He's come in search of treasure... ...Sydney hates him. Grace loves him... Will he rip mother and daughter apart?
Sydney had it all. Her own successful business in Chicago, doing what she loved. What she was born to do, and then she didn’t. Now, in her second act of life, she’s come back to where it all began. Her plan is simple. No men. No drama. No heartache. She ignored the omens last time. Won’t happen again.
Okay, so the first omen wasn’t great. On the journey home, she’s stopped by the state police. There’s a fugitive on the loose. But that wasn’t really about her. Right? And she’s only got two weeks to open her new business. But hey. That’s not an omen. Is it? Then she finds her old sleazeball, grab hands professor kissing her mother in Grace’s bookstore. Her father’s ghost wants the jerk dead. Grams' ghost wants him gone. That’s not all. The professor is on a treasure hunt, and it’s turning the Village of Moon Lake upside down, bringing undesirables into town, and pitting neighbors against neighbors. Add to that three handsome men vying for Sydney’s attention, and the omens spell one word in capital letters. That word is TROUBLE!
If you love cozy mysteries, ghosts, and offbeat characters, download this Paranormal Women’s Fiction set in the rural community of Moon Lake, Indiana.
Lucia Kuhl is the author of thirty midlife paranormal cozy mysteries. She believes every story needs at least one ghost, maybe a witch, or possibly an angel. A pet is always good. Talking forest animals are even better. Oh, and a hint of romance while headstrong, opinionated characters mingle.
A few of her women sleuths carry guns. Some only need magic. And her characters never miss a chance to dance. Lucia enjoys exploring tough subjects and lighting them in humorous ways to lessen the sting while showcasing their root issues. Her books contain no sex, strong violence, or profanity.
You’ll find Lucia at Luciakuhl.com. Check the social media bar in the header or footer to follow her on any or all platforms. Want to know what’s happening in her story worlds between books.
No spoilers, just some details from the first 20% or so.
Acquired Kindle edition when offered free on Amazon, 4 November 2026.
I understand that giving away a book in a series -- usually the first book -- is intended to hook the reader on the characters, setting, storyline, and/or writing style so they buy the subsequent books. There was nothing about this book that intrigued me at all, and a lot of things that actively disinclined me to follow either the series or the author.
Oft-changed cover and title creates confusion. So does the misnumbering of the books in the various apparently linked series; the reader needs a program to keep track of each series and the books in them. So does the blurb on this Goodreads page that implies the book is told from a first-person point of view, when in fact it's all third person. (Does that mean the book was substantially revised at some point in its publishing history? That seems to be a recurring issue in author-published books lately.)
Originally I started to read this several months ago when I acquired Magic in Moon Lake: Books 1-3 on 20 May 2026. I read two chapters and quit; it wasn't holding my interest. It was so much not holding my interest that it didn't even register when I saw the single volume offered free in November. (I acquire a lot of books this way.) When I began reading the single book, I immediately knew I had read the opening before, so I had to do some research to figure out why it was so familiar. That's when I found the earlier (free) purchase of the set. Why give away three books in May, then just one in November? That seemed to suggest to me that giving away three books hadn't proven to boost sales.
These Amazon freebies aren't like the review copies distributed by Netgalley or BookBub, in that there's no expectation of a review, favorable or otherwise. They're just free. And like those readers who subscribe to other services with a promise to provide a review, I'm not ashamed to say I take advantage the freebies to build a library of the types of books I like to read.
I don't like to read poorly written books. Unfortunately, there are a lot of them in amongst the freebies.
Also unfortunately, Moon Lake Sleuths is one of those poorly written books. In a spirit of determination, I set aside my earlier disappointment and have actually read seven chapters this time, in the hope it would get better. Alas, it did not. The plot makes no sense. The "magical" setting makes no sense. And what's supposed to be "writing" is horrible.
Sydney Hovan has just ended -- or had ended for her -- what seems to have been a twenty-year marriage. It's left her heartbroken and bitter, to the point that she's swearing off drama and men. It has also, at least according to the blurb here on GR, left her with an empty bank account.
"I thought I was happy. The joke was on me. I owned a successful dance studio in Chicago and came home to a handsome, charming, successful man. Life was good until the day I discovered he’d cleaned out my bank accounts and leveraged my assets. Grieving and faced with financial ruin and shame, I packed my things and moved back to Moon Lake, Indiana, determined to following three simple rules. No men. No heartache. No drama."
