women of Paris.
This thought-provoking novel is a worthy successor to Mary Tod’s three earlier books, and one I’m happy to recommend.
April 11, 2021
An exquisitely crafted story combining poignancy and passion that follows the lives of two strong women and their families during the horrendous 1870/71 siege of Paris. Camille and Miriele enjoy lives of privilege within the same family and show tremendous courage and strong values as they choose to dedicate themselves to helping those less fortunate as conflicts escalate. The horrors of war come alive through Tod's meticulous research (always) but hope and friendship are also strong themes that ultimately inspire and make this a most satisfying read.
March 20, 2021
Paris in Ruins tells the gut-wrenching tale of Paris torn apart with two wars in two years (1870-1871); the Franco-Prussian War and the resulting civil war between the French government and the Paris Commune, a radical socialist, anti-religious, and revolutionary government that took over Paris in March through May.
The novel tells this complex and heartbreaking tale through two prominent families and how their members dealt with the wars, each in unique ways. Camille Noisette finds herself caught between two worlds, both sympathizing and spying on the Communards, and nursing the wounded at a makeshift hospital actress Sarah Bernhardt opened. While, Camille’s friend, Mariele de Crecy and is captured by the Prussians, later, taking care of the poor, abandoned children of the Communards at the church.
I have never experienced such dilemma within each character in a novel—each character is wrenched between opposing desires and outward forces of politics, social conscious, safety and love of their family and their country which is being torn apart before their eyes. A masterful depiction of the complications and horrors of war. Eye-opening and satisfying.
Rebecca Rosenberg www.rebecca-rosenberg.com
The novel tells this complex and heartbreaking tale through two prominent families and how their members dealt with the wars, each in unique ways. Camille Noisette finds herself caught between two worlds, both sympathizing and spying on the Communards, and nursing the wounded at a makeshift hospital actress Sarah Bernhardt opened. While, Camille’s friend, Mariele de Crecy and is captured by the Prussians, later, taking care of the poor, abandoned children of the Communards at the church.
I have never experienced such dilemma within each character in a novel—each character is wrenched between opposing desires and outward forces of politics, social conscious, safety and love of their family and their country which is being torn apart before their eyes. A masterful depiction of the complications and horrors of war. Eye-opening and satisfying.
Rebecca Rosenberg www.rebecca-rosenberg.com
April 14, 2021
The Noisette and de Crécy families are among Paris' wealthy and elite at the beginning of the Franco-Prussian War in 1870. Camille Noisette and Mariele de Crécy are future sister in laws who want to fight for what is right and protect their family and city during the time. Camille finds her place as a nurse in the Odeon theatre alongside Sarah Bernhardt, quickly Camille becomes accustomed to blood and amputations as she realizes that more and more of Paris' men are dying around her. To help even more, Camille agrees to go to radical meetings with family friend Andre Laborde and report back on anything dangerous that the women's factions are planning. Camille then recruits Mariele to help her brother Victor at the local church taking care of children whose parents are fighting and being forced to work longer hours for meager pay. Mariele finds that she loves spending time with the children and that caring for them comes naturally to her. She also finds a heightened sense of compassion and courage to keep the children safe.
Paris in Ruins is the engaging story of two women who dared to care for the people in their city in a time of war when they had the means to escape. Camille and Mariele are both women of means who have been protected their whole lives. After seeing the effects of the war on the people of Paris and the stark contrast between their families and the poor of the city, they are both compelled to open their hearts and homes to help. I was very interested in the Paris Commune group that was able to overtake Paris after the war. I would love to know more about the war from the Commune's point of view other than just Camille's time within the group. It was wonderful to see Camille and Mariele change their attitudes and behaviors due to their involvement in the war and I wish I could have seen how they continued to change their behavior to help the divide in Paris. I was very interested in The Franco-Prussian War is not a time period that I know a lot about, I was glad that the writing was rich in historical detail. I loved learning more about the eccentric actress Sarah Bernhardt and her amazing work to turn the Odeon theatre into a hospital. Overall, a compelling story of two courageous women during the Franco-Prussian War.
This book was received for free for an honest review.
Paris in Ruins is the engaging story of two women who dared to care for the people in their city in a time of war when they had the means to escape. Camille and Mariele are both women of means who have been protected their whole lives. After seeing the effects of the war on the people of Paris and the stark contrast between their families and the poor of the city, they are both compelled to open their hearts and homes to help. I was very interested in the Paris Commune group that was able to overtake Paris after the war. I would love to know more about the war from the Commune's point of view other than just Camille's time within the group. It was wonderful to see Camille and Mariele change their attitudes and behaviors due to their involvement in the war and I wish I could have seen how they continued to change their behavior to help the divide in Paris. I was very interested in The Franco-Prussian War is not a time period that I know a lot about, I was glad that the writing was rich in historical detail. I loved learning more about the eccentric actress Sarah Bernhardt and her amazing work to turn the Odeon theatre into a hospital. Overall, a compelling story of two courageous women during the Franco-Prussian War.
This book was received for free for an honest review.
March 24, 2021
A gorgeous historical fiction read on so many fronts, MK Tod’s newest novel has three compelling heroines – Camille, Mariele, and Paris. For this enthralling and powerful story of two women fighting to save their families and beloved city from destruction is ultimately the story of Paris in all its beauty, passion, heartbreak, and redemption. Ms Tod’s novel reveals the backbone and heart of these women, and as we discover their characters and beliefs, and go to war with them, Paris emerges as the star of the novel. Extraordinarily descriptive, the sights and sounds of the city are immersive and completely engulfing. I really enjoyed the people in Ms Tod’s brilliantly constructed novel, but I fell in love with 19th century Paris, and long to revisit its cafes, streets, parks, arrondissements and buildings with this book in my pocket and the story in my heart. Paris in Ruins is a wonderful ode to revolution and reconstruction, showing us that even in the deepest despair, there is hope and humanity on every street corner. Paris in Ruins? Paris in Triumph. Highly recommend.
March 30, 2021
Paris in Ruins is a dramatic look at a period that I haven’t seen covered in much fiction: the end of the Franco-Prussian War and the subsequent occupation of Paris by the revolutionary Communards who blame the rich and bourgeoisie for the woes of the poor and working class. I knew a little about the time period before reading this but was stunned to learn how much the people of Paris endured.
At the start of the novel, the two protagonists, upper-middle-class young women named Camille and Mariele, are social acquaintances linked only by the engagement of Mariele to Camille’s brother. As turbulent events and the harrowing experiences of war strip away their social veneer, each young woman discovers hidden strengths and deep convictions. They also develop a true bond with each other. If you’re looking to branch out of fiction about the two world wars but still want a similar story, this novel would fit the bill.
I received a pre-publication copy in exchange for an honest review.
At the start of the novel, the two protagonists, upper-middle-class young women named Camille and Mariele, are social acquaintances linked only by the engagement of Mariele to Camille’s brother. As turbulent events and the harrowing experiences of war strip away their social veneer, each young woman discovers hidden strengths and deep convictions. They also develop a true bond with each other. If you’re looking to branch out of fiction about the two world wars but still want a similar story, this novel would fit the bill.
I received a pre-publication copy in exchange for an honest review.
April 20, 2021
Do you enjoy reading about little known times in history? I love when I can.learn about periods of history that aren't often written about. Paris In Ruins is one such book.
Set in 1870. Paris is about to enter a hard war with Prussia. While the city in under siege the city is trashed and there is little food and lots of sickness. The people can't survive. Just when it can't get any worse, the Prussia war is over, but the radicals are screaming in the streets for the French government to change. They are unrelenting and won't back down.
Through it all Camille, a society girl does all she can to help by becoming a nurse for the sick and injured. Her sister in law Marielle can't believe how horrific the poor are living so she volunteers to help the children.of the poor. The two grow closer during the long years they spend together and soon realize how important the work they are doing for the war is.
