What do you think?
Rate this book
Magic in Manhattan #3
Wonderstruck
Don’t miss the stunning conclusion to Allie Therin’s Magic in Manhattan series!
New York, 1925
Arthur Kenzie is on a mission: to destroy the powerful supernatural relic that threatens Manhattan—and all the nonmagical minds in the world. So far his search has been fruitless. All it has done is keep him from the man he loves. But he’ll do anything to keep Rory safe and free, even if that means leaving him behind.
Psychometric Rory Brodigan knows his uncontrolled magic is a liability, but he’s determined to gain power over it. He can take care of himself—and maybe even Arthur, too, if Arthur will let him. An auction at the Paris world’s fair offers the perfect opportunity to destroy the relic, if a group of power-hungry supernaturals don’t destroy Rory and Arthur first.
As the magical world converges on Paris, Arthur and Rory have to decide who they can trust. Guessing wrong could spell destruction for their bond—and for the world as they know it.
Magic in Manhattan
Book 1: Spellbound
Book 2: Starcrossed
Book 3: Wonderstruck
New York, 1925
Arthur Kenzie is on a mission: to destroy the powerful supernatural relic that threatens Manhattan—and all the nonmagical minds in the world. So far his search has been fruitless. All it has done is keep him from the man he loves. But he’ll do anything to keep Rory safe and free, even if that means leaving him behind.
Psychometric Rory Brodigan knows his uncontrolled magic is a liability, but he’s determined to gain power over it. He can take care of himself—and maybe even Arthur, too, if Arthur will let him. An auction at the Paris world’s fair offers the perfect opportunity to destroy the relic, if a group of power-hungry supernaturals don’t destroy Rory and Arthur first.
As the magical world converges on Paris, Arthur and Rory have to decide who they can trust. Guessing wrong could spell destruction for their bond—and for the world as they know it.
Magic in Manhattan
Book 1: Spellbound
Book 2: Starcrossed
Book 3: Wonderstruck
10 pages, Audible Audio
First published February 9, 2021
79 people are currently reading
1019 people want to read
About the author
Allie Therin
12 books886 followersAllie Therin is a bicultural author of award-winning romance and urban fantasy. She also is, or has been, a bookseller, an attorney, a Parks & Rec assistant, a boom operator, and a barista for one (embarrassing) day.
A longtime fan of romance, mystery and speculative fiction, she now strives to bring that same delight to her readers. Allie grew up in a tiny Pacific Northwest town with more bears than people, although the bears sadly would not practice Spanish with her.
A longtime fan of romance, mystery and speculative fiction, she now strives to bring that same delight to her readers. Allie grew up in a tiny Pacific Northwest town with more bears than people, although the bears sadly would not practice Spanish with her.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 311 reviews
July 17, 2025
This just remained solidly enjoyable audiobook listen from start to finish and i had a great time escaping into this cozy historical fantasy world with Rory and Arthur that was filled with magic, adventure and romance.
Each instalment of this series really built on the work of the one before, with the characters, plot and world building gaining more depth and life to them, the more time we spent in these books.
Unfortunately, it never quite came together to reach that final special something to make it a truly 5 star read to me but it was definitely a solid 4.5 stars. My (very slight) grievances remained the same throughout the whole three books in that I thought the overarching plot about the relics could have been stronger, but I did think it came to a fairly satisfying conclusion.
Throughout all three books Rory and Arthur remained my favourite part as they were just adorable together. They did start to skirt a little close to a tiresome miscommunication dynamic here but it didn’t drag enough to really get under my skin. Book one was definitely the most explicit of the three books, with the following two books being much more closed door. I wouldn’t have minded seeing some more of the physical intimacy between these two when the emotional intimacy was so charming, but it was in no way essential.
I think that Rory really got the better end of the deal for character development and I think that Arthur had a bit of his potential character complexity missed and the opportunity to explore his potential shell shock and experience during the war was lost to his utility of being rich and handsome. We are reminded time and again about how this 6”4 man is an ex-soldier and able to look after himself, but we never really get to see that, and selfishly I would have enjoyed seeing more of that lol.
I appreciate that during the 20s it was very much a ‘real men don’t have emotions and cry’ sort of attitude, but with the culmination of the emotional climax of this book got so close to the point of crying, but we never actually tipped over that point of a good few tears. As a result I feel like I have a bit of the emotional equivalent of a missed sneeze. I just needed A LITTLE more emotional catharsis and I am sad I didn’t get it.
These audiobooks were absolutely a great way to spend some 30ish hours and I’ll be continuing the spin off series (eventually).
Each instalment of this series really built on the work of the one before, with the characters, plot and world building gaining more depth and life to them, the more time we spent in these books.
Unfortunately, it never quite came together to reach that final special something to make it a truly 5 star read to me but it was definitely a solid 4.5 stars. My (very slight) grievances remained the same throughout the whole three books in that I thought the overarching plot about the relics could have been stronger, but I did think it came to a fairly satisfying conclusion.
Throughout all three books Rory and Arthur remained my favourite part as they were just adorable together. They did start to skirt a little close to a tiresome miscommunication dynamic here but it didn’t drag enough to really get under my skin. Book one was definitely the most explicit of the three books, with the following two books being much more closed door. I wouldn’t have minded seeing some more of the physical intimacy between these two when the emotional intimacy was so charming, but it was in no way essential.
I think that Rory really got the better end of the deal for character development and I think that Arthur had a bit of his potential character complexity missed and the opportunity to explore his potential shell shock and experience during the war was lost to his utility of being rich and handsome. We are reminded time and again about how this 6”4 man is an ex-soldier and able to look after himself, but we never really get to see that, and selfishly I would have enjoyed seeing more of that lol.
I appreciate that during the 20s it was very much a ‘real men don’t have emotions and cry’ sort of attitude, but with the culmination of the emotional climax of this book got so close to the point of crying, but we never actually tipped over that point of a good few tears. As a result I feel like I have a bit of the emotional equivalent of a missed sneeze. I just needed A LITTLE more emotional catharsis and I am sad I didn’t get it.
These audiobooks were absolutely a great way to spend some 30ish hours and I’ll be continuing the spin off series (eventually).
May 11, 2021
The series finished the same way it started, in a mix of good and bad.
I see improvements and I don’t regret sticking with it until the end, but those improvements are inconsistent at best and I didn’t get all the answers I needed.
The relationship started really promising in this book, there was a conversation at the beginning that had me hoping Arthur and Rory had finally learned to open up to each other in a real way, not just by declaring their mutual love for each other, but also by sharing their doubts and fears and working together to find a compromise that worked for both of them, a middle ground for all their differences. I should’ve known it was too good to be true, after all it took for them to even have that conversation, but and that’s when most of the real progress was made, so I had good reasons to be hopeful.
I don’t want to say it was all for nothing, but when it came time to show how far they had gone and how much they had changed, it turned up to be… halfway there, I’d say. The good intentions were there, I just never got to see them in action because it didn’t suit the dramatic effect, I suppose.
Not that it was all bad. There were some cute moments between Arthur and Rory——and I also liked that
The storyline involving Gwen and Ellis left me with conflicting feelings. I liked that it wasn’t all so clear-cut and the took me by surprise, but the effect was a little tempered by the
I’m usually fine with that kind of questions remaining unanswered if I’m sure that the characters have learned how to be a couple, because I can trust that they’ll work out the details eventually. I’m not so sure that’s the case here, though.
