Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Dukes of Distinction #4

Duke of Arrogance

Rate this book
A woman spurned by the ton...

A duke harboring an appalling secret...


Life radically changes for Arabella Jennings, the daughter of an Oxford don, when her father becomes the Earl of Barrington. She’s an intellectual who would rather be discussing Shakespeare’s works but now finds herself navigating the vicious waters of Polite Society.

Jonathan Sutton’s twin dies, making him the new Duke of Blackmore. Pledging to live for both himself and Arch, Jon becomes one of London’s leading rakes, breaking rules and bedding women as his brother would have done had he lived.

Jon meets Arabella the first night of the Season and decides this woman, so different from every conquest he’s made, might help him from the abyss he’s sunk into.

Can a bluestocking with a quick wit tame the disreputable Duke of Arrogance—and save his soul?

Find the answer in The Duke of Arrogance, Book 4 in the Dukes of Distinction.

216 pages, Kindle Edition

First published May 6, 2021

370 people are currently reading
256 people want to read

About the author

Alexa Aston

148 books482 followers
Award-winning and USA Today bestselling author Alexa Aston lives with her husband in a Dallas suburb, where she eats her fair share of dark chocolate and plots out stories while she walks every morning. She enjoys travel, sports, and time with her family.

Her historical romances bring to life loveable rogues and dashing knights, while her contemporary romances are light and flirty and sometimes contain a bit of suspense.

Stay in touch with Alexa at:

Website: https://alexaaston.com/

Newsletter Sign-Up: https://dashboard.mailerlite.com/form...

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/authoralexaa...

Twitter: https://twitter.com/AlexaAston

BookBub Follow: https://www.bookbub.com/authors/alexa...

Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/author/alexaaston

BingeBooks Author Page: https://bingebooks.com/profile/AlexaA...

Goodreads Author Page: https://www.goodreads.com/author/show...

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,216 (59%)
4 stars
577 (28%)
3 stars
203 (9%)
2 stars
40 (1%)
1 star
14 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 106 reviews
Profile Image for Debbie DiFiore.
2,740 reviews317 followers
May 19, 2021
Very different

The hero is a twin whose brother died young so he goes out and lives the life his brother would have lived . The irony here is the disease that took the brother was vile, and yet the hero went out and by living for his brother exposed himself to the same disease over and over. It was stupid. I think if anything he would have done a complete 360 and lived a better life so it would mean something. I don't want to give it away but that was disappointing. Instead of doing something noble, like finding a cure, he chose to be a disgusting 'rake'! I felt sorry for Arabella. She is going to continue to be meeting his ex lovers everywhere she goes. And yes she definitely handled herself well when she was confronted but she is going to have to deal with this for the rest of their married life. Just yuk. He was faithful to her after they met but he did take her for quite a ride with his wavering I want her, I don't want her, I love her, I will never love her, and on and on. I was very weary of that by the end. But it was a good read. I don't know if I have ever read this author before but I will try her again. She writes pretty well.
Profile Image for &#x1f989;Maggie Whitworth.
3,254 reviews113 followers
May 6, 2021
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
💋💋

A real moody Duke for you in this one, he reckons he has it made, rules the Ton.
Little do the Ton know they aren’t seeing the real man. It’s an act, but why?

Emotional and beautiful chemistry between Jon and Arabella, both have had challenging pasts, both need someone to show them they fit in, are loved, who better than each other.

Really great story to keep you hooked and happy, Alexa never fails to deliver on the emotion and passion.
Five Stars

I received an Arc copy of this book and chose to post this review
Profile Image for HR-ML.
1,274 reviews55 followers
June 14, 2021
Regency. This had a new-to-me author. Too perfect for me.

Jonathan's older twin died, then his sire had an apoplexy
episode and soon died. Jon became the duke but his secret
bore a hole in his soul. Arabella's Da, 4th son of an earl,
served as an Oxford don, in philosophy? (author unclear
on his area of academic expertise). Arabella sat in on his
lectures and wrote his lectures. She was as good as an
academic herself. Da, Bella & students debated when they
had evening meals together.

Jon met Bella & considered her outspoken, intelligent &
humorous. He knew her for a short time before he
decided she'd become his future duchess. But he didn't
trust love: we readers knew the drill.

Bella demonstrated intelligence, confidence & common
sense. Her Da became an earl after deaths in the family
(too many, too close together). Bella's confidence
collapsed as she joined ton events. I doubt Bella would
be totally in the dark RE ton rules. I doubt the mean
girls would be so blatant & brazen toward Bella.

Jon honored his late twin Arch by being like him-
a flimsy rationale-an entitled rake who broke the rules.
Which seemed nonsense. Jon had 3 besties who were all
dukes. Really?

