What do you think?
Rate this book
D.I. Clare Mackay #5
Next in Line
A murder victim with celebrity connections spells trouble for DI Clare Mackay...
Gabrielle Fox is known to many due to her successful TV career, so when her brother and his pals hire the salubrious Lamond Lodge for his birthday celebrations, it is noted by the St Andrews locals. A ripple of shock goes round the town when Russell Fox is gunned down on the premises.
DI Clare Mackay is attending a wedding when she sees Gabrielle receive a phone call then flee. Soon after, Clare learns why when the news of the shooting reaches her. Instead of trying to enjoy the day – not easy when the groom is her ex-boyfriend – Clare is preoccupied.
Clare gets to work on uncovering the facts surrounding Russell Fox’s death. The guests at the lodge have secrets to hide, but even when Clare begins to unravel the deceit, it doesn’t bring the answers. The detective can’t help but wonder why no one who knew Russell seems capable of telling the truth, and whether there is more than one person with a reason to want him dead…
A thrilling addition to the much-loved and bestselling detective fiction series from a rising star in Scottish crime fiction. Ideal for fans of Alex Gray, D. K. Hood and Rachel Amphlett.
Gabrielle Fox is known to many due to her successful TV career, so when her brother and his pals hire the salubrious Lamond Lodge for his birthday celebrations, it is noted by the St Andrews locals. A ripple of shock goes round the town when Russell Fox is gunned down on the premises.
DI Clare Mackay is attending a wedding when she sees Gabrielle receive a phone call then flee. Soon after, Clare learns why when the news of the shooting reaches her. Instead of trying to enjoy the day – not easy when the groom is her ex-boyfriend – Clare is preoccupied.
Clare gets to work on uncovering the facts surrounding Russell Fox’s death. The guests at the lodge have secrets to hide, but even when Clare begins to unravel the deceit, it doesn’t bring the answers. The detective can’t help but wonder why no one who knew Russell seems capable of telling the truth, and whether there is more than one person with a reason to want him dead…
A thrilling addition to the much-loved and bestselling detective fiction series from a rising star in Scottish crime fiction. Ideal for fans of Alex Gray, D. K. Hood and Rachel Amphlett.
288 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 21, 2021
175 people are currently reading
578 people want to read
About the author
Marion Todd
39 books351 followersMarion grew up in the City of Dundee, now home to the magnificent V&A Museum. Always a keen writer, she has had point-of-view pieces published in the Dundee Courier and short stories in My Weekly magazine. She won first prize in the Family Circle Magazine Short Story for Children Competition in 1987.
More recently, Marion has turned her hand to crime fiction and was one of only six commercial fiction writers selected to pitch to an industry panel at XPONorth in Inverness in 2017. In 2018 Marion was long-listed for the Sunstory Award and the Scottish Arts Council Short Story Award. This year she was short-listed for Dundee Rep’s Stripped programme. She is represented by Northbank Talent Management and her debut novel, See Them Run, will be published as an eBook by Canelo on 31 October 2019.
Before becoming a full-time writer, Marion worked as a lecturer, candle-maker and hotel lounge pianist, a job which provided rich material for her novels. When she isn’t writing, Marion can be found tussling with her jungle-like garden and walking in the beautiful Scotish countryside.
Marion lives in North East Fife overlooking the River Tay and is a sometime babysitter for her daughter’s unruly but lovable dog.
More recently, Marion has turned her hand to crime fiction and was one of only six commercial fiction writers selected to pitch to an industry panel at XPONorth in Inverness in 2017. In 2018 Marion was long-listed for the Sunstory Award and the Scottish Arts Council Short Story Award. This year she was short-listed for Dundee Rep’s Stripped programme. She is represented by Northbank Talent Management and her debut novel, See Them Run, will be published as an eBook by Canelo on 31 October 2019.
Before becoming a full-time writer, Marion worked as a lecturer, candle-maker and hotel lounge pianist, a job which provided rich material for her novels. When she isn’t writing, Marion can be found tussling with her jungle-like garden and walking in the beautiful Scotish countryside.
Marion lives in North East Fife overlooking the River Tay and is a sometime babysitter for her daughter’s unruly but lovable dog.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 178 reviews
September 15, 2021
This is the latest in Marion Todd's great DI Clare Mackay Scottish crime series based in St Andrews, which has Clare attending a wedding with DCI Alastair Gibson, the groom is an ex-boyfriend which has her experiencing momentary pangs of what might have been. Other guests include the well known and popular TV presenter, Gabrielle 'Gaby' Fox and her TV producer husband, Luke Gasparini, they leave after Gaby receives what appears to be a troubling phone call. Soon after, DS Chris West informs her of a murder, a shooting at the exclusive Lamond Lodge. By the time Clare gets to the scene, she feels as if she has lost valuable time in beginning the inquiry by arriving late. The victim turns out to be chef, Russell Fox, Gaby's brother. He had been shot early in the morning whilst on a walk.
