What do you think?
Rate this book
True Colors #11
The Silver Shadow
A Shadowy Figure Is Intent on Harming Denver’s Women
Step into True Colors -- a new series of Historical Stories of Romance and American Crime
Denver of 1900 is still a dangerous place to be following the silver crash of 1893. And of out of the dark comes a shadow intent on harming women. Ambitious young Denver newspaper reporter Polly Blythe is searching for the big story that’s going to launch her career. On Friday evening, August 24, 1900, she gets her break when two women are cracked over the head within a two-minute walk of each other. But policeman Edwin Timmer thwarts Polly’s ideas of a serial criminal. . .until the shadowy figure strikes again. Will the reporter and the policeman team up to find the culprit before her strikes too close for comfort?
Step into True Colors -- a new series of Historical Stories of Romance and American Crime
Denver of 1900 is still a dangerous place to be following the silver crash of 1893. And of out of the dark comes a shadow intent on harming women. Ambitious young Denver newspaper reporter Polly Blythe is searching for the big story that’s going to launch her career. On Friday evening, August 24, 1900, she gets her break when two women are cracked over the head within a two-minute walk of each other. But policeman Edwin Timmer thwarts Polly’s ideas of a serial criminal. . .until the shadowy figure strikes again. Will the reporter and the policeman team up to find the culprit before her strikes too close for comfort?
256 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 1, 2021
6 people are currently reading
1237 people want to read
About the author
Liz Tolsma
41 books1,779 followersLiz Tolsma is the author of several WWII novels, romantic suspense novels, prairie romance novellas, and an Amish romance. She is a popular speaker and an editor and resides next to a Wisconsin farm field with her husband and their youngest daughter. Her son is a U.S. Marine, and her oldest daughter is a recent college graduate. Liz enjoys reading, walking, working in her large perennial garden, kayaking, and camping. Please visit her website at www.liztolsma.com and follow her on Facebook, Twitter (@LizTolsma), Instagram, YouTube, and Pinterest. She is also the host of the Christian Historical Fiction Talk podcast.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 155 reviews
August 14, 2021
I have been really enjoying the True Colors series from Barbour Books.
They are all based on True Crime Cases that happened long ago and people have forgotten about.
Some of the cases I have heard of and looked up and found more information on them.
This one is elusive, I couldn't find a thing about it.
Very interesting and attention keeping series.
Pub Date 01 May 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
They are all based on True Crime Cases that happened long ago and people have forgotten about.
Some of the cases I have heard of and looked up and found more information on them.
This one is elusive, I couldn't find a thing about it.
Very interesting and attention keeping series.
Pub Date 01 May 2021
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
April 30, 2021
Liz Tolsma is quickly becoming a favorite author of mine. She has strong, unwavering, determined female leads that will do nothing to stop them from getting what they want. Again in this book, Polly is a strong and determined female news reporter who will not let a man tell her what, or where, she should be.
Polly Blythe is a reporter for the Denver Post, of engagements, weddings, and articles women would read. But it is her dream to be a front-page reporter of the happenings of Denver, and when the Silver Shadow starts his run, that is the story Polly wants. But in the day of men dominating the working world, will she get her big break, and how many will try to derail her dreams because she is just that, a woman. And will the eye of a certain detective change that dream?
Edwin Price is an up and coming detective for the Denver police department who also is determined to find the Silver Shadow after the case becomes personal. But when Ms. Blythe comes into the police department asking to speak to the victims and become partners in the case - police and newspaper - can he keep his focus on the case and not the beautiful news reporter.
I enjoyed this book from the very beginning and was eager to see how Edwin and Polly solve this case, how working together brings them closer, and how their belief in God sets them in the path of belief and love.
I received this as an advanced read from Netgalley and the publisher. All opinions are my own.
Polly Blythe is a reporter for the Denver Post, of engagements, weddings, and articles women would read. But it is her dream to be a front-page reporter of the happenings of Denver, and when the Silver Shadow starts his run, that is the story Polly wants. But in the day of men dominating the working world, will she get her big break, and how many will try to derail her dreams because she is just that, a woman. And will the eye of a certain detective change that dream?
Edwin Price is an up and coming detective for the Denver police department who also is determined to find the Silver Shadow after the case becomes personal. But when Ms. Blythe comes into the police department asking to speak to the victims and become partners in the case - police and newspaper - can he keep his focus on the case and not the beautiful news reporter.
I enjoyed this book from the very beginning and was eager to see how Edwin and Polly solve this case, how working together brings them closer, and how their belief in God sets them in the path of belief and love.
I received this as an advanced read from Netgalley and the publisher. All opinions are my own.
October 22, 2024
3.65 rating. Good story, moderate suspense, but very abrupt ending and not all MCs accounted for.
April 23, 2021
1900-1901 Denver, Colorado
It's unsafe for women to walk around alone in the evening. Seemingly at random times, women are hit over the head and left to suffer.
Policeman Edwin Timmer is driven to find the villain. His motivation is knowing one of the victims and that his father was murdered when he was a child and the criminal was never found.
Newspaper reporter Polly Blythe is also inspired to find the villain. She wants to prove that she has talent and can succeed in her chosen profession. Her father doesn't support her choice and wants her to come home to St. Louis to marry and have children.
The steps taken to try and find the attacker kept me engaged throughout the novel.
Loved the historical details provided after the final chapter, especially in regard to hospital patronage at that time.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
It's unsafe for women to walk around alone in the evening. Seemingly at random times, women are hit over the head and left to suffer.
Policeman Edwin Timmer is driven to find the villain. His motivation is knowing one of the victims and that his father was murdered when he was a child and the criminal was never found.
Newspaper reporter Polly Blythe is also inspired to find the villain. She wants to prove that she has talent and can succeed in her chosen profession. Her father doesn't support her choice and wants her to come home to St. Louis to marry and have children.
The steps taken to try and find the attacker kept me engaged throughout the novel.
Loved the historical details provided after the final chapter, especially in regard to hospital patronage at that time.
My gratitude to publisher Barbour for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.
May 6, 2021
Another historical crime book! I have appreciated learning more about historical crimes through this series. Yes, they are often sickening because the crimes are committed by twisted minds, but they are also intriguing. This one had me guessing at the antagonist. I was wrong in my prediction, which means I thoroughly enjoyed watching the mystery unfold.
This one revolved around the Denver Post and crime against women – not violating them, but giving them concussions. Getting a glimpse inside the criminal’s twisted mind added a depth to the story.
Since this book was more mystery-driven than romance driven, I did enjoy the romantic elements. Yes, Edwin and Polly were sweet on each other, but their romance seemed to develop slowly and believably instead of rapidly. The majority of the romance was toward the end of the book and was more sweet than sappy to me.
