What do you think?
Rate this book
The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood
You are invited underneath the great greenwood tree to hear how a young man became a hero, and a hero became a legend.
When Robin takes a shortcut through Sherwood Forest, the path he chooses leads not to Nottingham’s archery contest, but to a life on the run from the law. Unable now to become a knight and joined by his childhood friends, Robin Hood leads the most infamous outlaw band ever to evade the king and his sheriff.
Blending true history with new stories, popular inaccuracies, and some almost forgotten medieval legends, The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood brings a new life to the greenwood, which here feels as fresh as it does traditional. With an academic background in medieval English studies, A. E. Chandler captivates with this unique and nuanced reinterpretation of Robin Hood’s struggles and adventures. The forest is waiting.
This expanded second edition contains bonus material, including a translation of one of only five surviving medieval Robin Hood "ballads," two medieval recipes, and a historical note.
Narrated by British actor Joel Benedict, who also sings six original songs by the author, and plays a sixteenth century tune on the lute.
8.5 hours.
When Robin takes a shortcut through Sherwood Forest, the path he chooses leads not to Nottingham’s archery contest, but to a life on the run from the law. Unable now to become a knight and joined by his childhood friends, Robin Hood leads the most infamous outlaw band ever to evade the king and his sheriff.
Blending true history with new stories, popular inaccuracies, and some almost forgotten medieval legends, The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood brings a new life to the greenwood, which here feels as fresh as it does traditional. With an academic background in medieval English studies, A. E. Chandler captivates with this unique and nuanced reinterpretation of Robin Hood’s struggles and adventures. The forest is waiting.
This expanded second edition contains bonus material, including a translation of one of only five surviving medieval Robin Hood "ballads," two medieval recipes, and a historical note.
Narrated by British actor Joel Benedict, who also sings six original songs by the author, and plays a sixteenth century tune on the lute.
8.5 hours.
Audiobook
Published April 21, 2021
5 people are currently reading
894 people want to read
About the author
A.E. Chandler
5 books253 followersA. E. Chandler holds a Master of Arts with Merit from the University of Nottingham, where she wrote her dissertation on the social history behind Robin Hood. While earning a BA in Ancient and Medieval Studies at the University of Calgary, she also took courses in publishing and creative writing.
Chandler has had short stories, poetry, and articles published, in addition to a book of collected non-fiction entitled Into the World, the Questionable Quizzes series, and the bestselling novel The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood. To get exclusive bonus content, including the original 2nd chapter of The Scarlet Forest, visit Chandler's author website.
Living in England, and travelling in Europe, Asia, and Africa have also contributed to her stories and characters - she has been chased by a camel rider through the Sahara Desert, skated down a volcano in Sicily, and gotten unintentionally locked inside of a medieval prison in France. Currently, she lives in Calgary, where she is a visiting expert with the Glenbow Museum’s military collection, and writes historical fiction as well as contemporary fiction concerning history.
Chandler has had short stories, poetry, and articles published, in addition to a book of collected non-fiction entitled Into the World, the Questionable Quizzes series, and the bestselling novel The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood. To get exclusive bonus content, including the original 2nd chapter of The Scarlet Forest, visit Chandler's author website.
Living in England, and travelling in Europe, Asia, and Africa have also contributed to her stories and characters - she has been chased by a camel rider through the Sahara Desert, skated down a volcano in Sicily, and gotten unintentionally locked inside of a medieval prison in France. Currently, she lives in Calgary, where she is a visiting expert with the Glenbow Museum’s military collection, and writes historical fiction as well as contemporary fiction concerning history.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews
March 26, 2021
"Hold there, fair friend."
"Now listen thou to this fine tale Of love I sing to thee. For 'tis a pretty little tale, And hath sweet melody."
For me, Robin Hood has been one of the dearest characters of all time. I remember watching that 1984 TV Series many times when I was little, and that recall takes me back to those wonderful times even now. However, I haven't really thought of reading any books behind it. Consequently, when I was offered a copy of the book for an unbiased review, I jumped at the opportunity to read The Scarlet Forest, for I was keen to see how enjoyable it would be to re-live those memories after all this time. I know the 5-star rating already says it , but I'm thrilled to say this is far better than I had imagined. I loved every little bit of it! It was wonderful going back to Sherwood, after a long long time.
"I make it a custom to kiss the fairest lass at each contest - gives me good luck."
Story begins with the event that changes Robert Locksley's life to Robin Hood, and picks up from there. We do get several fun little flashbacks to the life before later on as we move forward. While the essence of Robin Hood's well-known traits are kept intact, the author recite the merry men's adventures in a most enjoyable manner, with careful attention to even the smallest of details. The world around Sherwood Forest and Nottinghamshire is created beautifully, giving one a very cozy feeling. Each chapter recounts a different adventure (with a couple of exceptions) and each one is equally entertaining. The main characters, including Lady Marian, Little John, Will Stutely, and Will Scarlet bring their own amusement to the story, introducing a nice bit of variety to the flow. There's no lack of humor as well.
"Sir Sheriff, if thou dost disobey mine orders but one time more, thine head shall be sent to France, whilst thy body remains in England."
There was a little bit of Romance as well, mainly related to Robin and Marian. Given the setting of the story, it wouldn't have come out well to have more than that. Being said that, I found 'that little bit' was effectively used by the author to properly convey the emotions between the two. But it's the bond between all members of the band that carries the most weight, even till the end. And speaking of the ending - which is obviously necessary for this to be a complete depiction - was tough to swallow. But it's not my place to spoil the book for future readers, so I'll stop at that.
"Love certainly softens one's brains, does it not?"
One thing I regret is not being able to truly appreciate the intricacy of contents. Each chapter was full of interesting little details, with the aim of delivering historically accurate information as much as possible. Had I been adequately knowledgeable in the background of legend of Robin Hood (aside from having watched the TV series, which I'm now convinced isn't that much), I would've enjoyed the book on an even deeper level. But, having read this, now I have a reference to measure my future reads on Robin Hood. Any fan of Robin Hood, or historical fiction for that matter, is going to love The Scarlet Forest.
"Master! Robin Hood come home!"
"Long live the greenwood."
*Thank you A.E. Chandler for providing a copy of the book for an unbiased review*
"Now listen thou to this fine tale Of love I sing to thee. For 'tis a pretty little tale, And hath sweet melody."
For me, Robin Hood has been one of the dearest characters of all time. I remember watching that 1984 TV Series many times when I was little, and that recall takes me back to those wonderful times even now. However, I haven't really thought of reading any books behind it. Consequently, when I was offered a copy of the book for an unbiased review, I jumped at the opportunity to read The Scarlet Forest, for I was keen to see how enjoyable it would be to re-live those memories after all this time. I know the 5-star rating already says it , but I'm thrilled to say this is far better than I had imagined. I loved every little bit of it! It was wonderful going back to Sherwood, after a long long time.
"I make it a custom to kiss the fairest lass at each contest - gives me good luck."
Story begins with the event that changes Robert Locksley's life to Robin Hood, and picks up from there. We do get several fun little flashbacks to the life before later on as we move forward. While the essence of Robin Hood's well-known traits are kept intact, the author recite the merry men's adventures in a most enjoyable manner, with careful attention to even the smallest of details. The world around Sherwood Forest and Nottinghamshire is created beautifully, giving one a very cozy feeling. Each chapter recounts a different adventure (with a couple of exceptions) and each one is equally entertaining. The main characters, including Lady Marian, Little John, Will Stutely, and Will Scarlet bring their own amusement to the story, introducing a nice bit of variety to the flow. There's no lack of humor as well.
"Sir Sheriff, if thou dost disobey mine orders but one time more, thine head shall be sent to France, whilst thy body remains in England."
There was a little bit of Romance as well, mainly related to Robin and Marian. Given the setting of the story, it wouldn't have come out well to have more than that. Being said that, I found 'that little bit' was effectively used by the author to properly convey the emotions between the two. But it's the bond between all members of the band that carries the most weight, even till the end. And speaking of the ending - which is obviously necessary for this to be a complete depiction - was tough to swallow. But it's not my place to spoil the book for future readers, so I'll stop at that.
"Love certainly softens one's brains, does it not?"
