What do you think?
Rate this book
Ruth Galloway #10
Musta enkeli
Suosikkiarkeologi selvittää murhaa Italian auringossa
Kymmenennessä Ruth Galloway -mysteerissä uppoudutaan italialaisen pikkukaupungin menneisyyteen. Suosittu brittisarja yhdistää ihmissuhteiden ja perhe-elämän arkiset ongelmat niin historiallisten kuin tuoreidenkin murhien tutkintaan.
Arkeologi Ruth Gallowayn rakkauselämä on kertakaikkisen solmussa ja Ruth pahasti loman tarpeessa. Kun häntä pyydetään apuun kaivauksille Italiassa, hän tarttuu heti tilaisuuteen yhdistää työ ja huvi. Mutta liittyvätkö muinaiset luut myös tuoreempiin kuolemantapauksiin? Kun komisario Harry Nelson vielä ilmestyy Italiaan, Ruth huomaa sotkeutuneensa monenlaisten salaisuuksien seittiin. Menneisyys kirii kiinni niin Ruthia kuin Nelsoniakin. Lopullisten valintojen aika on pian käsillä.
Kymmenennessä Ruth Galloway -mysteerissä uppoudutaan italialaisen pikkukaupungin menneisyyteen. Suosittu brittisarja yhdistää ihmissuhteiden ja perhe-elämän arkiset ongelmat niin historiallisten kuin tuoreidenkin murhien tutkintaan.
Arkeologi Ruth Gallowayn rakkauselämä on kertakaikkisen solmussa ja Ruth pahasti loman tarpeessa. Kun häntä pyydetään apuun kaivauksille Italiassa, hän tarttuu heti tilaisuuteen yhdistää työ ja huvi. Mutta liittyvätkö muinaiset luut myös tuoreempiin kuolemantapauksiin? Kun komisario Harry Nelson vielä ilmestyy Italiaan, Ruth huomaa sotkeutuneensa monenlaisten salaisuuksien seittiin. Menneisyys kirii kiinni niin Ruthia kuin Nelsoniakin. Lopullisten valintojen aika on pian käsillä.
344 pages, ebook
First published February 8, 2018
3001 people are currently reading
5652 people want to read
About the author
Elly Griffiths
75 books9,482 followersElly Griffiths' Ruth Galloway novels take for their inspiration Elly's husband, who gave up a city job to train as an archaeologist, and her aunt who lives on the Norfolk coast and who filled her niece's head with the myths and legends of that area. Elly has two children and lives near Brighton. Though not her first novel, The Crossing Places is her first crime novel.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,808 reviews
January 20, 2018
This is the tenth in the series featuring Dr Ruth Galloway, the forensic archaeologist set in Norfolk. Ruth has been experiencing an emotionally stressful time when her hopes of cementing a relationship with DI Harry Nelson are dashed with his wife, Michelle, becoming pregnant. It is the summer holidays, and Ruth is contacted by Professor Angelo Morelli asking her for her expertise in a excavated skeleton in Italy. Angelo is a famous TV archaeologist, and is an ex-lover of Ruth's from her past. This bolsters Ruth's ego which is badly in need of a boost, and with her best friend, Shona, Louis, and her daughter, Kate, sets off for a break in the sun, with Angelo providing them with accommodation in the beautiful Liri valley, at the fictional village of Castello di Angeli. Nelson is disturbed to hear that Mickey Webb, a man responsible for the death of his wife and two children in a fire, has been set free after seeing the light and becoming a committed a Christian, who married again whilst in prison. Webb uttered threats promising retribution when Nelson arrested and charged him, suspicious events have the police keeping an eye on him. This latest addition in the series focuses less on the two crime storylines in Norfolk and Italy, instead giving us a welcome insights into the returning and familiar characters and their relationships.
Nelson is out of sorts when he finds out that Ruth and Kate have gone to Italy without informing him, although hearing about an earthquake has him boarding a flight with Cathbad in tow, to ascertain that Ruth and Kate are okay. Ruth is greeted by unwelcome graffiti on the apartment walls, and a wolf's skull left by the door. The local community has a strong history of the partisans and the resistance fighters fighting the Nazis. Ruth finds herself caught up in the media interest in Angelo's skeleton which appears to have been subject to a deviant burial, given the stone in the mouth. Nelson's departure has an insecure Michelle pondering on the quandry she finds herself with her uncertainty as to who is the father of her unborn child and contemplating getting involved with Tim who loves her unconditionally. Ruth once again comes across a murder, that of the old priest, Don Tomaso, who had wanted to share some information with her. Ruth finds herself in danger, that extends to her precious daughter, Kate, Shona and her son, Louis. Meanwhile, in Norfolk a scary scenario unfolds with deadly consequences that has a fearful Nelson wracked with guilt racing back to his lawful family in England.
It is always a pleasure to catch up with this wonderful cast of characters that have wormed their way into my heart. I was particularly pleased to experience a little more time in the company of Cathbad, who has had a miniscule part in recent books. Ruth remains entangled and subject to her emotional need for Nelson, a married man who remains loyal to Michelle and his two daughters. He is ripped apart though by his feelings for Ruth and his daughter, Kate, fuelling ongoing trauma in his life, destined to continue for some time yet. I enjoyed the Italian location and the intrigue and the continuing passions that are inflamed by the past. All in all, this was a terrific read, highly entertaining and wonderful to once again be immersed with this great cast of characters that Griffiths continues to develop in a compelling manner. I can't wait for the next book! Many thanks to Quercus for an ARC.
Nelson is out of sorts when he finds out that Ruth and Kate have gone to Italy without informing him, although hearing about an earthquake has him boarding a flight with Cathbad in tow, to ascertain that Ruth and Kate are okay. Ruth is greeted by unwelcome graffiti on the apartment walls, and a wolf's skull left by the door. The local community has a strong history of the partisans and the resistance fighters fighting the Nazis. Ruth finds herself caught up in the media interest in Angelo's skeleton which appears to have been subject to a deviant burial, given the stone in the mouth. Nelson's departure has an insecure Michelle pondering on the quandry she finds herself with her uncertainty as to who is the father of her unborn child and contemplating getting involved with Tim who loves her unconditionally. Ruth once again comes across a murder, that of the old priest, Don Tomaso, who had wanted to share some information with her. Ruth finds herself in danger, that extends to her precious daughter, Kate, Shona and her son, Louis. Meanwhile, in Norfolk a scary scenario unfolds with deadly consequences that has a fearful Nelson wracked with guilt racing back to his lawful family in England.
It is always a pleasure to catch up with this wonderful cast of characters that have wormed their way into my heart. I was particularly pleased to experience a little more time in the company of Cathbad, who has had a miniscule part in recent books. Ruth remains entangled and subject to her emotional need for Nelson, a married man who remains loyal to Michelle and his two daughters. He is ripped apart though by his feelings for Ruth and his daughter, Kate, fuelling ongoing trauma in his life, destined to continue for some time yet. I enjoyed the Italian location and the intrigue and the continuing passions that are inflamed by the past. All in all, this was a terrific read, highly entertaining and wonderful to once again be immersed with this great cast of characters that Griffiths continues to develop in a compelling manner. I can't wait for the next book! Many thanks to Quercus for an ARC.
September 5, 2023
EXCERPT: Giving your son to God sounds sinister somehow. Ruth once found the body of an Iron Age girl who had been tied down and left on the marshes to die, an offering to some faceless, nameless diety. She thinks of Isaac carrying the wood on which he is going to be sacrificed by his father, a story which pops up quite often in her parent's church, where it seems to be held up as an example of good parenting.
THE BLURB: Dr Ruth Galloway is flattered when she receives a letter from Italian archaeologist Dr Angelo Morelli, asking for her help. He's discovered a group of bones in a tiny hilltop village but doesn't know what to make of them. It's years since Ruth has had a holiday, and even a working holiday to Italy is very welcome!
So Ruth travels to Fontana Liri, accompanied by her daughter Kate and friend Shona. In the town she finds a medieval shrine and a dark secret involving the war years and the Resistance. To her amazement she also finds Harry Nelson, who is enduring a terrible holiday at a resort nearby. But there is no time to overcome their mutual shock - the ancient bones spark a modern murder, and Ruth must discover what secrets there are in Fontana Liri that someone would kill to protect.
MY THOUGHTS: I completely understand why the Ruth Galloway series is, and I quote, 'My favourite current crime series' - Val McDermid.
Elly Griffiths writes in a quietly sinister fashion that keeps me glued to the page. Her characters are delightful, but all too human, all capable of deceit, guilt, indecision and bad judgment. It was lovely to catch up again with Cathcart (known as Michael in his pre-druid life) and his very perceptive pronouncements. He is a very deep character, and one of my favorites.