The Lodge had been hired, along with a security guard to ensure privacy, to celebrate Russell's 40th birthday celebrations, with 3 friends from childhood, Doug Gerrard, Steve Christie, and Eamon Ferry, along with Gaby and Luke. The 3 friends prove to be remarkably unforthcoming about what occurred during the party, what secrets are they harbouring? As the police team, including PC Sara Stapleton engaged to West, delve into the life of the victim, they discover he has spent time at Barlinnie prison for drink driving, where he made an enemy of a fellow prisoner, Zac Buchanan. As the inquiry comes under intense media scrutiny, DCI Tony McAvettie is assigned to lead the team, an unwelcome presence with his history of philandering. In a case that proves to be difficult, complex and hard to make any progress in, Clare and her fellow police officers work hard to get to the truth, but even if they learn the truth, will justice be served?
One of the reasons I enjoy this series is the blend of professional police work with the personal lives of Clare and her team, for example, Clare now seems to be in a stable relationship with Alastair, and we are given insights into Chris and Sara's relationship. This is a terrific addition to this great crime series, it is dark, engaging and entertaining, with plenty of suspense and tension, and with a host of suspects for the police team to look into. Many thanks to the publisher for an ARC.
The Lodge had been hired, along with a security guard to ensure privacy, to celebrate Russell's 40th birthday celebrations, with 3 friends from childhood, Doug Gerrard, Steve Christie, and Eamon Ferry, along with Gaby and Luke. The 3 friends prove to be remarkably unforthcoming about what occurred during the party, what secrets are they harbouring? As the police team, including PC Sara Stapleton engaged to West, delve into the life of the victim, they discover he has spent time at Barlinnie prison for drink driving, where he made an enemy of a fellow prisoner, Zac Buchanan. As the inquiry comes under intense media scrutiny, DCI Tony McAvettie is assigned to lead the team, an unwelcome presence with his history of philandering. In a case that proves to be difficult, complex and hard to make any progress in, Clare and her fellow police officers work hard to get to the truth, but even if they learn the truth, will justice be served?
One of the reasons I enjoy this series is the blend of professional police work with the personal lives of Clare and her team, for example, Clare now seems to be in a stable relationship with Alastair, and we are given insights into Chris and Sara's relationship. This is a terrific addition to this great crime series, it is dark, engaging and entertaining, with plenty of suspense and tension, and with a host of suspects for the police team to look into. Many thanks to the publisher for an ARC.
September 18, 2021
DI Clare Mackay #5
A deadly shot fired at sunrise, a phone-call later in the day and two guests leave a wedding abruptly with DI Clare Mackay, attending with her partner DCI Alastair Gibson, wishing she could too!! By the following day Clare and her team are on the case searching for the early morning killer.
This is another good addition to this series which always seem to have an air of authenticity about them. Much of this comes from the excellent characterisation, Clare is very likeable and her actions during an investigation feel believable. This is an author who knows her characters thoroughly as all are well fleshed out. I like the developing relationship with Alastair and he gives her the stability she needs. The police team are a good one, especially likeable is DS Chris West and he and Clare make a good contrast to each other. I like the camaraderie of the team and their banter is always entertaining. You get a good blend in a Marion Todd of police case and private life, the latter is not overdone with just enough to add realism. The investigation is an intriguing one, once they get the victims name all kinds of dodgy actions eventually emerge, accompanied by characters with a tenuous link to the right side of the law and suspicion rightly falls in several directions. You think you have the whole thing figured out but no, you definitely don’t!! There are several good plot twists and turns that keep you reading on until the evidence stacks up to a good finale. I love the setting for the novels, in and around St Andrews which is well described and adds atmosphere.
Overall, these are very readable police procedural mysteries. The author writes novels with solid plots and with good pacing that keeps you reading on. There are believable moments of tension and suspense which makes it a compelling and immersive read.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Canelo for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review.
A deadly shot fired at sunrise, a phone-call later in the day and two guests leave a wedding abruptly with DI Clare Mackay, attending with her partner DCI Alastair Gibson, wishing she could too!! By the following day Clare and her team are on the case searching for the early morning killer.
This is another good addition to this series which always seem to have an air of authenticity about them. Much of this comes from the excellent characterisation, Clare is very likeable and her actions during an investigation feel believable. This is an author who knows her characters thoroughly as all are well fleshed out. I like the developing relationship with Alastair and he gives her the stability she needs. The police team are a good one, especially likeable is DS Chris West and he and Clare make a good contrast to each other. I like the camaraderie of the team and their banter is always entertaining. You get a good blend in a Marion Todd of police case and private life, the latter is not overdone with just enough to add realism. The investigation is an intriguing one, once they get the victims name all kinds of dodgy actions eventually emerge, accompanied by characters with a tenuous link to the right side of the law and suspicion rightly falls in several directions. You think you have the whole thing figured out but no, you definitely don’t!! There are several good plot twists and turns that keep you reading on until the evidence stacks up to a good finale. I love the setting for the novels, in and around St Andrews which is well described and adds atmosphere.