This story required too much suspension of belief to be
enjoyable. A magistrate would've investigated the many
deaths which made the h's Da an earl? The pieces of this
story fit too conveniently into place.
Profile Image for Elodie’s Reading Corner.
2,554 reviews152 followers
May 1, 2021
Duke of Arrogance
Dukes of Distinction Book 4
Alexa Aston
https://www.facebook.com/authoralexaa...
Release Date 05/06/2021
Publisher Dragonblade Publishing
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B091G2MZ66/...

𝗕𝗹𝘂𝗿𝗯

A woman spurned by the ton . . .

A duke harboring an appalling secret . . .

Life radically changes for Arabella Jennings, the daughter of an Oxford don, when her father becomes the Earl of Barrington. She’s an intellectual who would rather be discussing Shakespeare’s works but now finds herself navigating the vicious waters of Polite Society.

Jonathan Sutton’s twin dies, making him the new Duke of Blackmore. Pledging to live for both himself and Arch, Jon becomes one of London’s leading rakes, breaking rules and bedding women as his brother would have done had he lived.

Jon meets Arabella the first night of the Season and decides this woman, so different from every conquest he’s made, might help him from the abyss he’s sunk into.

Can a bluestocking with a quick wit tame the disreputable Duke of Arrogance—and save his soul?

𝗠𝘆 𝗿𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄

Will he let his past doom his future ...

I sadly missed the first three books in this series due to my own fault, a too crowded reading schedule. But the first three books await patiently on my shelves for a later time with some reading time to spare.
So when I saw for once that my reading week agenda was for once not too overwhelming, I jumped on the occasion for this upcoming release.
Plus I was in need of some lighter read, and I know the author would perfectly suit this single purpose.
The heroes have been both wrongly labeled because of fraud first impressions, he a profligate and she an inept bluestocking.
He first had been erroneously nicknamed for his older late brother’s wild escapes, so when he inherited his sire’s title, he continued to live the life his brother would have, living behind his own dreams and aspirations.
Arabella became in the space of an instant a lady when her whole life she had only been a commoner, her father’s assistant, an educated woman. So while she can quite well handle all situations only requiring knowledge and cleverness, she is at lost when facing the ton’s rules and its acerbic tongue. Why her first foray in society leaves her a bitter taste.
Until an unknown gentleman sweetens the blow she just received from her inexperience with ton’s rules.
Their courtship is easy and smooth until Jonathan fears his darkest secret might taint their relationship. Yet can he let her go when she fulfill all his inner needs and wants.

A cute romance about two persons who want more than living by the society’s rules.
4 stars

𝗦𝘁𝗲𝗮𝗺 𝗹𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗹 onscreen foreplays and lovemaking scenes.

I have been granted an advance copy by the publisher Dragonblade Publishing, here is my true and unbiased opinion.

https://www.facebook.com/429830134272...
Profile Image for Lori D.
4,080 reviews131 followers
May 7, 2021
A Duke that is Arrogant? Surely not! At least outwardly Jon, the Duke of Blackmore appears the rake personified but inside he may be feeling different. Awarded the title at an early age, when his twin died, it had dictated his emotions, especially the secrets he kept.

Arabella suddenly found herself the daughter of Earl, when her father, previously an Oxford don, inherited the title. The only problem was, attending her first ball at twenty five and having no idea how to act, was going to be a problem.

Then she and Jon met. Alexa has brought us another wonderful story to add to this fabulous series! I could not help but want to hug Jon and Arabella was in need of him, although neither realized it. Simply perfect!
527 reviews4 followers
August 26, 2022
Duke of Arrogance is the fourth in a series about five dukes, each known by a moniker that supposedly defines him but does not accurately describe him.

At least that's supposedly the case with Jonathon Sutton, Duke of Blackmore. Born the younger twin, he never expected to be more than the spare, and he was okay with that. Devoted to his brother Arch--who was really the arrogant one of the two--he spent years willingly taking the blame for his brother's mistakes and misadventures, especially in the face of their father, who only loved his heir and had no affection or patience for Jon. But Arch dies when they're just 16, and his father quickly follows, leaving Jon a duke before he even enters university. In honor of his brother, Jon decides to be the arrogant ass that Arch would have been. He proceeds to behave like a jerky moron for about a decade.

That's partly why I didn't fall in love with this book. It's not enough to tell me that he's really a misunderstood, shy rule follower when none of his natural tendencies follow him into adulthood; he may not have started out an entitled arrogant jerk, but he legitimately becomes one. Snapping at a servant and pulling out the "I'm a bloody duke" card? Not cool, your Grace.

But what of our heroine? Intelligent bookish Arabella Jennings has a status change as well when her father--an Oxford don and a fourth son--unexpectedly inherits an earldom. Together, they navigate the waters and eventually end up in London, where Arabella is to have her first Season. Her first ball is pretty much a disaster, and she hides in the library. That is where Jon meets her for the first time. Almost immediately, he decides to court her.

