What do you think?
Rate this book
The Hidden Child
In this new historical novel by the author of Daughter of the Reich, Londoners Eleanor and Edward Hamilton have wealth, status, and a happy marriage—but the 1929 financial crash is looming, and they’re harboring a terrible, shameful secret. How far are they willing to go to protect their charmed life—even if it means abandoning their child to a horrific fate?
Eleanor Hamilton is happily married and mother to a beautiful four-year-old girl, Mabel. Her wealthy husband, Edward, a celebrated war hero, is a leading light in the burgeoning Eugenics movement—the very ideas that will soon be embraced by Hitler—and is increasingly important in designing education policy for Great Britain.
But when Edward and Eleanor’s otherwise perfectly healthy daughter develops debilitating epileptic seizures, their world fractures. Mabel’s shameful illness must be hidden or Edward’s life’s work will be in jeopardy and the family’s honor will be shattered.
When Eleanor discovers Edward has been keeping secrets, she calls into question everything she believed about genetic inferiority, and her previous unshakeable faith in her husband disintegrates. Alarmed, distressed, and no longer able to bear the family’s burden, she takes matters into her own hands.
Inspired by the author’s personal experience, The Hidden Child illuminates the moral and ethical issues of an era shaped by xenophobia, prejudice, fear, and well-intentioned yet flawed science. Vividly rendered, deeply affecting, and impeccably researched, Louise Fein’s new historical novel is a sweeping story and a richly drawn portrait of a family torn apart by shame, deceit, and dangerous ideals.
Eleanor Hamilton is happily married and mother to a beautiful four-year-old girl, Mabel. Her wealthy husband, Edward, a celebrated war hero, is a leading light in the burgeoning Eugenics movement—the very ideas that will soon be embraced by Hitler—and is increasingly important in designing education policy for Great Britain.
But when Edward and Eleanor’s otherwise perfectly healthy daughter develops debilitating epileptic seizures, their world fractures. Mabel’s shameful illness must be hidden or Edward’s life’s work will be in jeopardy and the family’s honor will be shattered.
When Eleanor discovers Edward has been keeping secrets, she calls into question everything she believed about genetic inferiority, and her previous unshakeable faith in her husband disintegrates. Alarmed, distressed, and no longer able to bear the family’s burden, she takes matters into her own hands.
Inspired by the author’s personal experience, The Hidden Child illuminates the moral and ethical issues of an era shaped by xenophobia, prejudice, fear, and well-intentioned yet flawed science. Vividly rendered, deeply affecting, and impeccably researched, Louise Fein’s new historical novel is a sweeping story and a richly drawn portrait of a family torn apart by shame, deceit, and dangerous ideals.
480 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 2, 2021
555 people are currently reading
18561 people want to read
About the author
Louise Fein
5 books842 followersLouise is an internationally bestselling and prize winning author of historical fiction, focusing on unheard voices or from unusual perspectives. Her fourth novel, Book of Forbidden Words, will be published in February 2026.
Louise, holds an MA in Creative Writing from St Mary’s University and now writes full time. Equally passionate about historical research and writing, she loves to look for themes which have resonance with today’s world. Louise lives in the Surrey countryside, UK, with her family, and is a slave to the daily demands of her pets.
Louise, holds an MA in Creative Writing from St Mary’s University and now writes full time. Equally passionate about historical research and writing, she loves to look for themes which have resonance with today’s world. Louise lives in the Surrey countryside, UK, with her family, and is a slave to the daily demands of her pets.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 705 reviews
March 28, 2025
Why I chose to listen to this audiobook:
1. parts of GR friend, Marilyn's review (https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...) intrigued me to add this unique historical fiction to my WTR list; and,
2. March 2025 is my "E and F Authors" Month!
Praises:
1. the setting (both time and place) was well-developed. A couple of years before the Stock Market Crash of 1929, we're transported to England. Women have the right to vote, but are frowned upon working in traditionally male-held careers (e.g. journalism). Health care is somewhat improving, but it was frustrating to hear of the arrogance of the medical community and its stubbornness to learn something new and innovative. And then there's the infamous Eugenics Movement (embraced by Adolf Hitler) which was promoted by the snobbery of the "upper classes" - it was all good and righteous, until it hits you personally;
2. the characters were well-developed as well, showing growth as the story progressed. As a mother and grandmother, I could acutely feel Eleanor Hamilton's pain upon witnessing her 4-year-old daughter Mabel's debilitating epileptic seizures, and worse, being coerced to have Mabel institutionalized with no parental visitation allowed. Her husband, Edward Hamilton, comes across as a real ass, both professionally and personally. Chapters that were narrated by the "flame-haired woman" (aka epilepsy) were quite chilling but enlightening; and,
3. narrator, Marisa Calin does an excellent job re: authenticity.
Overall Thoughts:
It's quite the educational story which also pulled hard on my heartstrings!
1. parts of GR friend, Marilyn's review (https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...) intrigued me to add this unique historical fiction to my WTR list; and,
2. March 2025 is my "E and F Authors" Month!
Praises:
1. the setting (both time and place) was well-developed. A couple of years before the Stock Market Crash of 1929, we're transported to England. Women have the right to vote, but are frowned upon working in traditionally male-held careers (e.g. journalism). Health care is somewhat improving, but it was frustrating to hear of the arrogance of the medical community and its stubbornness to learn something new and innovative. And then there's the infamous Eugenics Movement (embraced by Adolf Hitler) which was promoted by the snobbery of the "upper classes" - it was all good and righteous, until it hits you personally;
2. the characters were well-developed as well, showing growth as the story progressed. As a mother and grandmother, I could acutely feel Eleanor Hamilton's pain upon witnessing her 4-year-old daughter Mabel's debilitating epileptic seizures, and worse, being coerced to have Mabel institutionalized with no parental visitation allowed. Her husband, Edward Hamilton, comes across as a real ass, both professionally and personally. Chapters that were narrated by the "flame-haired woman" (aka epilepsy) were quite chilling but enlightening; and,
3. narrator, Marisa Calin does an excellent job re: authenticity.
Overall Thoughts:
It's quite the educational story which also pulled hard on my heartstrings!
September 8, 2021
Eleanor is married to world war one hero Edward Hamilton and they have a four year old daughter Mabel. The Hamilton's live in a beautiful home in the English countryside, they own a London apartment and are well off. Edward’s a professor, he’s interested in psychology and the science of eugenics. For me this was a rather controversial topic, using Darwin’s theory of survival of the fittest, adults and children would be put into categories and it also involves more controversial ideas and practices.
Both Edward and Eleanor believe in eugenics and for Eleanor she has a personal reason for her beliefs. When Mable starts having funny turns, she goes blank, mentions a lady she sees during her episodes and Eleanor puts it down to her being tired. Mabel she has a fit, the Hamilton’s can’t ignore their daughter’s condition, they seek medical advice and she’s diagnosed with epilepsy.
Edward’s very concerned about his career, Eleanor’s in shock, and she has no idea how limited and horrible the treatment was for epileptics in the 1920’s. This cause’s immense tension in the couple’s relationship, when Eleanor discovers Edward has been keeping a secret from her for over twelve years and she starts to question his honesty and his beliefs. Eleanor's desperate to help her daughter, she loves her and the doctor treating Mable won’t listen to her at all, and she comes up with a plan and is determined to save her.