My favorite passage from the book is this- 'As he speaks, he turns to the tombstone, white and stark among the older graves, like a false tooth in a mouthful of decaying molars.' Wandering through graveyards is a pastime of mine. I make up stories about the inhabitants, and wonder about their lives. However, I doubt that I will be able to do so in the future without thinking of the 'decaying molars'.
The setting for this book moves from Norfolk to the Liri Valley region in Italy, a rather beautiful and historic area. I soaked up the atmosphere, and swear I gained a kilo from all the delicious sounding pasta they ate. Although the village of Castello degli Angeli where Ruth is staying is completely fictional, other places they mentioned and visited are real, and I journeyed along with them, enjoying the sights if not the food, courtesy of Google Earth.
The plot is not particularly fast-paced, but the book loses nothing because of this. In fact it is, in this instance, a redeeming quality. That is not to say that there is no action, because there is plenty.
The Dark Angel by Elly Griffiths is an extremely satisfying read. I award it ☆☆☆☆1/2 simply exquisite stars.
Thank you to Quercus Books via Netgalley for providing a digital copy of The Dark Angel by Elly Griffiths for review. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own personal opinions.
Please refer to my Goodreads.com profile page or the 'about' page on sandysbookaday.wordpress.com for an explanation of my rating system.
This review and others are also published on my blog sandysbookaday.wordpress.com https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
THE BLURB: Dr Ruth Galloway is flattered when she receives a letter from Italian archaeologist Dr Angelo Morelli, asking for her help. He's discovered a group of bones in a tiny hilltop village but doesn't know what to make of them. It's years since Ruth has had a holiday, and even a working holiday to Italy is very welcome!
So Ruth travels to Fontana Liri, accompanied by her daughter Kate and friend Shona. In the town she finds a medieval shrine and a dark secret involving the war years and the Resistance. To her amazement she also finds Harry Nelson, who is enduring a terrible holiday at a resort nearby. But there is no time to overcome their mutual shock - the ancient bones spark a modern murder, and Ruth must discover what secrets there are in Fontana Liri that someone would kill to protect.
MY THOUGHTS: I completely understand why the Ruth Galloway series is, and I quote, 'My favourite current crime series' - Val McDermid.
Elly Griffiths writes in a quietly sinister fashion that keeps me glued to the page. Her characters are delightful, but all too human, all capable of deceit, guilt, indecision and bad judgment. It was lovely to catch up again with Cathcart (known as Michael in his pre-druid life) and his very perceptive pronouncements. He is a very deep character, and one of my favorites.
My favorite passage from the book is this- 'As he speaks, he turns to the tombstone, white and stark among the older graves, like a false tooth in a mouthful of decaying molars.' Wandering through graveyards is a pastime of mine. I make up stories about the inhabitants, and wonder about their lives. However, I doubt that I will be able to do so in the future without thinking of the 'decaying molars'.
The setting for this book moves from Norfolk to the Liri Valley region in Italy, a rather beautiful and historic area. I soaked up the atmosphere, and swear I gained a kilo from all the delicious sounding pasta they ate. Although the village of Castello degli Angeli where Ruth is staying is completely fictional, other places they mentioned and visited are real, and I journeyed along with them, enjoying the sights if not the food, courtesy of Google Earth.
The plot is not particularly fast-paced, but the book loses nothing because of this. In fact it is, in this instance, a redeeming quality. That is not to say that there is no action, because there is plenty.
The Dark Angel by Elly Griffiths is an extremely satisfying read. I award it ☆☆☆☆1/2 simply exquisite stars.
Thank you to Quercus Books via Netgalley for providing a digital copy of The Dark Angel by Elly Griffiths for review. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own personal opinions.
Please refer to my Goodreads.com profile page or the 'about' page on sandysbookaday.wordpress.com for an explanation of my rating system.
This review and others are also published on my blog sandysbookaday.wordpress.com https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
https://sandysbookaday.wordpress.com/...
April 25, 2018
In the last several months I have read an inordinate amount of novels set in Italy. Was surprised to find in this book, which is set in England, that I would once again be traveling to Italy, in particular Castello degli Angeli. A town slowly dying, all it's young people moving to Rome for employment opportunities. It is also a town with a long memory, memories and tragedies from the second World War.
Ruth is called to Italy when an old friend finds bones and needs a bone expert. Wanting to get away from home, due to the emotional turmoil caused by the ever changing situation with Nelson. She takes Kate, and Shonna and Louis travels with them. Things will develop in Italy, unexpected situations, but things will also happen back home.
I enjoy this very character oriented series, the mix of characters, including a druid. It is interesting, I always learn something new pertaining to archeology and past civilizations. The personal developments and changing relationships are also enjoyable, though I admit to wanting to shake Nelson in more than one situation. For some reason, with this series, I feel as if I am actually a character in the story, rather than a reader watching from afar.
ARC from Edelweiss.
Ruth is called to Italy when an old friend finds bones and needs a bone expert. Wanting to get away from home, due to the emotional turmoil caused by the ever changing situation with Nelson. She takes Kate, and Shonna and Louis travels with them. Things will develop in Italy, unexpected situations, but things will also happen back home.
I enjoy this very character oriented series, the mix of characters, including a druid. It is interesting, I always learn something new pertaining to archeology and past civilizations. The personal developments and changing relationships are also enjoyable, though I admit to wanting to shake Nelson in more than one situation. For some reason, with this series, I feel as if I am actually a character in the story, rather than a reader watching from afar.
ARC from Edelweiss.
January 4, 2021
Firstly I wonder who wrote the blurb for this book? I quote "To her amazement she also finds Harry Nelson, who is enduring a terrible holiday at a resort nearby. But there is no time to overcome their mutual shock." This not how it happens at all.
Anyway, moving on, The Dark Angel is set in Italy although the author alternates chapters between Italy and England and moves two separate story lines forward simultaneously. The English side ended up interesting me the most despite the fact that there were murders and spooky happenings in Italy.
I enjoyed the book as I always enjoy this author's work. but found I was not really interested in all the detail about Italy and its architecture and religion. Maybe I just was not in the mood or maybe I was anxious for the author to go back to what was happening at home, which ended up being major and totally unexpected. It will not be long before I grab the next book to see what happens.
Anyway, moving on, The Dark Angel is set in Italy although the author alternates chapters between Italy and England and moves two separate story lines forward simultaneously. The English side ended up interesting me the most despite the fact that there were murders and spooky happenings in Italy.
I enjoyed the book as I always enjoy this author's work. but found I was not really interested in all the detail about Italy and its architecture and religion. Maybe I just was not in the mood or maybe I was anxious for the author to go back to what was happening at home, which ended up being major and totally unexpected. It will not be long before I grab the next book to see what happens.
February 25, 2018
I want to start by saying this in one of my favorite series and the characters dear to me, because they have always come across as very real. The mystery aspect of the plot in the Ruth Galloway books is not their strong point, but I don't really care, I read them for my love of the characters. As for The Dark Angel, I really enjoyed a solid two thirds of the book and really sped through, though I had intended to pace myself and make it last. But then something happened, and though I won't say anything to spoil it, this really upset and disappointed me, because I not only felt it was unnecessary, but also a bit of a cop-out. Anyone who has read this book will know what I am referring to and I would love to know what you think! All in all, I still really like Ruth and would be happy to know her in real life, but the way the book ended was so disappointing I just cannot give it the five stars I had felt sure I would initially. Even four feels a bit of a stretch, but I have my loyalties. When you wait a whole year for the next installment in a beloved series and the book really lets you down, it almost feels personal. I am sure you know what I mean. It's been a few days since I finished this book, but had I written this review immediately after I turned the final page, I do not doubt it would have been downgraded to three stars, which makes me quite sad:-/
Find more reviews and bookish fun at http://www.princessandpen.com
Find more reviews and bookish fun at http://www.princessandpen.com
March 24, 2020
It feels a little odd to be reading The Dark Angel, which takes place in Fontana Liri, Italy, while the Coronavirus rages there. But it was nice to be reminded of Italy in a time before all this horror.
Ruth receives a call from a fellow anthropologist, asking if she can come to Italy to examine some bones he has found while conducting an excavation for his tv show. He confides in her that he thinks someone is trying to kill him. “I think he’s confused me with Miss Marple”, she tells Shona, who has gone with her for a bit of holiday.
Meanwhile, a man Nelson saw convicted for the murder of his wife and children has been released from prison. At the time he was sent away, he vowed to get revenge on Nelson and the other police involved.
These books are never fast paced and this time, it’s near the halfway point before we get a murder. In a weird twist, Nelson and Cathbad end up in Italy with Ruth. I have to say that the crimes here are weaker than normal. But I have to admit my pleasure in reading these books is always more about the characters than solving the crimes. I got a huge kick that Bruno is now a full fledged character in his own right.
I found this book the perfect antidote to the stressful times. But I’m despondent that I'm now forced to wait for book 12 to be published. I started this series with book 11 (The Stone Circle) and have now made my way through all of them.