The courting goes well until it doesn't. Arabella, for all her intelligence, falls quickly for Jon's good looks and charisma. They do share a love of books and learning, and I wish we'd seen more of them clicking. Instead, Jon suffers an "I'm not good enough for her; she deserves someone to love her" crisis, and he steps away. But then after a few weeks, he changes his mind again, and Arabella only puts up a token resistance. I really wanted her to make him grovel.

So that's pretty much the pace of the story: Arabella steadily moving forward through her Season with the Duke of Arrogance bouncing between being amazing and assholey. There is a Big Secret in his background that has to be dealt with too, and it is. But it doesn't really end up making too much of a difference in the long run.

In spite of all my grievances, I didn't dislike this book, which is generally well written. It is good to see the characters from previous novels, especially the heroine and hero from the third book, The Duke of Disrepute (I really liked that one); there's actually a slight overlap in the storylines, which is fun, though it may spoil the end of book 3 for this who read the series out of order.

I'm looking forward to the final duke's story. (Dare I hope Sebastian will find his match in Elizabeth?)

I received an ARC of this book from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for my honest opinion. Thanks!
Profile Image for Carole Burant.
1,278 reviews38 followers
May 4, 2021
Alexa Aston continues to write such wonderful stories for her Dukes of Distinction series. This time it's the Duke of Arrogance whose story is told and honestly, all I wanted to do was hold Jonathan and tell him everything was going to be all right!!! I actually shed tears for him for what he'd gone through because of his twin.

The characters become so realistic as you read their story and you can't help but be completely immersed in their lives. I loved Jon, no matter how arrogant he could be, and I also loved Arabella in all her honesty, wit and intelligence. Together they are the perfect couple, if only Jon would open up his heart and let her in. Be prepared for balls, tea parties, rides in Hyde Park, as well as how vicious the ton can be! If I would have been Arabella, I would have given up on it all! lol I also enjoyed seeing characters from the previous books make appearances.

I received an ARC of this book via NetGalley and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
Profile Image for Edwina " I LoveBooks" "Deb".
1,440 reviews17 followers
November 27, 2021
AUDIBLE EDITION!!

Arabella Jennings father was an Oxford Don. But now all his brothers are dead and he has become the new Earl of Barrington. Arabella is very intelligent and beautiful but she is also, kind. She is found by Jonathan the Duke of Blackmore reading a book in the library of a Ball she was attending. Jon was bored with the ball too. But he and Arabella strike up a conversation and she tells him how she tried to meet young ladies at the Ball but they had Stubbed her giving her the Cut Direct. Jon sets out to help her by introducing her to all his Ducal friends and their wives. Jon loves Arabella straight forward way of conversing with him. He is determined she will become his next Duchess.

I loved Jon and Arabella they talk and work things out. No misunderstandings that are not cleared up right away. This is what I loved about this story.

Narration was Okay!!
Profile Image for Anna.
1,090 reviews7 followers
September 11, 2021
Hero pushed heroine away.
"im too damaged goods"...
Heroine was trying to win him back...
Not my cuppa

Profile Image for Brenda.
3,504 reviews47 followers
May 6, 2021
This is a great read to make sure you are going to be happy with the story.
Jon and Arabella's story made a good read. You never knew what would happen next.
Alexa Aston writes a good storyline.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. This in no way affects my opinion of this book which I read and reviewed voluntarily.
Profile Image for Pam  Bereznak.
1,828 reviews137 followers
May 11, 2021
OMG I freakin' loved this book.
I just recently started reading Alexa Aston books and LOVED this series especially this book. I think this is my favorite so far.

The two characters were amazing. Perfect for each other.
So good!!!!!
Profile Image for Rainelle.
2,204 reviews125 followers
June 15, 2021
Duke of Arrogance, by Alexa Aston. It was such a pleasure for me to read this book. The first few chapters introducing Arabella and Jon had my mouth gaping like a fish. There was so much intense drama in them. I thought sure someone wouldn’t make it out alive in the book.
The book was very entertaining and fun to read. The story focused on the courtship of Jon and Arabella. This book is an easy read for the diehard readers. The book provides the readers with information about the formalities of being introduced into the ton. This is something Arabella finds herself struggling to cope with.
But with the help of Jon, his sister and his friends, Arabella slowly excepts these friendly gestures. Until next time my fellow readers… read on!


Profile Image for Kendra (NurseKendraReads).
354 reviews23 followers
May 9, 2021
Duke of Arrogance by Alexa Aston

I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.

