My reaction to this book is tempered by the fact that it's not the type of book I normally read. Having said that, I recently saw Di Morrissey interviewed on ABC Breakfast and I found the interview interesting and she came across as charming, down to earth, and a writer whose work I believed it was time to check out. Thus, The Islands.
First comment: it's just too long. I can't understand why books have to be such great doorstoppers, as so many are, almost as though the author is telling three stories in one. Now, one thing I did really like is how much I learnt about the people of Hawaii and their feelings regarding the take-over of their country by the USA and their loss of sovereignty, right up to their modern day attitudes towards the US presence, and particularly the navy, in their islands. That is something that I had no knowledge or appreciation of, and so for me that is a huge bonus from reading this book. I suppose my main grumble about the book is the super quick, super fast way everything ties up so neatly at the end, and, I have to say, in a pretty predictable way. I think I knew on page 1 (or was it 2?) who Catherine would end up married to. I found that ending totally unsatisfying.
Now I've said all that, this is a book that I know many people will enjoy (am definitely passing it on to a couple of family members who will, I know, love it), and they will have the bonus of learning so much about Hawaii while doing so.