Overall, these are very readable police procedural mysteries. The author writes novels with solid plots and with good pacing that keeps you reading on. There are believable moments of tension and suspense which makes it a compelling and immersive read.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Canelo for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review.
August 17, 2025
Good read!
An enjoyable plotline and unexpected twists in this book #5 of the ongoing 'D.I. Clare Mackay' police procedural series. Still not into their romantic relationship (Clare & her old boss) but do enjoy the various supporting characters.
Recommended book and series!
An enjoyable plotline and unexpected twists in this book #5 of the ongoing 'D.I. Clare Mackay' police procedural series. Still not into their romantic relationship (Clare & her old boss) but do enjoy the various supporting characters.
Recommended book and series!
January 7, 2022
Despite not yet having read the preceding instalments in Marion Todd's D.I. Clare Mackay series, I thoroughly enjoyed Next in Line. It's a well-conceived police procedural, set in and around the picturesque Scottish city of St. Andrews.
The book opens with the protagonist, D.I. Clare Mackay, bemusedly attending the wedding of her ex-partner. Fortunately, Clare's given an early excuse to leave, when she's called to an unusual crime scene - a shooting death - at a plush country house outside St. Andrews. Discretion is required, as the murdered man is the brother of television personality Gaby Fox, who Clare briefly met as a fellow guest at the wedding.
Clare and her team begin sifting through the clues, interviewing the friends of the victim, Russell Fox, to discern a motive for his murder and following up leads about the presence of a suspicious van seen in the area the previous night. Feathers are ruffled by the arrival of D.C.I. Tony McAvettie, renowned for his sexual shenanigans with junior officers and tendency to take credit for others' work, appointed to oversee the investigation.
As the investigation proceeds, the team uncover possible financial motives for Russell's murder and identify a prison sentence he served some years ago as a possible contributor to current events. Can Clare unravel all the tangled threads and identify the killer before they claim another victim?
I appreciated that, as well as a strong and complex plotline surrounding the investigation, Next in Line also featured a compelling intertwined narrative focussing on Clare's private life, in particular her developing relationship with D.C.I. Alastair Gibson. Characters were well-developed and believable and the dialogue snappy, with a sprinkling of Scots vernacular.
Next in Line was an engrossing and entertaining read. I'll certainly be seeking out earlier books in the series for my future reading pleasure. I'd recommend the book to any reader who enjoys well-characterised police procedurals, in the line of Ann Cleeves' Vera Stanhope series and Caroline Graham's D.C.I Barnaby series. Like both those series, I believe this would translate well to television adaptation in the future.
My thanks to the author, Marion Todd, publisher Canelo, and Netgalley for the opportunity to read and review this title.
The book opens with the protagonist, D.I. Clare Mackay, bemusedly attending the wedding of her ex-partner. Fortunately, Clare's given an early excuse to leave, when she's called to an unusual crime scene - a shooting death - at a plush country house outside St. Andrews. Discretion is required, as the murdered man is the brother of television personality Gaby Fox, who Clare briefly met as a fellow guest at the wedding.
Clare and her team begin sifting through the clues, interviewing the friends of the victim, Russell Fox, to discern a motive for his murder and following up leads about the presence of a suspicious van seen in the area the previous night. Feathers are ruffled by the arrival of D.C.I. Tony McAvettie, renowned for his sexual shenanigans with junior officers and tendency to take credit for others' work, appointed to oversee the investigation.
As the investigation proceeds, the team uncover possible financial motives for Russell's murder and identify a prison sentence he served some years ago as a possible contributor to current events. Can Clare unravel all the tangled threads and identify the killer before they claim another victim?
I appreciated that, as well as a strong and complex plotline surrounding the investigation, Next in Line also featured a compelling intertwined narrative focussing on Clare's private life, in particular her developing relationship with D.C.I. Alastair Gibson. Characters were well-developed and believable and the dialogue snappy, with a sprinkling of Scots vernacular.
Next in Line was an engrossing and entertaining read. I'll certainly be seeking out earlier books in the series for my future reading pleasure. I'd recommend the book to any reader who enjoys well-characterised police procedurals, in the line of Ann Cleeves' Vera Stanhope series and Caroline Graham's D.C.I Barnaby series. Like both those series, I believe this would translate well to television adaptation in the future.
My thanks to the author, Marion Todd, publisher Canelo, and Netgalley for the opportunity to read and review this title.