Yet she still managed to scrape up enough cash to buy her parents' house in Indiana? That lack of internal consistency can ruin a book for me pretty darn quickly.
As can a lack of understanding geography. If Sydney left Chicago at 4:00 a.m. via I-90, she'd be crossing the state line into Indiana within an hour or so, perhaps less. In another hour and a half she'd reach South Bend. According to the text on page 1, her new home was but twenty-five minutes from there. Or roughly three hours' total travel time. Yet when she arrives at that new home, no mention is made of the early hour, nor of the time change from Central Standard Time in Chicago to Eastern Standard Time in Indiana. Indeed, it almost seems as if she's arrived in the late morning, since Able Heinz is already up and about on New Year's Eve.
Even if Moon Lake and the neighboring town of Abracadabra are supposed to be magical, good world-building depends on attention to details like time and distance. Especially for someone coming from the mundane world of Chicago.
Then there's the fact that this whole moving from Chicago happens on New Year's Eve, but by the next morning -- page 16 -- Sydney's mother Grace is at her book shop with no mention being made of it now being New Year's Day. There had certainly been no celebration of New Year's Eve, though Sydney does mention that if she hadn't left Chicago, she'd have hosted a New Year's Eve ball. So why make a point of mentioning it as though there were some significance to the date, and then New Year's Day doesn't matter?
I might have been able to ignore some of this, but what really turned me off was the lack of character development. The inconsistency of Sydney's financial picture was part of that. The "reality" author Kuhl establishes for Sydney -- the disastrous end to a marriage, the uprooting of her entire life, the loss of her business -- never seems to impact her. She doesn't have any uncertainty about her future. Well, of course, she's got this cozy and apparently more or less wealthy family to come back to, a setting for her new dance studio, and even the prospect of expensive landscaping doesn't cause much concern. I guess with all the ghosts running around, Sydney just assumes it will all be taken care of?
Then of course comes the issue with Edmund "Sleazeball" Spencer, the would-be rapist. Yes, it's icky. It's very icky. It's throw-this-book-against-the-wall icky. (I've given up on the sanctity of real persons' names. Apologies to Edmund Spenser.)
I could accept, albeit reluctantly,, that Sydney had never told her mother about the incident while Sydney was in college, though I did question why Sydney was even going to college and what had she studied since "Dancing was all she knew, and she’d been self-employed for most of her life." If in fact "Teaching dance was in her DNA," shouldn't there have been some mention made of her education for that? And if the incident happened twenty years ago, I could even understand how and why Sydney might have questioned her recollection of what happened and therefore refrained from bringing the subject up again with her mother.
But then there's the issue of ages. Again, according to the text, Sydney's been living in Chicago for twenty years. This puts her somewhere in the neighborhood of forty. Her mother Grace was at one time engaged to Spencer, which means both of them have to be at least sixty-ish or so. That they'd be making out in an open-for-business bookstore on New Year's Day is just plain ludicrous. And there's already a customer in the store!
I nearly quit at that point. I think it was just sheer anger that kept me reading. That's how I found out that the ghost of Sydney's father had accompanied her to the college campus -- wherever it was -- and supplied the broom with which Sydney fought off Spencer's assault. So, excuse me, why didn't the ghostly daddy come to Sydney's rescue when the thieving husband was up to his dirty work? Obviously, Dad's spirit isn't tethered to one place.
So I come to the writing of this review after having read seven chapters, and I'm pretty sure this is going to be a DNF. At 19%, there's no discernible plot, the characters are uninspiring, and the writing is cringeworthy. But yeah, lots of people love it, 'cause it's so quirky, right? I hate that word.
No. Just no. This book was deadly dull. The bit where the fmc’s mother was dating the man who attempted to rape her daughter in college and continued to date him after she found out about the assault? Gross. The mystery was slow moving to the point of stagnation.
Any review over 1 star has been paid for. Anyone who actually read the book knows it's absolutely awful. Poorly written, disjointed, reads like AI in many places.
And the main character's mother dates a man she knows tries to r*pe her daughter... No.
I deleted the book permanently from my Kindle and this author is on a DO NOT READ AGAIN list. Disgusting.
The interactions and conversations were stilted enough to begin with, but the mom’s (non)reaction to finding about her boyfriend’s attempt to sexually assault her daughter in the past pushed it to the limit.