Ruth receives a call from a fellow anthropologist, asking if she can come to Italy to examine some bones he has found while conducting an excavation for his tv show. He confides in her that he thinks someone is trying to kill him. “I think he’s confused me with Miss Marple”, she tells Shona, who has gone with her for a bit of holiday.
Meanwhile, a man Nelson saw convicted for the murder of his wife and children has been released from prison. At the time he was sent away, he vowed to get revenge on Nelson and the other police involved.
These books are never fast paced and this time, it’s near the halfway point before we get a murder. In a weird twist, Nelson and Cathbad end up in Italy with Ruth. I have to say that the crimes here are weaker than normal. But I have to admit my pleasure in reading these books is always more about the characters than solving the crimes. I got a huge kick that Bruno is now a full fledged character in his own right.
I found this book the perfect antidote to the stressful times. But I’m despondent that I'm now forced to wait for book 12 to be published. I started this series with book 11 (The Stone Circle) and have now made my way through all of them.
April 11, 2018
There are serious dangers in waking the spirits of the dead.
Dr. Ruth Galloway, UK bone specialist in archaeology, seems to know this quite often and usually up front and personal. Ruth has been contacted by an old colleague, Angelo Morelli, to examine some unusual bones found in an excavation site in the Liri Valley in Italy.
Dead men usually tell no tales, but this one speaks volumes from the confines of his grave. Buried face down is demeaning at best, but this poor soul has also had a stone lodged in his mouth where his tongue should have been.....the silence of an ancient statement.
The August Italian sun beckons for one last holiday before Ruth's daughter, Kate, returns to school. Wishing for company on this trek, Ruth invites her friend, Shona, and her son, Louis, to join them. What appears to be a routine dig turns into far more than what Ruth bargained for. The historical vibes of the village have been laced with the impact of Fascists, Nazis, and resistance fighters during World War II. It is evident in the older generations who speak of an occupied Italy where the deep footprint is still embedded there.
The lulling breezes of the Italian countryside will soon reverse and take on a mighty windstorm. Ruth comes upon the body of the local elderly priest in the darkness of the village church. Who would ever harm this gentle soul and, more importantly, why?
Elly Griffiths creates quite the multi-leveled scenario here with lightning strikes both in Italy and in the UK simultaneously. Be assured. I have only read a few of her books and I was still able to follow the backstories going on in the lives of these characters. And there's quite a bit of eyebrow-raising with sparking relationships and who is connecting with whom. That in itself will draw you into this storyline. Oh, the games people play.
The Dark Angel emerges you into the pools of great storytelling from the onset. Just as things begin to sort out towards the end, Griffiths throws in a totally unexpected event that will play havoc in the future of many of these characters. Have mercy! She can't write fast enough for the next one to get here while we anxiously tread water. Yowzers!
I received a copy of The Dark Angel through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Houghton Mifflin Harcourt (Quercus) for the opportunity.
Dr. Ruth Galloway, UK bone specialist in archaeology, seems to know this quite often and usually up front and personal. Ruth has been contacted by an old colleague, Angelo Morelli, to examine some unusual bones found in an excavation site in the Liri Valley in Italy.
Dead men usually tell no tales, but this one speaks volumes from the confines of his grave. Buried face down is demeaning at best, but this poor soul has also had a stone lodged in his mouth where his tongue should have been.....the silence of an ancient statement.
The August Italian sun beckons for one last holiday before Ruth's daughter, Kate, returns to school. Wishing for company on this trek, Ruth invites her friend, Shona, and her son, Louis, to join them. What appears to be a routine dig turns into far more than what Ruth bargained for. The historical vibes of the village have been laced with the impact of Fascists, Nazis, and resistance fighters during World War II. It is evident in the older generations who speak of an occupied Italy where the deep footprint is still embedded there.
The lulling breezes of the Italian countryside will soon reverse and take on a mighty windstorm. Ruth comes upon the body of the local elderly priest in the darkness of the village church. Who would ever harm this gentle soul and, more importantly, why?
Elly Griffiths creates quite the multi-leveled scenario here with lightning strikes both in Italy and in the UK simultaneously. Be assured. I have only read a few of her books and I was still able to follow the backstories going on in the lives of these characters. And there's quite a bit of eyebrow-raising with sparking relationships and who is connecting with whom. That in itself will draw you into this storyline. Oh, the games people play.
The Dark Angel emerges you into the pools of great storytelling from the onset. Just as things begin to sort out towards the end, Griffiths throws in a totally unexpected event that will play havoc in the future of many of these characters. Have mercy! She can't write fast enough for the next one to get here while we anxiously tread water. Yowzers!
I received a copy of The Dark Angel through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Houghton Mifflin Harcourt (Quercus) for the opportunity.
June 18, 2018
This was disappointing.
I think the author boxed herself in by using Italy as the setting for this book. It was easy enough to get Ruth there with a request to consult on an archeological television show. She, of course, brings her daughter. Ruth's best friend, Shona, also comes along with her son. Shona provides a way to free Ruth from childcare. To get Nelson to Italy, the author writes in an earthquake. It’s minor by Italy’s standards, but it rattles Nelson enough that he races to Italy to make sure Ruth and Katie are okay. It’s strange that a beloved character, Cathbad, comes with Nelson. Cathbad seems to be there to help keep the kids occupied and to dispense his occasional nuggets of mystical wisdom.
Much is made of Ruth's self-image problem with her weight and Shona accentuates that. Shona is attractive and stylish, but also shallow and selfish. Ruth is self conscious when she appears at the beach in a one piece bathing suit while everyone else is wearing bikinis. I don’t see how these two are best friends. Shona seems to take advantage of Ruth when she takes a nap or goes off to flirt with Graziano.
Most of this book feels like watching someone else's video of their vacation. It’s dull and boring. Ruth completes filming for the tv show in just a few hours, but she’s not involved in any archeological digging. They go to the beach or the pool or to church. I can’t tell you how many times the kids were sat down to watch a Disney DVD. Ruth and Nelson have one day to spend together alone, and they do something unexpected.
As for the crimes, a priest is murdered in the small village where our main characters are staying. Ruth is only a witness and Nelson has no jurisdiction. The reader isn’t really privy to the investigation, except for knowing that some World War II event is causing problems now. There wasn’t enough to keep me interested in that crime. Back in England, a prisoner is released and is threatening revenge. Nelson thought he had it handled before he left, and Judy thought she had it handled after that. This leads to the only important event that happens in this book.
This book is weak and makes me feel like the series is dying. I wonder if the author should have started this book with that important event, figured out where the chips should fall, and brought this series to a conclusion. Maybe this book just delayed that scenario until the next book.
I think the author boxed herself in by using Italy as the setting for this book. It was easy enough to get Ruth there with a request to consult on an archeological television show. She, of course, brings her daughter. Ruth's best friend, Shona, also comes along with her son. Shona provides a way to free Ruth from childcare. To get Nelson to Italy, the author writes in an earthquake. It’s minor by Italy’s standards, but it rattles Nelson enough that he races to Italy to make sure Ruth and Katie are okay. It’s strange that a beloved character, Cathbad, comes with Nelson. Cathbad seems to be there to help keep the kids occupied and to dispense his occasional nuggets of mystical wisdom.
Much is made of Ruth's self-image problem with her weight and Shona accentuates that. Shona is attractive and stylish, but also shallow and selfish. Ruth is self conscious when she appears at the beach in a one piece bathing suit while everyone else is wearing bikinis. I don’t see how these two are best friends. Shona seems to take advantage of Ruth when she takes a nap or goes off to flirt with Graziano.
Most of this book feels like watching someone else's video of their vacation. It’s dull and boring. Ruth completes filming for the tv show in just a few hours, but she’s not involved in any archeological digging. They go to the beach or the pool or to church. I can’t tell you how many times the kids were sat down to watch a Disney DVD. Ruth and Nelson have one day to spend together alone, and they do something unexpected.
As for the crimes, a priest is murdered in the small village where our main characters are staying. Ruth is only a witness and Nelson has no jurisdiction. The reader isn’t really privy to the investigation, except for knowing that some World War II event is causing problems now. There wasn’t enough to keep me interested in that crime. Back in England, a prisoner is released and is threatening revenge. Nelson thought he had it handled before he left, and Judy thought she had it handled after that. This leads to the only important event that happens in this book.
This book is weak and makes me feel like the series is dying. I wonder if the author should have started this book with that important event, figured out where the chips should fall, and brought this series to a conclusion. Maybe this book just delayed that scenario until the next book.
March 4, 2018
I will say from the outset that over the course of the Ruth Galloway books, I have had an up and down relationship with them, but feel almost a sense of guilt if I decide not to pick up the next in the series. The Dark Angel reaches the landmark of ten books, featuring the everywoman character of Galloway, who set apart by her sheer ordinariness, intelligence, frequent crisis of confidence, and somewhat unbelievably tangled personal relationships, has accrued a significant following of readers in her wake.