One thing I regret is not being able to truly appreciate the intricacy of contents. Each chapter was full of interesting little details, with the aim of delivering historically accurate information as much as possible. Had I been adequately knowledgeable in the background of legend of Robin Hood (aside from having watched the TV series, which I'm now convinced isn't that much), I would've enjoyed the book on an even deeper level. But, having read this, now I have a reference to measure my future reads on Robin Hood. Any fan of Robin Hood, or historical fiction for that matter, is going to love The Scarlet Forest.
"Master! Robin Hood come home!"
"Long live the greenwood."
*Thank you A.E. Chandler for providing a copy of the book for an unbiased review*
September 8, 2023
A Robin Hood Retelling
The Scarlet Forest is a mesmerizing retelling of the classic story of Robin Hood. From the first chapter, we discover Robin Hood and how he becomes an outlaw. The book touches on Robin Hood and his band of outlaws including Marian and Little John. This crew is at odds with the villainous Sheriff of Nottingham. How will things turn out for Robin Hood?
From the first chapter, I was blown away by the prose. The writing is very readable with sentences and paragraphs of an appropriate length. No page long paragraphs here. A.E. Chandler has an exquisite and varied vocabulary, and she has clearly done her research. The prose is polished that the story flowed so smoothly from the narrator.
Additionally, I was pleased that the action started from page one, and I do really love the story of Robin Hood, a great person who protected the poor and defenseless.
Now, there are a few things that I would change. Personally, I really enjoy a strong story arc, where we lead up to a major turning point. In The Scarlet Forest, each chapter could almost standalone. The book felt more like a compilation of short stories versus one continuous story arc.
Also, if I were editor of The Scarlet Forest, I would have trimmed this down. Recently, I was at Disneyland for a vacation, and this time, it was much different returning as a content creator and writer. There were two rides that I went on where I read the book first – Wendy and Peter (otherwise known as Peter Pan) and Winnie-the-Pooh. Both of these stories are just shy of 200 pages. However, The Scarlet Forest is just over 300 pages. Again, if I were editor, I would have trimmed some of the stories about Robin Hood’s men. I wanted to connect to Robin, and there were a couple of chapters that felt a bit repetitious (men pretending to be outlaws, men pretending to be someone else, men bragging about how awesome they are and daring Robin Hood to a contest).
Finally, as editor, I would consider modernizing the language a bit. There is no “you” but “thou” and “thine." Instead of someone saying something, they would “spake” or “quoth.”
Overall, The Scarlet Forest is a book that A.E. Chandler should be proud of and is an excellent retelling of Robin Hood.
*Thanks to A.E. Chandler for a free copy of this book in exchange for my fair and honest opinion. A.E. Chandler (yes I do know her real name but I’m not going to be that person) has been one of my biggest supporters. My sincerest thanks and gratitude!
Connect With Me!
Blog Twitter BookTube Facebook Insta
The Scarlet Forest is a mesmerizing retelling of the classic story of Robin Hood. From the first chapter, we discover Robin Hood and how he becomes an outlaw. The book touches on Robin Hood and his band of outlaws including Marian and Little John. This crew is at odds with the villainous Sheriff of Nottingham. How will things turn out for Robin Hood?
From the first chapter, I was blown away by the prose. The writing is very readable with sentences and paragraphs of an appropriate length. No page long paragraphs here. A.E. Chandler has an exquisite and varied vocabulary, and she has clearly done her research. The prose is polished that the story flowed so smoothly from the narrator.
Additionally, I was pleased that the action started from page one, and I do really love the story of Robin Hood, a great person who protected the poor and defenseless.
Now, there are a few things that I would change. Personally, I really enjoy a strong story arc, where we lead up to a major turning point. In The Scarlet Forest, each chapter could almost standalone. The book felt more like a compilation of short stories versus one continuous story arc.
Also, if I were editor of The Scarlet Forest, I would have trimmed this down. Recently, I was at Disneyland for a vacation, and this time, it was much different returning as a content creator and writer. There were two rides that I went on where I read the book first – Wendy and Peter (otherwise known as Peter Pan) and Winnie-the-Pooh. Both of these stories are just shy of 200 pages. However, The Scarlet Forest is just over 300 pages. Again, if I were editor, I would have trimmed some of the stories about Robin Hood’s men. I wanted to connect to Robin, and there were a couple of chapters that felt a bit repetitious (men pretending to be outlaws, men pretending to be someone else, men bragging about how awesome they are and daring Robin Hood to a contest).
Finally, as editor, I would consider modernizing the language a bit. There is no “you” but “thou” and “thine." Instead of someone saying something, they would “spake” or “quoth.”
Overall, The Scarlet Forest is a book that A.E. Chandler should be proud of and is an excellent retelling of Robin Hood.
*Thanks to A.E. Chandler for a free copy of this book in exchange for my fair and honest opinion. A.E. Chandler (yes I do know her real name but I’m not going to be that person) has been one of my biggest supporters. My sincerest thanks and gratitude!
Connect With Me!
Blog Twitter BookTube Facebook Insta
April 3, 2021
*4.5 stars *
It’s clear that the author has extensive knowledge of her subject, given that she holds an MA with Merit from the University of Nottingham, where she wrote her dissertation on the social history behind Robin Hood.
Everything you ever wanted to know about the legend and lore of Robin Hood and his band of Merry Men is to be discovered in The Scarlet Forest - how the band of outlaws was formed, the daily workings of life in the camp in beautiful Sherwood Forest, the sumptuous feasts, the robbing of the rich to pay the poor, the deep and enduring love between Robin and Maid Marion (aka Anne), yet ever mindful that this band of outlaws had to be on their guard at all times, given the price on their heads, and some of those heads (including Robin’s) came very close to a public hanging at times.
To have the ability to transport the reader to medieval times, creating vivid scenes and events, requires extensive research and great skill, so that one experiences the feeling of actually being there, of connecting with the characters, joining them round the camp fire, becoming truly involved in their lives and adventures. A.E. Chandler has those skills in abundance. Such an interesting, exciting and enjoyable read. A wonderful story, wonderfully told!
* Thank you to A.E. Chandler for a digital copy of The Scarlet Forest, for which I have given an honest unbiased review *
It’s clear that the author has extensive knowledge of her subject, given that she holds an MA with Merit from the University of Nottingham, where she wrote her dissertation on the social history behind Robin Hood.
Everything you ever wanted to know about the legend and lore of Robin Hood and his band of Merry Men is to be discovered in The Scarlet Forest - how the band of outlaws was formed, the daily workings of life in the camp in beautiful Sherwood Forest, the sumptuous feasts, the robbing of the rich to pay the poor, the deep and enduring love between Robin and Maid Marion (aka Anne), yet ever mindful that this band of outlaws had to be on their guard at all times, given the price on their heads, and some of those heads (including Robin’s) came very close to a public hanging at times.
To have the ability to transport the reader to medieval times, creating vivid scenes and events, requires extensive research and great skill, so that one experiences the feeling of actually being there, of connecting with the characters, joining them round the camp fire, becoming truly involved in their lives and adventures. A.E. Chandler has those skills in abundance. Such an interesting, exciting and enjoyable read. A wonderful story, wonderfully told!
* Thank you to A.E. Chandler for a digital copy of The Scarlet Forest, for which I have given an honest unbiased review *
November 8, 2021
The legend of Robin Hood has a fresh retelling in A. E. Chandler’s offering THE SCARLET FOREST: A TALE OF ROBIN HOOD. Many stories of Robin’s adventures and the “making” of his Sherwood Forest’s compatriot outlaws are brilliantly pieced together to present us with a wonderous work of historical fiction.
For all the "good" that Robin and his men do, they continue to vex the Sheriff of Nottingham and his group of law enforcers by getting the better of them seemingly at every turn. The Sheriff is the perfect foil for Robin and his merry band.
As a child, the legend of Robin Hood was my favorite book. And, I can’t fathom a guess at how many times I watched the movie with Errol Flynn as Robin. To be reintroduced to him via Chandler’s book was captivating. THE SCARLET FOREST fleshes out each character so fully one feels present and witness to all.
I rate this a 5 star read and invite all lovers of historical fiction and adventure to read this book and enjoy every moment of it.