I think I’ve read somewhere that there are plans for a spin-off——and there might be some answers there, but I’m not that eager to find out.
I see improvements and I don’t regret sticking with it until the end, but those improvements are inconsistent at best and I didn’t get all the answers I needed.
The relationship started really promising in this book, there was a conversation at the beginning that had me hoping Arthur and Rory had finally learned to open up to each other in a real way, not just by declaring their mutual love for each other, but also by sharing their doubts and fears and working together to find a compromise that worked for both of them, a middle ground for all their differences. I should’ve known it was too good to be true, after all it took for them to even have that conversation, but and that’s when most of the real progress was made, so I had good reasons to be hopeful.
I don’t want to say it was all for nothing, but when it came time to show how far they had gone and how much they had changed, it turned up to be… halfway there, I’d say. The good intentions were there, I just never got to see them in action because it didn’t suit the dramatic effect, I suppose.
Not that it was all bad. There were some cute moments between Arthur and Rory——and I also liked that
The storyline involving Gwen and Ellis left me with conflicting feelings. I liked that it wasn’t all so clear-cut and the took me by surprise, but the effect was a little tempered by the
I’m usually fine with that kind of questions remaining unanswered if I’m sure that the characters have learned how to be a couple, because I can trust that they’ll work out the details eventually. I’m not so sure that’s the case here, though.
I think I’ve read somewhere that there are plans for a spin-off——and there might be some answers there, but I’m not that eager to find out.
June 28, 2025
What an enjoyable time this was! I was so thoroughly invested and COULD NOT STOP LISTENING! This series definitely grew on me. I feel like the author really found her stride over the 3 books. Initially I wasn’t sold on the narrator but he developed distinct voices for everyone so by this final book it was very easy listening.
I loved Arthur’s progression throughout the series. And Rory too. Great cast of side characters. The plot in this one has been my favourite of the three (it is one continuous plot, they do need to be read in order). Satisfying resolution. A few loose ends hanging about so I’m keen to get into the spin off series with Wesley and Sebastian and read more in this world.
The whole trilogy is fade to black but I didn’t miss the smut.
I loved Arthur’s progression throughout the series. And Rory too. Great cast of side characters. The plot in this one has been my favourite of the three (it is one continuous plot, they do need to be read in order). Satisfying resolution. A few loose ends hanging about so I’m keen to get into the spin off series with Wesley and Sebastian and read more in this world.
The whole trilogy is fade to black but I didn’t miss the smut.
October 11, 2021
***4.5 Stars***
... and with that I officially declare myself befairied...
The spin-off can't come soon enough! Loved it!!!
... and with that I officially declare myself befairied...
The spin-off can't come soon enough! Loved it!!!
December 20, 2020
A stunning conclusion to what has been an outstanding paranormal historical romance series.
The pacing in this book is exceptional, taking the reader as it does on a tension-edged journey not only in America, but across the Atlantic to London and Paris.
The enemies are ever more threatening, and the powers they wield put all of our band of happy adventurers at risk.
Arthur and Rory are still dealing with the disparity of their social classes as well as the laws of the day, while the Baron's henchmen seem to be surrounding the paranormals' search to destroy the mind control relic.
As with the previous two books, there is zero on page steam outside of a couple of kisses and fade to black inferences of what they're doing behind closed doors.
And it still disappoints me a little, especially given the additional magical connection which is now binding the two men together.
We again get told of their passion and willingness to put their lives at risk for the other, and we see them do that when it comes to physical danger, but we don't see it when it applies to their physical intimacy.
I still think this concluding narrative pulls together all the loose ends with skill but I think it could have been even more powerfully emotional if we'd seen what they have to lose expressed on page.
But I have zero qualms about the plotting, it's a very clever and totally satisfying build up to the final battle.
The threats feel absolutely real, I wasn't at all sure how they were going to pull themselves out of the predicament they end up in.
And I would never have guessed at the solution, although it is sneakily hinted at in the plotting earlier when I look back with hindsight, very cleverly executed.
A bit of a bittersweet experience, as I say goodbye to these wonderful characters and the world Allie has created, but also a firm knowledge that I look forward very much to seeing what comes next!
#ARC kindly received from the author in return for an honest and unbiased review.
The pacing in this book is exceptional, taking the reader as it does on a tension-edged journey not only in America, but across the Atlantic to London and Paris.
The enemies are ever more threatening, and the powers they wield put all of our band of happy adventurers at risk.
Arthur and Rory are still dealing with the disparity of their social classes as well as the laws of the day, while the Baron's henchmen seem to be surrounding the paranormals' search to destroy the mind control relic.
As with the previous two books, there is zero on page steam outside of a couple of kisses and fade to black inferences of what they're doing behind closed doors.
And it still disappoints me a little, especially given the additional magical connection which is now binding the two men together.
We again get told of their passion and willingness to put their lives at risk for the other, and we see them do that when it comes to physical danger, but we don't see it when it applies to their physical intimacy.
I still think this concluding narrative pulls together all the loose ends with skill but I think it could have been even more powerfully emotional if we'd seen what they have to lose expressed on page.
But I have zero qualms about the plotting, it's a very clever and totally satisfying build up to the final battle.
The threats feel absolutely real, I wasn't at all sure how they were going to pull themselves out of the predicament they end up in.
And I would never have guessed at the solution, although it is sneakily hinted at in the plotting earlier when I look back with hindsight, very cleverly executed.
A bit of a bittersweet experience, as I say goodbye to these wonderful characters and the world Allie has created, but also a firm knowledge that I look forward very much to seeing what comes next!
#ARC kindly received from the author in return for an honest and unbiased review.
March 5, 2021
I've given this a B+ at AAR, 4.5 stars
Wonderstruck is the third book in Allie Therin’s Magic in Manhattan series of paranormal romances set in 1920s New York, and is the best of the bunch, boasting a high-stakes, fast-paced plot, engaging characters, strong worldbuilding and a central relationship that has come on leaps and bounds since the first book.
When I reviewed the previous book (Starcrossed), I said I wish I’d thought to re-read Spellbound(book one) first, as there is very little recapping and I was at a bit of a loss to start with. Wanting to avoid the same again, I listened to the audio version of Starcrossed shortly before beginning Wonderstruck and I’m pleased I did, because I had no problems getting into the story this time around. (Which is to say that I’d advise anyone interested in reading Wonderstruck to do a bit of backtracking first!). As this is a series with overarching plot-threads, there will be spoilers for the other books in this review.
When Wonderstruck opens, we find Arthur Kenzie in Montreal with his close friends, paranormals Jade, a telekenetic and Zhang, who can walk on the astral plane. They’re there searching for a way to destroy a dangerous supernatural artefact, a pomander created using the most vile magic in existence and which has the ability to enslave non-magical minds. Arthur has been away from New York – and from his lover, powerful psychometric Rory Brodigan – for a month and is no closer to his objective than when he started – and the lack of progress and time away from the man he loves is really trying his patience. He knows it’s best for Rory that he stays put in New York, but he misses him dreadfully.