I will be honest, and say that this book didn’t really fill me with any sense of satisfaction. As the whole love triangle, now love square, rumbles on unabated, I felt that Griffiths focussing on the machinations of this neglected to provide any sort of interesting plot, despite despatching both Ruth and her on/off/on/off/on/off lover policeman Harry to the steamy surrounds of Italy. The central ‘mystery’ that Ruth finds herself embroiled was all a wee dull, and I didn’t really care who was being killed and for what reason. Also I think that Griffiths has slightly shot herself in the foot, by despatching a character one book too early, as the continuing existence of this person could easily have let them survive a bit longer to spice things up a bit. In fact, the way they were despatched was a bit ludicrous too. Also it felt a bit one-out, one-in as the closing sentence of the book heralds the reappearance of a figure from Ruth’s past, who may or may not add a bit of energy to the series.
On a more positive note, I always appreciate Ruth’s witty asides, and her day to day battles with weight, appearance, and desperately seeking to not say the wrong thing at the wrong time. I love her groundedness, and her professional demeanour, along with the insight into archaeology that arise from the books. I will read the next one, and undoubtedly the next, but unfortunately The Dark Angel didn’t quite hit the spot for me this time.
I will be honest, and say that this book didn’t really fill me with any sense of satisfaction. As the whole love triangle, now love square, rumbles on unabated, I felt that Griffiths focussing on the machinations of this neglected to provide any sort of interesting plot, despite despatching both Ruth and her on/off/on/off/on/off lover policeman Harry to the steamy surrounds of Italy. The central ‘mystery’ that Ruth finds herself embroiled was all a wee dull, and I didn’t really care who was being killed and for what reason. Also I think that Griffiths has slightly shot herself in the foot, by despatching a character one book too early, as the continuing existence of this person could easily have let them survive a bit longer to spice things up a bit. In fact, the way they were despatched was a bit ludicrous too. Also it felt a bit one-out, one-in as the closing sentence of the book heralds the reappearance of a figure from Ruth’s past, who may or may not add a bit of energy to the series.
On a more positive note, I always appreciate Ruth’s witty asides, and her day to day battles with weight, appearance, and desperately seeking to not say the wrong thing at the wrong time. I love her groundedness, and her professional demeanour, along with the insight into archaeology that arise from the books. I will read the next one, and undoubtedly the next, but unfortunately The Dark Angel didn’t quite hit the spot for me this time.
April 17, 2018
3.5 stars
When I started reading this, I couldn’t help but think about how far these characters have come. There’s a personal story arc that has evolved at a snappy pace from the beginning & it shows no sign of slowing down here.
As the book opens, we find Ruth in a bit of a funk. Nothing like going to a wedding to make you reflect on your life as a singe mom. Especially when the father of your daughter is there with his pregnant wife. So when the chance to check out old bones in Italy comes along, Ruth packs up Kate & runs away.
Angelo Morelli is a charismatic Italian archeologist with a problem. Someone is messing with his dig site & his head. He need some publicity to bolster interest & funding so calls old friend Dr. Ruth Galloway. In short order Ruth arrives in the beautiful small town of Castello degli Angeli with Kate, best friend Shona & her son. But from the start, it’s clear not everyone is happy about her visit.
There are several plot lines that emerge from the Italian side of the story. A mysterious immigrant named Samir, the local cleric anxious to talk to Ruth & a mystery from WWll involving Angelo’s grandfather. Back in King’s Lynn, Nelson gets news a convicted killer has been released. He’s responsible for putting the guy away & remembers his threat to get even. Probably not a good time to dash off to Italy.
A large part of the book, much more than previous ones, is devoted to the entangled love lives of Ruth, Nelson, Michelle & Tim. At times, it felt like the author is getting ready to tie up some long standing story arcs in the next instalment & uses this book to clear her plate. The ending certainly takes care of one aspect…..lordie, I did NOT see that coming. The result (for me) was the plot lines dealing with mystery & archeology were underserved. I desperately wanted to know more about Angelo’s grandfather time in the resistance & learn Samir’s history as I found him an intriguing character. These are glossed over & the whole Italian side of the story kind of fizzles down to a neatly tied up resolution. There’s a lot more going on back in Norfolk but Ruth & Nelson are absent for all of it. We also spend significant time listening in on the inner thoughts of our 4 star-crossed lovers as each considers their situation.
So…not my favourite in the series. I love Ruth. In many ways she is an every-woman whom you can relate to & I enjoy that the focus has always been on her strength & intelligence instead of her appearance. This is book #10 & I think the author in that tricky spot where she needs to fish or cut bait re: the long running love triangle (or square). So personally, I’m going to consider this one a small bump in the road & look forward to catching up with the gang in #11.
When I started reading this, I couldn’t help but think about how far these characters have come. There’s a personal story arc that has evolved at a snappy pace from the beginning & it shows no sign of slowing down here.
As the book opens, we find Ruth in a bit of a funk. Nothing like going to a wedding to make you reflect on your life as a singe mom. Especially when the father of your daughter is there with his pregnant wife. So when the chance to check out old bones in Italy comes along, Ruth packs up Kate & runs away.
Angelo Morelli is a charismatic Italian archeologist with a problem. Someone is messing with his dig site & his head. He need some publicity to bolster interest & funding so calls old friend Dr. Ruth Galloway. In short order Ruth arrives in the beautiful small town of Castello degli Angeli with Kate, best friend Shona & her son. But from the start, it’s clear not everyone is happy about her visit.
There are several plot lines that emerge from the Italian side of the story. A mysterious immigrant named Samir, the local cleric anxious to talk to Ruth & a mystery from WWll involving Angelo’s grandfather. Back in King’s Lynn, Nelson gets news a convicted killer has been released. He’s responsible for putting the guy away & remembers his threat to get even. Probably not a good time to dash off to Italy.
A large part of the book, much more than previous ones, is devoted to the entangled love lives of Ruth, Nelson, Michelle & Tim. At times, it felt like the author is getting ready to tie up some long standing story arcs in the next instalment & uses this book to clear her plate. The ending certainly takes care of one aspect…..lordie, I did NOT see that coming. The result (for me) was the plot lines dealing with mystery & archeology were underserved. I desperately wanted to know more about Angelo’s grandfather time in the resistance & learn Samir’s history as I found him an intriguing character. These are glossed over & the whole Italian side of the story kind of fizzles down to a neatly tied up resolution. There’s a lot more going on back in Norfolk but Ruth & Nelson are absent for all of it. We also spend significant time listening in on the inner thoughts of our 4 star-crossed lovers as each considers their situation.
So…not my favourite in the series. I love Ruth. In many ways she is an every-woman whom you can relate to & I enjoy that the focus has always been on her strength & intelligence instead of her appearance. This is book #10 & I think the author in that tricky spot where she needs to fish or cut bait re: the long running love triangle (or square). So personally, I’m going to consider this one a small bump in the road & look forward to catching up with the gang in #11.
April 1, 2020
A week later and I’m still not sure how to put into words my disappointment with this and the last book. Both had interesting mysteries and this Dr Ruth Galloway installment also featured the Italian shore and lots of new characters... BUT...
Quite simply, Ruth’s personal life is quickly dominating these books, and the personal plot lines are starting to resemble a TV soap opera (a term
I caught in another review that finally helped me understand why I’ve been reluctant to write a review).
I just want Ruth’s personal life to have some sort of permanent resolution so EVERYONE— readers and characters— can all move on and change up the personal narrative. I prefer crazy plot twists that are related to the mystery!
Maybe my ambivalence is also tied to the fact I’ve caught up on this series— but, for the most part, I’ve enjoyed the 4-star trip and look forward to the next book. ‘Cuz no doubt there are more crazy twists to come— and like a soap opera fan, I’m still kinda addicted!!
Quite simply, Ruth’s personal life is quickly dominating these books, and the personal plot lines are starting to resemble a TV soap opera (a term
I caught in another review that finally helped me understand why I’ve been reluctant to write a review).
I just want Ruth’s personal life to have some sort of permanent resolution so EVERYONE— readers and characters— can all move on and change up the personal narrative. I prefer crazy plot twists that are related to the mystery!
Maybe my ambivalence is also tied to the fact I’ve caught up on this series— but, for the most part, I’ve enjoyed the 4-star trip and look forward to the next book. ‘Cuz no doubt there are more crazy twists to come— and like a soap opera fan, I’m still kinda addicted!!
February 26, 2018
More soap opera than crime solving this time around, but there's nothing wrong with that. Occasionally.