To be honest, half way through The Hidden Child, I wasn’t sure I could finish the book, I found the whole idea of the science of genetics and eugenics horrifying, the medical treatment and attitudes towards children especially distressing. However I continued reading the story, I can understand why Louise Fein included these topics in the book, it was well written and you certainly question the ideas, morals and medical treatment at the time.
I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review and five stars from me. https://karrenreadsbooks.blogspot.com/
Both Edward and Eleanor believe in eugenics and for Eleanor she has a personal reason for her beliefs. When Mable starts having funny turns, she goes blank, mentions a lady she sees during her episodes and Eleanor puts it down to her being tired. Mabel she has a fit, the Hamilton’s can’t ignore their daughter’s condition, they seek medical advice and she’s diagnosed with epilepsy.
Edward’s very concerned about his career, Eleanor’s in shock, and she has no idea how limited and horrible the treatment was for epileptics in the 1920’s. This cause’s immense tension in the couple’s relationship, when Eleanor discovers Edward has been keeping a secret from her for over twelve years and she starts to question his honesty and his beliefs. Eleanor's desperate to help her daughter, she loves her and the doctor treating Mable won’t listen to her at all, and she comes up with a plan and is determined to save her.
To be honest, half way through The Hidden Child, I wasn’t sure I could finish the book, I found the whole idea of the science of genetics and eugenics horrifying, the medical treatment and attitudes towards children especially distressing. However I continued reading the story, I can understand why Louise Fein included these topics in the book, it was well written and you certainly question the ideas, morals and medical treatment at the time.
I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review and five stars from me. https://karrenreadsbooks.blogspot.com/
March 10, 2023
The Hidden Child by Louise Fein my first 5🌟 for the month! Wonderful book about the effects of research and Eugenics in the era building up to WW2.
The research was good. The characters were so strong I literally ended up despising Edward who was a professor and writing research for Eugenics and in favor of putting the disabled into institutions. What appears as a weak character, Eleanor, ended up being of strong mind anf character fighting for her child.
I’ve read other books on Eugenics but this is the first one that really went more in detail about what it is and the damage it truly had on humans, particularly, children.
Imagine having epilepsy and being shunned from society, locked in an institution. Makes me think of a dog I had as a child. He had epilepsy. He would have been put down. It amazes me of the pure ignorance “back then.” The abuse children and adults were subjected to. Surgeries to prevent child birth. The lives destroyed.
The research was good. The characters were so strong I literally ended up despising Edward who was a professor and writing research for Eugenics and in favor of putting the disabled into institutions. What appears as a weak character, Eleanor, ended up being of strong mind anf character fighting for her child.
I’ve read other books on Eugenics but this is the first one that really went more in detail about what it is and the damage it truly had on humans, particularly, children.
Imagine having epilepsy and being shunned from society, locked in an institution. Makes me think of a dog I had as a child. He had epilepsy. He would have been put down. It amazes me of the pure ignorance “back then.” The abuse children and adults were subjected to. Surgeries to prevent child birth. The lives destroyed.
December 14, 2021
The Hidden Child by Louise Fein was a very heart wrenching yet compelling book. I listened to the audio CD that was very well narrated by Marisa Calin. This was my first book that I have read by Louise Fein and I was very impressed with her meticulous research. The chapters alternated between the main characters. The Hidden Child took place in England after World War I, at the onset of World War II and through The Great Depression. It explored the morality and outlook of the eugenics society that was gaining popularity in England during this time period. The Hidden Child was inspired by the author’s own family experience and I believe that that made it even more compelling. The characters were complex, very human with real flaws and strengths and quite believable. It was a story of hope, motherhood and how unconditional love knew no limits when the welfare of a child was at stake.
Eleanor and Edward met at work after Eleanor’s mother was viciously killed by a man that suffered from mental illness. The two began to work in earnest to prove and support the findings of the Eugenics movement that was becoming quite popular in England during the 1930’s. The two were very attracted to each other, respected each other and began to like each other very much. They were eventually married and had a daughter. Their daughter, Mabel, grew into a vivacious, smart and precocious little girl. When Mabel was four years old, she started to have seizures. The first time it ever happened, Eleanor had taken Mabel with her to welcome her sister Rose home from her trip to Paris. Eleanor was visibly shaken and scared at what she had witnessed. As fast as the seizure happened, it ceased and Eleanor thought that maybe she had imagined the whole thing. She quickly put it out of her thoughts and mentioned it to no one. Then the seizures began to happen more frequently and Eleanor knew that she could no longer ignore what was happening to her sweet daughter. When Edward witnessed one of his daughter’s seizures he was quick to make sure that Mabel was kept out of the public eye. After all, he had his reputation to uphold. A doctor was consulted and it was determined that Mabel suffered from epilepsy. In those days, the stigma of having epilepsy was embarrassing and a reflection of class and upbringing. Since Edward was so involved in the Eugenics movement he arranged a consultation with the most prominent doctor in the field of epilepsy. It was soon decided that Mabel would be better off living in a facility where she could be cared for with the most up to date treatments. Eleanor and Edward were at odds over this decision especially when Eleanor was denied visitation privileges. Edward was fostering a great amount of secrets about himself. He was keeping secrets about his personal life that occurred before he met Eleanor and about his work and research for the Eugenics movement. He would do anything to save his reputation and secure his position in society, even if it was at his own daughter’s expense. These secrets would eventually affect the stability of his marriage and the fate of his family. Eleanor had no choice. She had to intervene for her daughter’s sake. Would Eleanor figure out how best to help Mabel in time? Would she be able to give Mabel the life she deserved to live? How far would she go to save her daughter from the bleak life Edward had laid out for her?
Epilepsy was thought of as a condition only the poorest classes got. Sterilization was often a solution. Since epilepsy was not well understood, the treatments were harsh and often led to deterioration in the patient’s cognitive ability and thus the patients were often labeled as feeble minded. They were institutionalized in the 1920’s and 1930’s and were not offered many opportunities. Feelings of prejudice, fear and shame were associated with epilepsy at this time in history. Louise Fein brilliantly executed and wrote this historical fiction novel that opened my eyes to so many things that occurred during this time period that I was not aware of. It was powerful, engaging, heart wrenching yet heartwarming all at the same time. This was the first book that I have read by Louise Fein but I look forward to reading her past novels and future ones as well. I highly recommend this book.
Eleanor and Edward met at work after Eleanor’s mother was viciously killed by a man that suffered from mental illness. The two began to work in earnest to prove and support the findings of the Eugenics movement that was becoming quite popular in England during the 1930’s. The two were very attracted to each other, respected each other and began to like each other very much. They were eventually married and had a daughter. Their daughter, Mabel, grew into a vivacious, smart and precocious little girl. When Mabel was four years old, she started to have seizures. The first time it ever happened, Eleanor had taken Mabel with her to welcome her sister Rose home from her trip to Paris. Eleanor was visibly shaken and scared at what she had witnessed. As fast as the seizure happened, it ceased and Eleanor thought that maybe she had imagined the whole thing. She quickly put it out of her thoughts and mentioned it to no one. Then the seizures began to happen more frequently and Eleanor knew that she could no longer ignore what was happening to her sweet daughter. When Edward witnessed one of his daughter’s seizures he was quick to make sure that Mabel was kept out of the public eye. After all, he had his reputation to uphold. A doctor was consulted and it was determined that Mabel suffered from epilepsy. In those days, the stigma of having epilepsy was embarrassing and a reflection of class and upbringing. Since Edward was so involved in the Eugenics movement he arranged a consultation with the most prominent doctor in the field of epilepsy. It was soon decided that Mabel would be better off living in a facility where she could be cared for with the most up to date treatments. Eleanor and Edward were at odds over this decision especially when Eleanor was denied visitation privileges. Edward was fostering a great amount of secrets about himself. He was keeping secrets about his personal life that occurred before he met Eleanor and about his work and research for the Eugenics movement. He would do anything to save his reputation and secure his position in society, even if it was at his own daughter’s expense. These secrets would eventually affect the stability of his marriage and the fate of his family. Eleanor had no choice. She had to intervene for her daughter’s sake. Would Eleanor figure out how best to help Mabel in time? Would she be able to give Mabel the life she deserved to live? How far would she go to save her daughter from the bleak life Edward had laid out for her?