This was an extremely moving novel that gripped me from the start. The new time period really kept me engaged and the author is such an incredible story teller.
Set in 1870. Paris is about to enter a hard war with Prussia. While the city in under siege the city is trashed and there is little food and lots of sickness. The people can't survive. Just when it can't get any worse, the Prussia war is over, but the radicals are screaming in the streets for the French government to change. They are unrelenting and won't back down.
Through it all Camille, a society girl does all she can to help by becoming a nurse for the sick and injured. Her sister in law Marielle can't believe how horrific the poor are living so she volunteers to help the children.of the poor. The two grow closer during the long years they spend together and soon realize how important the work they are doing for the war is.
This was an extremely moving novel that gripped me from the start. The new time period really kept me engaged and the author is such an incredible story teller.
March 26, 2021
This was not only a fantastic book but I also learned about a time in history that I knew little about. I found myself goggling frequently to get more information.
The year is 1870 and Napolean has just abdicated when Prussia begins the siege of Paris. The people are suffering both from bombs but also from lack of food and sickness. Immediately after the end of the Prussian war, there is another war in the streets of Paris between the government and a group of radicals who want to overthrow the government Paris spent over 2 years in shambles as a result of both of these wars. The author immerses her readers in the tumultuous struggles through two main characters.
Camille and Mariele are both part of the elite in Paris. They live the good life and could have just stayed in their roles as pampered females. Camille had always been outspoken and starts to nurse the wounded at a hospital in the Odeon theater run by Sarah Bernhardt. She also spies on the group of people who want to overthrow the government, Her brother is engaged to Mariele who seems to be a very quiet obedient daughter until she is asked to help take care of the children who are destitute. As she becomes involved in their lives, she begins to question the gap between the rich and the poor. Both of these women change from being pampered debutants to being strong viable women who want to help the people of Paris as much as they can. The stronger they both become, the more their friendship grows.
This was a fantastic historical fiction book about a time in history that is rarely written about. The author has done extensive research and it shows on every page. The two main female characters are distressed about the wars and how they are affecting the people in the city that they love but they both grow to become strong resilient women willing to do whatever they can to save their city and its people. I highly recommend Paris in Ruins.
Thanks to the publisher for a copy of this book to read and review. All opinions are my own.
The year is 1870 and Napolean has just abdicated when Prussia begins the siege of Paris. The people are suffering both from bombs but also from lack of food and sickness. Immediately after the end of the Prussian war, there is another war in the streets of Paris between the government and a group of radicals who want to overthrow the government Paris spent over 2 years in shambles as a result of both of these wars. The author immerses her readers in the tumultuous struggles through two main characters.
Camille and Mariele are both part of the elite in Paris. They live the good life and could have just stayed in their roles as pampered females. Camille had always been outspoken and starts to nurse the wounded at a hospital in the Odeon theater run by Sarah Bernhardt. She also spies on the group of people who want to overthrow the government, Her brother is engaged to Mariele who seems to be a very quiet obedient daughter until she is asked to help take care of the children who are destitute. As she becomes involved in their lives, she begins to question the gap between the rich and the poor. Both of these women change from being pampered debutants to being strong viable women who want to help the people of Paris as much as they can. The stronger they both become, the more their friendship grows.
This was a fantastic historical fiction book about a time in history that is rarely written about. The author has done extensive research and it shows on every page. The two main female characters are distressed about the wars and how they are affecting the people in the city that they love but they both grow to become strong resilient women willing to do whatever they can to save their city and its people. I highly recommend Paris in Ruins.
Thanks to the publisher for a copy of this book to read and review. All opinions are my own.
March 30, 2021
In 1870, Paris is being torn apart in a fight between self-determination and the foreign Prussian Army seeking to bend the French to their will. The gorgeous city is now a place of chaos and destruction, beset by violence and chaos. With the advent of war, people from different walks of life are on much more equal footing: each pulled into a fight for survival. Mariele and Camille were both born to a life of luxury but the war rips all of that away. Both of them will be forced to fight for their survival and for those that they love. Will they be able to rise to the occasion?
Both of the heroines at the center of the book are fascinating! Both of them are willing to leave their extremely comfortable lives in order to find some way to contribute to their country. Camille finds herself tending to the wounded in a theater-turned-hospital, run by none other than famous actress Sarah Bernhardt. Camille is also called into service as a spy to watch the communards. Mariele works hard to save the children orphaned by the war. Camille and Mariele will be called on over and over again to show what they are made of and both will discover that they are made of tougher stuff than they realized. These are two heroines that you can stand up and cheer for!
Paris is one of those places where although I have never been, I want to read about every chance I get. The Franco-Prussian War is really not a time period that I have read much in and so it was amazing to see how quickly war descended upon the country and how quickly things turned upside down. The detail in this book was fantastic. The author does a great job of bringing Paris under siege to life. There are so many different groups at odds during this time period and the author infuses great historical detail so that you can understand all of the different motives that helped to throw the city into chaos. This is a wonderful tale of resilience, strength, and hope - perfect for my fellow historical fiction lovers!
Both of the heroines at the center of the book are fascinating! Both of them are willing to leave their extremely comfortable lives in order to find some way to contribute to their country. Camille finds herself tending to the wounded in a theater-turned-hospital, run by none other than famous actress Sarah Bernhardt. Camille is also called into service as a spy to watch the communards. Mariele works hard to save the children orphaned by the war. Camille and Mariele will be called on over and over again to show what they are made of and both will discover that they are made of tougher stuff than they realized. These are two heroines that you can stand up and cheer for!
Paris is one of those places where although I have never been, I want to read about every chance I get. The Franco-Prussian War is really not a time period that I have read much in and so it was amazing to see how quickly war descended upon the country and how quickly things turned upside down. The detail in this book was fantastic. The author does a great job of bringing Paris under siege to life. There are so many different groups at odds during this time period and the author infuses great historical detail so that you can understand all of the different motives that helped to throw the city into chaos. This is a wonderful tale of resilience, strength, and hope - perfect for my fellow historical fiction lovers!
March 21, 2021
For M.K. Tod fans, and anyone who loves riveting historical fiction, this will come as a welcome and long-awaited release. Tod reaches into the history of the family she describes in her WWI novel, LIES TOLD IN SILENCE, to tell the story of Mariele Noisette (nee de Crécy) and her friend Camille Noisette, young upper-class women living in Paris in the tumultuous year following the fall of Napoleon III. As the Prussians lay siege to the city, Camille plunges into the horrors of nursing the wounded and Mariele takes on the task of caring for destitute children. And as unrest grows among the lower classes, Camille becomes caught up in a scheme to spy on radicals plotting to overthrow the French government. Both women learn new and startling truths about their society and about themselves.
The research and descriptions of the Paris of the time are first-rate. Tod lovingly and skillfully builds a world where glamor and beauty coexist with fear, destruction, poverty and starvation. Her characters are compassionate, thoughtful, well-drawn and thoroughly sympathetic. And the history is fascinating.
This is a story that Americans rarely learn in school. That the fairy tale city of Paris was so nearly destroyed, was brutalized and bombed not only by foreign invaders but by its own citizens, can come as a shock. The terrors of the Commune established following capitulation to Prussia throw into stark relief the inequities of society and the cruelty of civil war. Tod is expert at bringing to life the details that inform great events and portraying the anguish and the hopes of those caught up in them. Historical fiction at its best; highly recommended.
I received a pre-publication review copy from the author.
The research and descriptions of the Paris of the time are first-rate. Tod lovingly and skillfully builds a world where glamor and beauty coexist with fear, destruction, poverty and starvation. Her characters are compassionate, thoughtful, well-drawn and thoroughly sympathetic. And the history is fascinating.
This is a story that Americans rarely learn in school. That the fairy tale city of Paris was so nearly destroyed, was brutalized and bombed not only by foreign invaders but by its own citizens, can come as a shock. The terrors of the Commune established following capitulation to Prussia throw into stark relief the inequities of society and the cruelty of civil war. Tod is expert at bringing to life the details that inform great events and portraying the anguish and the hopes of those caught up in them. Historical fiction at its best; highly recommended.
