Normally when I go to write a book review, I try to think of everything I enjoyed and did not enjoy about the story I read. I try to write a fair review that expresses my opinion without spoiling the plot of the story too much.
Yet when I started to write this review, all I could think about was how sad I feel. With other stories, I finish them, reflect on them, and usually move on to the next story. I adore reading and actually get cranky when I have nothing to read. For the first time, I find myself very reluctant to move on. It must sound silly, but by putting down my Tintin collection, it feels like I am saying goodbye to a good friend.
I first heard of Tintin when I saw the cartoons on television as a youngster. When I heard about the Spielberg movie, I knew immediately I had to go see it. I think it was Mr. Spielberg's movie that convinced Egmont to publish the original comics in English. Shortly after, I bought the whole box set. It took me awhile to sit down and read through all of Tintin's adventures. Once I started I was hooked.
Since this is a comic book from the 40s, I tried to overlook things such as the racism, the lack of any noticeable female characters (other than Castafiore, who is very noticeable!) and the fact that everyone bows to a white man. Since it's a comic book, I could forgive the fact that out of all the people in the world, it's a young reporter from Brussels who can put a stop to many dangerous criminals and dastardly schemes.
What I could really not forgive was the very drawn out tangents that would happen in some of the stories. I think the time I found this particularly irritating was in The Broken Ear. I can understand the need to insert humour to even out the tension of a serious plot. I get boggled when Tintin is somehow forced into joining an army, simply because he managed to get drunk before one of his many scheduled executions. Then after he was done with the army, the plot managed to get back on course. By that point, the original plot felt like an afterthought. That was the worst instance of it, but there are other times it happens. I always find these instances a bit jarring.
The stories did get good as I kept reading. Where it seemed that Herge had used a tangent at first, everything would eventually come full circle to be connected again. I really enjoyed the stories that were fully connected like that, such as Cigars of the Pharaoh, The Blue Lotus, The Seven Crystal Balls, Prisoners of the Sun, Tintin in Tibet and Tintin and the Picaros. Once I started them I had to finish them since they were so tense and action-packed!
There are several characters in the Tintin series. For this review I decided to write about my favourite character, which is Tintin himself. I have heard complaints that Tintin has little to no personality. I think the reason it seems that way is because Tintin seems like an introvert. He does have plenty of personality, it's just when he's standing next to Captain Haddock or Professor Calculus, it's harder to see it.
In The Blue Lotus, he talks to Chang about racism, and how people have an idea that Chinese people have long fingernails and are quite mean. He also points out that people have these misconceptions because they simply don't know enough about each other. I doubt someone without a personality would say this. Even in Tintin in the Congo, even if the drawings themselves are racist, Tintin himself is not. He never says anything such as "filthy nigger" or something equally stupid. He has no problems becoming an important member of a tribe. He also had no problems becoming an officer in an army, or becoming involved with an Asian society. He even stops people from harassing an Indian child or from harassing a Chinese worker. Given the time period this was written in, this says a lot about Tintin's personality. He believes in what's fair, even if it goes against popular thinking.
He's frequently cross with Snowy since Snowy is prone to misbehaving. I would be pretty concerned if my own dog was a Whiskey lover. If Tintin was truly so bland, he would probably reprimand Snowy very briefly and be done with it. However, we see Tintin become quite cross on many occassions. Not just with Snowy, either. Tintin does get annoyed when people are being roundabout or bullheaded, and has even told people where to go on occasion.
He does not actively seek out friendships or people, yet he seems fine spending time with them when they come around. A very classic introvert. It's not that he never wants company or has no opinions, he just prefers to keep to himself unless it's necessary. This results in him appearing to not have much of a personality.
I think Tintin's quiet personality does allow for the other characters to bounce off him, though. I think one of the few times Tintin instigated a story was the one he debuted in, Land of the Soviets. After that story, it's usually the supporting characters that drag him into his adventures. Once Tintin gets into his adventures, he always sees them through with his courage and wits. Tintin does get into several fist fights, but it's usually his wit that saves the day.
Like any story, The Adventures of Tintin has its good points and bad points. The tangents can be random and a little annoying, however the really good stories and characters make up for them. The characters are developed enough to enjoy without taking away from the plot too much. Generally I prefer well developed characters interwoven into the plot. For the Adventures of Tintin, I think it works better that the characters are not always personally involved.
I definitely recommend this for fans of Sherlock Holmes and Indiana Jones, or stories similar to those. There is enough action to keep the action fans satisfied with enough character development to keep readers wanting to see more adventures. I will miss reading Tintin, since I have enjoyed watching him in his adventures, even the more annoying ones. For now I move on to other stories. I will definitely come back to read them all again one day, as will any existing and future lovers of the series.