The news that there is to be a secret paranormal exhibit at the upcoming world’s fair in Paris offers some hope, however. Such an exhibit might well draw the attention of someone with the knowledge to help them destroy the pomander – but a trip to Paris will mean more weeks, maybe months away from New York, and bringing Rory to Europe just isn’t an option. Baron Zeppler, the telepath who is bent on harnessing the power of magical relics for his own nefarious purposes, is now undoubtedly aware of Rory’s existence and of the power he can wield through the Tempest Ring and his psychometry – and Arthur is determined to keep Rory as far from his evil machinations as possible.
But of course, the best laid plans never pan out. Arthur, Jade and Zhang return to New York so that Arthur can be with Rory on his twenty-first birthday, and after another failed attempt to destroy the pomander, they realise they’re going to need help. None of them likes the idea of approaching Gwen and Ellis – the former wartime best friends of Jade and Arthur who betrayed them in Spellbound; but after Gwen saved Rory’s life in Starcrossed, they’ve realised they have a common aim in wanting to neutralise the pomander and put Baron Zeppler out of commission. Working on the principle that ‘the enemy of my enemy is my friend’ (sort of), and realising that it’s no longer safe to leave Rory in New York, the four of them – Arthur, Rory, Jade and Zhang – sail across the Atlantic and head for London.
What follows is a tense and exciting romp that kept me reading until well past my bedtime! With Arthur hiding a terrible secret of his own, and the line between friend and enemy becoming blurred, the story moves at full pelt into the nail-biting finale, wherein our heroes are forced to battle the vilest magic of all.
Amid the thrills and spills, Arthur and Rory find time for a few tender moments, and I have to say that Ms. Therin has at last managed to convince me of their genuine attachment and absolute devotion to one another. Previously, I found it difficult to see what a wealthy sophisticate like Arthur could see in the prickly, much younger Rory (the age gap is about eight years) who, when they first met, behaved like a complete brat towards him. Here, however, I finally bought their connection, and even though their relationship is still beset with problems of communication and trust, they feel really solid as a couple. As in the previous books, the author doesn’t sweep aside the difficulties faced by two men attempting a romantic relationship in the 1920s, difficulties which are compounded by their vast difference in social status. One of the major sticking points between them has always been Rory’s refusal to accept Arthur’s help or to rely on him in any way. By now, Arthur is finding it a bit wearing, his heart heavy because he feels that Rory’s reluctance to lean on him is because Rory has always got one foot halfway out the door. Here at last, Rory starts to realise how his attitude is hurting the man he loves; he admitted in the last book that he would want to help Arthur were their situations reversed, but he still wasn’t able to make any concessions. Now though, he’s grown up enough to realise it’s not weak to ask for and accept help, and I was impressed with the amount of character growth Rory exhibits in this book.
The author’s research into Prohibition Era New York is excellent, enabling her to skilfully weave the threads of her own magical world into the historical background, putting the reader squarely at a table in Jade’s speakeasy or inside Rory’s dingy room at his rat-infested boarding house. I noted – with a smile – that she chose an International ship for the gang to travel across the Atlantic so there would be booze available!
On the downside, I did find some of the information about the relics a bit confusing, and while Zeppler is definitely eeeevil, I was never completely clear as to why he wanted to amass All the Relics and All the Magic. World domination, I suppose, but that’s rather unoriginal! There were a few places it seemed there was just too much going on and too many characters on page – although I admit that might be more a ‘me’ problem than a ‘book’ problem – and a couple of plot points appeared and then disappeared, never to be seen again.
But I enjoyed Wonderstruck despite those quibbles, and was completely caught up in the story. A compelling combination of vivid historical setting, memorable characters, fascinating magic and a heartfelt romance, It’s a fine way to end this unique series.
Wonderstruck is the third book in Allie Therin’s Magic in Manhattan series of paranormal romances set in 1920s New York, and is the best of the bunch, boasting a high-stakes, fast-paced plot, engaging characters, strong worldbuilding and a central relationship that has come on leaps and bounds since the first book.
When I reviewed the previous book (Starcrossed), I said I wish I’d thought to re-read Spellbound(book one) first, as there is very little recapping and I was at a bit of a loss to start with. Wanting to avoid the same again, I listened to the audio version of Starcrossed shortly before beginning Wonderstruck and I’m pleased I did, because I had no problems getting into the story this time around. (Which is to say that I’d advise anyone interested in reading Wonderstruck to do a bit of backtracking first!). As this is a series with overarching plot-threads, there will be spoilers for the other books in this review.
When Wonderstruck opens, we find Arthur Kenzie in Montreal with his close friends, paranormals Jade, a telekenetic and Zhang, who can walk on the astral plane. They’re there searching for a way to destroy a dangerous supernatural artefact, a pomander created using the most vile magic in existence and which has the ability to enslave non-magical minds. Arthur has been away from New York – and from his lover, powerful psychometric Rory Brodigan – for a month and is no closer to his objective than when he started – and the lack of progress and time away from the man he loves is really trying his patience. He knows it’s best for Rory that he stays put in New York, but he misses him dreadfully.
The news that there is to be a secret paranormal exhibit at the upcoming world’s fair in Paris offers some hope, however. Such an exhibit might well draw the attention of someone with the knowledge to help them destroy the pomander – but a trip to Paris will mean more weeks, maybe months away from New York, and bringing Rory to Europe just isn’t an option. Baron Zeppler, the telepath who is bent on harnessing the power of magical relics for his own nefarious purposes, is now undoubtedly aware of Rory’s existence and of the power he can wield through the Tempest Ring and his psychometry – and Arthur is determined to keep Rory as far from his evil machinations as possible.
But of course, the best laid plans never pan out. Arthur, Jade and Zhang return to New York so that Arthur can be with Rory on his twenty-first birthday, and after another failed attempt to destroy the pomander, they realise they’re going to need help. None of them likes the idea of approaching Gwen and Ellis – the former wartime best friends of Jade and Arthur who betrayed them in Spellbound; but after Gwen saved Rory’s life in Starcrossed, they’ve realised they have a common aim in wanting to neutralise the pomander and put Baron Zeppler out of commission. Working on the principle that ‘the enemy of my enemy is my friend’ (sort of), and realising that it’s no longer safe to leave Rory in New York, the four of them – Arthur, Rory, Jade and Zhang – sail across the Atlantic and head for London.
What follows is a tense and exciting romp that kept me reading until well past my bedtime! With Arthur hiding a terrible secret of his own, and the line between friend and enemy becoming blurred, the story moves at full pelt into the nail-biting finale, wherein our heroes are forced to battle the vilest magic of all.
Amid the thrills and spills, Arthur and Rory find time for a few tender moments, and I have to say that Ms. Therin has at last managed to convince me of their genuine attachment and absolute devotion to one another. Previously, I found it difficult to see what a wealthy sophisticate like Arthur could see in the prickly, much younger Rory (the age gap is about eight years) who, when they first met, behaved like a complete brat towards him. Here, however, I finally bought their connection, and even though their relationship is still beset with problems of communication and trust, they feel really solid as a couple. As in the previous books, the author doesn’t sweep aside the difficulties faced by two men attempting a romantic relationship in the 1920s, difficulties which are compounded by their vast difference in social status. One of the major sticking points between them has always been Rory’s refusal to accept Arthur’s help or to rely on him in any way. By now, Arthur is finding it a bit wearing, his heart heavy because he feels that Rory’s reluctance to lean on him is because Rory has always got one foot halfway out the door. Here at last, Rory starts to realise how his attitude is hurting the man he loves; he admitted in the last book that he would want to help Arthur were their situations reversed, but he still wasn’t able to make any concessions. Now though, he’s grown up enough to realise it’s not weak to ask for and accept help, and I was impressed with the amount of character growth Rory exhibits in this book.