I received a pre-publication review copy from the author.
March 12, 2021
As the author, I think Paris In Ruins is a wonderful story full of drama, romance, war, danger, and tragedy - all the elements that make a novel compelling. Instead of balls and soirees, my two heroines - Camille and Mariele - face bombardment, rationing, loss, and great personal risk. As a result, they and their families are forever changed by the siege and insurrection that tore Paris apart in 1870. I hope you'll enjoy it!
March 31, 2021
Paris in Ruins by M.K. Tod will keep you reading until the very last page. There is so much drama as the two principal characters navigate the upheavals that overtake their lives that they are changed forever.,
Set in Paris in September 1870, at the moment the France of the Second Empire has fallen to the Prussians, this novel covers little more than one year. But what a year it is. The title says it all. Paris falls into ruins.
Yet the story isn’t bleak. Love and friendship blossomed. Characters were tested and found true and strong. Women took on challenges unthinkable before disaster struck. Tragedies struck, and I found myself close to tears. But Camille and Mariele, the heroines, picked themselves up, bruised and shaken but determined to carry on.
Camille and Mariele, the two young women at the centre of the novel, develop in tandem. Camille defies her parents, begging her father to stay in Paris when her mother and remaining siblings flee to Lyon as Paris readies itself for the imminent siege. Rebellious daughter of a rich haute bourgeois family who has experienced nothing but ease, she is eager to defend her city against the hated Boche. Soon she is nursing during the day and spying in the evenings, walking alone at night on bomb-pitted streets in dangerous neighbourhoods. She dares not imagine what her mother would think.
Her future sister-in-law, Mariele, becomes her friend as she proves her mettle. From another rich bourgeois family, her father waits a bit to long to send her and her mother from Paris. Their terrifying encounter with the Prussian enemy, and Mariele’s courage as she handles the protracted encounter, wins Camille’s admiration.
Throughout these events the romances between Mariele and her betrothed, Bertrand, and Camille and her love interest develop slowly. As conditions in the city worsen, the poor starve and freeze, and revolutionary leaders agitate while battles are fought between the National Guard and the besieging Prussians. Naturally, the young men join the National Guard, so the young women and their families are consumed with worry. As the siege worsens, civil war erupts within Paris. The danger to the rich inside the city seems as imminent as to the French guardsmen outside. The fear and tension are palpable.
The novel plays back and forth between the points of view of Camille and Mariele. Their characters are distinct, yet they frequent a small social circle, so we see the people they encounter from two unique perspectives. For example, seeing Bertrand through his sister’s and then through his fiancé’s eyes adds depth to his character and to theirs. Tod manages her cast of characters well. Each is well-rounded and believable, the secondary characters flesh out the story and add drama.
As the situation worsens, Paris descends into full blown chaos and civil war. Terror descends as our characters fight to survive. Giving nothing away, I can say the ending brings the novel to a satisfying and believable conclusion. Which is not to say that it is a universally happy one. This is a war story.
Tod is a successful historical novelist who has written several stories that take place in wars settings. Unravelled, Time and Regret and Lies Told in Silence link to France and WWI and WWII. They include some descendants of the characters in Paris in Ruins.
Do buy and read this novel. Tod is both a compelling writer and an excellent historian. It is unusual to read a story of this period from rich bourgeois women’s points of view and she tells it persuasively.
Paris in Ruins
M.K. Tod
Heath Street Publishing
ISBN—book-978-0-9919670-4-9
ISBN—e-book-978-0-9919670-5-6
Set in Paris in September 1870, at the moment the France of the Second Empire has fallen to the Prussians, this novel covers little more than one year. But what a year it is. The title says it all. Paris falls into ruins.
Yet the story isn’t bleak. Love and friendship blossomed. Characters were tested and found true and strong. Women took on challenges unthinkable before disaster struck. Tragedies struck, and I found myself close to tears. But Camille and Mariele, the heroines, picked themselves up, bruised and shaken but determined to carry on.
Camille and Mariele, the two young women at the centre of the novel, develop in tandem. Camille defies her parents, begging her father to stay in Paris when her mother and remaining siblings flee to Lyon as Paris readies itself for the imminent siege. Rebellious daughter of a rich haute bourgeois family who has experienced nothing but ease, she is eager to defend her city against the hated Boche. Soon she is nursing during the day and spying in the evenings, walking alone at night on bomb-pitted streets in dangerous neighbourhoods. She dares not imagine what her mother would think.
Her future sister-in-law, Mariele, becomes her friend as she proves her mettle. From another rich bourgeois family, her father waits a bit to long to send her and her mother from Paris. Their terrifying encounter with the Prussian enemy, and Mariele’s courage as she handles the protracted encounter, wins Camille’s admiration.
Throughout these events the romances between Mariele and her betrothed, Bertrand, and Camille and her love interest develop slowly. As conditions in the city worsen, the poor starve and freeze, and revolutionary leaders agitate while battles are fought between the National Guard and the besieging Prussians. Naturally, the young men join the National Guard, so the young women and their families are consumed with worry. As the siege worsens, civil war erupts within Paris. The danger to the rich inside the city seems as imminent as to the French guardsmen outside. The fear and tension are palpable.
The novel plays back and forth between the points of view of Camille and Mariele. Their characters are distinct, yet they frequent a small social circle, so we see the people they encounter from two unique perspectives. For example, seeing Bertrand through his sister’s and then through his fiancé’s eyes adds depth to his character and to theirs. Tod manages her cast of characters well. Each is well-rounded and believable, the secondary characters flesh out the story and add drama.
As the situation worsens, Paris descends into full blown chaos and civil war. Terror descends as our characters fight to survive. Giving nothing away, I can say the ending brings the novel to a satisfying and believable conclusion. Which is not to say that it is a universally happy one. This is a war story.
Tod is a successful historical novelist who has written several stories that take place in wars settings. Unravelled, Time and Regret and Lies Told in Silence link to France and WWI and WWII. They include some descendants of the characters in Paris in Ruins.
Do buy and read this novel. Tod is both a compelling writer and an excellent historian. It is unusual to read a story of this period from rich bourgeois women’s points of view and she tells it persuasively.
Paris in Ruins
M.K. Tod
Heath Street Publishing
ISBN—book-978-0-9919670-4-9
ISBN—e-book-978-0-9919670-5-6
April 6, 2021
In Paris in Ruins, M.K. Tod brings to life an era of history which is seldom covered in the English-speaking world, the Siege of Paris during the Franco-Prussian war, followed by the Paris Commune (and the resulting fighting over Paris between communard and French government forces.) Tod, however, clearly knows the history well, and she makes it page turning reading by putting us into the interlocking stories of Camille and Mariele.
Mariele is newly engaged to Camille's older brother, Bertrand. Camille is perhaps attracted to the worldly and politically engaged Andre, who leads her into a double life of attending the meetings of working class revolutionaries to find out the state of their plans a the Prussian siege closes in and the government of Napoleon III teeters.
These main characters are key to the novel's appeal. Both are, in that oft used phrase, "strong female characters", but not in the incongruously-spouting-21st-century-opinions way which that term sometimes denotes in historical fiction. Camille is, in the language of her time, "bold" -- more willing to defy conventions and expectations. Mariele at first seems quieter, but as the story moves on proves to have hidden reserves of strength even when she finds herself quite literally under fire.
Both come from families of the haute bourgeoisie, affluent but not aristocratic, and as such they are well positioned to see both the unconscious and at times unfeeling privilege of the rich and also the terrible violence which bubbles up from the working class's demands for justice. This is not a story which serves up clear heroes and villains, but rather one which looks at the human predicaments of people whose experiences and families push them onto different sides of an increasingly brutal conflict.