October 13, 2021
4.5 stars rounded up to 5
Clare MacKay #5
Gabrielle Fox is known to many due to her successful career, so when her brother and his pals hire the salubrious Lamond Lodge for his birthday celebrations, it's noted by the St. Andrews locals. A ripple of shock goes round the town when Russell Fox is gunned down on the premises. DI Clare MacKay is attending a wedding when she sees Gabrielle Fox receive a phone call then flee. Soon after, Clare learns about the shooting.
Clare and DCI Al are attending the wedding of her ex-boyfriend when Russell Fox is shot. But she takes over investigating the shooting the following day.
I really like this series. There is lots of suspects and curve balls thrown in to keep you guessing. I like that we get a little more backstory to the characters with each new book. There's elements of humour alongside the investigation. This is a well written and entertaining read. I hope we don't have long to wait for book 6.
I would like to thank #NetGalley #Canelo and the author #MarionTodd for my ARC of #NextInLine in exchange for an honest review.
Clare MacKay #5
Gabrielle Fox is known to many due to her successful career, so when her brother and his pals hire the salubrious Lamond Lodge for his birthday celebrations, it's noted by the St. Andrews locals. A ripple of shock goes round the town when Russell Fox is gunned down on the premises. DI Clare MacKay is attending a wedding when she sees Gabrielle Fox receive a phone call then flee. Soon after, Clare learns about the shooting.
Clare and DCI Al are attending the wedding of her ex-boyfriend when Russell Fox is shot. But she takes over investigating the shooting the following day.
I really like this series. There is lots of suspects and curve balls thrown in to keep you guessing. I like that we get a little more backstory to the characters with each new book. There's elements of humour alongside the investigation. This is a well written and entertaining read. I hope we don't have long to wait for book 6.
I would like to thank #NetGalley #Canelo and the author #MarionTodd for my ARC of #NextInLine in exchange for an honest review.
October 14, 2021
This was the fifth in this series and again, it was very good especially the unexpected ending. It was like slipping on a comfortable pair and slippers as I remember the characters from the previous books. I do hope there will be more in this series. My thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
February 24, 2024
I like this series, but I have questions. Does the DCI really have nothing better to do than draw her bath, mop her brow, pour her wine, cook her meals? And yet somehow, at the same time, earn some kind of promotion? COME ON!
January 13, 2025
A new author and new series for me, book number five, but this didn't matter. A bit slow towards the last part of the book but a good detective story, and I'll look out for more Detective Claire Mackay books.
September 20, 2021
I always look forward to Marion Todd's books and she must be working tirelessly because already we're onto book 5 in the DI Clare Mackay series. "Next in Line" features all the old favourites among the staff and some characters from previous novels. As is customary, the chapters are short making it hard to put down as I promise myself "just one more chapter before bed", which always turns out to be a lie. I like that Todd includes the occasional bit of Scots dialogue. I also particularly liked how the text messages are laid out in the ebook. Another good read and, as always, I look forward to the next in the series.
October 10, 2021
Has DI Clare MacKay conquered her tendency to be a workaholic? The latest book by Marion Todd, Next in Line, opens with her at a wedding with her new love interest, DCI Alistair Gibson. Ah, no, it’s the wedding of Clare’s ex, and more or less a command performance. Still she is managing some light conversation with another couple at the table until she gets a phone call advising her of a newly discovered body. To the surprise of no one, least of all Alistair, Clare wants to immediately rush back to St. Andrews. The only thing that stops her is his reminding her they’ve both had a few glasses of wine and are most likely over the limit. At least it gives her an excuse to bail on the remaining festivities and the next day she is off and running.
This is the fifth book in the series, and may be the best one yet. The story is excellent, with twists and turns that keep the reader on their toes as they try to figure out where the story is going. No worries, Clare and her team are taking those twists and turns at the same time, and they have the advantage of being a crack investigative team. Fortunately, the reader gets the opportunity the follow along with the investigation and learning facts at the same time as Clare and her team.
Being familiar with Todd’s other books in the series, her excellent writing style feels more like a welcome home and the reader is immediately drawn into the world of DI MacKay. This current case is the murder of a man who was celebrating his birthday with three friends from his school days at an exclusive lodge near the grounds of a posh hotel. As the case unfolds Clare learns his sister is a TV personality and happens to be the woman she met at the wedding reception. The story quickly moves into the solid police work being done by Clare and her team as they investigate leads, follow hunches, and roll with the unexpected twists and turns the case takes as they proceed.
The pace is excellent and the story so engaging it pulls the reader through. As the chapters are short, it’s easy to read “just one more chapter” than to put the book down, and before you know it you’ve read another hour or so. There are some recurring characters beyond DCI Gibson who are part of Clare’s team and their stories and personalities are continuing from previous books. The case they are trying to solve is completely contained within this book. So, if you are a series reader, this is a series I would recommend reading from beginning, reading them in order, as the characters develop and grow as the series continues. However, if you are just interested in a well-written mystery that is engaging in and of itself, there is no need to read the previous books in the series as the main story is easily understood without in-depth knowledge of their personal story.