For all the "good" that Robin and his men do, they continue to vex the Sheriff of Nottingham and his group of law enforcers by getting the better of them seemingly at every turn. The Sheriff is the perfect foil for Robin and his merry band.
As a child, the legend of Robin Hood was my favorite book. And, I can’t fathom a guess at how many times I watched the movie with Errol Flynn as Robin. To be reintroduced to him via Chandler’s book was captivating. THE SCARLET FOREST fleshes out each character so fully one feels present and witness to all.
I rate this a 5 star read and invite all lovers of historical fiction and adventure to read this book and enjoy every moment of it.
August 15, 2022
Why I chose to read this book:
1. GR friend, Tharindu, recommended this book to me a year ago. Since I knew a little bit about Robin Hood (but not a whole lot), I accepted this recommendation and purchased a hard copy for myself; and,
2. August is my self-proclaimed "As the Spirit Moves Me Month".
Praises:
1. right from the start, I loved the authentic vocabulary and dialogue. Even though it was so true to the time of medieval England, I could easily follow along. Nothing drives me crazier than reading ancient historical fiction that sounds like modern-day lingo;
2. each perfect-length chapter reads like a different adventure story with occasional storytelling, arm-to-arm combat and comedic scenes mixed in. I was captivated while reading each chapter and would look forward to the next adventure;
3. true that this book is generally plot-driven, but author A.E. Chandler has developed some characters very well! Marian (aka Anne) is no damsel-in-distress. Her "girl power" persona commanded respect from everyone! And although Robin comes across as a brave, clever, chivalrous, incorrigible rascal who often pushes his luck, our hero is sometimes portrayed as quite vulnerable in his beliefs and actions with others. I never thought that the story of Robin Hood would make me cry, but Robin's repentance at a local parish moved me to tears! and,
4. Chandler has also included a "Historical Note" (which begs the question, "Did Robin Hood really exist or not?"), a "Select Bibliography", a popular ballad, recipes, book club questions, and a most useful "Glossary".
Niggles: Can't think of any! 😊
Overall Thoughts:
Chandler has done her homework! Literally! As a graduate student at the University of Nottingham, she did her dissertation on the legendary Robin Hood. Through her extensive research, her book The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood is a wonderful retelling of this fascinating character!
Recommendation?
A great book for fans of Robin Hood or for anyone (like me) who is interested in reading about the legendary hero who stole from the rich and gave to the poor.
Thank you so much, Tharindu, for the recommendation!
1. GR friend, Tharindu, recommended this book to me a year ago. Since I knew a little bit about Robin Hood (but not a whole lot), I accepted this recommendation and purchased a hard copy for myself; and,
2. August is my self-proclaimed "As the Spirit Moves Me Month".
Praises:
1. right from the start, I loved the authentic vocabulary and dialogue. Even though it was so true to the time of medieval England, I could easily follow along. Nothing drives me crazier than reading ancient historical fiction that sounds like modern-day lingo;
2. each perfect-length chapter reads like a different adventure story with occasional storytelling, arm-to-arm combat and comedic scenes mixed in. I was captivated while reading each chapter and would look forward to the next adventure;
3. true that this book is generally plot-driven, but author A.E. Chandler has developed some characters very well! Marian (aka Anne) is no damsel-in-distress. Her "girl power" persona commanded respect from everyone! And although Robin comes across as a brave, clever, chivalrous, incorrigible rascal who often pushes his luck, our hero is sometimes portrayed as quite vulnerable in his beliefs and actions with others. I never thought that the story of Robin Hood would make me cry, but Robin's repentance at a local parish moved me to tears! and,
4. Chandler has also included a "Historical Note" (which begs the question, "Did Robin Hood really exist or not?"), a "Select Bibliography", a popular ballad, recipes, book club questions, and a most useful "Glossary".
Niggles: Can't think of any! 😊
Overall Thoughts:
Chandler has done her homework! Literally! As a graduate student at the University of Nottingham, she did her dissertation on the legendary Robin Hood. Through her extensive research, her book The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood is a wonderful retelling of this fascinating character!
Recommendation?
A great book for fans of Robin Hood or for anyone (like me) who is interested in reading about the legendary hero who stole from the rich and gave to the poor.
Thank you so much, Tharindu, for the recommendation!
September 17, 2022
The Scarlet forest: a tale of Robin Hood by A.E. Chandler is a retelling of Robin Hood as a major character, who is staying in the woods and robs the rich and gives to the less fortunate. Robin is a clear leader and with his company are outlaws. There is a price on Robin's life and he should be hanged. However, the vagabond pals do robberies not even thinking to stop.
I started this book by reading a written copy in PDF, it is not the most convenient way to read, I've read one-third of the book. Then I switched to the Audible audio version beautifully narrated by Joel Benedict. It was nice listening while on walks with my dog.
Thank you, A. E. Chandler provided copies of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I started this book by reading a written copy in PDF, it is not the most convenient way to read, I've read one-third of the book. Then I switched to the Audible audio version beautifully narrated by Joel Benedict. It was nice listening while on walks with my dog.
Thank you, A. E. Chandler provided copies of this book in exchange for an honest review.
December 8, 2025
This wonderful book is an amazing retelling of Robin Hood and his heroic exploits as an outlaw of myth.
Historical details have been thoroughly researched, mostly obtained at the University of Nottingham, coincidence???, thus giving her great knowledge about this subject and this same subject has been finally brought to life exceptionally well by the author.
At the end of the book, you'll notice very well documented historical details, as well as a Glossary list, and some other very fine explanations.
Storytelling is absolutely wonderful, even the Old English bits, not to forget the legend and lore of Robin Hood and his Merry Men come very much to the forefront, and ultimately the greedy dealings and hard and brutal atmosphere of England during the Reign of King Henry III and Queen Eleanor in the 13th Century are beautifully pictured and described.
This tale is set in the later part of the 13th Century, 1260s and 1270s, and it starts off with Robin Hood, aka Robert, from being a noble son into becoming an outlaw due to some disagreements and misunderstandings with some foresters, and from then on, his lonely path will be filled with men, such as the likes of Little John, Will Scarlet, Will Stutely, Much and Friar Tuck and others, and lastly not to forget his love, Maid Marian, aka Anna, and they will all become the outlaws of Barnsdale and Sherwood Forest, and all the time being hunted by the Sheriff of Nottingham and King Henry III.
What is to follow as a whole is a fascinating tale about Robin Hood and his Merry men that is told in a truly amazing fashion by the author, and that will certainly set alight each human heart that is filled with mischief adventure but that is also shared with terms like, honesty, courteous, courage and justice.
Very much recommended to anyone who loves the myth of a heroic Robin Hood, and his exploits as King of Sherwood Forest and Barnsdale, and that's why I like to call this book: "A Legendary Robin Hood"!
**Thank you to the author for a digital copy of "The Scarlet Forest", for which I've given an unbiased and honest review.**
Historical details have been thoroughly researched, mostly obtained at the University of Nottingham, coincidence???, thus giving her great knowledge about this subject and this same subject has been finally brought to life exceptionally well by the author.
At the end of the book, you'll notice very well documented historical details, as well as a Glossary list, and some other very fine explanations.
Storytelling is absolutely wonderful, even the Old English bits, not to forget the legend and lore of Robin Hood and his Merry Men come very much to the forefront, and ultimately the greedy dealings and hard and brutal atmosphere of England during the Reign of King Henry III and Queen Eleanor in the 13th Century are beautifully pictured and described.
This tale is set in the later part of the 13th Century, 1260s and 1270s, and it starts off with Robin Hood, aka Robert, from being a noble son into becoming an outlaw due to some disagreements and misunderstandings with some foresters, and from then on, his lonely path will be filled with men, such as the likes of Little John, Will Scarlet, Will Stutely, Much and Friar Tuck and others, and lastly not to forget his love, Maid Marian, aka Anna, and they will all become the outlaws of Barnsdale and Sherwood Forest, and all the time being hunted by the Sheriff of Nottingham and King Henry III.
What is to follow as a whole is a fascinating tale about Robin Hood and his Merry men that is told in a truly amazing fashion by the author, and that will certainly set alight each human heart that is filled with mischief adventure but that is also shared with terms like, honesty, courteous, courage and justice.