Tod's writing is workmanlike rather than literary, and there are a few places where dialog is a bit heavy on exposition, but given the characters and the rich historical background I think few if any readers will hold that against the book. It's a page turning read and a window on a different and fascinating time.
Mariele is newly engaged to Camille's older brother, Bertrand. Camille is perhaps attracted to the worldly and politically engaged Andre, who leads her into a double life of attending the meetings of working class revolutionaries to find out the state of their plans a the Prussian siege closes in and the government of Napoleon III teeters.
These main characters are key to the novel's appeal. Both are, in that oft used phrase, "strong female characters", but not in the incongruously-spouting-21st-century-opinions way which that term sometimes denotes in historical fiction. Camille is, in the language of her time, "bold" -- more willing to defy conventions and expectations. Mariele at first seems quieter, but as the story moves on proves to have hidden reserves of strength even when she finds herself quite literally under fire.
Both come from families of the haute bourgeoisie, affluent but not aristocratic, and as such they are well positioned to see both the unconscious and at times unfeeling privilege of the rich and also the terrible violence which bubbles up from the working class's demands for justice. This is not a story which serves up clear heroes and villains, but rather one which looks at the human predicaments of people whose experiences and families push them onto different sides of an increasingly brutal conflict.
Tod's writing is workmanlike rather than literary, and there are a few places where dialog is a bit heavy on exposition, but given the characters and the rich historical background I think few if any readers will hold that against the book. It's a page turning read and a window on a different and fascinating time.
April 11, 2021
If you love danger and intrigue, romance, Paris, are a history buff, or just love reading about France, then this is the book for you. Well written, spell-binding, and very highly recommended!
Set in Paris, the story gives readers an unparalleled insight into the lives of the inhabitants of Paris during the 1870-71 siege. This author, who lives in Toronto with her husband, is no stranger to writing historical fiction, having written three previous books. Indeed, she was prompted to write this story by questions concerning one of her previous novels, ‘Lies Told in Silence.’
I particularly enjoyed this story because it is set in a period of history that’s not that well known. The time just after the abdication of Napoleon III, who was the nephew of Napoleon I, when the Prussian army laid siege to Paris.
Written through the eyes of two privileged young ladies, Camille Noisette, and Mariele de Crécy, one not only discovers through them what life was like for the well-to-do who lived in the city, but also the poor and underprivileged. A true tale of “upstairs, downstairs” as the author cleverly reveals life for those with and without at a time of great change in Paris. It’s wonderfully well researched.
Both Camille and Mariele, who are destined to become sisters-in-law, find themselves stepping out from their protected lives in order to help others, at a time when young ladies didn’t do such things. Camille, offers to become a nurse, witnessing first-hand the horrendous injuries received on the battle fields, and finding strength and fortitude to overcome her fears, and work alongside the doctors in their makeshift operation rooms. And Marielle, looks after the children of the poor, offering them love and a little food in the basement of a church, whilst their fathers fight in the war.
For her country, Camille is asked to infiltrate the ranks of the ‘radicals,’ the poor, starving, people of Paris who are rebelling. And, through her eyes as a spy, the reader discovers another side to the city, and can really appreciate the vast differences between the classes.
You’re swept along, immersed in the story and see the Paris of the 19th century through the eyes of the main characters.
I was captured immediately by this story. M.K. Tod has opened my eyes to this fascinating period of history, and with the story lines of her two protagonists, and their families, she paints an amazing portrait of Paris under siege.
This book is a real treat for readers who love France and its history. A masterfully written story of hope despite tragedy and a real page turner.
Set in Paris, the story gives readers an unparalleled insight into the lives of the inhabitants of Paris during the 1870-71 siege. This author, who lives in Toronto with her husband, is no stranger to writing historical fiction, having written three previous books. Indeed, she was prompted to write this story by questions concerning one of her previous novels, ‘Lies Told in Silence.’
I particularly enjoyed this story because it is set in a period of history that’s not that well known. The time just after the abdication of Napoleon III, who was the nephew of Napoleon I, when the Prussian army laid siege to Paris.
Written through the eyes of two privileged young ladies, Camille Noisette, and Mariele de Crécy, one not only discovers through them what life was like for the well-to-do who lived in the city, but also the poor and underprivileged. A true tale of “upstairs, downstairs” as the author cleverly reveals life for those with and without at a time of great change in Paris. It’s wonderfully well researched.
Both Camille and Mariele, who are destined to become sisters-in-law, find themselves stepping out from their protected lives in order to help others, at a time when young ladies didn’t do such things. Camille, offers to become a nurse, witnessing first-hand the horrendous injuries received on the battle fields, and finding strength and fortitude to overcome her fears, and work alongside the doctors in their makeshift operation rooms. And Marielle, looks after the children of the poor, offering them love and a little food in the basement of a church, whilst their fathers fight in the war.
For her country, Camille is asked to infiltrate the ranks of the ‘radicals,’ the poor, starving, people of Paris who are rebelling. And, through her eyes as a spy, the reader discovers another side to the city, and can really appreciate the vast differences between the classes.
You’re swept along, immersed in the story and see the Paris of the 19th century through the eyes of the main characters.
I was captured immediately by this story. M.K. Tod has opened my eyes to this fascinating period of history, and with the story lines of her two protagonists, and their families, she paints an amazing portrait of Paris under siege.
This book is a real treat for readers who love France and its history. A masterfully written story of hope despite tragedy and a real page turner.
April 26, 2021
Historical fiction transports the reader to the past. Inspired historical fiction informs our present. Paris In Ruins accomplishes both. Mary Tod takes us back to the Siege of Paris during the Franco-Prussian war and the social unrest of the Paris Commune. We experience the events through two privileged women, Camille and Mariele.
Instead of fleeing Paris in advance of the siege, as did many of the wealthy, these two young women are determined to stay and help the poor and needy. Camille volunteers at a converted hospital and sees the realities of war firsthand, while Mariele volunteers at a church where the poor children of the parish are cared for. Both women are courageous and push the boundaries of their traditional lives as the unrest escalates.
Cut off from food supplies and driving food prices, poor military leadership and lack of communication, Paris turns from defending itself against an invading army to tearing each other apart. I was riveted by these scenes and found them to be some of the most gripping in the book, as well as the most heartbreaking. When people are faced with chronic uncertainty and death, the ties that bind unravel and propaganda becomes a deadly weapon. And stirring this mixture are those who stand to benefit the most. It’s hard not to draw parallels to today’s political unrest.
The characters were well-drawn, and there wasn’t a moment that I did not fear for their safety. I loved Camile’s daring and her growing relationship with Andre as they worked together to gather intelligence on the Commune. I loved Mariele’s quiet strength as she defied the conventions of her station and raised two young children whose father was away fighting for France.
Paris In Ruins is beautifully written and with keen characterization. A highly recommended novel that covers a period in history that deserves more attention.
Instead of fleeing Paris in advance of the siege, as did many of the wealthy, these two young women are determined to stay and help the poor and needy. Camille volunteers at a converted hospital and sees the realities of war firsthand, while Mariele volunteers at a church where the poor children of the parish are cared for. Both women are courageous and push the boundaries of their traditional lives as the unrest escalates.
Cut off from food supplies and driving food prices, poor military leadership and lack of communication, Paris turns from defending itself against an invading army to tearing each other apart. I was riveted by these scenes and found them to be some of the most gripping in the book, as well as the most heartbreaking. When people are faced with chronic uncertainty and death, the ties that bind unravel and propaganda becomes a deadly weapon. And stirring this mixture are those who stand to benefit the most. It’s hard not to draw parallels to today’s political unrest.
The characters were well-drawn, and there wasn’t a moment that I did not fear for their safety. I loved Camile’s daring and her growing relationship with Andre as they worked together to gather intelligence on the Commune. I loved Mariele’s quiet strength as she defied the conventions of her station and raised two young children whose father was away fighting for France.
