This is a long review, so I apologize in advance. I don't know why I keep giving this series a chance. I was initially drawn to this series because it involved a mom who got sucked into mysteries. The last few books were total flops, so I got hopeful when I read more positive reviews on this latest installment.
This book finds us back in Tinker's Cove with the characters I fell in love with since book 1. Ted Stillings has applied for (and received) a grant, which allows him to purchase the neighboring towns' newspaper and add an additional reporter, Rob Callahan, to the Pennysaver's staff. From the get go, Lucy feels intimidated and threatened by Rob and doesn't really seem to give him an inkling of a chance. In a portion of the book, Lucy gets mighty offended when Ted hands over his editing duties to Rob. Rob asks Lucy for help on editing her news story and Lucy thinks she is really sticking it to Rob when she leaves work early and let's Rob "fend for himself" while editing HER news story, even though he asked her opinions. She flounces out of the office, slamming the door, even making the door bell jingle extra hard, so Rob knew she meant business, in true petulant child form. This seems to come back to bite Lucy in the ass when, her news story was printed and it is chock full of errors. Gee Lucy.....maybe if you had, I don't know, stuck around and been there while Rob edited your work, it would be correct?
The real and true crime doesn't happen until about 3/4 of the way in the book and, once again, the murderer just falls into Lucy's lap with no real investigative reporting happening on her end. I miss the old days where the ENTIRE BOOK had the crime and investigative reporting within the book. Lately, the crime is like an afterthought in addition to Lucy's ramblings and life events.
In the background, Lucy's father in law passes away and a woman(Kate) is claiming to be Bill's sister. Kudos to Edna, Bill's mom, for attempting to give this woman a warm welcome into the family....because she surely didn't receive it from ANYONE in Lucy's family, including Lucy's brats she calls children. Lucy speaks up and tells Edna that she thinks this woman is doing this for financial gain and was pretty hurtful in her words to Edna. Lucy is then SHOCKED that Edna leaves the farmhouse the next day and moves in with Kate. I don't blame Edna. Lucy was very rude and disrespectful to her. Later on, while dealing with the Kate saga, Bill is still giving Kate and Edna grief and THEN Lucy tells Bill to basically relax. Really? Flip flop Lucy.
Lately, it wouldn't be a Lucy Stone book without mentioning or having a few things in it: Politics? ✔Me too movement? ✔ Women's supposed inequality? ✔ Grammatical errors that I fix and have to keep a pencil nearby when I read? ✔ Lucy's double standards and judgement? ✔ Abortion vs pro-life?✔ Climate change? ✔ How crappy the economy has been for the last year? (We get it. You hate Trump!) ✔ Blue Lives Matter versus Black Lives Matter? ✔
Sadly, the entire premise and crime of this book is ONE. BIG. POLITICAL. HOT TOPIC. How disappointing.
Some things I found confusing/offensive within the book:
Page 120- Phyllis states "isn't it funny how coffee tastes and smells so good until you spill it? Then it's just icky." Is she licking coffee up after it's spilled and it tastes gross? Confusing statement.
Page 163: Lucy was becoming breathless from the effort of keeping up with Rosemary, who was surprisingly quick for such a large woman. Page 166: Lucy wondered if Rosemary approved of all this emphasis on Catholicism....or maybe she appreciated having time to herself she could spend at the gym. WOW. DIG? The weight comments on other characters continues. The comments are really unnecessary.
Lucy goes to interview Gabe's mom and, when asked about Melanie (the woman who accused him of sexual infractions), his mother's demeanor instantly changes and she becomes hard and cold towards Lucy. Lucy's response? Well, shucks, I must've hit a nerve and she brushes it off. Didn't his mother's response tell her ANYTHING? Isn't Lucy supposed to be this investigative reporter? Is she that clueless and lacks instincts?
I used to thoroughly enjoy Lucy, when she was a younger mother and actually investigated crimes. Now that Lucy has grown older, she has turned into a cranky, judgemental old lady. (Judging Rev. Marge for having a second helping of mac and cheese, while noting that she had gotten fat, yet Bob Goodman had a "full plate", but must've "missed lunch"?) Come on Leslie Meier. Do better please. You're about to lose another reader.