The author’s research into Prohibition Era New York is excellent, enabling her to skilfully weave the threads of her own magical world into the historical background, putting the reader squarely at a table in Jade’s speakeasy or inside Rory’s dingy room at his rat-infested boarding house. I noted – with a smile – that she chose an International ship for the gang to travel across the Atlantic so there would be booze available!
On the downside, I did find some of the information about the relics a bit confusing, and while Zeppler is definitely eeeevil, I was never completely clear as to why he wanted to amass All the Relics and All the Magic. World domination, I suppose, but that’s rather unoriginal! There were a few places it seemed there was just too much going on and too many characters on page – although I admit that might be more a ‘me’ problem than a ‘book’ problem – and a couple of plot points appeared and then disappeared, never to be seen again.
But I enjoyed Wonderstruck despite those quibbles, and was completely caught up in the story. A compelling combination of vivid historical setting, memorable characters, fascinating magic and a heartfelt romance, It’s a fine way to end this unique series.
September 4, 2022
I am so not ready to say goodbye to Ace and Rory. I absolutely adored these two together and their magical adventures to save the world.
Historical Romance is usually a no go for me, but this trilogy sucked me in from book 1. The setting starts off in NYC in 1925 during prohibition. The description and language had me even more intrigued.
I highly recommend this trilogy and there is also a standalone spinoff that I am going to jump into soon.
Historical Romance is usually a no go for me, but this trilogy sucked me in from book 1. The setting starts off in NYC in 1925 during prohibition. The description and language had me even more intrigued.
I highly recommend this trilogy and there is also a standalone spinoff that I am going to jump into soon.
June 25, 2025
10/10 no notes, the perfect ending for Teddy and Ace.
I absolutely adored this series, from start to finish, I couldn't have asked for more. The world-building is intricate enough that it makes you want to know more, but at the same time easy to follow. The complete set of characters from MCs to secondary characters was so fun, the found-family aspects were really cozy and the romance was lovely.
This book starts right after the last one ends, with Ace, Jade, and Zhang trying to find a way to destroy the evil relic but ultimately not succeeding. After some developments and interventions by Baron Zegler, Rory, Arthur, Jade, and Zhang go to London to find Gwen and Ellis and see if they can reach an agreement. After the ending of the last book, they might be onto something.
Lord Fine aka Wesley got himself redeemed at leats for me in this book, he comes across as prickly and rude but I am 100% sure he has a tragic backstory and probably abandoment issues, he acts as a proper friend giving Ace the wake up call he needs and I for one can't wait to read his series Proper Scoundrels I just hope he gets his HEA.
Some twists and turns had me on the edge of my seat, and I could not believe what was happening. The last 20% was so anxiety-inducing that I was going crazy to finish it.
I liked a lot how this book ended, I know that it was a bit open and lacking details, but I still think the Love declaration at the end was all this book needed.
I absolutely adored this series, from start to finish, I couldn't have asked for more. The world-building is intricate enough that it makes you want to know more, but at the same time easy to follow. The complete set of characters from MCs to secondary characters was so fun, the found-family aspects were really cozy and the romance was lovely.
This book starts right after the last one ends, with Ace, Jade, and Zhang trying to find a way to destroy the evil relic but ultimately not succeeding. After some developments and interventions by Baron Zegler, Rory, Arthur, Jade, and Zhang go to London to find Gwen and Ellis and see if they can reach an agreement. After the ending of the last book, they might be onto something.
Lord Fine aka Wesley got himself redeemed at leats for me in this book, he comes across as prickly and rude but I am 100% sure he has a tragic backstory and probably abandoment issues, he acts as a proper friend giving Ace the wake up call he needs and I for one can't wait to read his series Proper Scoundrels I just hope he gets his HEA.
Some twists and turns had me on the edge of my seat, and I could not believe what was happening. The last 20% was so anxiety-inducing that I was going crazy to finish it.
I liked a lot how this book ended, I know that it was a bit open and lacking details, but I still think the Love declaration at the end was all this book needed.
March 6, 2021
I've truly enjoyed the ending of Allie Therin's Magic in Manhattan's series.
The end of the adventures of Rory, Ace and their gang of paranormal friends delivers a lot of fun and tension in a final novel that is fast-paced and very well written.
Despite staying true to their deep-seated characteristics - Arthur's overprotectiveness, Rory's grumpy attitude etc. - the characters follow a nice narrative arch that closes on a lovely but not sappy conclusion that sees Rory on the cusp of reconnecting with his Italian roots.
The magic plotline doesn't suffer from the move from NYC to Europe and it's nice to see Rory, Ace, Jiawei and Jade move in a different environment. Things get complicated between blood magic, torn auras, dangerous relics and seedy paranormals and the last few chapters were a real page-turner.
I also liked the ambiguous presence of Gwen and Ellis - friends or foe? - and the way Wesley and Sebastian are re-inserted in the story with so much potential they would deserve a spin-off of their own.
There are some things I've always loved in this series - the sense of location and time, the attention to historical details and the avoidance of obvious and more-followed paths and of course, its two lovely main MCs - and I've found all of them in Wonderstruck.
A worthy and very nice conclusion to a series that I truly loved.
The end of the adventures of Rory, Ace and their gang of paranormal friends delivers a lot of fun and tension in a final novel that is fast-paced and very well written.
Despite staying true to their deep-seated characteristics - Arthur's overprotectiveness, Rory's grumpy attitude etc. - the characters follow a nice narrative arch that closes on a lovely but not sappy conclusion that sees Rory on the cusp of reconnecting with his Italian roots.
The magic plotline doesn't suffer from the move from NYC to Europe and it's nice to see Rory, Ace, Jiawei and Jade move in a different environment. Things get complicated between blood magic, torn auras, dangerous relics and seedy paranormals and the last few chapters were a real page-turner.
I also liked the ambiguous presence of Gwen and Ellis - friends or foe? - and the way Wesley and Sebastian are re-inserted in the story with so much potential they would deserve a spin-off of their own.
There are some things I've always loved in this series - the sense of location and time, the attention to historical details and the avoidance of obvious and more-followed paths and of course, its two lovely main MCs - and I've found all of them in Wonderstruck.
A worthy and very nice conclusion to a series that I truly loved.
February 17, 2021
I had more or less the same reaction to this one than the other two in the series, it wasn't bad, but I had problems with many aspects of the plot and characterization. I liked the idea behind this a lot, and this was enjoyable, but... there's a lot of things left to chance, and sometimes things seems to happen only to move the plot along, not because they have to.
There's some things unexplained at the end, things related to the magic system that I had to come with an explanation talking with my fellow BR, and we get to meet a lot of characters that come a bit "out of the blue" and that swiftly dissappear when their part in the plot is finished and we never know anything else about them ever. Also, he "very bad guy", after three books of being evil incarnate, didn't exactly deliver in the end, it was too easy a resolution.
Still, I had a good time and BReading with Ele is always a pleasure.