Very much recommended to anyone who loves the myth of a heroic Robin Hood, and his exploits as King of Sherwood Forest and Barnsdale, and that's why I like to call this book: "A Legendary Robin Hood"!
**Thank you to the author for a digital copy of "The Scarlet Forest", for which I've given an unbiased and honest review.**
February 23, 2022
The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood (2nd ed.)
by A. E. Chandler is the tale of Robert, second son of the Earl of Huntington, who becomes Robin o’ the Hood or Robin Hood. The author blends history, myth, legends, and her own stories in a fascinating tale of Robin Hood’s adventures, misadventures, struggles, and successes. On his way to an archery contest, Robert takes a shortcut through Sherwood Forest that would change his life and those of his friends.
Robin Hood is generally a likeable character with depth, but he has character flaws that does not allow for others taunting him and causing him to prove himself even as a young lad. He also is one that believes those that can should help those in need versus keeping all of their wealth for themselves. As one would expect, there is a love interest in Marian Fitzwalter, and a nemeses in the Sheriff of Nottingham. Wide varieties of characters play roles in the ensuing story and provide the necessary support or conflict.
An intriguing opening pulls the reader in. The prose was unique, and, once this reader got used to the cadence and language, it became compulsively readable. Despite being fast-paced with plenty of action interspersed with some time to get to know the main characters, it is also vividly descriptive without slowing down the pace. The ending is dramatic, with lots of tension.
Overall, this was an enjoyable and entertaining read. Themes include corruption, jealousy, love, friendship, trust, helping those in need, and much more. The historical note at the end of the book is highly enlightening. I am looking forward to reading more books by this author. If the above sounds like something you would enjoy, then I recommend that you check it out.
Thanks to the author for a complimentary copy of this novel and the opportunity to read and provide an honest review. Opinions are mine alone and are not biased in any way. The publication date was July 24, 2020.
Robin Hood is generally a likeable character with depth, but he has character flaws that does not allow for others taunting him and causing him to prove himself even as a young lad. He also is one that believes those that can should help those in need versus keeping all of their wealth for themselves. As one would expect, there is a love interest in Marian Fitzwalter, and a nemeses in the Sheriff of Nottingham. Wide varieties of characters play roles in the ensuing story and provide the necessary support or conflict.
An intriguing opening pulls the reader in. The prose was unique, and, once this reader got used to the cadence and language, it became compulsively readable. Despite being fast-paced with plenty of action interspersed with some time to get to know the main characters, it is also vividly descriptive without slowing down the pace. The ending is dramatic, with lots of tension.
Overall, this was an enjoyable and entertaining read. Themes include corruption, jealousy, love, friendship, trust, helping those in need, and much more. The historical note at the end of the book is highly enlightening. I am looking forward to reading more books by this author. If the above sounds like something you would enjoy, then I recommend that you check it out.
Thanks to the author for a complimentary copy of this novel and the opportunity to read and provide an honest review. Opinions are mine alone and are not biased in any way. The publication date was July 24, 2020.
April 19, 2021
This wasn’t the Robin Hood of my childhood.
The truth is, I don’t remember much from the story except “Rob from the rich and give to the poor” and that Robin Hood and his crew lived in Sherwood forest. I was thinly educated so I was interested in expanding my knowledge and I appreciate the author for sending me an e-galley to read.
Robin Hood, his right hand man Little John (who isn’t so little), and Marian’s adventures with their band of outcasts are detailed with a keen eye for the customs of the era. They duel with swords and wits to survive and level the playing field between greedy landlords and the nefarious Sheriff of Nottingham.
I was reminded of how brutal people were not so long ago. Those condemned to die for their crimes often suffered slow torturous deaths by design. Amusement came in the form of abusing others and causing pain. I sometimes shy away from reading accounts of these types of events but history isn’t often pretty. However even with the many feuds, there's restraint in the telling for those sensitive to gore (which I sometimes am).
I really enjoyed this beyond just the story. The research is evident regarding customs and language and I especially liked the dialog with mid century English colloquialisms and idioms.There is additional information at the back of the book not included in the prose which I found interesting.
Overall, there is a sense of goodwill and I loved learning more about Robin Hood’s life.
Thank you to the author A.E. Chandler for the opportunity to read this.
The truth is, I don’t remember much from the story except “Rob from the rich and give to the poor” and that Robin Hood and his crew lived in Sherwood forest. I was thinly educated so I was interested in expanding my knowledge and I appreciate the author for sending me an e-galley to read.
Robin Hood, his right hand man Little John (who isn’t so little), and Marian’s adventures with their band of outcasts are detailed with a keen eye for the customs of the era. They duel with swords and wits to survive and level the playing field between greedy landlords and the nefarious Sheriff of Nottingham.
I was reminded of how brutal people were not so long ago. Those condemned to die for their crimes often suffered slow torturous deaths by design. Amusement came in the form of abusing others and causing pain. I sometimes shy away from reading accounts of these types of events but history isn’t often pretty. However even with the many feuds, there's restraint in the telling for those sensitive to gore (which I sometimes am).
I really enjoyed this beyond just the story. The research is evident regarding customs and language and I especially liked the dialog with mid century English colloquialisms and idioms.There is additional information at the back of the book not included in the prose which I found interesting.
Overall, there is a sense of goodwill and I loved learning more about Robin Hood’s life.
Thank you to the author A.E. Chandler for the opportunity to read this.
May 29, 2022
5 Stars for The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood 2nd ed. ebook Scribd by A. E. Chandler.
This was a wonderful set of stories spanning the life of Robin Hood. Most are the author’s retelling with some new stories mixed in. The author’s passion and dedication to this subject is quite apparent in the writing.
This was a wonderful set of stories spanning the life of Robin Hood. Most are the author’s retelling with some new stories mixed in. The author’s passion and dedication to this subject is quite apparent in the writing.
September 8, 2021
I read this book as a new fan to Robin Hood. I would always mean to look more into him or watch movies about him but I just never got around to it. And after reading this, I feel like I've been missing out on a lot!
I love this character! He's charismatic, brave, strong and I think above all else: a gentlemen. He doesn't just steal from the corrupt and give to the poor for sport. He truly does it to protect those who can't defend themselves. He always knows what to do and there are some touching and intense moments from this book that will always stick with me from now on and that's what I love to see from my favourite stories! There are moments when Robin and his gang would reminiscent about the old days together and there's just this wave of nostalgia that would come over me every time they did. I would feel like I was really there with them, doing everything they did. Seeing everything they saw. That's a powerful feeling to have from a story! Also, I couldn't get enough of his companions! He truly couldn't have become the man he was without them. Marian was a perfect match for Robin Hood! She was strong and beautiful! This is a couple that I will always remember.
There's a good mix of action, comedy, romance and it's got its dark moments too! If you're new to Robin Hood, I think this would be a perfect place to start! It was for me!
June 28, 2022
A hero for all time
The myths and legends of Robin Hood in modern retelling along with some new stories. Not rewritten for realism but unabashedly preserving the flavor of the old legends. Reminded me of Richard Green in the 1950's television series which we watched avidly on Saturday mornings.
The myths and legends of Robin Hood in modern retelling along with some new stories. Not rewritten for realism but unabashedly preserving the flavor of the old legends. Reminded me of Richard Green in the 1950's television series which we watched avidly on Saturday mornings.
November 6, 2021
4.5 stars
Perhaps you've missed me but I've been to Sherwood Forest and the 13th century for a while to stay with Robin Hood and his band of outlaws.
The legend was well researched and explained, I loved it!
Perhaps you've missed me but I've been to Sherwood Forest and the 13th century for a while to stay with Robin Hood and his band of outlaws.
The legend was well researched and explained, I loved it!
March 10, 2021
The Scarlet Forest is an excellent new collection of Robin Hood tales. In some ways, Robin, Marian and their band of Merry Men have evolved over the centuries just as the balladeers’ Middle-English, a mixture of Anglo-Saxon and Norman French, has transformed into the modern vernacular. However, one major theme of the old tales remains consistent in the re-telling: Robin Hood, the outlaw, enforces the law when corrupt officials, of both the state and the church, fail to do so.
The Robin Hood stories take satirical jabs at the malfeasance of officials, as well as those crafty individuals, both lay and clergy who hide behind a cloak of respectability while engaging in nefarious practices.