There was a strong independent-woman thread, with Polly wanting to prove herself so much so that she defied her father (even if she had a reason) and refused to listen to the men in her life who cared for her. I personally would have liked to see a glimpse of forgiveness of her toward her father instead of her insisting on her own way.
The spiritual thread came out most toward the end and primarily when the characters were helpless and had to rely on God. The criminal actually had a contorted view of his actions pleasing God, which were disgusting as they were intended to be. I would have liked to have seen a little more balance between this and an actual Biblical viewpoint of pleasing God. It was kind of there, but not really in the forefront of the story.
As with many of the other True Colors books, you have to love disturbing mysteries to appreciate this book.
*I received this book from CelebrateLit and happily provided my honest review*
This one revolved around the Denver Post and crime against women – not violating them, but giving them concussions. Getting a glimpse inside the criminal’s twisted mind added a depth to the story.
Since this book was more mystery-driven than romance driven, I did enjoy the romantic elements. Yes, Edwin and Polly were sweet on each other, but their romance seemed to develop slowly and believably instead of rapidly. The majority of the romance was toward the end of the book and was more sweet than sappy to me.
There was a strong independent-woman thread, with Polly wanting to prove herself so much so that she defied her father (even if she had a reason) and refused to listen to the men in her life who cared for her. I personally would have liked to see a glimpse of forgiveness of her toward her father instead of her insisting on her own way.
The spiritual thread came out most toward the end and primarily when the characters were helpless and had to rely on God. The criminal actually had a contorted view of his actions pleasing God, which were disgusting as they were intended to be. I would have liked to have seen a little more balance between this and an actual Biblical viewpoint of pleasing God. It was kind of there, but not really in the forefront of the story.
As with many of the other True Colors books, you have to love disturbing mysteries to appreciate this book.
*I received this book from CelebrateLit and happily provided my honest review*
May 1, 2021
I have really been enjoying this series. Most of the crimes I have heard of. And I did some researching on the ones I did not. This one was very elusive. I couldn’t find a thing about it. Still it was fun to read. I wonder what is in store for readers next?
My thanks to Barbour Publishing for a copy of this book via Net Galley. I was not required to leave a review.
My thanks to Barbour Publishing for a copy of this book via Net Galley. I was not required to leave a review.
May 25, 2021
I love these True Colors crime novels as it is so fascinating to learn of true criminals and try to figure out why they perpetrated the crimes they did. I then like to look up the actual cases and research them. This author has become one of my favorite to follow as she weaves truth with fiction like a well woven tapestry. I especially love the faith element and how the characters see the need to rely on it when they see doing things on their own strength isn’t working. Weave in a little spark of romance to lighten the story and you have a winner. This book is part of a series but each book stands alone. Barbour Publishing has done an outstanding job creating something different to capture our attention. I highly recommend this to anyone who enjoys history, true crime, and a well woven story of truth and fiction where truth is stranger than fiction.
I received a complimentary copy from CelebrateLit. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
I received a complimentary copy from CelebrateLit. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
July 6, 2021
Polly Blythe is ahead of her time and determined to become a serious journalist, but instead the editor has assigned her to engagements and weddings. Edwin Price is a detective for the Denver Police Department. It is 1900 and a man who becomes dubbed by Polly as the Silver Shadow is brutalizing women throughout the city. All have the same MO, nothing stolen, no sexual attacks, just simply hit over the head with a metal object. When one of Polly's roommates is attacked and left with brain damage, Polly knows she has to find out who is doing this and soon becomes entwined in Edwin's investigation.
Liz Tolsma never disappoints. Her suspense is always a roller coaster ride that leaves me wondering what will happen next. Her obvious research adds depth and interest to her writing, and she brings her characters to life with vividness and intensity. Well written novel that is part of the True Crime series.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
Liz Tolsma never disappoints. Her suspense is always a roller coaster ride that leaves me wondering what will happen next. Her obvious research adds depth and interest to her writing, and she brings her characters to life with vividness and intensity. Well written novel that is part of the True Crime series.
**I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. Opinions are mine alone. I was not compensated for this review.
May 25, 2021
This is my fifth book that I have read from this series and so far I have enjoyed all of them. I will say that this one was a bit different than the others I have read in the series. There was suspense but it was bit more subdued but the storyline does keep you engaged and at least for me it kept me guessing on who the culprit was. It was also different because in this one you actually get to know the Silver Shadow and get a peek inside his train of thought and see his reasoning for attacking these women which was an interesting take on the storyline.
I really enjoyed the characters of Polly and Edwin. Polly is a go-getter and all she wants is to be a reporter that actually reports news and not society events. She really fights for this throughout the story and it made me sad that a huge part of it was because she was trying to get her father to be proud of her and accept her for who she was. Edwin is a detective with the Denver Police Department. He meets Polly through her investigation of these incidents and through that build a friendship and a later on a relationship. Their romance was nice and slow and very realistic. I really enjoyed their banter and how she would take over and somehow run the show.
This is my second book from this series that was written by her and I thought she did a great job. You can tell that she did her research and I think she did a great job at making these characters come alive even though a huge chunk of it is more fiction than historical. She did a great job at weaving the message that God's bigger and knows all of the plans for our lives throughout the story.
Overall I thought this was a great story and addition to the series. If you enjoy historical true crimes, suspense and a little romance then this is the book for you! I can't wait for the next one!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
I really enjoyed the characters of Polly and Edwin. Polly is a go-getter and all she wants is to be a reporter that actually reports news and not society events. She really fights for this throughout the story and it made me sad that a huge part of it was because she was trying to get her father to be proud of her and accept her for who she was. Edwin is a detective with the Denver Police Department. He meets Polly through her investigation of these incidents and through that build a friendship and a later on a relationship. Their romance was nice and slow and very realistic. I really enjoyed their banter and how she would take over and somehow run the show.
This is my second book from this series that was written by her and I thought she did a great job. You can tell that she did her research and I think she did a great job at making these characters come alive even though a huge chunk of it is more fiction than historical. She did a great job at weaving the message that God's bigger and knows all of the plans for our lives throughout the story.
Overall I thought this was a great story and addition to the series. If you enjoy historical true crimes, suspense and a little romance then this is the book for you! I can't wait for the next one!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
September 1, 2025
4.5 stars rounded down to 4
I did not want to put this book down once I started it, I was very quickly invested in the happenings and the characters. Each chapter left me hanging and needing to know what was going to happen next. Someone in Denver is targeting women out alone at night, and the police have no leads. Polly, a journalist meets police detective, Edwin, while writing a story on the happenings. The case begins to hit close to home for both of them but with the leads so few how will they ever figure it out. There was a moment where I was very concerned that the story would end badly for one of the characters I'd connected with. This would have been a five star book for me, but there is one part where the dates and references are incorrect based on information given in the previous chapter and this really bothered me. I do recommend this book though, it will keep you guessing until the end.