Epilepsy was thought of as a condition only the poorest classes got. Sterilization was often a solution. Since epilepsy was not well understood, the treatments were harsh and often led to deterioration in the patient’s cognitive ability and thus the patients were often labeled as feeble minded. They were institutionalized in the 1920’s and 1930’s and were not offered many opportunities. Feelings of prejudice, fear and shame were associated with epilepsy at this time in history. Louise Fein brilliantly executed and wrote this historical fiction novel that opened my eyes to so many things that occurred during this time period that I was not aware of. It was powerful, engaging, heart wrenching yet heartwarming all at the same time. This was the first book that I have read by Louise Fein but I look forward to reading her past novels and future ones as well. I highly recommend this book.
October 29, 2021
I’m a little torn on how to rate this one. While I liked the story overall, some parts of it frustrated me in ways that I find difficult to articulate. From the get go, I understood that this would not be an easy read by any means, as I knew from the summary that the subject matter revolved around the burgeoning eugenics movement at the end of the 1920s in Europe. With eugenics forever linked to the Holocaust in my mind, I had mixed feelings going into this book and to be honest, wasn’t too sure if I was up for a story (albeit a fictional one) about the beginnings of a movement associated with one of the most horrific war atrocities in history. With that said, I had read this author’s debut novel and liked it overall, so I figured I would give this one a try.
After having finished this one, I will say that I’m glad I took a chance on it, as it gave me better insight into the historical context behind why people back then had the attitudes and beliefs they did (even though I disagree with them completely). I also appreciated the writing, which I felt was well done overall (though some of the narrative did meander a bit, but not to the point of hugely impacting my reading experience).
My frustrations with this book were mostly with the characters — specifically the 2 main characters whose alternating perspectives the narrative was told from. Edward and Eleanor Hamilton are a wealthy, happily married couple in England who are both proponents of the eugenics movement for their own personal reasons, but Edward is a stronger believer due to his profession. When their sweet and beautiful four-year-old daughter Mabel starts to experience epileptic seizures, with each one more frequent and severe, their perfect lives shatter. The decision is made that Mabel, with her shameful illness, must be hidden away in order to protect the family’s honor as well as Edward’s work in eugenics. But things get worse from there, to the point that Edward’s and Eleanor’s marriage teeters on the verge of collapse.
To be perfectly honest, I found both Edward and Eleanor very difficult to like — not just because of the views they espoused, but also their personalities and the way they behaved throughout the story, annoyed for about 75% of the story. At certain points, I felt there was a lot of time spent by both of them attempting to justify their views and it got to be a bit too much in my opinion. I was hoping there would be more focus on Mabel, since her illness was technically the catalyst of the entire story, but there wasn’t as much on her as I expected. While both characters did end up having redeeming qualities that came into play later on, I think by that time, my frustration with them was too palpable to overcome.
Having said all that, I think the story overall was a good one and it’s obvious the author, Louise Fein, was meticulous in her research. While I did have issues with some aspects of the story, it was still an eye-opening read, one that I feel was well worth the effort. I heard that Fein is working on her third novel, which I’m definitely looking forward to reading!
Received ARC from William Morrow via NetGalley.
September 6, 2021
England, 1928. Eleanor Hamilton is happily married. Her wealthy husband takes a leading part in the burgeoning Eugenics movement. It’s about improving the health and wealth of the nations. Those who are in some way not classified as higher intelligence should be in a way handled as they lead toward a disastrous future. But the Hamilton’s lives get complicated when their four-year-old daughter develops debilitating epileptic seizures. Not only that, those idealistic and questionable ideas get embraced by Hitler.
This leads to Edward’s concerns about his career and Eleanor’s shocking discovery of epileptic treatment at the time. There is also a secret causing a friction between the couple. Eleanor desperate to help her daughter takes some things into her own hands.
The story vividly presents the horrifying movement and medical “treatments.” It can be a distressing read at times, but it is believably portrayed.
I struggled to fully connect with the characters. There are tiny parts giving flashbacks about them, but for me this wasn’t enough to get me attached to any character. I wished they were more fleshed-out before introducing the whole concept of the story.
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This leads to Edward’s concerns about his career and Eleanor’s shocking discovery of epileptic treatment at the time. There is also a secret causing a friction between the couple. Eleanor desperate to help her daughter takes some things into her own hands.
The story vividly presents the horrifying movement and medical “treatments.” It can be a distressing read at times, but it is believably portrayed.
I struggled to fully connect with the characters. There are tiny parts giving flashbacks about them, but for me this wasn’t enough to get me attached to any character. I wished they were more fleshed-out before introducing the whole concept of the story.
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
January 21, 2025
Ideea de la care a plecat scrierea cărții mi-a plăcut. Nimeni nu-și dorește un copil bolnav dar dacă soarta te încearcă trebuie să răzbați.
Ritmul mi se pare totuși lent.
Conceptul eugenistic mi se pare îngrozitor și mai ales ipocrizia cu care este susținută tocmai de cei care provin din clasele inferioare.
Sacrificiul, dragostea și devotamentul lui Eleanor pentru copiii ei este demn de o mamă greu încercată ce trebuie să se împartă între 2 copii mici dintre care unul cu epilepsie.
Pe de altă parte, Edward e genul de om laș, ce nu-și asumă obligațiile, nu-și acceptă identitatea, își însușește merite necuvenite doar pentru a susține o ideologie în care nici măcar el nu crede. Faptul că spre sfârșitul cărții își schimbă comportamentul, e greu de crezut,nici un om nu își modifică caracterul la maturitate.
Notele autoarei sunt interesante.
🌟🌟🌟
June 6, 2021
It’s every parent’s nightmare that one day, out of the blue, your toddler suffers an epileptic seizure: eyes rolling back and body thrashing and jerking as if possessed. Now imagine it’s the 1920s and your husband is a eugenicist, who believes that genetic weaknesses, such as epilepsy, should be bred out of the population by introducing forced sterilisation programmes and institutionalising sufferers. This is the premise of Louise Fein’s stunning new novel, and it had me hooked from the first page.
Confession time: I often cheat by reading Authors’ Notes before I start a novel, and in this case I found out that Louise Fein has personal experience of an epileptic child. It’s obvious she knows what she’s talking about in her acutely observed descriptions of little Mabel’s eyes clouding over, her jerky movements, and the way her behaviour starts to regress. The story is told from the points of view of her mother, Eleanor, and her father, Edward, with occasional short chapters from the point of view of Epilepsy itself, a malign, opportunistic kind of demon.