Release date: May 6, 2021

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 Stars
Steam: 🌶🌶 🌶/5

This is the fourth book in the Dukes of Distinction series. However, that did not make me understand this book any less. It holds up good as a stand alone. There are mentions of the other Dukes, but nothing confusing that would make it hard to just read this one.

This books starts out really interesting. Both the love interests are thrust into new roles in society due to tragic circumstances. Jon a Duke and Arabella the daughter of the newly appointed Earl.

Arabella has never been out in “polite society” before so she doesn’t know most of the rules of the Ton. This makes for some really great scenes.

Points for insta attraction by the love interests. I also really enjoy the banter between these two characters. Arabella is such a strong female and I love it. Jon’s sister Elizabeth also was such a good character and I loved reading scenes that had her in it.

The writing of this book was excellent, it was fast paced and kept me interested throughout! I felt the love interests had great chemistry!

4.5 stars
as I would have liked some scenes to have been a bit longer, especially scenes with the two main characters in conversations, as these parts were so fun in the book. I also think some plot points could have been flushed out more. But overall a really great read.

After reading this, I want to check out the other books in this series!

This book was a cute, steamy, short historical romance! This book is 230 pages so it’s perfect for a short, steamy romantic summer read.

Thanks to NetGalley,
Dragonblade Publishing for the ARC in exchange for my honest review!
3,474 reviews42 followers
May 2, 2021
This is the fourth book in the Dukes of Distinction series, and the third one that I have read. The series is about hot dukes who are also good friends. There are some mild spoilers here for Elise and Weston's engagement scene if you want to read their book first.

Jonathan, Duke of Blackmore goes by the moniker Duke of Arrogance but deep down he's more like the Duke of Insecurity. His father had no love to spare for his spare, only for his heir, Arch, Jon's twin brother. When Jon loses both his brother and his father in the same day, he becomes the duke quite unexpectedly. He has promised his brother to live a full life for both of them, but he feels guilty for inheriting what was supposed to belong to Arch, and harbors a tragical secret about the way that Arch died. He has lived a rake's life but all his dukely friends are getting married now and Jon thinks it's time too.

Lady Arabella has also been thrown into her title quite unexpectedly, as her father was the estranged fourth son of an earl and never hoped to inherit a title. Arabella's father used to be an university don and they never had much clue about how the ton works. Now that Arabella is making her come-out she feels dowdy and out of place at her first ball. However, an accidental meeting between Jon and Arabella leads to Arabella dancing with several dukes that night, and she gains new friends and a dashing titled suitor. However, his past makes Jon feel inadequate and unworthy of love, and they have to deal with Jon's secrets before they can be happy together. (I would have preferred it if Jon realized he needed to do that before announcing their engagement and anticipating their vows).

I enjoyed this book a lot and finished it in a day.

A tiny historical research nitpick: When Jon thinks about not getting married he wants to announce the ton that his cousin Arthur will be his heir apparent. But a cousin would be an heir presumptive. An heir apparent is someone who cannot be displaced by the birth of another, such as the oldest living son.

I got a digital review copy from Netgalley and I'm leaving a voluntary, honest review.
828 reviews52 followers
May 10, 2021
It was a good book but I would say that the first three chapters were just so unbelieveable that I had a hard time liking this book as much as I’d want.

What happened in those chapters, you ask? Well **SPOILERS AHEAD**

… there are lots of deaths of characters on and off the page. Arabella’s father is the forth son and suddenly he learns that he became a duke after all three of his brothers died suddenly. I mean, I’m not saying it’s not possible and it’s definitely unique because I haven’t seen this kind of plot in any book I’ve ever read but it is still just so… ugh, impossible? I guess I would prefer if at least one died two years or something ago not in the same chapter and months or even days apart.

To make this even more unbelieveable is the fact that Jon’s brother and father also died in the same chapter (well, separately from Arabella’s I think) all in the matter of seconds, making him the new duke. How convenient, right? Now, they are both members of the society. Well, Jon’s brother and father died 14 or so years before the story begins but nonetheless.

Arabella of course didn’t know how to act in Society and after crying in the bathroom she kindly helps a woman with her hair only to realise minutes later that the woman is no other than Jon’s sister. Said sister than introduces Arabella to her friends and now our heroine becomes the belle of the ball in a matter of an hour if not less.

The book is filled with this coincidences, it’s very short on angst, not much of smut just a couple hot moments but nothing memorable. Some things were also quite unbelievable (I’m sorry for using this word so much but it is true). For example, her dragging Jon in a bedroom just for kissing before they were even married or engaged. I also couldn’t believe she was in love with him after knowing him for a month or two.

3 stars. I didn’t like the book but didn’t hate it. I was just dispassionate towards it.