However you decide to enjoy Marion Todd’s book, be assured enjoy is the operative word. Todd’s writing style is comfortable, concise and offers an excellent balance between character development and case information. As you follow along with Clare, figuring out the best way to interpret the information she receives, the twists and turns may offer moments of reordering your thoughts. Also, liike Clare, you won’t have much time to contemplate these as you will be moving toward the next step in the investigation.
Next in Line is an excellent example of a police procedural where things move on a logical path, there is a sense of urgency because that’s what law enforcement feels when they are trying to solve a case, and dangerous situations are logical instead of contrived. There is just enough personal story for Clare as well as a few others in her precinct to create an interesting world filled with people you either would like to get to know or, at the very least, want working your case if you ever found yourself in need of their services.
This is the fifth book in the series, and may be the best one yet. The story is excellent, with twists and turns that keep the reader on their toes as they try to figure out where the story is going. No worries, Clare and her team are taking those twists and turns at the same time, and they have the advantage of being a crack investigative team. Fortunately, the reader gets the opportunity the follow along with the investigation and learning facts at the same time as Clare and her team.
Being familiar with Todd’s other books in the series, her excellent writing style feels more like a welcome home and the reader is immediately drawn into the world of DI MacKay. This current case is the murder of a man who was celebrating his birthday with three friends from his school days at an exclusive lodge near the grounds of a posh hotel. As the case unfolds Clare learns his sister is a TV personality and happens to be the woman she met at the wedding reception. The story quickly moves into the solid police work being done by Clare and her team as they investigate leads, follow hunches, and roll with the unexpected twists and turns the case takes as they proceed.
The pace is excellent and the story so engaging it pulls the reader through. As the chapters are short, it’s easy to read “just one more chapter” than to put the book down, and before you know it you’ve read another hour or so. There are some recurring characters beyond DCI Gibson who are part of Clare’s team and their stories and personalities are continuing from previous books. The case they are trying to solve is completely contained within this book. So, if you are a series reader, this is a series I would recommend reading from beginning, reading them in order, as the characters develop and grow as the series continues. However, if you are just interested in a well-written mystery that is engaging in and of itself, there is no need to read the previous books in the series as the main story is easily understood without in-depth knowledge of their personal story.
However you decide to enjoy Marion Todd’s book, be assured enjoy is the operative word. Todd’s writing style is comfortable, concise and offers an excellent balance between character development and case information. As you follow along with Clare, figuring out the best way to interpret the information she receives, the twists and turns may offer moments of reordering your thoughts. Also, liike Clare, you won’t have much time to contemplate these as you will be moving toward the next step in the investigation.
Next in Line is an excellent example of a police procedural where things move on a logical path, there is a sense of urgency because that’s what law enforcement feels when they are trying to solve a case, and dangerous situations are logical instead of contrived. There is just enough personal story for Clare as well as a few others in her precinct to create an interesting world filled with people you either would like to get to know or, at the very least, want working your case if you ever found yourself in need of their services.
October 21, 2021
Being a huge Marion Todd fan (I’ve read her first 4 books in the DI Clare Mackay series) I was very excited to read book number 5 which went straight to the top of my pile.
Marion has yet again come up with an top notch police procedural thriller. I enjoyed meeting DI Mackay again. She is an excellent detective who is always completely immersed in her case.
We follow this latest case as the brother of a top tv personality has been shot dead at a remote holiday lodge. The lodge had been rented to celebrate his 40th birthday and a handful of his friends were staying there for a party weekend. DI Mackay gets her teeth straight into the case like a terrier and does not let up until the shooter has been found. There are of course many red herrings and twists and turns to keep the interest and momentum going!
Can’t wait to see what is in store for DI Mackay in her next case!
Many thanks to Canelo and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy of the book which is due out on 21st October.
Marion has yet again come up with an top notch police procedural thriller. I enjoyed meeting DI Mackay again. She is an excellent detective who is always completely immersed in her case.
We follow this latest case as the brother of a top tv personality has been shot dead at a remote holiday lodge. The lodge had been rented to celebrate his 40th birthday and a handful of his friends were staying there for a party weekend. DI Mackay gets her teeth straight into the case like a terrier and does not let up until the shooter has been found. There are of course many red herrings and twists and turns to keep the interest and momentum going!
Can’t wait to see what is in store for DI Mackay in her next case!
Many thanks to Canelo and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy of the book which is due out on 21st October.
November 21, 2021
This is the fifth instalment in Marion Todd's Detective Inspector Clare Mackay series, set in St Andrews, Scotland.