Here’s just one example of law enforcement, Robin Hood style; Robin’s encounter with a Corn Engrosser. The ancient legal term is defined as follows: “Engrossing and the kindred practices of forestalling and regrating were early regarded as serious offences in restraint of trade, and were punishable both at common law and by statute. They were of more particular importance in relation to the distribution of corn supplies.”
Robin, disguised as a beggar, meets up with a corn engrosser on the highway near Sherwood. He (Robin in disguise) warns the man of Robin Hood’s dislike for the prohibited trade:
“Dost thou not know his (Robin’s) dislike for thine? To raise the price of corn by withholding it until famine prices are reached is depraved. Only profit concernest thee.”
Robin tricks the engrosser into disclosing where he hides his money; Robin then reveals his true identity and “enforces the law” by confiscating the ill-gotten gains. Likewise, Robin and his band enforce the Forest Law including how much timber might be taken, by whom and for what purpose. Those who despoil Sherwood for their own personal gain had better be on the lookout for Robin Hood.
My first impression of Robin Hood was formed by movies and television, for example the 1938 Errol Flynn Adventures of Robin Hood and the 1950’s TV series with Richard Greene. The 20th century cinematic Robin Hood was itself partially derived from 19th century literature that had its roots in Sir Walter Scott’s Ivanhoe. Scott’s Robin of Locksley varies somewhat from the bawdier and more roguish, satirical character of Lancastrian and Yorkist era ballads and Tudor plays that were taken from an oral tradition that goes back to the Plantagenet Period. Moreover, the usurping Prince John versus Richard I, Norman versus Saxon plot is a modern addition to the Robin Hood legend. Regardless, throughout the centuries the concept of the honorable law-enforcing outlaw hero remains.
In the following passage from The Scarlet Forest, Anne/Marian affirms her husband’s true character: “Robin, thou art the outlaw who doth sit here defending the rule of the society that hath cast thee out, as hath been ever thy wont. Thou art the criminal who doth uphold justice better than the Sheriff. Thou art the robber who can be more generous than the gentry. Thou art the excommunicant who doth show more devotion than the clergy.”
The Scarlet Forest was very well-researched. It contains a comprehensive Historical Note that answers many questions I’ve had about the Robin Hood stories, or explains why some of the questions can’t be answered with certainty. I won’t wander too deep into the weeds—or the forest—about the multitude of interesting subjects raised by these tales that are addressed in the Note. Here are a few puzzling questions that the Note answers or explains. Was there an historical Robin Hood? Was he noble or common? What was his “real” name? When did he live? Was there an historical Marian (or Anne of the Hood)? Were Robin and Marian married? What about the Merry Men: Little John, Will Stutely, Will Scarlet (Gamewell), Arthur a Bland, Allan a Dale, Midge or Much the Miller, Friar Tuck et. al. Are they historical or fictional; individuals or composites? How do the Robin Hood stories relate to the history of the long bow?
In addition, the stories tell us something about the evolution of English law and government including the Forest Law, Magna Carta and the conflict between Church and State. There’s enough “meat” on the bones of these medieval stories for several of Robin’s feasts.
The Robin Hood stories can be analyzed to an extent far beyond the scope of my review. For example, taken as a whole, the arc of Robin’s story makes him arguably one of the great Tragic Heroes of English literature. However, to put it more simply, I like the adventure, humor, friendship, honor and romance of characters who fight for justice in an authentic historical setting, which is why I recommend this well-written, thoroughly researched and thoughtful version to readers of all ages.
The Robin Hood stories take satirical jabs at the malfeasance of officials, as well as those crafty individuals, both lay and clergy who hide behind a cloak of respectability while engaging in nefarious practices.
Here’s just one example of law enforcement, Robin Hood style; Robin’s encounter with a Corn Engrosser. The ancient legal term is defined as follows: “Engrossing and the kindred practices of forestalling and regrating were early regarded as serious offences in restraint of trade, and were punishable both at common law and by statute. They were of more particular importance in relation to the distribution of corn supplies.”
Robin, disguised as a beggar, meets up with a corn engrosser on the highway near Sherwood. He (Robin in disguise) warns the man of Robin Hood’s dislike for the prohibited trade:
“Dost thou not know his (Robin’s) dislike for thine? To raise the price of corn by withholding it until famine prices are reached is depraved. Only profit concernest thee.”
Robin tricks the engrosser into disclosing where he hides his money; Robin then reveals his true identity and “enforces the law” by confiscating the ill-gotten gains. Likewise, Robin and his band enforce the Forest Law including how much timber might be taken, by whom and for what purpose. Those who despoil Sherwood for their own personal gain had better be on the lookout for Robin Hood.
My first impression of Robin Hood was formed by movies and television, for example the 1938 Errol Flynn Adventures of Robin Hood and the 1950’s TV series with Richard Greene. The 20th century cinematic Robin Hood was itself partially derived from 19th century literature that had its roots in Sir Walter Scott’s Ivanhoe. Scott’s Robin of Locksley varies somewhat from the bawdier and more roguish, satirical character of Lancastrian and Yorkist era ballads and Tudor plays that were taken from an oral tradition that goes back to the Plantagenet Period. Moreover, the usurping Prince John versus Richard I, Norman versus Saxon plot is a modern addition to the Robin Hood legend. Regardless, throughout the centuries the concept of the honorable law-enforcing outlaw hero remains.
In the following passage from The Scarlet Forest, Anne/Marian affirms her husband’s true character: “Robin, thou art the outlaw who doth sit here defending the rule of the society that hath cast thee out, as hath been ever thy wont. Thou art the criminal who doth uphold justice better than the Sheriff. Thou art the robber who can be more generous than the gentry. Thou art the excommunicant who doth show more devotion than the clergy.”
The Scarlet Forest was very well-researched. It contains a comprehensive Historical Note that answers many questions I’ve had about the Robin Hood stories, or explains why some of the questions can’t be answered with certainty. I won’t wander too deep into the weeds—or the forest—about the multitude of interesting subjects raised by these tales that are addressed in the Note. Here are a few puzzling questions that the Note answers or explains. Was there an historical Robin Hood? Was he noble or common? What was his “real” name? When did he live? Was there an historical Marian (or Anne of the Hood)? Were Robin and Marian married? What about the Merry Men: Little John, Will Stutely, Will Scarlet (Gamewell), Arthur a Bland, Allan a Dale, Midge or Much the Miller, Friar Tuck et. al. Are they historical or fictional; individuals or composites? How do the Robin Hood stories relate to the history of the long bow?
In addition, the stories tell us something about the evolution of English law and government including the Forest Law, Magna Carta and the conflict between Church and State. There’s enough “meat” on the bones of these medieval stories for several of Robin’s feasts.
The Robin Hood stories can be analyzed to an extent far beyond the scope of my review. For example, taken as a whole, the arc of Robin’s story makes him arguably one of the great Tragic Heroes of English literature. However, to put it more simply, I like the adventure, humor, friendship, honor and romance of characters who fight for justice in an authentic historical setting, which is why I recommend this well-written, thoroughly researched and thoughtful version to readers of all ages.
April 6, 2022
I’ve been a fan of Robin Hood books and movies ever since I was a kid and watched the Adventures of Robin Hood series, staring Richard Greene, religiously on TV. I also have several Robin Hood novels on my bookshelf and added A. E. Chandler’s The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood to my collection.
Chandler’s book consists of various Robin Hood tales. Some are traditional ones while others are new ones. All are delightful. They describe how Robin became an outlaw, his various exploits, and finally his death. Some of them I’ve read before in other versions, but others are new—at least to me. Chandler pulls you right into the stories, and writes in a style that mimics the way people wrote and spoke during Robin Hood’s time in the 13th century.
Chandler knows what she’s writing about because she received her M.A. degree from the University of Nottingham and wrote her dissertation about the social history of Robin Hood’s time. So it’s no wonder that the stories in her book reflect those problems: the difficulty of everyday existence for the lower class, the injustice of the justice system, the corruption of the clergy, and how people had to break the law by to put food on their table.
All in all, this is a wonderful book by a talented writer.
