Ichijo and Nanami are dating. Were dating. After what happened with his mom, Ichijo decides that he can’t put Nanami through the same thing, which leads to a surprising turn from Ieiri and a bit of adolescent idiocy from Ichijo. But what are friends for, if not to point out when you’re being dumb?
So, there’s the good version of this story where what happens is believable and completely makes sense given what we’ve learned of our characters and their bad decisions. Then there’s the other version, which is trite and incredibly dumb and based on our characters throwing all their growth clear out the window for the sake of making things awkward for an entire volume.
It probably falls somewhere in the middle, which is largely where I find myself on this one, which is equal parts solid and incredibly overwrought and features wild swings and corporate involvement and the class struggle as applies to high school students.
Ichijo gets this ball rolling by deciding his course of action all on his own, no need to consult his girlfriend (bodes real well for their communication in future and Nanami thankfully takes him to task for this later). Needless to say, this turns out to be an incredibly bad idea.
Thus, he makes the supreme leap in logic that she can’t get hurt if they’re not together so he does everything short of ascending to the astral plane to start ghosting her. This is exactly as awkward as it sounds, especially in the face of Nanami’s relentless nature (her speech on communication is more of what this manga needed by half).
On the plus side, this gives the other boys something to do, as the are quick to point out how incredibly stupid this, not to mention unfair to Nanami. I think the biggest problem is how quickly Ichijo just sides with his evil grandmother. Family loyalty and all, but sheesh.
Of course, there are reasons, but they don’t hold up to a lot of scrutiny, but do make a sort of logical sense in a ‘I am teenager and must take on the world myself’ sort of way. The reason also brings Ichijo’s absentee father into the picture and they have an actual talk that’s one of the other better parts of the volume.
Ieiri really has a heel turn this time and turns out to be a huge ally for Nanami when the chips are down. His ridiculous un-date is incredibly sneaky and one of the more clever tricks in here as it goes a long way to making up for some of his earlier plotting in a fairly organic way. It’s also emblematic of how your friends often know the best way to get your hackles up.
Naturally the day is saved by speechifying and it turns out that having some spine was all that was needed and, while this led us down some good pathways, the resolution for this really, really feels like a ‘we need to end this storyline and move to the next arc’ moment. I get that you want your character empowerment, but it doesn’t feel earned and that’s a big issue when you’re tackling family.
There’s just something that doesn’t sit right here, maybe the shocking uptick in big melodrama when the story was quite fine with its regular levels before? Naturally we end on a suggestion that even more of this is coming our way and I question throwing this much parent drama into the story in rapid succession.
3.5 stars - sigh, this is really good in many individual moments but something just felt off to me about it. Moment to moment there is some great stuff, but it doesn’t feel like the series I’ve come to enjoy when looking at the overall experience. I’ll let the good parts tug it upward, but it’s a 3.5 stars as it can get.