I did not want to put this book down once I started it, I was very quickly invested in the happenings and the characters. Each chapter left me hanging and needing to know what was going to happen next. Someone in Denver is targeting women out alone at night, and the police have no leads. Polly, a journalist meets police detective, Edwin, while writing a story on the happenings. The case begins to hit close to home for both of them but with the leads so few how will they ever figure it out. There was a moment where I was very concerned that the story would end badly for one of the characters I'd connected with. This would have been a five star book for me, but there is one part where the dates and references are incorrect based on information given in the previous chapter and this really bothered me. I do recommend this book though, it will keep you guessing until the end.
April 12, 2021
Liz Tolsma, an author that I've found to be very good at writing suspense thrillers in this series. The Silver Shadow, as with the others in this series is a nicely written standalone as part of the True Colors historical series. This story takes place in Denver during the 1900s where it appears that no women can be safe on the streets as the murderer is targeting women only.. Then we meet Polly Blythe, a young reporter and Detective Edwin Timmer who has been assigned to the case. Ultimately the two end up having their own personal reasons for catching the criminal and in the process, a relationship ensues towards the end as the drama unfolds itself.
This story is fiction based on true history that weaves mystery, suspense, twists and a bit of religion. I recommend this book for those who love true crime stories that are mixed with mystery and a bit of romance. Definitely a page-turner and quick read for me.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing via NetGalley in exchanged for my fair and honest review. All opinions are my own.
This story is fiction based on true history that weaves mystery, suspense, twists and a bit of religion. I recommend this book for those who love true crime stories that are mixed with mystery and a bit of romance. Definitely a page-turner and quick read for me.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing via NetGalley in exchanged for my fair and honest review. All opinions are my own.
April 7, 2021
We begin this book with the mugging of several woman who are out after dark on the streets of Denver in 1900, seems that no woman is safe, and why is this happeing? We meet a young woman that is wanting to prove herself, Polly Blythe wants to do more than just woman fluff articles! She soon becomes personally involved in the attacks, and goes upon a mission to find the culprit.
We also meet Police Detective Edwin Timmer, who ultimately ends up with a personal reason to catch the Shadow, and we get to meet him and know how much he cares, and his struggles.
The author does keep you guessing as to is the Thug, and she also gives us a bit of sweet romance, along with not knowing whom will be hurt or killed next.
Be sure to read the author's notes at the end, and learn how much the author has enjoyed writing these True Crime Stories, and how the real story played into this fictional read.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Barbour, and was not required to give a positive review.
We also meet Police Detective Edwin Timmer, who ultimately ends up with a personal reason to catch the Shadow, and we get to meet him and know how much he cares, and his struggles.
The author does keep you guessing as to is the Thug, and she also gives us a bit of sweet romance, along with not knowing whom will be hurt or killed next.
Be sure to read the author's notes at the end, and learn how much the author has enjoyed writing these True Crime Stories, and how the real story played into this fictional read.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Barbour, and was not required to give a positive review.
April 1, 2021
This story is a fictionalized true crime story set in Denver, Colorado in 1900. The story is told from the part of the 3 main characters. The Silver Shadow, Polly and Edwin. Polly is a twenty-something reporter at the Denver Post trying to find her way in a man's world. Edwin is a police officer that is trying to avenge his guilt for witnessing his father's murder. The Silver Shadow is a menacing murderer who is striking women on the streets of Denver. He feels that he is doing the Lord's work and teaching the people of Denver a lesson.
This was a captivating story to look at all of the different sides of the people that were being affected by the actions of the Silver Shadow.
Thanks to netgalley and Barbour Publishing for the arc. The opinions are my own.
This was a captivating story to look at all of the different sides of the people that were being affected by the actions of the Silver Shadow.
Thanks to netgalley and Barbour Publishing for the arc. The opinions are my own.
August 24, 2021
First sentence: “What is this?” Balding Joe Ward, his light-colored hair curling over his ears, smacked his copy of the Denver Post against his desk. A whiff of newsprint filled the city editor’s office.
Premise/plot: Polly Blythe works at the Denver Post newspaper. She covers the society pages--and hates it, mostly. She wants to cover REAL news, not sensationalized society fluff pieces. The novel is set in Denver, Colorado, circa 1900/1901. The city is about to experience a series of attacks--muggings-- targeting women. As Polly becomes interested in the case and covering it--off and on--the attacker seems to focus on HER specifically. Will she live long enough to see him arrested and charged with his crimes?
As a journalist she is seeking information--inside information--and one of her sources is a handsome police officer, Edwin Timmer. These two will work closely--perhaps not by his choice, at first. Can he protect the woman he's coming to love?
My thoughts: The Silver Shadow is the eleventh book in the True Colors series. These books are usually based on true crimes from American history. This book is very loosely based on a true crime case in Denver at the turn of the century. In reality, that criminal was never caught. In the novel, we get everything tied up neatly with ribbons and bows.
If you enjoy mystery and suspense with your romance, this one might suit well. It wasn't personally my favorite and best from the series. There were a couple of things that irritated me about The Silver Shadow.
What bothered me most was the red herring. For two-hundred pages it is hinted sometimes strongly, sometimes weakly, that the criminal is...well...I won't share his name for obvious spoiler reasons. Something BIG happens. And then it's revealed like in the last two chapters that it was RANDOM person whom we've never met. Since we've spent some of almost every chapter inside his head, it seems tricksy to have it turn out to be RANDOM DUDE as opposed to red herring. Granted, about halfway through I was like this is most likely a red herring because all directions are pointing straight to him. Still I was looking for any indication that it was someone else--anyone else--and the clues never really pointed anywhere (else). It was just frustrating as a mystery to have nothing to work with but misdirection.
Another thing that bothered me was learning at the end of the novel that in reality the criminal was never caught, never arrested, never put on trial, and that essentially the whole book has been misdirection.
Premise/plot: Polly Blythe works at the Denver Post newspaper. She covers the society pages--and hates it, mostly. She wants to cover REAL news, not sensationalized society fluff pieces. The novel is set in Denver, Colorado, circa 1900/1901. The city is about to experience a series of attacks--muggings-- targeting women. As Polly becomes interested in the case and covering it--off and on--the attacker seems to focus on HER specifically. Will she live long enough to see him arrested and charged with his crimes?
As a journalist she is seeking information--inside information--and one of her sources is a handsome police officer, Edwin Timmer. These two will work closely--perhaps not by his choice, at first. Can he protect the woman he's coming to love?