It's Russell Fox's 40th birthday and he, his sister, Gaby and a few mates are celebrating at the salubrious Lamond Lodge. DI Clare Mackay is attending a wedding with DCI Alastair Gibson. The groom is an ex-boyfriend of Clare's which she is finding distracting. Later, DS Chris West informs her of a murder, the victim being Russell Fox who was shot at the Lamond Lodge. Gaby was also a guest at the wedding that Clare attended. In a complex case, Clare and her team must work hard to get to the truth in a case where secrets are being closely guarded and everyone is unforthcoming.
Once again, I was completely and thoroughly hooked by this compelling story right from the start. I think Next in Line would be fine as a standalone, but I recommend reading the first ones in the series as you'd be missing out if you didn't! I fell right into this well-crafted and absorbing tale and I felt as though I was shadowing Clare as she worked at chasing her leads and following her instincts. Marion Todd's writing style continues to be impressive and noteworthy. Clare is a more than competent DI who always strives to look after her team and cares about getting justice. This is a Scottish crime series that I have found highly appealing and engaging, and I look forward to reading the next instalment.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel at my request from Canelo via NetGalley and this review is my own unbiased opinion.
It's Russell Fox's 40th birthday and he, his sister, Gaby and a few mates are celebrating at the salubrious Lamond Lodge. DI Clare Mackay is attending a wedding with DCI Alastair Gibson. The groom is an ex-boyfriend of Clare's which she is finding distracting. Later, DS Chris West informs her of a murder, the victim being Russell Fox who was shot at the Lamond Lodge. Gaby was also a guest at the wedding that Clare attended. In a complex case, Clare and her team must work hard to get to the truth in a case where secrets are being closely guarded and everyone is unforthcoming.
Once again, I was completely and thoroughly hooked by this compelling story right from the start. I think Next in Line would be fine as a standalone, but I recommend reading the first ones in the series as you'd be missing out if you didn't! I fell right into this well-crafted and absorbing tale and I felt as though I was shadowing Clare as she worked at chasing her leads and following her instincts. Marion Todd's writing style continues to be impressive and noteworthy. Clare is a more than competent DI who always strives to look after her team and cares about getting justice. This is a Scottish crime series that I have found highly appealing and engaging, and I look forward to reading the next instalment.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel at my request from Canelo via NetGalley and this review is my own unbiased opinion.
August 5, 2025
again just so easy and quick to read, i’m really enjoying the series. this one got a tiny bit confusing at some points but still really good
February 1, 2024
A very well-co structured story without hysteria or hyperbole. The characters are understated and are therefore more relatable. It makes a refreshing change to have a female DI that isn’t all angst and aggression. She’s someone I feel I’d like to work with. In my opinion, there was a little too much time spent on the DI’s flu (although I’m sure this was to demonstrate Clare’s dedication to the case). I would like to have found out the final verdict of the guilty and the consequential sentence too but the story is about the police’s role in finding out whodunnit and not the ensuing court case.
All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed it.
I’d like to read more from this author - this is the fifth Clare Mackay book, there seemed no need to have read the previous ones. It would make a great TV series especially being set in Scotland.
All in all, I thoroughly enjoyed it.
I’d like to read more from this author - this is the fifth Clare Mackay book, there seemed no need to have read the previous ones. It would make a great TV series especially being set in Scotland.
October 24, 2021
Having read the other books in this series, I was keen to read the next installment.
DI Clare Mackay enjoys a rare weekend off attending ex boyfriend, Tom's, wedding with her partner, DCI Alistair Gibson (so nice to see them back together) Unfortunately, they are interrupted with a call about the murder of Russell Fox at Lamond Lodge. He had been celebrating his birthday with a group of friends. His sister, Gaby, is a popular tv presenter and had also been attending the wedding.
Once again, Marion Todd drip feeds information to the reader and the book is well plotted with details revealed at just the right time. There was a good balance between the new narrative and the original characters. I love the small quirks like Zoe and her baking, Clare's dog Benji and the relationship between Chris and Sarah.
This is part of a really engaging police procedural set and I look forward to reading more by this author.
Thanks indeed to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
DI Clare Mackay enjoys a rare weekend off attending ex boyfriend, Tom's, wedding with her partner, DCI Alistair Gibson (so nice to see them back together) Unfortunately, they are interrupted with a call about the murder of Russell Fox at Lamond Lodge. He had been celebrating his birthday with a group of friends. His sister, Gaby, is a popular tv presenter and had also been attending the wedding.
Once again, Marion Todd drip feeds information to the reader and the book is well plotted with details revealed at just the right time. There was a good balance between the new narrative and the original characters. I love the small quirks like Zoe and her baking, Clare's dog Benji and the relationship between Chris and Sarah.
This is part of a really engaging police procedural set and I look forward to reading more by this author.
Thanks indeed to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
January 30, 2025
The Blurb 📖
DI Clare Mackay is at a wedding with her partner when she gets a call about a murder. The victims sister turns out to be a famous TV personality who was at the same wedding as Clare.
The investigation uncovers secrets and throws up many suspects and many reasons for the murder. Can Clare and her team figure out who the murderer is?