⭐⭐⭐
Rating: 3 out of 5.
ARC provided via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Full post: https://slovenianbookworm.wordpress.c...
Profile Image for Gerda.
775 reviews
February 20, 2022
This book was an OK read for me thus two **.
The plotline sounded interesting the execution was not, there were several inconsistencies:
- he saw how his brother suffered from the pain caused by syphilis, nevertheless he started the same debaucherous life sleeping through the ladies of the ton.
- why regret helping his twin and thinking of it as murder and therefore not deserving happiness. These self doubts come up till the end.
- Arabella's family lives in paltry conditions, poor food, no servants. I doubt that a don of a renown university, his students being the offsprings of nobility who had to pay large fees wouldn't get enough wage to provide well for his family.
- her father was the fourth son of an earl (that means imbibe manners from one's infancy), had a good education otherwise he wouldn't be a don, so didn't he learn the manners of the ton at Eton, Harrow, Cambridge, or Oxford? Why didn't he instruct his daughter? Her mother wanted to belong to nobility ( that's why she married him) wouldn't she know a little bit and pass it on to her daughter?
Nice to read but the above mentioned points bothered me the whole time.
Profile Image for Dew.
762 reviews63 followers
September 20, 2022
Regrettable

Ay. This book. It is bad. There’s an okay idea for a story and the characters are marginally interesting, but the execution is not up to the task. The first 3 chapters should be cut entirely and reincorporated as emotional reveals as it makes him seem like a psychopath who saw his brother for the 1st time in 6 months, spent 30 minutes catching up, then helped him commit suicide without the bat of an eyelash before going after his father. In a single afternoon, he took out all the male members of his family.

If one can get past the introductory death and mayhem, the insta-love discussing Puck from A Midsummer Night’s Dream was not nearly the meet-cute that I’m sure the author intended. “You’ve heard of Shakespeare? I’ve read Shakespeare! We should get married!” After 2-3 days of courting they’re ready to say “I do” until the author realized that she needed another 5 chapters - queue more death, obligatory page count, and the regularly scheduled HEA.
154 reviews2 followers
June 5, 2021
I was a bit disappointed

I love Alexa Aston, but what stayed with me the most after reading this,was how it seems all heroes are man whores. Why is that? Why doesn’t it matter that the “H” bedded every woman the h will meet in the ton? How many more ex-mistresses will make comments to the h? Does it really make it ok that he didn’t really like being a rake? Doesn’t it make it worse that he had all that sex with all those women for nothing? Everything is too easy for the H, even when he abandoned the h.
Profile Image for Sophie.
1,445 reviews553 followers
May 1, 2021
I received an Advance Reader Copy from the publisher via NetGalley. This in no way impacted on my view.

For Jonathan Sutton, he never expected that he would become Duke of Blackmore at the age of sixteen. As the second son, 7 minutes younger than his twin brother, he always thought Arch, the golden child would inherit, and not for years. But, after his brother contracted syphilis and died, causing his father to have a stroke and also pass, he was left alone in the world, with only his 6 year old sister, Elizabeth, for company. His moniker in the ton is the Duke of Arrogance, but after Elizabeth's debut last year, he has tried to curb his excesses, and become more respectable. However, he still hasn't considered marriage, not even when three of his best friends have found happiness; that is, until he meets Lady Arabella Jennings in a library. Arabella was born as plain old Miss Jennings, the only daughter of a fourth son, and was more than happy with her lot in life, especially when it awarded her the opportunity to help her Oxford don father with his lectures, and embrace her own studies. Now finding herself as the daughter of a newly inherited Earl, she makes her debut in her twenties, and immediately makes a number of mistakes, and faux pas. But, with the help of Jon and his friends, she starts to make her way in society, but may be at risk of losing her heart. Can Jon find it in himself to be open to love, or will his pass come back to haunt him?

As the fourth book in the series, I already felt like I knew Jon from meeting him in previous stories, but I absolutely loved him as the hero this time around. He had had a difficult childhood, and had to grow up quickly that it had irrevocably changed him. He only had Elizabeth and his friends to keep him grounded, but now nearly thirty, and with his friends settling down, it's time for him to consider his future. Arabella was a lovely heroine too, who was lucky in the fact that her father had allowed her a well rounded education, better than most women her age, but finding herself a 'lady', without knowing the ways of the ton, it was difficult for her to make friends or even go about her business in her new society. Meeting both Jon and Elizabeth was a godsend, and though there are moments of angst that were perhaps unnecessary, but all in all, I enjoyed the book, and can't wait for the final instalment.
3,286 reviews37 followers
May 6, 2021
Duke of Arrogance by Alexa Aston. I must disclose I am a huge fan of Aston and of this series. Take it for what it's worth. Jonathon Sutton had been a friend of the other Dukes of Disrepute for years, but he didn't think he should be a duke. He thought he was a fraud. He had killed his brother at 15 to get the title. Well, not to get the title. That was just the result. He killed him because Arch had begged him to. Arch was dying and he was in pain. Jon did it and resolved to live his life as Arch would have. It wasn't really him, but he had done it for all these years. He had also taken care of his sister, Elizabeth, and she was a beautiful as she was kind, and she loved him. Arabella Jennings was the daughter of an Oxford don. She was not allowed to be more because she was female. She did most of his research and wrote most of his lectures. She was there most of the time, including when the missive came telling him his brothers within weeks of one another and he was now the Earl of Barrington. Her mother was thrilled: she was to have the life she had always wanted. Sadly, she didn't see it to fruition.