My thoughts: The Silver Shadow is the eleventh book in the True Colors series. These books are usually based on true crimes from American history. This book is very loosely based on a true crime case in Denver at the turn of the century. In reality, that criminal was never caught. In the novel, we get everything tied up neatly with ribbons and bows.
If you enjoy mystery and suspense with your romance, this one might suit well. It wasn't personally my favorite and best from the series. There were a couple of things that irritated me about The Silver Shadow.
What bothered me most was the red herring. For two-hundred pages it is hinted sometimes strongly, sometimes weakly, that the criminal is...well...I won't share his name for obvious spoiler reasons. Something BIG happens. And then it's revealed like in the last two chapters that it was RANDOM person whom we've never met. Since we've spent some of almost every chapter inside his head, it seems tricksy to have it turn out to be RANDOM DUDE as opposed to red herring. Granted, about halfway through I was like this is most likely a red herring because all directions are pointing straight to him. Still I was looking for any indication that it was someone else--anyone else--and the clues never really pointed anywhere (else). It was just frustrating as a mystery to have nothing to work with but misdirection.
Another thing that bothered me was learning at the end of the novel that in reality the criminal was never caught, never arrested, never put on trial, and that essentially the whole book has been misdirection.
May 30, 2021
I'm pretty sure The Silver Shadow is Liz Tolsma's best book to date. I don't say that lightly, because I LOVED The Green Dress more than probably all of the other books in the series (one still torments me a bit, though). Maybe it was just when I read it, or even that I just really resonated with the characters on a new level, but this one stands out more than all of Tolsma's books. Polly Blythe (whose name really reminds me a lot of "Nellie Bly" of The Gray Chamber) is a beautiful combination of bold, feisty, uncertain, and vulnerable.
The crime--riveting. While motives and the actual culprit were fictionalized, I think Tolsma used the most actual people from the time in her book than in any other book, despite her claim that it is the most fictionalized of the ones she's written. The fact that they never actually caught the killer, and she brought one to justice, of course makes that claim reasonable.
Of everything in the book though, two things stand out most to me.
First, personal motivations. I found that each character's motivations for why they did what they did--particularly Edwin, his family, and Polly--were deep and layered. It wasn't a simple case of a girl wanting to prove she could do a job as good as a man. One by one, Polly's motivations were peeled back until you found a core beneath them that breaks your heart. The same is true for many of the characters.
Second, the characters' faith. Each character had a different element of faith they demonstrated in quiet, natural ways that feel as if you're watching faith in action by people who have no idea anyone would be observing.
While I received a review copy of this book free, I also purchased two of my own copies so... yeah. There's that.
Recommended for lovers of historical fiction, true crime, and excellent writing that keeps you riveted to the page... and makes you look over your shoulder when you're walking out alone after dark. ;)
The crime--riveting. While motives and the actual culprit were fictionalized, I think Tolsma used the most actual people from the time in her book than in any other book, despite her claim that it is the most fictionalized of the ones she's written. The fact that they never actually caught the killer, and she brought one to justice, of course makes that claim reasonable.
Of everything in the book though, two things stand out most to me.
First, personal motivations. I found that each character's motivations for why they did what they did--particularly Edwin, his family, and Polly--were deep and layered. It wasn't a simple case of a girl wanting to prove she could do a job as good as a man. One by one, Polly's motivations were peeled back until you found a core beneath them that breaks your heart. The same is true for many of the characters.
Second, the characters' faith. Each character had a different element of faith they demonstrated in quiet, natural ways that feel as if you're watching faith in action by people who have no idea anyone would be observing.
While I received a review copy of this book free, I also purchased two of my own copies so... yeah. There's that.
Recommended for lovers of historical fiction, true crime, and excellent writing that keeps you riveted to the page... and makes you look over your shoulder when you're walking out alone after dark. ;)
June 6, 2021
What lingers in the shadows…
If you have followed my reviews throughout this series, you know how I feel about it. These authors are talented and their stories are gripping. The Silver Shadow is no different. In fact, it might be the best (but I won’t make that official because I haven’t taken a second look at the others).
We know the verse, “What ever is done in the dark will be brought into the light.” Or something like that. Polly and Edwin work to bring this person to justice in The Silver Shadow but they seem to work more in parallel instead of together. That proves to be an issues in their investigations.
Polly is desperate and a little reckless but her heart and intentions are in the right place. She wants these attacks on the women of Denver to stop and she is a bull dog in sticking to her intuition that tells her it is one person.
Edwin, he is admirable but he is singularly focused because of his personal pain. I felt like his reasoning for not agreeing with Polly’s hunch was only an excuse to keep her out of the investigation. Not that I could blame him. Women being out after dark were the target of these attacks.
The third point of view that popped up from time to time proved to offer a chilling element to the story that might have you on your guard when out on your evening walks.
Page-turner, gripping, heart pounding, engaging—all words I would associate with this story and I know I am not alone.
***I was given a copy of this book from the publisher through CelebrateLit. A positive review was not required but freely given.
If you have followed my reviews throughout this series, you know how I feel about it. These authors are talented and their stories are gripping. The Silver Shadow is no different. In fact, it might be the best (but I won’t make that official because I haven’t taken a second look at the others).
We know the verse, “What ever is done in the dark will be brought into the light.” Or something like that. Polly and Edwin work to bring this person to justice in The Silver Shadow but they seem to work more in parallel instead of together. That proves to be an issues in their investigations.
Polly is desperate and a little reckless but her heart and intentions are in the right place. She wants these attacks on the women of Denver to stop and she is a bull dog in sticking to her intuition that tells her it is one person.
Edwin, he is admirable but he is singularly focused because of his personal pain. I felt like his reasoning for not agreeing with Polly’s hunch was only an excuse to keep her out of the investigation. Not that I could blame him. Women being out after dark were the target of these attacks.
The third point of view that popped up from time to time proved to offer a chilling element to the story that might have you on your guard when out on your evening walks.
Page-turner, gripping, heart pounding, engaging—all words I would associate with this story and I know I am not alone.
***I was given a copy of this book from the publisher through CelebrateLit. A positive review was not required but freely given.
May 9, 2021
3.5 stars
"I WILL GET YOU. . . That was it. Four small words. Four small, powerful words."
A rather ominous four words. They should scare most women to death. But Denver newspaper reporter Polly Blythe didn't scare easily, or maybe she did . . . but she was still determined that the "silver shadow", the man who had been slinking around the city at night, attacking innocent women at will, had to be stopped; even if it meant being part of the process. And she knew exactly who could help her. Detective Edwin Timmer. Polly was determined to make a name for herself, to prove to her father and her editor that she could write stories of substance, and this case had practically "hit her over the head".