As Mabel’s health gets progressively worse, the story switches to the deterioration of her parent’s marriage. Lies are uncovered, secrets revealed, and they each find they didn’t truly know their spouse. We learn about epilepsy and the eugenics movement alongside them, and I found this fascinating; I love novels I learn something new from.
I won’t include any spoilers, but your heart will break over what happens to poor little Mabel and over the choices her parents make. Like Louise Fein’s debut novel, People Like Us, it encourages us to imagine what we would do in the characters’ positions. It’s pacy, well-written, and utterly engaging. I can’t wait to see what this author writes next; she has leapt straight into my ‘favourites’ list.
Confession time: I often cheat by reading Authors’ Notes before I start a novel, and in this case I found out that Louise Fein has personal experience of an epileptic child. It’s obvious she knows what she’s talking about in her acutely observed descriptions of little Mabel’s eyes clouding over, her jerky movements, and the way her behaviour starts to regress. The story is told from the points of view of her mother, Eleanor, and her father, Edward, with occasional short chapters from the point of view of Epilepsy itself, a malign, opportunistic kind of demon.
As Mabel’s health gets progressively worse, the story switches to the deterioration of her parent’s marriage. Lies are uncovered, secrets revealed, and they each find they didn’t truly know their spouse. We learn about epilepsy and the eugenics movement alongside them, and I found this fascinating; I love novels I learn something new from.
I won’t include any spoilers, but your heart will break over what happens to poor little Mabel and over the choices her parents make. Like Louise Fein’s debut novel, People Like Us, it encourages us to imagine what we would do in the characters’ positions. It’s pacy, well-written, and utterly engaging. I can’t wait to see what this author writes next; she has leapt straight into my ‘favourites’ list.
November 18, 2021
The Hidden Child by Louise Fein is a historical fiction novel set in the build-up to WWII. It revolves around the eugenics movement prevalent in America and Europe at the time. From Wikipedia, "Eugenics is a set of beliefs and practices that aim to improve the genetic quality of a human population, historically by excluding people and groups judged to be inferior or promoting those judged to be superior".
Edward, the husband, is a vocal supporter of eugenics. His wife, Eleanor, is a dutiful wife who supports her husband. When Mabel, their four-year-old daughter, starts to develop seizures, the mother's beliefs in the movement begin to change. What follows is a mother's struggle to save her daughter from the world, even if it means that she has to stand up against her husband.
The story is narrated by the husband-and-wife duo in alternating chapters. Epilepsy is personified, and gets its own voice in the form of short chapters here-and-there. This reminded me of what Markus Zusak did with Death in The Book Thief.
Thanks to the author and the publisher for the ARC.
Edward, the husband, is a vocal supporter of eugenics. His wife, Eleanor, is a dutiful wife who supports her husband. When Mabel, their four-year-old daughter, starts to develop seizures, the mother's beliefs in the movement begin to change. What follows is a mother's struggle to save her daughter from the world, even if it means that she has to stand up against her husband.
The story is narrated by the husband-and-wife duo in alternating chapters. Epilepsy is personified, and gets its own voice in the form of short chapters here-and-there. This reminded me of what Markus Zusak did with Death in The Book Thief.
Thanks to the author and the publisher for the ARC.
October 22, 2021
Secrets….Edward Hamilton has one and now he and his wife have one.
The secret they share together is that their daughter has epilepsy. He has to hide it because he is in charge of a study of eugenics and is on the committee for Great Britain’s educational system.
It was sad hearing they were ashamed their daughter had epilepsy and kept her hidden from everyone. The treatment back then was awful, and my heart was broken for Mable.
My heart broke for Eleanor too, and I didn’t like Edward or trust him. All he cared about was his image and his job.
We follow the family as they move through their days worrying about Mabel and as a new baby arrives.
The chapters where epilepsy speaks was unique and very interesting to have that in the book.
I enjoyed the chapters about Eleanor more than the ones that featured Edward and The International Congress of Eugenics. The information about this Congress was very distressing and I never knew about it.
THE HIDDEN CHILD hit home about the epilepsy because my brother has epilepsy, and I remember how frightening it was when he had a seizure.
The book is well written and well researched with many ethical issues being addressed as well.
Historical fiction fans as well as women’s fiction fans will enjoy this book. 4/5
This book was given to me by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The secret they share together is that their daughter has epilepsy. He has to hide it because he is in charge of a study of eugenics and is on the committee for Great Britain’s educational system.
It was sad hearing they were ashamed their daughter had epilepsy and kept her hidden from everyone. The treatment back then was awful, and my heart was broken for Mable.
My heart broke for Eleanor too, and I didn’t like Edward or trust him. All he cared about was his image and his job.
We follow the family as they move through their days worrying about Mabel and as a new baby arrives.
The chapters where epilepsy speaks was unique and very interesting to have that in the book.
I enjoyed the chapters about Eleanor more than the ones that featured Edward and The International Congress of Eugenics. The information about this Congress was very distressing and I never knew about it.
THE HIDDEN CHILD hit home about the epilepsy because my brother has epilepsy, and I remember how frightening it was when he had a seizure.
The book is well written and well researched with many ethical issues being addressed as well.
Historical fiction fans as well as women’s fiction fans will enjoy this book. 4/5
This book was given to me by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
August 15, 2021
Eleanor Hamilton is happily married and a mother to a beautiful four year old girl, Mabel. her wealthy husband Edward, a celebrated war hero, is a leading light in the burgeoning eugenics movement - the very ideas that will soon be embraced by Hitler - and is increasingly important in designing the education policy for Great Britain. But when Edward and Eleanor's otherwise healthy daughter develops debilitating seizures, their world fractures. Mabel's shameful illness must be hidden or Edward will be in jeopardy and the family's honour will be shattered.
Set in the 1920s: What an intriguing and thought provoking read this book is. The author has done her research before writing this book. The story is told in alternating chapters by Edward and Eleanor's perspectives. Edward and Eleanor are both members of the eugenics society and when their four year old daughter has epileptic seizures, they wonder how she can be fixed and if they can keep her hidden. The pace is steady and I quickly became invested in Edward, Eleanor and Mabel's story. We also get mini chapters from the voice of epilepsy. I quite enjoyed this book.
I would like to thank #NetGalley #HeadOfZeus and the author #LouiseFein for my ARC of #TheHiddenChild in exchange for an honest review.
Set in the 1920s: What an intriguing and thought provoking read this book is. The author has done her research before writing this book. The story is told in alternating chapters by Edward and Eleanor's perspectives. Edward and Eleanor are both members of the eugenics society and when their four year old daughter has epileptic seizures, they wonder how she can be fixed and if they can keep her hidden. The pace is steady and I quickly became invested in Edward, Eleanor and Mabel's story. We also get mini chapters from the voice of epilepsy. I quite enjoyed this book.
I would like to thank #NetGalley #HeadOfZeus and the author #LouiseFein for my ARC of #TheHiddenChild in exchange for an honest review.
November 30, 2021
It’s 1929 and Eleanor and Edward Hamilton are living a priviledged life in England. They have a flat in London and a beautiful country home. Four-year-old Mabel is the joy of their life. Edward is a war hero, an educator and a leader in the Eugenics Society. Members of the eugenics movement seek “to improve the human population by increasing reproduction of the most desirable characteristics in human beings and suppressing reproduction of the least desirable.” When Mabel is diagnosed as having epilepsy, the Hamilton’s believe they need to keep her illness a secret and keep their daughter hidden as it would jeopardize Edward’s career. But Edward is hiding more than his daughter’s illness and is forced to deal with years of deception. Eleanor is heartbroken and fears Edward will win out and Mabel will be sent to an institution.
