During the American Revolution, British light infantry and grenadier battalions figured prominently in almost every battle and campaign. They are routinely mentioned in campaign studies, usually with no context to explain what these battalions were. In an army that employed regiments as the primary deployable assets, the most active battlefield elements were temporary battalions created after the war began and disbanded when it ended.
The Distinguished Corps: British Grenadier and Light Infantry Battalions in the American Revolution is the first operational study of these battalions during the entire war, looking at their creation, evolution and employment from the first day of hostilities through their disbandment at the end of the conflict. It examines how and why these battalions were created, how they were maintained at optimal strength over eight years of war, how they were deployed tactically and managed administratively. Most important, it looks at the individual officers and soldiers who served in them.
Using first-hand accounts and other primary sources, The Distinguished Corps describes life in the grenadiers and light infantry on a personal level, from Canada to the Caribbean and from barracks to battlefield.
Stuffed with information as per usual with Hagist’s books, but it’s difficult to love. Suffers the same problem as Noble Volunteers in that it is a straight A-B account with far too much quotation and not enough analysis. You never really get the author’s opinion about anything, which makes it a pretty boring read, in what should be an exciting subject (eg. See Matthew Spring’s “With Zeal and Bayonets Only” on how to enthuse the subject and thesis so brilliantly).
Besides that quibble, this IS a useful and comprehensive book, with an incredible appendix and bibliography that can only aid research into the topic of Light Infantry in the late 18th century. I may have moaned about the over use of quotation, but they are properly referenced ready for further reading.
The imprint itself is… what it is. I found the text pretty small (may get the ebook to zoom in a bit) and often over 75 characters per line which is hard on the eyes. Pictures and figures are well represented and footnotes are neat.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, could not put it down once I started. I usually prefer a bird’s eye military history that tracks the grand strategy of campaigns, but given the Grenadier and Light Foot battalions’ roles in the AWI, this book covers the whole conflict from the British perspective, since these units were at the forefront of almost every major action. My only disappointment was the lack of information about the Southern campaigns. Fair enough, the Grens and LF were only present together at the Siege of Charleston, and later the LF battalions were sent to support Cornwallis in Virginia, but these chapters were thin in comparison to earlier ones. Still, it was a great book with tons of information about the British experience of the war. I had assumed that these elite battalions would eventually get completely worn out, but I learned that the Grenadier and Light Foot companies were constantly replenished by receiving the best men from the line companies. I also learned more about how the British adapted their uniforms to North American service, as well as their tactics.
Hagist does a great job of bringing decades of research about the individual men and units of the British Army to bear on his text covering the makeup and activities of the flank battalions during the American Revolution.
As Marlburian warfare (early 1700s) gave way to Frederician warfare (mid 1700s), the Grenadier Company, a sub unit of the 6-12 company Battalion, became special forces of a sort- big men who could throw their hand bombs longer distances- but who were also called on for heavy job. As Frederick's linear warfare was developing into the Grande Armee Napoleonic style, a new special unit was added in the British army, among a few other militaries looking for an edge, the "Light" company. Where the Grenadiers were the elite fighters in formation, the new Light company was for throwing a skirmish line ahead and to the flanks of the Battalion, smaller, wiry fellows who could move at the double and be relied on to fight as small groups or individual(they were trusted to come back- desertion was a big part of 18tyh Century warfare.). Basic doctrine usually meant that these formations were at the command of the Battalion commander, but they could also be detached for various reasons. In the American Revolutionary War, British Expeditionary Commanders often chose to mass the Grenadier and Light companies from their line Battalions of Redcoats into Battalion size units- and use those as a sort of "special forces" - usually shock assignments for the Grenadiers and skirmishing/raiding for the "Lights". In this book, Number 80 in the "Reason to Revolution 1721-1815" series from Helion Books, Don Hagist, a writer on the period give us a survey of how this experimentation went in the AWI. It's a great way to tell the story of the British Army in North America, and covers almost every theatre of the war. The book is filled with b/w pics, maps, colour plates, diagrams and tables to support the narrative, in the publisher's style. It's a very interesting way to look at the AWI.
I first encountered this phenomenon as a Wargamer in the 1970s, playing Napoleonic games, and i learned what the Napoleonic generals and army developers learned- it's a great way of "Creating" "elite" units to use for special tasks- but it does also make ALL your battalions small, and less powerful- and one is really tempted to use the "special" units for all the heavy lifting- getting the "Line " soldiers less fit for battle. What the AWI experimentation really proved was the the contemporary army needed full battalions of Light Infantry- that did not involve taking units from other battalions. And that the Line Battalion's Colonel really needed his own Grenadiers and Light infantry companies for his own use- much as modern Battalion commander use their in-unit Mortars, Machine guns and Missiles- for added power when needed. Hagist shows us the whole experiment as tried in one conflict, although this was also being proved elsewhere in the period. I really enjoyed learning about this facet of the war.
There are only a few adult themes and graphic violence passages, so this is a fine book for a 11/12 year old Junior Reader with a historical bent. For the Gamer/Modeler/Military Enthusiast, the intended market- this book is very on point. The Gamer gets a lot of information for campaigns, scenarios, and army development, The modeler gets great information for building, painting, and diorama development. The Military Enthusiast gets a look at a clear experimentation period in warfare- where a 7 Years War army is morphing into a Napoleonic army - in the middle of fighting a war. I think the American Revolutionary War buff will also want to understand this facet as well. An interesting look at military doctrine in development.