This is what seems to be the first of many of Edgar Mittelholzer's preaching novels. This is Edgar Mittelholzer's fifth novel, and it is the first entirely set in England. The story takes place in the idyllic village of Middenshot, near the Broadmoor lunatic asylum. However, terror and horror lash the idyllic, village life when a serial killer escapes from the asylum and commits murder every night. As in many of his novels, there is a vast array of characters:
1. Mr. Jarrow, who has been mad for about 17 years since his car accident.
2. Mr. Jarrow's wife, whom Mr. Jarrow believes to be dead and with whom he only speaks at the séances he holds once a week.
3. Mr. Holme, an ex-policeman who grows orchids and who seems to be Edgar Mittelholzer in desguise
4. Grace, Mr. Jarrow's daughter, who dreams of a love life with Mr. Holme and away from her parents.
5. Hyacinth, Mr. Holme's housekeeper, who regards her rump as her shapeliest asset to win Mr. Holme's love.
6. North and Southerby, the detectives who address Edgar Mittelholzer's ever present ideas about crime and punishment.
As in many other of his novels, the weather plays an important role setting the mood not only for the place but also for the characters and the reader. In addition, as in many of his books, the battle between strength and weakness is one of his preaching arguments:
"Most people avoid the dreadful. Think only of what's pleasant. But the dreadful is always there, always simmering behind our backs, or beyond our blinkers, always waiting to surge into view... it's strength or weakness that counts in this life of ours. If you act with strength, you win out and you achieve worthwhile states of being. If you act with weakness, you lose and you suffer chaos and defeat."
My favorite parts of the novel have to do with Mr. Jarrow. His comical displays of madness and the amusing séances he holds to talk to his wife are some of the highlights of the novel. However, I am giving this book four instead of five stars because of Mittelholzer's blunt and tiresome preaching concerning his ideas about crime and punishment. These are present in other of his novels, such as "A Tinkling in the Twilight" and "The Piling of Clouds". These ideas can be summed up as: if human vermin (the serial killer in this novel) is exterminated from the very beginning, it will not cause any more trouble in the future (escaping and continue murdering) because there is no such as thing as "rehabilitating bad seeds". You are what you were born and your upbringing has nothing to do with your becoming a good or a bad person as you grow up: you are born either good or a bad, period.
Had Edgar Mittelholzer been more subtle about this topic, this would have been a five star book. Despite the preaching, I still deem it a great novel. It is out of print, but it deserves to be reissued.