The Good 📖
This is book 5 in the DI Clare Mackay series. If you've read the earlier books, then picking this up is like being with old friends. You know them, you understand their motivations, you know how they think. But that does t make the book predictable. There are plenty of twists in this book to keep you turning the pages - or in my case swiping the pages!
I also like the setting. For me, it's very familiar as it's not far from where I live. I like being able to visualise where it's taking place.
It's also great to see Clare and Al's relationship developing in this book. She deserves to be happy.
The Meh 📖
I don't like Tony - but in fairness, I can see why he was brought back. And let's face it, he isn't meant to be liked!
The Result 📖
This is another Libby app read, albeit a digital book rather than an audio. If I tell you I'm already reading number 6 in the series and I've just bought tickets to Marion's event at Topping & Company Booksellers of St Andrews on 5 February, that should give you huge clues to solve the mystery of where I recommend this or not!
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/12Fk...
DI Clare Mackay is at a wedding with her partner when she gets a call about a murder. The victims sister turns out to be a famous TV personality who was at the same wedding as Clare.
The investigation uncovers secrets and throws up many suspects and many reasons for the murder. Can Clare and her team figure out who the murderer is?
The Good 📖
This is book 5 in the DI Clare Mackay series. If you've read the earlier books, then picking this up is like being with old friends. You know them, you understand their motivations, you know how they think. But that does t make the book predictable. There are plenty of twists in this book to keep you turning the pages - or in my case swiping the pages!
I also like the setting. For me, it's very familiar as it's not far from where I live. I like being able to visualise where it's taking place.
It's also great to see Clare and Al's relationship developing in this book. She deserves to be happy.
The Meh 📖
I don't like Tony - but in fairness, I can see why he was brought back. And let's face it, he isn't meant to be liked!
The Result 📖
This is another Libby app read, albeit a digital book rather than an audio. If I tell you I'm already reading number 6 in the series and I've just bought tickets to Marion's event at Topping & Company Booksellers of St Andrews on 5 February, that should give you huge clues to solve the mystery of where I recommend this or not!
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/12Fk...
October 21, 2021
Though this was a No 5 in the series, it does well as a stand alone.
A murder takes place in an exclusive boutique hotel, in isolated gardens in Scotland. The victim and his family are well known and reporters are all over the place. The family had faced tragedy before when theylost another sibling in the tsunami in Thailand and this murder is resurrecting a lot of old memories.
Celebrating his 40th birthday Russel did not expect to be murdered on his birthday. The marksman who shot him was an expert shot and Detective Claire has to whittle down her suspects - the immediate ones are cagey, careful and extremely smart. Further widening her net, Claire discovers many extraneous strands to the initial story and now she is looking at people far beyond her initial line up.
Family complications galore in the victims family, treachery amongst friends of decades and keen and slow methodical detection makes this a best seller read.
The setting too added a lot of atmosphere to the story.
A murder takes place in an exclusive boutique hotel, in isolated gardens in Scotland. The victim and his family are well known and reporters are all over the place. The family had faced tragedy before when theylost another sibling in the tsunami in Thailand and this murder is resurrecting a lot of old memories.
Celebrating his 40th birthday Russel did not expect to be murdered on his birthday. The marksman who shot him was an expert shot and Detective Claire has to whittle down her suspects - the immediate ones are cagey, careful and extremely smart. Further widening her net, Claire discovers many extraneous strands to the initial story and now she is looking at people far beyond her initial line up.
Family complications galore in the victims family, treachery amongst friends of decades and keen and slow methodical detection makes this a best seller read.
The setting too added a lot of atmosphere to the story.
July 8, 2022
Yet another thrilling, interesting, and creative murder novel by Marion Todd. This is #5 in her series about Claire MacKay who I adore. It’s set in Scotland and the audiobook is read by the author who has an amazing Scottish accent and narrates this beautifully.
I never want this series of books to end! You’ll love the characters who are well developed, and also enjoy the clever relationship while on the trail of a murderer.
I never want this series of books to end! You’ll love the characters who are well developed, and also enjoy the clever relationship while on the trail of a murderer.
November 23, 2023
I have been binging this series, and thoroughly enjoying it. This latest instalment was spot on. Good plot, great character development and some nippy dialogue just to keep us going. It is always interesting to see how the various aspects of the story blend in together to make a coherent whole, and how the initial investigations into all relevant issues work together.
June 29, 2022
Almost Shakespearean at the end with family identities
March 5, 2024
Good series. Like eating a box of candy.
August 17, 2024
(More 3.5 stars)
January 11, 2024
Brilliant.
March 8, 2022
A good story line, easy to read, my type of book. Will definitely look out for more from this author.
July 17, 2022
Moves along at a nice clip. A few too many plot threads for my taste, but all resolved neatly. Loved the descriptive imagery.