Author Louise Fein has written a well-researched story that is often hard to read. Long associated with Nazi Germany’s desire to breed a master race, the eugenics movement had originally started in England with many prominent supporters there and in the United States. Their beliefs and desire for the creation of new laws to support them seem outlandish and unthinkable today yet this book, which includes many historical figures, takes place less than 100 years ago. It feels more like England in a Charles Dickens novel.
I enjoyed Fein’s debut novel Daughter of the Reich and The Hidden Child is another worthwhile read. In A Note from the Author, Fein reveals that she is a mother of an epileptic child which makes this story very personal and touched me even more.
Author Louise Fein has written a well-researched story that is often hard to read. Long associated with Nazi Germany’s desire to breed a master race, the eugenics movement had originally started in England with many prominent supporters there and in the United States. Their beliefs and desire for the creation of new laws to support them seem outlandish and unthinkable today yet this book, which includes many historical figures, takes place less than 100 years ago. It feels more like England in a Charles Dickens novel.
I enjoyed Fein’s debut novel Daughter of the Reich and The Hidden Child is another worthwhile read. In A Note from the Author, Fein reveals that she is a mother of an epileptic child which makes this story very personal and touched me even more.
November 11, 2021
I’m not really sure how this book ended up on my to read list, but it did. The subject matter - the eugenics movement of the 1920s - is certainly interesting. Unfortunately in this novel, it is a burdened by stiff infelicitous writing, ridiculous expository dialogue that is forced to display all of the author’s research (and a good many anachronisms - like when one character urges another to “live his best life”), and a treacly cloying plot (lots of wetting manly shirtfronts with womanly tears). I skimmed a lot and often debated quitting. An airport-y read, and not much more.
September 1, 2021
Mini-Review
This historical fiction looks at the eugenics movement, which promoted selective breeding by removing unwanted genetic features from human beings. In 1929, “Eleanor Hamilton is happily married and mother to a beautiful four-year-old girl, Mabel. Her wealthy husband, Edward, a celebrated war hero, is a leading light in the burgeoning eugenics movement—the very ideas that will soon be embraced by Hitler—and is increasingly important in designing education policy for Great Britain.” (From book blurb). Their four-year-old daughter begins to have seizures and is diagnosed with epilepsy. The novel puts a personal spin on the horrors of selective breeding. This is a heart-wrenching tale with an unbelievable ending. This reviewer’s side note: Eugenics was popular in America during much of the first half of the twentieth century, yet it earned its negative association mainly from Adolf Hilter’s obsessive attempts to create a superior Aryan race. America discredited the movement until following the horrors of Nazi Germany.
I received this Advance Review Copy (ARC) novel from the publisher at no cost in exchange for an honest review.
Find all my book reviews at:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/list…
https://books6259.wordpress.com/
https://www.barnesandnoble.com/review…
https://www.facebook.com/martie.neesr…
https://twitter.com/NeesRecord\
https://www.instagram.com/martie6947/
https://www.amazon.com/
This historical fiction looks at the eugenics movement, which promoted selective breeding by removing unwanted genetic features from human beings. In 1929, “Eleanor Hamilton is happily married and mother to a beautiful four-year-old girl, Mabel. Her wealthy husband, Edward, a celebrated war hero, is a leading light in the burgeoning eugenics movement—the very ideas that will soon be embraced by Hitler—and is increasingly important in designing education policy for Great Britain.” (From book blurb). Their four-year-old daughter begins to have seizures and is diagnosed with epilepsy. The novel puts a personal spin on the horrors of selective breeding. This is a heart-wrenching tale with an unbelievable ending. This reviewer’s side note: Eugenics was popular in America during much of the first half of the twentieth century, yet it earned its negative association mainly from Adolf Hilter’s obsessive attempts to create a superior Aryan race. America discredited the movement until following the horrors of Nazi Germany.
I received this Advance Review Copy (ARC) novel from the publisher at no cost in exchange for an honest review.
Find all my book reviews at:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/list…
https://books6259.wordpress.com/
https://www.barnesandnoble.com/review…
https://www.facebook.com/martie.neesr…
https://twitter.com/NeesRecord\
https://www.instagram.com/martie6947/
https://www.amazon.com/
November 7, 2021
Such a good story focusing on the Eugenics movement in London.
July 9, 2022
*www.onewomansbbr.wordpress.com
*www.facebook.com/onewomansbbr
**3.5 stars**
The Hidden Child by Louise Fein. (2021).
London, 1929. Eleanor is a dutiful mother, a caring sister and an adoring wife to celebrated war hero Edward who is a pioneer in the eugenics movement. But then their young daughter Mabel begins having debilitating seizures and it is clear she has epilepsy - one of the 'undesirable' conditions that Edwards campaigns against. Forced to hide their daughter away so Edward's work is not jeopardised, the couple must confront the truth of their past - and the secrets that have been buried. Will they be able to fight for their family, or will the truth destroy them?
An interesting topic, this novel is about the eugenics movement in the context of a pro-eugenics couple who are shocked when their small child develops epilepsy. At a fairly long length of 470 pages, the reader experiences the full confusion and emotional journey for Eleanor and Edward after their daughter's diagnosis. Some readers may find parts of this story confronting as there are descriptions of those who have been institutionalised, and discussions on sterilising 'undesirables'. I think the author has treated the topic respectfully and is bringing awareness to real events that some people may not have much knowledge on. I appreciated the author's note explaining that she was inspired by her own daughter's epilepsy diagnosis which gave the story a very personal touch.
Overall: I would recommend this novel for those that are interested in the synopsis.
*www.facebook.com/onewomansbbr
**3.5 stars**
The Hidden Child by Louise Fein. (2021).
London, 1929. Eleanor is a dutiful mother, a caring sister and an adoring wife to celebrated war hero Edward who is a pioneer in the eugenics movement. But then their young daughter Mabel begins having debilitating seizures and it is clear she has epilepsy - one of the 'undesirable' conditions that Edwards campaigns against. Forced to hide their daughter away so Edward's work is not jeopardised, the couple must confront the truth of their past - and the secrets that have been buried. Will they be able to fight for their family, or will the truth destroy them?
An interesting topic, this novel is about the eugenics movement in the context of a pro-eugenics couple who are shocked when their small child develops epilepsy. At a fairly long length of 470 pages, the reader experiences the full confusion and emotional journey for Eleanor and Edward after their daughter's diagnosis. Some readers may find parts of this story confronting as there are descriptions of those who have been institutionalised, and discussions on sterilising 'undesirables'. I think the author has treated the topic respectfully and is bringing awareness to real events that some people may not have much knowledge on. I appreciated the author's note explaining that she was inspired by her own daughter's epilepsy diagnosis which gave the story a very personal touch.
Overall: I would recommend this novel for those that are interested in the synopsis.
September 8, 2021
Eugenics is a subject I know little about but nonetheless I find it both horrifying and fascinating in concept. The Hidden Child isn’t the first fiction book I’ve read that covers the subject but its the first that deals with the subject in such detail. Here it is at the very heart of the story and focuses on a family that is in danger of tearing itself apart in the battle of beliefs over love.