"Has anyone ever told you that you are the most hardheaded woman?"
Polly Blythe was going to be the death of him; Edwin had been unsuccessful in his efforts to convince the pretty little reporter to leave crime solving in the hands of the police . . . but then again, he could hardly blame her. Even in his own estimation the chief was not putting enough importance on the continual random muggings on the streets of Denver. However, when the case looms very close and personal, Edwin and Polly realize that some things are just out of their hands.
Such a fascinating story! Not only the fictional version, but the historical one as well. Readers will feel the urgency and the angst to catch this disillusioned killer, not only to make the streets of Denver much safer, but to clear the way for Polly and Edwin to live outside the shadows for the rest of their days.
"I WILL GET YOU. . . That was it. Four small words. Four small, powerful words."
A rather ominous four words. They should scare most women to death. But Denver newspaper reporter Polly Blythe didn't scare easily, or maybe she did . . . but she was still determined that the "silver shadow", the man who had been slinking around the city at night, attacking innocent women at will, had to be stopped; even if it meant being part of the process. And she knew exactly who could help her. Detective Edwin Timmer. Polly was determined to make a name for herself, to prove to her father and her editor that she could write stories of substance, and this case had practically "hit her over the head".
"Has anyone ever told you that you are the most hardheaded woman?"
Polly Blythe was going to be the death of him; Edwin had been unsuccessful in his efforts to convince the pretty little reporter to leave crime solving in the hands of the police . . . but then again, he could hardly blame her. Even in his own estimation the chief was not putting enough importance on the continual random muggings on the streets of Denver. However, when the case looms very close and personal, Edwin and Polly realize that some things are just out of their hands.
Such a fascinating story! Not only the fictional version, but the historical one as well. Readers will feel the urgency and the angst to catch this disillusioned killer, not only to make the streets of Denver much safer, but to clear the way for Polly and Edwin to live outside the shadows for the rest of their days.
May 31, 2021
3.5 Stars
As the author states in the notes at the end of the novel, The Silver Shadow is the most fictionalized version of a true crime than any other book in the series. This is because of the lack of source materials.
Liz Tolsma does a remarkable job of weaving a suspenseful story with many historical names and influences in 1900 and 1901 Denver. While this book isn’t as disturbing as some of the other books in the series, it does still astound the reader as to how some humans can injure others for their own reasons.
And while I enjoyed the slow burn romance between Polly and Edwin, there were a few instances in the book that had me scratching my head. Overall, this was a nice addition to the series, but the fact that I can’t go look into the true facts of the crime made it lose some of the appeal of the other books in the series had for me.
Disclosure statement: I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
As the author states in the notes at the end of the novel, The Silver Shadow is the most fictionalized version of a true crime than any other book in the series. This is because of the lack of source materials.
Liz Tolsma does a remarkable job of weaving a suspenseful story with many historical names and influences in 1900 and 1901 Denver. While this book isn’t as disturbing as some of the other books in the series, it does still astound the reader as to how some humans can injure others for their own reasons.
And while I enjoyed the slow burn romance between Polly and Edwin, there were a few instances in the book that had me scratching my head. Overall, this was a nice addition to the series, but the fact that I can’t go look into the true facts of the crime made it lose some of the appeal of the other books in the series had for me.
Disclosure statement: I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
May 10, 2021
I was excited for this one ever since I gave 5 stars to The Gold Digger, also part of the True Crimes series and written by Liz Tolsma.
I was again provided with an intriguing historical mystery, a hero you don’t see every day, and a headstrong heroine who tried to find her place in a male dominated world. Sophie’s recovery from the Silver Shadow was probably the saddest for me.
I didn’t find the crime as strong and creepy as in the Gold Digger, but the author again kept me guessing with a few different suspects, made me second guess myself and threw in some creepy factor by showing us some POV from the culprit and why he was targeting women.
The author also ended with a note of what was true facts, where she had to get creative with fiction and a list of the real victims of the Silver Shadow.
Recommended for readers who like a bit more of a thriller plot.
Looking forward to the next true crime book in the series.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
I was again provided with an intriguing historical mystery, a hero you don’t see every day, and a headstrong heroine who tried to find her place in a male dominated world. Sophie’s recovery from the Silver Shadow was probably the saddest for me.
I didn’t find the crime as strong and creepy as in the Gold Digger, but the author again kept me guessing with a few different suspects, made me second guess myself and threw in some creepy factor by showing us some POV from the culprit and why he was targeting women.
The author also ended with a note of what was true facts, where she had to get creative with fiction and a list of the real victims of the Silver Shadow.
Recommended for readers who like a bit more of a thriller plot.
Looking forward to the next true crime book in the series.
*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*
September 22, 2021
This series reminds me of the Twightlight Zone! Goodness!
But in light, I have enjoyed this series and this book is an excellent addition.
Wonderful characters and events that I never knew about until I picked up this series.
Tolsma writes the most wonderful stories! I love each and every one but I think The Pink Bonnet is my favorite.
In my opinion Polly is ahead of her time and I admired her for the work she did.
I thought Edwin and Polly made a great team. I found myself rooting for them as they tried to find out the whodunit. I very much enjoyed sleuthing with them.
I hope to see more books in this series continue. What a great series!
My thanks for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
But in light, I have enjoyed this series and this book is an excellent addition.
Wonderful characters and events that I never knew about until I picked up this series.
Tolsma writes the most wonderful stories! I love each and every one but I think The Pink Bonnet is my favorite.
In my opinion Polly is ahead of her time and I admired her for the work she did.
I thought Edwin and Polly made a great team. I found myself rooting for them as they tried to find out the whodunit. I very much enjoyed sleuthing with them.
I hope to see more books in this series continue. What a great series!
My thanks for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
June 4, 2021
Imagine living in a city where women are afraid to walk the streets. Women are being attacked and the criminal evade the police. Put together a policeman and a woman struggling to make it in the world of journalism where men dominant the profession and you have a mystery to be solved. Based on a true story, Liz Tolsma brings it to life as you meet great and not so great ones. Well developed story that makes you look behind yourself when walking in the dark. Great book, want to know what happens and how it ends? READ THE BOOK!
Blessings,
Karen Hadley
Rating: 5*
I received this book as a gift and all opinions are my own.
Blessings,
Karen Hadley
Rating: 5*
I received this book as a gift and all opinions are my own.
April 19, 2021
Do you enjoy crime stories? Maybe a bit of true crime but with some fiction. This book "The Silver Shadow" is book eleven in the True Colors series. What a plot this is. There seems to be a mysterious person that keeps hitting women on the head.