TW: Sexual assault. This is so poorly written to begin with but I had to stop when she was waffling about how to get her mom to stop dating the professor who tried to rape her when she was in his class in college… like… “how do I convince her not to see him? The heart wants what it wants!” What about tell her you literally had to fight him off with a broom that her dead husband magically put in your hand?!? If you can’t tell your mom that her scum of a boy friend tried to rape you, maybe you don’t have as great a relationship with her as you think.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This was a quick, easy read and kept me wanting to read more. The story follows a bit of a treasure hunt turned murder mystery. Nothing was overly surprising in the book but it was still quite enjoyable to watch it unfold.
There were a few things I had issue with but it didn't detract from the overall story. The timeline was a bit hard to follow at times. It would seemingly jump around in the middle of a paragraph and occasionally I had to backtrack to figure out when something happened. I also understand this is the first in the series, but there are many things that are mentioned with no context so we are just left to wonder for an entire book. I want to know more about the past relationship and what broke it apart. She mentions may times the one DNR officer possibly being linked to her ex but we don't even know anything about the ex. So it being mentioned on multiple occasions was slightly annoying.
Overall, there were a lot of interesting aspects introduced in the first book and I really want to see where they all go. I am hopefully that we will get more backstory for our main characters and learn more about all the attractive men milling about in Moon Lake.
Dance artist and teacher, Sydney, is returned home to start over, opening her own dance studio, but first she had to overcome a murder, solve a secret treasure mystery, over come past hurts and past terrors. The writing and plotting are easy to follow, making this a very quick fast read. I liked that Sydney is a strong, independent woman and stands up for herself. I did feel like a had walked into book 2. Without explanation, we’re carrying on conversations with ghosts. Events happen way too fast, with the ghosts helping out. All in all, a fun, non taxing simple read.
This series has potential but the numerous punctuation and grammatical errors riddled throughout has put me off reading any other books by this author. Characters are constantly saying things that should have an exclamation point but have a question mark, there are quotation marks missing on nearly every page, and it’s hard sometimes to follow who is saying what.
Loved this paranormal mystery series. The plot line is interesting and has lots of twists and turns. The characters are well written with just enough quirkiness to make you enjoy them. The mysteries as there are more then one are intriguing and advance the storyline in ways that bode well for an on going series.
Enjoyed the story, characters, and the mystery. Sydney returned to her home town, Moon Lake, from Chicago. She was looking for, among other things, no drama. Not exactly what she found! Follow along to see how she & her companions investigate the happenings in the town. You'll be glad you did!!!
This had me a bit confused, like when I started the book I was missing the actual starting of it. I am missing content. I jumped right in the middle, but it was actually the beginning. Hunh?
I don't know, maybe it's just me. Ya, probably. I'm sure the next book will be better now that I know the characters a bit.
This is a cute story with a good mystery. I couldn’t guess that each person had something to do with it. The one thing was the back story on Sydney. What was she running from? Why was she moving back to the small town she moved away from? The characters were well written emotionally and physically.
I got a little confused with the third person point of view. Didn't know which 'she' you were talking about, names weren't used often enough for me. But that's me. Loved the story regardless!
I enjoyed this story. Just discovered this author, and I am pleased I did. The plot, mystery and characters are good. I will be reading the next book in this series.
Sydney comes home to find a fugitive on the loose in the area and her mother is dating her ex professor. A buried treasure brings strangers to town and trouble. I liked the way the story unfolded and I am looking forward to more.
Well written, with a great cast of characters, both good and bad. An interesting location, and ghosts. I really enjoyed this book, and have high hopes for the other boom. Lucia Kuhl writes a really good story!
This was just okay for me. All the paranormal cozy elements were there, but I wasn’t really drawn into it like I hoped. This will just be a blip in my mind.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I felt like there were so many characters, n I couldn't really tell who was talking sometimes.. it was a good story! I just didn't really get into it..
Felt like I was missing something though. Like the chapters started mid story. Left me asking questions about her history. Introduction to Lily, story about her ex.
2024 bk 174. If I had read this series first before the Farm series I might have enjoyed it more. It was like I came back to review a test after taking the test. Not bad, but I felt that the missing pieces were already stored in my head. That said, I did enjoy getting to know the main character as a main character and not in a supporting role.
This is the first book in another paranormal cozy series. I did enjoy this although I really had a hard time understanding how a mom could accept a creep like Edmund after what he did. I loved Aunt Lily and Sydney the main character in the books. I look forward to reading the next book.