There's some things unexplained at the end, things related to the magic system that I had to come with an explanation talking with my fellow BR, and we get to meet a lot of characters that come a bit "out of the blue" and that swiftly dissappear when their part in the plot is finished and we never know anything else about them ever. Also, he "very bad guy", after three books of being evil incarnate, didn't exactly deliver in the end, it was too easy a resolution.
Still, I had a good time and BReading with Ele is always a pleasure.
January 27, 2021
4 Stars
Review:
*I received an ecopy of this book from the publisher. This has not influenced my review.*
Once again, Rory and Arthur were just darn adorable! They are SUCH a cute couple, and their light-hearted banter, smoldering attraction, and deepening feelings are the highlight of this series.
This book also really focused on the adorable found family element in the series. With his mother dead and his father just awful, Rory felt mostly alone in life and didn't trust easily. But he wasn't alone, and his new lover and friends were determined to show him that.
Since this book was the last in the trilogy, it wrapped up the plot about Zeppler, the paranormal relics, and the romance in a happy, satisfying way. I felt like there were some background elements that were brought up or seemed hinted at but then were never brought up again, but nothing big. There were also some interesting uses of magic and paranormal abilities, plus some surprising little twists here and there.
The Prohibition Era setting was great again, but this time the characters traveled to Europe for a while, which was fun too!
Overall this was a really great, sweet, fun series with interesting magic, a vibrant historical setting, lovable characters, sweet found family, and an adorable romance!
*Rating: 4 Stars // Read Date: 2021 // Format: eARC*
Recommended For:
Fans of Books 1 and 2 in Allie Therin's Magic in Manhattan series. Anyone who likes adorable characters and relationships, supernatural powers, and the Prohibition Era.
Original Review @ Metaphors and Moonlight
Review:
*I received an ecopy of this book from the publisher. This has not influenced my review.*
Once again, Rory and Arthur were just darn adorable! They are SUCH a cute couple, and their light-hearted banter, smoldering attraction, and deepening feelings are the highlight of this series.
This book also really focused on the adorable found family element in the series. With his mother dead and his father just awful, Rory felt mostly alone in life and didn't trust easily. But he wasn't alone, and his new lover and friends were determined to show him that.
Since this book was the last in the trilogy, it wrapped up the plot about Zeppler, the paranormal relics, and the romance in a happy, satisfying way. I felt like there were some background elements that were brought up or seemed hinted at but then were never brought up again, but nothing big. There were also some interesting uses of magic and paranormal abilities, plus some surprising little twists here and there.
The Prohibition Era setting was great again, but this time the characters traveled to Europe for a while, which was fun too!
Overall this was a really great, sweet, fun series with interesting magic, a vibrant historical setting, lovable characters, sweet found family, and an adorable romance!
*Rating: 4 Stars // Read Date: 2021 // Format: eARC*
Recommended For:
Fans of Books 1 and 2 in Allie Therin's Magic in Manhattan series. Anyone who likes adorable characters and relationships, supernatural powers, and the Prohibition Era.
Original Review @ Metaphors and Moonlight
April 26, 2022
4.5 absolute magic
February 21, 2021
This appears to be a conclusion to "Magic in Manhattan" series. I say appears because blurb says so, I have no idea whether the next book will be coming in Rory and Arthur's adventures and if it will be I am not sure if I will invest in it or not. I say it because unfortunately my enjoyment of this trilogy went down instead of up with every new book. I loved the first book, liked the second book quite a bit but not as much as the first one and this one I overall liked the least.
Initially I was bored, then when the story picked up the pace and was entertaining I was annoyed at "oh I need to tell you a very important thing, but of course I will not, because - I am afraid to lose you and it is not fair to you, etc, etc, etc". I had been there, read that too many times and do not get me wrong sometimes this works, but man the character better have a *very* good reason to be quiet and here as far as I am concerned well, he really did not have that good reason.
At least I understood why I was irritated with the "I am not talking " plot development, but I could not understand why first quarter of the story I was bored and then the feeling of the boredom kind of returned at the end after the story climaxed and then it dawned on me. I did not feel like I got enough of the payoff. I mean hunting the magical relics was something that I found fun and very promising in the first book and do not get me wrong, all the villains got punished here and good guys fully prevailed, but I was not really seeing what effect this all had on the world as a whole. It is hard to explain, but I almost felt like saying "that's it?"
It is quite weird that I felt that way, because last quarter of the story was quite suspenseful, but somehow I was still disappointed with the ending. I guess relics itself disappointed me. I know that those things became very destructive for paranormals in the world of these books, but it still did not quite work for me.
I was confused about Gwen and Ellis in the second book. Sadly I am even more confused about them after the third book ended. I guess they are supposed to have the shades of grey but still do the right thing, but I was still confused as to why they had to choose the means they chose in order to do the right thing.
I still like Rory and Arthur, although their chemistry somehow diminished for me as well.
C-/C
Initially I was bored, then when the story picked up the pace and was entertaining I was annoyed at "oh I need to tell you a very important thing, but of course I will not, because - I am afraid to lose you and it is not fair to you, etc, etc, etc". I had been there, read that too many times and do not get me wrong sometimes this works, but man the character better have a *very* good reason to be quiet and here as far as I am concerned well, he really did not have that good reason.
At least I understood why I was irritated with the "I am not talking " plot development, but I could not understand why first quarter of the story I was bored and then the feeling of the boredom kind of returned at the end after the story climaxed and then it dawned on me. I did not feel like I got enough of the payoff. I mean hunting the magical relics was something that I found fun and very promising in the first book and do not get me wrong, all the villains got punished here and good guys fully prevailed, but I was not really seeing what effect this all had on the world as a whole. It is hard to explain, but I almost felt like saying "that's it?"
It is quite weird that I felt that way, because last quarter of the story was quite suspenseful, but somehow I was still disappointed with the ending. I guess relics itself disappointed me. I know that those things became very destructive for paranormals in the world of these books, but it still did not quite work for me.
I was confused about Gwen and Ellis in the second book. Sadly I am even more confused about them after the third book ended. I guess they are supposed to have the shades of grey but still do the right thing, but I was still confused as to why they had to choose the means they chose in order to do the right thing.
I still like Rory and Arthur, although their chemistry somehow diminished for me as well.
C-/C
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 9, 2021
I am so happy I took a chance on picking up this series, it has been a true delight getting to know Rory, Arthur and their friends. The world that Allie Therin has created is full of magic but the true magic is this story that introduced us to this glorious world. I loved that this is a paranormal historical series.
The books take us from New York to Europe and follows psychometric Rory who has difficulty controlling his magic while wearing his relic, a ring that makes him control the wind. Arthur is no paranormal but since finding out that magic is very real he has been helping his paranormal friends in fighting the powers that want to take over the world with bad magic. When these two men meet Rory is introduced to other paranormals who show him he is not alone in the world. Rory is stubborn and grumpy and does not take hand outs. Arthur is rich and handsome and wants to help Rory. The attraction between them is sweet and it was so wonderful seeing them fall in love and finally accept that they are worthy of each other.
This book takes this group of misfits through many magical challenges and across both the Atlantic Ocean and English Channel as they meet up with old foes who may not be foes to fight the most powerful paranormal before he finds Rory and uses his magic to unlock secrets that can put all non-paranormals in trouble. It was exciting and fast paced. I love how Rory, Arthur and their friends Jade & Zhang work together. The secondary characters have so much to offer in this series and at a time when women were not looked at as equals, in the paranormal world they are some of the strongest. Jade especially is a strong female who leads with no qualms. I loved her character so much.