May 14, 2018
Ruth is dealing with a lot on the personal front, including the fact that Nelson's wife, Michelle, is pregnant. Ruth and Nelson's daughter, Kate, is six now, and while Michelle knows about Kate, Nelson's older daughters do not. Nelson was very close to leaving Michelle for Ruth, before he found out his wife was pregnant again. So when Ruth is invited to Italy to assist a former friend, Angelo Morelli, in looking at some bones, she is actually a bit excited at the thought of a holiday/work trip. It will give her and Kate a chance to get away. They embark on the trip along with Ruth's friend Shona and her son, Louis. Once there, Ruth realizes how entrenched the people of the Italian village are in the past--including what happened during World War II. Further, Angelo is convinced someone is trying to kill him. Before she knows it, Ruth is immersed in a modern-day murder mystery: something she can't seem to avoid, no matter where she travels.
It's no secret that I love Ruth and Elly Griffiths' series of novels featuring our intelligent, plucky heroine. Despite the fact that I know absolutely nothing about bones, I identify with her (e.g., stepping on a plane with Kate for the first time and feeling nervous flying with her daughter, whose safety "overrides everything else"). Ruth's wit, sarcasm, and sense of humor are always absolutely spot-on, and it's wonderful being back with her and her circle of pals, especially the grumpy yet protective Nelson. The Nelson/Ruth dynamic is its typically complicated yet oddly sweet self, and there's a surprising amount of progress or information regarding the characters' personal lives in this novel.
As mentioned, these books are always just lovely and humorous. The narration style is impeccable and works flawlessly. Each character is so perfectly "them," and I enjoyed that we heard from a lot of characters this time around, even Nelson's elder daughter. Oh, and yes, there's also a great mystery plot thrown in, involving an Italian town, some bones (of course), and a variety of deeply buried secrets. Griffiths introduced us to some new characters with the new locale, and I found the mystery to be interesting and engaging. It was front and center enough to keep us interested, but refreshing to get a little more movement on the characters' personal lives, too.
Overall, another winner from Griffiths. As always, I cannot wait for the next Ruth novel (especially because there is some serious unresolved business by the end of this one!). I think of Ruth, Harry, Kate, and the entire cast as dear friends by now. You can read this as a stand-alone, but as always, I recommend reading the whole series, because it's just so darn good. 4.5 stars.
A huge thanks to the publisher and Edelweiss for a copy of this novel in return for an unbiased review; it is available in the U.S. everywhere as of 05/15/2018.
Blog ~ Twitter ~ Facebook ~ Google+ ~ Instagram
It's no secret that I love Ruth and Elly Griffiths' series of novels featuring our intelligent, plucky heroine. Despite the fact that I know absolutely nothing about bones, I identify with her (e.g., stepping on a plane with Kate for the first time and feeling nervous flying with her daughter, whose safety "overrides everything else"). Ruth's wit, sarcasm, and sense of humor are always absolutely spot-on, and it's wonderful being back with her and her circle of pals, especially the grumpy yet protective Nelson. The Nelson/Ruth dynamic is its typically complicated yet oddly sweet self, and there's a surprising amount of progress or information regarding the characters' personal lives in this novel.
As mentioned, these books are always just lovely and humorous. The narration style is impeccable and works flawlessly. Each character is so perfectly "them," and I enjoyed that we heard from a lot of characters this time around, even Nelson's elder daughter. Oh, and yes, there's also a great mystery plot thrown in, involving an Italian town, some bones (of course), and a variety of deeply buried secrets. Griffiths introduced us to some new characters with the new locale, and I found the mystery to be interesting and engaging. It was front and center enough to keep us interested, but refreshing to get a little more movement on the characters' personal lives, too.
Overall, another winner from Griffiths. As always, I cannot wait for the next Ruth novel (especially because there is some serious unresolved business by the end of this one!). I think of Ruth, Harry, Kate, and the entire cast as dear friends by now. You can read this as a stand-alone, but as always, I recommend reading the whole series, because it's just so darn good. 4.5 stars.
A huge thanks to the publisher and Edelweiss for a copy of this novel in return for an unbiased review; it is available in the U.S. everywhere as of 05/15/2018.
Blog ~ Twitter ~ Facebook ~ Google+ ~ Instagram
March 4, 2018
Really annoyed me, the series has been going downhill for me for a while but this one was really not a mystery more the Ruth and Nelson melodrama. I think this might be the last one I read in this series.
December 29, 2020
This book doesn’t quite fit the series, for a start most of the action takes place in Italy. But forget the bones, this story is all about the characters.
Ruth is invited to Italy to provide expert advice at a Roman dig by Dr Angelo Morelli, another former lover! She is keen on the idea of a break after learning that DCI Nelson’s wife, Michelle, is pregnant again. Nelson is the father of Ruth’s daughter, 7 year old Kate. There’s also some uncertainty about the father of Michelle’s baby-to-be. It’s complicated. Ruth invites her friend Shona and her son Louis along to Italy for company and childminding. Dr Morelli has made accomodation available in the charming hillside town of Castello degli Angeli. The dig is nothing exciting for the overall story arc.
In a convenient plot device (I struggled with this) there is a minor earthquake and Ruth’s phone is off so Nelson hears about it and assumes the worst and is on a plane to Italy the next morning, accompanied by Cathbad. Of course. The earthquake has disrupted the local graveyard behind the church and a skeleton is uncovered that shouldn’t be there. The next thing we know, Ruth is embroiled in yet another murder investigation.
Meanwhile, back in England, tragedy strikes. And it has a unfortunate impact on Ruth and Nelson’s non-relationship. I really can’t say any more. I think this book was weaker than the rest of the series but I’m already onto the next one. And then I’m almost there! 3.5. Stars rounded up but it’s a close thing! But by the time you get to book 10 you’re in it for the long haul.
Ruth is invited to Italy to provide expert advice at a Roman dig by Dr Angelo Morelli, another former lover! She is keen on the idea of a break after learning that DCI Nelson’s wife, Michelle, is pregnant again. Nelson is the father of Ruth’s daughter, 7 year old Kate. There’s also some uncertainty about the father of Michelle’s baby-to-be. It’s complicated. Ruth invites her friend Shona and her son Louis along to Italy for company and childminding. Dr Morelli has made accomodation available in the charming hillside town of Castello degli Angeli. The dig is nothing exciting for the overall story arc.
In a convenient plot device (I struggled with this) there is a minor earthquake and Ruth’s phone is off so Nelson hears about it and assumes the worst and is on a plane to Italy the next morning, accompanied by Cathbad. Of course. The earthquake has disrupted the local graveyard behind the church and a skeleton is uncovered that shouldn’t be there. The next thing we know, Ruth is embroiled in yet another murder investigation.
Meanwhile, back in England, tragedy strikes. And it has a unfortunate impact on Ruth and Nelson’s non-relationship. I really can’t say any more. I think this book was weaker than the rest of the series but I’m already onto the next one. And then I’m almost there! 3.5. Stars rounded up but it’s a close thing! But by the time you get to book 10 you’re in it for the long haul.
January 4, 2020
Buddy read with GR friend Hilary, reading sections at relatively close to the same time and then discussing each at least a bit.
I’m happy that this was my first 2020 book. I love having this mystery series highlighted in my reading record. I’ve been zipping through these books. I had wanted to make them last so I wouldn’t have to start waiting the full length of time between publication dates for the next book(s) but I read books 1-9 between August and December 2019. Now book 10. Book 11 will be almost next. Book 12 doesn’t come out in the United States until June 2020 and in England in February 2020. These books/the series is addictive. Now I’ll have to wait. I will read her standalone book after book 11 and before book 12 and at some point I’d like to try her other series written under her real name, Domenica de Rosa.
I love the main characters, the additional characters, the temporary characters, the relationships (with one type of exception; I could do without all the soap opera stuff/the love triangles), the dogs & cats, the archelogy, the settings, the history, the cultures.
In this book I fell even more in love with one particular dog!
This one was even more amusing than most and I love the humor in these books. It was also a bit scary, in more than one arena, but not overly so.
I am loving Kate. I love Cathbad and I I did get a kick out of his being able to speak Italian. The characters and relationships are wonderful.
I always love the settings for these books, usually Norfolk, and sometimes other English counties, but up until now, England. Here I also liked “getting away” and enjoyed the Italian hill town setting as a main part of the story in this book. I did appreciate that some of the story still took place in Norfolk England.
Spoilers for this book, and all the previous books too:
I love how for each book the author auctions off a character name to raise money for a charity that helps teenagers who have cancer https://www.clicsargent.org.uk/ and how one of the temporary good characters carries the winner’s name. What a great idea. I love the rest of the author’s notes at the end of the book too because she explains where/what/who is real vs. what she makes up for the story.
I’m happy that this was my first 2020 book. I love having this mystery series highlighted in my reading record. I’ve been zipping through these books. I had wanted to make them last so I wouldn’t have to start waiting the full length of time between publication dates for the next book(s) but I read books 1-9 between August and December 2019. Now book 10. Book 11 will be almost next. Book 12 doesn’t come out in the United States until June 2020 and in England in February 2020. These books/the series is addictive. Now I’ll have to wait. I will read her standalone book after book 11 and before book 12 and at some point I’d like to try her other series written under her real name, Domenica de Rosa.
