God Was Not in the Fire: The Search for a Spiritual Judaism

by Daniel Gordis

Examining the role of Judaism in the answering of life's most important questions and the development of self-identity, an argument for the importance of Judaism explains its unique traditions

Genres: Judaism, Jewish, Religion, Judaica, Spirituality, Nonfiction

256 pages, Hardcover

First published September 11, 1995

Reviews

[Sid Groeneman · Rating 4 out of 5]

The author, Rabbi Daniel Gordis, addresses the question raised by many cultural/secular Jews--and possible also by mildly to moderately observant Jew: Why be Jewish? Although not written from a strictly Orthodox perspective, Gordis doesn't dilute the prescribed practices. Rather, he makes a case that delving deeper into Judaic practices can lead to a richer, more fulfilling life--even if one takes to it partially and gradually. Perhaps most interesting is his repeated permission, advocacy even, to "wrestle with God," which he maintains is fully within the tradition. Another important take-away is that behavior can induce beliefs, not just the other way around as is commonly thought. Unlike most other religions, creed is less important in Judaism than following mitzvoth (commandments, of which there are two kinds--interpersonal ethics and those between man and God). Core chapters in this clearly written book deal with God, Jewish learning, ritual, mitzvoth, and prayer. In a culture that prizes individual choice and transient "happiness," living a more fully Jewish life will not be appealing or easy for most. But Gordis makes the case that it's worth the effort.

[Mike Doyle · Rating 4 out of 5]

Kind of answers the question of Why Judaism? The answer is pretty much Why Not? The book demonstrates the importance of ritual and Jewish action as community-building and comforting elements of Jewish religious practice--whether or not you accept "stories" about God or reject the religious aspects of your Jewish upbringing.

[Corey Libow · Rating 4 out of 5]

A transformative book, that's maybe a little dated. This very 90's analysis of American Judaism, where it's diagnosis about how "modern Jews" aren't compelled by ritual or spirituality and abandoning Jewish identity, doesn't hit the same in 2024 when I can hop on Instagram and see a BuzzFeed style first person essay about "how my favorite fantasy novel connected me deeper to my Irish Jewish roots." But Daniel Gordis' thesis was prescient - there has been a large migration of young Jews to a more observant, considered practice in the 21st century. It's one that coincides with an overall shift of the youth towards an anti-capitalist, less corporate exploration of our lives (we are the daughters of the witches you couldn't burn etc etc..)

Gordis makes the case that Judaism offers something unique, special, and deep in a search for spirituality. And it's made well! It builds it's case from the most essential blocks of Jewish identity and gradually shows how when you layer practice and ritual with an individualistic understanding, even the most rigorous and restrictive elements of traditional Judaism become meaningful choices. And in an era when Judaism has become more accessible (and thus twisted and watered down) than ever before, there's a relief in the power of age old traditions - even if we all wrestle with them.

[Katie Cutler · Rating 4 out of 5]

Daniel Gordis offers a thoughtful journey into Jewish spirituality, exploring how to keep faith alive in today’s world. The book dives into the challenges of reconciling traditional Jewish beliefs with modern, secular life. I really appreciated his honesty and the way he wrestles with tough questions about God, suffering, and religious practice.

Gordis’ reflections are insightful and approachable, making this a great read for anyone interested in Jewish spirituality or exploring how faith can evolve. It’s a thought-provoking and meaningful book, especially for those searching for a more spiritual connection to Judaism.

[Barry · Rating 4 out of 5]

wonderful insights worth many re-reads

[Igrann32257 · Rating 5 out of 5]

A new way of seeking and knowing God. Well written and clear.