Chandler’s book consists of various Robin Hood tales. Some are traditional ones while others are new ones. All are delightful. They describe how Robin became an outlaw, his various exploits, and finally his death. Some of them I’ve read before in other versions, but others are new—at least to me. Chandler pulls you right into the stories, and writes in a style that mimics the way people wrote and spoke during Robin Hood’s time in the 13th century.
Chandler knows what she’s writing about because she received her M.A. degree from the University of Nottingham and wrote her dissertation about the social history of Robin Hood’s time. So it’s no wonder that the stories in her book reflect those problems: the difficulty of everyday existence for the lower class, the injustice of the justice system, the corruption of the clergy, and how people had to break the law by to put food on their table.
All in all, this is a wonderful book by a talented writer.
January 28, 2023
an astonishing retelling in the olde voice
🏹 🌳 Ms. Chandler offers us a retelling of the famous tale blending legend with what facts can be found. She does it all with classic charm, giving us the flavor of the olde English, and maintaining that flow consistently and with the right amount of pith. It’s sheer delight and stirred the heart of the young man within still wending his way through life’s Greenwood with yew wood in hand - perhaps with enough draw weight on the bow to pierce armor if he has the strength. She is a wonderful storyteller and brought me to dreaming.
🏹 🌳 I’ve been to Old Forest. Without knowing it. At first. And camped there. That was indeed magick all. However the Sheriff of Nottingham found me among the long trailing mosses, German Shepherd on leash. But he was a better manner of Sheriff than in the legend because he only wanted me to avoid a naked flame, then left me there in the ancient Greenwood to fancy my fancies and lie there alive among the old (still speaking) oaks.
🏹🌳Ms. Chandler has done some wonderful writing here. It’s green rich indeed.
🏹 🌳 Ms. Chandler offers us a retelling of the famous tale blending legend with what facts can be found. She does it all with classic charm, giving us the flavor of the olde English, and maintaining that flow consistently and with the right amount of pith. It’s sheer delight and stirred the heart of the young man within still wending his way through life’s Greenwood with yew wood in hand - perhaps with enough draw weight on the bow to pierce armor if he has the strength. She is a wonderful storyteller and brought me to dreaming.
🏹 🌳 I’ve been to Old Forest. Without knowing it. At first. And camped there. That was indeed magick all. However the Sheriff of Nottingham found me among the long trailing mosses, German Shepherd on leash. But he was a better manner of Sheriff than in the legend because he only wanted me to avoid a naked flame, then left me there in the ancient Greenwood to fancy my fancies and lie there alive among the old (still speaking) oaks.
🏹🌳Ms. Chandler has done some wonderful writing here. It’s green rich indeed.
August 21, 2024
A shorter read than most Robin Hood tales, but rousing good adventure and a fun story!
Update: After a reread, I revised my rating upward to five stars! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Update: After a reread, I revised my rating upward to five stars! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
August 2, 2022
Absolutely brilliant book, I cannot praise enough the research and thought put into this book to make it such a wonderful book.
A.E. Chandler is the master of Robin Hood. Chandler holds a Masters Degree in Medieval Studies and wrote her dissertation on Robin Hood. Nobody understands Robin Hood, better then Ms. Chandler.
Ms. Chandler has blended fact and fiction, history and myth and created an outstanding story of Robin Hood, Maid Marion and Little John.
We learn how Robert became Robin Hood.
"Blinding is too good for thee. Hanging is too god for thee. Thou art not worth the rope. The forest is thine home now. Here starve, and freeze, and die alone. Thou has killed thyself. Now run! Run to save they murderous hide!"
The code of Honour that Robin and his Merry Men lived by
"A code of honour was sworn. The band vowed never to menace woman nor child, to away give aid to the poor, to be plain in the dealings, and to value all men at their true worth, regardless of rank. They vowed to fight fairly, and lay down their lives for woman, King, or honest man."
The love between Robert and Marion
"The solution she found to regain her life was to give it up. She left family, comfort, and safety to live in a cave in the freezing wintertime, and be hunted like an animal in the summer. Let it be known that she never regretted it."
I was provided with a free copy of this novel, by the author A.E. Chandler in return for my honest review.
5 Stars: It was amazing. It was compelling, well-researched, entertaining and/or moving and often complex. I will definitely want to read more books by this author.
A.E. Chandler is the master of Robin Hood. Chandler holds a Masters Degree in Medieval Studies and wrote her dissertation on Robin Hood. Nobody understands Robin Hood, better then Ms. Chandler.
Ms. Chandler has blended fact and fiction, history and myth and created an outstanding story of Robin Hood, Maid Marion and Little John.
We learn how Robert became Robin Hood.
"Blinding is too good for thee. Hanging is too god for thee. Thou art not worth the rope. The forest is thine home now. Here starve, and freeze, and die alone. Thou has killed thyself. Now run! Run to save they murderous hide!"
The code of Honour that Robin and his Merry Men lived by
"A code of honour was sworn. The band vowed never to menace woman nor child, to away give aid to the poor, to be plain in the dealings, and to value all men at their true worth, regardless of rank. They vowed to fight fairly, and lay down their lives for woman, King, or honest man."
The love between Robert and Marion
"The solution she found to regain her life was to give it up. She left family, comfort, and safety to live in a cave in the freezing wintertime, and be hunted like an animal in the summer. Let it be known that she never regretted it."
I was provided with a free copy of this novel, by the author A.E. Chandler in return for my honest review.
5 Stars: It was amazing. It was compelling, well-researched, entertaining and/or moving and often complex. I will definitely want to read more books by this author.
![Profile Image for Terence M [on a brief semi-hiatus].](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.gr-assets.com%2Fimages%2FS%2Fcompressed.photo.goodreads.com%2Fusers%2F1712357414i%2F6658001._UY200_CR4%2C0%2C200%2C200_.jpg&w=128&q=75)
April 13, 2023
"Outlier Alert"
1-Star - DNF - I simply "Did Not Like It"
The Scarlet Forest - A Tale of Robin Hood by A.E. Chandler
Audiobook: 08:29 Hours - Narrator: Joel Benedict
I tried assiduously to listen to, and enjoy, this novel. I can only say that, at 52%, I failed miserably. The "story" flittered hither and yon, the "Ye Olde English" text and dialogue were maximally distracting, and the narration, in keeping with the dialogue, was flat, unexciting, and annoying.
From my Reading Activity:
March 1, 2023 @ 30%
This is my own book, bought and paid for (as are all my books), so my only obligation is to review it fairly and honestly. @30% heard, my feelings are somewhat ambivalent. Am I hearing the same book as other reviewers? It doesn't seem so at this stage.
1-Star - DNF - I simply "Did Not Like It"
The Scarlet Forest - A Tale of Robin Hood by A.E. Chandler
Audiobook: 08:29 Hours - Narrator: Joel Benedict
I tried assiduously to listen to, and enjoy, this novel. I can only say that, at 52%, I failed miserably. The "story" flittered hither and yon, the "Ye Olde English" text and dialogue were maximally distracting, and the narration, in keeping with the dialogue, was flat, unexciting, and annoying.
From my Reading Activity:
March 1, 2023 @ 30%
This is my own book, bought and paid for (as are all my books), so my only obligation is to review it fairly and honestly. @30% heard, my feelings are somewhat ambivalent. Am I hearing the same book as other reviewers? It doesn't seem so at this stage.
October 27, 2021
10/26/21 re-read update: The meta in this book is truly top-notch. I love how the author winks at Robin Hood enthusiasts and academics. (The new audiobook is great!)
This book has firmly earned its place as my favorite Robin Hood book of all time. I love the story of Robin Hood, and I'm generally more in love with the story than I am with the history. That said, my ideal Robin Hood books (and other media) are those that truly honor and emulate the story, by informing and building the story through history. The Scarlet Forest is a lighthearted adventure of a book, but informed at every turn by history, and written by someone who loves the story as much as I do. It felt like the part of my heart that is in love with Robin Hood mythos had been written out on the page.
This book uses dozens of well-known and lesser-known traditional Robin Hood adventures and combines them all into one text, along with a few additional stories of the author's invention. Every time I started a new chapter, I would excitedly realize which story that chapter would focus on and eagerly read on.