I love the main characters, the additional characters, the temporary characters, the relationships (with one type of exception; I could do without all the soap opera stuff/the love triangles), the dogs & cats, the archelogy, the settings, the history, the cultures.
In this book I fell even more in love with one particular dog!
This one was even more amusing than most and I love the humor in these books. It was also a bit scary, in more than one arena, but not overly so.
I am loving Kate. I love Cathbad and I I did get a kick out of his being able to speak Italian. The characters and relationships are wonderful.
I always love the settings for these books, usually Norfolk, and sometimes other English counties, but up until now, England. Here I also liked “getting away” and enjoyed the Italian hill town setting as a main part of the story in this book. I did appreciate that some of the story still took place in Norfolk England.
Spoilers for this book, and all the previous books too:
I love how for each book the author auctions off a character name to raise money for a charity that helps teenagers who have cancer https://www.clicsargent.org.uk/ and how one of the temporary good characters carries the winner’s name. What a great idea. I love the rest of the author’s notes at the end of the book too because she explains where/what/who is real vs. what she makes up for the story.
January 1, 2019
The last one of the series so far. This time the book was situated mainly in Italy instead of Norfolk, which made a nice change. I just love the atmosphere and all the characters and I hope book 11 will come out soon. Can't wait!
June 12, 2024
This installment of Ruth Galloway was not quite as satisfying as the previous volumes, possibly because all the players are waiting for the other shoe to drop (or at least for Michelle to give birth). Ruth herself is still the independent woman that I appreciate. She is building an academic reputation and has become a recognized forensic anthropology expert. This expertise results in her involvement in an archeological site in Italy and dealing with a former lover, Angelo Morelli.
This is the book where I came to the conclusion that Harry Nelson is much more interested in Ruth than I had realized before. He is brought up short when he turns up at a site where bones have been found and is confronted with Ruth's manager Phil, who is filling in for her. Harry is immediately pissed that he doesn't get to see Ruth and that she and Kate have gone to Italy without telling him. Despite the fact that his wife is pregnant, not feeling great, and about to undergo a prenatal scan, when there is an earthquake in Italy Nelson buys a plane ticket and hares off to make sure they're okay. This seems to also cinch things for Michelle.
Needless to say, Ruth has distinctly mixed feelings about the whole thing. On one hand, she was quietly sad at Dave Clough's wedding at the beginning of the novel. However she has no desire to have anyone trying to run her life, which Nelson would surely try to do (even more than he already does).
Griffiths gives us good, tense situations in both Italy and Norfolk. They both provide the momentum driving the plot, while she further tangles the personal relationships. The whole Ruth-Harry-Michelle-Tim conundrum gets altered irrevocably by book's end, but we get no closer to knowing how things will shake out. That's an excellent hook to get me invested in the next book, although (as usual) I will try to hold out as long as possible before grabbing it.
This is the book where I came to the conclusion that Harry Nelson is much more interested in Ruth than I had realized before. He is brought up short when he turns up at a site where bones have been found and is confronted with Ruth's manager Phil, who is filling in for her. Harry is immediately pissed that he doesn't get to see Ruth and that she and Kate have gone to Italy without telling him. Despite the fact that his wife is pregnant, not feeling great, and about to undergo a prenatal scan, when there is an earthquake in Italy Nelson buys a plane ticket and hares off to make sure they're okay. This seems to also cinch things for Michelle.
Needless to say, Ruth has distinctly mixed feelings about the whole thing. On one hand, she was quietly sad at Dave Clough's wedding at the beginning of the novel. However she has no desire to have anyone trying to run her life, which Nelson would surely try to do (even more than he already does).
Griffiths gives us good, tense situations in both Italy and Norfolk. They both provide the momentum driving the plot, while she further tangles the personal relationships. The whole Ruth-Harry-Michelle-Tim conundrum gets altered irrevocably by book's end, but we get no closer to knowing how things will shake out. That's an excellent hook to get me invested in the next book, although (as usual) I will try to hold out as long as possible before grabbing it.
April 19, 2018
Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for providing me with an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review!
Ruth, still reeling from the events of the end of the last book, is living day to day, trying to hang out. An old friend calls her up and invites her to help with some bones in Italy, so she packs up Kate, Shona, and Louis and heads to Italy... where of course, murder happens. Meanwhile, back in Norfolk, one of Nelson's cadre of historical arrests is released, and stuff happens at home as well.
I enjoyed watching Ruth getting to explore the little Italian town, be on vacation, and get to meet some new characters. The relationships from prior books all develop a little more, and we get some depth added to at least one character who previously had very little page time. And while some of the events at the end were expected (because of well-written build up throughout the course of the novel), one big thing was completely unexpected, at least to me.
Yet again, a Ruth Galloway novel that doesn't disappoint - it's like Elly Griffiths knows what she's doing! ;) Thank goodness she does. And thank goodness the publishers keep coming back for more. I know I'm ready for the next one!
Ruth, still reeling from the events of the end of the last book, is living day to day, trying to hang out. An old friend calls her up and invites her to help with some bones in Italy, so she packs up Kate, Shona, and Louis and heads to Italy... where of course, murder happens. Meanwhile, back in Norfolk, one of Nelson's cadre of historical arrests is released, and stuff happens at home as well.
I enjoyed watching Ruth getting to explore the little Italian town, be on vacation, and get to meet some new characters. The relationships from prior books all develop a little more, and we get some depth added to at least one character who previously had very little page time. And while some of the events at the end were expected (because of well-written build up throughout the course of the novel), one big thing was completely unexpected, at least to me.
Yet again, a Ruth Galloway novel that doesn't disappoint - it's like Elly Griffiths knows what she's doing! ;) Thank goodness she does. And thank goodness the publishers keep coming back for more. I know I'm ready for the next one!
July 7, 2018
The Dark Angel by Elly Griffiths (Ruth Galloway, #10)
Another excellent entry in the Ruth Galloway series by this gifted author.
Ruth receives an urgent message from a friend in Italy. a friend whom she has not seen in years. Angelo Morelli needs an archaeologist of Ruth's standing to identify bones which he has uncovered in his native town in Italy. Ruth prepares Kate as well as Shone along with Louis(shone Phil's son) for the journey overseas.
DCI Nelson is notified of the release of murderer Mickey Webb. Nelson had played a huge part in getting this monster put away...he had hoped for a life sentence. The last words after Webb's sentencing were that he would get even with Nelson no matter how long it took him.
The writing was smoothly written as the author brought the reader from Italy covering Ruth's journey back to England to cover Nelson's family. This story did not end the way I thought it would end. The ending actually took me by surprise.
Excelent story-excellent series-highly recommended.
Another excellent entry in the Ruth Galloway series by this gifted author.
Ruth receives an urgent message from a friend in Italy. a friend whom she has not seen in years. Angelo Morelli needs an archaeologist of Ruth's standing to identify bones which he has uncovered in his native town in Italy. Ruth prepares Kate as well as Shone along with Louis(shone Phil's son) for the journey overseas.
DCI Nelson is notified of the release of murderer Mickey Webb. Nelson had played a huge part in getting this monster put away...he had hoped for a life sentence. The last words after Webb's sentencing were that he would get even with Nelson no matter how long it took him.
The writing was smoothly written as the author brought the reader from Italy covering Ruth's journey back to England to cover Nelson's family. This story did not end the way I thought it would end. The ending actually took me by surprise.
Excelent story-excellent series-highly recommended.
May 8, 2018
The latest Ruth Galloway novel takes her on a business/holiday away from King's Lynn and Norfolk to sunny, hot Italy. She, her friend Shona and their children, Kate and Louis, are traveling because Ruth has been invited by a long-ago colleague to assist with the identification of some bones. He does have ulterior motives: Galloway is well known and these bones are to be televised! But much of the time will be vacation before her oncoming semester.
Meanwhile, at home, in a separate plot line, a man is released on parole from prison after 10 years. His crime: directing the arson that killed his wife and children. Among the involved officers: Harry Nelson. Nelson's boss alerts him to be watchful as they have difficulty believing this man truly has found religion and reformed. Additionally, Nelson's wife is very much pregnant. And Ruth's mother has died, simultaneous with the end of the last book, The Chalk Pit leaving Ruth's father living alone in London.. So there is much happening with our regulars.
Now I have provided the set up....I won't give away much plot. Needless to say there is a lot about to happen. As always, Griffiths' writing kept me glued to the story, moving from one development to the next. In Italy, there are major secrets that Ruth begins to suspect but which impact people in the small town where she stays. A town that still holds strong grudges dating to WWII. In King's Lynn the regulars are all on board, as we want them to be.