Professor Edward Hamilton, a war hero, is a man of science – his specialism being in the field of psychology and education. He fervently believes in the future of eugenics to create a ‘survival of the fittest’ and to improve the human population by only using those most desirable characteristics and breeding out the worst – inherited diseases, and anybody regarded as being of ‘feeble mind’. His wife Eleanor, having her own tragic background at the hands of an ‘undesirable’ supports this, however when their beloved young daughter Mabel develops one of the illnesses that is regarded as undesirable, the collision course is set for a dilemma of heartbreaking proportions.
Hamilton is a wealthy man and they live a good life with well connected friends however all his money can’t protect him from what he must face with Mabel.
The Hidden Child gripped me from the first page. I knew that eugenics had been part of American society until recent decades and there are references to the Aryan concept being promoted by Germany’s Hitler but I didn’t realise that the UK had been pursuing its own policies to such a large degree.
The story is told from the alternative views of Edward and Eleanor with the occasional voice of Epilepsy itself, as if it were speaking from Mabel. This threw me the first time but it works well and is especially effective later on as the story develops.
The writing is just superb – the characters are beautifully captured – despite his status and intelligence, Edward is a tormented soul with a backstory of his own. Eleanor loves her husband dearly but has grave doubts about the way forward and the decisions that were being made about their daughter. My heart broke for Mabel and the story made me so angry that innocent people could be regarded as ‘disposable’ just because they didn’t conform to what a few privileged people believed should make a perfect society.
This was just a stunning read and there is so much more to the story that I can’t say here. It’s thought provoking and as well as being a fabulous fiction story to entertain, it also educated me. I loved it and it will without a doubt be one of my favourite books of the year.
There is a very interesting author’s note included which tells of her own experience with epilepsy which explains why she was able to write with such authenticity and also a note about the Eugenics movement and the mix of real and fictional characters in the story.
Professor Edward Hamilton, a war hero, is a man of science – his specialism being in the field of psychology and education. He fervently believes in the future of eugenics to create a ‘survival of the fittest’ and to improve the human population by only using those most desirable characteristics and breeding out the worst – inherited diseases, and anybody regarded as being of ‘feeble mind’. His wife Eleanor, having her own tragic background at the hands of an ‘undesirable’ supports this, however when their beloved young daughter Mabel develops one of the illnesses that is regarded as undesirable, the collision course is set for a dilemma of heartbreaking proportions.
Hamilton is a wealthy man and they live a good life with well connected friends however all his money can’t protect him from what he must face with Mabel.
The Hidden Child gripped me from the first page. I knew that eugenics had been part of American society until recent decades and there are references to the Aryan concept being promoted by Germany’s Hitler but I didn’t realise that the UK had been pursuing its own policies to such a large degree.
The story is told from the alternative views of Edward and Eleanor with the occasional voice of Epilepsy itself, as if it were speaking from Mabel. This threw me the first time but it works well and is especially effective later on as the story develops.
The writing is just superb – the characters are beautifully captured – despite his status and intelligence, Edward is a tormented soul with a backstory of his own. Eleanor loves her husband dearly but has grave doubts about the way forward and the decisions that were being made about their daughter. My heart broke for Mabel and the story made me so angry that innocent people could be regarded as ‘disposable’ just because they didn’t conform to what a few privileged people believed should make a perfect society.
This was just a stunning read and there is so much more to the story that I can’t say here. It’s thought provoking and as well as being a fabulous fiction story to entertain, it also educated me. I loved it and it will without a doubt be one of my favourite books of the year.
There is a very interesting author’s note included which tells of her own experience with epilepsy which explains why she was able to write with such authenticity and also a note about the Eugenics movement and the mix of real and fictional characters in the story.
October 27, 2021
A fascinating, engrossing book about a dark part of Britain history. Although the eugenics movement is difficult and often uncomfortable to read about as a modern reader, Fein manages to show the very real human cost of prejudice and lack of scientific understanding in the story of the Hamilton family. An important read.
November 18, 2021
Science, medicine and superstition, along with a eugenics program feature in this novel. An intriguing read though the chapters from Eleanor’s point of view worked better than those from her husband Edward. Recommended.
July 8, 2021
The Hidden Child by Louise Fein is a poignant Historical fiction novel. The author’s experiences while raising a child with epilepsy are the inspiration behind this story.
Though it’s a fictional piece, at the heart of the story is the eugenics movement which propagated selective breeding by eliminating undesirable genetic traits among humans. Edward, one of the staunch advocates of this movement, his wife Eleanor and daughter Mabel are the central characters in this though-provoking read.
Edward is involved in researching on eugenics, and is about to present his findings to the Eugenics Society. But things turn topsy-turvy when 4-year-old Mabel is diagnosed with epilepsy. To protect his social standing and honor, he takes some drastic steps to ensure the debilitating disease remains a secret. Eleanor, though initially supports the eugenics movement, Mabel’s condition and a few chance discoveries force her to think otherwise and lead to a change in her actions. Edward’s shameful secrets from the past continue to torment him, until the day he comes clean to the world, and Eleanor.
As much as the subject is thought provoking and disturbing, it is the impeccable narration which spoke to me tremendously. Fein’s writing skills are exemplary. Her vocabulary and style are impressive; especially in the way she has paid attention to details and has woven intricate and unforgettable characters amidst realistic settings. The story is set in the late 1920s, and I was transported to the distant era with an ease. This is what I need the most from any historical fiction – the feeling of being in the story.
Fein describes with utmost honesty the lives of the rich, poor and diseased. She details the demeaning and appalling attitudes of the elite towards the people affected with disorders.
Apart from the settings, it is the characters themselves which made this novel a memorable read. Although there are many people involved in the story, it doesn’t get confusing. They all have their distinct personality and place in the story. Eleanor’s character changes impressively. The way she metamorphoses into a strong woman, a confident wife and mother is inspiring and emotional. Edward, though stubborn at first, realizes his folly and undergoes a transformation himself.
And lastly, it is the positive and satisfying ending which made me quite happy.
The Hidden Child is a well-researched and well-written novel, and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and Head of Zeus in exchange for my honest review.
4.5 stars rounded to 5.
BLOG
Though it’s a fictional piece, at the heart of the story is the eugenics movement which propagated selective breeding by eliminating undesirable genetic traits among humans. Edward, one of the staunch advocates of this movement, his wife Eleanor and daughter Mabel are the central characters in this though-provoking read.
Edward is involved in researching on eugenics, and is about to present his findings to the Eugenics Society. But things turn topsy-turvy when 4-year-old Mabel is diagnosed with epilepsy. To protect his social standing and honor, he takes some drastic steps to ensure the debilitating disease remains a secret. Eleanor, though initially supports the eugenics movement, Mabel’s condition and a few chance discoveries force her to think otherwise and lead to a change in her actions. Edward’s shameful secrets from the past continue to torment him, until the day he comes clean to the world, and Eleanor.
As much as the subject is thought provoking and disturbing, it is the impeccable narration which spoke to me tremendously. Fein’s writing skills are exemplary. Her vocabulary and style are impressive; especially in the way she has paid attention to details and has woven intricate and unforgettable characters amidst realistic settings. The story is set in the late 1920s, and I was transported to the distant era with an ease. This is what I need the most from any historical fiction – the feeling of being in the story.