We mean you introduced the main two characters—some of the crime that is going on. We meet a mysterious male that wants to teach women their place in the time of the 1900s. The woman is a reporter for the Denver Post. Edwin is the other main character; He works at the Denver Police department.
The more we get into the story or plot. It is more interesting. Polly gets another dressing down from her boss. She still wants this story and to solve these crimes. The detective has to get the runaround, and these bosses seem to think it nothing to be concerned about these crimes. The story is getting more twists and turns. The man shows up once more and remains described as the Silver shadow. Will he be caught?
This book has quite a few twists and turns. Who could be the mysterious Silver Shadow? When will they stop? It is a good book for adults if they want a little history and some crime and a mystery to go along with it. I hope to be able to read more of these True Color series books. I have read a few of them and enjoy them.
We mean you introduced the main two characters—some of the crime that is going on. We meet a mysterious male that wants to teach women their place in the time of the 1900s. The woman is a reporter for the Denver Post. Edwin is the other main character; He works at the Denver Police department.
The more we get into the story or plot. It is more interesting. Polly gets another dressing down from her boss. She still wants this story and to solve these crimes. The detective has to get the runaround, and these bosses seem to think it nothing to be concerned about these crimes. The story is getting more twists and turns. The man shows up once more and remains described as the Silver shadow. Will he be caught?
This book has quite a few twists and turns. Who could be the mysterious Silver Shadow? When will they stop? It is a good book for adults if they want a little history and some crime and a mystery to go along with it. I hope to be able to read more of these True Color series books. I have read a few of them and enjoy them.
October 24, 2024
I’ve tried four times to get into this story, and it’s just not grabbing my interest. I’m not a fan of overtly feminist characters, and Polly definitely is. I’m also not a fan of altered history.
There are many thousands of other books waiting to be read—I’m not giving this one any more of my time.
There are many thousands of other books waiting to be read—I’m not giving this one any more of my time.
October 3, 2023
Although I enjoy true crime and historical fiction, this one's not for me. I don't like revenge plots, and I also really didn't like being in the bad guys head. It made me very sad, and I just didn't want to pick it up. The writing was good, though.
May 30, 2021
Who knows what evil lurks in the hearts of men?
This is the most unusual book of the True Colors series thus far, in my opinion, which only makes it all the more intriguing. I purposely avoid book summaries, except for perhaps a very bare-bones version, when choosing which books to read, and in the case of this series, I usually recognize the case very early on. As “The Silver Shadow” progressed, however, and I still remained clueless, I really had to fight the urge to peek ahead!
Something that struck me from the beginning is that this case reminded me of Jack the Ripper, albeit less gruesome, due to the female targets and the nocturnal timing of the crimes, as well as the fact that the perpetrator was able to strike and escape each time. Liz Tolsma, as she details in her author’s note, takes artistic liberty with “The Silver Shadow” because little is known about the crimes themselves. So little, in fact, that only one text appears to mention them: “Famous Crimes the World Forgot” by Jason Lucky Morrow. A quick Internet search of my own turned up only one article, which also references this text. I won’t spoil the story by revealing the ultimate outcome; suffice it to say that this historic crime spree offers plenty of fodder for the imagination.
Tolsma provides some of the specifics of the crimes of “The Silver Shadow” committed between August 1900 and March 1901 in Denver, Colorado, crafting a fictionalized storyline around a young female reporter named Polly Blythe and police detective Edwin Price. Tapping into the mindset of the time period, Tolsma writes Polly as a burgeoning careerwoman fighting against the patriarchy in order to prove herself and achieve success. Polly opines: “It’s not that I’m after fame and fortune. I want recognition of hard work. Acceptance as a capable, intelligent reporter. That’s what I would like.” Which puts her directly at odds with the Silver Shadow, who believes that women “had to learn how to stay home and put their husbands and their families first.” Polly’s dogged determination challenges Detective Price to not only solve the case and protect the women of Denver, but also to come to terms with an old burden.
An absorbing combination of psychology, romance, and mystery make “The Silver Shadow” a must-read for fans of the genre while simultaneously demonstrating the emergence and subsequent repercussions of women’s rights in society. The insights into the perpetrator’s mind keep readers guessing and offer a speculated motive. A summary of the victims in the author’s note at the end of the story is very helpful for gaining perspective on the case as a whole. I do wonder about one of the fictional characters in the novel, whose story I don’t feel is fully resolved. Also, a pedantic point that is very likely no fault of the author but has niggled my senses: on the back cover, the detective’s name is given as Edwin Timmer, but his surname throughout the book is Price.
I received a complimentary copy of this book through Celebrate Lit and was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.
This is the most unusual book of the True Colors series thus far, in my opinion, which only makes it all the more intriguing. I purposely avoid book summaries, except for perhaps a very bare-bones version, when choosing which books to read, and in the case of this series, I usually recognize the case very early on. As “The Silver Shadow” progressed, however, and I still remained clueless, I really had to fight the urge to peek ahead!
Something that struck me from the beginning is that this case reminded me of Jack the Ripper, albeit less gruesome, due to the female targets and the nocturnal timing of the crimes, as well as the fact that the perpetrator was able to strike and escape each time. Liz Tolsma, as she details in her author’s note, takes artistic liberty with “The Silver Shadow” because little is known about the crimes themselves. So little, in fact, that only one text appears to mention them: “Famous Crimes the World Forgot” by Jason Lucky Morrow. A quick Internet search of my own turned up only one article, which also references this text. I won’t spoil the story by revealing the ultimate outcome; suffice it to say that this historic crime spree offers plenty of fodder for the imagination.
Tolsma provides some of the specifics of the crimes of “The Silver Shadow” committed between August 1900 and March 1901 in Denver, Colorado, crafting a fictionalized storyline around a young female reporter named Polly Blythe and police detective Edwin Price. Tapping into the mindset of the time period, Tolsma writes Polly as a burgeoning careerwoman fighting against the patriarchy in order to prove herself and achieve success. Polly opines: “It’s not that I’m after fame and fortune. I want recognition of hard work. Acceptance as a capable, intelligent reporter. That’s what I would like.” Which puts her directly at odds with the Silver Shadow, who believes that women “had to learn how to stay home and put their husbands and their families first.” Polly’s dogged determination challenges Detective Price to not only solve the case and protect the women of Denver, but also to come to terms with an old burden.
An absorbing combination of psychology, romance, and mystery make “The Silver Shadow” a must-read for fans of the genre while simultaneously demonstrating the emergence and subsequent repercussions of women’s rights in society. The insights into the perpetrator’s mind keep readers guessing and offer a speculated motive. A summary of the victims in the author’s note at the end of the story is very helpful for gaining perspective on the case as a whole. I do wonder about one of the fictional characters in the novel, whose story I don’t feel is fully resolved. Also, a pedantic point that is very likely no fault of the author but has niggled my senses: on the back cover, the detective’s name is given as Edwin Timmer, but his surname throughout the book is Price.