Paris In Ruins is beautifully written and with keen characterization. A highly recommended novel that covers a period in history that deserves more attention.
March 18, 2021
M.K. Tod has brought to vivid life a period of French history I wasn't familiar with (and I'm a Francophone!). I could recite chapter and verse the events and characters of The Revolution of 1789, and of course I'm familiar with the one when Jean Valjean's story takes place in the early 19th century, but I didn't know that in 1871, those republicans were at it again. It was nicknamed the Paris Commune, and we follow two young women enmired in the thick of it, evading bullets, barricades and bullies, doing their duty as best a woman could in the day, and both finding love despite the chaos. Tod beautifully evokes the horrors of a besieged city--its crumbling buildings, foul smell of rotten flesh, feces and uncollected effluence, and the fear of Prussian cannonballs dropping from the sky as inside the city citizens fought each other. This is where Tod's book shines, in my opinion. I gave this book four stars. The lack of a fifth was due to a need to edit the historical expository narrative and that, for me, her two heroines became interchangeable. I wished she had combined them into one stronger character.
April 11, 2021
Thank you to @hfvbt and the author for including me in the book your office Paris in Ruins
Camille and Mariele are two young ladies in a Paris under siege by the Prussians...
✔️ I loved learning about this time in French history that I was totally unfamiliar with
✔️ the story is told from the perspective of two strong young women . I really enjoyed both Camille & Mariele and their stories
✔️ did you know Sarah Bernhardt, the famous French actress, ran a hospital during the siege of Paris ? Wow. So many amazing women in history and I love reading about them !
✖️ at times I got a little lost in all the details of the siege and the events following 🤷♀️
Overall, an enjoyable Historical fiction novel.
3.5 ⭐️
Camille and Mariele are two young ladies in a Paris under siege by the Prussians...
✔️ I loved learning about this time in French history that I was totally unfamiliar with
✔️ the story is told from the perspective of two strong young women . I really enjoyed both Camille & Mariele and their stories
✔️ did you know Sarah Bernhardt, the famous French actress, ran a hospital during the siege of Paris ? Wow. So many amazing women in history and I love reading about them !
✖️ at times I got a little lost in all the details of the siege and the events following 🤷♀️
Overall, an enjoyable Historical fiction novel.
3.5 ⭐️
May 3, 2021
Great, exciting story about a lesser-known part of French history, and two compelling main female characters. I thought the language could be less stilted, more beautiful, less telling, more showing, but the story in the end overrode those quibbles.
March 14, 2021
I was given an ARC of this novel and read it in record time. I did not know much about the siege of Apris and I love books that have me running to Wikipedia to look up the facts. The two main characters of the story are women from wealthy families and through their lens, you can see how the turmoil of war and the raid on Paris impacts their perceptions of privilege. The reader also gets a first-hand account of the revolution that was brewing at the time because one of the main characters, Camille, is planted as a spy. It is a face-paced novel that had me anxiously waiting to read what would happen next. Thoroughly enjoyable.
March 31, 2021
Like Downton Abbey for Paris! Two young women of privilege turn their lives upside down nursing soldiers and caring for orphaned children in their homes amongst the siege of Paris and then a bloody insurrection. Gripping and heart wrenching! I knew that France had undergone MANY revolutions in the 19th century, but this one is EPIC. Must read!!
April 14, 2021
I am not quite sure why I decided to read this book. The title is not all that alluring, but a book set in the French upheaval of 1870 promised to be both educational and intriguing—and I liked the fact that Ms Tod has chosen to relate events through the POV of two women. Very often when it comes to war and violence, such events are described through the eyes of male characters.
The book opens in September of 1870. Cocky Wilhelm of Prussia, edged on by equally cocky and substantially wilier Otto von Bismarck, has decide to teach the French a lesson. After defeating Napoleon III and the French Army at Sedon, the Prussian army has now encircled Paris.
Prussia is not the only enemy. Paris is a hotbed of socialist sentiments, loud voices clamouring for a new revolution, a glorious Commune. The more moderate among the Parisians are concerned, and one of our heroines, Camille Noisette, is recruited to attend various Women’s Right meetings. Camille belongs to the haute bourgeoisie. She is intelligent, beautiful, poised—and bored. Which is probably why she agrees to help a certain André Laborde in collecting information about the radicals.
As the siege progresses, things become even more unbearable for those who had little to begin with, and the proponents of revolution have more and more people flocking to their banners—but first the Prussians must be defeated.
Except that they are not. Camille, determined to help, volunteers at Sarah Bernhardt’s makeshift hospital. I loved the cameo portrait of famous actress Sarah Bernhardt, depicting a strong, successful woman who had no problems rolling up her sleeves to genuinely help in times of need. Soon enough, Camille and the other volunteers are run of their feet trying to cope with all the wounded. Helping doctors saw off people’s limbs, watching men expire from wounds and sickness—it changes Camille, as does her relationship with André. She is no longer an indulged, protected hothouse flower: she is a strong, if scared, young woman watching her beloved Paris destroyed by bombs and violence.
Camille’s brother, Bertrand is engaged to be married to Mariele. Initially, the bold and self-assured Camille has little in common with the shy Mariele, but after a terrifying experience at the hands of the Prussians, Mariele is obliged to find the backbone within. I really liked how Mariele grew from pampered and shy to strong and shy—she was still Mariele, still sweet and caring, but with an inner core of newfound strength.
Ms Tod has evidently done a lot of research. At times, this leads to monologues from various male characters in the cast bringing their loved ones up to date on one armed conflict or the other, thereby affecting pace significantly. Ms Tod does not shy away from blood and gore and her descriptions of amputations and exploding bombs are as vivid as any TV show. And through all this, Ms Tod guides us through the ravaged Paris, through a Bois de Bologne deprived of its trees, through streets filled with debris and raging fires. She presents us with the stunning interiors of the homes of the well-to-do, with starving urchins, with women determined to lay down their lives in defence of the Commune. Angry rebels who strike defenceless priests, men who kill, men who sit stunned in the aftermath of yet more violence, more blood. In Ms Tod’s expert hands, the Paris Commune becomes a vibrant red—the red of spilled blood, of defiant rebel banners.
Camille and Mariele emerge from the events of 1870/71 permanently changed and yet, at the same time, more than eager to retreat into the life they once knew. A safe, uncomplicated life, a life built on conventions and expectations, free of excessive excitement and turmoil. No wonder, I say: no wonder at all!
The book opens in September of 1870. Cocky Wilhelm of Prussia, edged on by equally cocky and substantially wilier Otto von Bismarck, has decide to teach the French a lesson. After defeating Napoleon III and the French Army at Sedon, the Prussian army has now encircled Paris.
Prussia is not the only enemy. Paris is a hotbed of socialist sentiments, loud voices clamouring for a new revolution, a glorious Commune. The more moderate among the Parisians are concerned, and one of our heroines, Camille Noisette, is recruited to attend various Women’s Right meetings. Camille belongs to the haute bourgeoisie. She is intelligent, beautiful, poised—and bored. Which is probably why she agrees to help a certain André Laborde in collecting information about the radicals.
As the siege progresses, things become even more unbearable for those who had little to begin with, and the proponents of revolution have more and more people flocking to their banners—but first the Prussians must be defeated.
Except that they are not. Camille, determined to help, volunteers at Sarah Bernhardt’s makeshift hospital. I loved the cameo portrait of famous actress Sarah Bernhardt, depicting a strong, successful woman who had no problems rolling up her sleeves to genuinely help in times of need. Soon enough, Camille and the other volunteers are run of their feet trying to cope with all the wounded. Helping doctors saw off people’s limbs, watching men expire from wounds and sickness—it changes Camille, as does her relationship with André. She is no longer an indulged, protected hothouse flower: she is a strong, if scared, young woman watching her beloved Paris destroyed by bombs and violence.