Fein describes with utmost honesty the lives of the rich, poor and diseased. She details the demeaning and appalling attitudes of the elite towards the people affected with disorders.
Apart from the settings, it is the characters themselves which made this novel a memorable read. Although there are many people involved in the story, it doesn’t get confusing. They all have their distinct personality and place in the story. Eleanor’s character changes impressively. The way she metamorphoses into a strong woman, a confident wife and mother is inspiring and emotional. Edward, though stubborn at first, realizes his folly and undergoes a transformation himself.
And lastly, it is the positive and satisfying ending which made me quite happy.
The Hidden Child is a well-researched and well-written novel, and I thoroughly enjoyed reading it.
I received an ARC from NetGalley and Head of Zeus in exchange for my honest review.
4.5 stars rounded to 5.
BLOG
June 8, 2024
Mi-a plăcut mult ideea de la care a pornit autoarea acest roman și cum l-a construit.
O familie se vede pusă în fața unei alegeri dificile atunci când descoperă că fiica lor suferă de epilepsie. De ce să aleagă? Pentru că tatăl este un lider al mișcării eugeniste iar asta înseamnă că trebuie să ascundă existența acestui copil.
Mama este un exemplu de iubire, devotament, sacrificiu și intuiție.
O familie se vede pusă în fața unei alegeri dificile atunci când descoperă că fiica lor suferă de epilepsie. De ce să aleagă? Pentru că tatăl este un lider al mișcării eugeniste iar asta înseamnă că trebuie să ascundă existența acestui copil.
Mama este un exemplu de iubire, devotament, sacrificiu și intuiție.
December 28, 2021
Secrets….Edward Hamilton has one and now he and his wife have one.
The secret they share together is that their daughter has epilepsy. He has to hide it because he is in charge of a study of eugenics and is on the committee for Great Britain’s educational system.
It was sad hearing they were ashamed their daughter had epilepsy and kept her hidden from everyone. The treatment back then was awful, and my heart was broken for Mable.
My heart broke for Eleanor too, and I didn’t like Edward or trust him. All he cared about was his image and his job.
We follow the family as they move through their days worrying about Mabel and as a new baby arrives.
The chapters where epilepsy speaks was unique and very interesting to have that in the book.
I enjoyed the chapters about Eleanor more than the ones that featured Edward and The International Congress of Eugenics. The information about this Congress was very distressing and I never knew about it.
THE HIDDEN CHILD hit home about the epilepsy because my brother has epilepsy, and I remember how frightening it was when he had a seizure.
The book is well written and well researched with many ethical issues being addressed as well.
Historical fiction fans as well as women’s fiction fans will enjoy this book. 4/5
This book was given to me by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The secret they share together is that their daughter has epilepsy. He has to hide it because he is in charge of a study of eugenics and is on the committee for Great Britain’s educational system.
It was sad hearing they were ashamed their daughter had epilepsy and kept her hidden from everyone. The treatment back then was awful, and my heart was broken for Mable.
My heart broke for Eleanor too, and I didn’t like Edward or trust him. All he cared about was his image and his job.
We follow the family as they move through their days worrying about Mabel and as a new baby arrives.
The chapters where epilepsy speaks was unique and very interesting to have that in the book.
I enjoyed the chapters about Eleanor more than the ones that featured Edward and The International Congress of Eugenics. The information about this Congress was very distressing and I never knew about it.
THE HIDDEN CHILD hit home about the epilepsy because my brother has epilepsy, and I remember how frightening it was when he had a seizure.
The book is well written and well researched with many ethical issues being addressed as well.
Historical fiction fans as well as women’s fiction fans will enjoy this book. 4/5
This book was given to me by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
October 31, 2021
I loved this book! My first book by the author - highly impressive! I purchased the audiobook, THE HIDDEN CHILD by Louise Fein and narrated by Marisa Calin. Highly recommend it and could not put it down. Full review coming!
January 28, 2022
[Thanks Netgalley for the ebook. This review is my honest opinion but just another opinion, you should read this book and judge it by yourself]
Leí People Like Us y me gustó mucho cómo Louise Fein escribió la relación entre un chico judío y una chica bien filonazi, así que no lo dudé al pedir su nuevo libro en Netgalley. Desde luego, lo de esta mujer son los temas complicados, ya que trata la epilepsia y la eugenesia mezclándolo en una misma familia, donde el padre es fiel defensor de esta filosofía que choca frontalmente con la epilepsia que sufre su hija. Por desgracia, he tenido serios problemas con el modo en el que está escrita la historia, en primera persona del presente pero de un modo extraño, con frases cortas, como muy deslavazado todo. No sé, a pesar de que estaba interesada en lo que ocurría, este modo de contarlo me ha mantenido muy distanciada de la historia. En el tramo final parece que remonta algo, pero para mí ya era tarde. Otra vez será con ella.
Leí People Like Us y me gustó mucho cómo Louise Fein escribió la relación entre un chico judío y una chica bien filonazi, así que no lo dudé al pedir su nuevo libro en Netgalley. Desde luego, lo de esta mujer son los temas complicados, ya que trata la epilepsia y la eugenesia mezclándolo en una misma familia, donde el padre es fiel defensor de esta filosofía que choca frontalmente con la epilepsia que sufre su hija. Por desgracia, he tenido serios problemas con el modo en el que está escrita la historia, en primera persona del presente pero de un modo extraño, con frases cortas, como muy deslavazado todo. No sé, a pesar de que estaba interesada en lo que ocurría, este modo de contarlo me ha mantenido muy distanciada de la historia. En el tramo final parece que remonta algo, pero para mí ya era tarde. Otra vez será con ella.
December 14, 2021
I appreciated this author's foray into the world of eugenics, which is once again rearing its ugly head in present-day politics. It may not be called by the same name, but there are still those who believe that a person with a disability cannot live a happy and fulfilled life; that children with disabilities should be aborted before they are even born, or at least hidden away in institutions where they cannot disturb the rest of the world with their difficult lives. My brother became disabled after an auto accident and was a tireless advocate for the rights of the disabled - recognizing the slippery slope that one steps on when believing that some people do not have lives worth living.
Eugenics - "The study or practice of attempting to improve the human gene pool by encouraging the reproduction of people considered to have desirable traits and discouraging or preventing the reproduction of people considered to have undesirable traits." Hitler was one of the most famous practitioners of eugenics, but many people don't realize that Margaret Sanger, founder of Planned Parenthood, was a huge fan of managing the reproduction of "undesirables".
So that brings me to this book - the story of a professor of eugenics in London between the world wars, and his beautiful wife, and their child Mabel. Mabel is the perfect child, and her parents are so proud of her - until she begins to have epileptic seizures out of the blue at age 4. Suddenly, her father Edward is anxious to have her put away in an institution, hidden away from anyone who might connect his "defective" child with his political ambitions. Her mother Eleanor is aghast and wants to do everything possible to save her child, but she gives in to her husband's pressure. Until she finds out that her husband has been keeping secrets from her. Her trust in him broken, she decides to go against his wishes and rescue her child from the horrors of the institution.
I didn't agree with or appreciate that several of the characters in this novel had very loose morals. But it didn't change the lessons of the story in my view.
Eugenics - "The study or practice of attempting to improve the human gene pool by encouraging the reproduction of people considered to have desirable traits and discouraging or preventing the reproduction of people considered to have undesirable traits." Hitler was one of the most famous practitioners of eugenics, but many people don't realize that Margaret Sanger, founder of Planned Parenthood, was a huge fan of managing the reproduction of "undesirables".