I received a complimentary copy of this book through Celebrate Lit and was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.
April 22, 2021
Being the mother of a detective, I have high expectations for crime novels, and I hate to admit that this book was a disappointment. The writing seemed more geared to the young adult market, with awkward descriptions like, "Fire rushed from Polly's belly to her face, exploding out her ears." I find it hard to take that (or Polly's high opinion of herself amidst her frequent fainting spells) very seriously. I realize law enforcement has changed a lot in the past hundred years, but even allowing for that, I felt the way the police department and court system was depicted was juvenile. And the fact that this book did NOT follow the historical facts of the case left me even more cold.
One of the things I did like about the book was Edwin's realization of God's sovereign plans. He could USE Edwin, but didn't NEED his schemes and plans to bring about justice. After all his machinations, Edwin is finally able to pray, "Thank you, Lord....You do a much better job than I do."
I received an early copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley and was not required to post a review.
One of the things I did like about the book was Edwin's realization of God's sovereign plans. He could USE Edwin, but didn't NEED his schemes and plans to bring about justice. After all his machinations, Edwin is finally able to pray, "Thank you, Lord....You do a much better job than I do."
I received an early copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley and was not required to post a review.
June 7, 2021
The Silver Shadow is a mysterious story taken from an actual historical series of attacks in Denver, CO between August 24, 1900 and April 19, 1901. I very much appreciated the author’s attention to historical detail even while taking some creative liberties. I also really enjoyed reading what historical facts exist in public record about this series of crimes at the end of the novel. While quite the sensational story, the actual culprit was never found historically speaking.
I appreciate Liz Tolsma’s easy style as a writer. The narrative never feels forced or awkward and the dialog between characters is quite natural. Sometimes I did feel like there were awkward jumps between scenes, but I did enjoy the way the characters evolved from start to finish.
Polly Blythe is quite the spitfire of a heroine! I loved her tenacity and spirit as she pushed forward to do what she felt she was created to do. It was certainly not easy for a woman to break into the word of news reporting at the turn of the century, buy she kept pressing on. Her dogged determination did have some deeply personal roots which are revealed as the story progresses endearing her all the more to the reader.
The hero, Edwin Price, was easy to like and root for as he searched for the culprit plaguing the women of the city. His desire to clear his conscience from a regret from childhood drives his passion for justice. I appreciated this character development in particular and enjoyed how this particular individual grew throughout the ordeals he faced.
I also very much appreciated the way faith was handled. I pretty much only read Christian fiction or children’s literature as I try to keep what I read clean. Still, I don’t really appreciate a book that forces the faith aspect of the story. Tolsma did an excellent job of weaving the faith of the main characters seamlessly throughout the story. She kept it believable and relatable, while still bringing the reader closer to the Lord in their own faith journey.
The love story between the two main characters progressed in a sweet way and with much more grace than I sometimes read in novels. I appreciated that Tolsma does not feel the need to focus on intimacy, especially as my own teen daughters are reaching the age to enjoy reading stories with romance. I am excited to recommend this particular title to my 15-year-old who really likes a good mystery.
This is a light read, great for summer vacation. I highly recommend this title and look forward to reading more from Liz Tolsma!
I appreciate Liz Tolsma’s easy style as a writer. The narrative never feels forced or awkward and the dialog between characters is quite natural. Sometimes I did feel like there were awkward jumps between scenes, but I did enjoy the way the characters evolved from start to finish.
Polly Blythe is quite the spitfire of a heroine! I loved her tenacity and spirit as she pushed forward to do what she felt she was created to do. It was certainly not easy for a woman to break into the word of news reporting at the turn of the century, buy she kept pressing on. Her dogged determination did have some deeply personal roots which are revealed as the story progresses endearing her all the more to the reader.
The hero, Edwin Price, was easy to like and root for as he searched for the culprit plaguing the women of the city. His desire to clear his conscience from a regret from childhood drives his passion for justice. I appreciated this character development in particular and enjoyed how this particular individual grew throughout the ordeals he faced.
I also very much appreciated the way faith was handled. I pretty much only read Christian fiction or children’s literature as I try to keep what I read clean. Still, I don’t really appreciate a book that forces the faith aspect of the story. Tolsma did an excellent job of weaving the faith of the main characters seamlessly throughout the story. She kept it believable and relatable, while still bringing the reader closer to the Lord in their own faith journey.
The love story between the two main characters progressed in a sweet way and with much more grace than I sometimes read in novels. I appreciated that Tolsma does not feel the need to focus on intimacy, especially as my own teen daughters are reaching the age to enjoy reading stories with romance. I am excited to recommend this particular title to my 15-year-old who really likes a good mystery.
This is a light read, great for summer vacation. I highly recommend this title and look forward to reading more from Liz Tolsma!
May 27, 2021
I absolutely love this series and look forward to learning about crimes that have taken place during different time periods. This story is set in the 1900s where women were not welcomed in the world of working outside the home. Men believed they should be at home tending to children, doing housework and be at their husband’s beck and call.
I welcomed the star of the story with enthusiasm. Polly was out to prove that women could work outside the home and do it just as well as men. Her time as a reporter was not welcomed by some and I liked how determined she was to succeed. Her strength and wisdom suited her well as she became involved in a story that shook the quiet neighborhood she lived.
Denver was thriving and there was much going on as the city grew and crime picked up. As readers are introduced to this mysterious person who was harming women, I knew it was going to be a race to solve the crime. The author does state that she did take some liberties in the story but I think she did a good job of bringing the characters to life. I was trying to keep up with the little crumbs of evidence but couldn’t quite figure out who it was.
Edwin is a good police officer who won’t rest till he finds the culprit that injured women in vicious and random attacks. The choice of weapon made me cringe. As the author described the attacks, I could feel the pain that radiated in the victim’s head. It was a horrible crime and I’m glad that Polly and Edwin teamed up to capture the person. The only problem I had with the story was the way Polly seemed to act like was not concerned about her safety. Why did she keep going out at night by herself knowing someone was out there attacking women? She had been warned many times but she was so determined to break the story she forgot her own safety.
Overall the book was entertaining but it did lack the punch that other stories in the series have had. It lacked details at times and some were not consistent with the story and was confusing. I did like how a group of men came together to help catch the person but they disbanded quickly. The police department was not very equipped to handle a case like this as they continually arrested someone who turned out to be innocent. The story is good but I felt like the ending was rushed and I was hoping for more attention given to the person behind the crimes. It was a great opportunity to delve into the reason he did it and perhaps go back to his past and allow readers to see why he chose to target women.
