When I knew I was going to be reading Suicide House, by Charles Donlea, I grabbed Some Choose Darkness off of Amazon, as a Kindle Unlimited choice. Both books feature Rory Moore, a forensic reconstructionist, and Lane Phillips, a psychologist, who is an expert on serial killers. The first book focuses on an "alleged" serial killer, who is going to be released from prison, after serving forty years for the murder of Angela Mitchell, whose body has never been found.
The book starts with one of the killer's murders, where he employs ropes, pulleys, and body weight to torture and kill his victim. It's the summer of 1979 and five women will go missing, bodies never found, while another woman's body will be found. This timeline is intertwined with later timelines and the present, where Rory must take on the representation of the serial killer, after her lawyer father dies. Rory can't understand why her father was so involved in the affairs of this serial killer and she is obsessed with finding out how involved her father really was in the life of the man.
In 1979, the serial killer's murder spree was cut short when an autistic woman, Angela Mitchell, mailed a packet to police, with detailed information and evidence, that led to the arrest of the killer. But Angela Mitchell could not be found and the killer was convicted of her murder, despite the lack of a body. Throughout the years, the killer paid Rory's father to search for a living Angela, so that the killer's conviction of murder could be overturned.
Rory, also autistic, feels a strong tie to Angela and is obsessed with finding out more about her, finding her, and what had happened all those years ago. Both Rory and Angela are geniuses although Angela suffered from her way of coping with life and being labeled in demeaning and incorrect diagnoses. Where Rory has difficulties dealing with living people, she is adept of seeing what others cannot see and piecing together long ago murders.
This is a brutal and terrifying novel that has us in the presence of the killer, his victims, and the women who want justice for the dead. We get to feel the pull of compulsion and obsession on both Angela and Rory as they parallel each other in different timelines. Donlea sets the scene, puts us in the minds of Angela and Rory, and even puts us in the mind of the killer. I was able to figure out a lot of things in the book even by midpoint but in no way did it take away from my enjoyment of the story. Creepy is too mild of a word for the feelings I felt, while reading the book, but the feeling will stay with me for a long time.
Published April 2, 2019
This was a Kindle Unlimited choice