So that brings me to this book - the story of a professor of eugenics in London between the world wars, and his beautiful wife, and their child Mabel. Mabel is the perfect child, and her parents are so proud of her - until she begins to have epileptic seizures out of the blue at age 4. Suddenly, her father Edward is anxious to have her put away in an institution, hidden away from anyone who might connect his "defective" child with his political ambitions. Her mother Eleanor is aghast and wants to do everything possible to save her child, but she gives in to her husband's pressure. Until she finds out that her husband has been keeping secrets from her. Her trust in him broken, she decides to go against his wishes and rescue her child from the horrors of the institution.
I didn't agree with or appreciate that several of the characters in this novel had very loose morals. But it didn't change the lessons of the story in my view.
June 6, 2021
Another stunning book by Louise Fein! The Hamilton’s have a secret. Eleanor’s husband Edward is a pioneer in the eugenics movement leading up to WWII—powerful, smart, and revered. But when their daughter begins to show signs of epilepsy, their lives turn upside down. Now they must face the truth, and the consequences of his work as it gains notoriety. A captivating story with beautifully drawn characters and an intriguing plot—a must-read for historical fiction fans.
May 31, 2022
4.1
Edward is a rising star in the eugenics movement in 1920s England. Their stated goal is to better the human race and to have less crime and disease in the future. He is married to Eleanor, and they have a 4-year-old daughter Mabel.
Mabel begins to have seizures and is diagnosed with epilepsy. Epilepsy is considered shameful and something to be hidden. Mabel goes to a clinic where her condition worsens. Edward is concerned about appearances and is in denial about Mabel, partly due to current beliefs and partly because of his workaholic professional life.
Some chapters are narrated by “epilepsy.” I found this to be a unique approach! The other chapters alternate between narration by Edward and Eleanor.
To what lengths will a mother go to , to protect her child? Eleanor has a plan- what will happen with her plan?
What happened with Edward’s research data?
What happened to Edward when he was in battle during WWI? How does this continue to effect his life?
* A sad story at times— A happier ending that I expected!
* I really liked Fein’s Daughter of the Reich.
Edward is a rising star in the eugenics movement in 1920s England. Their stated goal is to better the human race and to have less crime and disease in the future. He is married to Eleanor, and they have a 4-year-old daughter Mabel.
Mabel begins to have seizures and is diagnosed with epilepsy. Epilepsy is considered shameful and something to be hidden. Mabel goes to a clinic where her condition worsens. Edward is concerned about appearances and is in denial about Mabel, partly due to current beliefs and partly because of his workaholic professional life.
Some chapters are narrated by “epilepsy.” I found this to be a unique approach! The other chapters alternate between narration by Edward and Eleanor.
To what lengths will a mother go to , to protect her child? Eleanor has a plan- what will happen with her plan?
What happened with Edward’s research data?
What happened to Edward when he was in battle during WWI? How does this continue to effect his life?
* A sad story at times— A happier ending that I expected!
* I really liked Fein’s Daughter of the Reich.
January 15, 2022
This is Historical Fiction that takes place between WWI and WWII in England. This one turned out to be different than what I thought it was going to be and that was a good thing. One of the MCs is a strong believer in the Eugenics movement that was gaining traction during that period of time. When he discovered that his young daughter was an epileptic, to avoid the shame of having others think he had bad genetics, he talks his wife into institutionalizing his daughter.
I liked where this one went. Eleanor was a strong female MC. I loved her mothering instincts. And her husband, the other MC, pretty much had the layers painfully peeled back showing the reader his soul.
I almost DNFd this one early on because I did not care for the narrator at all. I also didn't care that the disease had its own POV....that was weird. So 3 stars.
I liked where this one went. Eleanor was a strong female MC. I loved her mothering instincts. And her husband, the other MC, pretty much had the layers painfully peeled back showing the reader his soul.
I almost DNFd this one early on because I did not care for the narrator at all. I also didn't care that the disease had its own POV....that was weird. So 3 stars.
March 19, 2022
Well! Expected and unexpected. I had not anticipated learning so much about the eugenics movement within the pages of this historical fiction. Bravo. Apparently, and maybe as with many people, I always pointed fingers at the Nazi regime when assigning blame. Who knew the good old U.S.A. was complicit. I definitely recommend. And, as reiterated in its pages, we should remember, “The liberty of the individual should not be subjugated b the state.”
September 9, 2021
One novel you really don’t want to miss!
Eleanor and Edward Hamilton have a good life; war hero Edward is a proponent of the eugenics movement to rid society of the undesirable conditions which afflict so many. They are seeing their social status rise and the future is bright until their young daughter, Mabel, shown signs of epilepsy. Ever mindful of his studies and standing, Edward convinces his wife to agree to lock their daughter up, hiding her away from the ever watchful eyes of society; but there are secrets in the past which could do untold harm if they were ever to surface. Can they protect their family – or will the truth come out?
Before I refer to this book, I have to mention this author’s debut novel ‘People Like Us’ which was such an amazing read that it made me eager to read her follow up novel. This book is everything I expected – and so very much more. A fictional read, based on fact, this story has consumed me! Even when not actively reading, it has been on my mind and stays there even after completion. It is an incredibly breathtaking read which completely blew me away! Beautifully written, it at no time betrays the extensive research it must have taken and the immense skill involved in producing such a terrific read while incorporating the facts. I not only urge everyone to read this but to also absorb the author’s acknowledgements at the end – they are extremely interesting and informative. Louise Fein received many accolades following her first novel but I suspect these will be nowhere near the furore this one will create. She is not only an author to watch, she is one not to be missed.
I’m not entirely sure I even know enough superlatives to do this novel credit; suffice to say it is one of the most prodigiously stunning books it has ever been my good fortune to review. Five stars seem so insufficient, but they are all I have; however they are shining and sparkling so brightly they will dazzle you!
Eleanor and Edward Hamilton have a good life; war hero Edward is a proponent of the eugenics movement to rid society of the undesirable conditions which afflict so many. They are seeing their social status rise and the future is bright until their young daughter, Mabel, shown signs of epilepsy. Ever mindful of his studies and standing, Edward convinces his wife to agree to lock their daughter up, hiding her away from the ever watchful eyes of society; but there are secrets in the past which could do untold harm if they were ever to surface. Can they protect their family – or will the truth come out?
Before I refer to this book, I have to mention this author’s debut novel ‘People Like Us’ which was such an amazing read that it made me eager to read her follow up novel. This book is everything I expected – and so very much more. A fictional read, based on fact, this story has consumed me! Even when not actively reading, it has been on my mind and stays there even after completion. It is an incredibly breathtaking read which completely blew me away! Beautifully written, it at no time betrays the extensive research it must have taken and the immense skill involved in producing such a terrific read while incorporating the facts. I not only urge everyone to read this but to also absorb the author’s acknowledgements at the end – they are extremely interesting and informative. Louise Fein received many accolades following her first novel but I suspect these will be nowhere near the furore this one will create. She is not only an author to watch, she is one not to be missed.
I’m not entirely sure I even know enough superlatives to do this novel credit; suffice to say it is one of the most prodigiously stunning books it has ever been my good fortune to review. Five stars seem so insufficient, but they are all I have; however they are shining and sparkling so brightly they will dazzle you!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 705 reviews