Camille’s brother, Bertrand is engaged to be married to Mariele. Initially, the bold and self-assured Camille has little in common with the shy Mariele, but after a terrifying experience at the hands of the Prussians, Mariele is obliged to find the backbone within. I really liked how Mariele grew from pampered and shy to strong and shy—she was still Mariele, still sweet and caring, but with an inner core of newfound strength.
Ms Tod has evidently done a lot of research. At times, this leads to monologues from various male characters in the cast bringing their loved ones up to date on one armed conflict or the other, thereby affecting pace significantly. Ms Tod does not shy away from blood and gore and her descriptions of amputations and exploding bombs are as vivid as any TV show. And through all this, Ms Tod guides us through the ravaged Paris, through a Bois de Bologne deprived of its trees, through streets filled with debris and raging fires. She presents us with the stunning interiors of the homes of the well-to-do, with starving urchins, with women determined to lay down their lives in defence of the Commune. Angry rebels who strike defenceless priests, men who kill, men who sit stunned in the aftermath of yet more violence, more blood. In Ms Tod’s expert hands, the Paris Commune becomes a vibrant red—the red of spilled blood, of defiant rebel banners.
Camille and Mariele emerge from the events of 1870/71 permanently changed and yet, at the same time, more than eager to retreat into the life they once knew. A safe, uncomplicated life, a life built on conventions and expectations, free of excessive excitement and turmoil. No wonder, I say: no wonder at all!
June 19, 2021
This is the sort of historical fiction I really enjoy reading: I know just enough about the period to follow along the time frame but in the hands of an excellent author I find out more from an investment in the characters of the book. M.K. Tod's Paris in Ruins illuminates Paris in 1870 during the Franco Prussian War as Camille and Mariel find their world torn apart by the Franco Prussian War and then the revolt of the Commune. Camille starts the story off as the more confident and daring girl but by the end of the story timid Mariel evolves into a courageous and risk taker. With danger and treachery confronting not only these two young women but their sweethearts, brothers and fathers, they resort to covert methods to protect their family and city. This view of Paris during the age of the Commune, Sarah Bernhardt, invading armies, love stories, betrayals and tragedy comes to life thanks to Tod's meticulous research and development of her two main characters. Highly recommend!
March 15, 2021
Paris in Ruins is a poignant novel of resilience and friendship set during a fascinating period of French history : the Paris Commune. After the fall of Napoleon III in September 1870, the French Empire is replaced by a new Republic. But the war with Prussia is still ongoing and the regime is fragile. The working class, under the leadership of revolutionaries like Louise Michel, denounces the failure of Thiers’ government to protect Paris from a Prussian occupation and threatens to overthrow the regime.
One of the things I love most about historical novels is when they manage to immerse the reader in a key turning point in history in such a way that the uncertainty of the moment and the plurality of possible outcomes is perceptible. Paris in Ruins does just that. In the novel, we experience the violent uprising of the Communards from the point of view of two young women of the haute bourgeoisie. Camille and Mariele both grew up in wealthy families and became friends after Mariele got engaged to Bertrand, Camille’s brother. Although they sympathize with the workers’ fight for better living conditions, they are also horrified at the prospect of another Revolution.
As they experience the siege of Paris by the Prussian army from September 1870 to January 1871, both Camille and Mariele find that they cannot just stay in their comfortable homes while men are being killed for defending the city. Each of them will find her own path to resilience and emancipation. In doing so, they will encounter key figures of the period such as Louise Michel and Sarah Bernhard. They will see some of their conceptions about class, love and family seriously challenged.
Thanks to these two very endearing characters, Paris in Ruins is a very enjoyable read. I found myself immersed in the action from the very first page and I appreciated the chronological chapters which help recreate what day to day life in besieged Paris must be have been like. Being myself passionate about 19h century French history, I found that M. K. Tod manages to give a very convincing account of this particularly complex and chaotic period. I guess that a reader less familiar with the Second Empire may feel a bit lost at times by some of the references to the political situation (feelings towards the fallen Emperor, reminiscences of 1848…), but the novel remains very close to its characters at all times so that we truly get to understand the situation through their eyes. A good example is the very interesting evolution of the National Guard described in the novel. Through the involvement of Bertrand, the reader sees how this initially bourgeois-led initiative to defend the city ends up becoming a workers’ militia threatening to overthrow the government.
All in all, Paris in Ruins is my favourite novel of M. K. Tod to date and I think it would deserve to be translated into French to reach a broader audience!
I would like to thank the author for sharing a pre-publication copy of the novel with me.
One of the things I love most about historical novels is when they manage to immerse the reader in a key turning point in history in such a way that the uncertainty of the moment and the plurality of possible outcomes is perceptible. Paris in Ruins does just that. In the novel, we experience the violent uprising of the Communards from the point of view of two young women of the haute bourgeoisie. Camille and Mariele both grew up in wealthy families and became friends after Mariele got engaged to Bertrand, Camille’s brother. Although they sympathize with the workers’ fight for better living conditions, they are also horrified at the prospect of another Revolution.
As they experience the siege of Paris by the Prussian army from September 1870 to January 1871, both Camille and Mariele find that they cannot just stay in their comfortable homes while men are being killed for defending the city. Each of them will find her own path to resilience and emancipation. In doing so, they will encounter key figures of the period such as Louise Michel and Sarah Bernhard. They will see some of their conceptions about class, love and family seriously challenged.
Thanks to these two very endearing characters, Paris in Ruins is a very enjoyable read. I found myself immersed in the action from the very first page and I appreciated the chronological chapters which help recreate what day to day life in besieged Paris must be have been like. Being myself passionate about 19h century French history, I found that M. K. Tod manages to give a very convincing account of this particularly complex and chaotic period. I guess that a reader less familiar with the Second Empire may feel a bit lost at times by some of the references to the political situation (feelings towards the fallen Emperor, reminiscences of 1848…), but the novel remains very close to its characters at all times so that we truly get to understand the situation through their eyes. A good example is the very interesting evolution of the National Guard described in the novel. Through the involvement of Bertrand, the reader sees how this initially bourgeois-led initiative to defend the city ends up becoming a workers’ militia threatening to overthrow the government.
All in all, Paris in Ruins is my favourite novel of M. K. Tod to date and I think it would deserve to be translated into French to reach a broader audience!
I would like to thank the author for sharing a pre-publication copy of the novel with me.
Read
April 1, 2021This book was received from the Author, and Publisher, in exchange for an honest review. Opinions and thoughts expressed in this review are completely my own.
This is a non spoiler review, because you as reader need to read this book. Also, I feel sometimes I have in the past gave away to much of the plot line. This has diminished the pleasure for would be readers.
Paris In Ruins is another remarkable, unforgettable book by the author by M.K. Tod
Set to the backdrop the the Franco-Prussian War and the civil war of the radical movement the Paris Commune.
This is a riveting emotionally charged story that explores, friendship, bravery, perseverance.
Following Napoleon III’s defeat, Prussian forces laid siege to Paris, and through Todd’s seamless narration we see first hand the horrors of a besieged city. As civil strife and unrest mount between two distinct factions within France.
Camille Noisette, has lived a life of privilege, along with her brother Bertrand fiancé, Mariele de Crecy. Camille father has been very light handed with Camille since the death of her sister. She’s been able to dodge any betrothal, but is intrigued with a young gentleman named André Laborde.
When things start to develop further and a siege to Paris is in the horizon. Most of the Well-to-do aristocratic families flee the city. Camille has convinced her father that she is quite capable of taking care of herself.
Marielle family has waited to long and have missed their chance to leave the city undetected. Nothing prepares these young women the calamity that befalls the remaining residents left in Paris. As the storyline unfolds a notable french actress Sarah Bernhardt establishes a military hospital. Our young heroine Camille steps up to volunteer. Mariele is moved by the despair of those barely hanging on, as the food becomes scares for everyone especially the poor. She does what she can and finds she is passionate about working with young children.