Arabella was to have her season. She was a little old, but what of it? It was what her mother had wanted for her. She had had new clothes made up before leaving their country house but, even she could see they were not right: much too plain, not stylish at all. And the Ton was not kind to people who were different. It was that night Jon saw her and knew she was the one for him, despite the clothing. This was, in many ways, a love story to better most. Sadly, Jon decided he was not good enough. He was a murderer. So he told her it could never be. And them, he left town. She was destroyed. All of her friends, his friends, really were with her, even Elizabeth. He came home in a few weeks with a nephew in tow. He asked her to tutor him so he could sit for university exams in a year. Things slowly changed between them, but he was still a murderer. This is a lovely couple: Jon, a loyal and true man, and Arabella, intelligent, outgoing, forgiving. Their story is told in a gentle way with lots of twists and turns. I liked it.

I was invited to read a free e-ARC of Duke of Arrogance by Dragonblade, through Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are mine. #netgalley #dukeofarrogance
1,603 reviews12 followers
June 21, 2021
This is an OK historical romance, but I did have some issues with it.

First off, I was glad that the author changed her plot line for this book. The first 3 books in this series had basically the same plot line, with only small variations. At least this one was a little different.

For the most part, I liked both Arabella and Jon, but thought Jon's sudden transformation from a womanizing playboy was unrealistic. I also thought his sudden decision that Arabella would be perfect for his duchess was unlikely -- how could he know if she was perfect in just a few minutes time?

There were some minor editing errors, but none that really bothered me. The biggest one was that Arabella worked to manage her father's estate/home early in the book (and did a very good job) -- but then in the end of the book she has no experience running an estate/home?

I thought Jon's recovery from his terrible guilt (no spoilers, though) was a little too sudden. Yes, Arabella's love would help, but it wouldn't completely eliminate his guilt or give him the ability to completely forgive himself.

The story was mildly entertaining, so I will finish the series -- but I probably would not continue the series if it wasn't free with Kindle Unlimited. Because of the issues I noted above, it gets 3 stars from me.

My rating system is below.
1 star -- Hated it, or did not finish. I usually only give this rating if some of the content is truly objectionable to me, like if one of the main characters does something really awful, and gets away with it.
2 stars -- Didn't like it. This rating usually means that I thought the writing wasn't very good, the editing was terrible, I didn't like the characters, or it had other major flaws.
3 stars -- I liked it, but had some minor issues with it. This rating means that there were minor editing issues, the story needed more character development, it was just too unrealistic, or had some other fairly minor issue. The majority of books I read get this rating – I do not consider it a bad rating.
4 stars -- I liked it a lot. This is a high rating for me, and I rarely give a higher one.
5 stars -- I loved it, and will probably read it again. Very few books are good enough to get this rating from me. The ones that do are usually classics.
1,647 reviews15 followers
May 10, 2021
4.5 STARS

I’ve read all the books in the series and they are all stand alone. But, as usual with series, you have cross over character’s.

Story starts when the H is 16. He is a twin, born minutes after his brother the future Duke. Their father wants nothing to do with the H since he is the spare. The brothers love each other with the H always taking the blame for his brother. The way the scene’s unfold between the brother’s and their father is heart breaking. Then we jump years in the future and the h’s father is the fourth son so no title would ever be is. He teaches at the university and our h sits in on his classes.

The h/H meet and it is a very bumpy road to HEA. Romance builds slowly, which I liked. Our h’s father along with the h, are thrown into Society, without knowing all the rules or how to dress appropriately. As anyone who reads these stories, the Ton is unforgiving and so cruel. They tried to break our h’s spirit, but she is one tough cookie! My favorite interactions were with an old bed partner of the H’s and our h. I laughed out loud over the sharp dialogue the h threw at her several times.

There is lovemaking outside of marriage, heat level high, bedroom door pretty wide opened,

I loved the h from the start but the H was as the title states - very arrogant!! As the story unfolds you realize that isn’t who he is. Another heart tug when he explains why he acts as he does.

Something happens near the end of the story that was shocking how it played out. Having to do with a women, wow didn’t see that twist! I shouldn’t be surprised because this author’s stories are not cookie cutter’s so twists are the norm (in a good way). I did want to know if the H followed through what he intended to do with this women. I wanted to see if played out.

No cheating, no cliffhanger, HEA, romance, suspenseful ending, great epilogue a few years in the future and steam. I recommend this author and this series. (ljb).
Profile Image for Candy Briggs.
731 reviews14 followers
May 4, 2021
Archie and Jonathan Sutton were identical twins and Jon always took the punishment for them both. He loved his brother and couldn't stand to see him hurt. His father had nothing to do with Jon, he was a second son, and his sister well, She was a girl. Archie was the heir and eventually the duke. So his father took him everywhere when they were not in school. His father took him to a brothel. Two months before the end of school, Archie broke out in this horrible rash, blisters all over the place, and white spots in his mouth. He was sent home with great sped. At the end of school, he hurried home and his brother had been installed into the dowager house and was extremely ill.
Arabella Jennings was the daughter of an Oxford don. He had received bad news of his clergyman brother had died. He really didn't know his brothers they were more than a decade older than he. He was the fourth son and with the age difference, her father was not close to his brothers. She wasn't interested in the ton and love being her dad's assistant. She would sit in the back of his classes, attended small seminars, and writing his lectures, she had a full life. A solicitor came to their house and told her father his brothers had died and he was the new earl. He was flabbergasted.
I really enjoyed this story. I ended staying up all night reading and for us old folks that is not good. But the book was that good. The characters were amazing even the servants wanted to protect Jon and Arabella. They were good to almost everyone. She could not understand what was so hard to thank someone for giving her a towel or giving her pins for her hair. She was kind and gracious as was Jon. His friends seemed very helpful and the author did a wonderful job writing this great novel. It is for the over eighteen bunch. I recommend this highly.
I received this ARC from Net Galley and voluntarily reviewed it.
Profile Image for Jacqueline's Reads.
3,106 reviews1,529 followers
October 1, 2025
Duke of Arrogance is the fourth book in the Dukes of Distinction series. This is Arabella and Jon's story.

First off, don't be fooled by the cover, this book is NOT steamy at all. You get a kiss at the 50% and some touchy feely at the 80% mark. Which is fine, I just don't like the cover which is misleading. I was curious about Jon's story because he seems like the most sane one out of all of his friends. I was looking forward to a lower angst storyline.

Overall, the storyline is lower angst. Jon has a little dramatic past which is introduced into the beginning but overall, it doesn't really affect Jon, it just doesn't seem like it when I was reading. Arabella is a normal and sweet girl. Her family just game to into title so she has no idea on how to act around the ton and it's so adorable to read.

I really liked how Jon and Arabella met, at a random library and she thinks he is lying when he says he's a Duke because why would he give her the time and day. Honestly this read could have been a 5 star rating for me, but the author (in my opinion) pushed some sloppy angst at the 50% mark just for non added value tension and I was just kind of like... REALLY?! Once I got past that mark, I felt like the story rubbed me the wrong way.

Don't get me wrong, the book is good. I just felt like the writing was a little lack luster and could have been polished a bit more, at least in regard toward creating drama between the two leads. BUT this one has the least angst out of the books I read, so there's that.

I'll finish out the series, but I think I am ready to move on from the Dukes of Distinction.
Profile Image for Rachel.
1,017 reviews17 followers
May 6, 2021
*I received a free ARC from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review*

Duke of Arrogance is another great installment in the Dukes of Distinction series! I really enjoyed the first three books, but this one may be my favorite. Arabella is such a breath of fresh air as a historical romance heroine. Unlike the women in the previous books (who are all strong and intelligent women themselves) Arabella doesn't have a tragic story prior to meeting Jon. The death of her mother may be brushed over a little too quickly, but after the losses experience by Sam, Phoebe, and Elise it was nice to have a heroine not weighed down by her past. I also loved her quick wit - I almost cheered out loud when she stood up for herself (and Jon) with Lady Walton. All of the heroes in the previous books had something in their past that helped shaped who they were at the beginning of their stories, but Jon's is definitely the saddest. When it was revealed the real reason he doesn't think he is good enough for Arabella is that he doesn't love himself my heart broke a little for him. His relationship with his sister and cousin are really sweet. I appreciated that his lapse in judgment over Arabella didn't last long (and that she didn't go out of her way to make things too easy for him in winning her back) and that the situation with Lady Walton was quickly resolved rather than being drawn out for too long. I can't wait for the final book in the series (and am hoping it involves Elizabeth)!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Lana Birky.
1,705 reviews22 followers
June 14, 2021
Jonathan Sutton, the Duke of Blackmore is handsome rake, who is rich, brooding, rude & arrogant - earning him the Ton's nickname of the Duke of Arrogance. He was raised as the spare heir & was basically ignored by his father as his older twin by seven minutes was the future duke. However, when he was sixteen, his brother & his father both died on the same day & left Jon as the new duke & responsible for raising his six-year-old sister - their mother had died giving birth to her. Now, at almost thirty years old, he must think of marriage & an heir but there will be no love - he has built walls & the guilt he feels will never knock those walls down.

Arabella Jennings' father was an Oxford don, fourth son & just recently become the Earl of Barrington. The family made their way to London & soon after Arabella's mother became ill & died. Although Arabella was well educated, lovely & very forthwith but neither her nor her father knew anything about polite society. When she accidently meets & has a conversation with a man in the library, there is some electricity between them & upon leaving they introduce themselves & he tells her he is the Duke of Blackmore & she thinks he is teasing.

I have read the first three in the series and loved them all, but I will say that this one had me in tears several times, but the happy times made it all worth the tough times. I highly recommend this book & the entire series - you will fall in love with all the characters - main & secondary!!
Profile Image for Janet.
5,195 reviews66 followers
May 3, 2021
Life radically changes for Arabella Jennings, the daughter of an Oxford don, when her father becomes the Earl of Barrington. She’s an intellectual who would rather be discussing Shakespeare’s works but now finds herself navigating the vicious waters of Polite Society. Jonathan Sutton never expected to become the Duke after all he’s the spare born seven minutes after the heir. Then his brother Arch dies closely followed by his father, making him the new Duke of Blackmore. Pledging to live for both himself and Arch, Jon becomes one of London’s leading rakes, breaking rules and bedding women as his brother would have done had he lived. Jon meets Arabella the first night of the Season in the library where they discuss Shakespeare and he decides this woman, so different from every conquest he’s made, might help him from the abyss he’s sunk into.
This is the fourth book in this engrossing series. I'm loving the series & have found all four books very hard to put down. I started & ended this book by crying but in between laughed & thoroughly enjoyed the verbal banter. I loved both of them, he’s riddled with guilt living his life for Arch, she's the feisty intelligent woman together they complement each other perfectly. Their chemistry sizzles. We also catch up with characters from previous books, which I also love. I also really liked Elizabeth & Arthur – I’d love for them to have their HEAs
My honest review is for a special copy I voluntarily read
Profile Image for Sandra Standefer.
417 reviews6 followers
May 7, 2021
At 16 Jon Sutton’s life changed forever when his twin brother suddenly dies leaving Jon as the new Duke of Blackmore. Guilt and trying to keep his brothers memory alive Jon has become what he thought his brother would have been. Earning his moniker as the Duke of Arrogance until he meets the one woman that makes him want to be better.

Arabella Jennings has been raised in a modest home with freedoms that most women would never experience. Her father is the second son of an Earl and is employed as an Oxford don. When his brother the Earl unexpectedly dies they are both thrown into a world that neither knows anything about. During her first ball Arabella is scorned by the ton until she meets Jon Sutton, the Duke of Blackmore. When he unexpectedly asked her to dance the supper dance and be her partner for dinner, Arabella suddenly becomes someone everyone wants to meet.

As he season progresses, Arabella becomes a very sought after woman and the more time they spend together the more Jon makes it known that she belongs to him. As Arabella and Jon fall for each other Jon starts to pull away, he has secrets and is afraid that he doesn’t deserve someone like Arabella.

This was such an enjoyable story to read. I have read other books in the Dukes of Distinction and enjoyed reading them all, this one was one of my favorites! It was so well written that I could picture it all. Just loved this one! Definitely recommend reading this book!
Profile Image for Bridget Love to read Lewis.
2,473 reviews28 followers
May 8, 2021
Who are you, really?

Jonathan is a twin. He has lived for years with guilt and remorse pretending to be the rake and womanizer his brother would have been had he lived!? Arabella is intelligent beautiful and fits no mold! As a daughter to a professor she is more comfortable with men then woman! Arabella is a natural teacher and student she is over the spiteful nasty Ton when taken to London to fulfill her Mother's last request! Arabella mom so loved the gowns, glittering London ball rooms so much than Arabella ever would!! Arabella experienced a great deal of success but will she pick from the pack?
Arabella reminds me of almost a reverse Cinderella. She is snubbed for how she is dressed and her forward manners, introducing herself to strangers! When Jon introduced himself it’s hilarious as she does not believe him! Arabella beauty is obvious to all both inside and out! Jon was immediate in his attraction to her!
So glad when Jonathan laid down his secrets and wept openly with Arabella! He never grieved properly and left the painful past behind! Arabella didn't judge the known rake for his past she wanted him to behave consistently and acknowledge the future!! Their shared future full of possibility if Jon would let go and let love! Does love win or does Jon keep pushing away the one woman that is good for him and knows there's love inside Jon if only we would let Arabella pull out!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 106 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.