"I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and Celebrate Lit and was under no obligation to post a review."
I welcomed the star of the story with enthusiasm. Polly was out to prove that women could work outside the home and do it just as well as men. Her time as a reporter was not welcomed by some and I liked how determined she was to succeed. Her strength and wisdom suited her well as she became involved in a story that shook the quiet neighborhood she lived.
Denver was thriving and there was much going on as the city grew and crime picked up. As readers are introduced to this mysterious person who was harming women, I knew it was going to be a race to solve the crime. The author does state that she did take some liberties in the story but I think she did a good job of bringing the characters to life. I was trying to keep up with the little crumbs of evidence but couldn’t quite figure out who it was.
Edwin is a good police officer who won’t rest till he finds the culprit that injured women in vicious and random attacks. The choice of weapon made me cringe. As the author described the attacks, I could feel the pain that radiated in the victim’s head. It was a horrible crime and I’m glad that Polly and Edwin teamed up to capture the person. The only problem I had with the story was the way Polly seemed to act like was not concerned about her safety. Why did she keep going out at night by herself knowing someone was out there attacking women? She had been warned many times but she was so determined to break the story she forgot her own safety.
Overall the book was entertaining but it did lack the punch that other stories in the series have had. It lacked details at times and some were not consistent with the story and was confusing. I did like how a group of men came together to help catch the person but they disbanded quickly. The police department was not very equipped to handle a case like this as they continually arrested someone who turned out to be innocent. The story is good but I felt like the ending was rushed and I was hoping for more attention given to the person behind the crimes. It was a great opportunity to delve into the reason he did it and perhaps go back to his past and allow readers to see why he chose to target women.
"I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and Celebrate Lit and was under no obligation to post a review."
April 27, 2021
Liz Tolsma's The Silver Shadow is based around crimes perpetrated by the once infamous "Capitol Hill Thug" who assaulted women walking alone after dark in 1900-1901 Denver. In an end note, the author states that this was her most fictionalized of the four stories she's written for the multi-author True Colors series of true American Historical crime/Inspirational romantic suspense from Barbour Books.
With little source material to work with, Tolsma has woven the story of a young newspaper reporter, Polly Blythe, who is determined to prove herself in a field hostile to women and the policeman, Edwin Timmer, who is determined to bring the Shadow to justice. Interspersed between Polly and Edwin's growing attraction as they work together and face professional obstacles are chapters that slowly reveal the motivation of the man Polly will name the Silver Shadow.
The Silver Shadow is the eleventh book in the True Crimes series, which can (luckily for me) be read in any order. So, if you have enjoyed other titles in the series you may enjoy this new addition, or if not, then this is a fine place to start. Either way, this is an enjoyable entry in the series, bringing to life an obscure piece of American criminal history. At times it felt that the proscribed length for this series was a hindrance to delving deeper, but Polly and Edwin are personable, the challenges they face keep the story moving, and I enjoyed how commonplace the element of faith was in Edwin's home and the police station - though not in the newspaper office.
This review refers to a temporary digital galley I voluntarily read via NetGalley, courtesy of the publisher. A positive review was not required and all opinions are my own.
With little source material to work with, Tolsma has woven the story of a young newspaper reporter, Polly Blythe, who is determined to prove herself in a field hostile to women and the policeman, Edwin Timmer, who is determined to bring the Shadow to justice. Interspersed between Polly and Edwin's growing attraction as they work together and face professional obstacles are chapters that slowly reveal the motivation of the man Polly will name the Silver Shadow.
The Silver Shadow is the eleventh book in the True Crimes series, which can (luckily for me) be read in any order. So, if you have enjoyed other titles in the series you may enjoy this new addition, or if not, then this is a fine place to start. Either way, this is an enjoyable entry in the series, bringing to life an obscure piece of American criminal history. At times it felt that the proscribed length for this series was a hindrance to delving deeper, but Polly and Edwin are personable, the challenges they face keep the story moving, and I enjoyed how commonplace the element of faith was in Edwin's home and the police station - though not in the newspaper office.
This review refers to a temporary digital galley I voluntarily read via NetGalley, courtesy of the publisher. A positive review was not required and all opinions are my own.
April 30, 2021
The Silver Shadow by Liz Tolsma is a marvellous Christian historical novel and part of the True Colors series.
It is a fascinating novel set in Denver in 1900 and based on true crimes. Fact blends with fiction to produce a cracking tale.
We witness the plight of women. They were seen as the weaker sex who need to stay protected in the home. It was deemed unsafe for them to walk the streets after dark. Women may have received the vote but were still viewed as unworthy by some. There were some plucky women who were determined not to be put down by chauvinistic attitudes and who actively sought out the perpetrator of the crimes against women.
Women were prejudiced against in the workplace. The leading lady longs to be a serious journalist but is given the frivolous social events of females to cover. Her writing skills are not taken seriously by either her employer nor her father.
The characters were well drawn and realistic. The women with their caring attitudes, looked out for each other.
Trusting God was important. He will never let us down. His plans for our lives can be trusted. When events spiral out of control, we can call out to God who will rescue us. We can cry out to Him with our hearts when our lips have no words.
The Silver Shadow was a fabulous read. It is also quite as a scary read as you realise similar crimes against women actually happened in 1900.
This True Colors crime series is fantastic. I am loving all the books in it.
I received a free copy of the book from Barbour Publishing at Net Galley for a blog tour with Celebrate Lit. All my opinions are my own.
It is a fascinating novel set in Denver in 1900 and based on true crimes. Fact blends with fiction to produce a cracking tale.
We witness the plight of women. They were seen as the weaker sex who need to stay protected in the home. It was deemed unsafe for them to walk the streets after dark. Women may have received the vote but were still viewed as unworthy by some. There were some plucky women who were determined not to be put down by chauvinistic attitudes and who actively sought out the perpetrator of the crimes against women.
Women were prejudiced against in the workplace. The leading lady longs to be a serious journalist but is given the frivolous social events of females to cover. Her writing skills are not taken seriously by either her employer nor her father.
The characters were well drawn and realistic. The women with their caring attitudes, looked out for each other.
Trusting God was important. He will never let us down. His plans for our lives can be trusted. When events spiral out of control, we can call out to God who will rescue us. We can cry out to Him with our hearts when our lips have no words.
The Silver Shadow was a fabulous read. It is also quite as a scary read as you realise similar crimes against women actually happened in 1900.
This True Colors crime series is fantastic. I am loving all the books in it.
I received a free copy of the book from Barbour Publishing at Net Galley for a blog tour with Celebrate Lit. All my opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 155 reviews