Rivals by Tommy Greenwald is an excellent exploration of the cultural issues surrounding youth sports, rivalries, different economic classes, and the internal conflict I'm sure many athletic youth face between their love for the game and all of the drama and demand that goes along with playing it. While the cover suggests a classic middle-grades sports story, and it certainly fits the genre, there is depth to be found here alongside some great starting off points for important discussions with young readers.
The main characters, Carter, Austin, and Alfie each go through their own struggles as they work through their increasing understanding that the demands the adults in their world place on them are killing their love of the game. This book highlights all the issues that permeate youth sports today: overbearing parents, supremely intense rivalries between children, the us-and-them mentality of families from different social classes, the pressure to succeed at all costs, and the pressure to secure the family's future through that success. All the kids in this book want to do is play ball- it is the adults whose pressures start to cause the kids to make poor choices. I think many youth athletes will find this book relatable and perhaps even eye-opening, and it should prompt some excellent discussions with students about the pressures the world places on their shoulders to be increasingly 'perfect' and 'successful' at increasingly younger ages.
One of the things I really love about this book is that the kids ultimately solve the social problems themselves- in fact, they actively work to get the adults out-of-the-way, so to speak, so that they can come together and unify over their love of basketball. This is a great message for kids in a position where the adults may not be able to be supportive in solving social problems, such as in school. It gives kids a blueprint for how to be better people now, where they are, rather than assuming that adults should be the ones to solve all the problems.
Now for the teachery bit: This book is a true middle-grades book. Content-wise, it's appropriate for upper-elementary students, but I think the true demographic is 7th-8th graders. There are some instances of bullying and some conflict that occur as part of sports trash-talk between kids, and some of this is based on race/ class (a student makes a disparaging comment suggesting that another student should go work at the country club like the rest of her family, for example). But, there are a lot of excellent examples of other kids in this book who are upstanders, not bystanders, including kids who are considered popular. Students see lots of great demonstrations of how to stand up in the moment when a friend or teammate makes an inappropriate comment. There is some diversity in this book, but all the central characters are white. It is noted early on that the town in which the book takes place has an obvious class division, where one middle school is mostly rich, white kids while the other school is lower-income and more diverse.
This is an excellent addition to any classroom library, and I think it would make a great book club offering or whole-class novel for students in grade 6 and lower-level readers in grade 7. I think on-level readers in grade 7 might find this book too easy a read, but there is enough depth to dive into characterization, theme, connections to the real world, etc. There are a ton of great articles, documentaries, etc. out there about youth sports, so this book could be a good basis for an argument or research unit as well!