Seeing first hand disparity of the people, both Camille and her friend Marielle, form a strong bond. We follow these two young woman as their characters grow and evolve, into strong resilient women.
M.K. Tod writing grabs you from the very first in this memorable book.The pace was brisk and vividly rendered, each scene is richly atmospheric. The romance was depicted wonderfully, and I felt invested in both Mariele de Crecy and Camille Noisette lives.
M.K. Tod has created an engaging and memorable heroines, and her highly accomplished writing ensures that the reader is swept along in this propulsive emotional historical fiction.
This is a non spoiler review, because you as reader need to read this book. Also, I feel sometimes I have in the past gave away to much of the plot line. This has diminished the pleasure for would be readers.
Paris In Ruins is another remarkable, unforgettable book by the author by M.K. Tod
Set to the backdrop the the Franco-Prussian War and the civil war of the radical movement the Paris Commune.
This is a riveting emotionally charged story that explores, friendship, bravery, perseverance.
Following Napoleon III’s defeat, Prussian forces laid siege to Paris, and through Todd’s seamless narration we see first hand the horrors of a besieged city. As civil strife and unrest mount between two distinct factions within France.
Camille Noisette, has lived a life of privilege, along with her brother Bertrand fiancé, Mariele de Crecy. Camille father has been very light handed with Camille since the death of her sister. She’s been able to dodge any betrothal, but is intrigued with a young gentleman named André Laborde.
When things start to develop further and a siege to Paris is in the horizon. Most of the Well-to-do aristocratic families flee the city. Camille has convinced her father that she is quite capable of taking care of herself.
Marielle family has waited to long and have missed their chance to leave the city undetected. Nothing prepares these young women the calamity that befalls the remaining residents left in Paris. As the storyline unfolds a notable french actress Sarah Bernhardt establishes a military hospital. Our young heroine Camille steps up to volunteer. Mariele is moved by the despair of those barely hanging on, as the food becomes scares for everyone especially the poor. She does what she can and finds she is passionate about working with young children.
Seeing first hand disparity of the people, both Camille and her friend Marielle, form a strong bond. We follow these two young woman as their characters grow and evolve, into strong resilient women.
M.K. Tod writing grabs you from the very first in this memorable book.The pace was brisk and vividly rendered, each scene is richly atmospheric. The romance was depicted wonderfully, and I felt invested in both Mariele de Crecy and Camille Noisette lives.
M.K. Tod has created an engaging and memorable heroines, and her highly accomplished writing ensures that the reader is swept along in this propulsive emotional historical fiction.
April 4, 2021
I read a book by this author a while back and I had really liked it so I was excited to get my hands on this one!
We follow Camille and Mariele who were raised for a life of parties and servants. They have a lot in common, but it takes the horrors of war to bring them together to fight for the city and the people they love. A few weeks after the abdication of Napoleon III, the Prussian army lays siege to Paris. Camille volunteers to nurse the wounded soldiers and agrees to spy on a group of radicals plotting to overthrow the French government. Mariele is Camille's future sister-in-law and finds that she is appalled by the gaps between the rich and poor. She volunteers to look after destitute children. Together they must find the courage and strength to endure the months of hardships.
This author really knows how to suck a reader into the story. I could not put this down! I finished it in just a couple of sittings. I had to know what was going to happen next! It totally captivated me from page one. Soooooooo good!
I think I liked Mariele's story more. I found myself more interested in what she was up to. Don't get me wrong, I liked Camille too and I worried for her as well, but I feel like I connected with Mariele more so. Mariele starts off so docile, but she really finds her strength and you can even argue finds herself in this world of chaos. You can say the same thing for Camille and you would be right. However, there is something about Mariele that I really leaned into.
What a scary thing to have to go through. I was so worried for our characters. War is bloody and terrible and even though I know the general history....I was still on the edge of my seat and was worried for our girls and the others. Such a scary thing to have to go through. I can't even imagine *shudders* The author really does a wonderful job bringing this world and our characters alive.
Overall, I was captivated by this story and our heroines. I could not put this down! I highly recommend it for historical fiction lovers. It is really good. I would even say it is a contender for the Best of the year ;) 5 stars from me.
We follow Camille and Mariele who were raised for a life of parties and servants. They have a lot in common, but it takes the horrors of war to bring them together to fight for the city and the people they love. A few weeks after the abdication of Napoleon III, the Prussian army lays siege to Paris. Camille volunteers to nurse the wounded soldiers and agrees to spy on a group of radicals plotting to overthrow the French government. Mariele is Camille's future sister-in-law and finds that she is appalled by the gaps between the rich and poor. She volunteers to look after destitute children. Together they must find the courage and strength to endure the months of hardships.
This author really knows how to suck a reader into the story. I could not put this down! I finished it in just a couple of sittings. I had to know what was going to happen next! It totally captivated me from page one. Soooooooo good!
I think I liked Mariele's story more. I found myself more interested in what she was up to. Don't get me wrong, I liked Camille too and I worried for her as well, but I feel like I connected with Mariele more so. Mariele starts off so docile, but she really finds her strength and you can even argue finds herself in this world of chaos. You can say the same thing for Camille and you would be right. However, there is something about Mariele that I really leaned into.
What a scary thing to have to go through. I was so worried for our characters. War is bloody and terrible and even though I know the general history....I was still on the edge of my seat and was worried for our girls and the others. Such a scary thing to have to go through. I can't even imagine *shudders* The author really does a wonderful job bringing this world and our characters alive.
Overall, I was captivated by this story and our heroines. I could not put this down! I highly recommend it for historical fiction lovers. It is really good. I would even say it is a contender for the Best of the year ;) 5 stars from me.
May 6, 2021
My, oh my!!
Well, what can I say about this book?
I was completely blown away and left gasping in pure delight at the richness, the passion, the endless highs and lows of atmospheric emotion which steals your heart and ruins you for all other historical fiction.
Paris in Ruins is the first book I have read by MK Tod, and it definitely won’t be the last I can’t believe that this talented author has passed me by for so long. How is that? It’s once again I must have been walking around with eyes closed tight – no wonder I walk into things …LOL!!
Set in Paris in the turbulent year of 1870, Paris in Ruins tells the story of two extraordinary women who must face the unspeakable horrors of their beloved Paris in the depths of war, a war which will not only tear the country apart but which cost so much to so many, Camille and Mariele have to delve deep within them to find that strength to fight. I love the fluid, vivid and engaging writing style, it pulls the reader right into the thick of the action while enthralling us with rich and meticulously researched historical detail which comes alive on the page.
Set during the Franco-Prussian War, and despite loving the Napoleonic era and having watched far too much Sharpe as a child I didn’t know that much about this particular period of history and I was thrilled to learn more about it as I read. Don’t you just love it when you a book which not only thrills and entertains, but educates and gives you goose-bumps? And this is certainly one of those books!
I liked that the social gap was a prime topic for the overall story, Camille doesn’t see those beneath her station until she begins to nurse the wounded and then when she is enlisted to spy on the radicals, but she is very much an upper-crust young lady who has been rather spoiled – but she soon comes crashing down to earth. Then we have Mariele who like Camille is also from the upper classes but unlike those of her station she doesn’t snub her nose at those below her she is appalled at the injustice of how the poor are treated, that the social line between the poor and the rich seems to be getting wider and wider, she is determined to help those in need.
Hmmm? Not a lot has changed has it?? Even in the 21st century, we can still say that there is a gap – or as many say it here a North/South divide…Oops, got a little political there, it won’t happen again.
I loved getting to know both Camille and Mariele, they are different in their ways and views but there are similarities between them; both coming from upper-class stock and both in a more privileged position than most women. At first, I have to be honest, I did wonder how two such different women could ever be friends they were like chalk and cheese, but it’s only once the darkness of war clouds Paris that they come together and get to know the other and see that they aren’t as different as they (and me) thought. I did doubt if they ever would be the best of friends, but with so much against them, their families and their very way of life they were stronger together than apart. Both women are bold, determined, loyal, passionate, brave, fearless, caring and kind, they love their city and the people and I found their courage hugely inspiring.