All the characters are here, and some in bigger roles than they usually receive in more traditional novels like this one. Marian, in particular, is given a prominent role and although she is a member of the Merry Men, fights, robs, and experiences all the traditional adventures, she is not necessarily "not like other girls". She is practical and thinks before she acts, making thoughtful decisions. I loved Marian in this book, or rather, Anne of the Woods, as she is known under her outlaw alias.
Sherwood Forest itself feels like a character in this novel, and the passages written about the forest are visceral and simply the best I've ever read describing Sherwood Forest.
The entire novel is written in old English, and rather than coming across as fake, cheesy, or unnecessary, it feels immersive and real. The language used is not such that it detracts from the storytelling but adds to it. Not many authors can pull this off, in my opinion, and this book delivered.
This is a book for anyone like me, who grew up loving this story and is as familiar with it as an old friend. I texted my girlfriend while I was reading it and said this: "It's like the author pulled out all the things that make it a wonderful story, a wonderful piece of history, and a wonderful passion and put it into a cohesive story."
This book has firmly earned its place as my favorite Robin Hood book of all time. I love the story of Robin Hood, and I'm generally more in love with the story than I am with the history. That said, my ideal Robin Hood books (and other media) are those that truly honor and emulate the story, by informing and building the story through history. The Scarlet Forest is a lighthearted adventure of a book, but informed at every turn by history, and written by someone who loves the story as much as I do. It felt like the part of my heart that is in love with Robin Hood mythos had been written out on the page.
This book uses dozens of well-known and lesser-known traditional Robin Hood adventures and combines them all into one text, along with a few additional stories of the author's invention. Every time I started a new chapter, I would excitedly realize which story that chapter would focus on and eagerly read on.
All the characters are here, and some in bigger roles than they usually receive in more traditional novels like this one. Marian, in particular, is given a prominent role and although she is a member of the Merry Men, fights, robs, and experiences all the traditional adventures, she is not necessarily "not like other girls". She is practical and thinks before she acts, making thoughtful decisions. I loved Marian in this book, or rather, Anne of the Woods, as she is known under her outlaw alias.
Sherwood Forest itself feels like a character in this novel, and the passages written about the forest are visceral and simply the best I've ever read describing Sherwood Forest.
The entire novel is written in old English, and rather than coming across as fake, cheesy, or unnecessary, it feels immersive and real. The language used is not such that it detracts from the storytelling but adds to it. Not many authors can pull this off, in my opinion, and this book delivered.
This is a book for anyone like me, who grew up loving this story and is as familiar with it as an old friend. I texted my girlfriend while I was reading it and said this: "It's like the author pulled out all the things that make it a wonderful story, a wonderful piece of history, and a wonderful passion and put it into a cohesive story."
August 13, 2021
A highly entertaining and refreshing walk back into the forest of Sherwood! I’ve always loved Robin Hood and Maid Marian, and this story added much more character to the both of them, especially Anne. Also, enjoyed the medieval language brilliantly used by the writer.
I only wish that the retelling was more imaginative; it was wholesome but comprised of events already told through various pieces of literature and tv/cinematic adaptations. I did feel that the writer used her vivid imagination to twist and highlight Anne’s character (which I totally loved) but I wanted more of that! That’s my only complaint!
Thanks to the author for the free eARC in return for my honest review.
3.5/5🌟(rounding up).
I only wish that the retelling was more imaginative; it was wholesome but comprised of events already told through various pieces of literature and tv/cinematic adaptations. I did feel that the writer used her vivid imagination to twist and highlight Anne’s character (which I totally loved) but I wanted more of that! That’s my only complaint!
Thanks to the author for the free eARC in return for my honest review.
3.5/5🌟(rounding up).
June 14, 2020
Have finally had a chance to sit down and start reading this medieval gem of a tale. I am starting with a five star review, mostly because I love anything to do with Robin Hood lore and already, this book by A.E. Chandler has me in its grasp even only after the first few chapters.
What has captured me most about this read is the historical accuracies. In particular, the flowing language of English antiquity used in the story to portray a genuine sense that this spin of Robin Hood's life is different from the rest out there. I literally get the sense that this book is legitimately from the time and place of this famous outlaw's existence. Great way to magically transport a reader through time! Well done, and look forward to finishing the story...
What has captured me most about this read is the historical accuracies. In particular, the flowing language of English antiquity used in the story to portray a genuine sense that this spin of Robin Hood's life is different from the rest out there. I literally get the sense that this book is legitimately from the time and place of this famous outlaw's existence. Great way to magically transport a reader through time! Well done, and look forward to finishing the story...
July 19, 2018
The Scarlet Forest is an incredible tale of the life of Robin Hood. We learn how he and Marion met, how his band of Merry Men was formed and follow them on their exciting but risky activities. Life was not easy at that time but they were all happy to live the adventurous lives of outlaws. This book made it sound like a good thing that Robin Hood and his men took from wealthy men and gave most of the money to less fortunate people. When the wealthy were corrupt politicians and men of the church, I actually wanted them to pay for their greed.
This book was written in an old English style making it easy to relate to the times. It was wonderful to get to know the Merry Men and what brought them to Robin. As well as how much they liked the freedom of living in the forest. But they had to be careful not to be caught or they would be hung for their crimes.
We will probably never know if Robin Hood was real or a myth. Even so, this story of his life held my interest and left me crying.
This book was written in an old English style making it easy to relate to the times. It was wonderful to get to know the Merry Men and what brought them to Robin. As well as how much they liked the freedom of living in the forest. But they had to be careful not to be caught or they would be hung for their crimes.
We will probably never know if Robin Hood was real or a myth. Even so, this story of his life held my interest and left me crying.
March 16, 2021
Nottingham Fair. Robert (18, brother) was entered in an archery shooting match.
The Sheriff plans on luring Robin Hood into the archery competition.
It seems Robin Hood & Marian Fitzwalter (aka Anne, Robert’s BFF, Baron Fitzwalter’s eldest daughter) were in love.
The 10 best archers were announced.
Percival (fewterer), the 3 three greyhounds, Baron Fitzwalter, Robert, & Will Stutely were set to go deer hunting.
Friar Tuck had wed Allan & Edith.
Countess Agatha (Huntington, Earl David of Huntington mother, Lady Margaret of Gamewell, Robin Hood’s mother) had passed away.
Baron Fitzwalter had died & his estate was divided into 4 lots, except for Anne, who had been disowned.
What will Robin Hood (outlaw), Little John, & the Merry Men’s next quest be?
I do not receive any type of compensation for reading & reviewing free books from publishers & authors. Therefore, I am under no obligation to write a positive review, only an honest one.
An awesome book cover, great font & writing style. A very professionally written Historical Fiction book. It was quite easy for me to read/follow from start/finish & never a dull moment. There were no grammar/typo errors, nor any repetitive or out of line sequence sentences. Lots of exciting scenarios, with several twists/turns & a huge description list of unique characters, settings, facts etc. to keep track of. This could also make another great Robin Hood movie, an animated cartoon, or better yet a mini-TV series. It was as exciting as I hoped, I liked it, but I will only rate it at 4/5 stars.
Thank you for the free author; Thistledown Press; Goodreads; MakingConnections; Making Connections discussion group talk; Amazon Digital Services LLC. Mobi; ePub book
Tony Parsons MSW (Washburn)
The Sheriff plans on luring Robin Hood into the archery competition.
It seems Robin Hood & Marian Fitzwalter (aka Anne, Robert’s BFF, Baron Fitzwalter’s eldest daughter) were in love.
The 10 best archers were announced.
Percival (fewterer), the 3 three greyhounds, Baron Fitzwalter, Robert, & Will Stutely were set to go deer hunting.
Friar Tuck had wed Allan & Edith.
Countess Agatha (Huntington, Earl David of Huntington mother, Lady Margaret of Gamewell, Robin Hood’s mother) had passed away.
Baron Fitzwalter had died & his estate was divided into 4 lots, except for Anne, who had been disowned.
What will Robin Hood (outlaw), Little John, & the Merry Men’s next quest be?
I do not receive any type of compensation for reading & reviewing free books from publishers & authors. Therefore, I am under no obligation to write a positive review, only an honest one.