It is sad that this series is over. I look forward to whatever Allie Therin has to offer in the future.
ARC received via NetGalley in exchange for review
The books take us from New York to Europe and follows psychometric Rory who has difficulty controlling his magic while wearing his relic, a ring that makes him control the wind. Arthur is no paranormal but since finding out that magic is very real he has been helping his paranormal friends in fighting the powers that want to take over the world with bad magic. When these two men meet Rory is introduced to other paranormals who show him he is not alone in the world. Rory is stubborn and grumpy and does not take hand outs. Arthur is rich and handsome and wants to help Rory. The attraction between them is sweet and it was so wonderful seeing them fall in love and finally accept that they are worthy of each other.
This book takes this group of misfits through many magical challenges and across both the Atlantic Ocean and English Channel as they meet up with old foes who may not be foes to fight the most powerful paranormal before he finds Rory and uses his magic to unlock secrets that can put all non-paranormals in trouble. It was exciting and fast paced. I love how Rory, Arthur and their friends Jade & Zhang work together. The secondary characters have so much to offer in this series and at a time when women were not looked at as equals, in the paranormal world they are some of the strongest. Jade especially is a strong female who leads with no qualms. I loved her character so much.
It is sad that this series is over. I look forward to whatever Allie Therin has to offer in the future.
ARC received via NetGalley in exchange for review
March 7, 2021
The first thing that got me in this book was Rory thinking he was all by himself and that he was "just Rory", not someone's family. That broke my heart so much. He was abandoned many so times before, which made him believe everyone would leave and he'd always protect himself against this.
When Arthur showed Rory that he was wanted, that everyone was happy to have him around he finally started believing in that. It was very beautiful.
They were struggling to destroy that horrible relic that could affect everyone and at the same time, they'd have to find excuses to be together, always hiding from everyone outside their circle because their love wasn't accepted. I usually avoid historical romances because this breaks my heart too much but I'm so glad I gave Magic in Manhattan a chance!
Their love was always the sweetest, you know that healthy relationship everyone should have? That's it, that's them!
Zhang, Jade, Pavel and Sasha were also amazing as I always say. A great group of friends who support each other for real and consider the other family. I even liked Gwen and Ellis, god I liked Wesley!!! And of course Sebastian, I'm so curious to see them interact!
I will read the spin-off series for sure! I love Allie's writing and fantastic characters and worldbuilding. A great ending for a great series.
When Arthur showed Rory that he was wanted, that everyone was happy to have him around he finally started believing in that. It was very beautiful.
They were struggling to destroy that horrible relic that could affect everyone and at the same time, they'd have to find excuses to be together, always hiding from everyone outside their circle because their love wasn't accepted. I usually avoid historical romances because this breaks my heart too much but I'm so glad I gave Magic in Manhattan a chance!
Their love was always the sweetest, you know that healthy relationship everyone should have? That's it, that's them!
Zhang, Jade, Pavel and Sasha were also amazing as I always say. A great group of friends who support each other for real and consider the other family. I even liked Gwen and Ellis, god I liked Wesley!!! And of course Sebastian, I'm so curious to see them interact!
I will read the spin-off series for sure! I love Allie's writing and fantastic characters and worldbuilding. A great ending for a great series.
March 5, 2021
4.25 stars. This one rather fizzled out like a damp squib unfortunately, and after all the previous build-up from the first 2 stories about how bad a super villain Baron Zeppler was too 🙁. Yes, he was definitely a psycho megalomaniac, and had great mind reading powers, but as with most megalomaniacs, he got others to do his dirty work for him and we didn't get to see him at his very worst [thank goodness].
Do we assume Sebastian and Lord Fine were alive and well in London? Will Ace's family really be OK with Rory as their son's paramour? Regrettably, the answers to these and other questions may never be answered.
Do we assume Sebastian and Lord Fine were alive and well in London? Will Ace's family really be OK with Rory as their son's paramour? Regrettably, the answers to these and other questions may never be answered.
December 27, 2025
A heart-stopping final showdown, plot twist, and a good ending to the series.
As always, our main couple is the delight of the book as they’re bridging the last steps to truly trust each other enough with their vulnerable moments. I also love every barb Rory trades with Wesley (Arthur’s ex) since book 2.
Wesley eyed Rory, who was glaring hard enough that Arthur was grateful the ring was in its lead box and not on Rory’s finger. “I still don’t know what to call you.”
“Funny, ’cause I got lots of ideas of what to call you,” said Rory.
I do feel like we’re missing certain closure, though, like the part with Arthur’s family. The big bad villain is a bit 2-dimensional, and although the plot is good, it’s like seeing a painting in broad strokes, but missing the details. Still, I really enjoyed this series and will surely continue to the spin-off.
As always, our main couple is the delight of the book as they’re bridging the last steps to truly trust each other enough with their vulnerable moments. I also love every barb Rory trades with Wesley (Arthur’s ex) since book 2.
Wesley eyed Rory, who was glaring hard enough that Arthur was grateful the ring was in its lead box and not on Rory’s finger. “I still don’t know what to call you.”
“Funny, ’cause I got lots of ideas of what to call you,” said Rory.
I do feel like we’re missing certain closure, though, like the part with Arthur’s family. The big bad villain is a bit 2-dimensional, and although the plot is good, it’s like seeing a painting in broad strokes, but missing the details. Still, I really enjoyed this series and will surely continue to the spin-off.
February 11, 2021
4.5 Stars!
It's no secret I love this series. Book #1, Spellbound was my first book by Allie Therin and I almost instantly loved her writing and the tale she wove with these two men and their paranormal adventures in the 1920s.
Fast forward two books later to this book and the writing is still as good and the story still as compelling as ever. This time, their paranormal adventures took them out of their home turf of NY, into new places, and finally culminated at Paris where the "Big Bad" that had been lurking in the shadows finally came to light. Let me tell you this, he really was a piece of work . *shudders*
Rory and Ace were as cute together as ever and even though this book threw a lot at them, they managed to get even stronger in their relationship. Also, like the previous two books in this trilogy this book managed to deliver intimacy without giving us explicitly laid out sexy times. As someone who reads a lot of steam, books like this can be refreshing when done right like this was.
So yeah, if you like your historical romance or PNR done right, don't hesitate to pick up this trilogy. You will not regret it.
** eARC Graciously Provided by Publisher via Netgalley in Exchange for an Honest, Unbiased Review **
It's no secret I love this series. Book #1, Spellbound was my first book by Allie Therin and I almost instantly loved her writing and the tale she wove with these two men and their paranormal adventures in the 1920s.
Fast forward two books later to this book and the writing is still as good and the story still as compelling as ever. This time, their paranormal adventures took them out of their home turf of NY, into new places, and finally culminated at Paris where the "Big Bad" that had been lurking in the shadows finally came to light. Let me tell you this, he really was a piece of work . *shudders*
Rory and Ace were as cute together as ever and even though this book threw a lot at them, they managed to get even stronger in their relationship. Also, like the previous two books in this trilogy this book managed to deliver intimacy without giving us explicitly laid out sexy times. As someone who reads a lot of steam, books like this can be refreshing when done right like this was.
So yeah, if you like your historical romance or PNR done right, don't hesitate to pick up this trilogy. You will not regret it.
** eARC Graciously Provided by Publisher via Netgalley in Exchange for an Honest, Unbiased Review **
February 10, 2021
This book's only flaw is that it didn't tell me if insufferable ass Lord Fine got himself a boyfriend or not
Anyway, proper RTC, but an excellent conclusion to one of my fave romance series ever, Rory and Arthur's final book/HEA is all I wanted it to be!
EDIT: there's a Wesley/Sebastian spinoff coming at some point so I lied the book is actually flawless
Anyway, proper RTC, but an excellent conclusion to one of my fave romance series ever, Rory and Arthur's final book/HEA is all I wanted it to be!
EDIT: there's a Wesley/Sebastian spinoff coming at some point so I lied the book is actually flawless
July 16, 2024
5⭐️
I really enjoyed this PNR series.
Yeah ok, the villain was a bit too willainy. But. I think it fits in this magical story.
I really enjoyed this PNR series.
Yeah ok, the villain was a bit too willainy. But. I think it fits in this magical story.
May 6, 2021
Updated for audio
4.75 stars
Read Camille's audio review in its entirety here.
4.5 stars
Wonderstruck is the third book in Allie Therin’s fabulous Magic in Manhattan trilogy. The books read as one long story and so you should start at the beginning of this wonderful historical paranormal series. This final book is full of romance, adventure, and excitement, tying things up nicely both with the larger series arc, as well as for Rory and Arthur.
From the suspense end, things have heated up and they are facing danger from all direction. For me, as exciting as these stories are, the real heart of the series is Arthur and Rory’s relationship and Therin does a great job tying things up for them as well. One of the recurring themes here has been both men’s desire to take care of the other, even at the expense of themselves.
So this was a wonderful end to a really great series. Therin balances a taut and exciting paranormal thriller with a really emotional romance. This final book brings the story to a great close and I have so enjoyed these stories.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
4.75 stars
Read Camille's audio review in its entirety here.
4.5 stars
Wonderstruck is the third book in Allie Therin’s fabulous Magic in Manhattan trilogy. The books read as one long story and so you should start at the beginning of this wonderful historical paranormal series. This final book is full of romance, adventure, and excitement, tying things up nicely both with the larger series arc, as well as for Rory and Arthur.
From the suspense end, things have heated up and they are facing danger from all direction. For me, as exciting as these stories are, the real heart of the series is Arthur and Rory’s relationship and Therin does a great job tying things up for them as well. One of the recurring themes here has been both men’s desire to take care of the other, even at the expense of themselves.
So this was a wonderful end to a really great series. Therin balances a taut and exciting paranormal thriller with a really emotional romance. This final book brings the story to a great close and I have so enjoyed these stories.
Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.
March 27, 2021
I have really, really enjoyed this series by Allie Therin. It's been such an entertaining journey. Therin has created a really cool, fully realized world of magic and adventure with a cast of incredible characters and one of the sweetest romances I've seen in a while. I'm sorry it's over, I could definitely have stood to stay here for a while.
January 10, 2021
"Wonderstruck" is the third and final book in Allie Therin's Magic in Manhattan series, set in an alternate universe /1920's New York where magic exists, and paranormals with various powers are working to save the world from powerful supernatural relics in the hands of dangerous magical malcontents.
Arthur McKenzie, Rory, Zhang, Jade and former adversaries Gwen and Ellis have banded together to acquire and neutralize the last relic. This adventure takes them to Paris where the relic will be offered for sale at a secret paranormal ehxibit at the Paris World's Fair.
Much of the plot involves their efforts to get to Paris and find the seller of the relic. Rory and Arthur are happy together, yet Rory's almost pathological need to not rely on Arthur is a bit wearing. As Arthur says:
As in the prior books, the middle of the story slows a bit and relies more than once on the sudden introduction of a mysterious character, but the author pulls it all together and gives us a very suspenseful thriller of an ending that is very satisfying.
Therin excels in creating an interesting alternate universe and peopling it with well-developed main characters, as well as concluding each book with a well-written exciting conclusion. I remain exasperated at the slowness of the plot at times and the continuing petty conflicts in Ace and Rory's relationship, but overall Magic in Manhattan is an engaging series. 3.5 stars for "Wonderstruck" and a solid 4 stars for the entire series.
I received an ARC from the Publisher, via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review.
Visit my blog, Sinfully Good Gay Book Reviews
Arthur McKenzie, Rory, Zhang, Jade and former adversaries Gwen and Ellis have banded together to acquire and neutralize the last relic. This adventure takes them to Paris where the relic will be offered for sale at a secret paranormal ehxibit at the Paris World's Fair.
Much of the plot involves their efforts to get to Paris and find the seller of the relic. Rory and Arthur are happy together, yet Rory's almost pathological need to not rely on Arthur is a bit wearing. As Arthur says:
"... you'll choose the suffering you think you've earned over the help you don't think you deserve, and Teddy, I don't know how to handle this heartbreak.But even as Rory finally agrees to allow Arthur to help fight his battles, petty jealousy from both parties continues. And Arthur holds an essential secret close to the vest, unwilling to tell Rory (at this point, I'm yelling at my Kindle, use your words, for gawd's sake talk to one another). The book continues to be fairly non-explicit, but thankfully by the end of the series, their relationship feels settled and very secure.
As in the prior books, the middle of the story slows a bit and relies more than once on the sudden introduction of a mysterious character, but the author pulls it all together and gives us a very suspenseful thriller of an ending that is very satisfying.
Therin excels in creating an interesting alternate universe and peopling it with well-developed main characters, as well as concluding each book with a well-written exciting conclusion. I remain exasperated at the slowness of the plot at times and the continuing petty conflicts in Ace and Rory's relationship, but overall Magic in Manhattan is an engaging series. 3.5 stars for "Wonderstruck" and a solid 4 stars for the entire series.
I received an ARC from the Publisher, via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review.
Visit my blog, Sinfully Good Gay Book Reviews
September 29, 2021
4.5*
what a great ending to the trilogy, im in love
what a great ending to the trilogy, im in love
February 15, 2021
I’ve loved this series since the beginning, so it’s no surprise that the end of the trilogy gets high marks from me. The quality remains consistent, and the central romance continues to develop without contrived drama popping in at set progress percentages to break up the couple.
I respect how Therin built her magic system: it’s soft enough to enhance the story as needed but internally consistent enough to feel plausible and reliable. The reader can more or less trust that Magic A stays Magic A while preserving a bit of mystery and wonder.
On the M/M front, we’re looking at moderate steam in this installment. There frankly isn’t a lot of time for intimacy in the plot, and what’s there tends toward the “fade-to-black” variety. I don’t need all of my romances to have explicit sex, and it doesn’t fit the tone for every kind of story, but worth mentioning for readers who might be disappointed by its relative lack.
While I do think it would have been very possible to get another great book out of the material here, I’m satisfied with this ending, and it seems likely that we can look forward to new stories in this universe.
I respect how Therin built her magic system: it’s soft enough to enhance the story as needed but internally consistent enough to feel plausible and reliable. The reader can more or less trust that Magic A stays Magic A while preserving a bit of mystery and wonder.
On the M/M front, we’re looking at moderate steam in this installment. There frankly isn’t a lot of time for intimacy in the plot, and what’s there tends toward the “fade-to-black” variety. I don’t need all of my romances to have explicit sex, and it doesn’t fit the tone for every kind of story, but worth mentioning for readers who might be disappointed by its relative lack.
While I do think it would have been very possible to get another great book out of the material here, I’m satisfied with this ending, and it seems likely that we can look forward to new stories in this universe.
January 7, 2022
Reread Update - just so good! It made my best reads of 2021 list at All About Romance: https://allaboutromance.com/the-best-...
This series has kept me spellbound from the very start and I'm delighted to say that the finale is everything I had hoped for - except I don't want it to end! (cue the crying). In preparation for this finale I recently reread the first two books in the Magic in Manhattan series before starting this one and I definitely recommend it if you're like me with a poor memory for details, and also because they are definitely worth re-reading.
The final installment sees Rory and Arthur on their quest to find a magical object ( a siphon) that can be used to drain magic from the other magical objects that they've encountered over the course of the series. It will require lots of help, from their tried and true friends Jade and Zhang, to their nemeses Gwen and Ellis as well as some other paranormal characters who've appeared along the way. The action starts from the very beginning and doesn't let up as Arthur and Rory make their way to the continent and the world's fair in Paris where they hope to acquire what they need. But while the magic and worldbuilding in this series is top notch, the evolution of Rory and Arthur's relationship into one of equals is just as important. Rory has matured from the first novel and now they are in a position where they both need each other - and have to admit it in order for them to successfully navigate the trials they encounter in this book. I enjoyed every moment of this story (and the series as a whole) and it absolutely deserves a place on my keeper shelf!
A copy of this story was provided by the publisher via NetGalley.
This series has kept me spellbound from the very start and I'm delighted to say that the finale is everything I had hoped for - except I don't want it to end! (cue the crying). In preparation for this finale I recently reread the first two books in the Magic in Manhattan series before starting this one and I definitely recommend it if you're like me with a poor memory for details, and also because they are definitely worth re-reading.
The final installment sees Rory and Arthur on their quest to find a magical object ( a siphon) that can be used to drain magic from the other magical objects that they've encountered over the course of the series. It will require lots of help, from their tried and true friends Jade and Zhang, to their nemeses Gwen and Ellis as well as some other paranormal characters who've appeared along the way. The action starts from the very beginning and doesn't let up as Arthur and Rory make their way to the continent and the world's fair in Paris where they hope to acquire what they need. But while the magic and worldbuilding in this series is top notch, the evolution of Rory and Arthur's relationship into one of equals is just as important. Rory has matured from the first novel and now they are in a position where they both need each other - and have to admit it in order for them to successfully navigate the trials they encounter in this book. I enjoyed every moment of this story (and the series as a whole) and it absolutely deserves a place on my keeper shelf!
A copy of this story was provided by the publisher via NetGalley.
October 14, 2021
WONDERSTRUCK was such a great conclusion to the MAGIC IN MANHATTAN series and I love Rory and Arthur so much! The story continues from the previous books as the whole gang -- Rory, Arthur, Zhang, and Jade -- try to find a way to destroy the magical relic before it can fall into the hands of the evil Baron Zeppler. But this book gives us the added bonus of a trip to Paris' World Fair where they hope to find answers.
I've enjoyed the mysteries and adventures from the beginning and this is no exception, but what I truly enjoy about this series is the characters. Rory and Arthur continue to build on their relationship and it really comes to a head as Rory finally starts to reach out and trust that Arthur will always be there for him. It's not easy going and they both deal with some insecurities but it was great to see the final walls start to come down. As always Rory is his usual grumpy self and Arthur is busy trying to save the world and being overprotective and they both have to deal with how those things affect their relationship. I also loved Zhang and Jade and they feature prominently in this story as well as some other paranormals that I wasn't expecting.
As always, a series ending is bittersweet because I don't want to let go of the characters but the good news is that the author has confirmed she's writing a spin off featuring the snobby Lord Fine and the paranormal Sebastian so I can't wait to read that when it comes out!
Content Warning: References to child abuse and being committed to an insane asylum
I've enjoyed the mysteries and adventures from the beginning and this is no exception, but what I truly enjoy about this series is the characters. Rory and Arthur continue to build on their relationship and it really comes to a head as Rory finally starts to reach out and trust that Arthur will always be there for him. It's not easy going and they both deal with some insecurities but it was great to see the final walls start to come down. As always Rory is his usual grumpy self and Arthur is busy trying to save the world and being overprotective and they both have to deal with how those things affect their relationship. I also loved Zhang and Jade and they feature prominently in this story as well as some other paranormals that I wasn't expecting.
As always, a series ending is bittersweet because I don't want to let go of the characters but the good news is that the author has confirmed she's writing a spin off featuring the snobby Lord Fine and the paranormal Sebastian so I can't wait to read that when it comes out!
Content Warning: References to child abuse and being committed to an insane asylum
February 10, 2021
I enjoyed the heck out of Wonderstruck. I'm sad to say goodbye to Ace and Teddy but it was a lovely send off.
Therin is a master at setting a scene so that the reader is immersed in a different time period. Her attention to detail is phenomenal, and it pays off in spades.
The descriptions of the characters' voyage from NYC to London--the differences in classes, the accommodations--is fascinating. And on to Paris and London. Life in 1925 is meticulously recreated in America and abroad. Aside from the magic, every tiny aspect of the time period is thoroughly represented.
The worldbuilding of the magic is so colorful and imaginative. The range of powers the paranormals have and how those powers interact grabbed my attention and curiosity. I simply couldn't put this book down.
And what brings it all together is the romance between Arthur and Rory. I am here for all the mushy, sweet, and adorable scenes with these two.
All of these elements--the historical setting, the magic, and the love story--combine to make an exceptional story and a wonderful conclusion to the Magic in Manhattan trilogy.
***Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.***
Therin is a master at setting a scene so that the reader is immersed in a different time period. Her attention to detail is phenomenal, and it pays off in spades.
The descriptions of the characters' voyage from NYC to London--the differences in classes, the accommodations--is fascinating. And on to Paris and London. Life in 1925 is meticulously recreated in America and abroad. Aside from the magic, every tiny aspect of the time period is thoroughly represented.
The worldbuilding of the magic is so colorful and imaginative. The range of powers the paranormals have and how those powers interact grabbed my attention and curiosity. I simply couldn't put this book down.
And what brings it all together is the romance between Arthur and Rory. I am here for all the mushy, sweet, and adorable scenes with these two.
All of these elements--the historical setting, the magic, and the love story--combine to make an exceptional story and a wonderful conclusion to the Magic in Manhattan trilogy.
***Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.***
February 22, 2021
*I* am wonderstruck at how good this installment is. How do they keep getting better?? Great characters, squishy-challenging romance all tangled up in magic, and a nicely tricksy plot drawing to a satisfying close. There could be more, but it isn't necessary, and these three novels are among the strongest stories I've read. Love them. Highly recommended.
September 16, 2021
Probably the least engaging of the trilogy, despite a strong action-driven plot-line and some unexpected 'I did not see that coming' developments. A good wrap-up to the over-arching storyline with a not too sappy HEA ending. 3.5 stars.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 311 reviews