Overall, Paris In Ruins is a beautiful, emotional, riveting, remarkable, memorable, sweeping tale full of dangers, sadness, friendship and love. I thoroughly enjoyed my trip to post-Napoleonic France and getting to know the incredible men and women who fought so courageously for what they believed.
Well, what can I say about this book?
I was completely blown away and left gasping in pure delight at the richness, the passion, the endless highs and lows of atmospheric emotion which steals your heart and ruins you for all other historical fiction.
Paris in Ruins is the first book I have read by MK Tod, and it definitely won’t be the last I can’t believe that this talented author has passed me by for so long. How is that? It’s once again I must have been walking around with eyes closed tight – no wonder I walk into things …LOL!!
Set in Paris in the turbulent year of 1870, Paris in Ruins tells the story of two extraordinary women who must face the unspeakable horrors of their beloved Paris in the depths of war, a war which will not only tear the country apart but which cost so much to so many, Camille and Mariele have to delve deep within them to find that strength to fight. I love the fluid, vivid and engaging writing style, it pulls the reader right into the thick of the action while enthralling us with rich and meticulously researched historical detail which comes alive on the page.
Set during the Franco-Prussian War, and despite loving the Napoleonic era and having watched far too much Sharpe as a child I didn’t know that much about this particular period of history and I was thrilled to learn more about it as I read. Don’t you just love it when you a book which not only thrills and entertains, but educates and gives you goose-bumps? And this is certainly one of those books!
I liked that the social gap was a prime topic for the overall story, Camille doesn’t see those beneath her station until she begins to nurse the wounded and then when she is enlisted to spy on the radicals, but she is very much an upper-crust young lady who has been rather spoiled – but she soon comes crashing down to earth. Then we have Mariele who like Camille is also from the upper classes but unlike those of her station she doesn’t snub her nose at those below her she is appalled at the injustice of how the poor are treated, that the social line between the poor and the rich seems to be getting wider and wider, she is determined to help those in need.
Hmmm? Not a lot has changed has it?? Even in the 21st century, we can still say that there is a gap – or as many say it here a North/South divide…Oops, got a little political there, it won’t happen again.
I loved getting to know both Camille and Mariele, they are different in their ways and views but there are similarities between them; both coming from upper-class stock and both in a more privileged position than most women. At first, I have to be honest, I did wonder how two such different women could ever be friends they were like chalk and cheese, but it’s only once the darkness of war clouds Paris that they come together and get to know the other and see that they aren’t as different as they (and me) thought. I did doubt if they ever would be the best of friends, but with so much against them, their families and their very way of life they were stronger together than apart. Both women are bold, determined, loyal, passionate, brave, fearless, caring and kind, they love their city and the people and I found their courage hugely inspiring.
Overall, Paris In Ruins is a beautiful, emotional, riveting, remarkable, memorable, sweeping tale full of dangers, sadness, friendship and love. I thoroughly enjoyed my trip to post-Napoleonic France and getting to know the incredible men and women who fought so courageously for what they believed.
April 25, 2021
Set during the Franco-Prussian War, Paris in Ruins covers the months the city was besieged by the Prussians and then when the Paris Commune, a revolutionary socialist group, were briefly in control. The story follows two families, the Noisettes and the de Crécys, through the activities of their daughters, Camille and Mariele respectively.
Although they come from similar backgrounds, Camille and Mariele, her brother's fiancée, do not know each other that well. Mariele thinks Camille is bold and intimidating, while Camille considers Mariele timid. Both are determined to help their beloved and beleaguered city any way they can. Camille becomes a nurse and also gathers information on a group of radicals; Mariele helps to look after children from poor families who often go without food.
M.K. Tod's latest release successfully describes a city under siege with all the privations one would expect. She also brings into focus the social divide, which Mariele questions and in her own way does something about. Camille, too, sees the injustices around her and while she supports some of the radicals' views, she does not condone their methods.
I usually read novels set in Paris during World War II, so was instantly intrigued by this one set during the Franco-Prussian War. My knowledge of this period in French history is virtually non-existent, so I found this novel not only entertaining but informative as well.
Paris in Ruins is a great read and one I'm happy to recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of this book as a participant in a book blog tour.
* https://adarngoodread.blogspot.com
Although they come from similar backgrounds, Camille and Mariele, her brother's fiancée, do not know each other that well. Mariele thinks Camille is bold and intimidating, while Camille considers Mariele timid. Both are determined to help their beloved and beleaguered city any way they can. Camille becomes a nurse and also gathers information on a group of radicals; Mariele helps to look after children from poor families who often go without food.
M.K. Tod's latest release successfully describes a city under siege with all the privations one would expect. She also brings into focus the social divide, which Mariele questions and in her own way does something about. Camille, too, sees the injustices around her and while she supports some of the radicals' views, she does not condone their methods.
I usually read novels set in Paris during World War II, so was instantly intrigued by this one set during the Franco-Prussian War. My knowledge of this period in French history is virtually non-existent, so I found this novel not only entertaining but informative as well.
Paris in Ruins is a great read and one I'm happy to recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of this book as a participant in a book blog tour.
* https://adarngoodread.blogspot.com
April 25, 2021
Paris in Ruins
Another great historical fiction book by Mary Tod, that takes place in Paris during the Franco Prussian war, and the revolution that followed immediately after the Franco Prussian Armistice. This book follows two aristocratic families especially two young women Camille and Marielle who participate assisting with aid in war torn Paris. Marielle worked with the children left under the care of the church, and Camille worked in a makeshift hospital at the Odeon Theatre in Paris organized by Sarah Bernhardt.
It is remarkable how the storyline takes the reader through the different Arrondissements or Districts and streets of Paris with such magnificent detail, that the reader feels they are there. I followed there travels around Paris on Streetviewmap. Just a daily trip through the Paris Streets held such fears and turmoil, it is difficult for us to understand.
The fear, for loved ones and immediate family is comprehensive and frightening. The citizens of Paris are expected to let go their way of life to accommodate the masses.
The uncertainty and chaos after May 29 1871 was horrendous for those citizens left alive in Paris.
The revolutionaries wanted to do away with all of the aristocracy, believing that their lives would be better if they did. In the words of the author the revolution was sparked by atheism, anarchy, and foolish pride.
I have read few novels set during the Franco Prussian war, this book was excellent. It stirs up many emotions, and teachings. I would highly recommend Paris in Ruins, I give it a 5 star without question. Thank you Mary for a wonderful book.
Another great historical fiction book by Mary Tod, that takes place in Paris during the Franco Prussian war, and the revolution that followed immediately after the Franco Prussian Armistice. This book follows two aristocratic families especially two young women Camille and Marielle who participate assisting with aid in war torn Paris. Marielle worked with the children left under the care of the church, and Camille worked in a makeshift hospital at the Odeon Theatre in Paris organized by Sarah Bernhardt.
It is remarkable how the storyline takes the reader through the different Arrondissements or Districts and streets of Paris with such magnificent detail, that the reader feels they are there. I followed there travels around Paris on Streetviewmap. Just a daily trip through the Paris Streets held such fears and turmoil, it is difficult for us to understand.
The fear, for loved ones and immediate family is comprehensive and frightening. The citizens of Paris are expected to let go their way of life to accommodate the masses.
The uncertainty and chaos after May 29 1871 was horrendous for those citizens left alive in Paris.
The revolutionaries wanted to do away with all of the aristocracy, believing that their lives would be better if they did. In the words of the author the revolution was sparked by atheism, anarchy, and foolish pride.
I have read few novels set during the Franco Prussian war, this book was excellent. It stirs up many emotions, and teachings. I would highly recommend Paris in Ruins, I give it a 5 star without question. Thank you Mary for a wonderful book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews