Honestly, the book was boring to me. A whole lot of nothing happened with pretty language. Cinderella's slipper just so happens to fit her stepsister Esmeralda's foot. That was why I bought this book. I had just been asking myself, "What would happen if the slipper fit more than one girl?" The exicution of the book, however, left a lot to be desired.
The pacing was slow. Days in the book blended together because nothing happened. It's mostly Cinderella moping about because her Prince (named Prince) was going to marry Esmeralda, and the Prince moping about because he didn't find his Mysterious Princess (and then moping about because some other Lord casts glances at Cinderella). The main characters, sans Esmeralda, were either cardboard cutouts or just jerks. Cinderella was boring because she rarely did anything beyond mope and tell us in very colorful purple prose how afraid of her stepmother she was, the Prince was a jerk, his faithful cousin could be non-existent, Pricilla (the other stepsister) contributed very little, and the stepmother was so stereotypical evil I'm surprised she didn't twirl a mustache. Things like this are okay in fairy tales where the whole story fits on a page and is told to little kids, but when I read an adult adaptation, I expect characterization.
Frankly, it would have been more interesting if told through Esmeralda's eyes only. Here she is, some poor girl who grew up under the oppression of a social-climbing mother, just happens to have the right foot size and KNOWS she's not whom the prince wants, discovers a comraderie with her sister and stepsister, and worries about doing the right thing or what the world expects of her. Of all the characters, I liked Esmeralda the best.
The prince's habit of forgetting Esmeralda's name was annoying. Especially after 50% in and we discover he has no problems remembering anyone else's name. It just smacked to me of disrespect, that we were seeing the prince's disrespect toward a woman he didn't love and we were expected to laugh at it. I didn't find it funny. I pitied poor Essie.
Speaking of the prince, his obsession with both his Princess and Cinderella just screamed of problems. Had he married Essie, I could just imagine him carrying on an affair because he didn't care about her feelings, only his own. And Cinderella presented no better. With her constant mooning over the prince and hopes that he looks her way, I can see her going along with the affair because it proves he loved her.
Furthermore, I would have suggested that Ms Wheeler invest in a baby name book, except I can tell she owns one. She threw an entire baby name book worth of E names at us for the many, many, MANY names the prince comes up with for Esmeralda, but failed to give the prince a name beyond Prince. Seriously, yes, that was his name. Prince. His parents have names, the fairy godmother has a name, the uncalled for mouse that Cinderella drags along who did nothing has a name. All but the prince. Why? Heck, call him Charlie Charming or something. But Prince just smacks of laziness.
The ultimate purple prose in the book became tedious. We'd get description over and over again of how stoic the queen was, how evil the stepmother was, how beautiful Cinderella was, and so on with different words to describe the same ones used maybe a paragraph before. I had to put the book down to look up some of the words. Long paragraphs to tell us that a character is unpleasant could be better spent showing us.
All in all, it was a vast disappointment. The ending was very tacked on. We spend countless chapters of the characters talking and doing nothing, only to have it end with a confession, possible murder (which doesn't go anywhere or had any resolution. pity), and the sudden knowledge of who Cinderella is and we all live happily ever after with three epilogues. No book needs three epilogues.