Will probably reread, as this is a series I feel I will revisit.
Will probably reread, as this is a series I feel I will revisit.
March 3, 2022
A bit slow to begin with, I actually considered just putting this one down over the first 3 or so chapters, I'm entirely not sure why. Saying that, I'm glad I continued. This book was a good read, although I kind of thought I'd guessed the motive early on, I was in fact proved wrong. I liked the fact it was a Scottish book, and I'd definitely read more by the author.
February 11, 2022
Next in Line is the fifth book in the DI Clare Mackay series set in St Andrews. I have enjoyed them all, and the unusual setting is one of the attractions. Clare is called back from the wedding of her ex, when a dead body is discovered at Lamond Lodge, where a group of old friends were celebrating a birthday. The victim turns out to be the brother of TV personality Gaby Fox, who had also been at the wedding.
The motive for the killing is not obvious at first, and Clare and her team find it difficult to make any headway as everyone seems to hiding something. Short chapters move the story along and the mystery is slowly unravelled. This is a believable police investigation, with lots of setbacks and changes of direction, where the reader knows everything the police do, but there is no input from the killer. Several times I thought I had it worked out only to discover I was yet again being led up the garden path. The characters are well drawn, and the team of police officers has become well known to the reader over the course of the previous four books, with just enough detail about their private lives to make them believable. I look forward to reading the next book in the series, Old Bones Lie, when it is published later in the year. Thanks to Canelo and NetGalley for a digital copy to review.
The motive for the killing is not obvious at first, and Clare and her team find it difficult to make any headway as everyone seems to hiding something. Short chapters move the story along and the mystery is slowly unravelled. This is a believable police investigation, with lots of setbacks and changes of direction, where the reader knows everything the police do, but there is no input from the killer. Several times I thought I had it worked out only to discover I was yet again being led up the garden path. The characters are well drawn, and the team of police officers has become well known to the reader over the course of the previous four books, with just enough detail about their private lives to make them believable. I look forward to reading the next book in the series, Old Bones Lie, when it is published later in the year. Thanks to Canelo and NetGalley for a digital copy to review.
February 14, 2023
I think this series and the individual books are pretty good. I sometimes see holes in the plot and I’m sometimes annoyed by Claire’s overthinking or other characters’ behavior, but those are minor quibbles. I enjoy the series and will keep reading it.
I have a major complaint with this book in that I think the author did not adequately wrap up the case against the villains. There was really only one sentence about what I thought was a fairly incidental piece of evidence, in which Claire says, “That’ll do it.” And that was it. There was absolutely nothing about how they had enough evidence to convict these guys, after pages and pages of discussion about how they didn’t have enough evidence to convict. I also thought that the last chapter with Gabby was hard to believe and kind of stupid, but maybe the author needs to set up a relationship with her for future books. Heck if I know.
Speaking of the author, I think she does an excellent job of narrating these books, and I’ve never before said that about a fiction author narrating their own book. She doesn’t have different voices for different characters, but that’s the only flaw in her otherwise pretty much perfect narration.
I have a major complaint with this book in that I think the author did not adequately wrap up the case against the villains. There was really only one sentence about what I thought was a fairly incidental piece of evidence, in which Claire says, “That’ll do it.” And that was it. There was absolutely nothing about how they had enough evidence to convict these guys, after pages and pages of discussion about how they didn’t have enough evidence to convict. I also thought that the last chapter with Gabby was hard to believe and kind of stupid, but maybe the author needs to set up a relationship with her for future books. Heck if I know.
Speaking of the author, I think she does an excellent job of narrating these books, and I’ve never before said that about a fiction author narrating their own book. She doesn’t have different voices for different characters, but that’s the only flaw in her otherwise pretty much perfect narration.
October 27, 2021
This is the fifth book in the DI Clare MacKay series… I love that it started with Clare and her partner, DCI Alistair Gibson at the wedding of Clare’s ex, I’m glad they finally got their act together! Clare gets a call to inform her of the death/murder of Russell Fox at Lamond Lodge where he had been celebrating his birthday with his friends. His sister Gaby was at the same wedding as Clare and she is shocked at the news. Clare is finding it hard to delegate as Alistair persuades her to trust her team to start the investigation rolling…
This was yet another great police procedural story of a “who dunnit”… with plenty of suspects and too many alibis, can Clare get to the crux of the story, a few twists that blew my mind and a great finale, what more could you ask for, I love this series and cannot wait for the next instalment.
This was yet another great police procedural story of a “who dunnit”… with plenty of suspects and too many alibis, can Clare get to the crux of the story, a few twists that blew my mind and a great finale, what more could you ask for, I love this series and cannot wait for the next instalment.
November 6, 2021
Very enjoyable crime story, part of a series. Though I have not read any of the previous books, I feel that this didn’t hamper my enjoyment of this story as it reads well as a stand-alone too.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my review.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 178 reviews