An awesome book cover, great font & writing style. A very professionally written Historical Fiction book. It was quite easy for me to read/follow from start/finish & never a dull moment. There were no grammar/typo errors, nor any repetitive or out of line sequence sentences. Lots of exciting scenarios, with several twists/turns & a huge description list of unique characters, settings, facts etc. to keep track of. This could also make another great Robin Hood movie, an animated cartoon, or better yet a mini-TV series. It was as exciting as I hoped, I liked it, but I will only rate it at 4/5 stars.
Thank you for the free author; Thistledown Press; Goodreads; MakingConnections; Making Connections discussion group talk; Amazon Digital Services LLC. Mobi; ePub book
Tony Parsons MSW (Washburn)
January 29, 2018
I loved the book cover. Its simply awesome.
The MA dissertation attached at the end was so informative. WoW!! it was amazing.
In Chapter 4- Aspen - I loved the poem and how Anne interprets and Robin gives a positive response to it.
I loved the words - malmsey, sennight, wolf's head
The Medieval England language was simply breathtaking and it reminded me of Old King James Version of Bible.
Even those whom men condemn, God stands willing to redeem- Powerful statement.
The Bibliography was a treat to go through.
The most touching moment for me was when Robin and Anne part, he kisses her forehead and says - I would not see thee once more in danger.
I agree that no one can prove if Robinhood ever existed but he will always be etched in the legacy for years and years to come!
I enjoyed reading this book and I wish Chandler all the best for her future authorship works too.
The MA dissertation attached at the end was so informative. WoW!! it was amazing.
In Chapter 4- Aspen - I loved the poem and how Anne interprets and Robin gives a positive response to it.
I loved the words - malmsey, sennight, wolf's head
The Medieval England language was simply breathtaking and it reminded me of Old King James Version of Bible.
Even those whom men condemn, God stands willing to redeem- Powerful statement.
The Bibliography was a treat to go through.
The most touching moment for me was when Robin and Anne part, he kisses her forehead and says - I would not see thee once more in danger.
I agree that no one can prove if Robinhood ever existed but he will always be etched in the legacy for years and years to come!
I enjoyed reading this book and I wish Chandler all the best for her future authorship works too.
October 22, 2019
Beautifully blending history, centuries of legend and her own knowledge as a medieval scholar, Chandler writes the best, most faithful version of Robin Hood's story that I've come across. At first I was nervous reading the stylized old fashioned wording, fearing another slog like Howard Pyle's classic, but this was easily readable and there are some fantastic turns of phrase as the story unfolds. All the episodes from the ballads and traditional stories are played out here, the clever tricks, adventures and poignant moments you expect bound together in a wonderful narrative. This has earned a place of honor front and center of my Robin Hood book collection.
December 26, 2018
A high-quality retelling of the Robin Hood legend, with a powerful narrative voice. Well worth a read (and then a re-read or two after that, I dare say).
October 8, 2020
An enjoyable romp through Medieval England. This book tells the tales of RobinHood with a new spin all told with an eye on the history of the day. A great read.
November 29, 2021
The Scarlet Forest faithfully recreates the tale of Robin Hood by blending fact, fiction, and folklore. Through interconnected stories and events, the reader is led through Sherwood Forest with the Band of Merry Men, in a valiant attempt to discover the man behind the myth.
Reading The Scarlet Forest is akin to jumping into a luminous and richly detailed painting. The book is so visual and immersive, lavishly drizzled with wonderful historical detail and anecdote. There is an archaic slant to the language which enhances the narrative. The prose never feels over-elaborate or forced but its lyrical, almost whimsical quality wonderfully complements the tales of Nottingham’s favourite son and his childhood friends. The Scarlet Forest is a veritable Troubadour in paper (or digital) form.
It is clear that The Scarlet Forest has been written from a place of utmost passion and enthusiasm. The Author’s fascination for her subject shines through every word. The wealth of information contained in the book is astounding, and yet it does not present too dry nor academic.
However, given that the subject matter may or may not have existed, weaving all the components together to produce an entertaining and readable account is no mean feat, but it’s fully achieved in The Scarlet Forest. Never was the adage, ‘hiding in plain sight’ more appropriate than for Robin Hood. His cat and mouse capers with the Sheriff and his men are both clever and amusing. Robin plays the game with such bold, impish humour it makes you forget, that in most instances, the game has life or death stakes.
A.E. Chandler has developed Robin as such a rounded, dimensional character he literally jumps from the page. He has a childlike innocence and joy touched with vulnerability and yet, in many respects, his actions point to a single-minded, ruthless cunning. All of Robin’s compatriots have these qualities but A.E. Chandler is careful to only lay them as foundations of personality in the others; the band of outlaws are individuals and, while wholeheartedly supporting Robin, they are their own people and fully convince as such.
What’s most lovely about The Scarlet Forest are the character vignettes that feature in most chapters. From the nobility to the outlaws, there are some beautifully rustic and bucolic portrayals with bawdiness and haughtiness in equal measure and let’s not forget the main character; Sherwood Forest. Every time I picked up The Scarlet Forest, I was transported into its verdant world to the extent that I could hear the subtle rustling of the forest floor, smell the keen, savoury scent of ancient loam, and fairly see the sunlight slipping over polished leaves. It really is that sensory and evocative.
One of the reasons I love historical fiction is for all the little gems of knowledge you gain; etymology of words, names, places, and venerable, quirky occupations; The Scarlet Forest provides an embarrassment of riches on all scores. Further, despite all the medieval posturing, it’s interesting how many of the themes explored within the tales have a great deal of contemporary relevance, society is still confronting the same issues; which is reassuring on the one hand, but uncomfortably thought-provoking on the other.
The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood is a wondrously imaginative and historically absorbing re-telling of a legend that never grows stale. Highly recommended.
Reading The Scarlet Forest is akin to jumping into a luminous and richly detailed painting. The book is so visual and immersive, lavishly drizzled with wonderful historical detail and anecdote. There is an archaic slant to the language which enhances the narrative. The prose never feels over-elaborate or forced but its lyrical, almost whimsical quality wonderfully complements the tales of Nottingham’s favourite son and his childhood friends. The Scarlet Forest is a veritable Troubadour in paper (or digital) form.
It is clear that The Scarlet Forest has been written from a place of utmost passion and enthusiasm. The Author’s fascination for her subject shines through every word. The wealth of information contained in the book is astounding, and yet it does not present too dry nor academic.
However, given that the subject matter may or may not have existed, weaving all the components together to produce an entertaining and readable account is no mean feat, but it’s fully achieved in The Scarlet Forest. Never was the adage, ‘hiding in plain sight’ more appropriate than for Robin Hood. His cat and mouse capers with the Sheriff and his men are both clever and amusing. Robin plays the game with such bold, impish humour it makes you forget, that in most instances, the game has life or death stakes.
A.E. Chandler has developed Robin as such a rounded, dimensional character he literally jumps from the page. He has a childlike innocence and joy touched with vulnerability and yet, in many respects, his actions point to a single-minded, ruthless cunning. All of Robin’s compatriots have these qualities but A.E. Chandler is careful to only lay them as foundations of personality in the others; the band of outlaws are individuals and, while wholeheartedly supporting Robin, they are their own people and fully convince as such.
What’s most lovely about The Scarlet Forest are the character vignettes that feature in most chapters. From the nobility to the outlaws, there are some beautifully rustic and bucolic portrayals with bawdiness and haughtiness in equal measure and let’s not forget the main character; Sherwood Forest. Every time I picked up The Scarlet Forest, I was transported into its verdant world to the extent that I could hear the subtle rustling of the forest floor, smell the keen, savoury scent of ancient loam, and fairly see the sunlight slipping over polished leaves. It really is that sensory and evocative.
One of the reasons I love historical fiction is for all the little gems of knowledge you gain; etymology of words, names, places, and venerable, quirky occupations; The Scarlet Forest provides an embarrassment of riches on all scores. Further, despite all the medieval posturing, it’s interesting how many of the themes explored within the tales have a great deal of contemporary relevance, society is still confronting the same issues; which is reassuring on the one hand, but uncomfortably thought-provoking on the other.
The Scarlet Forest: A Tale of Robin Hood is a wondrously imaginative and historically absorbing re-telling of a legend that never grows stale. Highly recommended.
November 5, 2021
A great overview of Robin Hood possibilities, and written in an old English style! As a fan and student of Medieval stories, I loved it!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews