4 stars
A thoughtful & touching story of family, survival, trust, & secrets. It’s more literary fiction than a mystery, although there are secrets & unanswered questions that lend suspense. I liked the characters, & especially the setting.
[What I liked:]
•The Allied Occupation of Japan (1945-1952) is a fascinating time period—occupying forces on high alert for any communist/socialist activity, massive political shifts, civilians struggling with tragedy & trauma in the aftermath of the war, & rapid cultural & social & economic changes (often imposed by the occupiers & often motivated by racism). It’s an era I’ve personally invested time in researching, and this book delivers: evocative of place, societal tensions, and the war-torn landscape of 1951 Japan, just months away from Japan’s regaining of national sovereignty.
•I really liked Elly. She’s so relatable & admirable, but not at all perfect. Fergus, Vida, & Ted I liked as well—each is very interesting & I wanted to know them better.
•The domestic/relational tensions are skillfully woven together with the larger external threats facing Elly & those connected to her. The thrills aren’t there just for excitement’s sake, the secrets touch her deepest fears & longings.
•This book is well researched & the writer has an academic background in Japanese history. I really appreciated the bibliography she shared, as well as her notes on the historical events & figures that inspired this novel.
[What I didn’t like as much:]
•Getting Spero’s birth registered with no proof seemed a bit far-fetched...although I know things weren’t quite as well documented back then. Still, since it was pointed out that Elly had difficulty getting her own British passport as an adult, you’d think there would have been similar roadblocks in getting one for Spero.
•The infidelity bit is kind of glossed over at the end. It’s not really resolved between the involved parties, so it felt a little like things were brushed under the rug to give a happy ending by the end of the book.
•Kamiya’s character is hard for me to sum up my feelings for. On one hand he does have emotional depth, & I liked his backstory & seeing how he processed his thoughts & feelings about his adventures during the story. On the other, I never really got a sense of what he was living for. Of course he was young & perhaps still only in survival mode, but I think I would’ve connected to him better if I knew what he wanted out of life & what his dreams were.
CW: murder, torture, infidelity, miscarriage
[I received an ARC ebook copy from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review. Thank you for the book!]