There are some events toward the end that left me wondering a bit. But I do trust Griffiths and admire the characters that she writes. I'm very much looking forward to the next book in the series. I recommend this novel as I have recommended every other book in the series.
A copy of this book was provided by the publisher through NetGalley in return for an honest review.
Meanwhile, at home, in a separate plot line, a man is released on parole from prison after 10 years. His crime: directing the arson that killed his wife and children. Among the involved officers: Harry Nelson. Nelson's boss alerts him to be watchful as they have difficulty believing this man truly has found religion and reformed. Additionally, Nelson's wife is very much pregnant. And Ruth's mother has died, simultaneous with the end of the last book, The Chalk Pit leaving Ruth's father living alone in London.. So there is much happening with our regulars.
Now I have provided the set up....I won't give away much plot. Needless to say there is a lot about to happen. As always, Griffiths' writing kept me glued to the story, moving from one development to the next. In Italy, there are major secrets that Ruth begins to suspect but which impact people in the small town where she stays. A town that still holds strong grudges dating to WWII. In King's Lynn the regulars are all on board, as we want them to be.
There are some events toward the end that left me wondering a bit. But I do trust Griffiths and admire the characters that she writes. I'm very much looking forward to the next book in the series. I recommend this novel as I have recommended every other book in the series.
A copy of this book was provided by the publisher through NetGalley in return for an honest review.
January 6, 2020
Read as a buddy read with Lisa Vegan, reading sections each day and chatting after.
We raced through this one, Laura is right, these are addictive and we both wanted to read the next book soon after!
Although this is another great mystery with some wonderful characters and settings this probably was the least enjoyable book of the series for me in terms of the mystery. Although still good, it wasn't quite as enjoyable or complex as the other mysteries.
The characters are good to be with again, I do enjoy looking into their lives and I do enjoy all of the characters in these stories. There are slight downsides for me that I almost considered giving this 3 stars for The other downside for me is the continuity mistakes, vegetarian characters eating pork and a vegan character eating dairy products and eggs and Kate's parentage being out in the open and then her sisters not knowing. I suppose this is a 3.5 stars for me but there is a lot about these books I really like.
Goodreads friend Laura warned us that we might feel the need to read the next book after and she was right. Some series are good to go back to after a break but these do feel like ones you have to keep going back to!
We raced through this one, Laura is right, these are addictive and we both wanted to read the next book soon after!
Although this is another great mystery with some wonderful characters and settings this probably was the least enjoyable book of the series for me in terms of the mystery. Although still good, it wasn't quite as enjoyable or complex as the other mysteries.
The characters are good to be with again, I do enjoy looking into their lives and I do enjoy all of the characters in these stories. There are slight downsides for me that I almost considered giving this 3 stars for The other downside for me is the continuity mistakes, vegetarian characters eating pork and a vegan character eating dairy products and eggs and Kate's parentage being out in the open and then her sisters not knowing. I suppose this is a 3.5 stars for me but there is a lot about these books I really like.
Goodreads friend Laura warned us that we might feel the need to read the next book after and she was right. Some series are good to go back to after a break but these do feel like ones you have to keep going back to!
May 10, 2018
First Sentence: ‘This grave has lain undisturbed for over two thousand years.’
Archeologist Ruth Galloway and her daughter are invited to Italy by fellow archaeologist, and television host, Angelo Morelli to help identify bones found in a hillside town. Fontana Liri was Angelo’s ancestral home and where his grandfather played an important part during the resistance movement of WWII. But if the war is over, why are threats, and attempts being made on Angelo’s life? In England, DI Harry Nelson learns of the impending release of Micky Webb, a man he put in prison. Is Micky now threatening Harry, his family, and pregnant wife? Still, a natural disaster sends Harry to Italy to ensure the safety of his former lover, Ruth, and the daughter they produced together.
Author’s notes can provide such fascinating information. One should always take the time to read them.
There is an interesting juxtaposition of the focus on religion and Catholicism, and relationships involving infidelity. And infidelity does play a major role in this book, and series. In fact, it basically dominates the plot of the book.
Griffiths runs the separate storylines of Ruth and Nelson in parallel and it works. One is never confused as to which plot thread is being addressed. The story of Samer, the Syrian refugee is sad and typical of that which the Syrian people, many of whom are Catholics, are experiencing.
The information about the history of the area in Italy is interesting. The information regarding the positions in which people are buried in the church’s cemetery is even more so. It also provides an interesting perspective on some Italians’ views toward the Roman evacuations--”There are too many Roman sites in Italy,’ says Angelo. ‘There are only two metro lines in Rome because whenever they start digging, they come up against another damn amphitheater. The Romans are everywhere.’”
Ruth is a very real, very human character. In spite of her intelligence and capabilities, she is almost painfully self-critical and self-deprecating. Cathbad is a character one can’t help but like. He’s a Druid who—“…views the rules as guidance only, and guidance for other people at that.”
There are a couple of wonderful literary references to make one smile—“Stop it, she tells herself, you’re not Miss Marple, this has nothing to do with you.”—and one which is very Sherlock Holmes—”Nelson tries to cast his mind back. He remembers bloody Tim talking about something he called a memory house. Apparently, you have to go in and search through the rooms until you find the hidden memory.” She also makes mention of reading Ian Rankin.
The disposition of the corpses, both in England and in Italy provides one another piece of historical information. It’s one of those great “Who knew?” moments.
There is suspense, both in Italy and in England, and both are well done and include some good twists.
“The Dark Angel” is not Griffith’s best book by far. One could say the focus of the book was primarily on relationships and infidelity, with a small percent on the mysteries, and a tiny percent on archeology. Yes, there is a powerful cliff-hanger ending, but it may not be enough to ensure one will continue with the series.
THE DARK ANGEL (Pol Proc-Ruth Galloway/Harry Nelson-Italy/England-Contemp) - Okay
Griffiths, Elly – 10th in series
Houghton Mifflin Harcourt – May 2018
Archeologist Ruth Galloway and her daughter are invited to Italy by fellow archaeologist, and television host, Angelo Morelli to help identify bones found in a hillside town. Fontana Liri was Angelo’s ancestral home and where his grandfather played an important part during the resistance movement of WWII. But if the war is over, why are threats, and attempts being made on Angelo’s life? In England, DI Harry Nelson learns of the impending release of Micky Webb, a man he put in prison. Is Micky now threatening Harry, his family, and pregnant wife? Still, a natural disaster sends Harry to Italy to ensure the safety of his former lover, Ruth, and the daughter they produced together.
Author’s notes can provide such fascinating information. One should always take the time to read them.
There is an interesting juxtaposition of the focus on religion and Catholicism, and relationships involving infidelity. And infidelity does play a major role in this book, and series. In fact, it basically dominates the plot of the book.
Griffiths runs the separate storylines of Ruth and Nelson in parallel and it works. One is never confused as to which plot thread is being addressed. The story of Samer, the Syrian refugee is sad and typical of that which the Syrian people, many of whom are Catholics, are experiencing.
The information about the history of the area in Italy is interesting. The information regarding the positions in which people are buried in the church’s cemetery is even more so. It also provides an interesting perspective on some Italians’ views toward the Roman evacuations--”There are too many Roman sites in Italy,’ says Angelo. ‘There are only two metro lines in Rome because whenever they start digging, they come up against another damn amphitheater. The Romans are everywhere.’”
Ruth is a very real, very human character. In spite of her intelligence and capabilities, she is almost painfully self-critical and self-deprecating. Cathbad is a character one can’t help but like. He’s a Druid who—“…views the rules as guidance only, and guidance for other people at that.”
There are a couple of wonderful literary references to make one smile—“Stop it, she tells herself, you’re not Miss Marple, this has nothing to do with you.”—and one which is very Sherlock Holmes—”Nelson tries to cast his mind back. He remembers bloody Tim talking about something he called a memory house. Apparently, you have to go in and search through the rooms until you find the hidden memory.” She also makes mention of reading Ian Rankin.
The disposition of the corpses, both in England and in Italy provides one another piece of historical information. It’s one of those great “Who knew?” moments.
There is suspense, both in Italy and in England, and both are well done and include some good twists.
“The Dark Angel” is not Griffith’s best book by far. One could say the focus of the book was primarily on relationships and infidelity, with a small percent on the mysteries, and a tiny percent on archeology. Yes, there is a powerful cliff-hanger ending, but it may not be enough to ensure one will continue with the series.
THE DARK ANGEL (Pol Proc-Ruth Galloway/Harry Nelson-Italy/England-Contemp) - Okay
Griffiths, Elly – 10th in series
Houghton Mifflin Harcourt – May 2018
May 15, 2018
If there were an award for the most annoying characters in a book series (that you keep reading, despite the fact) would I award it to Ruth Galloway & DCI Harry Nelson. Sorry, to everyone that loves the series, but Ruth inner monologue about how fat she is and how religion sucks, etc. just rubs me the wrong way. Nelson's thoughts aren't much better. So, when you look at it do they fit very well together. To bad that Nelson is married and his wife is pregnant, although the father of the baby could be Nelson or Michelle's lover. Yeah, it's like a soap opera. The personal stuff is probably why I keep reading the books, it's so melodramatic.
I found The Dark Angel to be OK. To set most of the story in Italy was a nice move and I came to enjoy most of the book, yes, there were too much ranting inner monologues, but part of me has gotten used to it and I have started to look forward to seeing how many times Ruth can think that she is fat or that all the other women are so beautiful. As for the case, I have to admit that I was wrong about the ending, I had my mind set on a different conclusion on the storyline in Italy. I quite like the fact that I was wrong, kudos to the author.
Back in England is a man released from prison that swore to get revenge on DCI Nelson, but the man in question has found God, or so he claims. Nelson isn't sure, and he's worried the man would do something to him or any of the other's involved with the case. But, then he learns that an earthquake has occurred in Italy where Ruth and his daughter are staying and he leaves his pregnant wife and daughter behind to go to Italy. Leaving them all alone...
The Dark Angel is better than the previous book. I told myself that I would give this series one more chance and I'm actually glad that I read the book, and yes I will read the next. Especially since the book ended with a cliffhanger...
I want to thank Houghton Mifflin Harcourt for providing me with a free copy through Edelweiss for an honest review!
I found The Dark Angel to be OK. To set most of the story in Italy was a nice move and I came to enjoy most of the book, yes, there were too much ranting inner monologues, but part of me has gotten used to it and I have started to look forward to seeing how many times Ruth can think that she is fat or that all the other women are so beautiful. As for the case, I have to admit that I was wrong about the ending, I had my mind set on a different conclusion on the storyline in Italy. I quite like the fact that I was wrong, kudos to the author.
Back in England is a man released from prison that swore to get revenge on DCI Nelson, but the man in question has found God, or so he claims. Nelson isn't sure, and he's worried the man would do something to him or any of the other's involved with the case. But, then he learns that an earthquake has occurred in Italy where Ruth and his daughter are staying and he leaves his pregnant wife and daughter behind to go to Italy. Leaving them all alone...
The Dark Angel is better than the previous book. I told myself that I would give this series one more chance and I'm actually glad that I read the book, and yes I will read the next. Especially since the book ended with a cliffhanger...
I want to thank Houghton Mifflin Harcourt for providing me with a free copy through Edelweiss for an honest review!
March 18, 2018
Ruth Galloway is one of my favorite detectives, and I love this series by Elly Griffiths because it is unique, clever, and smartly written. The Dark Angel, the 10th installment, takes Ruth with her friend Shona and their children in tow to Italy to investigate a group of bones found by an Italian archaeologist in Fontana Liri. While investigating the ancient bones, Ruth is pulled into a modern murder that eventually unveils a secret kept since World War 2. Griffiths’ descriptions of Fontana Liri are spectacular; I felt like I was there. The Dark Angel is a solid addition to the series and well worth reading. My one complaint is that I wish that Ruth’s personal life would settle a bit more than it has so far. I received this book to read and review; all opinions are my own.
October 18, 2024
Another Ruth Galloway book that has now become a favorite. I’m going to be sad when this series is over. I just love these books!
December 16, 2017
For long-time fans of the delightful Ruth Galloway (newbies should start at the beginning of the series), this takes Ruth out of her usual setting and places her in Italy. With some plot manipulation, Griffiths gets Nelson there, too, and we have two rather thin crime plots unravelling, one at home and one in Italy.
As ever, plot is shown to be Griffiths' weakness - but Ruth is such a great character, and the narrative voice so slyly funny that I can forgive a lot. Here the long-term characters don't have much to do, and we tip into overheated soap-opera in places.
3.5 stars for one of the weaker entries in a favourite series - hopefully Ruth and friends will be back to their witty best next time.
Thanks to Quercus for ARCs via Amazon Vine and NetGalley
As ever, plot is shown to be Griffiths' weakness - but Ruth is such a great character, and the narrative voice so slyly funny that I can forgive a lot. Here the long-term characters don't have much to do, and we tip into overheated soap-opera in places.
3.5 stars for one of the weaker entries in a favourite series - hopefully Ruth and friends will be back to their witty best next time.
Thanks to Quercus for ARCs via Amazon Vine and NetGalley
March 20, 2018
4.5 stars
I love the Ruth Galloway series and eagerly look forward to the next book. I try to read slowly to make it last longer but I can never do it. I have to keep turning the pages and this is no exception. I was a little nervous because Ruth goes off to help out on an archaeology study in Italy. She is going to vacation too so takes Shona, Kate, and Louis (Shona's son) with her. I get nervous when authors send their characters to Italy especially after Elizabeth George sent Barbara Havers there and it was just awful.
Ruth behaves oddly in Italy too. She spends little time on the project, goes swimming a lot and seems quite aimless. It's hard to picture her out of Norfolk and maybe that's why she seems to be drifting. There's an earthquake in a town 20 miles away and Nelson flies out with Cathbad to check on them. I think how wonderful it would be to live in Europe where you can fly to Italy the next day. Their is a murder and Ruth and Nelson are dragged into the investigation.
Meanwhile back in Norfolk, a horrible criminal is released from prison. How a man convicted of arranging the murder of his wife and children is released is beyond me. He has vowed to get vengeance on Nelson. Weird things start happening and you wonder if it's the criminal. Meanwhile Michelle is getting reacquainted with an old friend while Nelson is in Italy. The love triangle heats up.
Then the book takes an unexpected twist that will echo for books to come. I can't wait to see where it goes next. The author is unafraid to take chances and I am excited for the next book.
I love the Ruth Galloway series and eagerly look forward to the next book. I try to read slowly to make it last longer but I can never do it. I have to keep turning the pages and this is no exception. I was a little nervous because Ruth goes off to help out on an archaeology study in Italy. She is going to vacation too so takes Shona, Kate, and Louis (Shona's son) with her. I get nervous when authors send their characters to Italy especially after Elizabeth George sent Barbara Havers there and it was just awful.
Ruth behaves oddly in Italy too. She spends little time on the project, goes swimming a lot and seems quite aimless. It's hard to picture her out of Norfolk and maybe that's why she seems to be drifting. There's an earthquake in a town 20 miles away and Nelson flies out with Cathbad to check on them. I think how wonderful it would be to live in Europe where you can fly to Italy the next day. Their is a murder and Ruth and Nelson are dragged into the investigation.
Meanwhile back in Norfolk, a horrible criminal is released from prison. How a man convicted of arranging the murder of his wife and children is released is beyond me. He has vowed to get vengeance on Nelson. Weird things start happening and you wonder if it's the criminal. Meanwhile Michelle is getting reacquainted with an old friend while Nelson is in Italy. The love triangle heats up.
Then the book takes an unexpected twist that will echo for books to come. I can't wait to see where it goes next. The author is unafraid to take chances and I am excited for the next book.
April 23, 2018
Ruth Galloway is one of my favorite crime novel characters. She is an academic specializing in ancient bones. A colleague and old friend invites her to Italy to look at some old bones, and Ruth, desperate for a holiday, takes off for 2 weeks in Italy with her 6year-old daughter Kate and friend Shona, and her four year old son.
I would have rated this higher but the crime doesn't occur until well past half the book. I also am not fond of overly long books and felt this could have been a bit shorter. Eventually there is a murder and it is not obvious who the culprit could be. Ruth's personal life continues to be complicated, and as always, the end of the book leaves some questions unanswered, meaning I can't wait to read the next installment.
I would have rated this higher but the crime doesn't occur until well past half the book. I also am not fond of overly long books and felt this could have been a bit shorter. Eventually there is a murder and it is not obvious who the culprit could be. Ruth's personal life continues to be complicated, and as always, the end of the book leaves some questions unanswered, meaning I can't wait to read the next installment.
July 19, 2019
3.5 stars.
My least favorite of a quite good series. Not as fresh or compelling, and the relentless theme of baby or toddler in jeopardy (or alternately, mother of same and by extension the point is still baby or toddler in jeopardy) has finally become tiring. I was waiting for that to happen, but the other qualities of the series have offset this odd repeat thus far.
The echo effect at this point removes much of the tension and mystery of the book if you’ve been following the series. I very much hope Griffiths can move beyond the mommy’s-worst-fear trope in the next book.
My least favorite of a quite good series. Not as fresh or compelling, and the relentless theme of baby or toddler in jeopardy (or alternately, mother of same and by extension the point is still baby or toddler in jeopardy) has finally become tiring. I was waiting for that to happen, but the other qualities of the series have offset this odd repeat thus far.
The echo effect at this point removes much of the tension and mystery of the book if you’ve been following the series. I very much hope Griffiths can move beyond the mommy’s-worst-fear trope in the next book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,808 reviews